Short Answer
Tawba (repentance), in Mustafa Özbağ Efendi's definition, is, from a mistake or a fault, «turning away from it, turning back.» It has three aspects: with the tongue, with the state, and with the heart: with the tongue one seeks forgiveness (istighfar), with the state one does not return to the sin again, and with the heart the sin no longer even passes through the heart. Mustafa Özbağ Efendi mentions tawba and istighfar as «more or less the same things.» The essence of tawba is sincerity (nasuh tawba); and if there is a right owed to another person, one must seek reconciliation with the one to whom it is owed. Whoever complies with these is «as though he had never sinned.»
What Is Tawba? Mustafa Özbağ Efendi's Definition
Tawba means "to return" in the dictionary sense. Mustafa Özbağ Efendi begins with a narrated hadith, then gives the definition:
The one who repents is like one who has never sinned, as stated in the hadith. What is tawba? When a person commits a mistake, a fault, for weak Muslims like us, it is turning away from it, turning back.
Mustafa Özbağ Efendi — What Is Tawba? — Genuine Remorse and Return
Repentance with the Tongue, the State, and the Heart
Mustafa Özbağ Efendi enumerates three layers of tawba. The first is the one with the tongue:
There is tawba with the tongue; that is, a person at the very least, in the briefest form, saying Astaghfirullah al-'Azim. […] This is that person's tawba with his tongue.
Mustafa Özbağ Efendi — What Is Tawba? — Genuine Remorse and Return
The second is the one with the state, that is, with behavior:
And there is also tawba with the state. What is this tawba with the state? That person's not returning to that sin again. This is also tawba in deed; that is, that person repented in deed, that sin did not return again.
Mustafa Özbağ Efendi — What Is Tawba? — Genuine Remorse and Return
The third is the one with the heart:
And there is also tawba of the heart. […] Its furthest point is that he repented with his heart. From then on, the door of returning to that sin is closed in that person; he does not even let it pass through his heart.
Mustafa Özbağ Efendi — What Is Tawba? — Genuine Remorse and Return
The Repentance of Everyone, the Repentance of the 'Arif
Mustafa Özbağ Efendi distinguishes tawba as the tawba of the common people, of the 'arif (the knower of God), and of those of still higher stations. For the common people, tawba is abandoning sin:
The tawba of the common people, in this sense, is turning back, retreating from the wrongs, the shortcomings, the evils they have committed.
Mustafa Özbağ Efendi — 140th Dergah Talk — Tawba, Prayer, and Gnosis ('Irfan)
The 'arifs, on the other hand, repent not for sin but for heedlessness:
The tawba of the 'arifs: they repent of their heedlessness. They repent of a moment's forgetting. They repent of a moment's not remembering. They repent, saying, "I abandoned the dhikr of Allah for a moment."
Mustafa Özbağ Efendi — 140th Dergah Talk — Tawba, Prayer, and Gnosis ('Irfan)
The Conditions of Tawba
Mustafa Özbağ Efendi explains the conditions through the tawba of Adam (peace be upon him); this tawba is mentioned in al-A'raf 7/23:
He confessed his wrongdoing, and at the same time expressed that he felt remorse. […] At the same time, he also blamed his own nafs. […] And at the same time, he did not lose hope in Allah's mercy.
Mustafa Özbağ Efendi — The Tawba of Adam (peace be upon him) (short talk)
The elements gathered from the sentences in the narration are as follows (the compilation is ours):
- Confession: if the wrong was against Allah, confession is made to Allah; if it was against a person, it is made to that person.
- Remorse: feeling regret for what was done.
- Blaming the nafs: not placing the fault on someone else and not exonerating one's own nafs.
- Making amends: if there is an injustice, undoing the harm and seeking reconciliation.
- Hope: not losing hope in Allah's mercy.
At the end of the narration, Mustafa Özbağ Efendi says what will happen if these points are observed:
If a person truly observes these five main points and repents in this way, he is as though he had never sinned. Look, he is as though he had never sinned, but he must comply with the rules of this tawba.
Mustafa Özbağ Efendi — The Tawba of Adam (peace be upon him) (short talk)
Istighfar and Dhikr
Istighfar is asking for forgiveness. Mustafa Özbağ Efendi does not separate istighfar from tawba, and he places tawba within dhikr:
What is istighfar? Are tawba and istighfar different things? They are not; they are more or less the same things. For that reason, neither tawba nor istighfar are different things. […] Moreover, tawba is under the umbrella of dhikr. It is also dhikrullah, that is, remembering Allah.
Mustafa Özbağ Efendi — What Is Tawba? — Genuine Remorse and Return
Tawba Nasuh: Sincere Repentance
Tawba nasuh, which appears in at-Tahrim 66/8, is one of the verses Mustafa Özbağ Efendi recites in his talks. He explains the meaning of the word nasuh as follows:
Nasuh tawba means sincere tawba. Nasuh means sincere. It means with ikhlas (pure sincerity). […] That person will not return again, will not do it again. He will not fall into that deficiency again. He will not fall into that wrong again.
Mustafa Özbağ Efendi — 140th Dergah Talk — Tawba, Prayer, and Gnosis ('Irfan)
He sets the measure as follows:
Look, tawba is abandoning a sin. […] In deed you will abandon a sin; that is the essence of tawba. And the deeper, inward side of tawba is that the sin will not pass through your heart, will not pass through your mind, you will not think of returning to it again. The true tawba, the tawba we call nasuh tawba, is that.
Mustafa Özbağ Efendi — 26th Dergah Talk — True Repentance
Sincerity is tested in repetition:
Repentance must be with sincerity, genuine, far from the games of the nafs, far from the deception of Satan. Does Satan deceive while one is repenting? Yes. If you commit the same sin again, Satan is deceiving you through that very repentance. If you fall again into the same filth, pardon the expression, you are in the trap of the nafs.
Mustafa Özbağ Efendi — 2025 Talk #154 — Masnavi, Couplet 2210: The Repentance of Repentance
The Rights of Others and Repentance
If the sin was also committed against a person, repentance becomes twofold. Mustafa Özbağ Efendi first explains confession:
You committed an offense against Allah; confess your offense to Allah. Or you committed an offense against a person; then go before that person and confess your offense to them as well. Say: I made this mistake against you, I did this wrong to you. Confess it to that person himself.
Mustafa Özbağ Efendi — The Repentance of Adam, peace be upon him (short talk)
Then, the return to the one whose right was violated:
If he made a mistake, a shortcoming, a deficiency, if he violated someone's rights, if he committed an offense against someone, if he caused harm, he will go and seek release from him by reconciling with him. This is repentance in action.
Mustafa Özbağ Efendi — The Repentance of Adam, peace be upon him (short talk)
The Place of Repentance in Sufism
Mustafa Özbağ Efendi places repentance at the beginning of the path. This should be read together with the account of the path in the pages What Is Seyr-i Suluk? and Four Gates, Forty Stations :
The first condition of Sufism, the first condition, the first and most important matter, is repentance. If someone is to be a person of Sufism, if he is to enter a tariqa, his first condition is that he repent.
Mustafa Özbağ Efendi — 148th Dergah Talk — Repentance, Taqwa and the Perfect Murshid
He describes the state of one who does not abandon repentance through his own practice:
We repent to Allah at least a hundred times a day. We repent because we regard repentance as an act of worship, and we repent because we constantly see ourselves as sinners. A person who does not see himself as a sinner has no place in Sufism, in the tariqa.
Mustafa Özbağ Efendi — 171st Dergah Talk — Repentance, the Circle of Dhikr
After Repentance
Falling into sin again after repentance is a frequently asked question. Mustafa Özbağ Efendi first says not to abandon repentance:
So, should we not repent? Let us repent, even if only with our tongue.
Mustafa Özbağ Efendi — 2025 Talk #154 — Masnavi, Couplet 2210: The Repentance of Repentance
Then he explains Allah's forgiveness through a hadith narration:
Allah said: My servant remembered his Lord who would forgive him; I have forgiven him. He sinned again, and repented again. Allah said: My servant remembered his Lord who would forgive him; I have forgiven him. He even said it a third time: I forgave again. There is one more statement after that: Now, whatever you do from here on, do it, He said. Allah's mercy is vast, yet it is also said in the hadith: Allah accepts only the repentance that is made from the heart.
Mustafa Özbağ Efendi — 2025 Talk #154 — Masnavi, Couplet 2210: The Repentance of Repentance
He also attributes despair to Satan:
All of these are the words of Satan, the whispering of Satan. […] But whatever happens, never give up hope, and knock on the door of repentance every day.
Mustafa Özbağ Efendi — 188th Dergah Talk — Repentance and Hope
Where to Begin? Reading Order
For daily practice, Mustafa Özbağ Efendi advises never letting repentance leave the tongue:
The dervish will not abandon repentance. He will repent every day, repent for everything, repent for every state of his. He will not let it fall from his tongue; he will not let his repentance fall from his tongue.
Mustafa Özbağ Efendi — 171st Dergah Talk — Repentance, the Circle of Dhikr
- What Is Repentance? — short talk. The definition; repentance with the tongue, with the state, and with the heart.
- The Repentance of Adam, peace be upon him — short talk. Confession, remorse, reconciliation, hope.
- 140th Dergah Talk. The repentance of the common people and of the gnostic.
- 26th Dergah Talk. True repentance.
- 2025 Talk #154. Sincerity and repetition.
- 188th Dergah Talk. Repentance and hope.
- 171st Dergah Talk. The place of repentance in Sufism.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is repentance?
According to Mustafa Özbağ Efendi's definition, repentance is turning away from a mistake and a fault, "turning away from there, turning back." It has three aspects: with the tongue, with the state, and with the heart.
What are the conditions of repentance?
The elements gathered from Mustafa Özbağ Efendi's account of the repentance of Adam, peace be upon him, are as follows: confession, remorse, blaming the nafs, making amends and reconciliation, and not despairing of mercy.
Are repentance and istighfar the same thing?
Mustafa Özbağ Efendi says, "Repentance and istighfar are not different things," and he mentions repentance under the umbrella of dhikr.
What is tawba nasuh?
It is sincere repentance. According to Mustafa Özbağ Efendi, "Tawba nasuh means sincere repentance," and it includes not falling into that wrong again.
How does one repent from a sin that involves the rights of others?
According to Mustafa Özbağ Efendi, a person who has violated another person's rights goes to the one whose right was violated, confesses his offense, makes amends for the harm, and reconciles with him.
What happens if one sins again after repentance?
Mustafa Özbağ Efendi advises never giving up repentance: «Let us repent, even if only with our tongues.» Despairing of Allah's mercy, on the other hand, is a whisper (waswasa) of Satan.
Related Pages
- The Story of the Prophet Adam: Creation, the Names, and Repentance
- What Is Hajj? The Meaning of Hajj and the Kaaba
- What Is Death? Death, the Grave, and Barzakh in Sufism
- What Is Guidance (Hidayat)? Guidance Is from Allah | Mustafa Özbağ Efendi
- What Are the Rights of Others (Haqq al-'Ibad)? Rights of Others and Seeking Forgiveness
- What Is Heedlessness (Ghafla)? Heedlessness and Awakening in Sufism
- What Is Gratitude (Shukr)? Gratitude and Praise (Hamd) in Sufism
- What Is Patience (Sabr)? Patience and Trial in Sufism
- Repentance — all talks
- Questions: Sufism — the first gate of the tariqa · The three stations of repentance
- Questions: The repentance of the common people, sincere repentance (tawba nasuh) · Repentance and backbiting · The conditions of repentance
- What Is the Nafs? · What Is Dhikrullah?
- What Is the Perfect Murshid (Murshid-i Kamil)? · What Is Sayr u Suluk (the Spiritual Journey)?
- Who Is Mustafa Özbağ Efendi?
- All topics
Sources
- The Holy Qur'an, al-A'raf 7/23; at-Tahrim 66/8 — verses cited in Mustafa Özbağ Efendi's talks; no translation of the verses is given.
- The hadith narrations are as related by Mustafa Özbağ Efendi; no source citations are given.
- Mustafa Özbağ Efendi, dergah and question-and-answer talks, mustafaozbag.com. Each of the quotations is linked to the video recording of the relevant talk.