Sunday, November 15, 2026
OUR PATH IS THE PATH OF PROPHETHOOD
Mustafa Özbağ
Irshad & Tasawwuf · Official Site

Silsile

Translated from Turkish. Original article (Turkish) →

Silsila-yi Sharifa

The Spiritual Chain of Lineage from the Prophet (peace be upon him) to Mustafa Özbağ Efendi

Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa
Peace and blessings be upon him
Hazrat Ali al-Murtada
May Allah honor his face
⋮ Chain of the Sheikhs ⋮
Sayyid Abd al-Qadir al-Jilani
Pir of the Qadiriyya (d. 1166)
Sayyid Ahmad al-Rifa'i
Pir of the Rifa'iyya (d. 1182)
⋮ The Qadiri-Rifa'i Chain ⋮
Sayyid Muhammad ibn Abd al-Rahim al-Nishabi
The Sheikh of Hazrat Haji Bektash Baba
Abd al-Rahim al-Tantawi
May Allah sanctify his secret
Abd al-Rahim al-Nishawi
May Allah sanctify his secret
al-Hajj al-Hafiz Abu Bakr al-Siddiq al-Chorumi
Haji Bekir Baba — May Allah sanctify his secret
Haji Ali Haydar Efendi of Akhaltsikhe
May Allah sanctify his secret
Haji Mustafa Anaç Efendi of Çorum
May Allah sanctify his secret
Haji Abdullah Gürbüz Efendi of Nevşehir
May Allah sanctify his secret
Mustafa Özbağ Efendi
May Allah sanctify his dear secret

The Outward Paths of Ijaza (Authorization)

① The Mesudiye Tekke in Bosnia
The Qadiri-Rifa'i Tariqa
② The Kabbashi Dergah in Sudan
Ijaza of Spiritual Guidance (Murshidship)

Ijazanama of Naqib al-Nuqaba — Chain of the Blessed Mantle (Khirqa-yi Sharifa)

1 Jumada al-Akhira 1415 (November 1994)

Sayyid Muhammad Abd al-Rahim Efendi
Egypt — Tanta
Lineage: Hazrat Ali al-Murtada → Imam Husayn (may Allah be pleased with him)
▼ invested him with the mantle
Abu Bakr al-Siddiq Efendi of Çorum
Haji Bekir Baba — May Allah sanctify his secret
▼ invested him with the mantle
Ali Haydar Baba Efendi of Akhaltsikhe
May Allah sanctify his secret
▼ invested him with the mantle
Haji Mustafa Anaç Efendi of Çorum
May Allah sanctify his secret
▼ invested him with the mantle
Haji Abdullah Gürbüz Efendi of Nevşehir
Perfect Murshid — Holder of Nine Tariqas
▼ appointed him Naqib al-Nuqaba
Mustafa Özbağ Efendi
Naqib al-Nuqaba — Sheikh of the Sohbet

The Mantles of the 9 Tariqas Mentioned in the Ijazanama:

Qadiriyya, Rifa'iyya, Naqshbandiyya, Badawiyya, Dusuqiyya, Shadhiliyya, Mevleviyya, Bektashiyya, Bayramiyya

The Lam-Alif Girdle: Those appointed as Naqib al-Nuqaba gird on the lam-alif. Because Hazrat Suhayb ibn Sinan al-Rumi girded the lam-alif on our master Hazrat Ali (may Allah honor his face), this custom has continued.

The Noble Pirs (Invoked in the Lesson Sheet):

Sayyid Abd al-Qadir al-Jilani, Sayyid Ahmad al-Rifa'i, Sayyid Ahmad al-Badawi, Sayyid Ibrahim al-Dusuqi, Sheikh Abu al-Hasan al-Shadhili, Shah-i Naqshband Muhammad Baha al-Din, Mawlana Jalal al-Din Rumi, Haji Bektash-i Veli, Haji Bayram-i Veli, Mehmed Muhyiddin Üftade, Uways al-Qarani, Muhyiddin Ibn al-Arabi, Niyazi-i Misri.

Source: mustafaozbag.com/gunluk-vird — Daily Wird Lesson Sheet


The Difference Between the Ijaza of Caliphate and the Ijaza of Sheikhhood

Greetings, may your talks be blessed,

1. Last week you said that you had not given anyone the caliphate, but there is a video on YouTube about an ijaza you gave in Bosnia. What do you say about that?

The ijaza of caliphate and the ijaza of sheikhhood are different things.


The Station of Mutmainna and Recognizing the Sheikh

2. In one of his talks, Abdullah Efendi says: "Unless the dervish reaches the station of mutmainna, he cannot tell whether his sheikh is false or genuine." You are the one among us who knew him best. So what did he mean to convey with this statement?

A person who has reached mutmainna becomes aware of the state of the grave. For example, he can meet with Hazrat Üftade, he can meet with Hazrat Emir Sultan. A person who has reached mutmainna sees true dreams more often, and small inspirations begin to come to his heart, so it is easier for him to identify his sheikh — let me put it that way.


The Silsila, the Lesson Sheet, and the Matter of Ijaza

3. In the old lesson sheets, Abdullah Efendi had the dergah's silsila invoked, and you have it done in exactly the same way. In this case, you yourself, esteemed sir, said: Actually the Sheikh Efendi should not have written the silsila, because Mustafa Efendi of Çorum had not given him the caliphate — you said so; that is, you did not find this correct from the standpoint of the Sufi tradition. Is it possible for you to explain this?

Now, when a perfect murshid, a sheikh efendi, grants sheikhhood to someone, once he grants sheikhhood to that person, it is a sign that this person continues that silsila, and he can include that silsila in his own lesson sheet. Why? Because that sheikh has commissioned the sheikh who will come after him. If he holds an ijaza in his hand, a proof, then technically he can substantiate it. Haji Mustafa Efendi of Çorum did not give an ijaza of sheikhhood to anyone. Let me go further: he did not give an ijaza of caliphate to anyone either. For someone who acts as a sheikh, technically it is not correct to write the name of his previous sheikh on his own lesson sheets. The reason? Because that sheikh did not grant him sheikhhood, so how could he technically write him — there is no ijaza at this point. That is, one sheikh efendi did not give an ijaza to another sheikh efendi. When no ijaza has been given, we cannot say, "Well, this person is the continuation of that sheikh." My dear brother, if you had reached the station of sheikhhood in his time, he would have given you the ijaza of sheikhhood too, whoever he might be. So it means that, during his lifetime, he did not see you at the station of sheikhhood. Look, whoever's sheikh this may be, I say this technically and it holds for everyone: someone did not see you at the station of sheikhhood, and because he did not see you at the station of sheikhhood, he did not give you the ijaza of sheikhhood. I say this within the scope of my own Sufi knowledge: I do not consider it appropriate for that person to write his own earlier sheikh in his lesson sheets as though he came from that silsila. The reason? Because that sheikh did not grant him sheikhhood. He is not a continuation of that silsila. Now I am saying this for everyone: Everyone sits down and attaches himself to a sheikh, and after that sheikh passes away -look, here is the deviation of this- after that sheikh passes away, he says, I am the continuation of that sheikh, and carries on. For example, after Sheikh Efendi passed away, someone else -let me not mention a name now, because it would become backbiting, gossip, slander, it would turn into something- someone else, although he had not received lessons from Sheikh Efendi, said, I am the continuation of Abdullah Efendi, and carried on after Sheikh Efendi. My dear brother, Sheikh Efendi did not give a caliphate or a sheikhship authorization in writing to any of the nakib al-nukaba (chief of the chiefs) within this dergah; where do you get off being his continuation when you did not even receive lessons from him? These are deceptions, these are tricks.

Look, I am not saying this because I want to do it. Sheikh Efendi said about me, "Announce your sheikhship." He told me this. I said I would not do such a thing, I did not come here for sheikhship; he told another friend of ours, "You say it," and he came out to the community and announced what Sheikh Efendi had said. Even though that was the case, Sheikh Efendi never said to my face, I have taken back the sheikhship I gave you. Look, he did not say such a word to my face. He did not say to my face, "I have taken your lessons," he did not say to my face, "I have taken your zakirship," he did not say to my face, "I have taken your sheikhship." Behind my back people claim that he said this and that. These matters are not settled by hearsay. If a sheikh gave sheikhship to someone, picked up the phone and said, "I have given you sheikhship, from now on you may act as a sheikh," then that person may act as a sheikh. Then, "Damn it, I took back your sheikhship." Took it back where, brother? Did you buy tomatoes and peppers at the market and sell them? Is this merchandise? This is not right. Look, Sheikh Efendi did not make this mistake anyway. He could have called me and said: My child, I gave you sheikhship, and I have also taken your sheikhship back; I gave you zakirship, and I have taken your zakirship back; I gave you lessons, and I have taken your lessons back. He could have said this. Would a sheikh be afraid of a disciple? If a sheikh is afraid of a disciple, he is not a sheikh in the first place. Look, a perfect murshid (murshid-i kamil) has no fear of a disciple; if he is afraid of a disciple, then that person is not a perfect murshid. Perfect murshids do not act out of fear. If I were to write this -because I have witnesses- everyone who was present at that gathering is a witness: Sheikh Efendi says to someone: I told Musta Efendi, he wanted to say this, you will go out to the community and say it, and everyone will attach themselves to Musta Efendi, as being the sheikh. Fine, and then afterwards you would say "damn it" and turn back, for example? He could have turned back, but he did not say any such thing to me, so I cannot say anything of this kind about Sheikh Efendi, I cannot say he turned back. Others claim that he said so. You are the ones claiming it. As a result of those claims, I went to him and said, they are saying this and that, that you have taken my lessons, my zakirship, everything of mine. They are lying, he said to me. That is what he told me as well. They are lying, you mind your own business, he said to me. Very well, may Allah make his way clear. Despite that, he gave me a written authorization (icazet). He gave it to no one else. For someone to get up and act as a sheikh on the strength of Abdullah Efendi, saying I am his continuation, is not ethical, it is not right. Look, from the standpoint of the method of Sufism (tasawwuf) it is not right. So a person may say, in his own way, I was raised under this sheikh of mine, I grew up here, I can recite for his spirit (ruhaniyet). I can recite. Look, I can recite. Why? I stayed with him for eighteen years, he has a claim of labor on me, I can recite for him; he said to me, you will act as a sheikh, you may act as a sheikh. He even had it announced; if I wished, I could also continue his path. I -I am giving an example- could have it written on the lesson papers, but technically, my dear brother, he did not give me a sheikhship authorization. Hacı Mustafa Efendi of Çorum did not give it to him either. You do not hold an authorization (icazet), so how could you give one to someone else? You have no sheikhship authorization, so whom will you give a sheikhship authorization to, in writing? You cannot. You give it, you give it, but "I did it, so it is done," he says. Sheikh Efendi did not do such a thing and did not give it to anyone anyway. He gave only the nakib al-nukaba authorization to five people; to the rest he gave a nakib authorization, that much. This is what Sheikh Efendi gave.

That is why, I still do not find it right for those who, after Abdullah Efendi Hazretleri, prepare the lesson papers as though they were a continuation of Sheikh Efendi. This is not right. May Allah forgive me, I would not have wanted to say this in the manner of a shath (ecstatic utterance); were I to claim it, it would be my right. Why? Sheikh Efendi had it announced to everyone. Whether someone accepts it or not is a separate matter. Someone says, come on, what has that got to do with anything, I don't believe it. He doesn't believe it; don't believe it, you are not obliged to believe it, but if I were to get up and say this, I would say: this man made it up on his own. Did somebody else say it? Yes. Did somebody else say it? Yes. Whether or not someone considers this sufficient is a separate matter, so here, since Çorumlu Hacı Mustafa Efendi had not given him a sheikhly authorization (ijaza), Sheikh Efendi could have refrained from writing it; in my view, technically, he should not have written it. I am not saying this as criticism; I am saying it from a technical standpoint. Sheikh Efendi, too, technically did not give me an ijaza; he said it verbally. Can I write it even though he said it verbally? Yes. He said it verbally, and there are witnesses to this: all the old dervishes, everyone who was present at the sohbet that day, are witnesses. Did he take it back? He would have had to come and say again, through the same channel, "I have taken back his sheikhhood"; he did not say anything of the sort. He did not say such a thing, and so it was left standing there. As for me, I neither said "I rejected it" nor did I say "fine, I am the continuation of his path"; I did not say anything of that kind either. So it is a bit like reopening old ledgers, but people should know, those who want to learn, those who want to hear the truth, those who want to know the truth should hear it: Abdullah Efendi Hazretleri did not have a sheikhly ijaza from Çorumlu Hacı Mustafa Efendi, and Sheikh Efendi Hazretleri, before he passed away, did not outwardly give a sheikhly ijaza to anyone. Verbally, he gave it to Ahmet Turan abi in Sivas, he said what he said; he told me this too: "I told Ahmet Turan as well, let him declare his sheikhhood, and I am telling you too: declare your sheikhhood while I am still alive." I said, "I cannot declare it, I cannot say it, sir, please forgive me, I did not come here for sheikhhood, I am sorry, I did not want to say it like this." He said, "I will find someone to say it," and he called a friend on the phone and had him say it. I do not know what they discussed among themselves; that friend knows. That friend announced the words Sheikh Efendi had spoken to everyone in the whole lesson, he declared it; that is all.


Stations Seen in Dreams and the Master's Interpretation

4. A dervish sees a dream, and when he tells it to his master, he says, "My master gave no importance to my dream," or "In my dream they gave me such and such stations, but my master did not give them." What do you say about such statements?

These are not right things. Whenever someone sees a station in his dream, sees it this way or that way in his dream, his master interprets it accordingly; his master knows the symbol of that station accordingly. If there is no symbol there, then that station, that dream, is not a righteous dream (salih rüya). But his master may also leave it without interpretation, yet he may think that it could turn into reality, pray for him, and cast his gaze (nazar) upon him in this matter; these things can happen. Therefore, whether a dream is interpreted or not, however it was interpreted or not interpreted, dervishes must submit and not raise their voices; but people are very covetous in this regard. Especially dervishes, may Allah protect us; instead of listening and obeying, they ask, "Sir, what is the meaning of this? Sir, what is the state of this? Could you explain this?" My dear brother, there is no rule that everything will be explained and everything will be said; be calm, be patient, continue on your path. When something happens to you, do not wonder; we take pride in it, we applaud it. For you to become a perfected person makes us happy; we have no difficulty in this regard. Therefore, such statements are not right statements; they are even what could lead a person astray, may Allah protect us.


Living a Life Indexed to Dreams and States

5. Some of our dervish brothers live a life indexed to dreams and states (hal), and by this they see themselves on an axis of right or wrong. For example: "I received a warning in my dream," or "had it been wrong, I would have received one." Even regarding certain rulings in the principles of fiqh (usul al-fiqh), in tafsir, in the sira, in the hadiths and so on, as if those rulings did not exist, as if they were the first to notice them, their lives continue to be indexed to dreams and states. Even if you read the books, these rulings are already there; but on a matter they have not read, they carry an interpretation over from a dream into life as if there were none. What do you say about such convoluted, intertwined, complicated states?

Both dreams and states are all subject to the sharia within the circle of the Qur'an and the sunna. Whatever a person sees in his dream or in his state, all of it is subject to the sharia. Dreams and states that are subject to the sharia are sound; therefore, when a person is going to act according to his dream or his state, he is obliged to inform his master. If he acts by himself according to his own dream and state, he has become his own sheikh; that is, his nafs has become a sheikh to him, he is proceeding under the sheikhhood of his own nafs, and his spiritual bond with his master has ceased, if there is anyone who acts according to his dream and state. Because all dreams, all states, all karamat (miracles of saints), and all spiritual manifestations are subject to the sharia. Anything that does not conform to the sharia is satanic, it is heresy (zandaqa), may Allah protect us, and interpreting life and religion in this way is dangerous and wrong. We live our lives within the realm of causes, according to the outward; but if something was pointed out to us in a dream, if a warning came to us in our state, we go and tell our master: "I saw in my dream that I was selling my house, what should I do?" If he says "Sell," we sell. "I saw in my dream that I was selling this place"; it should not be sold. I have never seen anyone who dreamed a dream saying, "Give your property to such-and-such a person." Let us say my dervishhood began in '85, '85-'86, and we are in 2020, so it has been thirty-four years, more or less. In thirty-four years, in a dervish's dream: I have never seen anyone dream "Go and donate your property to so-and-so," or "Go and donate your car to so-and-so," or "Go and donate the hundred thousand dollars in your safe to so-and-so." Then there is a problem. Let me say even more: in thirty-four years I have seen only a few dervishes who saw a poor person in their dream and received the command "Go and give charity to this poor person." Yes. When it comes to flying away and escaping, we are wonderful; when it comes to acting according to our nafs, we are wonderful. A man commits something forbidden and says, "If this were wrong, it would have been shown to me in my dream." You fool, who are you that it would be shown to you in your dream while you are committing the forbidden? He wrongs his wife: "Even if I make a mistake, I would see it in my dream." You have fallen so low, you have followed your nafs so much, that you are not even being warned in your dream; look at the matter from that angle. If you had a little spirituality, you would be warned in your dream. So it means you have fallen so low that you are not even warned in your dream; what giant magnifying mirror are you looking at yourself in? May Allah protect us.


The Caliphs and Ijazas of Hacı Mustafa Efendi of Çorum

6. We had not heard of anyone else to whom Mustafa Efendi of Çorum gave an ijaza. That is how it was told to us.

A caliph of Tığlıoğlu Mehmed Efendi of İskilip (d. 1994), who received the caliphate (1965) from Mustafa Efendi of Çorum, and who also holds an ijaza from him, is reportedly still serving as a sheikh in his tekke in Çorum. The paragraph briefly quoted below writes on this subject as follows:

"Hacı Mehmed Efendi of Tığlı, who began guiding people after the death of his sheikh Kadir'in Ali Efendi in 1946, was a Qadiri-Halisi sheikh; after Ali Haydar Efendi of Ahıska granted the caliphate to Hacı Mustafa Anaç Efendi of Çorum, he went with his dervishes and pledged allegiance to Hacı Mustafa Efendi. In the Efendi's own words: Though they were masters, they became apprentices again." (I can provide the source separately if requested.) How do you assess this situation?

If Hacı Mustafa Efendi of Çorum gave an ijaza to another sheikh, that ijaza must be present, that is, this Hacı Mehmed Efendi of Tığlı was already a sheikh with an ijaza from someone else. Even though he was a sheikh with an ijaza from someone else, he went to attach himself to Hacı Mustafa Efendi of Çorum, which is a wonderful thing; and if Hacı Mustafa Efendi of Çorum gave him a written ijaza, then this written ijaza needs to be seen; otherwise that person went and took lessons from Hacı Mustafa Efendi of Çorum again. Taking lessons from Hacı Mustafa Efendi of Çorum does not mean that Hacı Mustafa Efendi of Çorum gave him an ijaza. He gives him lessons and says, "Brother, continue your sheikhship there." This is a separate technique in Sufism, but now it will sound like a shath (ecstatic utterance), and I do not want to say such a thing; for example, a certain Sheikh Efendi saw this humble one in his dream, and I said you need to take lessons; he said, "I took them, I accepted," and I said, "Fine." Now that person is a sheikh, but one with an ijaza. At this point, that person also continues his sheikhship there; if I see him as a mature sheikh, I must write him an ijaza. Giving him lessons is one thing, giving him an ijaza is another. I am speaking about these matters openly so that such an inheritance, such knowledge, may remain. Otherwise, can a sheikh take lessons from another sheikh? The answer: He can, but that sheikh must give him an ijaza. If he does not give an ijaza, then he has taken lessons, they have felt affection for one another, they have established brotherhood with each other; this is a different thing.

Now of course, until today I had not explained these matters openly and clearly. Time passes, life passes, and it was not asked so clearly; may Allah be pleased with the brother who asked, and I thank him. When clear questions are asked, one must of course give clear answers, and I tried to answer what the matter is; otherwise we have no business with anyone's sheikh, path, or dervishhood; we want correct knowledge to remain for people. Those who come later, by themselves, do not know, and they produce a great many things, they say a great many words. These matters are not something to joke about, they are not child's play; therefore, if a sheikh said to someone, "I have given you sheikhship," these are not words to be spoken in jest, or in anger, or out of sheer whim. If that is the case, then his sheikhhood becomes open to dispute, may Allah protect us. That is why, if an ijazah (authorization) has been written, these are not matters to be taken lightly like some joke. The one who writes that ijazah and sets his seal beneath it takes upon himself the spiritual responsibility for that person. When that person receives his ijazah and appears on the Day of Gathering, and says, "This man gave me the ijazah of sheikhhood, and I acted as a sheikh on the strength of that ijazah," then the one who gave it must be able to lift that responsibility from himself, and he must be able to say, "I gave him the ijazah because, for example, Hazrat Pir or the Prophet (peace be upon him) commanded me to do so"; only then is that spiritual responsibility lifted from him. But if, without saying such a thing, he says to someone, for instance on his own initiative, "I have given you sheikhhood, you are a sheikh," then he has taken on that person's spiritual responsibility, or if he has written an ijazah for him, he has taken on that person's spiritual responsibility. Writing an ijazah is not such an easy thing. Mark my words, it is not an easy thing. A person who does not know its spiritual importance, who does not know its spiritual responsibility, who does not know its spiritual depth or spiritual height, says some offhand thing like that, and in saying it he both ruins himself and ruins the one he said it to. Why? Because he himself is empty, because he has not reached that state, because he is not qualified for that state, and yet he struts about saying "I am a sheikh," putting on airs, making shath (ecstatic boasts) here and there; may Allah protect us, he will not be able to answer for it. That is why a murshid-i kamil (a perfected spiritual guide) must be careful about the words that come out of his mouth. When he says to someone, "You are the sergeant (chavush) here," that person is the sergeant and carries out his duty as sergeant. When he says to him, "You are the naqib," that person is a naqib and carries out his duty as naqib, and at the moment he grants him the position of naqib, that person must have a spiritual proof within him. If a murshid-i kamil says to someone, "You are the naqib al-nuqaba," there must be a spiritual proof within that person. If there is no spiritual proof, and he said it to him that way, then it has been mere whim and fancy. When he says to someone, "You are a caliph," when he says it outwardly, "You are a caliph," it has a spiritual depth and height. That sheikh efendi takes upon himself the spiritual responsibility for him, and when he says, "You are a caliph," he must write him an ijazah, if he himself holds an ijazah. If he himself holds no ijazah, then even if he says to him "You are a caliph," he must not be able to give him the ijazah of caliphate, he must not give it, because he himself has no ijazah of sheikhhood. "Well, it was given spiritually." If it was given spiritually, then it comes to you outwardly as well; it comes to your feet, it is brought and placed before you. If the Prophet (peace be upon him) gave you something spiritually, its outward manifestation must also appear in you; this is my belief, this is what I know. If you saw something in your dream, it will also come to you outwardly and its ijazah will be given. I know this. If a person has a spiritual state, if he has a spiritual station, its outward justification comes as well. For what is Allah, the Exalted, not capable of, that He should not be capable of this? Will this matter not be inspired to the Prophet (peace be upon him)? Or is Allah far from inspiring the hearts of the murshids, the living sheikhs, of that time? Whatever he needs comes to him. If Allah has given someone a spiritual duty, everything he needs comes to him. Even if he has nothing at all, even if he is a man stripped bare on this earth, even if he is someone whom no one on this earth esteems, it does not matter at all. There is nothing difficult for Allah. When the Almighty gives someone a station, who can take that station from his hand? Let people sit and say whatever they like about that person, that he was not given an ijazah, that this happened, that that happened. Leave it, my child, pass over that. If Allah has given him something, He gives him everything he needs. What does he need? An ijazah. He gives the ijazah too. What does he need? A tekke. He gives the tekke too. What does he need? A dergah. He gives the dergah too. What does he need? Murids. He gives the murids too. What does he need? People who will see dreams. He gives the people's dreams too. What does he need? Whatever he needs, He gives him. If a station is coming, whatever belongs to that station is given to him. For example, you appointed a governor to a place. The governor's rights are defined, his law is defined, the tools and equipment and vehicles in his hands are defined; you appoint a governor to a place. You appointed a governor and he has nothing. What kind of governor is he then? He is not a governor. The state is such that when it appoints a governor, the governor's whole staff comes with him. In the same way, the spiritual path, Sufism, is such a thing: if someone has been given a position, everything he needs is given to him. No one will make it empty. So it is not a matter of, 'The sheikh was going to give it but did not,' or 'The sheikh was thinking of giving it, but then this one stepped in, that one stepped in, and so he did not give it.' A perfected murshid (murshid-i kamil) is under no one's command. A perfected murshid is not under the command of his wife, his children, his spouse, his son, his servant, his grandfather, his grandmother. A perfected murshid is under the command of Allah, of the Messenger of Allah, of the Companions, of the pir efendis. What will influence him is something spiritual: he sees it in a dream, he sees it in a state (hal), an inspiration comes to his heart. That is what will influence him. Whoever tries to influence him outwardly may think they have influenced him. That is why a perfected murshid is a person of steadfastness (istikamet), a person of capacity (istidat), and in this matter also a person of will (irade). His will is in his own hands. If I see someone in my dream, I give what I saw, and that is that. I am not saying this because I consider myself to have seen something; I am saying it as evidence. I gave the Sheikh Efendi in Bosnia a sapling of a Qadiri tree, and there were other things as well, so I told him: you will walk the Qadiri path here, you will carry it on. No other meaning can be drawn from this anyway; that is a separate matter. A person does whatever the spiritual reality tells him, and he is not held responsible for it. He says: I saw so-and-so in my dream, he commanded me thus, and I carried it out, that is all. Look, that is all. Otherwise, he has a spiritual responsibility, he has a spiritual authority and effectiveness, and one acts accordingly. That is why this is my well-known thesis: walk on, my brother, practice Sufism, say Allah, remember Allah. Allah Himself has said: Whoever remembers Allah, Allah remembers him. That is a great proof. Remember Allah, walk on, and the spiritual reality will not leave you empty-handed. If you have done something, it will not fail to come back to you. Everyone will know their limits, everyone will know their rights, and no one will, all by himself, see himself in a magnifying mirror. This path is the path of humility, this path is the path of struggle against the nafs, this is not a path of 'I have become somebody.' That is what I know. You run on the path of Allah, you walk for Allah, you do things for Allah, and if something is going to be given to you, who is going to stop it? Was Abu Jahl able to stop the prophethood of the Prophet (peace be upon him)? He was not. He chose him as a prophet for Himself; He made him a prophet, supported him, and gave him everything he needed. So if someone is a perfected murshid, He gives him everything he needs. If it is authorization (icazet), the authorization comes; it comes, whatever he needs comes. If he is on the path of Allah, if he is running on the path of Allah, everything will come to him.

The subject is not to discuss the situation of the Sheikh Efendi, may Allah have mercy on him; that is not my concern, may Allah protect us. May Allah be abundantly pleased with him, may the Almighty (Allah) have mercy on him. He truly performed a difficult duty in a difficult time; his work was not easy. It truly was not easy. In that difficult time, he tried to fulfil that difficult duty as it deserved, may Allah be pleased with him, but those who came after him, unfortunately, are exploiting him, and I am saddened by that now. That is, a number of people who came after the Sheikh Efendi, a number of people, unfortunately exploit his Eminence the Sheikh Efendi, and I am saddened by this, and I truly do not know how they will give account on the Day of Gathering. May Allah protect us, may Allah help them, God willing.


The Types of Caliphate: Restricted (Muqayyad) and Absolute (Mutlaq) Caliphate

Greetings. Blessed talks to you all.

I am continuing from the 7th, the Thursday evening, with your permission. Regarding the assignment of duties, I will quote briefly, and then I will move on to the question, God willing. I ask for a little patience and understanding.

You said, "Being a sheikh is not a matter of giving and taking back." You said, "People take back what they have given; Allah does not take back what He has given; it does not befit the majesty of Allah," and you had also said so earlier.

In Sufi books it is stated that a position given to someone, especially the position of sheikh, cannot be taken back, and that doing so is a sign of deficiency. According to the customs of the exalted Rifa'i tariqa, first of all, caliphate is not given without passing, in order, through the ranks of Dervish, Chavush, Naqib, and Nukaba. Caliphate is of two kinds: Restricted Caliphate (Muqayyad) and Absolute Caliphate (Mutlak). Of these, Restricted Caliphate is valid for those who are Nukaba, who are blessed persons and candidates for sheikhship. But if one does not complete the journey of the path (sayr-i suluk), he is not given the authorization of sheikhship, and after the death of his sheikh he cannot become the postnishin (head of the lodge). These persons have the authority to teach lessons, but they cannot accept the allegiance (bay'a) of dervishes. No one is affiliated to them.

Absolute Caliphate, on the other hand: those among the Nukaba who have completed the journey of the path and finished the Seven Names (Asma-i Seba) are given the authorization of murshidship by their sheikh, and they begin to guide independently.

In the practice that has come down from the path of Haji Bekir Baba, the authority of the Sword of Proof (Kilic Burhani) is given to those who are sheikhs, together with the caliphate. This is the practice that has come from his Eminence Bekir Baba.

The sheikh who granted them can take back the caliphate of those we call holders of a restricted caliphate (mukayyed hilafet). But this has three conditions. There is the matter of "TARD" (expulsion) that is spoken about by certain people who are not masters of the principles and rules of the Exalted Tariqa. A dervish may be expelled by the Sheikh Efendi as a matter of testing. Indeed, it has happened that even seekers who had reached the rank of Çavuş and Naqib were expelled. But the conditions for expelling those noble persons who are Nuqaba are very heavy... Expelling caliphs who have received the absolute caliphate and begun giving guidance is absolutely impossible... For expulsion would show a deficiency in the Sheikh. Not a single member of the path of the Ahl al-Bayt takes back what he has given. Those who say things like "Our Sheikh Efendi expelled this one, expelled that one" unknowingly ascribe deficiency to their own Sheikhs.

The masters (mashayikh) who have received the absolute caliphate and begun the duty of guidance independently are considered spiritually detached from their Sheikh. Tığlıoğlu Mehmed Efendi and Hacı Kemâl Efendi, who received the absolute caliphate from Hacı Mustafa Efendi, served as Sheikhs during the same period. These two noble persons had completed their course of spiritual wayfaring (sayr u suluk) under their previous Sheikhs and pledged allegiance to Hacı Mustafa Efendi. The license (ijaza) given to Galib Kuşçuoğlu, the son-in-law of the Sheikh Efendi, on the other hand, is a license for blessing (tabarruk). The late Galib Efendi did not undergo the spiritual path by pledging allegiance to Hacı Mustafa Anaç Efendi. He is a caliph of Maraşlı Mustafa Yardımedici Efendi.


The Matter of Tard and a Technical Explanation

Despite this, we hear it said by word of mouth that Hacı Mustafa Efendi expelled such-and-such a caliph of his. Isn't this a contradiction?

We never heard such a thing from the mouth of Hacı Mustafa Efendi himself, but it used to be said that Çorumlu Hacı Mustafa Efendi, during his lifetime, expelled Galip Efendi and Kemal Efendi; that he had them expelled during their own lifetimes, yet both of them were acting as sheikhs. I heard these things after Çorumlu Hacı Mustafa Efendi had passed away. I have no knowledge as to whether Çorumlu Hacı Mustafa Efendi said this or not, so I did not speak much about it. I was also unable to bring this matter up and discuss it with any of the old dervishes, so it is not possible for me to give a ruling on it; but as a technical matter, the technical information that they cannot be expelled is correct.


Kemâl Akdeniz Efendi, Gâlib Efendi and Tığlıoğlu Mehmed Efendi

Regarding this matter, concerning what was done by those in our chain (silsila) who lived in history and have passed to the hereafter (not to dig things up but to draw lessons), well, in the research I have done, some matters turn out not to be at all as they were told to us.

For example, Kemal Akdeniz Efendi of Kırıkkale and Galip Efendi. Both of their licenses to be sheikhs came from Çorumlu. In Galip Efendi's license, H. Mustafa Efendi has a license prepared and has the name of Kemal Efendi written next to it as a witness, with the words "Sheikh Kemal son of Cemal of Kırıkkale" (1978). A copy of this license is displayed in Galip Efendi's dergahs and on the internet... Thus Çorumlu Mustafa Efendi left behind caliphs, but he did not leave behind a successor to the seat (postnishin). The matter of the tard concerning Kemal Efendi is likewise not as it was told to us. Tard means to drive out. A sheikh may drive his dervish out of the dergah as a matter of testing or on account of some wisdom. Dervishes, Çavuşes and Naqibs can be expelled; the expulsion of the Nuqaba has very heavy conditions. As for a Sheikh who has completed his wayfaring and been authorized to give guidance, he can absolutely not be expelled. It is known that in 1970 Hacı Mustafa Efendi gave a license of sheikhhood to Kemâl Akdeniz Efendi of Kırıkkale with a great ceremony. Moreover, Kemal Efendi himself mentions in his book that he received it directly from our Prophet. The license that Kemal Efendi received is preserved among the members of his family...

True. I know that the license he received hangs in his dergah. This is what I know: they had wanted to take a photograph of that license, I know that too, I know this place. I have some information about this as well, but word will get around somewhere, so I am keeping silent, not out of fear but because it would be perceived differently. I know that the license exists there; in fact, our Seyit Taş, may Allah have mercy on him, saw that license. Seyit Taş is gone now; because they had opened a shop there, when Seyit Taş opened the shop he went together with a friend from Bursa and they took a photograph of it there. That friend was also something of a journalist who took photographs here. So I do have some information about this.

Three people received a license from Mustafa Efendi, and all three of them were people who had already been fully trained.

Tığlı Efendi came ready from İskilip, that is, his wayfaring was complete; Galip Efendi from Maraş; and Kemal Efendi had completed his wayfaring under Ali Haydar Efendi. Because of his age, Mustafa Efendi gave him the license. The old dervishes in Çorum say the following:

"We think that Hacı Mustafa Efendi surely would have wanted to give a license to someone he had trained himself. For that reason, over time he honored his diligent naqibs such as Nevşehirli Abdullah Efendi, Ali Karaman, Yakup and Mustafa Boyraz by saying 'I will give it to you,' but he did not give it. Saying 'I will give' is one thing; saying 'I have given' is another."

Correct. I also heard this from the Sheikh Efendi (may his secret be sanctified), from Abdullah Efendi. He said, my son, he had told us he would write our ijazah, but he did not write it. He told me this. He said this about himself, not about Yakup Efendi. I also know this, so let me explain it here: He sent three or four dervishes from among the companions from Nevşehir to Yakup Efendi, and invited him to the dergah, saying let him come, I will give him the caliphate (khilafa); but Yakup Efendi did not accept. At that time, the companions who went to Yakup Efendi spoke to him somewhat condescendingly; I witnessed some of their conversation, that is, they did not speak in a manner befitting Yakup Efendi, and a mistake occurred there. This is my guess: Yakup Efendi was disturbed by those conversations, and Yakup Efendi did not attach himself to Abdullah Efendi Hazretleri.

In that case, I assume that there were people to whom Hacı Mustafa Efendi gave an ijazah, that is, an ijazah of sheikhhood, and that he had caliphs, but they were not known in Bursa? In this case, what would you say?

I knew that he had given it to Hacı Kemal Efendi, but we were told that after giving it to Hacı Kemal Efendi he expelled him. I also knew that Hacı Kemal Efendi had an ijazah. I knew that he held an ijazah on this matter, but what we were told was that Çorumlu Hacı Mustafa Efendi expelled him during his lifetime, that is how we knew it, and we knew that Çorumlu Hacı Mustafa Efendi himself said so. We also knew that he had expelled Galip Efendi. This was our knowledge.


The Ijazah Chain (Silsila) of Tığlıoğlu Mehmed Efendi

You had said that it is necessary to see the ijazah of Tığlılı Mehmet Efendi, to whom Çorumlu Mustafa Efendi gave an ijazah. Briefly, quoting from the receiving of the ijazah up to the present day; then I will move on to the question, God willing.

Some time after Çorumlu Hacı Mustafa Anaç Efendi Hazretleri became the postnishin (head of the lodge) of the Çorum Rifa'i Dergah in 1957, Tığlıoğlu Mehmed Efendi Hazretleri took along his own naqib, Nuri Efendi, and went to visit him, and they pledged allegiance (bay'a) to Çorumlu Hacı Mustafa Efendi Hazretleri. Seeing no standing in himself, Tığlıoğlu Mehmed Efendi Hazretleri, with great self-effacement, once again "became an apprentice though he was a master," for it was confirmed by many sheikhs of the time that the spiritual rank of Çorumlu Hacı Mustafa Anaç Efendi Hazretleri was very exalted...

Çorumlu Hacı Mustafa Anaç Efendi Hazretleri, in order to entrust to Tığlıoğlu Mehmed Efendi, who was older than himself yet showed great humility, the office of naqib of the Qadiri-Rifa'i path that came down by succession through the line of Hacı Bekir Baba, told Küçük Mustafa Efendi, the calligrapher also known as Bayburtlu Mustafa Efendi (d. 1966), to prepare the ijazah of Naqib al-Nuqaba; thereafter, with his own seal and the seals of the witnesses, they took his spiritual journey (sayr u suluk) upon themselves once again... A short while later, they also gave him the ijazah of spiritual guidance (murshid) through the chain coming from Sayyid Muhammad ibn Abd al-Rahim al-Nishabi (may his secret be sanctified), who was the sheikh of Hacı Bekir Baba Hazretleri...

By 1994, Tığlıoğlu Mehmed Efendi Hazretleri had begun to feel keenly the hardships brought by old age. As a final duty, he gave the ijazah documents, in the presence of witnesses, to three of his naqibs, whose training he had labored over for years until they completed their spiritual journey: to two of them from the Qadiri-Rifa'i order through the chain coming from Çorumlu Hacı Mustafa Efendi, and to the third from the Qadiri-Khalisi order through the chain coming from Sheikh Kadir'in Ali Efendi; and he appointed two of his caliphs as postnishin in İskilip and one in Çorum... After telling his brothers that day, "Our duty is finished! Now wait for me," a few days later, at the age of 109, in 1994, in the evening, while they were reciting the dhikr "Allah, Allah!", they departed to the World of Beauty (Alam-i Jamal)...

Two of his caliphs passed away without appointing a successor, and the only caliph currently alive, Zakir Kümbül Efendi, serves as sheikh in his dergah in Çorum. Zakir Efendi's ijazah is the continuation of the chain that Çorumlu Hacı Mustafa Efendi gave to Tığlıoğlu Mehmed Efendi.

Zakir Efendi has informed us that as soon as the coronavirus is over he will come to Bursa and visit you and the dergah. He will bring all of the ijazahs with him.


Relations with Sister Dergahs

Question: Our grandfather is one; how have the relations of the sister dergahs with one another been in history? Do you see benefit in forming a delegation and having them visit those dergahs? How do you assess all these developments? (Sources can also be provided separately)

We have no trouble with any dergah, and above all we have no trouble whatsoever with the dergah of Çorumlu Hacı Mustafa Efendi Hazretleri. I knew that Zakir Efendi was serving as sheikh in Çorum, but I did not know that Zakir Efendi had such an ijazah. Because what was communicated to us was that his ijazah was not an ijazah of sheikhhood. Since we had a sheikh, we did not go chasing after such a thing, asking what it was or was not; but I know that a person named Zakir Efendi serves as sheikh there, and I know that he is carrying on the Çorumlu Dergah, but I did not know that an ijazah had come to him from Tığlıoğlu; I knew that he was without an ijazah; I knew that he had an ijazah as naqib al-nuqaba, but I did not know that he had an ijazah of sheikhhood. So in this respect there would be no difficulty at all in our relations. If contact needs to be made on this matter, I would gladly make contact; if a visit is needed, I would visit, and there would be no difficulty whatsoever. If such contact is established, I do not see it as a problem. Even in these Corona days we can visit; we can get permission. Once we have permission, we can go and come and pay our visit. After Ramadan we would have no difficulty, but truly, the gathering of these sister dergahs and their coming together is an important thing for the continuity of the path. God willing, we will meet, we will talk, we will converse; it will be good and sweet.


The Matter of Bayburtlu Küçük Mustafa Efendi

You used to relate from Abdullah Efendi: "Hacı Mustafa Efendi gave an ijaza to one person. He did not leave the dergah. He passed away before Hacı Mustafa Efendi. The man from Çorum had 'Sheikh' written on his gravestone." That is what we used to hear from you. That blessed person turns out to have been Bayburtlu Mustafa Efendi. He is also called Küçük Mustafa Efendi. Because he was in the station of a dede, it is customary to write "Sheikh" on his gravestone. Those who have reached the Truth but cannot return to the people are in the station of a dede. His Excellency Ali Haydar Efendi took Hacı Mustafa Efendi, Bayburtlu Mustafa Efendi and Kemal Efendi, seven people in total, into the retreat cell (çilehane). Only Kemal Efendi and Çorumlu Hacı Mustafa Efendi came out of the suluk successfully. He passed away in 1963 and was buried next to Ahıskalı Ali Efendi. By the time Abdullah Efendi came, that blessed person had long since passed away. So this person was not his caliph.


Exploitation After Death and Precautions

Again in the Thursday sohbet you said, regarding the exploitation Abdullah Efendi suffered after his passing, that history repeats itself when its lessons are not learned. May God forbid it, so that it does not happen again over you after your passing, as you know, you often said, by way of an analogy, "When the blind man dies, he becomes almond-eyed" (that is, the dead are praised once they are gone), and so that we do not encounter negative events, God forbid, such as "he told me this in private" or "he gave me that in private," what more would you say to us, repainting well the lane lines on the road and adding traffic warning signs as well?

I do not say anything in private; I have suffered greatly from the troubles this causes. His Excellency Sheikh Efendi also told me many things in private, but there was nothing in writing. Things said in private truly do not constitute a ruling among the dervishes. They do not constitute a ruling for the continuity of the path, for the safety of the path. That is why I have not said anything to anyone in private; I say this openly and clearly. And I have not given anything in writing to anyone either; I say this too openly and clearly. Tomorrow or the day after, there will be none of this "he told me this in private" or "he gave me this in writing." There is no such thing. But if God permits, I am truly planning to prepare new ijazas. I even mentioned it to Cafer and to the friends. I said, let us prepare new ijazas, so that in the future, God willing, we may give them to those who should receive them, to whomever we have seen in our dreams or seen in our spiritual state. We are making our preparations now, God willing, if the Almighty grants breath and life. Some will emerge from among the brothers and friends, and we will also give to those who deserve it, whether from within or from outside. I have no difficulty or problem on this matter, but nobody knows when death will come, so let no one conclude anything on their own: "He was going to give it to me but did not," or "he said this to me but it did not happen." There is no such thing. That is why our zakirs are known, our brothers who lead the lessons, our çavuşes, are known. Everyone, the zakirs and the çavuşes, is currently known and continuing with their lessons. Now, there is one who had not been announced as a çavuş: there is our textile-merchant brother Fehim. I gave him the çavuş role, and the brothers at the dergah do not know about it. Let me say it now so that people here may know. So I have given our brother Fehim the çavuş role, and I told him, you can both give sohbet and lead lessons. In fact I had said it to him before: if you wish, go to Gemlik, I will give you the çavuş role, and lead lessons there. I had already told him this earlier. The friends do not actually know this. I was going to announce it and say it, so that they would add his phone number to the list of those who lead lessons. This is the only one that was not known; all the rest were known. It has probably become known now; it has been two or three days since I told him: lead lessons, give sohbet, give lessons. All the rest are known; it is open and evident in front of the dergah, and there is no problem on this point. That is why at the şeb-i aruz ceremonies I bring all the zakirs and all those who lead lessons up into the hall, so that people may see them there and bear witness one to one, who is doing what, who stands at which point, in which circle. I want them to know this. That is why at the şeb-i aruz ceremonies I bring all the zakir brothers onto the program, so that it is especially made known there. Of course, at the last şeb-i aruz, had he arrived earlier, I would also have brought out the Sheikh Efendi from Bosnia, but it was too late, it did not work out, there was no preparation. As for Sudan, I also told His Excellency Kabbashi, I said, who wants it, give us one of your children, let him come forward, and he did come forward, so our work was done. That is why I have no word given privately to anyone, and there is nothing I have said privately.

Let me put it this way: I truly wish, more than anyone, that Allah would raise up one of our brothers, God willing, that the Almighty would raise one up. While we are still in good health, without leaving any worry behind us, I would be happy, God willing, to grant an ijaza to a brother.


The Source of the Silsila: Is it Abdullah Efendi, or Bosnia and Sudan?

Again, with reference to Thursday evening's sohbet: does your silsila come from Abdullah Efendi, or does it come from the Bosnian Mesudiye Tekke and the Sudanese Qabbashi silsila from which the ijaza was received? If it comes from these places where the ijaza was received, which is what we understood from your sohbet, could you tell us the chains of transmission of these silsilas one by one at a suitable time, as on your website?

God willing. On this point, there is an outward (zahir) silsila. Now, since the subject has come up, let me speak about these things: as an outward silsila, it runs from Abdullah Efendi up to the rank of naqib al-nuqaba. But our spiritual bond with the training of Çorumlu Hacı Mustafa Efendi in the dergah, with the dergah tenure of Çorumlu Hacı Mustafa Efendi, continued; it continued even after Abdullah Efendi passed away. This again is a private matter. That it would continue like this, and the sign of it, was told to me by Yakup Efendi, the naqib al-nuqaba of the Sheikh Efendi of Ankara, during umrah, in the presence of the Prophet (peace be upon him): "The continuation of the dergah is going through you, Mustafa Efendi." In fact, outwardly I did not know Yakup Efendi, and as far as I know he did not know me either. It came to my heart that this was Yakup, and I went to him during umrah, may Allah have mercy on him. I said, "Peace be upon you, I am Mustafa Özbağ from Bursa," and he looked at me and said, "Musta Efendi," and then, "Aren't you Musta Efendi, the brother of our Ahmet?" I said, "Yes." Because my brother used to go back and forth to him; my brother was close with him. In fact, right after I took lessons from Abdullah Efendi, he said a lot to my brother. Actually, even before I took lessons, he told my brother: bring your brother, bring your brother, bring your brother. Because there were three dreams that my brother told about. My brother saw them at the time when he had newly taken lessons. One of them is interesting; my brother told me about it too. Of course, he told it later, my brother told it years afterwards. While Çorumlu Hacı Mustafa Efendi and the whole community were performing dhikr, my brother sees me there too, with my hair and beard turned gray. He had thrown a skewer from afar into my heart. At that time I had no connection with dervishhood yet. Then, in another dream, when my brother went to visit the Çorumlu, he saw that I was sitting next to Çorumlu Mustafa Efendi, with my hair and beard turning gray. So my brother had one more dream like that. My brother is still alive, in Bursa, and anyone can reach him. Since my brother told these dreams to Yakup Efendi, Yakup Efendi said, "Bring him quickly," he told us. Anyway, of course, at that time we took lessons from Abdullah Efendi and carried on. Afterwards my brother told me several times, "Yakup Efendi is calling you, he wants to give you lessons." And I said, "I have already taken my lessons and I am walking on; I have a path, there is no need for anything else." But our spiritual bond with Çorumlu Hacı Mustafa Efendi never ended. In fact, during my first i'tikaf, may Allah forgive me, I craved fried vegetables that had been chilled in the refrigerator. In i'tikaf I was not eating or drinking anything; my tongue and lips were stuck dry. In Bayındır they make fried eggplant, pepper and tomato with yogurt; it is left over from the evening and put away in the refrigerator, and we like to eat it in the mornings. I craved it so much. The blessed one came and, with his own hands, took the fried vegetables with yogurt with three fingers and put them in my mouth. After that I never felt hungry again, may Allah forgive me. Our bond with Çorumlu Hacı Mustafa Efendi always continued; let me put it that way, our bond with him was never cut. It was never cut. In fact, again my brother said: Yakup Efendi had a brother, Karabüklü Mustafa Efendi. After the Sheikh Efendi passed away, when he went to visit him, he said to him, "Whisper in your brother's ear that he should take charge of the dergah, declare his sheikhship, and carry on," that is the meaning. My brother said, "Mustafa Efendi sends his greetings; he said to whisper in your ear that he will come to you." I said, "The phone is at my ear; you tell me what you are going to tell me." He said it like this and that. I said it is nothing I did not already know; I said, "May Allah be pleased with you, brother, forgive me what I owe you." In short, that is how it remained. That is why, as for spiritual ijazas (authorizations), may Allah show them to our dervish brothers in their dreams; there is no point in saying it, technically, because there is no sign of it. It is said that this is a continuation of Çorumlu Hacı Mustafa Efendi, may Allah be pleased with him. Let me not discuss these things now; if the Almighty (Allah) shows its manifestation in a technical sense as well, then there is nothing to be said. I mean, what is the technical manifestation? That meaning, that dream, must also technically turn into an ijaza. If it turns into an ijaza technically as well, then there is nothing to say against it. That is one. Second, the dreams people see themselves and the states they experience bind only themselves. That is why I do not much approve of relaying these things to dervishes, of telling dervishes, "I saw such a dream, they told me such and such, they told me to do such and such." Because people are being deceived with these things, being tricked like this. It is just what that person saw. If Allah has given you something, He will also provide its technical foundation to people. That is why, let me put it this way, outwardly (zahir) we have two silsilas (chains of transmission). The first is from the Mesudiye Tekke, and the second is from Kabbashi Hazretleri in Sudan. This is the outward (zahir) silsila. Is even one silsila enough for a person? Answer: It is enough, but there are two outward silsilas here. Yes, I am saying this outwardly, openly and clearly, what is in my heart: the dergah of Çorumlu Hacı Mustafa Efendi, may Allah be pleased with him, has not been closed. I know that his dergah is not closed. I know that his dergah is not closed, but there is no outward manifestation of it. If the Almighty (Allah) shows an outward manifestation on this point, then we would have no objection to that either; we would have no problem, may Allah make it good, God willing. Let me say this for myself: the position we stand at, or rather the circle we stand in, let me put it that way, the veil we stand behind, is not far from the teaching of Çorumlu Hacı Mustafa Efendi, nor from his manner and conduct. Yes, today it has been updated somewhat toward our own time, it has come toward our day, with certainly some further novelties; that is a separate matter, but it is not something outside the line of Çorumlu Hacı Mustafa Efendi. In general I am in favor of the spiritual and the material, that is, the technical side, going together; therefore there is no need to speak much or to act hastily in these matters. I always say this: I believe that if Allah has given something to someone, its technical foundation will also come into being. If the Almighty (Allah) is going to bring everything into being, He brings it into being on this point. Certainly these matters are spiritual. I do not want to say these things now. Back when I was serving as a zakir (leader of dhikr) in Bayındır, there were people who regarded this humble servant as a sheikh and wanted to take lessons from me as a sheikh. I used to tell them, I have a sheikh, I am his disciple, I have no sheikhhood or anything like that, do not do such things. It has been going on like this for years. If you look at these things, you could step out into the middle and play the sheikh, but these are not the right directions, not the right conduct. What matters is that this affair proceeds on the right footing, both spiritually and technically. Because we should leave behind us a properly straight road. The brothers who are moving with us now are truly enduring hardships; if one may put it so, they are coming along digging a well with a needle. It is not an easy thing: all the attacks, all the words and insults, from both sides, from here and there, none of it is easy, my friends, my brothers. We walk this road standing upright in this matter, but the Almighty (Allah) also gives its reward. Let me put it this way: the dergah they are connected to is not a dergah without ijaza. The place they are connected to and stand in has every kind of material and spiritual ijaza, so for them it is a sturdy handle, a sturdy door. Therefore, if someone is looking for an outward ijaza, there are people, my brother, let him go and look; if he is looking for a spiritual ijaza, let him perform istikhara, and if he sees it in his dream, let him take his lesson. On this point there is no problem for the brothers, and no problem on my part either. I am not someone who set out saying "I have become a sheikh," I never said so, and I will not say it until the end of my life: I will not say "I have become a sheikh." Because those who say "I have become a sheikh" cheapen sheikhhood, may Allah protect us. "I became this, I became that." Go on, my brother, look to your own business; if you have become one, you have become one. It is not nice for you to get up and say it like that. In my opinion it is not nice. Prophets may proclaim their own prophethood, because they act by command. Therefore, for a wali (friend of God), for a murshid-i kamil (perfect spiritual guide), to get up and say "I have become a perfect murshid" strikes me as somewhat absurd, may Allah protect us.


Ijazas Obtained from Abroad and the Matter of Tabarruk (Seeking Blessing)

QUESTION 12 - You said that a certain Efendi who used to act as a sheikh had somehow obtained a professorship title from Azerbaijan. In those days there was a fashion of buying diplomas from abroad with money. These days there is a fashion of studying at a university in Cyprus, but most Cyprus graduates amount to nothing in real life. If they say, "There was no place left in the country with a sound silsila to give an ijaza, so he went and got it from abroad," what can we say?

There will be people who say such things too; anyone can say anything. We did not go abroad to receive an ijaza, nor did we go for anything else. We were invited for the sake of Allah, and we answered the invitation — both sides did. They saw this themselves, in their own way. For example, when I went to Sudan, there was a program on the very night I arrived — a big program where all the sheikhs, all the dervishes, everyone gathered together, like a mawlid. On the very night we arrived, mind you. I landed in Sudan by plane around two or three in the middle of the night, settled into the hotel, the next morning we went to the Sheikh Efendi's tekke, and in the evening we went to his program. When I went to the program that evening — may Allah forgive me — they had prepared the ijaza. That is to say, that ijaza is not the kind of ijaza that can be prepared in two or three hours. They had prepared the ijaza before I even went. And what the Sudanese Kabbashi said — he said something there like: I have known him for a long time. Let me say this now too: I also knew him; it is not that I did not know him, so I knew him as well. As for its being from abroad — if you look at it that way, Haji Bekir Baba's ijaza was also from Tanta in Egypt. Then one could say: was there no one left in the Ottoman lands, in Turkey, to give an ijaza, that he took an ijaza from Tanta in Egypt? Or else all the old sheikhs in Turkey who received an ijaza received it from outside. Why? Because they all came from outside. So what shall we say then — that he could not find one at home and so found one abroad? Everyone says some word or other; there is no problem in this. On this matter, if his heart is not at peace, let him not take lessons from anyone; I have no obligation to prove anything to anyone. If I had come forward by proclaiming something, then I would have to struggle to prove it; but I am not someone who has emerged by proclaiming anything. I worship Allah, I strive to live Sufism; and to the brothers who see me in their dreams, I tell them as well: whatever you see in your dream, I am that — it is that simple. If a man sees an unimportant person in his dream, then I am unimportant; if he sees an important person, then I am important for him. I have no problem with that.


Inwardness and the Spiritual Journey

If this path has an inwardness — and it should — what can you say to us, who are your fellow travelers on the path?

I tell my friends — my inside and my outside are the same — I say it the same way to those far away and to those near: we are here for the sake of Allah, we are here for Allah; no one has any expectation of anyone else; let everyone work and strive for Allah, and the Almighty will surely give whoever works and strives what he deserves.

Did you say to them, "Give me an ijaza," and so those Sheikh Efendis gave you an ijaza? Or did they give you an ijaza as a blessing (tabarruk), without your asking?

Let me put it this way: we had never met outwardly with the Sheikh Efendi in Sudan. He sent one of his dervishes and invited us, and we answered the invitation. I did not meet with the Sheikh Efendi in Sudan, nor with his sons, nor, for that matter, with the dervish who extended the invitation. It was only said that on such and such a date there would be a mawlid there and that we were invited to it. At that time I arranged my plane ticket and my journey on my own, and that was all. This subject was not even discussed. When we got there, we came across this. Perhaps if they looked at the videos, my astonishment would be visible — or rather, let me not say astonishment, my not having expected such a thing; so there is no problem on this point. With the Sheikh Efendi in Bosnia as well, no such thing was ever discussed or spoken of. Not at all. It was never discussed. I would regard it as a humiliation to myself to ask any place for an ijaza in the first place. I would regard it as a humiliation to myself. On this path of Sufism, up to this day, I have never asked anything of anyone on this point, never even spoken of it — may Allah forgive me. I would never ask anything from anyone. I still would not. May Allah open the way for everyone. My principle is this: if Allah gives something to someone, there is no one who can stand in the way of Allah; if Allah has chosen someone for Himself, there is no one who can stand in the way of that. Tear yourself apart as much as you like; if the Almighty is not going to give you an ijaza, He will not give it. I know sheikh efendis who tear themselves apart; I know what they are capable of doing for an ijaza, and I know what they ask for. I do not wish to speak about these matters; may Allah forgive me. There is a saying of Hazrat Rumi: "I looked at the deficiencies and errors around me, and I reached perfection by not doing them." That is why — Sufism is most correct when, by looking at the deficiencies being lived around Sufism and saying, "O my nafs, do not do these things," a person reaches maturity. This is a very beautiful system of discipline. That is why, having seen how much the caliphs and sheikh efendis I know, whom I have known and seen, turned somersaults for that ijaza, I said to myself: "Mustafa Özbağ, never do such a thing; expect nothing from anyone and ask nothing of anyone; say Allah and continue on your path" — thus I advised myself. Now in Turkey there are so many people acting as sheikhs who would sacrifice a great deal for an ijaza. Among the older ones too, I know those who would sacrifice a great deal for an ijaza — may Allah protect us, God willing.


Tabarruk Ijaza, Encouragement Ijaza, Actual Ijaza

Concepts such as teberruk ijazah, encouragement ijazah, actual (practical) ijazah and verbal ijazah, as you know, have by now entered the literature on this matter. What is the story behind all of this?

Now everyone is saying something on this subject. Teberruk ijazah, that is, what they call teberruk ijazah, means he gave it as a blessing. In reality it is not so, but he gave it "for blessing," that is, he presented it as a gift; or encouragement ijazah, again it is not really so, but he gave it for the sake of encouragement. There is a spiritual responsibility in this. How can anyone give it for encouragement, as a blessing? No, these are not right. Verbal ijazah, that is, he gave it by word of mouth. This is not right either. Look, not one of these is right, and people say such things to save their own situation. To save themselves. "Well, I gave him an ijazah, but it was a verbal ijazah." My dear brother, when you were speaking, were you not speaking from the Truth? Was what you said a lie then, was it wrong? Or "I gave it to him just to encourage him" — what are you doing, playing games? Are you joking around? In my opinion these are not proper expressions. That is why all of these are just idle talk. My dear brother, did you see someone in your dream? You did. If in that dream you saw him as a caliph — and as far as I know this is the right way — write and give him an ijazah as a caliph; if you saw that person as a sheikh, write and give him an ijazah as a sheikh. Once you have given that person the ijazah of sheikhood, you have given it, and the responsibility for it belongs to you, my dear brother, that is the end of it. Because will that person act as a sheikh with that ijazah? Yes. All the responsibility belongs to him. At the same time, the one who gave the ijazah will also receive his share of all the reward.

Now, Kabbashi gave a sheikhood ijazah. Well, I am not someone who acts as a sheikh with the sheikhood ijazah that Kabbashi gave, nor am I someone who acts as a sheikh with the ijazah of the Mesudiye Tekke, because I do not act as a sheikh. But if someone did, for example someone whose understanding of the Qur'an and the Sunna is sound, and he acted as a sheikh with that ijazah, reward would go to them too. They would also receive a share from it. Now let us think like this: there is a person who has reached the level of an ustad, who has reached the level at which he can act as a sheikh, and who is also seen spiritually as a sheikh; I would gladly give him an ijazah. Why? However many people he teaches, however many people he trains, I will receive reward from all of them. There is this side to the matter as well. While the Sheikh Efendi was alive, I said to him, "My master, when you pass away, my service to you and to your dergah will come to an end." This is actually a weighty statement. It is not a small statement like that. I explained this to all my friends too; I even explained it within the community, among my friends. At that time people could not work out the meaning behind this statement; they could not work out what this man was saying; it was taken as though it were a statement made in some chaotic moment. It was not. That statement was a manifestation of a truth. That is to say: when you pass away, as Mustafa Özbağ I will not render any service to you or to your dergah; that is, I will not be the continuation of your dergah, I will not be your continuation. If a dhakir, a naqib al-nuqaba', says this openly during a sheikh's lifetime, it is not an empty statement; I am not saying it to praise myself. It is the last thing that would be said to a sheikh, but I am someone who said it first. Forty oxen could not pull the weight of this. Even if you hitched forty oxen side by side and tied this statement behind them, forty oxen could not pull this statement. And when I first said it, I was in Bayındır; later I said it in Ödemiş too, then I said it in Bursa as well. I said it repeatedly in Bursa. No one followed up on this word. The Sheikh Efendi did not follow up on it either. Look, the Sheikh Efendi did not follow up on it either, but — may Allah forgive me — my inside is my outside; if I have seen something, I say what I have seen, and I also say what I have understood from what I have seen. In any case, I say what I know to be the truth. Now, I stayed beside Abdullah Efendi for eighteen years. Abdullah Efendi announced me as a sheikh outwardly, verbally, through another person. Did he put it into writing? No. Since he did not put it into writing, I am not at the point of rejecting this word that he said, but technically it has no meaning for me. Technically it has no meaning. Thus the path that Abdullah Efendi belonged to, the one that was his own, was in a way closed. That is, because Abdullah Efendi has no one at present whom he has raised and trained who could be given an ijaza (authorization). No one, especially those around him, supposed that by acting with hostility toward Mustafa Özbağ they would gain something. Yet the word they said was this: the Prophet (peace be upon him) has halted his seyr-i suluk (spiritual journey). The word they said was this: the Prophet (peace be upon him) has halted Mustafa Özbağ's seyr-i suluk. Look, even this word, look, even this word: if there are ten thousand dervishes in Abdullah Efendi's dergah, there is a naqib al-nuqaba' (chief of the naqibs) whose seyr-i suluk is under way. Look, I am interpreting on the basis of this very word, and the Prophet (peace be upon him) has halted the seyr-i suluk of that naqib al-nuqaba'. If the Prophet (peace be upon him) has taken the seyr-i suluk of a Sufi, of a dervish, into his own hands, then who is that person? Look, the message here is actually very clear. The seyr-i suluk of a naqib al-nuqaba', and I say this underlining it: if the Prophet (peace be upon him) has halted the seyr-i suluk of a naqib al-nuqaba', then what is that naqib al-nuqaba', brother? Where is he going? Where does his path lead? If the Prophet (peace be upon him) has halted it, now I am saying this and the whole place will rise up in an uproar, then that sheikh no longer has any authority there. Then that sheikh no longer has any say there, then that sheikh has nothing left there at all. The Prophet (peace be upon him) has halted it. And then the statement is this: He halted it, but he said that it would continue again, that he would open it again. This is the statement; the elders know this better. Now put this word together: there is a naqib al-nuqaba', and the Prophet (peace be upon him) has halted his seyr-i suluk and has said that it will continue after a while. After a while, then, in whom will it continue? If it will not continue in that sheikh? Then it will continue in himself. Has that sheikh passed away? He has. Did that sheikh himself say the words 'it will continue'? He did. Then it means, and I am not setting aside time and ground for myself, I have no need of that, I am simply interpreting the words, then if the Prophet (peace be upon him) is going to continue it, in whom will that person continue? He has no living sheikh. Who can continue what the Prophet (peace be upon him) halted? If the Prophet (peace be upon him) said the words 'it will continue,' then who can continue it? Good, let me now also place the technical knowledge upon this: the Prophet (peace be upon him) raises the poles (qutbs) of the age last of all, and this is technical knowledge. I make no claim about myself; I am saying this as technical knowledge. A saint (wali) is raised, and raised, and raised; after that saint has been raised, after a while his sheikh raises him, then the spiritual masters (pirs) raise him spiritually, then one of the prophets raises him, and finally the Prophet Muhammad Mustafa (peace be upon him) takes upon himself that person's maturation. This is technical knowledge. This is the continuation of the seyr-i suluk. This is the continuation of the seyr-i suluk. The final seat of instruction (rahle) belongs to Muhammad Mustafa (peace be upon him). Now, the Sheikh Efendi's son phoned me, and I told him: "Hasan, show me a second person in this dergah, a dervish with whose seyr-i suluk the Prophet (peace be upon him) has concerned himself." I said that. One sentence. He fell silent. He has to be silent, because... I am speaking of the words of those who speak on behalf of the Sheikh Efendi. What did they say? With great excitement they made an uproar before everyone and said that the Prophet (peace be upon him) has halted his seyr-i suluk. Excellent. May our lives be sacrificed for Him... Even in the halting by Muhammad Mustafa there are great divine mercies. What does it mean, after all? He has concerned Himself with a poor person... That is how I look at it. Even his being angry is a mercy. A teacher gets angry at the student who is going to amount to something: why did you do it like this? Why? Because he expects much of him. If a master is angry with a dervish, it is a mercy; in Sufism it is a measure: if a master scolds a dervish, he is concerned with that dervish, and that is a great mercy. If Muhammad Mustafa (peace be upon him) halted the seyr-i suluk of a poor, strange, friendless person like this, with no one behind him, no brother, father, paternal uncle or maternal uncle behind him, a wretched person like us, we regard that as mercy, we regard it as favor and honor. That is why, in what they said, they exaggerated and exaggerated, as if I had left the faith, they did not see the mercy. There is a wisdom in this too, just as there is wisdom in everything.

Now imagine a dergah whose seyr-i suluk has been halted, in whose time? In Abdullah Efendi's own time, in the last period of his health. It has been halted. That is, actually, you know, this is a bitter thing. I would not have wanted to interpret it this way, but, that is, he no longer has children... There is no one to come after him and carry on his legacy. This is a bitter thing at the final point, but Mustafa Özbağ said this beforehand. When no one knew, he said: when you pass away, my service to you and to your dergah will come to an end. Yes.

The Sheikh Efendi Hazretleri has truly done a great deal for me, and I am sorry on his behalf too, but there is nothing to be done; at that moment, too, everything is the divine manifestation (jilwa-yi rabbaniyya) of my Lord. It manifested itself this way, it seems.


The Matter of Having the Silsila Written and the Claims of Contradiction

13- Again from Thursday. Your answers to the question about Abdullah Efendi having the silsile written contain contradictions. Saying that writing it is unethical and then continuing that same mistake yourself is contradictory in itself. Unfortunately, what you said on this subject may be seen as unfounded from the standpoint of the history of Sufism. You are entitled to your own views, intertwined with emotional judgments, and to regard yourself as right, but from the standpoint of the tradition this may be seen as objectionable. Although it may appear that there is a state of mutual consent, which is certainly for you to judge and rests on the decision of the followers who follow you in this condition, unfortunately this is the picture that appears from the outside. What can you say about this?

Actually, my answers to the question about Abdullah Efendi having the silsile written are not contradictory; it is like this: yes, technically it was not possible for him to have it written. Why is it technically not possible? In the silsile, Çorumlu Hacı Mustafa Efendi had not given him an ijaza in writing. What will he say when he has it written? For example, the ijaza that the Egyptians Abdurrahim Tantavi and Abdurrahim Neshavi (may God be pleased with them) gave, the ijaza that was given to Çorumlu Hacı Ebu Bekir Efendi, the ijaza that he gave to Hacı Ali Haydar Efendi, the ijaza that he gave to Çorumlu Hacı Mustafa Efendi. There the link of ijaza was broken. The link was broken. How will he give an ijaza? What will he say about the ijaza? He can write this: by the link of the naqib ijaza that was given to me, by the link of the ijaza of naqib al-nuqaba', I give you the ijaza of naqib al-nuqaba'. Fine. This is technically correct. Now I will speak openly like this: when I do not hold two written ijazas, to whom can I give an ijaza? I can only give the ijaza of naqib al-nuqaba'. Can I give someone the ijaza of sheikhhood? I cannot. The reason? My dear brother, technically I do not have it, so how could I give it to you? If they ask: well, I saw it in my dream. You saw it in your dream, fine; if tomorrow or the day after I say, in my dream they told me that you are the dean of the Bursa Faculty of Theology, can I go and sit in the dean's office? But I saw it in my dream. My dear brother, you saw it in your dream, but you cannot go there and sit in the dean's office. Why? Technically you have no appointment in your hand, technically you have no diploma in your hand. It is not a contradiction. I do not see this as a contradiction. As for "Saying that writing it is unethical and then continuing that same mistake yourself is contradictory in itself" — writing it is unethical, and I am not continuing it. I did not write an ijaza from the Sheikh Efendi for anyone. I have not written an ijaza for anyone at all, technically, nor have I given the ijaza of sheikhhood to anyone in any way at all, whether verbally, in deed, in word or in writing. I did not give it. There is no contradiction. If you write down the contradiction, we can immediately answer where it is, openly. As for "What you said on this subject may be seen as unfounded from the standpoint of the history of Sufism" — there is no groundlessness; there is no groundlessness from the standpoint of the history of Sufism either. The technical point is this: if someone holds the ijaza of sheikhhood, that person can give the ijaza of sheikhhood; if someone does not hold the ijaza of sheikhhood, that person cannot give the ijaza of sheikhhood. This is the technical point. Look, this is the technical point. A person may not accept this, someone may not accept it, fine, but this is the technical point. In our lesson sheets, too, we have a lesson sheet that says "to all our past murshids of perfection", to all the saints, to all the murshids of perfection.

Here is the contradiction: does your writing out Abdullah Efendi's silsile exactly as it is in your lesson sheets not show that you have fallen into the same error?

(In the lesson sheet) Yes, at the end: "Three Ikhlas, one Fatiha. O my Lord, I have dedicated it to the souls of all past murshids of perfection, saints, friends of God, dervishes and believers, to the spirituality of our master Bayındırlı Hacı Mustafa Özbağ Efendi, to the spirituality of all living murshids of perfection, saints and friends of God, to the spirituality of all our dervish brothers and of the Ummah of Muhammad, and to the souls of those from the exalted orders and from our relatives and connections who have passed away; make it reach them and make them partakers." This is what is written in the lesson sheet. This is the lesson sheet I published. Other than this, I do not remember publishing any such lesson sheet. That is why it is not a contradiction. I have the daily wird right now on the computer, because I give it to those who ask for lessons; that is why the daily wird is written here on my computer. Look, I read it directly from there, so it is not a contradiction. Ah, someone other than me may have written a lesson, may have written a lesson sheet. Salim, take a look and see whether there is another lesson sheet on that page. Is it not the same? Nothing has changed. In the third section there is no silsile at all, in the third section. To speak openly, I will change the third section, once I write these ijazas now, God willing. In the old lesson sheets it was not written either; when it was written in the first lesson sheet it was the same. No. Somewhere someone may have written it and spread it around. That is why, especially in the latest period, I have told all the friends to download this new lesson sheet, because let me put it this way: there are people who, without my initiative, design lesson sheets in my name in various places and distribute them. Later such reports reach me, and I say, no, the lesson sheet that we wrote is not like that. That is why I specifically tell all the brothers and all the friends to download this new lesson. In other words, somewhere somebody is arranging things in their own way. They are probably trying to do something by arranging things somewhere, and that is why I say: I did not write the silsila (the chain of transmission) concerning our Sheikh Efendi, neither in the old ones nor in the new ones. Let me also say this: actually I could write it, because eighteen years... even if I said, let me write it, still it would not be right. As his sheikh-disciple I could write it, there is no difficulty in that, but I did not receive the sheikhly authorization (ijaza) from him. Because I did not receive it from him, I never wrote the silsila for him. I said, I did not receive an ijaza of sheikhhood from him; ethically this is not right. Now, for example, if someone fills in his own ijaza himself, it would be wrong anyway; I have not filled in an ijaza for myself, nor have I written one for myself. Kabbaşi Hazretleri's ijaza exists, he wrote the ijaza in Arabic, and I have not even looked at its Turkish. The ijaza of the Mesudiye Lodge exists; I do not have its Turkish memorized, I have not even looked at it. Now, if I myself had written an ijaza, say I had written a sheikhly ijaza for someone, I could not write the name of Abdullah Gürbüz Efendi of Nevşehir as the sheikh in the silsila; again it is not possible, it is not ethical. This is the situation.


Dedications in the Lessons and the Tradition of the Lesson Sheet

The dedications in the lessons continue out of habit. Is this correct?

Yes, the dedications in the lessons continue as a habit. Let me say it again: if I mention Sheikh Efendi's name in the dedications, that is still not outside of ethics. If I write in an ijaza that I am his continuation, then that would be a problem, but not otherwise. May Allah forgive us.

Let me say this from here too: I have no quarrel with Abdullah Efendi Hazretleri, we have no problem whatsoever; we meet with him as well, we have no difficulty, no problem between us. Everyone thinks there is a problem, but there is no problem at all. There is no problem at all. He has a claim of effort upon us; we are not at the point of having a problem with him. May Allah forgive us. He was my master, he was my sheikh; we ran the path together for eighteen years. In the last period some chaotic things happened, but they were not related to me. They went through some chaos of their own, within their own circles, with those around them, but it has nothing to do with me; he said nothing to my face. Let me put it that way. What I say on my part is this: he told me nothing. Or else I sent Cafer, Adnan and Hüseyin to him and said, go and ask what is going on, what is happening. They asked, and said, Efendim, it is like this and like this. He said, "My son, there is nothing at all; go back, and give my greetings to your elder brother Mustafa too, there is no problem." That is how we continue. May Allah make it well, God willing.


The History of the Dergah and Hacı Bekir Baba

First of all, let us state a correction concerning the commonly misunderstood history of the dergah. You said, "Hacı Bekir Baba did not write an ijaza for anyone and leave it before he passed away" (I will give the source); there is no such thing. The history is wrongly known. It is understood that you said Ali Haydar Efendi had no ijaza. The truth of the matter is this: Ali Haydar Efendi came from Akhaltsikhe. When he came to the dergah he was 36 years old. Before Bekir Baba he had been bound by oath of allegiance (bay'a) to Ömer Lütfi Efendi, called the Circassian sheikh. Later, by a spiritual sign, his former sheikh sent him to Kara Şeyh Bekir Baba. He is a person whom Hacı Bekir Baba himself trained for 5 years and for whom he wrote the ijaza. He is not someone who came having been trained elsewhere. Ali Efendi of Akhaltsikhe, who had an exceptional place among the famous sheikhs of his time, trained three caliphs and gave them ijaza. They are: Terzi Mehmed Efendi of İskilip, Uludereli Mehmed Efendi of İskilip, and Hacı Mustafa Efendi of Çorum. Ali Efendi granted the caliphate to Mustafa Efendi in 1955, that is, two years before his death. Also, you say "three people were attached to the man from Çorum." The truth of that is this: the dervishes were waiting for Mustafa Efendi of Bayburt, because he was a learned man. Because Hacı Mustafa Efendi was a tea-maker, there were those who grumbled, "Has it come down to the tea-maker Mustafa in the end?" There were surely some who did not attach themselves, but three people is a bit exaggerated. Mustafa Efendi was the naqib (the senior deputy) of this dergah. At the dergah, there were already three naqibs who had pledged allegiance, left from Ali Efendi at that time; their naqibs were Mustafa Efendi of Bayburt, Kemal Efendi and Haşmet Hafız, and there were many other naqibs and dervishes. Dervishes also attached themselves, but they took shape mostly around the young. This too is quite normal.

What I am saying like this is what Nevşehirli Abdullah Gürbüz Efendi related to me. Everything I am speaking about here is what Şeyh Efendi told me, and Şeyh Efendi said, “Çorumlu Hacı Mustafa Efendi Hazretleri told me, my son, when I began as a sheikh, such-and-such three people pledged allegiance to me.” He told him so, and I related what I heard from him. It may be true or it may not be. Since you say at the beginning of the text that I can give a source on this, it may well be true; in any case it is not something I will claim myself. What I heard was this.


The Question of Trust (Emanet), Authorization (Ehliyet) and the Seal

The old works say: “The tariqa is examined through two branches: 1. The practices of the tariqa (amal-i tariqat); 2. Trust and Authorization (Emanet and Ehliyet). The trust is the seal, and the authorization is the ijaza. By the rules of the method, if these are lacking, no one can act as a sheikh.” I will not ask my question about the amal-i tariqat part. That is already known.

Do you have the seal that is called the trust (emanet)? If you do, were you authorized through the chain (silsila)? Or by what means did you obtain it? If you do not have a seal, how do you assess the situation of one of the two branches of the tariqa being missing? They say there is the dergah seal and also the sheikh's private seal, the official seal.

Yes, our dergah had no such private seal; there was the private seal of Nevşehirli Abdullah Efendi, who was at the same time Şeyh Efendi's own, but Şeyh Efendi did not give sheikhdom to anyone, and so that seal remains with him.

If the seal that came from Abdullah Efendi is evaluated in light of the topics in the previous talks, what could be said about its weight and value?

Şeyh Efendi Hazretleri had a seal of his own. I myself had that seal made in Bursa; I had it made for him. If this is what is meant by the seal, it was with me until the last period of his illness, and the skewers were with me too. I told Şeyh Efendi several times, “Efendim, let me bring these,” and he said, “No, let them stay with you, Musta Efendi.” Even though he said let them stay with me, after a while I collected them again and took them to Nevşehir. I said, after he dies, after he passes away, there will be many difficulties, many problems, so I took the seal and the skewers of Şeyh Efendi Hazretleri to Nevşehir and handed them over. As for the seal of Şeyh Efendi here, yes, that is from Şeyh Efendi. I have no seal left from Abdullah Efendi.


The Conditions That Must Be Present in Ijazas

One of the conditions that ijazas must meet is that they be given as the result of completing the suluk (path of spiritual wayfaring); and what must be present are the life and approval of the sheikh who brought the disciple into the suluk, witnesses, the crown (taj), the investiture with the khirqa (cloak), and the ceremony that concludes with the tariqa wedding and is completed by its public announcement. The customs and practices that have come down to today through the traditional Sufi conventions are like this. Even if there are those who say that these methods belong to the past and no longer exist today, the truth is not so. The true heirs of this knowledge live without fame or renown. That being so, apart from the ijazas you received as a blessing (teberrüken) through transmission, do you have an original ijaza, in accordance with a completed suluk, that is, through service and spiritual aspiration (himmet)?

What you mean is the outcome of a suluk like that, that is, coming under a sheikh's suluk and completing a suluk within that sheikh's suluk. There are words Şeyh Efendi Hazretleri himself spoke concerning me. I will not say what he said to me; he said it to our Hüseyin, to Cafer, to brother Adnan: “My child, the Prophet (peace be upon him) stopped it, but he will open it again,” he said. That is what he told them. That is what Şeyh Efendi said. My longest suluk in this matter was with Abdullah Efendi Hazretleri. The later suluk is something different. It is not something where I can say outwardly, “That sheikh efendi took me into the suluk.” This matter has a somewhat more spiritual dimension, and it is something that continues in that spiritual dimension; but the ijazas that were given to me were, after all, ijazas given with ceremonies, not ijazas given or received as a blessing (teberrüken); and as for those ijaza ceremonies, everyone holds a ceremony according to the method and rule of their own dergah, and these are the ijazas that were given with such ceremonies.


What Is Suluk? The System of Spiritual Training

What is suluk? Suluk is a system of spiritual training. When we ask what suluk is, it is a system of spiritual training within the circle of the Qur'an and the Sunnah. In that system of spiritual training one is under the supervision of a perfect guide (murshid-i kamil), a sheikh. That is how it begins, but while it continues with this sheikh efendi, outwardly, after some time this suluk can be taken over onto that person, whether from the pir efendis, or from past prophets, or from the Prophet (peace be upon him). Generally the suluk of figures at the level of pir continues in this way. Therefore, when you ask whether I have a suluk and which sheikh efendi completed it for me, may Allah forgive me, I cannot say that I have no suluk; but neither can I say that I completed my suluk with a known, documented, living sheikh efendi. Those who say, "I have completed my suluk (spiritual journey) in the spiritual sense," should not be followed; the Sufi books fundamentally explain that this work, with its methods and rules, must be completed in the presence of a living sheikh. What do you say about this? On this point, yes, there are such things in the Sufi books, and they concern the fact that what is truly sought in the Sufi books is the spiritual, and at the same time that there should be an ijaza (authorization) for it; but this is a matter of right between the person who attaches himself and the one he attaches himself to. If the person who attaches himself sees this sign within himself in the spiritual sense, then he may go to the one to whom he is attached through that sign; this too is something found in the Sufi books. Does the one he goes to have the right to look for the outward existence of an ijaza in that person? Answer: He does. A person may say, "The dream I saw is not sufficient for me, but I am also looking for someone who holds an ijaza"; that is his right. When I describe these matters, I describe them like this: suppose a person has no ijaza in his hand, but in his dream the Prophet (peace be upon him) tells him, "You will go to so-and-so." What can he say? Or suppose a person has no ijaza, and although he has no ijaza, the Prophet (peace be upon him), or the earlier prophets, or one of the Companions, Hazrat Abu Bakr, may Allah be pleased with him, says: "You will go to so-and-so, you will attach yourself to him." What can that person do? That is why this spiritual side admits of no dispute, because "Obey Allah, obey the Messenger, and obey those in authority among you." The Sunnah is outward and the Qur'an is outward; fine, but Satan cannot enter the form and likeness of the Prophet (peace be upon him); he cannot. So if the Prophet (peace be upon him) says to him, "Go to such-and-such a master, go to such-and-such a sheikh; he is our child, he is our brother," or "he is the owner of the dergah," and the person goes and attaches himself, is anything further required of the one who attaches himself? It is not. Look, there is also this side to the matter: that person may not have an ijaza either. He may not. Right now there are such saints who have no ijaza. Yes. There are saints who have no written ijaza. And now there are also those who have a written ijaza but are not saints. He has a written ijaza but is not a saint. He has a written ijaza but is truly not even a murshid. Let alone a perfect murshid, he is not even a murshid, nor a saint, but he has a written ijaza. But he has a written ijaza, and because of that written ijaza people have gathered around him as dervishes, they remember Allah, they continue there, and that person has a written ijaza. If you were to say to that person, "How do you act as a sheikh?" he says, "I have a written ijaza; so-and-so sheikh gave it to me," or "my sheikh gave it to me." There is no question to ask him, no word to say.

The matter I constantly stress, and that is why I keep dwelling on it, is this: attach yourselves to the sheikh you will join through a sound dream, by seeing a dream. Why? Because your dream, the righteous dreams, are firmly established by the hadith as glad tidings, firmly established by the hadith as one part of the forty-six parts of prophethood; so such a person is not deceived by that dream. The Prophet (peace be upon him) has guided him, and there is nothing to be said against that. Now, this is the predicament of those sheikhs whose sheikhhood has not been confirmed in this spiritual sense but who hold an ijaza in their hands. They have no evidence in the spiritual sense, they have nothing in their hands, and they say: what matters is not the dream, what matters is the ijaza. Allah, Allah… The ijaza is important and the dream is important too; the dream is important, the ijaza is important, both are important. Look, both are important, which is why a person must complete his suluk under the training of a sheikh and then go. Fine, good. Now, suppose a person has reached the fifth station; all the people of Sufism know this: after the fifth station his suluk does not go backward. Why? Because a person who has been raised up to that fifth station, unless he persists greatly in a major sin, has his suluk continued for him. How is it continued? The qutbs (spiritual poles) of the age continue it. How do they continue it? Generally, if he is to be at the level of a perfect murshid, Jesus (peace be upon him) continues it for a while, and after that the Prophet (peace be upon him) continues it, for example; or after a while our master Hazrat Ali or our master Hazrat Abu Bakr takes an interest in him, and again his path is open; he will be a kurmay (staff officer), let me put it that way. In any case, if a person has received the fifth name, he is counted as having set out on the path of the kurmay; he is heading toward that kurmay status, if he trains himself, keeps himself sound and protects himself, he is traveling the path toward that kurmay status. Now, someone who has come that far — after the fifth name, the circle of the outward (zahir) is, in effect, complete; that is, a person who is being raised and has received the fifth name no longer has much connection with the outward. From the fifth name onward, his circle of seyr-i suluk (the spiritual journey) is entirely spiritual. It concerns the world of existence, the inward (batin) world, the things within oneself, and so on; his course is different. That being so, the oversight of a sheikh is not necessarily required for him. What is required is this: a sheikh must bring him up to that point. If someone has brought him up to that point, then that sheikh has already fulfilled his duty toward him. The heart wishes that a living sheikh would continue over him, but someone who has reached the fifth name — if his spiritual state is also clear, if his spiritual condition is open, and if he receives teaching from our master Ali, from our master Hazrat Abu Bakr, from our pirs, or from the prophets of the past, or receives teaching from the people of the graves, or from the Prophet (peace be upon him) — then there is no obligation for him to go to a sheikh either. His seyr-i suluk can continue; this side of the matter exists too. But I repeat this: neither a person's dream alone is sufficient, nor a person's direct ijaza alone is sufficient. The best is for both to be present: that one sees that person in a dream spiritually, and that the sheikh's ijaza is also there. If both of these are present, then for a dervish the matter is sufficient. If only the ijaza is there, that too can suffice for the dervish; and if someone says, "I only need the spiritual meaning," for a person who has made his commitment, that too can be regarded as sufficient for him. To regard these as nonexistent is not right. Why does the Prophet (peace be upon him) not show someone a sheikh, but shows him a particular person in his dream? That is, when our Sheikh Efendi — may Allah have mercy on him — passed away, we said that everyone should perform istikhara. While everyone was performing istikhara, why did people see in their dreams a naqib al-nuqaba who was at the dergah, and not the others? These are important matters. So there must be something in that person that made everyone see him in their dream. Or take the present situation: Sheikh Efendi — may Allah have mercy on him — passed away and left no one behind; they apparently feel no need, which means they continue on the same path. But suppose friends had attached themselves to someone who announced his sheikhhood, and he too passed away; then where will they perform istikhara, whom will they consult, to whom will they attach themselves, if they are thinking of attaching themselves? Why, then, is someone else not seen, while that person is seen? There are many scholars in the country, professors, muftis — why are they not seen in dreams? That is why dreams are important.


Benefiting from an Ijaza Given as a Blessing (Teberrüken)

While those who hold an original ijaza can benefit from an ijaza given as a blessing (teberrüken), do you think saying "I too have an ijaza" is a quick, day-to-day solution?

For a person — even if it was given as a blessing, whatever it may be — it carries a weight. So trying to belittle it by saying, "they gave it to him as a blessing"... Teberrüken means given in the sense of a gift. Fine, let it be given as a gift; then let someone else take it as a gift too — why does he not take it? I would not have wanted to explain it this way, but let me explain: now, those who act as sheikhs — may Allah forgive — I am not saying this out of arrogance — four or five sheikh efendis are going around, they call on the phone, they write on WhatsApp, saying, "Let us come and visit, will you give us a caliphate (khilafa) as well?" Even if it is given as a blessing, how can one give it without seeing it in a dream? I say this on my own account, because that person will act as a sheikh by your ijaza. In my view this is not a trivial matter. In my view this is not a day-to-day solution either. When a person is going to give an ijaza, he must think. And I say these things — I have never said "I am a sheikh," not to this day — I am trying to state the matter correctly, both technically and spiritually. I am not a sheikh, but the matter ought to be right, and I strive to state what is right. May Allah forgive me, I hold an ijaza, both outward and spiritual, but I do not say "I am a sheikh." It would be a claim, but this humble servant has all the qualities that are sought; still I do not say "I am a sheikh." I say: within the circle of the Qur'an and the Sunna, I try to live and to let others live correct Sufism, that is all. People do see me in their dreams, yes, as a teacher (ustad); and for the one who sees me as a teacher, do I give lessons? Yes. I see this as a spiritual responsibility; that is why my path too is like this, unique to myself.


Conditions Sought in Attaching Oneself to a Sheikh: Dreams and Consultation (Istishara)

What kind of ijaza is the ijaza given to you as a blessing (teberrüken)? I did not receive an ijaza as a mere blessing. It is like saying, out of friendship, 'we are friends, we are brothers, let me give you an ijaza too.' I have no such ijaza. When one speaks of an ijaza given as a blessing, there is a way and a procedure for it; one asks, 'Will you give me an ijaza?' Or else it has no spiritual manifestation behind it; it comes about without any spiritual manifestation. I have no ijaza given merely as a blessing. May Allah forgive me, this will sound a bit like a shath (an ecstatic utterance), but I have no ijaza given as a blessing. The ijazas given to me were not given as a blessing, none of the three of them. In the ijaza my sheikh gave me, he did not give it as a blessing; he gave me the ijaza of naqib al-nuqaba, and that was not as a blessing either. Sheikh Efendi told me many times, 'Let me write your caliph's ijaza,' and I stayed silent. I told him, 'Efendim, I did not come to the dergah for that.' I do not accept that the ijazas given to me were given as a blessing. From which tariqa are they? What is their content? One is Qadiri-Naqshbandi, and one is from a Qadiri dergah; the ijazas that came from the last two lines are like that. What is their content? I have never read their contents; they had them translated into Turkish, but I did not sit down and read what is in them. Friends who are curious can read them.

In your talks, until yesterday, when listing the conditions required for attaching oneself to a sheikh, you spoke of seeing him in a dream and consultation (istishara) as sufficient; then suddenly, in these last days, you say 'ijaza, ijaza, find a sheikh with an ijaza.' This really is a surprising change. Even back then I used to say that one of the qualities to be sought in that sheikh is certainly ijaza; I have been saying that for years. While my sheikh was alive, I could not speak about it, thinking my sheikh would be offended or would say something about this matter. The reason was this: I knew that my sheikh did not have an ijaza for sheikhhood, so I could not say that an ijaza is necessary. The reason I could not say it was related to my sheikh. I am saying this again, and I still say: if someone is going to attach himself to a place, he should see it in a dream and also consult; and if there is an ijaza as well, then it is light upon light, and there is no problem in that. What has changed? Yesterday it was like that, today it has become like this. Until yesterday there was no ijaza, but the brothers had accepted it for various reasons; so does this not mean there was a 'mistaken past'? If you consider it mistaken, since the situation that has come about and is visible is this, is this work going to proceed by gradually maturing, by stumbling and falling, by erring? Yet nothing new is being invented; the existing Sufism is being lived. If we were to invite you to self-criticism on this matter, how would you explain it? As a whole community, perhaps we are growing by stumbling and falling. I am not saying this for myself, but as a community we may be growing by stumbling and falling. And of course I gain experience with time. Every day is an experience, for every master, for dervishes, for everyone; but when I look at my past, I do not see it as a mistaken past either. The conditions of Turkey are out in the open, my conditions are out in the open, the conditions of the people of the tariqa in Turkey are out in the open, the conditions of the people of Sufism are out in the open. Within those conditions we try to live the best, the most correct, the most beautiful way, we strive for it; that is why I do not accept it as mistaken. There is nothing in my life that I would accept as mistaken. It was right for that day; for that day I had analyzed it in my own way, I had consulted, something had come to my heart; it was right for that day, and so I said it that way. Sufism, tasawwuf, is a channel open to development, to deepening, to rising; therefore it is not like a fiqh doctrine. Because it is not like a fiqh doctrine, it is open at every moment to change, at every moment to development, at every moment to transformation. As these things develop, change and transform, certainly when we look back at the past, it was like that yesterday and today it may be like this, but this does not fall into the category of a mistaken past. Not at all; I do not see it that way, not in the least. You said that nothing new is being invented; no, it is being invented. Let me put it my own way: within the circle of the Qur'an and the Sunnah, this will sound like a great shath, but today, how Sufism is to be lived, how it should be lived, perhaps we are analyzing it anew, and today, especially in the West and in the Balkans, people see from us how Sufism should be lived, by being reconsidered anew through ijtihad with a new understanding. According to a Sufi mentality, there is no need for you to hold a Shab-i Arus in an indoor sports hall; according to the classical Sufi mentality, there is no need for you to travel around Europe; according to the classical Sufi mentality, there is no need for you to go around city by city, province by province, district by district, village by village, neighborhood by neighborhood. But according to today's Sufi mentality, yes, you need to go around village by village and city by city; according to today's Sufi mentality, to put before people, in quotation marks, the Sufism that people find distorted, turn their noses up at, dislike, or criticize heavily, to design it in a nice and proper way and put it before people. Look, this is the correct Sufism that can be lived today, it says. This may perhaps be something beyond our stature, but in my own way I have been aiming at this in myself for thirty years. Because when I first became a Sufi, when I first entered dervishhood, I saw so many distorted things around me that I said, this is not it, this is not it, this is not it, this is not it. I kept coming along saying "this is not it," and I always said "this is not it." Why did I say "this is not it"? Because when I looked at the Sufi sources in my own hands, when I looked at the hadiths in my own hands, I saw that living out the hadiths is one of the most important circles of Sufism, and that it was not like that. Then I began to say "this is not it," and there are still things I say "this is not it" about. When I say "this is not it," am I doing it myself? No. I say "this is not it," and I will never do it again. Earlier I said "these forbidden things are not it" and was casting off the forbidden things from myself. Now there are those who put before people, as though it were very important, something that seems to belong to Sufism but has no connection with Sufism, something that seems to be within Sufism but is not given much importance within Sufism at all. The same thing happened with the sema as well. "Why don't you do the devr-i veled, why don't you take three steps, five steps, seven steps?" and so on; the argument led to more argument. Yet every Mevlevi sheikh who came, every new one, had developed some procedure and some etiquette of his own. It may have been necessary on that day, it may even have been right for that day, but at the point we have reached today, if they are going to do those things in their own way, then as our Hacı Cafer says, let the Ministry of Culture do it, fine, with my blessing; but at the point we have reached today I do not believe that it is like this. For example, the Sufism that was visible in the old Turkey was this: people held sohbet in their homes, people performed dhikr in their homes; this was the visible Sufism. That is, in that etiquette, for example, Hacı Mustafa Efendi of Çorum, Abdullah Gürbüz Efendi of Nevşehir, or Kemal Efendi, or those in Çorum, or those in Ankara, did not think of anything different; what they did on that day was that. They had seen it that way, and that is all they did. The one who first had dhikr performed inside a dergah, inside a mosque, is this humble servant. That is, carrying dhikr from the homes to the mosque, carrying dhikr and Sufism from the homes to dedicated places, carrying it to dedicated places, this was something that required courage; it was something that required putting your head on the line. I was criticized a great deal, but afterwards everyone came to the place I had spoken of. For example, in Bursa I took the Karabaş-ı Veli Tekke, saying we would hold sohbet for people there, we would do something there; some friends left, they could not understand the new generation. After us everyone rushed at the tekkes, everyone wanted to take over tekkes, everyone wanted to revive tekkes, but they took their courage from this community; and in their own cities, in small groups, people went and found the tekkes, researched them, some restored them; courage came to everyone, and one way or another they restored them and began to move forward. In fact they were not aware of it; that is, that courage came to them from this community. Just as this community carried dhikr from the homes to dedicated places, it carried it from dedicated places to the old tekkes, to the old tekkes. Look, when the sema began every night at the Karabaş-ı Veli Tekke, there were only two places in Turkey where the sema was performed, for a fee: one was at the Yenikapı Mevlevihane, and the other was at the Galata Mevlevihane. In all of Turkey there were so many Mevlevi lodges, and among those lodges the sema was performed in only two places; and one more in Konya, at the Şeb-i Arus ceremonies. The sema was not performed anywhere else. Apart from that, they performed it at weddings, at association events, in taverns, in nightclubs. Through this humble servant and the progress of this community, the sema began in places that have a semahane. For example, at the Gelibolu Mevlevihane the sema is held every month. The Gelibolu Mevlevihane had stood idle for eighty years. Now, reviving Sufism according to the circumstances of the time, according to the situation and standing of the geography and the cities, bringing it back to life, bringing it to a resurgence, and carrying this beyond the country. Look, carrying this beyond the country as well: on our most recent journey in the Balkans, seven programs were held in seven cities, and people learned a different culture of Sufism, a different Sufi culture; things like that. That is why I do not regard it as a mistaken past. We will take lessons from our recent past, we will gain experience again, and when something new comes before us, we will renew ourselves again. We will renew ourselves. For anyone who does not renew himself, the greatest task is not keeping pace with the age but presenting the Sufi profile to the Muslims living in every age, and presenting the Sufi profile to the people living in every city. Today, when you go to Urfa, for example, you can put a different Sufi profile before the people there. I do not say this to belittle anyone; if you go to Syria or Iraq, you can put something different before people. There people may perceive that as Sufism, but in the West they would not perceive it so. In the West they look differently, so what matters is to be the means by which people of every region and every segment approach Sufism positively and look at it positively; to cause them to approach the Qur'an and the Sunnah positively, to cause them to hold a positive approach to the Sufi teaching. That is why we will develop even further, we will change even further, we are subject to change and transformation — there is no problem on that point — but I will never regard my past as a faulty past. In fact, let me go even further: I am not someone who defines even my past before I met Islam as a faulty past. Just now, the person we call Üzeyir Türkkan — perhaps he listened to our brothers and friends before I met Islam, and now my greetings with him continue; when I go to him he shows me respect and regard, we sit and talk, or if he comes to me I show him respect and regard, we sit and talk, or perhaps he is listening now as well; and there is also our tall Abidin, our mutual friend — when I run into him too, I sit with him as a companion and we talk. I do not see them as a faulty past either. I have not seen any area, any stage of my life as a faulty past; I am a person at peace with my life. I lived that way on that day; if it was a sin, may my Allah forgive me, I repented; if it was not a sin, I do not see it as a faulty past — I carry it on my arm like this, all my brothers, all my friends. That is why, in truth, the situation we have reached is not only this right now; this community deserves better, we will live something better, we will live something more beautiful, perhaps this community will live a Sufism that people on earth have not seen and have not been able to live. I believe the Almighty (Allah) will grant it. They will live a Sufism above the world's perception, perhaps they will live a Sufism above the Sufism they have understood until today. Right now this may sound like an empty claim; the brothers and sisters now are living a Sufism above the Sufism that is commonly perceived. This can perhaps be looked at critically, but when we look at the i'tikaf retreats that come to me, perhaps when we measure it numerically, there is no dergah (Sufi lodge) with this many dervishes entering i'tikaf. Roughly thirty to forty percent of the dergah performs i'tikaf — women, that is — and they perform i'tikaf from group i'tikafs to individual i'tikafs. And if we were to tell of the states that appear and are lived in the i'tikafs, of what comes to me — you who say "you are only looking at the mistake metaphysically" — there are those who have grown in spiritual states and metaphysical veils that they could not have seen or lived in their lives. This gives me even more hope. I say: praise be to Allah, our friends, our brothers and sisters — I get goosebumps as I tell these things — our friends, our brothers and sisters are so devoted to the matter, so deeply involved in the work, that extraordinary journeys of seyr-u suluk (the spiritual wayfaring) are being lived with extraordinary effort. I claim that in this period there are those who, during their i'tikaf, in nearly the greater part of the dhikr of Allah, see the Prophet (peace be upon him), Abu Bakr, Umar, Uthman, Ali, Hasan, Husayn — may Allah be pleased with them — and their pir efendis, and there are even those who hold sohbet with them, who speak with them. As I interpret what is told to me, I truly see that their states have reached the truth (haqiqa), and I am delighted by this, and in my own way I hope through it; I say that we must run further ahead, that we must go further forward; indeed I claim this here, live on air: we are one of the dergahs where the most seyr-u suluk is lived. Look, we are one of the dergahs where the most seyr-u suluk is lived — I praise Allah for this. I did not use to speak like this; I do not like speaking in a very shath-like (ecstatic, boastful) manner. I praise Allah: we are one of the dergahs on earth where the most seyr-u suluk is lived, and I praise Him for this as well. Some might say, might criticize this: we do not give this much importance to dreams. Sit down where you are sitting! The Prophet (peace be upon him) said that a dream is one part of forty-six parts of prophethood — and to that we say, "we do not give much regard to dreams"? You are insolent. "We do not walk the path with dreams" — you are insolent; you are denying the way of the Prophet (peace be upon him), you are even falling into disbelief. Renewal of faith and renewal of marriage are required. Why? The dream is from the mubashshirat, the glad tidings: in the end times, the dreams of righteous people, the righteous dreams seen by righteous people, are among the mubashshirat. Where do you place this hadith? It cannot be. Or else, not giving importance to someone's dream, not giving importance to the inspirations (ilham) that come to his heart, means saying "we do not look at this." What will you look at in Sufism? What will you look at on the Sufi path? If it is prayer, the one in the mosque performs the same prayer; if it is fasting, the one in the mosque keeps the same fast; if it is zakat, everyone gives the same zakat, one-fortieth of their wealth. What will you look at in the Sufi? You will look at his spirituality, you will look at his seyr-u suluk. Where will you look at his seyr-u suluk? What does the Prophet (peace be upon him) say, again in the tafsir of the verse concerning the friends of Allah (awliya)? The Companions ask — the Companions, eager for knowledge, say: "O Messenger of Allah, we can guess the glad tidings in the hereafter — that is Paradise, the Beauty of Allah (Jamalullah) — but what are the glad tidings in this world?" The dreams they are seen in and the dreams that they see. The dreams in which they are seen and the dreams that they see. My dear brothers and sisters, I say this to everyone: the dreams seen by the friends of Allah, by the perfect murshids (murshid-i kamil), and likewise the dreams in which the friends of Allah, the perfect murshids, the righteous, the saints, the prophets and the Companions are seen, are also among the mubashshirat, that is, glad tidings in this world. That is why, if someone sees the Prophet (peace be upon him) in his dream, it is glad tidings in this world; if someone sees Jesus, or a prophet between Adam and Muhammad al-Mustafa, it is glad tidings in this world; this is established by hadith, established by the verse. If he sees the Companions, it is established by hadith, established by the verse. What did he see? He saw the saints (awliya). It is established by hadith, established by the verse. If someone sees in his dream a master, a perfect murshid, and receives glad tidings in this world, it is established by hadith, established by the verse, because that person's sheikh is, in his own eyes, a righteous man. That is why we do not give weight to a person who has no dream, no spiritual state (hal). So, you are going to appoint someone as naqib al-nuqaba (chief of the naqibs); on what will you rely for him? On his black eyebrows, his black eyes? You are going to grant someone a caliphate; on what basis will you grant his caliphate? Will you grant it by looking at his black eyebrows and black eyes? You are going to grant someone the rank of sheikh; from where will you grant the sheikhship? From where will you grant it? "He serves very well in this dergah, he runs about, he never leaves my side, whatever I say he says yes, well, fine, this one can be a sheikh"; will you decide like that? "We don't give weight to dreams." Fine, then what will you give weight to? In that case, however many flatterers you have around you, you will make all of them caliphs. "Look, he has served at my side for thirty years, he never contradicts a single word of mine, let me grant him a caliphate." If you do not give weight to dreams, that is how you will grant it; or else someone will come and say, "I saw in my dream that you were giving me a caliphate"; "Of course, my dear brother, God willing, we will grant it; let me too see it in my dream, and I will grant you the caliphate." That is the end of it. Look, by what means will you grant it to that person? There must be a manifestation (tajalli), during dhikrullah, while performing dhikr. We have experienced examples of these in the dergah: Ahmad al-Rifa'i came and said, "Give that person the post of chavush (sergeant, steward)." I gave the man the chavush post. I said, "This man is a chavush." He told someone, "Make this man the sohbet chavush (steward of the talks)" in the dergah. I announced it in the middle of dhikrullah, saying, "Let it remain upon me if I die or remain." Saying, "Let it remain upon me if I die or remain," I announced it in the middle of dhikrullah: "This brother of yours will give you sohbet from now on; he is your sohbet chavush," I said. On what shall we rely? In the time of our former Sheikh Efendi, in the presence of Khalid al-Baghdadi, Khalid al-Baghdadi granted the chavush post to one of our brothers right there. Khalid al-Baghdadi granted it, with the Sheikh Efendi also by his side; at that time I too have the authority to grant the chavush post to whomever I wish, I have the authority to grant the post of naqib, I have every authority. I granted him his chavush post in the presence of Khalid al-Baghdadi. I said, "Am I going to die bearing the responsibility for this?" I say again: let me see someone in my dream right now, and I do wish to see it, I wish to see his caliphate, and I will grant his caliphate. The reason? My dear brother, this too is a great joy for me, to see someone come to maturity is a great joy. I will not even look at whether he sees it or not; I will say that it is enough for me to see it myself, that what I have seen will be my proof and my evidence, and I will grant his caliphate, and I will, for example, have his ijaza (certificate of authorization) written. That is why a dream like that is not what matters, my dear brother; the spiritual state (hal) is not what matters, my dear brother; what matters is something else. Right now in this dergah there are those who see spiritual states with open eyes; right now in this dergah there are those who see the Prophet (peace be upon him) the moment they sit down in the dhikrullah circle; right now in this dergah there are brothers of ours who, while taking their lessons, study knee to knee with the Prophet (peace be upon him). I feel great joy at this, great joy, praise be to God. That is why the dream is needed, the ijaza is needed, sharia knowledge is needed too; all of it is needed. If all of these are complete in one person, it is a perfect thing; we applaud him. If someone's sharia is beautiful, wonderful; if someone's spirituality is beautiful, wonderful; if someone also has the outward ijaza, wonderful; if someone has dervish brothers who live spiritual states, wonderful. This shows that dergah is perfect, and shows that dergah is racing toward perfection, leaving its mark on every wing and every curtain. This is magnificent, and I feel very great joy at it. I praise God, I say praise be to the Almighty (Allah), He has given such brothers, their spirituality is open; He has given such brothers, their sharia is upright; He has given me such brothers, praise be to God. They stand upright and walk on against every kind of pressure, hardship, oppression, every kind of intrigue and scheming, praise be to God. They have no fear, no cowardice, no scattering, no asking themselves "what if?" Those who say "what if?" are blown away and gone anyway, praise be to God. That is why all of it is needed, my dear brother; perhaps after a while we will also say this, we will say that this quality is needed, we will say that this quality is needed, we will say that this quality is needed. Why? Because we will see that circumstances, conditions, everything will take us to a different place. This path belongs to Allah, because the path is not Mustafa Özbağ's; the path is not the path of Adnan, of Cafer, of Hüseyin; the path is not the path of Ahmed or Mehmed; the path is the path of the entire ummah. A Sufism is being lived anew, a magnificent Sufism is being lived anew, a Sufism full of metaphysics is being lived, within the sharia, within the rulings of the sharia. I always say: let those who would criticize us come, my brother, and let them say, "In terms of the sharia, this part of yours is lacking, let us complete it," and let them say, "In terms of Sufism, this part of yours is lacking, let us complete it." The Almighty completes; when we say "let us complete it," may Allah make us complete it. May the Almighty perfect all the deficiencies and all the shortcomings of all the Sufis, God willing. Because there is something like this: we come from a dark period of two hundred years. We come from a period in which saying "Allah" was forbidden. We come from doing dhikrullah in Bayındır with the feeling of being raided at every dhikr. We come from the time when the police car was always passing in front of our door. We come from the time when the police entered my hall in their boots. We come from the time when there was not a single Thursday lesson on which we were not raided. There are brothers listening now from Ödemiş too, old dervish brothers: we come from the times when we were raided in Ödemiş. We were raided in Ödemiş as well; there the gendarmerie raided us and the police raided us. We were raided in Bursa too. We come from having been beaten again and again; we do not come from being caressed, we come from being beaten again and again. That is why the Sufism we have lived is precious, and that is why I never regard it as a flawed past. That is why we believe that we are running toward something ever better, ever more beautiful, ever higher, ever deeper, ever broader, and we will keep running, if Allah grants us breath, God willing. So thanks be to the Almighty: we have no deficiency spiritually, and we have no deficiency outwardly; and on the point of the journey (seyr-i suluk) and on the point of the brothers' progress along it, they have no deficiencies, thanks be to God.

How would you assess the saying of Kemal Akdeniz Efendi, a sheikh who has completed his suluk (spiritual journey) and holds an ijaza, that "consultation (istishara) is more important than istikhara; it cannot be found through istikhara, it is a matter of eternal destiny"?

Every murshid-i kamil (perfected spiritual guide), every Sufi, every saint (wali) in every era has a truth of his own; he states that truth in his own way and conveys it to people in his own way. But are these general truths? They are general truths for their own time. What I say now is likewise a general truth for my own time. Tomorrow or the day after, after we have passed away, those who come after us will develop it further and change it further. Now, consultation (istishara) is more important than istikhara, that is correct; for their time they considered consultation sufficient, but I do not consider it sufficient. There is no rule that because Kemal Akdeniz Efendi considered it sufficient I must consider it sufficient too. I give importance to consultation and I give importance to istikhara as well. That is, when I say istikhara, what I mean is the spiritual one, seeing in a dream. That person must see his sheikh in his dream. Can one take lessons from a sheikh without seeing him? Yes. Can a sheikh give him lessons? Yes. But ever since I entered this path, for thirty-some years, I have been saying the same thing insistently: friends, take your lessons by seeing in your dreams. In fact, this saying of mine is famous: I say it for myself, that if I were to attach myself to a sheikh, I would enter i'tikaf (spiritual retreat). The reason? That person must oversee my i'tikaf. I would see him, I would want him. Because a murshid-i kamil, where there are dervishes living such spiritual states, must oversee those retreats, by Allah's permission; otherwise there is a problem in that dergah. How would you assess the saying "This is a matter of eternal destiny"? Behind the veil it may be seen as eternal destiny; he saw it that way, but I do not see it that way. Allah is the One who writes, the One who erases what He has written, the One who writes again. When one says "it is a matter of eternal destiny," this falls into jabriyya (determinism). We seek, we run, we strive, we struggle to overcome every hardship, we struggle to be rid of every difficulty. If we say "this is a matter of eternal destiny," we will tie our own hands and arms. Then we would say, "It is a matter of eternal destiny: if it is in your destiny, you will become affiliated with a dergah." That is not my understanding; I run, I tell everyone, I convey the message to everyone. The Prophet (peace be upon him) did not sit idle saying "guidance is a matter of eternal destiny"; he conveyed the message constantly, he advised constantly, he fought wars, he struggled; he did not say it and sit idle saying "it is a matter of eternal destiny." I look at the sunna of the Prophet (peace be upon him). I look at the sunna of his companions. Hazrat Umar (may Allah be pleased with him), in order to carry Islam forward, and Hazrat Abu Bakr (may Allah be pleased with him), in order to carry Islam further ahead, struggled so much and fought wars. They did not sit idle saying "this is a matter of eternal destiny"; that is not my way. Some people may sit like that, saying "it is a matter of eternal destiny," remembering Allah in a corner, and surely they train themselves and bring themselves to greater perfection. "The best among you is the one who is most beneficial to people"; I never forget that.


The Mevlevi Ijaza and Orders Received Through Dreams

It is clear from history that the Qadiri and Rifa'i branches were received from Çorum. Where did you receive the Mevlevi order? Seeing something in a dream is one thing, whereas receiving it from an authorized sheikh who lives what is seen in dreams and whose silsila (chain of transmission) is sound is another. So, where and in what way did Mevleviyya come to you, was it by inheritance, and in what way did you become a Mevlevi and take Mevleviyya as your own?

My Mevlevi identity begins before I ever entered the dergah — if we are going to start the subject that way — I had not yet entered the dergah, and my Mevlevi identity had already begun, let me put it like that. When I repented and turned back, my Mevlevi identity began. It continued with the Sheikh Efendi. The Sheikh Efendi was himself deeply influenced by Hazrat Mawlana Jalal al-Din Rumi, and so our Mevlevi identity began to make its way together with the Sheikh Efendi, and it has walked on and it continues, let me put it like that. Do I have an ijaza from the Mevlevi order? No. In the Sheikh Efendi's ijaza, in the ijaza of naqib al-nuqaba, the name of Hazrat Mawlana is there, but do I have an ijaza from a Mevlevi sheikh as a particular silsila, as a path? I do not. And I make no claim to that anyway. I do not say "I am a Mevlevi sheikh," "I am a sheikh," or "I am a Qadiri sheikh," "I am a Rifa'i sheikh" — I don't say that anyway — but I regard myself as a Mevlevi. Who is going to deny it, for example? And I claim Mevlevi identity as my own. What is it to anyone? Let everyone claim it. Let everyone come out into the open and say "I am a Mevlevi." Whose path is it? Or let everyone come out and say "I am a Qadiri" — whose path is it? What is that to me? Whether I accept him as a sheikh or not is my problem. If someone says from morning till evening "I am a sheikh," may God bless it, brother — what is it to me, I say; it does not concern me. I have never yet asked any sheikh, "Do you have an ijaza?" It does not concern me; what is it to me? Why should I ask anyone about his ijaza? From time to time this conversation came up at the sheikhs' gatherings. May God have mercy on the Sheikh Efendi; he went twice, then I went, three or four times, and as we were leaving the sheikhs' gathering there, some sheikh efendis would say, "I have an ijaza — and the Sheikh Efendi doesn't, does he?" "May God bless it," I would say. Some sheikhs had two or three ijazas at once; "May God bless it," I would say. Two of them even said, "Come, let us give you a caliphate." "May God be pleased with you," I said, "I have a sheikh; tell him," for example. Now, if someone claims for himself a belonging to a place, whether it be Sufism or religion, you have no right to tell him, "You are not this." If someone says, "I am a Muslim," can you tell him, "You are not a Muslim"? You cannot. If someone says, "I am a Mevlevi," you cannot tell him, "You are not a Mevlevi." It is just like that. If someone says, "I am a Rifa'i," what is it to anyone? I am a Rifa'i, and at the same time — what is it to anyone? For example: brother, I am a Rifa'i, and also a Qadiri, both a Rifa'i and a Naqshbandi — what is it to anyone? Both a Mevlevi and a Bayrami — what is it to anyone? You needn't believe it. Don't believe it. There is no one we have a quarrel with. There is no problem at all.


The Matter of Men Wearing Red

Regarding men wearing red: red is not simply permitted in every form, nor forbidden in every form. "Is there a distinction in the sharia between a little or a lot, lower or upper garment, cloak or shirt? As a matter of method, if you are a Mevlevi, what is this red? If you are a Rifa'i, it should be black? Drawing the istiva line on the sikke represents a very great station; by what authority did you exercise ijtihad and put it on?" Won't they say this?

Let them say it. Everyone will say something. If that person sees it in his dream, in its inner meaning, he will say: ah, that's why he said it, that's why he wore it, that's why he did it. And if that person does not see it, he will say something of his own. All the chelebis say this on the subject: what is Mevlevi about him? Well, don't accept it, brother; you are not obliged to accept it. You claim to be a Mevlevi while wearing a short skirt, without observing the covering of the body, and do we say to you, "You are not a Mevlevi"? You say "I am a Mevlevi" with a cigarette in your mouth, and do we claim that you are not a Mevlevi? You say in your dream "I am a descendant of Mawlana," and although you have never once seen him in your dream you say "I am a Mevlevi" — do we say anything? Never mind seeing him in a state of wakefulness — people who have not seen him even once in a dream pronounce judgments on the Mevlevi order and on Hazrat Mawlana; do we get up and issue a counter-statement saying that these people have nothing to do with Mawlana? Do we even say that Hazrat Mawlana Jalal al-Din Rumi turned up his face in disgust at the place where all of them were lined up, that he turned his face away? Do we even say that the Prophet (peace be upon him) gathered these people, all of them marching like the army of Patagonia, and turned his face away from them, and that we saw the figures he turned away from — do we say such things? We do not. And that Hazrat Abdulqadir Gilani drew his sword and laid it across the necks of all of them, and that a certain person threw himself into the middle and said: Sir, don't do this, don't do that — they make people say "Allah," even though they lack the manners, the etiquette and the authority — do we go around saying that, claiming that some person threw himself into it? We hold our tongues. We say: those who are trying to live the Qur'an and the sunnah, those who are trying to live Sufism anew — may they strive, we pray. We pray for them. Do we say anything about those who collect money with their ijazas, those who make their living from the pockets of dervishes through their ijazas, those who collect zakat with their ijazas, those who even tie the lesson papers they give to dervishes to payment — about gathering all of them up, all of them, and punishing them? Do we say that some person threw himself in for the sake of Allah, for Allah's sake, saying that these people are needed now by the Ummah of Muhammad, shedding tears, and going for days without food, bread or water? Do we say that? We don't. Though they are not qualified, though they are not qualified, they get their hands on an ijaza and make "shish" out of it — do we go and tell them that they know they will be tormented with those skewers, and yet they make shish burhan? Do we shame them? We say: don't do it. Don't. And what about those who were given the authority to make shish burhan, yet did not do it because they had no ijaza in hand — where are we going to put them? That is, I have the authority to make shish burhan, but I don't do it; if tomorrow or the day after someone asked me about my ijaza and I said, "They gave it to me spiritually," all hell would break loose. They would even go and file a complaint, and when they complain, they would give someone else nine months or ten months of punishment, and "they'll give me nineteen months" — where are we going to put those who say that and don't do it?

So that is why — yes, everyone asks something; let him go and turn to the Almighty, and let the Almighty show him in his dream; no problem. We are both Rifa'i, so we wear black, and Qadiri, so we wear green too, and Mevlevi, so we wear every color. If a person sees the color of the tennure in his dream, that matters with us. Hazrat Mawlana Jalal al-Din Rumi comes and says, "He made me wear a black tennure." Fine, his dream is true. True. Is it reality? Yes. Why shouldn't I have him wear black? I say: wear whatever you see in your dream. Sufism is built on this. Sufism is not a madrasa of fiqh, Sufism is not a madrasa of hadith, Sufism is not a madrasa of kalam, and Sufism is not a madrasa of tafsir either. Sufism, in one aspect, is a matter of metaphysical meaning within the sharia. That person will see it in his dream; this is the proof. He will see his tennure in his dream, he will see his sikke in his dream, he will see his hatt-i istiva (the equator line) in his dream, he will see his cloak in his dream — he will see, my dear brother. When he sees it, it is lawful for him, it is true. He has his proof in hand. He will say, "I saw it like this in my dream and I wore it." If you said such things to someone, now when it is talked about like this, it seems absurd to people; they say, what kind of world do these people live in? If the Prophet (peace be upon him) came to someone spiritually in his dream and said, "From now on you will walk around in this cloak, and you will hold sohbet in it," what could that person do? And if that person interprets dreams, if he interprets his own dream, and even if he says in his dream in his own way, "I would be embarrassed, how will I wear that?", and if he were told, "Are you embarrassed by what I say?", that person would sink into the ground, and he would not be able to recover for days. What will he do then? Yes. Isn't there a procedure for wrapping the turban in Mevlevism? Yes — how was Hazrat Mawlana's turban, I wonder? These are idle conversations. Someone comes to Hazrat Mawlana Jalal al-Din Rumi and says: "Master, how did the Prophet (peace be upon him) tie his sash? I want to tie it just as he tied it; it is the only thing left that I do not follow." And he says to him: "When you tie that too, you will become a perfect Abu Jahl." Doesn't a tariqa have its own procedures and etiquette within itself? Tariqas have their procedures and etiquette, but we are not a tariqa. Yes. A tariqa has its own procedures and etiquette. There is a saying that I have been repeating for years — this faqir has been saying it for years — there is no tariqa in Turkey. If you are a sayyid, the green shawl or green turban is wrapped from the base of the crown; if you are not, a finger's width higher — to those who say this, and to those who hold this station: insist on wearing clothes that are far from advertisement, that do not attract attention and that are made of colors not accepted by society — and what can be said about all these matters? Everyone can say something; everyone's truth belongs to himself. Clothing has a language of its own; I accept that, and this is the language of my clothing. I am not someone who conforms to society anyway, in my own way. Anyway, I don't see myself as someone with many procedures and rules. If I saw in my dream that I was told, "You will walk around bare from the waist up," I would walk around bare; if they gave me an order, "Tomorrow you are going there," I would go. This is my understanding of Sufism. Everyone has known this for thirty years. My sheikh told me, "Migrate," and I migrated the same day; my sheikh told me, "Sell," and I sold the same day. This is my understanding of Sufism. My sheikh even said, "I saw this in my dream, do it this way," and I did it that way. This is my understanding of Sufism; I even submitted to the dream he saw. They said, "Your sheikh saw it, you didn't see it." I said, "I have accepted everything of his — am I not going to accept his dream?" This is my understanding of Sufism. Suppose tomorrow I see something in my dream, a sound dream: "Do this," and I will do it tomorrow. "Throw it," I throw it; "hold it," I hold it; "wear it," I wear it, and I have no doubt at all. I have no doubt at all, provided that what is asked of me — that sound one I mentioned — is in accordance with the Qur'an and the Sunnah. I saw a car in my dream; they said, "Do not ride this." The next day I left the car; I said, I will never ride it again. They told me not to ride — so what am I going to ride? What they told me not to ride. In life. This is my understanding of Sufism. Sufism, in its main outlines, is already written in the books; you will live your day, you will live your state. They will tell you, "Go up the mountain," and you will go up the mountain. How else will you live Sufism? On the one hand you will say, "I am following in the footsteps of the Prophet (peace be upon him)," and he will say, "Go up the mountain," and you will say, "I am not going"? I set out for Istanbul for a sohbet — I do not want to tell all of this now — and then I looked up and I was somewhere else, on top of a mountain, and I stopped and asked myself where I was. I stopped, I looked, I looked around: I was on top of a mountain, the sea was visible from one spot, or perhaps I was the one seeing it. A wave of weeping came over me. I said, what have I become, where have I come to, what have I done, I said to myself. Then I phoned Barbaros. I said, Barbaros, it is like this: I do not know where I am right now, I am somewhere and I do not know where, I will probably be late. A person who set out for Istanbul had gone beyond Düzce, from there all the way to a Black Sea coast. And as I entered that road I followed it, I followed the trail, I went from here, from here, from here — I do not even see the road. When I came down to Düzce I understood: behind Düzce I had gone to the top of these mountains. Then of course I went there, and the matter did not end there; there was something else there. I said, this was going to be lived through. I even called Ahmet Acar. I said, "Ahmet Acar, my situation is not good, I do not even know where I am," like this, like this. I said, "I was going to come to Istanbul, I called Barbaros too." "Father, let me have you picked up," he said. I said, "My son, I do not know where I am, so how will you have me picked up?" Then the smartphone appeared. What will you do when you see it in your dream? Sufism is a metaphysical thing like this: if you have a sheikh, you ask your sheikh, "I saw this in my dream, I am going here." Well, and if he has passed away? They guide you. Sufism is like this. If someone is not going to enter this Sufism, then he will not — may Allah forgive — my path is like this. Look, my path is like this. I see it in my dream, I cannot make any sense of it, they do not say "that place," and then I look and say, ah, I had seen this place; yes, now it will be like this here, like this, like this — and it happens. The path manifests differently for everyone, of course; everyone has something different, of course; there is nothing to say against that. Why? They have always said that every spiritual state you see, every dream, must conform to the sharia, to the Qur'an and the Sunnah; they said it emphatically, stressing it again and again. There is no walking the path without taking dreams seriously, without taking spiritual states seriously. If it is only the outward (zahir), then go, my brother, sit before a mosque imam and let him teach you religion and live it. But Sufism is not like that. Whether it is a finger from above or a finger from below — by God, if they told me, "Tomorrow take off what is on your head, shave your head completely bare and walk," I would shave my head and walk; if they told me, "Tomorrow we have put something different on your head, you will walk with this," I would walk with that; I do not care at all. And I have no account to give to people. While people are racing toward 2021, I am living a Sufism like this; I myself take delight in the Sufism I live, I am happy, I take great delight, every day of mine is a different world, so I have no complaint whatsoever about this. People criticize and criticize. Before, they used to say, "He has no ijaza" — fine, I paid no attention to it at all; now they ask, "Where did you find his ijazas?" I found them on the street. Recently, too, someone mentioned a few matters: he says he is Rifa'i, but he does not do the shish (skewer ritual) and so on. Good heavens. What can I say; forget it, do not bother with it. Look, I always say to them in my own way: so, I say, it means the time is coming for certain things to come to light, slowly. A thing comes to light, its time comes, and when its time comes it will come to light; however much you pronounce a thing with your own tongue, there is no need to. My famous thesis is that if Allah has given you something, it comes to you. One brother used to say to me, he used to say, "You need a dergah." Good heavens. That friend said it once more: "Efendim, you need a dergah," and then I turned to him and said: if Allah has given someone something, He will give him his dergah too, He will give him everything. Allah has given someone something, has brought someone out into the open. He said to His prophets, "You are a prophet," gave them a book, gave them miracles, supported them, gave them whatever was needed. If the Almighty has told someone, "You are a friend of God (wali), you are a perfect murshid," and has brought him forth, and if He shows him to people in their dreams, then He will give what is needed — it is that simple. If a man says "I am such-and-such" and steps out into the open on his own, that is very dangerous. Whether it is really so or not, you wait, you watch, you investigate — and can you say to his word, "Oh, you are not that"? You can say it.

We are bold in claiming to live the Qur'an, the Sunnah and Sufism; we are bold in this, we make no claims in other things. Let people see whatever they see in their dreams; they say he is criticizing — let them criticize.


Women Dervishes Standing in the Dhikr of Allah

In the Rifa'i tariqa of Çorum it is the established practice that women dervishes absolutely may not stand up during the dhikr of Allah. There is also information on this in the work of H. Kemal Efendi. While this practice is observed meticulously today in places that received the caliphate, such as Çorum, Kırıkkale and İskilip, on what authority do you permit this?

The verse of the Qur'an says: "Remember Allah constantly while standing, sitting, and lying on your sides." My authority is the verse of the Qur'an. "Believing men and believing women, men who pray and women who pray" — are women lower than men? If the Qur'an has permitted Muslims something in a matter, it is not permissible to forbid it. As for saying, "This is Sufism, so-and-so would not have done it this way" — he may not have done it, my dear brother, he may not have; that is his method, his rule. Can a murshid develop a method of his own like this? The answer: he can. On this point, in my own judgment: the Qur'an has left something free, the hadiths have left something free, and the early Sufis said nothing about it. Therefore there is no harm in women standing up and remembering Allah. Even back when I was a new dervish, when I was serving as the zakir (leader of the dhikr), all our friends were from the so-called irregular path; people knew nothing of dervishhood or Sufism; we would gather people from the coffeehouse and bring them to remember Allah, and people's feet were aching. And we were in my grandfather's house, on the floorboards, with just one thin rag of a kilim on them, doing dhikr on that — no carpet, nothing — and it really hurts, truly hurts a person's knees. I saw that people were not remembering Allah, they were worrying about their knees. "Destur, ya Allah" — I made them stand up. We struck the dhikr, we remembered Allah, while standing. Right away someone from among us — he is not with us now anyway — that person went straight to the zakir of Tire and told him, "He made them stand up like this, he did dhikr like this." The zakir of Tire came, and said, "You cannot make them stand, it should be like this, it should be like that." I listened and listened and listened and listened, and I said nothing. I phoned the Sheikh Efendi. "As-salamu alaykum." "Wa alaykum as-salam." I said, "Are you my sheikh? Is it the zakir of Tire?" I said. He said, "What happened?" I said, "Efendim, the friends here are all people who came from the coffeehouse; their feet are aching, their knees are going stiff, and I had them do dhikr standing. If I have committed any discourtesy, I apologize. I am not qualified for this duty; if you wish, I will give up the role of zakir, and let that brother come and lead the dhikr here." "Musta Efendi, we are your sheikh, my son. From now on, whether standing, sitting, in the air, at sea, on land, under the earth, above the earth..." he went on listing, "have people do dhikr like that; take the lesson of whomever you wish, give the lesson to whomever you wish, expel whomever you wish from the dergah, admit whomever you wish into the dergah..." He said it all; he said everything that is said to a caliph — we learned this later. In fact, even before the Sheikh Efendi Hazretleri said it, I had already made people stand up, because their knees were aching. I say to my friends: have them remember Allah, my brother. Yes, it is the rule of the tariqa's procedure that only the naqibs make people stand up. My dear brother, we are not among those Sufis; we do not pick people up from the street, all of us are like that, so if I may put it this way, we are both vagabonds and bandits. We remember Allah while standing, sitting, lying on our sides, running — everywhere. Alhamdulillah.


Innovation and Change in the Erkan (Ritual Order)

On what authority did you introduce a new style that involves so much variability, and then another new style the next day?

I did it by the inspiration that the Almighty put into my heart; we will always be new. I am not a man of the tariqa, I say again. People of the tariqa follow the procedure and the rules, and cling tightly to the procedure and the rules. I am not a man of the tariqa; therefore I am always developing, always renewing, and I never want to remain behind a single veil. I am on the path of Hazrat Rumi, who said, "How beautiful to move on to a new place every day, how beautiful to settle in a new place every day." I am on the path of Hazrat Rumi, who said, "O son, undo the bond — until when will you remain tied to gold and silver?" For me, all the procedures and rules in the tariqa are bonds. All of them are bonds. Colors are bonds. If you see it in your dream, it is right; walk on, my brother. You saw it in a sound dream—go ahead, brother. Is there a verse on this? There is—go ahead, brother. Is there a hadith on this? There is—go ahead, brother. Is there anywhere in Ma'ruf al-Karkhi, Habib al-'Ajami, al-Junayd of Baghdad, Sari al-Saqati, the Risala of al-Qushayri, or the Risala of al-Sulami where they say, "Do not do this"? There is not. Go ahead, brother, go ahead. Go. Is there anything like that in the Masnavi? Go ahead, brother. There isn't—open the Masnavi and read it. The Masnavi itself renews itself. It says: how beautiful it is to camp in a new place every day, how beautiful it is to move on from the place where you camped. You will move on and camp, move on and camp—you will walk the road. And you will not be tied to gold and silver. Everyone sees that as worldly; I do not see it as worldly. Someone has said: you will take one step and do this, you will take two steps and do that. That is right; let those who count themselves a tariqa do it. Go ahead, brother, do not see it as a bond; say "Allah," go, flap your wings toward the beyond. This is the right way. In places like İskilip, where caliphate (khilafa) was granted, this method is observed with great care—so by what authority do you permit this? "I do it as I saw it in my dream." Is it in the verse? It is. Is it in the hadith? It is. I am walking. This is my authority. Allah has given me the authority—from whom else would I get it? The authority that Allah has given can only be confirmed by a perfected murshid (murshid-i kamil) who says to me: "Yes, the Almighty has given you this authority, but do not do this"—this is not forbidden, mind you. "Do not do this," he says. "Very well, Efendim," I say, and that is the end of it. But otherwise, who will stop me?

Being able to offer something new every day, or saying "I saw it in my dream, it binds me, it binds those who believe in me," and thus renewing oneself—regarding this, in the history of Sufism, what are the qualities and conditions required for making ijtihad in the tariqa?

The tariqa is one thing, Sufism is another. Sufism (tasawwuf) is a field open to ijtihad; when you say tariqa, it is not a field open to ijtihad. "My sheikh's sheikh's sheikh did it this way, and I continue to do it this way"—continue, brother. Are you needed? You are needed too, there is no problem in this, I do not reject it, but it is not my path. As if he had said to me, "O son, be free"—that is why I am free, I am free. If you saw it in your dream, come, brother; if you love it, come, brother. If you did not see it in your dream, we are nothing of yours; if you saw it in your dream, come, brother. You loved it—come, brother, ya Allah, our arms and our hearts are open to you.


The Understanding of Rites (Erkan) of Hacı Mustafa Efendi of Çorum

Hacı Mustafa Efendi of Çorum made not the slightest change in the rites (erkan); he would even say, "Whatever I received from my sheikh Ali Haydar Efendi, I passed on to you exactly as it was; I neither added nor removed anything."

Wonderful. That is his path, and mashallah, may Allah bless it. So this is nothing to be belittled, but it is not something that binds the other Sufi folk. I am saying this to the brother who asked the question—take it as an anecdote: whoever went to visit Hacı Mustafa Efendi of Çorum would place some pocket money for Hacı Mustafa Efendi under the cushion. Those who did this told me. When there was a need, he would say, "Take it from under the cushion there and spend it, my son"—he had seen it that way from his sheikh. I suppose those who follow his path do this too. What shall we do now? Everyone who comes to visit us—we do not have a cushion like that either; should they tuck money under the cushion now? If I speak, no one could stay seated where they are sitting. I am not saying these things about Hacı Musta Efendi of Çorum critically; I am saying them as a matter of the etiquette of the path: he would go to Kırşehir every Ramadan—because Ali Haydar Efendi would go there and pray the tarawih behind a hafiz, completing the whole Qur'an during Ramadan, he continued the path of Ali Haydar Efendi: he would go to Kırşehir and pray tarawih there behind a hafiz every Ramadan. Now, do those who follow his path go to Kırşehir and pray tarawih behind just any hafiz? They do not. Then they did not observe the etiquette and manners. Ali Haydar Efendi's etiquette did not continue—look, there it is. What happened? Why was it cut off? There may be more things I can tell about Hacı Musta Efendi of Çorum. What would they do then—if everyone who came after Hacı Musta of Çorum is to follow Hacı Musta Efendi of Çorum to the millimeter, to give an example, will they all go to Istanbul for eye surgery? Let me not carry on any further now.

Look, all the perfected murshids (murshid-i kamil) explained, in their own times, a religion that could be lived by them, a Sufism that could be lived. I reject none of them, but, how shall I put it, this is our method. I do not say that I am a continuation of Musta Efendi of Çorum; I make no such claim. If they can ask Hacı Musta Efendi of Çorum, let them ask whether there is such a thing in Mustafa Özbağ or not. Let them not visit the graves emptily, merely from the outside—let them ask. Yes. If they go to the cemetery like everyone else and recite three Ikhlas and one Fatiha, fine, that is still a grave visit. "Ask the people of the graves"—a hadith. Let them ask. The Prophet (peace be upon him) went to the head of a grave, placed a palm branch on each of them, and said, "Do you know why these brothers of yours are being tormented?" "The Prophet performed ablution like this, and you performed it that way — did you ask the grave?" You looked only at the sunnah of ablution; you did not look at the sunnah of speaking at the grave. At Badr he had all the polytheists thrown into a single well, then went and said, "'Utba, Shayba — now have you seen that I am the Messenger of Allah? Do you believe now? But it is too late." Why do people never follow this sunnah? Hazrat 'Umar, may Allah be pleased with him, went to the grave of the young man who had died out of fear of Allah; the Companions ran after him, asking where he was going. He went to that grave and said, "O so-and-so, have you found what Allah promised you?" All the Companions heard the reply: "I have found it, O Commander of the Faithful. Allah gave me even more than that." Why do they not look at these sunnahs? Moreover, he says: whenever you doubt even the hadiths on which the people of Sufism rely, or when you are in difficulty and cannot find your way out of a situation, ask the people of the grave. Go and ask them, my dear brother. Üftade Hazretleri is here, Emir Sultan is here, Ismail Hakki is here, Haci Bayram is in Ankara, and in Corum they are all lined up one after another. There had once been a slight coolness between me and Musta Efendi. My sheikh took me to the graveside and we recited the tawhid. He asked me, and I said, "Efendim, things are not good between me and Musta Efendi; he has not turned his attention toward me." He nodded his head. We recited the tawhid once more at his grave, and then, of course, I spoke the reason in my heart as well, and after that we embraced. He turned to me and said, "Is it settled now, Musta Efendi?" "It is settled, Efendim, may Allah be pleased with you," I said. Let them ask the people of the grave. What are the qualities and conditions required for exercising ijtihad in the tariqa? In the tariqa, no one can easily exercise ijtihad. Whoever does so is crucified anyway.


The Matter of the Kudum and the Daf

In the zikr of the order (erkan zikri), he absolutely did not allow the kudum or the daf to be struck, and he forbade it strongly. It is permitted only in the sohbet zikr. If one were asked, "By what authority did you make these changes?" — or even if someone said, "I did it, and it was fine," and those who come after you said, "I did it too" — then where would the essence of the matter, the original and authentic form, which has not mutated or degenerated, remain? What can you say to such words?

All the great ones of the people of Sufism, and likewise the scholars of fiqh, have issued fatwas that the kudum may be struck, or cymbals may be struck, during the remembrance of Allah (zikrullah). Look: the Hanafi jurists, the Hanbali jurists, including al-Suyuti, and likewise all the early Sufis, have fatwas and rulings of ijtihad that these may be done during zikrullah. Therefore what we do is based on these fatwas and rulings of ijtihad.


Guidance from the Grave and the Need for a Living Sheikh

They ask Abdullah Efendi (in his Sivas sohbet, which is also on YouTube), "Efendim, can a deceased sheikh guide from the grave?" He says: "No. If that were possible, everyone would turn to the grave of our Prophet. There must be a living sheikh." In your own talks you say, "One who has become acquainted with the state of the grave has no need of a sheikh." In the works of Sufism there is the principle: "Sainthood (wilaya) begins from the state of the grave, but there is no spiritual guidance (irshad) from the grave." Although there are exceptions in the history of Sufism that break this principle, they are called exceptions. An example of such an exception is Sultan al-'Arifin Bayezid al-Bistami's guidance of Abu'l-Hasan Kharaqani. If every dervish were included in this exception, why would it be an exception at all! Thus;

Look, not having a need is one thing. That is, a person who has become acquainted with the people of the grave has no need of a sheikh; he can continue his daily life without a sheikh, but he will have no seyr-i suluk (progress along the path). Let us put it that way. Because acquaintance with the state of the grave begins toward the end of the third station. In some it begins at the start of the third station, depending on the dervish's own state. It continues in the fourth station. When that person becomes acquainted with the state of the grave, he goes to Emir Sultan, and if he sees some deficiency or shortcoming in himself, or cannot see it, he repents, saying, "Ah, there is a deficiency in me," repents, and continues with his life. If from that moment on someone says, "I will not attach myself to a sheikh," then he does not; his path extends only that far, and he will go only that far. Otherwise, everyone has need of a sheikh. What is the source of this teaching of Abdullah Efendi? This was the teaching of Sheikh Efendi. Antepli Bilal Nadir said to him, "My son, after I pass away there is no one left among us who has been brought up to this; you will go and attach yourself to Corumlu Haci Musta Efendi. Do not remain without a sheikh; you absolutely must attach yourself to a murshid." His teaching came from both channels in just this way.

And while the great ones in the books of Sufism, not regarding this teaching as sufficient, say that one has need of a living sheikh until one completes the suluk and receives the ijaza (authorization), is this a contradiction that arises? Is there not, once again, a state of falling into inconsistency with the teaching you have received here? What do you say on this matter?

No, there is no contradiction. A person will receive teaching from a sheikh, and his teaching will continue with that sheikh. Now, I don't want to put it this way, but let me say it anyway: Sheikh Efendi, Abdullah Efendi, had my sheikhhood proclaimed himself, personally. What he told me is one thing, and I am not repeating what he told me at all: he himself had my sheikhhood proclaimed. I must have reached a state in this matter in which my sheikhhood could be proclaimed, for him to have had it proclaimed. I give this as an example so that those brothers will not misunderstand: between Oktay's dervishhood and mine there is a difference of five or six months. Why not Oktay, or why not Nuri, or why not Adil at that time? Adil was a naqib al-nuqaba' (chief of the naqibs) as well. Why not Mustafa in the Netherlands, in Europe? He had me spoken of together with Ahmet Turan, the elder brother from Sivas. Let me put it this way: it means that I received a certain training from him, such that in his own judgment he saw me in a position and condition to act as a sheikh. If he had not seen me in a position and condition to act as a sheikh, and yet he had it proclaimed in the dergah, saying 'He is a sheikh, proclaim his sheikhhood,' then did Abdullah Efendi lie? Was he playing a game, setting up a trick? Since that cannot even be imagined... He did proclaim my sheikhhood, and I rejected it myself; I said, 'We have taken it and put it aside.' My dear brothers, we took it and put it aside, but I said that since my sheikh is alive, I will not act as a sheikh until my sheikh passes away. That evening, it was as simple as that. Until a person receives the ijaza (authorization), he must be attached to a sheikh. Sheikh Efendi had already proclaimed mine; he just did not write it down. He did not write it. And he also had it done through someone else. He told me, 'Proclaim it tonight.' I said, 'I cannot proclaim it, Efendim.' He said, 'I will have someone proclaim it.' I, since I guessed whom he would telephone, and I am repeating this again and again, since I guessed whom he would telephone, said to him, 'Do not do it without speaking to me.' I asked, 'What did he say to you?' He said, 'He said such and such: go out this evening and proclaim it.' I told that friend, 'If he said so, then all right, go out and proclaim it,' and he went out and proclaimed it. Therefore, while they say that one needs a living sheikh until he completes the suluk (spiritual journey) and receives the ijaza, yes, even with my sheikh's word I still did not act as a sheikh; I waited, because there were things he had taught us. One of the things he taught us was this: 'Musta Efendi, my son, the sheikhhood given by a sheikh may not be sound; even that of the pir efendis may not be, it can be spoiled.' The word my sheikh gave, look, this is what he told me: 'Musta Efendi, if a sheikh efendi grants sheikhhood, a person can be spoiled, my son. If the pir efendis tell him, "You are a sheikh," he too can be spoiled. But if the Prophet (peace be upon him) says it, that person is not spoiled, my son.' I received this teaching from my sheikh. I received the teaching from my sheikh, and my sheikh had my sheikhhood proclaimed. While it is said here that one needs a sheikh, is this contradiction? I have no contradiction within my own nafs. Why? Even though I did not ask it of him, he himself, I don't want to put it this way, how many times he said it. I said, 'Efendim, I am not here for sheikhhood.' Even in the hospital, after the operation, when Sheikh Efendi was, in his own view, left alone with death, he said, 'Musta Efendi, my son, let me proclaim it.' I said, 'Efendim, I do not want it; I did not come to this dergah for sheikhhood; I do not ask you for such a thing; I am not here for this.' He said, 'My son, what kind of person are you? People are dying to become sheikhs, dying to become caliphs, and you say you do not want it.' I said, 'I do not want it, Efendim.' Because my belief is this: I am there for Allah; I am not there for sheikhhood. And right now too, I am here for Allah; I am not here because I am a sheikh. People call me a sheikh, it does not concern me; they call me a master (ustad), and I do not see myself that way either. I say that I am a person who runs in the way of Allah; I am running in the way of Allah. If Allah chose a leader for them, then He chose me, and I try to do what I can. And if you look at the technical side of the matter, my sheikh also gave me sheikhhood, and moreover, for those who want a sheikhhood ijaza, there is the ijaza as well, and moreover people have seen it in their dreams, yes they have. For me none of it is a contradiction. It is not a contradiction. Is there a case of falling into contradiction with the teaching you received here? What do you say on this matter? I have no contradiction at all. What Sheikh Efendi said is true: a person must certainly continue his seyr-i suluk (spiritual journey) with a sheikh. My sheikh proclaimed my sheikhhood, which means my seyr-i suluk with him had been completed, for him to have proclaimed it; if it had not been completed, would he have proclaimed it? He would not have. So I had completed my seyr-i suluk in his eyes, and so he proclaimed it.


Proofs and Ijaza Authorities

The Nakibs of the Çorum Rifa'i Tariqa, who hold an ijaza in its usul and erkan (principles and rites), are granted the authority of the Skewer burhan; those who are Nukeba are granted the authority of the Fire burhan; and those who are Sheikhs are given the great ijaza with the authority of the Sword burhan. When Hacı Bekir Baba and the Sheikhs after him received their caliphate, this authority was granted to them. It is known that Bekir Baba, Ali Haydar Efendi, Mustafa Efendi, Kemal Akdeniz Efendi, Tığlıoğlu Mehmed Efendi, and his present caliph, Hacı Zâkir Kümbül Efendi of Çorum, have all preserved this practice and perform the Sword and the other burhans on the Kandil nights... What do you say about this?

That is correct. It is correct that the Çorum dergah gave it with such an ijaza, it is correct that they continue with the ijaza on this matter, and they do perform it on the Kandil nights; that too is correct. What do you say about this? The burhan is not a matter to be made very large. The Sheikh Efendi, may his station be exalted, at first did not perform it himself, then he began to perform it, then he stopped, and he himself did not perform it: "My son, it is understood differently, I will not do it," he said, and that was that. I am among those who believe that an ijaza is needed for it to be performed. From time to time they also ask me, "Do you have such a burhan?" and I say, "What is there, what isn't there?" If I say I have it, I would have to perform it; if I say I don't, I would have told a lie. Let us say that it too has its time. Since I am someone who acts according to my dreams, if they say do it today, tomorrow, on such and such a day, then with the permission of the Almighty (Allah) we will do it; we have no difficulty or objection on this point. If Allah shows it, if they say, "Come on, let this too come out into the open," we will come out into the open; there is no difficulty on this matter, praise be to God. Others ask too: "Since he is Rifa'i, does he perform the burhan?" Allah, Allah. That is, is one to become a Rifa'i by performing the burhan? Now if it is a sign, very well, people may look for that sign, very well, I have nothing to say to that either. Now let me burst the curtain: if I were to do that now as well, they would say, "Where is the ijaza for that?" If I were to say, "I saw it in my dream, it happened thus and so," then another uproar would break out. I allude to it; I say the skewers were with me, they were always kept with me; I say that the Sheikh Efendi told me, "Let them stay with you," but they keep pressing and pressing on me. May Allah make it well, but everything has its time. As I say, there is nothing lacking in this dergah, everything is complete. The other day, regarding the tekke, I said that in the end they will make me do it, they will get me a place, and there I will set up the tekke from a tent of goat hair, I will tie a horse at its door, I will tie a camel too, and I will drive the skewer into whoever comes and goes there. I said all this, inside the goat-hair tent, but it seems the answer has not reached everywhere. The newspaper will put me on the front page the next day, of course; after that the penalty starts at no less than nine months, and under the law on knives, skewers, and such odds and ends, there is a penalty of up to one to three years. Do not take this personally, whoever asked this question. These questions come partly from those quarters; they come to me from other places; this is not about you. They are pressing on my vein, as if to make me do such a thing at once, suddenly, but I will not get carried away; everything has its time. I will put boiling cauldrons in the middle, I will put all the skewers and swords in the middle, I will light the fires there, we will roast the embers and the tulips, and there will be such an uproar that they will say, "Allah, Allah, Allah, Allah, what is going on?" and "The Mevlevis don't have this." Yes, in the end that is what they will say.


The Matter of Abdullah Efendi's Sheikhhood Ijaza from Çorum

You also said in the last talk that Abdullah Efendi of Nevşehir did not receive the sheikhhood ijaza from Çorum according to the proper usul. I am writing as the old dervishes in Çorum know it and relate it: Çorumlu H. Mustafa Efendi, may his station be exalted, gave Abdullah Efendi, the Nakib of Nevşehir, only the authority of the Skewer burhan. Because he had not reached the station of Nukeba, he did not give him the authority of the Fire burhan.

It is not correct. I am obliged to say it this way: when the Sheikh Efendi began to act as a sheikh, he did not have the authority of the Skewer burhan either. It is not correct. It is not correct. In fact, we were new dervishes at that time; in Sivas, Ali abi had the skewer and fire burhans, the Sheikh Efendi did not; indeed this was being discussed inside the dergah. Ali abi would puff out his chest and perform the skewer burhan and the fire burhan, as if to say "I have it," while implying that Abdullah Efendi did not; later it was given to the Sheikh Efendi spiritually. Let me drop this bomb from here now. No, it is not correct. Because the Sheikh Efendi has no ijaza for the skewer burhan. This is not correct either. These claims stem partly from their taking a stance against Abdullah Efendi, may his station be exalted, and partly from other things. There is no need to take a stance against one another; these are all products of sister dergahs, every one of them. There is no need for them to line up against one another, no need to needle one another; if there is, there is; if there isn't, there isn't; whether it was or wasn't, let everyone step forward and tell the truth.


The Ijaza of Nukebalik and Nakiblik

Do you know anything about a ceremony for the granting of Nukebalik, or about the ijaza for it?

No, Sheikh Efendi Hazretleri said, "Musta Efendi Hazretleri made us naqib al-nuqaba', my son," and that is all. At that time we knew that Yakup Efendi was a naqib al-nuqaba', that Karabüklü Musta Efendi was a naqib al-nuqaba', that at the same time Ali Efendi in Istanbul was a naqib al-nuqaba', and that Ali Abi in Sivas was a naqib al-nuqaba'. These were the naqib al-nuqabas that we knew of; these were the naqib al-nuqabas appointed by Çorumlu Hacı Musta Efendi. Ali Abi of Sivas had told me that Sheikh Efendi was a naqib al-nuqaba', let me put it that way; Ali Efendi in Istanbul had told me that Abdullah Efendi was a naqib al-nuqaba', and Yakup Efendi in Ankara had told me that Abdullah Efendi was a naqib al-nuqaba'. I know that personally, because I met with all three of them. Only with Musta Efendi in Karabük did I meet, but we did not discuss anything concerning the office of naqib al-nuqaba' with him.


The Testimony of the Dervishes of Çorum

If the dervishes who remain from Mustafa Efendi, who lived in Çorum, say that they never witnessed such a thing, what can you say? Did you ever see Abdullah Efendi perform the fire-and-sword burhan (proof)?

I know that Sheikh Efendi performed the skewer burhan. He did not perform a fire burhan in public, but he put me into boiling water. That is, he said to me, "Get in, Musta Efendi," and I said "destur" (with your permission) and got in. Let me speak openly about this now: people could not even put a finger into such water, no one at all could get in; it was only we who got in. After me, he got in too. To speak openly, it was as if a separate veil came down; I heard no sound, I heard no breath. There were others there too; whether they saw us get in or not, I do not know. It was such a state that he said to me, "Get in, Musta Efendi," and I got in. There were two or three other people beside us. This water cannot be entered, it was extremely hot water. It was the hottest spot of the hot spring in Sivas, right where it comes out, and apparently it comes out at I don't know how many degrees. No one could enter that room either; Sheikh Efendi had chosen that very place that day. No one could put a finger into the spring, those who were there could not, of course. I was beside Sheikh Efendi, and I heard him tell me to get in. That is how I heard it: "Musta Efendi, get in, my son," he said. I said "destur" and threw myself into the water. I moved one finger and my finger burned. I stayed like that, and then he got in too. "Don't stir," he said to me, may Allah have mercy on him. "I am not stirring at all," I said, and so we stayed there in the water. Well, of course, he said get in, and we would get out only when he said get out. The water keeps coming, but from behind it burns even more, the whole place is full of steam, nothing at all is visible. Sheikh Efendi Hazretleri had this; I saw it as a burhan, to speak openly. I said, no, this is a burhan; it came to me within my heart like this: "this is the burhan of heat." I said, this is nothing other than the burhan of heat. That is why, in Sheikh Efendi, this is what I saw. Perhaps an ijaza (authorization) is certainly required, in the rule of the tariqa method an ijaza is needed, yes indeed, but in the sphere of Sufism there is no condition of ijaza in this. That is, I do not wish to explain this, but when I entered my first i'tikaf (spiritual retreat), they told me: "Rub your head, say the basmala, and strike it against the mosque's pillar." I am bound to the command; whatever I see in my dream or in my state, I do it. I said Bismillahirrahmanirrahim, I rubbed my head, I tensed up, and I went off, hard, hard, hard, hard. And, you know how it is in youth, I struck it against the mosque with a thud, and the mosque shook. I wondered, is the mosque going to collapse? There was no one there, just before the morning prayer. "O Allah," I said to myself, "what kind of thing is this?" I did not understand it at all; I tell it to my friends in my close circle. When someone does something like this, ask, "Do you have an ijaza for it, as much as you like?" No, I do not. From that day to this I have never struck my head against anything, I have never hurled my head at anything; I said, someone might die or something, may Allah protect us. Is there an ijaza for this? No. Sheikh Efendi told me, get into the hot water, and I got in. Is there an ijaza? No. Sheikh Efendi has no ijaza in that matter either. That is why, I apologize very much, not everything is a matter of ijaza. That is, if something has been given to a person, however much someone may shout from over there, ijaza is needed. Very well, my dear brother, you do not do it without ijaza, but if it was given to him, if it was commanded, what is he to do? If he is somewhat of a delicate disposition, he says, how can I do it without ijaza, they will gossip, they will speak ill, they will scratch, they will throw stones. We see it in our dream and we do it, brother, whether they throw stones or fire cannons. The Prophet (peace be upon him), the earlier prophets, the Companions, the pir efendis: if my sheikh says something and it is within the Qur'an and the Sunnah, yes it is, I will do it, my dear brother, even if they assemble all the tanks and open fire. It will be received upon our heads and eyes; we say we must have had an ordeal ahead of us, and we bear it patiently and walk on.


The Claim of Sheikhhood Without Ijaza and Spiritual Responsibility

Since it is well known that a person who has not completed the seyr u suluk (spiritual journey) and who claims to have been assigned a duty through a dream cannot be a "Sheikh," why do you address him as "Sheikh Efendi"?

In my view, Sheikh Efendi Hazretleri was a sheikh. I believe in his sheikhhood, which is why I still say "Sheikh Efendi." No. Within his own state, in his own circle, in the place where he stood, he was a complete sheikh, and truly, anyone who wished to be trained was trained at his hands. Every sheikh has his own distinctive states, and he too had his own distinctive states, his own distinctive standpoint, but I see no hesitation regarding the sheikhhood of Sheikh Efendi Hazretleri. In the end, every person has places where they come under influence, where they are affected, and he had such places too. I stayed by his side for eighteen years. I apologize very much, I don't want to put it like this, but I am someone who knew him well. Now, even though the brothers who remained at the dergah may speak ill of me behind my back, this will be a very bold statement, but I am one of those who knew him best. Including his children. Look, including his children, and even, may Allah have mercy on her, including his wife, and even including the dervishes closest to him. Including those who on their own say, "I am serving as zakir, I am serving as naqib, I am serving as one of the nuqaba." I claim this; underline this, Salim, you underline it too: no one could know Abdullah Gürbüz Efendi as I knew him, no one knows as much as I know, and no one can know his spirituality and his rank as I know them. Those who are now producing talk on their own, those who are also producing talk about me, are, may Allah have mercy on Sheikh Efendi, harming him. May Allah forgive him. I was a person who knew what he would do, and where, even before he did it. I am saying this publicly for the first time: I was also a person who knew what he would go through during the illness, and I told those in my close circle. In fact, as proof of what I said, one day at the hospital Gökhan Karadayı was there, I am even mentioning the name. I said, "Gökhan, run over here," and he came, running. "Listen to what the professor says, to what is going to happen," I said. He listened to the professor. "Memorize these, keep them in your mind," I said, "because one day these will be needed." Gökhan Karadayı is here too, he is still alive. So, may Allah have mercy on him, may He have abundant mercy on him. I lived eighteen full years, a full life; I lived Sufism with him, fully. He was, in my view, one of the most important figures of the late period of a Sufism oriented toward the metaphysical. He was someone oriented toward the metaphysical, who gave importance to the states he saw and the dreams he saw, and who dwelt a great deal on this subject, on this very matter. In his own way he too had hopes, let me put it that way, but he was also bound to the spiritual meaning of the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him). For example, let me say this publicly for the first time: on his last umrah, he had our cook İsmail enlisted as a soldier among the Companions of the Suffa (Ashab al-Suffa) at the head of the Prophet's (peace and blessings be upon him) tomb. I am saying this publicly for the first time, don't tell anyone: he was having him perform rabita to the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him), having him ask the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) who would be the owner of the dergah after him, and the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) would say to İsmail: the owner of the dergah is Musta Efendi. İsmail performed rabita every day, and every day, after breaking the fast, on the way to the hotel, he would whisper it to Sheikh Efendi, and Sheikh Efendi would say to him, "Don't tell Musta Efendi." And I would say to İsmail, "İsmail, listen to your sheikh, don't tell anyone." He would be all flustered, saying, "Okay brother, okay brother," and I would say, "Please, İsmail, don't tell anyone." Look, I am saying this for the first time with my own mouth. I said this to İsmail after Sheikh Efendi passed away. Let no one have any doubt or suspicion in their mind about Sheikh Efendi's sheikhhood. His states in the final period after he took to his bed need to be discussed and analyzed separately; that is another matter. Even those are not things that would stain his sheikhhood or his duty. Yes.

You often used to say the saying "Time is the cure for everything," and I still say it: time brings many hidden and concealed things into the open. Yes. Would you not want to turn back from an error? I would want to turn back from an error, if I have an error within the bounds of the Qur'an and the Sunnah. If they say, "This is an error," I will turn back from there; what is there to say against it? In light of all these explanations and investigations, how do you really view Abdullah Efendi, how can you explain to us the situation that has come about?

I believe that Abdullah Efendi Hazretleri was spiritually assigned a mission and that he carried out that mission; I have never lost this belief. I have never lost it, and I have never hesitated on this matter. Look, even if I experienced difficulties in the matters of the last period with Sheikh Efendi Hazretleri, I see them as elements that caused me to mature and ripen. Sheikh Efendi Hazretleri did such a thing at that time, he did it himself, how he did it, how it came about, I am not saying anything about that at all, because, in quotation marks, I attribute everything to the illness of his final period.


The Fate of Those Who Act as Sheikhs Without Authorization to Guide

In the Sufi book 'Ziynet'ul-Qulub' there is a statement: "It is feared that those who act as sheikhs without being authorized to give guidance will be gathered with the insane on the Day of Gathering tomorrow." ... Hacı Mustafa Efendi of Çorum said that those who, without an ijaza (license), claim sheikhhood by themselves through a dream will, when they reach the grave tomorrow, be addressed with: "Come! Liar!" Knowing full well that this era will pass and that this sultanate will surely come to an end, what do you say about those who act as sheikhs and masters, and on what basis they gather people around themselves?

That is, if people do something like this on their own, out of their own heads, it is not right, mark my words, it is not right. But if someone's sheikh says to him, "You are a sheikh"; if a person's master says, "You are a sheikh"; if someone holds in his hand an ijaza authorizing him to act as a sheikh, I am speaking to both sides; or if someone in his dream sees the Prophet (peace be upon him) saying to him, "You are a sheikh, go out to the people, act as a sheikh, do your duty" — then that is something that binds everyone himself. To say "I am a sheikh" has no place in the etiquette and conduct (adab and erkan) of the early Sufis. For a person to say "I am a sheikh" has no place in the etiquette and conduct of the early Sufis, and that is why I keep this phrase far from myself. That is the first point. The second is that I gave my word to my sheikh in Bursa. I said that I would never come before the brothers and say "I have become a sheikh." I swore such an oath, I gave such a promise. I stand behind my word. I say I am not a sheikh. This is the method and rule of the early Sufis, and I have known it for a long time. So let those who have appeared out of nowhere on their own and say "I am a sheikh" think about this. Eyvallah.

Hacı Mustafa Efendi of Çorum said that those who, without an ijaza, claim sheikhhood by themselves through a dream will, when they reach the grave tomorrow, be addressed with: "Come! Liar!" Regarding Hacı Mustafa Efendi of Çorum, to be precise — I am putting this part in quotation marks, "those who claim sheikhhood by themselves through a dream" — the report that reached us is not like that. The report that reached us is this: those who claim sheikhhood although they are not sheikhs. Mark my words: those who claim sheikhhood although they are not sheikhs, when they reach the grave tomorrow, will be addressed with "Come, liar!" Yes, that is how I heard it. My sheikh, Abdullah Gürbüz Efendi of Nevşehir, said that those who act as sheikhs although they are not sheikhs would be subjected to this address, as Hacı Mustafa Efendi of Çorum had said. Knowing full well that this era will pass and that this sultanate will surely come to an end, what do you say about those who act as sheikhs and masters, and on what basis they gather people around themselves? If people truly do not see that person in their dreams as a sheikh or as a master, and if there is no sign or statement in the person himself that he is a sheikh or a master, if there is nothing at all, then his actually acting as a sheikh and master is not a sound circle from his own standpoint. As for the reasons — "I did it so that people would gather and not disperse," or "I did it so that they would not go off elsewhere" — these are empty words. But besides this, there are also hidden sheikhs. How do hidden sheikhs work? "We are at the point where our master left off, which is why we gather and continue the dhikr." Suppose the master passes away. After the master's death, for a month, two months, three months, five months, whatever it may be, while the istikharas and consultations continue, the people gather, and the dervishes fall into a search for a sheikh. During that search for a sheikh, it is sensible not to disperse, to stay together, to continue the dhikr, and to gather around the çavuş, the naqib, the nukaba, the zakir — whatever the hierarchical title may be — remembering Allah and continuing their sohbets. But when it is like this: "Our master said, you carry on, your owner will come," or "Your master said carry on, and until the Mahdi comes there will be no other sheikh" — such veiled words and conduct, whose meaning is unclear, which contradict the fundamental principles of Sufism and the fundamental principles of the Qur'an and the Sunna, are not right. These too are people who act as hidden sheikhs. How do they act as hidden sheikhs? They do not say openly, "We are acting as sheikhs." Rather: his sheikh has passed away, and after he passed away, "I saw him in my dream, he told me, you are the çavuş"; his sheikh has passed away, "I saw him in my dream, he told me, you are the zakir"; his sheikh has passed away, "I saw him in my dream, he told me, you are the sheikh." Mark my words, these are not right statements. For this person to create a rank for himself in this way is his acting as a hidden sheikh. Or else, although the sheikh himself left no ijaza, to say "I am his continuation, I am the continuation of his path" and claim to be the continuation of the path of a sheikh who left no ijaza — in his own view that person may perhaps have seen something like this in a dream or in a state, but from the standpoint of the method of Sufism these are not right things.

Because in Surah al-Isra, verse 71, it is stated: "On that day We will call all people by their leader" ... Right. And if it is said that it was received through a dream, in the religion of Islam a dream is not evidence. No, a dream is evidence. It is evidence for the Sufis. I do not accept this.

Hajji Mustafa Efendi of Çorum, addressing those who came to him narrating dreams and waiting for a rank, said: "My child, I must see it myself"... and this is a true word. A person may claim that in his own dream he attained various stations; he may say, "I attained various divine names," and say that he saw this in his dream. This also shows the importance that His Eminence Hajji Mustafa Efendi of Çorum gave to dreams. A master, a sheikh efendi, must see in his own dream the dervish or the person he has trained. A dream is evidence, one part of the forty-six parts of prophethood; and again in the hadith, the Prophet (peace be upon him) said that it is evidence for the one who sees and the one who is seen; it is glad tidings, it is evidence, it is among the mubashshirat (glad tidings). Therefore a master, a perfect murshid, a sheikh, whomever he is going to give a rank to, whomever he is going to give a position to, must see that person himself in his dream. I consider this determination of His Eminence Hajji Mustafa Efendi of Çorum to be correct, in my own view, and it is also the way of this humble one: if I see it in my dream, I give someone the post of çavuş; if I see it in my dream, I entrust a duty; if I do not see it in my dream, I do not entrust that person with any duty. And yet, could a sheikh, a master, whatever name you give it, give someone a duty even without seeing it in his dream? Yes, but only if that person himself asks for it; the general attitude of masters and perfect murshids is this: they do not give to the one who asks. This is what was taught among us. But does a master, a perfect murshid, a sheikh efendi, gather fruit from a dried-up tree? The answer: He does. He plants a dry tree; does it bear fruit? The answer: It does. This has to do with the skill of the master; it has to do with the master's supplication, his entreaty, his prayer and effort in this domain. Therefore, if a perfect murshid, a sheikh efendi, a saintly person were to give someone such a spiritual duty, were to assign him a duty spiritually, then even if that person were not worthy of it, would the Almighty, by God's permission, make him worthy? The answer: He would; but the elixir for this lies with that sheikh. Otherwise, whether the sheikh sees it in his dream or not, if there is an essential duty there, can he appoint someone as qualified for it? He can, and can that person indeed become qualified in that task? The answer: He can. It is beneficial not to close this door either.


Waiting for a Rank Through Dreams and the Warnings of the Sheikh of Çorum

In his work Tasavvuf ve Mârifet (1985 edition), Kemal Akdeniz Efendi also writes: "To say 'I saw our Prophet in my dream, I saw such-and-such pir efendis, I received an order' never constitutes any meaning. While it has been accepted unanimously among all the people of the Truth's path that one is obliged to put on the khirqa and crown and receive the ijaza in the murshid's own lifetime, through his himmet and gaze, to think otherwise is nothing but a satanic way." What can you say on this matter?

Kemal Akdeniz Efendi said something like this; it is his own determination, correct in his own view; very well. A person's heart desires that all sheikhs and all murshids, in their own lifetimes, crown and clothe in the khirqa the sheikhs, murshids and masters they have trained. The heart wishes for this, but if such a thing did not happen, then in cases where those sheikhs did not have an ijaza of sheikhhood and did not possess such a crown and khirqa, their granting sheikhhood to others would likewise not be correct. I am of that opinion.


The Humility of Mehmed Efendi of Tığlı

Mehmet Efendi of Tığlı used to say in his talks: "My children, even if I am not a sheikh, my sheikh is a sheikh, his sheikh is a sheikh, and his sheikh is a sheikh, and so on, all the way back to the Prophet, my son, they are all sheikhs." What is meant by this, and by the sheikh truly being a sheikh? What can you say on this matter?

In my talks I distinguish between sheikhs, saints, and perfect murshids. I see benefit in making this distinction. Sheikh means "the old one, the mortal pir." On the Sufi platform, he is the person at the very summit of a tariqa, and that person at the summit is called sheikh. In some places he is called a perfect murshid, in some places a master (ustad), in some places an abdal; indeed, in the hadiths he appears as abdal, and in the verses of the Qur'an he appears as wali (saint). I described this a little at the beginning of these talks: not every sheikh is a perfect murshid, nor is every sheikh a saint, but is he a sheikh? Yes. Then what kind of sheikh? He is a sheikh to whom the post was passed from father to son. He is a sheikh. Before that sheikh efendi passes away, he may say, "This one who serves at the dergah, who hurries about, who knows the etiquette and the rules best, let me give him an ijaza of sheikhhood so that the dergah continues, so that the path continues"; can he give sheikhhood to him too? The answer: He can. Is he also a sheikh? Yes. For example, in Bursa, the last sheikh of the Karabaş-ı Veli Tekke in the Republican period was an official of the Foundations (Vakıflar). Does he hold an ijaza? Yes. Is he a sheikh? Yes. But he was an official of the Foundations. The Foundations had appointed one of their own officials there for the protection, safeguarding and management of the endowment properties of the Karabaş-ı Veli tekke, for the collection of its revenues, and at the same time to keep that tekke standing. He was the last sheikh of the Karabaş-ı Veli tekke in the Republican period, before its closure, before the Law on Tekkes and Zawiyas was passed. Did he serve as sheikh there? Yes. Is his name also sheikh? Yes. Do we now accept him as a sheikh too? Yes. But is he a murshid-i kamil (a perfect spiritual guide)? No, in my assessment. A saint (wali)? No, in my assessment, but a sheikh? Yes. Then, begging your pardon very much, I will say this: can someone act as a sheikh? Answer: He can. Does he also hold an ijaza (license of authorization)? Answer: He does. Is every sheikh who holds an ijaza a murshid-i kamil? No. Is every sheikh who holds an ijaza a friend of Allah (wali)? No. Now, unfortunately, these things are not known in Turkey, they are not spoken about. Neither the technique of this path is discussed, nor its inner side, its metaphysics or its inwardness (batiniyya). No metaphysics, no inwardness, but does he have an ijaza? Answer: Yes. Have I met such sheikhs? Many, a great many. Just before the 28 February, in the times when the 28 February was brewing, there used to be gatherings of sheikhs in Turkey; around forty, fifty or more sheikhs would come, and when the sheikhs came to that gathering they would bring their own caliphs (khalifas) with them. At that gathering I got to know many sheikh efendis, and those gatherings are in fact still going on; they even invited me several times, and I said I could not come, that I would not be available. I am truly very busy; the talks are intensive, I go to various provinces and districts, I prepare talks. Our talks proceed in a somewhat more technical manner; we try to give commentary on certain subjects and to explain certain subjects, so when it is like that, a certain period of preparation is required. I am not able to keep attending those gatherings at the moment. May Allah be pleased with them, those who invited me liked me and respected me, and I thank them all, but in that period I got to know so many sheikhs there, and most of them also had ijazas, and despite their having ijazas, what this humble servant saw by his own reckoning was that none of them were saints (awliya), none of them were murshid-i kamil. Perhaps the subject has opened up in this way now, and those who keep attending those gatherings may be angry with me; this is my own assessment, but were they sheikhs? Yes. Did each of them hold an ijaza in their hands? Yes. Look, did they also have ijazas? Yes. I cannot say that every sheikh with an ijaza is a saint, I cannot say that every sheikh with an ijaza is a murshid-i kamil, I am not in a position to say this, but is every sheikh with an ijaza a sheikh? Answer: He is a sheikh. Can a prospective disciple (murid) attach himself to someone because he has an ijaza? Answer: He can. Is this correct within the tariqa culture? Yes. Look, is it correct within the tariqa culture? Yes. In the teaching of Sufism (tasawwuf) it is not correct, in the teaching of Sufism it is not correct. The reason? In the teaching of tasawwuf and Sufism, that person must see that sheikh in his dream. That person must himself see in that dream that he has attached himself to that sheikh. Can he become attached without seeing? Answer: He can become attached; that would be tariqa etiquette. Does he have an ijaza? Yes. Do they gather and perform dhikr (remembrance of Allah)? Yes; then he becomes attached. In fact, the great majority of those sheikhs with ijazas gather and remember Allah; metaphysical, spiritual states are not discussed among them, dreams are not discussed there, the inward side of the path is not discussed there metaphysically, because they are not authorized to discuss them, they have no knowledge of that subject; in fact, within their own dergahs they forbid the discussion of spiritual states (hal), they forbid the discussion of dreams; indeed some of the sheikhs say -I heard it with my own ears- that these matters are not accomplished through dreams, these matters are not accomplished through spiritual states. In fact, I once met a certain person in a garden outside Mecca the Noble, and when I said, "Musta Efendi, they place great reliance on dreams and states, this is not how it should be," I said, "Efendim, then through what will it be?" He replied, "If a person does not see a certain master in his dream, how will he be able to love him, how will he be able to see and understand that he is one in whom he can be annihilated (fana fi'sh-sheikh)? Or if a dervish does not see his sheikh together with the Prophet (peace be upon him), if he does not see him in his assembly, what spiritual proof will he have in hand that he is truly a perfect sheikh, that he is a murshid-i kamil?" At that he stopped and was left silent; of course there was no answer to give on the subject. That person held two ijazas in his hand, he had an ijaza from the Naqshbandi silsila (chain of transmission) and an ijaza from the Qadiri silsila, but when dreams were mentioned, he was left without words. Now one word leads to another; I am telling this not to praise myself but so that the path I came by may be understood. The brothers know this: there was a gathering in Bolu, a gathering of sheikhs. In Bolu, up on the slopes of the mountain, there is a certain holy man; there is even a mosque there and his tomb, a beautiful place, before you come to Bolu. The gathering was there. When we went there, the Sheikh Efendi, may Allah have mercy on him, said, "My son, there are cemeteries there; first let us go and visit them." Anyway, we went, and of course as we headed in that direction, the caliphs said among themselves, "They are going to the cemetery, surely something will happen there, let us go too," and some six or seven caliphs came behind us. May Allah have mercy on him, the Sheikh Efendi went to the head of a cemetery like this and had the tawhid recited three times, la ilaha illallah, la ilaha illallah, la ilaha illallah. He tapped my arm and said, “Agha, what happened?” I said, “Efendim, there is a person here who was clinging to you, there is a person here who was clinging to you, there is a person here who was clinging to us, there is a person over there. Efendim, he rose from the cemetery, but he didn't cling to you; he joined in the tawhid from here,” I said. “That's why he was so coy,” he said. We passed on to his grave and recited the tawhid three times at his head. “What happened?” he said. “It's done, Efendim, now,” I said, “that person is pleased,” I said. “Who was he, Musta Efendi?” he said. There is also a Naqshbandi sheikh in Bolu; his name was Mehmet, Mehmet Efendi. “He was the father of that sheikh efendi, Efendim,” I said. Of course I didn't know his father. This time that sheikh efendi's caliph was also there with us, and he said to me, “What kind of person was he?” I described him to him: his beard was like this, his clothes were like this, his turban was like this. “That's my sheikh,” he said. “When did you see him, in your dream?” he said. “I just saw him a moment ago,” I said. He couldn't believe it and just stood there. I turned and said, “Brother, are you far from these things? Do you never see such things? Do you not experience such things?” “No,” he said. At that I was left astounded; I said, Allah, Allah, a caliph! A person who is a caliph has no knowledge of the state of the grave. In our tradition they don't even make someone a çavuş if he has no knowledge of the state of the grave. For us, the state of the grave is like the beginning of dervishhood. Taking lessons is not enough; dervishhood begins in him once he comes to know the state of the grave. That is our teaching at that time. And I said, “Brother, this state is seen in our dervishes who are new to the path, those who have just begun the journey (seyr-i suluk). This is certainly common; indeed, we are the ones who see it,” I said. “No, Musta Efendi, I am seeing it here for the first time,” he said. But was he a caliph? Yes. Does he have an ijaza as well? Yes. A caliph with an ijaza, who received the ijaza from his previous sheikh, from that sheikh efendi, and continues in the caliphate. May Allah grant him a long and blessed life; I don't know whether he is alive or not. But he is a caliph.

Now, not every sheikh is a murshid-i kamil (perfect spiritual guide). Does he hold an ijaza? Yes. In fact, in Turkey now there are very, very famous sheikhs, leaving aside the east and southeast, very renowned, with great names and fame, and they too have no ijaza. It is an interesting thing, and they act as sheikhs. These are people in the Naqshbandi tariqa who make a stir, and when they pass away, they too have no ijaza; a great chaotic situation will arise, that is, it is not clear what will happen. But even those who hold an ijaza are not all saints (walis) and murshid-i kamil. Nevertheless, he is a sheikh efendi, so be it. Look, someone has become attached to him, so be it; he cherishes a love for that silsila-i mashayikh (chain of sheikhs). Bediuzzaman Said Nursi, too, speaks of this in his Mektubat. He says that such a person loves the chain of sheikhs, and because he loves it he trusts and feels confidence in them and does not lose hope in them. If he does not lose hope, he says, he may become a transgressor (fasiq) through major sins, but he saves his faith, and protects himself in the face of today's heresy (zindaqa). That being so, there is a sheikh with an ijaza; even if that sheikh with an ijaza is not a murshid-i kamil, a sheikh of that chain, his sheikh is also a sheikh, his sheikh is also a sheikh, his sheikh is also a sheikh, his sheikh is also a sheikh, and that chain continues all the way to the Prophet (peace be upon him). Does it continue? The answer: It does continue. Is it connected to a continuing chain, and does the disciple lose anything by attaching himself there? No, he loses nothing. He loses nothing in terms of the technique of Sufism, and he loses nothing in terms of the spirituality of Sufism. But will that dervish become a murshid-i kamil there? No. Let us underline this too: it is very difficult for the dervishes there, under the hand of that sheikh, to find the ways to become a murshid-i kamil; rather, he must go through the training of a murshid-i kamil. That is why, I will give an example of this now: If the sheikh to whom one will be bound has no spiritual manifestation of his own, but the sheikh has an ijaza, and it came by a sound route through that ijaza, then is there any difficulty in this? Does it go on like that? The answer: It goes on. Therefore, is this a good method? Yes. At the very least, a person may not have dreams of his own, may not have states of his own, may not have much knowledge in this field; then he looks at the sheikh's ijaza. Does the sheikh have an ijaza? He does. Who gave it to him? Such-and-such sheikh efendi. Who gave it to him? Such-and-such sheikh efendi, his sheikh, his sheikh, his sheikh, his sheikh, and if it goes all the way to the Prophet (peace be upon him), there is no difficulty in this.


Safeguarding the Secret and Recounting Spiritual States

One of the first rules taught by the Sheikh to dervishes who begin their journey of suluk (spiritual wayfaring) in the exalted tariqa is: *Hold the secret firmly.* "The one who sees does not tell; the one who tells does not know" is likewise a famous saying that has passed into the vocabulary of Sufism... The son of Hz. Haji Mustafa Efendi of Çorum, at the beginning of dhikrullah, spiritually saw the great ones of the path who came into the circle, and when he involuntarily said this openly, he died for having divulged the secret; this was told, in tears, by his own father, Haji Mustafa Efendi himself... Nevertheless;

Since this matter is so serious, isn't it interesting, and a contradiction, that in various videos you hand the microphone to Abdullah Efendi and to your dervishes and have them tell what they saw? No, it is not. Hz. Haji Mustafa Efendi of Çorum may have followed such a practice, but it is not contrary to the blessed sunna of the Prophet (peace be upon him). Since his son spoke in this way, Hz. Haji Mustafa Efendi of Çorum may have set down such a rule of conduct (adab) for himself; every sheikh has a circle of adab that he sets for himself, and this is that sheikh's right. A murid has no right to criticize a master, a sheikh, a murshid by saying, "Why do you forbid something that is established by the sunna of the Prophet (peace be upon him)?" Why? This too is one of the technical rules within Sufism itself: a sheikh efendi does not permit such a thing to be said or discussed; that belongs to that sheikh, and that prohibition does not bind all sheikhs. Can another sheikh efendi say it, thinking that its being discussed and told will also encourage the other dervishes toward spirituality? The answer: He can have it told. Is there a measure for this in the blessed sunna? Yes. The Prophet (peace be upon him) would both tell his own dreams to the Companions, and he would also have the Companions tell the dreams they had seen to him in front of everyone. Here, regarding the prohibition, is it the sheikh's own right? Yes, but having them told is the blessed sunna of the Prophet (peace be upon him), and it is moreover mutawatir, a strong sunna. Does it need to be told? In my view, yes, it needs to be told, but Allah knows best—I say Allah knows best because I was not involved in the matter—his son may have told it without the permission of Hz. Haji Mustafa Efendi of Çorum; he did not have permission, and though he lacked permission, in the delight and exhilaration of that state he blurted it out to those around him. Yes, I accept this: it is not correct behavior. A Sufi, a dervish brother, should tell the dreams and states he has seen first of all to his master, or to whomever his master permits—"You may tell so-and-so," or "You may tell the one in charge over you"—and only when his master says, "You may share this with your brothers" is that the measure, because these are mubashshirat (glad tidings); they are evidence, and they have the quality of warning people on this point, or of bringing glad tidings to those around him. Can the master have a dream or a state told? The answer: He can have it told. Is there any harm in this? No. Is there any difficulty? No. Is there any deficiency? No. Indeed, by this a sunna that I would call abandoned is being practiced. Whoever revives one of my blessed sunnas that has been abandoned in the end times will be given the reward of a hundred martyrs. Therefore, telling dreams to righteous people, telling dreams to perfect murshids and saints, and telling them to people within the framework of dreams being evidence and glad tidings—in this sense our brothers are carrying out an abandoned sunna. Therefore I see no harm in telling dreams and states to the masters, and to those whom qualified masters indicate. But this applies to all our brothers: after seeing the dreams and states they have seen, it is not very appropriate for them to get up and tell them all around; only after telling their masters, and if the masters say, "Tell this dream to your brothers," may they then tell it. "If the dervish says he sees what he imagines, he is said to have 'psychological' problems; if he says he does not see, he is a 'liar'; if he says he sees, he 'cannot keep a secret'—isn't that how it goes?" What a dervish imagines is imagination; that is not a dream. Only the people of this path know this. Does a dervish see what he imagines in a state (hal)? Yes. He cannot see in his dream what he imagines. Otherwise the whole ummah, all the dervishes, would imagine the Prophet (peace be upon him) in order to see him in their dreams, but they cannot see him. So it turns out that not everything imagined is seen in a dream. Can it be seen in a state? Yes. Can that person imagine something and take his imagining for a state? Yes. That is known to its people. He comes and tells his master, saying, "I saw it like this, I saw it like that," and if his master is truly qualified in this matter, he understands that it is a product of imagination. Why? In every state and every dream there are symbols pointing to its authenticity. Those symbols are 'ilm ladunni. Not every sheikh, not every master, not even some of those within the circle of the saints has this knowledge. For it is knowledge reserved only for perfect murshids, or for those who have been spiritually granted the science of dreams; even they may fail to get to the bottom of some dreams. Why? Because they do not have 'ilm ladunni; they have knowledge of dreams, but not 'ilm ladunni. 'Ilm ladunni is a different branch of knowledge. Does every sheikh have it? No. Does every wali have it? No. Every perfect murshid (murshid-i kamil) most certainly has it. That is why a person cannot see in his dream something he has imagined psychologically. Can he see it in his state (hal)? Yes. What is that? It is because he has confused the state (hal) with imagination. Can he see imagination as a state? Yes, and for that person it is not clear to himself whether it is a state or imagination; I had said that it is a mistake if he tells those around him, but if he comes and tells his teacher, then it is not a mistake. Look, failing to keep the secret here means telling those around him without his teacher knowing. He is trying to build a hierarchy for himself; he says to himself: come, brothers, look at what I see in my dream, bow to me; come, brothers, look, my state has opened, look at what I see in my state, gather around me. This is, in any case, one of the pitfalls of the path; it is a pitfall of the path for us as well, so if someone says he does not see anything, he is lying anyway. And a person in a disciplined community will tell his teacher that he has not seen anything, and the teacher will understand that he is saying he has not seen anything, and will then advise him gently. For example, now, through this question, all the brothers have learned that saying one has not seen anything is a lie. Of course our brothers know this, but now everyone has learned it once more. When they tell it to their teachers, or when they tell it to the person their teacher has permitted, they do not fall under the ruling of not keeping the secret.

In the investigations and research I have carried out: why is this seeing of states (hal) in vogue in the Rifa'i tariqa of Çorum only among the dervishes attached to Abdullah Efendi? I do not agree with this. I also met with the old dervishes; I met, even if briefly, with Yakup Efendi of Ankara, I met, even if briefly, with Mustafa Efendi of Karabük, I met, even if briefly, with Ali Efendi in Istanbul; and this was not brief: I met with Ali Akkül Abi in Sivas, and also in Sivas I was very close with Ahmet Turan Gümüş. Therefore I do not agree with the claim that states were not seen in the dergah of Hacı Mustafa Efendi of Çorum, that it was not that effective or authoritative. What I have met and what I have established are not in this direction: everyone would go to Hacı Mustafa Efendi of Çorum and tell him their dream and tell him their state, and there really were, and indeed there were, people who saw sound dreams and sound states. For example, Yakup Efendi, as far as I know, did not attach himself to Abdullah Efendi during his lifetime, and the reason he did not attach himself was: I did not see it in my dream. That is, this was the reason for his not attaching himself. Was he right? Yes. This was being discussed at that time, for example, that he had not attached himself. Again, for example, someone who heard it from his own mouth told me that Hasan Burkay Efendi went to Yakup Efendi and visited him with a view to asking him to join us or to become affiliated with us, and Yakup Efendi said: if we see it in our dream, in our state, then by all means we will join. He too was one of those who declared that they would join a given side if they saw it in their own dream, that is, who would decide on joining somewhere according to their own dream. And again, for example, when I was in Ödemiş, some of that person's disciples from İzmir took lessons from us; they have known me since that time. That person had come and said to me, join me, become my caliph, and I said, if I see it in my dream, by all means; if the Prophet (peace be upon him) commands me, by all means I will join you, I will have no difficulty in this matter. I said it so as not to hurt him, so as not to offend him. He stayed three days in Ödemiş; for three days we performed dhikr (zikrullah) every day and held lessons every day. Every day I said, there is no sign, there is no command concerning my joining. He said, you will see in three days, God willing, and he left. He left and never came again, of course, and we did not see anything either. That is why, for a person on the Sufi side, I think the dream is important and the state (hal) is important, and a person may not consider these alone sufficient; he may say, I also want an ijaza (authorization), this too is necessary; or a person may say, all I need is the ijaza; will he say that once I have the ijaza, it is enough? He will. That is why I believe that this seeing of states, or the seeing of dreams, was itself also effective in the dergah of Hacı Mustafa Efendi of Çorum; this is what I have heard, my investigation, my research. Afterwards I would like to point to something here; I am speaking in general terms: perhaps some sheikh efendis have doubts about themselves, which is why they stand cold toward states and dreams. They have doubts about their own sheikhhood, which is why they keep their distance from states and dreams. I am addressing them, I am addressing their brothers in the path: the dream is one part of the forty-six parts of prophethood. Whoever stands cold toward the dream is standing cold toward the mutawatir hadiths in which the Prophet (peace be upon him) declared it to be one part of the forty-six parts of prophethood. This is not right; may God forgive us. On this subject, Muhyiddin Ibn Arabi (may God be pleased with him) says: *Satan approaches a community in the state in which they are predominantly found.* How can one know whether Satan has a hand in what those who claim to have seen a state (hal) have seen? Everyone will go and tell it to his master, and if that master has this knowledge, he will know whether Satan had a hand in the state that person saw. One, two: there is a common belief of all the people of Sufism, of all of them. One: Satan cannot enter the form and likeness of the Prophet (peace be upon him), neither in a dream nor in a state. Two: Satan cannot enter the form and likeness of any of the prophets who came and went between Adam (peace be upon him) and Muhammad the Chosen (peace be upon him). Three: Satan cannot enter the form and likeness of Gabriel, Michael, Israfil, Azrael (peace be upon them) and the other angels. Four: in accordance with the hadith, "My Companions are like the stars; whichever of them you hold on to, you will find me," Satan cannot enter the form and likeness of any of the Companions. Five: he says, "I have left you two things; whoever holds fast to them will not go astray, he is on the right path: the Book of God, the Qur'an, and my Ahl al-Bayt (family)." In that case, Satan cannot enter the form and likeness of the Ahl al-Bayt either. By Ahl al-Bayt I mean our master Hasan, our master Husayn, and their descendants, and, as a chain (silsila), if a person's spiritual ijaza (authorization) as well as his material ijaza lies within this chain, then Satan cannot enter the form and likeness of those in the chain either. Six: it is the common belief of all the people of Sufism, such as al-Junayd of Baghdad, Sirri al-Saqati, Habib al-'Ajami, Bayazid al-Bistami. Abd al-Qadir al-Gilani, Ahmad al-Rifa'i, Ahmad al-Badawi, Ibrahim Dusuqi, Sheikh Abu al-Hasan al-Shadhili, Shah-i Naqshband Muhammad Baha' al-Din, Shah Mawlana Jalal al-Din Rumi, Haji Bektash Veli, Haji Bayram Veli, Uways al-Qarani, Mahmud Hudayi, the Khalwati, Jalwati and Ushshaqi pirs, and Muhyiddin Ibn Arabi as well: Satan cannot enter the form and likeness of these pirs. Now I come to this: I believe that Satan cannot enter the form and likeness of Haji Bekir Baba of Çorum, nor of Haji Ali Haydar Efendi, nor of the Çorum-based Haji Mustafa Efendi, and I continue: this is my own personal belief; I also believe that Satan cannot enter the form and likeness of my sheikh, the late Abdullah Efendi; this is my own belief. I believe that Satan cannot enter the forms and likenesses of these last four persons I have listed, Haji Bekir Baba, Haji Ali Haydar Efendi, Çorum-based Haji Mustafa Efendi and Abdullah Gürbüz Efendi; this is my personal circle. Now, this being so, all the people of Sufism are in agreement on this matter. For example, if we say that Satan can enter the form and likeness of İsmail Hakkı Bursevi as well, we technically break the rule of the path; or if we say that Satan can enter the form and likeness of Emir Sultan as well, then, so to speak, we break the pillars of the path within the Sufi circle. This is problematic. So, yes, does Satan approach a community from the right, in the state in which they are predominant? He can approach, but if there is a murshid-i kamil (perfect spiritual guide) at the head of that community, and if that community goes to their masters and tells them the dreams and states they have seen, then there is no such danger. That is why, that is why, it is not possible for me to agree with these people.

The saying "this state is seen in the dergahs of the murshid-i kamil" is quite fashionable, and for some reason those who see such things rely on it as evidence for themselves, though its source is unknown; I had heard this saying many times in this dergah. In Çorum there is no such saying, and they strongly oppose this saying.

There are such sayings in Çorum, and they come from the mouth of Çorumi himself. It is not right for those who do not have them to say "there is no such saying in Çorum" and thereby wriggle out of the matter. There is such a saying in Çorum, and everyone tells Çorumi (may God be pleased with him) both their dreams and their states. I still have an elder brother (abi) who studied with Çorumlu. Let me say this, then: he studied with Çorumlu and attended Çorumlu's sohbets, and together with those who attended Çorumlu's sohbets he attended sessions with Yakup Efendi, was very close with Mustafa Efendi, and kept going to them until both of them passed away, took part in their dhikr and attended their sohbets. For those who do not have it to say "there is no such thing in Çorum" is a slander against Çorumi (may God be pleased with him), and a slander against the Çorum dergah. I do not accept this, because there are still very old dervishes alive, and they too act according to their dreams, they too take instruction from their dreams or take initiation on that basis. For example, Yakup Efendi, it should have been Allawi*, was his name, took initiation with a sheikh in Mecca, and Mustafa Efendi of Karabük also took initiation with that sheikh in Mecca, and when they took initiation they declared that they had taken it after seeing him in their dreams. Mustafa Efendi of Karabük, before he passed away, was the Turkey sheikh of the Allawi* order; and before he passed away I suppose he assigned the duty to another person there, that is, Mustafa Efendi told him: from now on you will serve as sheikh on the path of the Allawi. What I heard on this matter is not something I heard with my own ears, but I know that it was so, which means that among them, in the dergah of Çorumlu. In that same dergah of Çorumlu, I also heard a great deal from Ali Akbil abi. They would take their dreams to Çorumlu Hacı Mustafa Efendi, they would take their states to Çorumlu Hacı Mustafa Efendi, they would relate them and tell them to him. For example, Ali abi also had a burhan for swelling and a burhan for fever; this is what he told me himself, that Çorumlu Hazretleri had given it to him. But I did not see his icazet for the swelling and fever burhan, and if I were to say that I saw it, I would not be telling the truth.


Abdullah Efendi's Statements About Kemal Efendi

There are videos currently on YouTube that contain negative statements by Abdullah Efendi about Sheikh Kemal Efendi of Kırıkkale, which do not reflect the truth. If they were published by your community, what would you advise about having them taken down, or at least about restoring those rights?

To my knowledge, Abdullah Efendi spoke about Sheikh Kemal Efendi of Kırıkkale in my presence both positively and negatively. He used to say the negative things on the basis of Çorumlu Hacı Mustafa Efendi; I have no knowledge of what is right or wrong in this matter. And as for Kemal Efendi, as far as I know there is no negative video from the time of Sheikh Efendi that we have shared. We have none. I have many videos of Sheikh Efendi. During the period of the 28 February, because the great majority of people were afraid, they gave me these videos and said, "You keep them," even if it would bring trouble upon my own head. Later, when the 28 February pressure eased, I returned them to their owners. But as far as I know, we have not published many videos related to Sheikh Efendi Hazretleri. The brothers who remained after Sheikh Efendi Hazretleri, saying desperately, "We are just as we were in Sheikh Efendi's time, we are continuing his path," are most likely the ones publishing them. As far as I know, we have no publication on this matter.


Opening a Good and a Bad Path

In a hadith it is stated: *Whoever establishes a good path in Islam will have its reward, and a share of the reward of those who follow that path will also be given to him, without any reduction in their reward. And whoever establishes a bad path in Islam will bear its sin, and a share of the sin of those who follow that bad path will also fall to him, without any reduction in their sin.* Furthermore, disregarding the Sufi principle "First rashad, then irshad," there are people who have not completed their seyr-i suluk, who do not know properly how a Çavuş is appointed, how a Naqib is appointed, how the Nuqaba and a caliph are appointed. What does it signify, in your view, that such people become "Ustad" as an intermediate form, without acting as a sheikh?

Ustad, sheikh, murshid, wali: in terms of content they all carry the same meaning, but abdal, wali, baba, dede, all of these are sheikhs in the language of their own dergahs. Therefore, calling someone ustad is not an intermediate form; it is the equivalent of murshid-i kamil. When ustad is said, it means a great teacher; it is the equivalent of murshid-i kamil. It is not the equivalent of wali either; it is an equivalent above sheikhhood, a degree above sheikhhood. Let me state this plainly: "He has himself called ustad and does not have himself called sheikh; because he is not a sheikh he has himself called ustad, he uses it as an intermediate form." They do not understand, they do not know, they are looking for a pretext to criticize. If they had asked, as you asked, they would have learned. If they had said, "Which is superior, a sheikh or an ustad?" The ustad is superior. "Which is superior, a wali or an ustad?" The ustad is superior. The reason? Because he is the one who trains the sheikhs. When ustad is said, he is someone who possesses seyr-i suluk. Not every sheikh possesses seyr-i suluk, nor does every wali, but an ustad possesses seyr-i suluk. Therefore ustad is not an intermediate form if it is used in its true meaning. But if it is used according to the principle of "turn it, scrape it, but let it not burn," then it is not right. So if someone is called "ustad" in quotation marks, that is not an intermediate form, provided it is used in the right circle and at the right point.


Ustad and the Training of Dervishes

If someone is a Sheikh or an Ustad, he trains dervishes skillfully, places the icazet in their hands, gives their burhan, and completes his duty... Eyvallah. While this has been the method handed down since our Hz. Pir Efendis, if from Abdullah Efendi onward a new path has been opened without icazet and solely with dreams of one's own making, then upon whom falls the responsibility of those who will come forward with this claim until the Day of Judgment? What is your opinion on this matter?

Abdullah Efendi Hazretleri came forward saying, "Yes, it was given to me in my dream"; or rather he had come forward, and then I became attached to him. I have not the slightest doubt about Sheikh Efendi's sheikhhood. As for someone who comes forward like this, saying it was given to me spiritually in my dream, and appears in public, whether he can gather dervishes in this way or not, I cannot say anything about that; whether people see that person in their dreams or not, I cannot say anything about that either. But are there such people at present? Yes, there are. They have no icazet, yet they act as sheikhs in Turkey. But Turkey also has its own particular difficulties. In Turkey now, for a person to say "I am a sheikh" is a crime. It amounts to acting against the well-known revolution laws. The moment someone takes this upon himself, takes it on and says "I am a sheikh" and gives someone an ijaza (authorization), that is his own affair; but it seems to me that undertaking such a thing carries a spiritual responsibility, and it is probably not within everyone's capacity. But is it my way? No. Did I take initiation (intisap)? Yes. Did I have a proof of my own? Yes, but what I say now to all the brothers is this: Go somewhere having seen it in your dream and take initiation. Let everyone see it in his dream, go and take initiation. This, and I say it in quotation marks, does a person have the right not to go by such a path? Yes, for example my elder brother did not take initiation, nor did my brother's friends. What they said was this: Hacı Musta Efendi of Çorum did not give Abdullah Efendi any ijaza; in fact, what they knew, and what I also know, is that he did not give ijaza to anyone. This is what Yakup Efendi said, this is what Mustafa Efendi of Karabük said, this is what Ali Abi of Sivas said. That is why, for example, those I know, those I am acquainted with, did not take initiation from among the dervishes of Hacı Musta Efendi of Çorum. Was that their right? Yes. Upon whom does the sin fall? It falls on those who set out on such a path; the sins are upon themselves. But the second sin, I suppose, also lies with those who go there without having seen him in a dream, without having any spiritual proof in hand. There are also many things that are not spoken about in Turkey, that is, concerning those who act as masters without an ijaza, those who have an ijaza and those who do not. If this were discussed clearly and put plainly in the open, truly great troubles would arise, especially among the people of the tariqa. Since I do not describe myself as one of the people of the tariqa, I keep myself outside of this trouble, and the reason is this: I am one of those who reject that there is a tariqa in Turkey, or that there are tariqas. I have always said that there is no tariqa in Turkey; let no one deceive anyone, let no one fool anyone. When one says tariqa, it has a school-level organization, a tekke (lodge), a zawiya, dress and attire, its various arguments and languages. Within the borders of the Republic of Turkey these were banned, closed down and cut off by the revolution laws. That is why I say this for all the tariqas: after the last revolution laws, there is in no way any tariqa in Turkey. We can say that Sufism exists in Turkey, we can say that tasawwuf exists, perhaps we can say that there are Sufi movements like those at the time when Sufism first emerged. How much of these Sufi movements has a technical discipline and how much does not, how much has an ijaza and how much does not, these are separate subjects of discussion. For example, I know that the last sheikhs of the Gümüshanevi line, those who came after Zahid Kotku (may God have mercy on him), have no ijaza. I may be mistaken, but I know that they have no ijaza. I will say this here, and the earth will shake: I know that even Mahmud Efendi has no ijaza. For example, when Mahmud Efendi passes away, to whom will he give an ijaza? He himself has no ijaza; to whom will he write and give an ijaza? Or, these are interesting subjects: are there dergahs in the east and southeast where ijaza is given from father to son, or given to brothers? The answer: There are. That is why these matters in Turkey are not matters that everyone can bear or speak about. Those with ijaza, those without ijaza, those with ijaza, how did they obtain the ijaza, did they complete their seyr-i suluk (spiritual journey), was it from father to son, is he a chair sheikh (kürsü şeyhi), a teaching sheikh (ders şeyhi), or was the ijaza given so that our dergah may continue, what kind of ijaza is it, what is its measure, what is its rule? Or there is also this: there is also the buhran (spiritual crisis/ecstatic state) in that, my dear brother. A buhran is not proof that someone is a murshid-i kamil (perfect spiritual guide). The fever buhran, the swelling buhran, the sword buhran, the oven buhran are not proof that that person is a murshid-i kamil. Being a murshid-i kamil is a different category, a different circle; sainthood (wilaya) is a different category, a different circle; being a sheikh is a different category, a different circle. So those who attack Abdullah Efendi (may God have mercy on him) so unjustly, saying he had no ijaza, can they do the same to Mahmud Efendi? Or can they do it to the dergah of Mehmed Zahid Kotku (may God have mercy on him)? That is, those who cannot say a word to those places, who cannot criticize those places on this matter, when it comes to Abdullah Gürbüz Efendi of Nevşehir, they gather all their tanks, cannons and rifles and fire ruthlessly. Isn't this injustice? Then let them sit down: all the sheikhs in Turkey who are without ijaza, let them discuss the measure; then let everyone sit down: of the sheikhs who claim to have an ijaza, how many have passed it from father to son, from grandfather to grandson? Let them discuss that too. I am not talking about the authorizations (ijaza) that pass from father to son, from grandfather to grandson, or those sheikhly authorizations given so that the dergah may continue, so that the path may continue. I am not talking about someone who has no sohbet, who cannot put two alifs side by side, who does not have enough fiqh knowledge even to sustain himself, let alone to be effective and authoritative enough to teach his dervishes fiqh, creed, kalam, hadith, or the subtle matters of Sufism, but who holds the outward authorization. When people speak about such cases, those who are spiritually qualified in this work will remain under suspicion. These things are not right. In that case everyone will sit down, everyone will put his own hat in front of himself, and he will say: what am I doing, where am I, what work am I occupied with? He will settle his own account himself and he will say: how just am I? People whose names no one could even dare to utter sit at the head of great dergahs, and at the head of dergahs without ijaza, and when it comes to the end you are told: be silent, say nothing, do not say anything, let not a single word come out of your mouth; but when it is Abdullah Efendi Hazretleri, attack him with tanks and rifles. That is not right, that is not justice. Look, it is not right, and it is not justice. A saint must be just, a perfect murshid must be just, a sheikh efendi must be just, a Sufi must be just. Then the measure will be spoken of, the measure will be spoken of. I say this here because a name was mentioned: the measure will be spoken of. Here, when we say that from Abdullah Efendi onwards, without ijaza and only through dreams of his own making, as far as I know, I say, may Allah protect me from ill opinion, may the Almighty protect me, I am open to making mistakes in this matter, but if Mahmut Efendi's ijaza exists in writing, if the written ijaza, the sheikhly ijaza, of Mehmet Zahit Kotku Efendi Hazretleri exists, then there is nothing to say and I take all my words back; but if it does not exist, then why do these people only direct words against Abdullah Efendi? That is the other side of the matter. Yes, I agree that no one should act as a sheikh without ijaza, I agree that no one should set out saying "I am a sheikh," that is right, that is right, so be it; but this too is a reality: if people see someone in their dream and want to go and attach themselves to him, and if that person has such a state, then what will that person do? There is this side to the matter as well.

How can those who have been masters for so many years explain why they have no naqibs or nuqaba' of their own training, or no caliphs, beside them, why none came to maturity, or why they were not able to bring anyone to maturity? It may be that no one matures; it may be that they cannot raise anyone. Not being able to raise someone is one thing, and someone not maturing is another matter. There is no rule that someone must necessarily mature; if no one matures, that person's dergah closes and his path closes; if someone matures, that person's dergah and path continue. Well, someone has not matured; when he has not matured, what will that person do? Will he give sheikhhood to one who has not matured? That is where it comes in: in that sheikhhood, in that ijaza, it becomes a matter of "let the path continue, let this work continue." It turns to that: whether he matures or does not mature does not matter, let the path continue, let the visitors keep coming, let us make the son a sheikh, and even let us make his son who will be born a sheikh, and even his son who will be born a sheikh, let it pass from father to son, from father to son, from father to son. That is how it is done too; they do that as well. After all, the sheikh is already determined there, so maturing has no meaning. What would he do by maturing? For example, there are dergahs like that, where the whole silsila passes from father to son, from father to son, from father to son. I am not belittling this, I am not belittling this, but does such a thing exist? The answer: It exists. Do they have ijazas? The answer: They do. I am not saying this to belittle anyone, but for a person to mature is truly not an easy thing. I do not claim that I have matured, but I do claim that it is not easy for a person to mature. It does not happen by sitting in a corner like this, it does not happen by counting money in a corner like this, it does not happen by never leaving the house, never leaving the city. To mature in this age is truly difficult: you will pass beyond the world, you will pass beyond women, you will pass beyond wealth, rank and position, it is not easy; and you will serve beside a sheikh, which is not easy, and you will serve for many long years, which is not easy. I look back, for example, at those who stayed with Sheikh Efendi: those who lasted the longest did not last long; a man would be worn out on a single journey, or worn out on a single trip, and could never again go beside Sheikh Efendi. You will take care over what you eat, you will take care over what you drink, you will take care over your sleep, you will take care over your lying down and getting up, you will take care over your dhikr, you will take care over your state; staying beside Sheikh Efendi was not easy. To someone who stayed beside Sheikh Efendi, he would say, for example, "Agha, what did you see in the cemetery?" Wherever there was a grave, Sheikh Efendi would stop there, immediately have dhikr of Allah performed, and right there he would ask the person next to him, "What did you see? What did he say to you?" So this was not an easy thing; or standing right beside Sheikh Efendi, standing in the front circle (halaqa), was not an easy thing. Sheikh Efendi would say, "What did you see, tell me." These things are perceived as if they were simple, but that dervish saw for himself that he had not yet matured. That person had been left at the point where, when the one who is going to present himself as a caliph says to him in dhikrullah, "What did you see?", that person stayed behind, but he was putting himself in the place of a caliph, for example, things like that. That is why being brought up to maturity is not an easy thing, truly it is not an easy thing: everyone picks at you, everyone shoves you around, everyone has something to say; what befalls you does not befall the cooked chicken. To be patient with these things, to put up with these things, to endure these things, to withstand these things is not everyone's job. That is why it is truly difficult to reach maturity. I do not see this as a fault in the sheikhs, that is, blame would also fall on Hacı Mustafa Hazretleri of Çorum, because from here, that is, as far as I know, in his last period Çorumlu Hacı Mustafa Efendi Hazretleri has no one whom he granted ijaza to, whom he raised, whom he declared to be a sheikh in his own right, for whom he held a ceremony and had a crown and a khirqa (cloak) put on; I know of no such person. Then, was there a deficiency in Çorumlu Hacı Mustafa Efendi as well? Something like that. May Allah protect us.

There are four seasons and there are all kinds of soil. When it is obvious that to grow, in every soil and in every season, fruits and vegetables of every kind, in visual beauty, taste and flavor, one must be an agricultural engineer, a farmer, a gardener who has acquired the knowledge of this craft, who has experience and a diploma; if, when it does not work out, when someone did not mature, it is said only that "you could not raise him, or you did not want to," what would you say?

If this person did not mature, if people do not, in their own way, dedicate their lives to this, you cannot make them dedicate it by force. How will you make them dedicate it by force? Now, the one who is trying to mature, the one who dedicates himself, we are already knocking him to the ground. I am not claiming that I have matured, but while I was traveling together with the Sheikh Efendi, I went bankrupt three times, and in all three of my bankruptcies, it was the dervishes standing closest to me who gossiped about me first. First the dergah gossiped about me. Nobody said, "Well, in which line of work did this man go bankrupt, where did he go bankrupt?" Nobody talked about that. The Sheikh Efendi passed away, my traveling with the Sheikh Efendi came to an end, and thanks be to the Almighty, my affairs were put in order. So it seems I was not a man without a working mind, I was not a man who did not know business; that is a separate matter.

Now, to be patient with that, to endure that, to put up with that is not everyone's job. The gardener is very orderly, fine, he must raise it everywhere, fine. Forgive me very much, the gardener is very orderly, but you are not raising flowers; a flower has no nafs, a plant has no nafs that would lead it toward the forbidden. This gardener example is not the right example. The olive tree has no nafs; Satan does not whisper into the olive tree; no woman comes to the olive tree and says, "I saw you in my dream, I want to be with you"; or nobody takes a box of money to the olive tree and says, "I love you very much"; or nobody comes and throws the money into the living room first and says, "Brother, take this money, I gave it to you as a gift for the sake of Allah," and then, after a year or two has passed, says, "When are you going to pay me back this money?"; nobody goes to the olive tree and weeps at its foot saying, "How this world pulls you, how do you wander about in this world, brother," and then, after two years have passed, comes to hate it; or you hoe around the base of the olive tree, you put manure into it, if it needs water you water it, and it gives you its olive fruit. But the human being, as established in the verse of the Qur'an, is forgetful, the human being, as established in the verse of the Qur'an, is treacherous, the human being, as established in the verse of the Qur'an, can come to a point lower than the animals. So illustrating this with the example of the gardener seemed a bit strange to me; it is not the right illustration. It is somewhat difficult to compare a human being with an olive tree. You understand the olive tree's language in its own way, you graft it at grafting time, you protect it, and it goes on its way. The human being is not like that: you graft him, he gets spoiled during the day; you graft him at night, his wife spoils him; you graft his wife, his boss spoils him; the world spoils him. You gather them all in dhikrullah, you bring them all together, you have them reconcile and forgive one another; while the man reconciles with his tongue, he scatters seeds of hypocrisy from his heart; he says, "My tongue reconciled, I did not reconcile." Whereas if he truly reconciled, and his heart there also confirmed his tongue, then in that dhikrullah he would pass through a veil of his own, or experience a spiritual state, or be granted a manifestation (tajalli) of the Almighty. That is why we are dealing with the human being. There is no greater savagery than facing the human being, and there is no greater wisdom and beauty than facing the human being. That is why saying "he did not mature" and tying this to gardening is not the right comparison; this is what I am trying to explain. That is, in lands where the forbidden is free, where the forbidden is open, where the forbidden is encouraged, you are trying to grow a rose in the middle of a swamp, and you are trying to protect it and keep it safe, but Satan and those who have become satanic attack from every direction the place you are trying to cultivate. You are trying to establish a garden of your own, and you are striving to protect that garden, to guard it, so that people may flourish and grow there in that garden that is like a garden of paradise; and everyone attacks it: the politician, the mayor, the lawyer, the judge, the prosecutor, the journalist, this one and that one, so-and-so's child, with spoiled milk, spoiled blood, a spoiled sex and lineage, every person who has turned into a devil attacks the place. Satan corrupts all of their hearts, Satan veils all of their eyes, and all of them, if one may put it so, have become Satan's servants and slaves, and they attack with all their strength. Under so many tanks, cannons, rifles, so much fire, you are trying to teach people something; and you pick up the one whose foot has slipped, you set the arm of the one whose arm is broken, you put back the eye of the one whose eye has been gouged out, you repair the tongue of the one whose tongue has been ruined. Is there a garden in this world that can raise someone, in which someone can flourish and grow? And for someone who is striving to grow like that, do people think, "Here a rare flower is growing, here something rare, a precious antiquity is coming into being; let us support it, let us give it strength, let us protect it in this regard with our prayers, with our spiritual attention, with our effort"? Is that what people think? People wait for the smallest flaw of the people of Sufism, of the Sufi: the media, the press, the state, the police, the police station, the judge, the prosecutor, and those who appear to be on your side, who appear to be one of your own, and this is the most painful part, all of the Muslims attack you. Right now we are trying to explain our purpose to Muslims who cannot understand what they read. They read and they do not understand. We are among a community that thinks insulting people on Twitter is Islam, that thinks speaking against people's honor, dignity and reputation with fake accounts on Twitter is waging jihad. That is why, when it is said, "He could not raise anyone," I do not accept it. Yes, I do not accept it. Why? Look, under so many attacks you are trying to protect your own life; under so many attacks you are trying to safeguard your brothers; where are people going to grow? A man is thinking about the bread he will take home in the evening, a man is thinking about the job he will go to in the morning, especially if it is a young community; it is not a community made up of retirees. If it were a community made up of retirees, you would give him a task, he would recite fifty thousand tawhid and strive, saying, "I will grow"; but protecting those young people in their youth is difficult, so this example of the agricultural engineer is not a correct example. No. With the example of the agricultural engineer, it is not possible for us to treat people and trees or plants as the same; that is why, yes, it is very hard to grow and very hard to raise others, and, knowing that difficulty, those who have given their hearts to this and who stand in the midst of this work deserve to be applauded and supported. For someone to attach himself to a master, a sheikh, a perfect murshid, a saint, a dergah, whichever it may be, is itself a great struggle against the nafs; and to look down on those who have attached themselves, to treat people who have taken that bond with contempt, or to treat with contempt whoever it is who is acting as a sheikh somewhere, acting as a master, acting as a saint, acting as a murshid, in my view means not knowing how difficult this work is. It means not knowing the pain of this work, the grandeur of this work, what it is really up against. Let me put it this way: I am not saying this to belittle Anatolia, but in small places there may be people of this kind who do not see this grandeur, this hardship; they gather, they host one another, they perform dhikr of Allah, and they do not have such a concern. But I do not think those in the West are in the same position. Especially those who do not live off the dervishes, who do not set their eyes on the dervishes' money, who do not take pocket money from the dervishes, who do not set up a cushion and take pocket money for themselves beneath it, or rather who have a huge pair of shalwar trousers sewn for themselves, with pockets that reach down to the knees, and every blessed Friday, for everyone who comes, without taking money into their pockets, without expecting anything from people, without hoping for anything, set out for the sake of Allah, for the sake of Allah to try to explain the Qur'an, the Sunnah, and true Sufism to people: to treat such people with contempt, to look down on them, to see them as lacking knowledge, as not being effective and competent in this matter, seems to me like overstepping one's bounds. May Allah protect us. That is why, whether he has an ijaza or not, whatever the case, if a person, an individual, stands up in the middle of the public and acts as a sheikh, has set out on the path, and if he pays attention to the criteria I have mentioned, these criteria I have mentioned are very important, and chief among them is not turning his path into a means of gain; "Come, brothers, we will build a Qur'an course, soft hands into the pocket; come, brothers, we will build a dergah, soft hands into the pocket; come, brothers, these services are not easy, soft hands into the pocket; come, brothers, we will build a Qur'an course, soft hands into the pocket; come, brothers, we will build a complex here, soft hands into the pocket; come, brothers, our sheikh needs help, look, those who come and go eat and drink, soft hands into the pocket" — if, in quotation marks, none of this is being said, then yes, these things are important, because in the verse, in Surah Ya-Sin, it says: follow those who do not ask you for a wage. If that person is not turning his position and standing into a fee, if he set out purely fi sabilillah, for the sake of Allah, with the effort of teaching people even a single letter, then please let no one look down on them or treat them with contempt, and let them support them as far as their strength allows, and let them protect them in their absence as far as their strength allows, because they are men of Allah. They are people of Allah. That is how I describe Abdullah Gürbüz Efendi too, and that is why I do not consider this much attack on him to be right. We would be with him for eighteen days, for fifteen days, far from his home, far from his family: go and stay somewhere for two days, hold a sohbet there, a sohbet during the day, dhikrullah in the evening; stay three days, a guest stays three days at most; then on the fourth day set out on the road, then go, stay two days or three days where you arrive, again a sohbet for the women during the day, a sohbet for the men at night; go a few more days, a few more days, a few more days. We would set out from Nevşehir and stay three days in Sivas, then a day or two in Malatya; first we would stop by Kayseri, hold a lesson in Kayseri during the day, and go to Sivas at night. He would rest at night in Sivas; the next day, a sohbet for the women during the day and a sohbet for the men in the evening; the next day the women would again gather in another place, group by group, and hold a sohbet there, and in the evening again a sohbet for the men in a separate place; from there we would make a one-day trip to Malatya and come back, then go on to Tokat. We would stay three days in Tokat; from Tokat we would go to Ankara and stay three days in Ankara; from Ankara we would cross over to Istanbul. In Istanbul he would stay at his daughter's house; I would go back to Bursa. He would stay three days in Istanbul and come to Bursa; there were many times when he stayed more than three days in Bursa. He would stay in Bursa three days, four days, five days, six days, and he never let a single day pass empty: women during the day, men in the evening. From Bursa we would go to Izmir. He would stay a day or two in Izmir, a day or two in Bayındır, a day or two in Ödemiş; from there I would pick him up and take him to Konya by way of Afyon; sometimes from there we would go to Isparta. He would stay a day or two in Isparta, then go on to Konya; sometimes I would turn back from Konya, and sometimes he would stay two days in Konya as well and we would go to Nevşehir. Show me one brave man who could endure this. Show me a brave man who would go along beside that sheikh, and show me a sheikh who would be able to endure this. Now, speaking behind Abdullah Efendi's back is a free-for-all, a free shot; now, claiming to be his continuation is a free-for-all too. People who did not have even three persons perform dhikrullah in the district where they lived later said, "We are on his path." Shame on you! You cannot follow his path. Why? His path was not a road that everyone could walk; while everyone sat around seeing dreams in their own way and attaching themselves to someone, he was out on the roads. Right or wrong, I am not debating that; I look at the service he rendered. I look at the service he rendered. He would go to Antalya, yes. I travelled around a large part of Anatolia with him. I claim that no one, including the children in his home, his wife (may Allah have mercy on her, his wife passed away), his daughters-in-law, his relatives and his children, knows better than I do what he went through and what he did not, what he thought and what he did not think. I claim that no one knows better than I do what he feared and what he did not fear, what grieved him and what did not grieve him. That is why it is not right to say "Abdullah Efendi had no ijaza," nail him to the cross and stone him. You will sit in a corner producing words, chanting the refrain "he had no ijaza," on and on. Yes, technically he did not have one, true; then go and say that to Mahmut Efendi too. Go on, say that to Esad Coşan too, go on, say that to Esad Coşan's son too. Look, I am mentioning names. Not in the sense that they are bad; I am speaking to those who attack Abdullah Efendi: have some fairness! Look, have some fairness; it is not right. And there are people I know, may Allah bless them, sheikhs with ijaza, who did not do even a tenth of what he did, and did not raise even a tenth of those he raised. In Abdullah Efendi's dergah, and I say this in the Sheikh Efendi's own phrase, there was one who conversed with the Prophet (peace be upon him). Again in the Sheikh Efendi's own phrase, in Abdullah Efendi's dergah there was a naqib al-nuqaba whom he had raised, who would interpret all the dreams and states. Again in Abdullah Efendi's own phrase, he had a naqib al-nuqaba who would see all the states of those who experienced states in the dhikrullah circle. While taking seven sound lessons in Abdullah Efendi's dergah, he had a naqib al-nuqaba who took lessons from the manifestation of light of the Nur-i Muhammadi, the Light of Muhammad (peace be upon him), pay attention here, pay attention here. Yes. The Prophet Muhammad Mustafa (peace be upon him) has two manifestations; not everyone knows this. One manifestation is his manifestation to the outward world, which is his prophethood and is connected with the duty of prophethood. This is the manifestation of Muhammad Mustafa to existence. His manifestation to existence. A sheikh may reach this point, and the manifestation (tecelliyat) that all sheikhs, or rather all the saints, have reached is this manifestation. But the Prophet Muhammad Mustafa (peace be upon him) has a spiritual manifestation, a luminous spiritual manifestation, that precedes this existence, and this is a state that belongs only to the perfect murshids (mürşid-i kâmil). Only perfect murshids can be clothed in this state, and only those who are perfect murshids know it; only those who are masters know it; only those who are masters, perfect murshids, are clothed in this state. The saints about whom the Prophet (peace be upon him) said, "Among my community there are saints who are equal to the prophets of the Children of Israel," are these saints. Therefore, those who speak ill of Abdullah Efendi's sheikhhood and of Abdullah Efendi's dergah will have to rinse their mouths and take a ritual bath (ghusl). They will rinse their mouths and take a ritual bath, and they will repent, and they will go to the head of his grave and repent. Those who attribute lies to Abdullah Efendi, who speak ill of Abdullah Efendi's being a perfect murshid, of his sheikhhood, and those who, afterwards, say "we are continuing on his path" and then talk all sorts of nonsense, all of them should go and repent at the head of his blessed grave; otherwise, spiritually, the two sides of their collar will never meet. Therefore, thank God, there were people raised in Abdullah Efendi's dergah, but whatever happens, what he told me on the phone was this: "Musta Efendi, my son, Hacı Musta Efendi of Çorum did not give it during his lifetime, and the dergah was scattered. I do not want the dergah to be scattered after I die. Together with Ahmet Turan Gümüş of Sivas, you declare your sheikhhood," he said to me. "Gather your friends and declare your sheikhhood." I said: "My Efendi, I cannot declare this; please forgive me." He said: "I will have someone else declare it." And he had it declared. So it means he had trained him. He held the naqib al-nuqaba (chief of the naqibs) and naqib ceremony of authorization (icazet), so it means he had trained him. Yes. It is not easy. I say this again and again: you can raise an olive tree. I have one on my roof; it came up by itself from a seed, it grows from the seed, I look after its water, and today I pruned it a little; it is growing, this olive tree. A human being is not like that. A human being commits treachery when you turn your back. A human being looks you in the eye, looks into your mouth, looking for where you might make a mistake so that he can catch you on it. A human being sells you where you should never be sold; a human being stabs you with a dagger where you should never be stabbed; a human being abandons you where you should never be abandoned. I personally stayed at the bedside of Sheikh Efendi in the hospital in Izmir for fourteen or fifteen days. There was an Oktay with me. In fact, Oktay was someone who saw with his own naked eyes the bond between Sheikh Efendi and me; they can go and ask him. He called Oktay "my hospital friend," he called him "my fellow in fate," and he said all kinds of things to me in the sense of friendship. And at that time we saw—I do not talk about these things at all—at that time I saw who the true child was, who the true dervish was, who sold what and where, who left what and where. The days of the surgery were separate days for us. Those who want to learn will be kind enough to find Oktay's way; I cannot say anything as soon as we speak; they will go and learn from Oktay who sold Sheikh Efendi. Oktay is like the black box of airplanes for us. Yes, Oktay Başaran of Bayındır is like the black box of airplanes. Some of them wanted me to cut them down, to sell them out as well. He is my companion on the path, Nuri is my companion on the path, Harun is my companion on the path. Especially Oktay: when no one in Bayındır believed me, he was the one who believed me. When no one came by Sheikh Efendi's side or mine at the hospital, Oktay was the one who came every day, leaving his work and business, and ran around with me. The newcomers and the old ones do not know these things now, so, friends, they will go and learn them, and I always say it: they will not fall short in their respect toward these three people. Harun was still almost a child when he came to me, so with his mistakes, his faults, his errors, his shortcomings, they are mine. If he has a fault, it is mine; if he has a deficiency, it is mine. No one will criticize them, and no one will be able to say a word against them. In Bursa, Cafer, Adnan, Hüseyin, no one will say a word against them, and like Hacı Erkan, those old ones, when everyone in Bursa scattered, they did not scatter; when everyone collapsed, they did not collapse. From Bursa onward, they are like the black box of the dergah. Yes. I say to everyone, to all of Turkey and the whole world: they will come and learn from them what Sheikh Efendi said and did not say about Mustafa Özbağ. They will come and learn from them what he told them before he died, what he bequeathed, what he said. They will learn not from hearsay but from those who heard it directly from his mouth. Therefore, there are those who have been raised, thank God. There were those who were raised in Sheikh Efendi's time, and there are those being raised now, thank God. I am not saying that no one has been raised, and I do not take this upon myself. There is no rule that a dergah has not raised anyone just because it has no caliph. Dear friends, we are not growing mushrooms, we are not raising human beings like that. We do not pull mushrooms out of the hollow of a tree. If you see this as making a greenhouse, putting two saplings in it and growing them, you are mistaken. The dust on my little finger would be too much for such gardening. The dust on my little finger would be too much for such gardening. Raising human beings is the hardest profession in the world.


Is It the Number of Dervishes or Their Quality?

Is it better to have a great number of dervishes, or is it right to take on only as many chicks as you can look after and raise? A broody hen sits on only as many chicks as she can hatch. Quantity or quality? Why are you taking on so many brothers and sisters in the path? And it is now known by everyone that you have no worries about making a living, either? Your brothers and sisters cannot reach you; they come by appointment, your phone is constantly busy, some say they call and you don't get back to them for days. What can you say about this situation?

It is not right to compare a perfected murshid, a sheikh, a saint to a broody hen. The broody hen's capacity is fixed: she is a mother hen, she tends her chicks well, you put ten or fifteen eggs under her, but a young hen you let sit on five or six. That is a separate matter, but a master, a sheikh, a saint does not look at it like that. Allah does not burden you with a load you cannot bear. If a man has seen him in his dream and has come, will you say to him, "Shall I not give you lessons?" The man has seen him clearly, vividly in his dream, and says, "I will take lessons." What will you say to him? Will you say, "My capacity is only this much"? In that case they would not even give you a sheep to tend on the mountain. If you add one more sheep to your five sheep, you end up handing it over to the wolves and the birds. If Allah gives someone knowledge from His own knowledge and wisdom from His own wisdom, and people see him in their dreams and come, then it means you will be able to look after them, since that many come. If you were not going to be able to look after them, would they come? It means they have spiritual provision, which is why they come; if they had no provision, would they come? The table is wide, praise be to God, because the table is not mine. Since this is a question that concerns me directly, I took it upon myself. The table is the table of the Nur-i Muhammadi (the Muhammadan Light), the table of the Muhammadan Light that existed when nothing existed. That is why the table is wide, it has no end or edge, and there is still much empty space that I can see. There are still those who have spirituality but do not yet have the outward, so thanks be to the Almighty (Allah), we are thinking of enlarging the dergah, we are thinking of moving to a bigger place, we are thinking of establishing a bigger place. Why? There are still many who will come. So let those who are here hold their places firmly, and let those who come later not push the others aside and sit there themselves; let them take care of themselves. The number of dervishes, many or few? This is not a matter of reason, my brother, nor a matter of mathematics. They say, "Speak according to your means." Your money is enough to buy fifty loaves of bread, you buy fifty loaves, you invite fifty people. That is what you think outwardly, but if a thousand come, the One who will provide for them is Allah. That is why there is no material plan in this work. When we first invited the late Sheikh Efendi Hazretleri (may Allah have mercy on him) to Bayındır, I also said to the zakir of Tire: Brother, our situation is not much, our house is not large, we are poor and humble people, brother, let ten people come with the Sheikh Efendi, and I will gather fifteen or twenty friends from Bayındır so that they too may establish closer contact with the Sheikh Efendi. Fine, fine, we agreed. May Allah have mercy on her, my mother said, "I don't want a crowd of men in the house," and off she went to her mother's house, and she didn't cook any food either. No, at that time we had no money or anything at all, so with what strength I had, I bought two kilos of dried beans and two kilos of rice. There was a friend, a cook, who came to the lessons, married, from our neighbourhood. I went to him and asked: would you cook these as beans and rice pilaf and bring them to the house? I will bring them, he said. Nuri, may Allah be pleased with him, even brought baklava and yoghurt. We were thinking at most twenty people would come, and by restaurant calculation we said two kilos is enough for all of them, because that is how it is figured in restaurants: two kilos of dried beans makes twenty portions, and two kilos of rice makes twenty portions. In my own reckoning I said it would be enough, because we had invited twenty or twenty-five people. We had Hacı Saim in Tire, a big old three-oh-two left over from the late Musta Efendi, parked outside, and people kept getting out, kept getting out, kept getting out. After that there was a Ford minibus, belonging to Ali from Manavgat; he had filled that minibus, and people kept getting out, kept getting out. After that, with private taxis and with this and that, the people came in such numbers, Allah, Allah... Neither the table nor the spoons nor the forks would be enough, it was impossible. Behind our house at that time there was something like a small kitchen, you couldn't even call it a kitchen, the food was there; there were a few tablecloths, and as for spoons, if there were fifteen or twenty spoons, that was all. I took charge of the food. Sheikh Efendi had had a dhikrullah performed, may Allah have mercy on him. I took charge of the food, and with every ladleful I was reciting the basmala, putting in "Bismillahirrahmanirrahim," I just kept on doing it, while Nuri and Oktay were serving it out. People ate and left, ate and left, ate and left. At one point Oktay came and said, "Brother, what is going on?" I said, "Oktay, be quiet, I don't know what is going on either, be quiet." They kept serving, because they knew the meal consisted of two kilos of dried beans and two kilos of rice. Everyone ate and left, ate and left, ate and left, and Sheikh Efendi had not yet eaten. Then he said, "Musta Efendi, my son, is everyone done?" I said, "Yes, Efendi, everyone has eaten and gone." He said, "You sit down and eat too," and we sat down and ate. I did not see him eat; I did not see him sit at the table. That is why I regard it as though he did not eat. Then we put something on a plate for him, and he ate that too. After that my sister's fiancé arrived. I said, "My God, where did he come from now?" We set the table for him as well, and put dessert out for him too. "Musta Efendi, is there no dessert?" He knows I don't like it. "There is, Efendi." "Musta Efendi, put out the dessert." So we put out the dessert, baklava now, and there was enough for them too. He takes it, sticks the fork in like this and brings it to Sheikh Efendi's mouth. I got irritated; I said to myself, why is he doing this, it is bad manners, this is not right. Sheikh Efendi did not want to refuse him, and he fed him and so on, and he too, he too was filled. The last word was this: "Musta Efendi, my son, is there any food left?" I said, "There is, Efendi." "Tell your mother as well, let your mother eat it," he said. "As you command, Efendi." We left. Now, if these matters had been a matter of reason, two kilos of rice and two kilos of dried beans would not have been enough for these people; about a hundred people ate that day. These matters are not a matter of reason; they are a matter of the heart, a matter of spirituality, so I cannot tell how many chicks they will give. Those who knew and loved one another in the world of souls know and love one another in this world as well. I take this matter even further beyond that, that is, before the world of souls was even created, in the manifestation of the Light of Muhammad (Nur-i Muhammadi), however many dervishes were appointed to a perfected murshid (murshid-i kamil), to a saint (wali), they come and receive their share. And this is not mathematical, such that you would attend only to as many people as you are able to; this is spiritual. A man sees it in his dream, which is why the dream is important. Our brothers see their mistakes in their dreams; our brothers see in their dreams where they went wrong. Their masters warn them in their dreams and guide them in their dreams, even if it be America or Canada. The man in Canada sees it in his dream, what am I to do? The man in Brazil sees it in his dream, what am I to do? The man in Argentina sees it in his dream, what will you do? Will you say, "You cannot have seen it"? I don't know the language, I don't know the tongue, and he says: you spoke to me in the language of Brazil. Inwardly I say, if only I knew the language of Brazil so that I could speak to that man. Allah makes him speak. So, "cluck cluck, chicken", yes, you put in as many chicks as would be enough to lie down on, fine, I accept that, but no one other than Allah knows the capacity of the saints, of the perfected murshids, of the prophets. Who is the insolent one who will set a capacity limit for Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa? Who is the insolent one who will set a capacity limit for the saints of Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa? These people probably watch too many American films. They probably regard ordinary Sufism as something mathematical, like an equation, like two times two makes four. In Sufism two times two does not make four; Sufism is something different. Quantity or quality? The one who will decide this is Allah. Who will decide this? A person, in his own way, runs things with his reason; he is a sheikh, he runs things with his reason, runs things with strategy, he calculates and weighs things; he can run things that way, so in his own way he says, what are you going to do, my dear, with a crowd, you and I and our boy are enough. Well, you be content with that. He acts according to his reason. "You, I and our boy, three hundred, five hundred people, we are precious," he says, and that is right, may Allah increase his worth. If this matter is spiritual, if people see it in a dream and come, who will set a capacity limit for it? Who will say that the limit should be kept at a fixed number? This is idle talk. Why do you take on so many ikhwan? I am not taking on anything. By ikhwan what is meant is brothers. That is a separate matter, they are all my brothers, but up to this day, since Sheikh Efendi passed away, I have never said to anyone, "Come, take lessons from me." Let one person say that I told him, "Come, take lessons from me." That person sees a dream, interprets his dream, and I even say: if you had asked me about this dream in my sheikh's lifetime, I would have told you that you need to take lessons. Yes. I am not someone who has set out to gather dervishes; I say this for my own nafs, may Allah protect me from that. We have not set out to gather people like that. I have never yet said to anyone, "Come, take lessons," no, never. All my friends and brothers know my word: Friends, whomever you see in your dream, go and take initiation with him; indeed, those who wish to leave their lessons may leave them and go, but if they leave and go, there is no return for them afterwards, know this too, I say. Therefore, whoever has come, I say my Lord has sent him, upon my head and eyes, I say, and I will never rise up and show any unwillingness toward him. It is now known by everyone that you have no worries about making a living, isn't it? Dervishes, my livelihood was never a worry, may Allah protect me from that. Up to this day, I am fifty-nine years old, and I have eaten from the sweat of my brow. I am still working, I am still a taxpayer, I still buy and sell real estate, cars and so on in my own way, I provide for my own sustenance myself, my business is my own; and so that this would be known, even though friends said "don't do it, don't bother," I even published my tax certificate, I said I am a taxpayer. I am a Bağ-Kur retiree by a decision of the Court of Cassation. I am still working, still a taxpayer, still buying and selling according to my strength; to this day I have never asked a single kuruş from any dervish brother, nobody can say "you asked this for your own nafs," or "you asked this for the dergah," or "you asked this for such and such." I do not open my mouth. If my own financial strength is enough for something, I undertake it; if my financial strength does not suffice, I say nothing to anyone. The Prophet (peace be upon him) borrowed even from a Jew, and he borrowed from Muslims; there have been times when I borrowed and times when I lent, there have, and that is fine, but apart from that I have nothing. So this saying, "It is now known by everyone that you have no worries about making a living," is a little insinuating; I do not take it upon my own nafs. There may be some among the dervishes who live off others; I never approve of it; there are those who take money from dervishes, but it is not my way. It is not my way. I am a person who is in love with his own freedom. As for taking pocket money from a dervish brother, if the Almighty (Allah) brings a person to that state, he takes it, and there is no problem in that, but may Allah protect me from it; He has protected me until today, may the Almighty (Allah) protect me from now on as well, and may the Almighty (Allah) grant me death in this state. When it was said, "you have no worries about making a living," I saw this saying as somewhat overstepping the bounds, may Allah protect us. "Your brothers cannot reach you, they come by appointment, your phone is constantly busy" — brothers can reach me whenever they want; every Thursday in Bursa I am a person who gives an open lesson to everyone, to the public. After the dhikr of Allah is finished, according to my strength, if my health permits, I sit there, and everyone comes in turn, and whatever they will discuss they discuss, whatever they will talk about they talk about, whatever they will tell they tell. Whoever cannot reach me cannot reach me because of their own laziness; whoever cannot reach me cannot reach me because of their own fuss and flurry. We are in a place where even a child can find us. As Ahmet Kaya said, a child finds us, and if that child wishes, he can shoot us; we have no protection, we have no private official chauffeur, we have no private secretary; on Thursdays we sit like a Turkmen chieftain and remember Allah, and everyone who comes comes up to us, right up under our nose, and tells whatever they will say, whatever they will tell; and on Saturdays, up there at the center of the Sufism foundation (tasawwuf foundation) — I no longer go to the tekke now — I am at the center of the Sufism foundation, I am there on Saturdays too, and everyone can come whenever they like and meet me there; and on Thursdays everyone knows my office is open on this matter, whoever wishes can come on Thursdays; he may come once and turn back and come again; if there are guests inside, if someone is meeting me, he can meet me; even today, even during the coronavirus period, I never interrupted the Thursday meetings, the office was always open, but I told my friends, protect yourselves. I have no concern about protecting myself; I told them, you protect yourselves. It was open. So they say they cannot reach me — that is just talk. My phone is open twenty-four hours a day, seven days a week. Now, this brother here should not be embarrassed; I am not saying it to embarrass him: he called me at two forty-eight at night. The one who called at two forty-eight is from Şırnak; I wrote back "Peace be upon you, are you calling at two forty-eight?" with a question mark. So my phone is on at two forty-eight too, and I can answer at two forty-eight too. My phone number is, more or less, with all the brothers. The one who says "in my dream a bird landed on my branch" calls at four o'clock. I do not accept that. Absolutely, I do not accept it in this matter. That is why, if someone says, "I cannot reach you," he needs to obtain a release of rights (halal) from me. Look, he needs to obtain a release from me. Why? My phone is on, my phone is on twenty-four seven. Even though I know the harm it does to the phone, they tell me, "Don't keep the phone on the charger." My phone is always on the charger. Why? Because it is on twenty-four seven. My phone lasts a year; at most it lasts two years, and then the phone is wrecked. Why? From too much talking, too much conversation, too much work, the phone works a great deal. And let no other message come out of this, like "Oh, he is saying his phone is like this, so let's buy him a new phone." It is not like that. I buy my own phone, alhamdulillah, I have no difficulty. So, "they say they cannot reach me": I do not accept it. My dear brother, if he wants to reach me, he will reach me. If people reach me from Antalya, from Manavgat, from Mersin, from Brazil, from Belgium, from America, all the way to Australia, then he too will reach me, my dear brother, if he wants to reach me. Even people whose language I do not know reach me, and if they send me messages in English, I have them translated through Google Translate, or by those whose English is good, and I write back to them. Every day there are at least twenty, thirty friends who tell me their dreams in messages. I have no discomfort; I am not saying this because I am bothered by them. I read every one of them, one by one, whenever I find the time. The time that I do not give to my wife and children, I give to my friends and brothers. And from my wife and children, too, I constantly ask for a release of rights. I say, "Forgive me my due, as a father and as a husband I cannot give you my full time." I say this, and I also tell them, "The days when we will have our fill of one another are not in this world," I say, yes. The days when we will have our fill of one another are not in this world. We have taken wing toward the other side. That is why I do not even have a private life, a private existence. On top of that, if some brothers, some people say, "We cannot reach you," they need to obtain a release of rights from me. They come by appointment, and that is not right either. I have told my friends this many times: do not make appointments with me, my psychology gets disturbed. No one asks me for an appointment. My psychology gets disturbed. When an appointment is requested, I say: come, my brother, if I am here, then see me, see me. If I am not here, then, apart from the front of the door, come back five minutes later and look again, come two minutes later. It is not so. "Your phone is constantly busy, what can I do?" Let them write a message. Right now, look, my phone is on, right beside me. He may fall ill, end up in the hospital, end up at the post office, end up here or there, something may befall him; some senseless man throws his wife out into the street, some senseless woman throws her husband out into the street, some senseless mother and father throw their child out into the street. As far as my strength allows, I try to reach all of them. I do not accept it. "I am calling," they say; there are those who say, "For days you did not call back." What can you say about this situation? My dear brother, he will call again. There is no such obligation that I must call back everyone who calls me. He will call, he will call again, he will call again. Am I going to call back everyone who calls? Where is there such a procedure, such a rule? Let him call again, call again, call again; I have no discomfort. No, it is not possible for me to accept these things.


Yad-i Sahih Bay'a and Giving Lessons Without Ijaza

What is yad-i sahih bay'a (valid pledge of allegiance)? Who can take the bay'a of the dervishes? If a sheikh who has not completed the suluk (the spiritual path) and has no ijaza (authorization) gives the yad-i sahih lesson, what can the dervish experience?

What is called giving the yad-i sahih lesson means taking from that person a very sharp, definite covenant, entering into a covenant. Yes, sheikhs can do this: a saint at the head of a tariqa, perfect murshids (spiritual guides) can do this; there is no problem in this. Who can take the bay'a of the dervishes? These can take it. They can perform the yad-i sahih bay'a. Sheikh Efendi, may Allah have mercy on him, had given this humble one permission to perform the yad-i sahih bay'a; he had said to me, "Musta Efendi, my son, you can give the yad-i sahih lesson." Now you will say, did I give it? No. I did not give it during my sheikh's lifetime either. If a sheikh who has not completed the suluk and has no ijaza gives the yad-i sahih lesson, what can the dervish experience? Trouble. That is, if he is truly a person without ijaza, and also has no spiritual authority or influence in this matter, then the dervish should not take the yad-i sahih lesson from him. Correct.


Changes of Names (Asma) in Seyr-i Suluk

After a dervish has begun his seyr-i suluk (journey on the path), what is the basis for acting on changes of the names (asma)?

There are two things: first, the dream the dervish sees; second, the dream or state (hal) the sheikh sees. These two affect each other. For example, suppose a dervish sees a dream that his lesson has changed in his seyr-i suluk, and tells it to the sheikh; if the sheikh has hesitation about it, he can himself also make rabita (spiritual connection) to him, to see whether this state exists or not. Even while the dream is being told, he needs to make rabita in such a case. If he made rabita while the dream was being told, if the symbols of the dream are correct and his rabita is correct, he changes that person's name (asma); there is no problem in this, and as for the changing of the name, let me put it this way, this is how we do it. First, that person sees it himself in his dream; second, if I see it, what I see, or if he sees it, what he sees. Sometimes, for example, he sees it in his dream, and I really do not like to do this. Sheikh Efendi (may Allah have mercy on him) did it — that is, he would not change a person's name (esma); only in his last years did he start doing so. The reason? Because a person whose name is changed collapses. "My son, we change their names and they fall," he said. Sheikh Efendi spoke the truth: when we really do change someone's name, he suffers a fall; an ego comes to him, a sense of self, a pride comes, and he says, "I have arrived at such-and-such a name." I do not keep people waiting easily. If it is right, or if it must be, then — as for those whose names I have not changed, it is not that he did not change mine, or that he wronged me; this is the training of a dervish. As they say, every brave man has his own way of eating yoghurt, and we too have our own way of eating yoghurt. Our intention is not to leave people untrained.


The Dangers When the Sheikh Is Not Perfected (Kamil)

What kinds of dangers await the dervishes if the sheikh is not perfected (kamil)?

If a sheikh is not perfected (kamil), it shows from every side that he is not. They say, "We attach importance to dreams" — and you are not perfected, which is why we do not attach importance to spiritual states (hal); you are not perfected, which is why. The people of perfection attach importance both to dreams and to spiritual states. "These are not very important; are our deeds based on dreams?" Then what are you reciting the adhan for, if deeds are not to be based on dreams? What kind of talk is this? If deeds were not to be based on dreams — the Prophet (peace be upon him) says that a dream is one part of the forty-six parts of prophecy — if deeds were not to be based on dreams, why did Ibrahim (peace be upon him) set out to sacrifice Ishmael? People are not aware of where their words are leading.


Esma Striking — Esma Pressing

What is esma striking (esma vurması) — esma pressing (esma basması)?

The people of Sufism say this in their own way; it exists in the tariqas. A person takes the name "Hu"; when he takes the name "Hu," he experiences a disturbance, and they say of him that the name has struck him, or a state of contraction (qabz) comes upon him, and this they call "the name pressed him." There is no such thing. Praise be to God. There is no one experiencing esma striking and no one experiencing esma pressing. It happens in the tariqas, in the sheikhs' dergahs — plainly and clearly. It does not happen, thanks be to God — let me indulge in a little shath (ecstatic utterance); let me have that much right to shath. It does not. Esma striking and esma pressing are not effective and authoritative like that chick-talk; in their dervishes, esma striking and esma pressing do occur. They give that name in their own way, and when they give that name, the weight upon him and the spiritual manifestations upon him do not pass through a filter; the Almighty (Allah) — if one may put it so — spirituality withdraws its hand and its hem from him, and in him esma striking occurs and esma pressing occurs. The name strikes him and the name presses him, and he even begins to say and do strange things. That is connected to the master at the beginning, yes. It has never happened — this humble one, for over thirty years now, since the time of Sheikh Efendi, when I was still a new dervish, Sheikh Efendi gave me that authorization (ijaza) verbally: you may take whichever lesson you wish, you may give whichever lesson you wish; to whomever you wish you may give whichever name he wishes, and you may take from whichever name you wish, you may also take your own name, he said. Look, in Sufism a station (maqam) is not taken; a name (esma) is taken. If you tell a man "you are a sheikh," he is a sheikh — so be careful when you say this. When you say "so-and-so is a sheikh," he is a sheikh; but you gave him the name "Hu," the man has fallen, you are training him, you look and he has fallen, and you say, "From now on you will recite the name "Allah," not the name "Hu."" This is what taking a name means. People do not know it like this. Why? They do not know the metaphysics of this path; they do not know the spirituality of this path. For example, in his dream he has recited the name "Hu," but in dreams there is symbolism; for that moment he rose to the name "Hu," while normally he has remained in the name "Allah." Someone who does not know this says, "You are in the name "Hu," recite the name "Hu."" The name presses him and the name strikes him — fine, so be it. That can happen, but if that person is qualified for it, he sees that the other catches momentary ascents. For example — I am giving an illustration now — at this very moment there are people in this dergah who have risen to the name "Haqq." At this very moment there are people in this dergah reciting the name "Haqq." I say this with great joy, thanks be to God. There is no esma striking and no esma pressing. People are not trained that way; there is no such thing. Thanks be to God, they are being raised — and not just one or two, among both women and men there are those who recite the name "Haqq," and among both women and men there are those who from time to time rise to the name "Qayyum." Now they will say, "For us dreams are not important, spiritual states are not important." We have brothers who meet with Gabriel (peace be upon him) — so where is it "not important"? It is important. While reciting their lesson, we have brothers who recite it together with the Prophet (peace be upon him), and with our masters Hazrat Abu Bakr, Umar, Uthman and Ali. Where is it that dreams are "not important" and spiritual states are "not important"? These people do not know Sufism; they do not know the Sufi path. Why? They are not effective, they are not accomplished, they have no spirituality. They have passed an ijazah over their hands: "We are authorized, by God, we are authorized." Let them produce a single dervish who gives lessons in that way, one who teaches like that. With proof and evidence, I mean spiritual proof and evidence. They say they will strike with the divine Names (asma)... Of course it strikes, and the Names slap people too, don't they? How? Plainly. It says, "You are not yet at this Name," and gives you a slap. This has never been experienced up to today. Has it been experienced in other places? The answer: yes, it has. If those who are not qualified give a divine Name, the Name strikes, the Name hits, the Names slap him. Why? Because the Name takes on a form; since it takes on the form of whoever it takes on, may God protect him. Therefore, if someone takes lessons from a master who is not perfected, these are the troubles he will experience while walking spiritually. But if it has come to this, they have already directed him to a perfected murshid, for they do not leave him there.


The Servants of the Divine Names (Asma Huddam) and the Murshid's Precautions

What is an asma huddam? When a divine Name is recited, what is the way the Murshid follows so that the huddams of the Names do not harm the dervishes?

If someone is a dervish of a perfected murshid, then yes, when different divine Names are recited as wird at different times and in different ways, they have their huddams. There can also be unbelieving jinn that appear like huddams, but these do not occur in the dergah of a perfected murshid, my dear brother. They do occur in the dergahs of those who are not perfected murshids, and yes, do they suffer trouble? The answer: they do. But this word of mine, this protection, holds for those who are bound to a master, to a perfected murshid, and recite only the wirds he has given. If a dervish says to himself, "I came to the Name Haqq, I said Haqq, Haqq in my dream, so let me now recite Haqq on my own," then a spiritual punishment comes upon him; that is what happens, it is a spiritual punishment. Why did you recite a Name out of your own head, while you were just sitting there? Are you a sheikh? Or else, changing a Name depends only on the master, or on the person the master permits. In the time of Şeyh Efendi Hazretleri, this humble one had the authority to change Names, let me put it that way. Now I have not yet given this to anyone in the dergah. On this point, if anyone's Name is to be changed, the master will change it. The brothers who listen to dreams are disciplined in this matter. They listen to dreams and they are gradually learning; they now say, "You will tell this dream to the master." The brothers tell me, they write to me, and if there is something that needs to be changed, I change it. That is why I always say it with emphasis: friends, do not change your lessons on your own, do not change your wird on your own. Do not say, "I found something here and there, in a book, on the back of a calendar leaf, such and such, say, if you recite Bismillahirrahmanirrahim seven hundred and eighty-six times at the time of the dawn prayer, this will happen." Sufis have no such things. Sufis do not practice Sufism in order to reach some worldly or otherworldly place or to possess something. We remember God for God's sake, not to arrive somewhere or to obtain something. "Let the trouble and calamity be lifted from me, let me recite this in such a way; let me be freed from prison, let me recite the basmala seven hundred and eighty-six times before the time of the dawn prayer." Sufis have no such things. Spiritual preservation and protection are lifted from those who do such things; this is not right. Did you become a Sufi somewhere? You did. Did you attach yourself somewhere and take lessons? You did. Your reciting a wird on your own out of your own head, your reciting a Name on your own out of your own head: no, my brother, it is finished. The end. The one who will change your Name and your wird is your master. In Sufism one does not say, "Master, may I recite this?" You recite whatever you were told. Do not say, "What if I recited this too?" My dear brother, we do not wish to hurt your hearts or offend you; we say: continue with your lesson. Continue with your lesson, continue with your wird, continue with your Name, that is all, it is that simple. Then after that there will be no slapping and no striking, and no huddam will come. Let me also tell you about huddams. There are huddams that are positive and huddams that are negative. Behind the negative huddam there is a group of jinn; it is a jinn, an unbelieving jinn. A huddam is not an angel like that, nor is it a human being; it is a separate form of being, let me put it that way. Our brothers have no business with huddams at all, none of them. Among those who have taken lessons from this humble one, up to today, not one has had a dream or a state of this kind, including the time of Şeyh Efendi. What is the way the Murshid follows so that the huddams do not harm the dervishes? For these matters they set up their own teachings in the tariqas; that is, one tariqa sheikh says to another sheikh, "If such a thing happens, you will give him this Name." Everything belongs to God, my dear brother; with us it is not like that. Up to today nothing has happened, praise be to God.


Shaqq al-Sadr and Sharh al-Sadr (the Opening of the Breast)

In which divine Name does shaqq al-sadr or sharh al-sadr occur?

We do not pay any attention to these expressions. There is no rule that the manifestations (tajalliyat) of such Names will be as people have written in books; the manifestations with us are not like that. So if there are those who apply more bookish methods, let them go ahead and apply them.


Names of God According to the Stations of the Nafs

What are the divine names (esmâ) recited according to the stations of the nafs, in order?

In terms of what is written in books, it begins with tawhid: La ilaha illallah, Allah, Hu, Hay, Hak, Qayyum, Qahhar, and so it goes on. This is bookish knowledge. And everyone tries to work out their own stations of the nafs from this, which is not right. Because it manifests differently upon each Sufi. I am telling you these things as knowledge, but for those who would take them and set themselves up as false sheikhs, I do not give my consent, let me say that from the start. Take a person, for instance: in terms of the stations of his nafs, his name is the name Hay, that is his station of the nafs, but the journey of his heart, his seyr-i suluk, is not in the name Hay; his heart's journey requires him to walk in tawhid. Within that plane of tawhid, the name Hay draws him. The sheikhs do not know this. That is why, when you are going to give someone a divine name according to the stations of his nafs, you tell that person: you will recite the name Hay, a hundred a day, two hundred a day, or whenever it comes to your mind you will recite the name Hay, but you will continue with tawhid, for example. This manifests differently in every dervish. Everyone who writes a book on these matters writes it according to his own experiences. Is it correct for him? The answer: it is correct, but it is correct for him. Is it valid for today? It is not; I say it clearly and plainly, it is not valid for today. The field in which each dervish is raised is a different place. The place where each dervish is struck is also different. One is very handsome, a fine strapping fellow, he has money, and women circle around him; another is a manager at some government office, an official, and things turn differently for him there; another has money, and the nafs strikes him in a different way; another is utterly poor, and the nafs strikes him differently. The manifestations of the nafs are different in everyone. That is why the manifestations of the divine names also manifest differently in different dervishes. To get up and say this name corresponds to this, that name corresponds to that, that is something bookish. I am not one of those who believe that Sufism can fit into a book or be attained through bookish knowledge. Otherwise someone would take a Sufi book and bring himself to perfection with it, and that is not possible. He will attach himself to a sheikh, go and sit at his knee, or, since I do not wish to use the word sheikh too much, he will find a master (ustad), sit at that master's knee, and surrender to him, saying: whatever you say, that I will do. That is how the work proceeds.


The Derivative Names of the Seven Names (Esmâ-i Seb'a) in the Journey of Suluk

What are the derivative names of the seven names (esmâ-i seb'a) in the journey of suluk?

Again, it is not possible to put this into a mold. That is, what they call the esmâ-i seb'a, the last name: that person is now approaching the last name, the circle of the caliph, and again it is not possible to put its derivative names into a book; it is not possible. Sometimes there are brothers approaching that point, and there are also women among them, for example; different rabitas are given to them, outside of the names, for instance. So making it bookish in this way is somewhat problematic.


The Breaking of the Heart and the Gaze of the Murshid

What can you say about the saying that the perfected murshids heal a broken heart (inkisar) with a single gaze?

That is correct. That is why we always tell the brothers, and the Sheikh Efendi used to say it too: once every forty days, a person should visit his master, see him, and the master should see him; he would say that the master will see him and he will see the master. I accept this. Certainly, if a person has a trouble, a grief, a problem, he should have contact with his master, and even meet him face to face. Yes, this is correct.


Intercession in the Grave and the Prophet's Warning

While the Prophet (peace be upon him) said, "O my daughter Fatima! Do not rely on the fact that your father is a prophet," how do you assess the claims of some sheikhs that they will help their dervishes in the grave, at the scale (mizan), and on the bridge (sirat)?

They may say such things; there are claims that there are people who say so, and they do say it. These are not things to be spoken of much. Can the Almighty (Allah) cause such a state to be experienced? The answer: He can, but to voice these things, to utter them openly in front of everyone, is not very pleasant.


Those Who Sit on the Sheikh's Seat and the Ahl al-Bayt

Under what conditions are those who sit on the sheikh's seat counted among the Ahl al-Bayt? Are they counted? What things are not permissible for those who belong to the Ahl al-Bayt?

Now, technically we might perhaps call everyone who sits on a sheikh's seat Ahl al-Bayt, but I am not one who considers that correct. Can he be counted? Technically he can be counted: can a person count a perfected murshid, a master, his sheikh, among the Ahl al-Bayt? The answer: he can, technically he can. Is there a basis for this in the hadith? Yes. The Companions ask, "O Messenger of Allah, when your Ahl al-Bayt become many, how will we recognize them?" He says, "Whoever holds fast to my Qur'an and my Sunna, that person is my Ahl al-Bayt." That being so, does a dervish have the right to say of his own master, because he holds fast to the Qur'an and the Sunna, that he is Ahl al-Bayt? Yes. Can he contemplate and think in this way? Yes. That is one; that is the outward (zahir) side of this matter. As for the inward side of the matter, there are those whom the Prophet (peace be upon him) called "my child" in a spiritual sense. If he said "my child" in a spiritual sense to a certain person, that person belongs to the Ahl al-Bayt. Let me say it as a humble faqir myself: I no longer look at that person's outward or inward. No, my dear brother, once he has said "my child" in a spiritual sense, nothing else is needed for him. It is not needed in my eyes. In my eyes he is of the Ahl al-Bayt both outwardly and inwardly; it is enough that the Prophet (peace be upon him) says of that person, "This is my child." The moment he says "my child," that person is of the Ahl al-Bayt. And when the Prophet (peace be upon him) says "my child" to him in this way, the other prophets in the spiritual realm, the other sheikhs, masters and pir efendis can no longer call him "my child"; they call him "our brother" instead. This is another subtlety. If a dervish, for example, in his dream (let me give an example) sees Abdulqadir al-Jilani and he calls so-and-so "our brother," it means that the Prophet (peace be upon him) has called that person "our child." Or if Rumi (Mawlana Jalal al-Din Rumi) calls a master or a sheikh "our brother," it means that the Prophet (peace be upon him) has called him "my child." For this is how it manifests spiritually: no one can any longer say "our child" to the one whom the Prophet (peace be upon him) has called "my child"; everyone calls him "our brother." And if the Prophet (peace be upon him) has called a venerable person "my child," that person is seen, in the spiritual realm, on his right. Let me put it this way: there are pulpits on which the sheikhs sit, and he does not sit there; he sits on his right. This is how he is seen in the spiritual realm; that is his manifestation there. What are the things that are not permissible for those who belong to the Ahl al-Bayt? The rights and rulings concerning this belong to that person himself. For someone who has reached this state, saying "he may do this, he may do that" and declaring his rulings is not within anyone's bounds, because he acts according to what comes to his heart. That is why we do not say anything like "he will commit this outwardly forbidden act"; it is nothing of the sort. But it is not he who decides what is to be done and what is not to be done.


This page is compiled from Mustafa Özbağ Efendi's answers to questions asked during his dergah talks about the silsila (chain of spiritual transmission), ijaza (authorization), caliphate (khilafa) and the method of the tariqa. The content is arranged in thesis format.