Sunday, November 15, 2026
OUR PATH IS THE PATH OF PROPHETHOOD
Mustafa Özbağ
Irshad & Tasawwuf · Official Site
al-Ghazali Talks·

Doubt and Truth | al-Ghazali Talks 14

Translated from Turkish. Original article (Turkish) →

1. Opening Supplication: «Raze Israel and Its Supporters to the Ground»

May Allah make your night blessed. (Amin.)

May my Lord make your day blessed. (Amin.) May He make your month, your year, your life blessed. (Amin.) May my Lord make all of us and the entire Ummah of Muhammad among those who know the truth as truth and falsehood as falsehood. (Amin.) May He make us among His servants who know the truth as truth and live it, speak it and cry it out, and who know falsehood as falsehood and strive (jihad) against falsehood. (Amin.)

Wherever Muslims are being oppressed, wherever the blood, the honour, the dignity and the self-respect of Muslims are being trampled underfoot, wherever people are being oppressed, wherever people's rights are being violated, may Allah take our revenge on all those who do these things. Amin. May He raze Israel and its supporters to the ground. (Amin.) May He grant freedom to the entire Ummah of Muhammad. (Amin.)

2. A New Topic for the Sohbet: «Imam al-Ghazali» — Imam al-Ghazali After Ijtihad

Today a new topic for our sohbet (spiritual discourse) will begin. Our brother Hakan, what was the topic? Was it ijtihad? Imam al-Ghazali. Eyvallah. So the topic is Imam al-Ghazali. Earlier you had said you would do a study related to ijtihad. So that is still ongoing, then.

Yes. As you know, "Breath" 1-2-3-4. The questions of that "Breath" series belonged to Brother Hakan. After that there was another set of questions concerning politics in Islam. That one too was connected with Brother Hakan.

And now the topic is al-Ghazali, it seems. God willing, we will talk about al-Ghazali. How many pages? There are roughly 6, 7, 8, 9 pages. 8 pages, God willing. That is why there is no Masnavi talk this evening. He had sent me a message during the day. Saying he would be a little late. And I said I would wait. God willing. Let us now start from the al-Ghazali end of things.

3. «One Who Does Not Doubt Cannot Find the Truth»: Imam al-Ghazali's Famous Saying

One who does not doubt cannot find the truth. Imam al-Ghazali — the topic became clear right away. This time let us not drag out the question on al-Ghazali and get straight into the subject.

One who does not doubt cannot find the truth. First we need to start with doubt. When we look at doubt, doubt comes in many kinds, but if a person is a seeker of truth, that person must certainly walk upon doubt. There is a scholarly doubt.

4. Scholarly Doubt vs. Religious Doubt: «Scholarly Doubt Directs a Person Toward the Truth»

Scholarly doubt directs a person to research and directs a person toward the truth. Whatever you find and call "this is real," "this is the truth," you doubt it. You look at what lies even beyond it. We call this scholarly doubt.

For example, a person may fall into doubt about any subject. To remove that doubt of his, he begins to research. He researches until his heart is fully at peace about that subject. Even if his heart is at peace, the person with scholarly doubt still says, the reality of this may yet be otherwise. He continues researching again. And then there is another doubt.

5. Religious Scepticism: Doubt About «the Existence of Allah, the Authenticity of Hadith»

For instance, looking at it in religious terminology, he falls into doubt regarding the existence of Allah. He starts researching about this. For instance, he falls into doubt regarding the hadiths. He starts researching about this. This is, so to speak, in quotation marks, religious scepticism.

This too normally helps that person find the truth, find reality, in his own way. Every doubt, provided it is not a psychological obsession, can lead a person to what is right, to what is right beyond what is right, and to what is right beyond that. That is why one should not approach scepticism with suspicion.

Or one should not look upon scepticism with an evil eye. In fact every thinking person ought to be somewhat sceptical. Then, in turn, to remove that doubt, he needs to work, to make an effort, to struggle, to research that subject.

6. «Every Doubt Is Like a Mount That Carries a Person to the Truth»

That is why I can define it more or less like this. Every doubt is like a mount that carries a person to the truth. If you become doubt's mount, you become its slave. It steers you.

But if, at this point, you do not become doubt's mount, and instead you use it as your mount, it carries you to the truth. In our society, people are generally the slaves of doubt. That is, unfortunately, they are its mount. This leads a person to ruin.

For example, a man sitting where he is becomes suspicious of his wife. Sitting where he is, he becomes suspicious of his family and children. Sitting where he is, he becomes suspicious of the employee next to him. You see, this ruins that person's psychology.

7. Making Room for the Congregation: «Clear the Doorway»

Now, you, move up a little more, come this way. This many more people can still fit here. Let the doorway be cleared because the ladies are coming. Come, come, come, move closer, closer like this. Move up, move up, move up, move up. Come, come, come, come, come. Move up. Let's see you move. Move, move, move, move. Come, come, come. Move up, move up, move up, move up. Stand up for a moment. Bismillah.

Not the ladies. Move up like this. Now clear the doorway. Move right up. Squeeze in a bit, let me see. Now everyone sit where you are. Let the doorway stay open. Don't always be like the Friday congregation, praying just the obligatory part and leaving right away — none of that here. The front is left empty, that's how it is. They'll pray at the very back and leave. God willing, let us not be like that.

8. The Two Faces of Doubt: «Doubt of the Nafs Leads to Ruin, Scholarly Doubt to the Truth»

So now, when looking at doubt, that is, when looking at the matter of doubt, if the doubt comes from the nafs (the self), then it has climbed on top of you. It takes you wherever it wants. Doubt — you have become the soldier of doubt. But if doubt is your soldier, then it has taken you to the truth.

When looking at doubt, we will look at it from two aspects. So, normally, if doubt is our soldier, let us climb on top of it. Let it take us to the truth. But if doubt climbs on top of us, then this becomes something of the nafs. It is not scholarly. Then wherever it drags us, that is where we will go. And its end, may Allah protect us, is ruin.

Yes. One who does not doubt cannot find the truth. That is, every person of knowledge, every seeker of truth already accepts this. Only the utterly ignorant do not accept it. May Allah make us good. (Amin.)

9. «How Do We Know Imam al-Ghazali?»: Evaluating a Person According to His Own Time

How do we know Imam al-Ghazali?

A great deal of research has been done on al-Ghazali. There are sub-points underneath, but let me just get straight into the subject. A great deal of research has been done on al-Ghazali. Many theses have been written. In universities, you know, associate professorship theses, graduation theses, this thesis, that thesis, "this in al-Ghazali," "that in al-Ghazali" — many theses have been written.

When evaluating someone, we need to evaluate him according to his own time. We are going to evaluate a person, after all. We need to evaluate him according to his own time, according to his own contemporaries. Now, if we look from where we stand, our evaluation of al-Ghazali will turn out different.

10. «Evaluating Mustafa Özbağ 50 Years Later Is Pointless»: One Must Look at His Contemporaries

For example, Mustafa Özbağ lived, he died. Mustafa Özbağ must be evaluated within Mustafa Özbağ's own time. What he lived through, what he saw, what he did, in what environment he grew up, in what environment he carried out Islamic work — he must be evaluated in that time. Well, evaluating Mustafa Özbağ 50 years from now is pointless.

What happened in his own time? What did he live through, what states did he pass through, what straits did he go through? One has to look at this. And one also has to look at his contemporaries.

While some people were sharing out trillions, what did he do? While some people were riding around in official cars, where was he going around? While some people were playing the hanger-on to various state institutions, municipalities, this one and that one, what kind of life did he build for himself? One has to look at these things.

Did he make religion a source of livelihood? While his own contemporaries were making it a source of livelihood, what did he do? While his own contemporaries were twisting a verse and hadiths, making them hop, making them jump, what did he do? That is how one must evaluate.

11. The Great Debate of al-Ghazali's Time: «Is the Qur'an Created or Not?»

If we are going to evaluate al-Ghazali too, we need to know al-Ghazali's time.

For example, in al-Ghazali's time, one of the biggest debates was whether the Qur'an is created or not. An example. This is the biggest debate. In al-Ghazali's time.

One of the great debates in al-Ghazali's time — at that time, normally, the Islamic world had newly opened its doors to the outside world. I'm giving an example: all the books of Aristotle, of Socrates, of Plato had been translated, and they had begun to be read and taught in the Islamic world.

Al-Ghazali at that time is in the position of responding to the philosophy of Socrates, of Plato, of Aristotle on this point.

12. From Which Angle Will We Look at al-Ghazali? — Philosophy, Kalam, Hadith, Politics

For example, from where will we look at al-Ghazali, then?

Will we look from a philosophical angle? Will we look at al-Ghazali from the angle of kalam? Will we look at al-Ghazali from the angle of hadith? Because in al-Ghazali's time, too, sayings that were normally perceived as hadith were circulating around.

For example, in al-Ghazali's time there was, so to speak, no work at the level of a university. More or less, at that time the state wanted a university to be founded and al-Ghazali to be placed at its head. Against what did the state found a university for him and have him put at its head? I mean, when we look at al-Ghazali then, when we look at him politically then, there is the matter of him being an assistant of the state.

13. The Existing State Must Be Discussed: «Where Do the Seljuks Stand Within Islam?»

we need to discuss the existing state.

Then we need to discuss the state to which he was attached. How much the state he was attached to is Islam, how much it isn't. At what point of Islam does it stand? In terms of its fiqh, its kalam — as fiqh and kalam, as politics — where does it stand?

We need to look at this too.

14. «The People of Anatolia Look at al-Ghazali Through the Ihya' 'Ulum al-Din»

But normally, now, when we as the public look at al-Ghazali, for example the people of Anatolia look at al-Ghazali's most famous work, the Ihya'. They look at the Ihya' 'Ulum al-Din (The Revival of the Religious Sciences). By looking at the Ihya' 'Ulum al-Din, they interpret al-Ghazali.

Well, but al-Ghazali disowns the earlier al-Ghazali, that is, himself. How does he disown him? He shuts himself up inside the minaret of the Umayyad Mosque. He stays there in seclusion for two years. After 2 years of seclusion: "I disown, I reject all the books I have written up to today." He says.

He writes the Ihya' after that. So now there is a difference between the al-Ghazali at the time he wrote the Ihya' and the al-Ghazali before the Ihya'.

15. «It Is Not Something Contrary to Human Nature»: The Journey Toward Perfection and Maturing

I mean, but this is not something normally contrary to human nature, this.

Imam Abu Hanifa (Imam-i A'zam) says the same thing. Imam-i A'zam says: "Had it not been for my last two years, Nu'man would have perished." Then Imam-i A'zam's earlier life and his last 2 years of life. between them, it means, there is a difference.

A human being shows this variability. A human being shows this change. A human being is capable of this attainment of perfection. A human being has been created suited to this. Today the point of perfection is different. 20 years later that person's point of perfection is different. If he is going along the noble Sunna, that is — because the one whose two days are equal is at a loss.

In accordance with the hadith, if a person walks the path toward perfection, that person matures more and more as he matures. Human fitra (innate nature) is suited to this. He was created for this. Because he walks on that point of perfection, he walks on the point of maturing — this is the fitra of creation.

16. Al-Ghazali's Many-Sidedness: Ibn Arabi's Metaphor of the Blind Men and the Elephant

That is why when we say al-Ghazali, a many-sided al-Ghazali appears before us. This is a bit like, you know, Ibn Arabi's metaphor of the blind man and the elephant. You know, bring a blind man and have him hold the elephant by its leg.

When you ask what the elephant resembles, he says it resembles a pillar. You know, if you have him hold it by the trunk, he says it resembles a hose. Then if you have him hold its ear, he says it resembles a ladle. If you have him hold it by its chest, he says it resembles a tray.

Ibn Arabi normally puts forward this metaphor in connection with blindness in knowing Allah. So when we look at someone — we too are looking at some person. When looking at him, we evaluate him in our own way, with our own perception. With our own perception, with our own knowledge, we evaluate him. Our perception and our knowledge actually become our god, our deity, over that person. May Allah forgive us.

17. A Chain of Questions: «How Do We Know Imam al-Ghazali?» — The One Who Poured Concrete Over Reason?

How do we know Imam al-Ghazali?

The question mark continues. The brother who asked the question.

Is he someone who poured concrete over reason in Islam, who put an end to free thought, who was almost hostile to philosophy, who bequeathed a reliance on transmitted knowledge (naql) — or is he one of the greatest architects of Sunni Islamic thought, a scholar of such stature as to make people say, "Even if all the books on Islam were to vanish and only the Ihya' remained, it would be enough"?

Note: This text is the speech itself as found in the recording of the sohbet: only spelling and punctuation have been edited, and obvious mishearings in the subtitles have been corrected; a few unclear passages have been left as heard. Section headings have been added to ease reading. The opening and closing prayers have not been included.


Bibliography

Work: Imam al-Ghazali, Ihya' 'Ulum al-Din — a 40-book compendium of the religious sciences that made people say «Even if all the books vanished, the Ihya' remaining would be enough» — written after he left Baghdad and spent two years in seclusion in Damascus

Philosophical Topic — The Debate on the Createdness of the Qur'an (Khalq al-Qur'an): A kalam debate in the 9th century between the Mu'tazila school's thesis that «the Qur'an is created» and the Ahl al-Sunna's thesis that «the Qur'an is the eternal speech of God and is not created». Under Caliph al-Ma'mun the «Mihna» (inquisition) was implemented; Ahmad ibn Hanbal was subjected to torture in this debate. — al-Ash'ari, al-Ibana; W. Madelung, Religious Schools and Sects in Medieval Islam

Philosophical Position — Doubt and Truth: The «systematic doubt» developed by al-Ghazali in al-Munqidh — an epistemological method that, some 600 years before Descartes and similarly to his «cogito ergo sum», questions the deceptiveness of the senses and of reason and arrives at resting in the heart's self-evident certainty of the Truth (necessary knowledge). — F. Köprülü-A. Aydın, Felsefe Yapısı: İslâm-Batı Hattı

Hadith — The Loss of One Whose Two Days Are Equal: «Whoever has two days that are equal to each other is at a loss.» — al-Daylami, Musnad al-Firdaws, no. 7378; al-Munawi, Fayd al-Qadir, V/259

Work — Muhyiddin Ibn Arabi: Ibn Arabi (Muhyiddin Ibn Arabi) (1165-1240), al-Futuhat al-Makkiyya; Fusus al-Hikam — an example of the «blind men and the elephant» metaphor in the Sufi lineage that continues with citations from al-Ghazali — on the relativity of knowing Allah. — Classical Sufi text; M. Chodkiewicz, An Ocean Without Shore

Historical Event — al-Ghazali's Departure from Baghdad: 488 AH / 1095 CE — al-Ghazali gave up the post of chief professor (mudarris) at the Nizamiyya madrasa and withdrew into seclusion in Damascus. More than two years of retreat in the minaret of the Umayyad Mosque of Damascus; followed by visits to Jerusalem, Mecca and Medina, and a return to his hometown of Tus (Khorasan). — al-Subki, Tabaqat al-Shafi'iyya, IV/110; W. M. Watt, Muslim Intellectual: A Study of al-Ghazali

Sufi Principle — The Journey Toward Perfection: «Takamul» (spiritual maturation) in Sufi psychology: each day being one step ahead of the previous day. Imam Abu Hanifa's saying, «Had it not been for my last two years, I would have perished»; the knowledge gained at the very last stage through the Sufi path of 'ilm ladunni (knowledge directly from God) surpassing the earlier knowledge. — Narration from Abu Hanifa; al-Qushayri, al-Risala

This text has been compiled in full detail from the 14th lesson (the final lesson of the series) of Mustafa Özbağ Efendi's «Questions on al-Ghazali» lecture series and re-edited to thesis standard. Source video: YouTube

Additional sources:

  • The Holy Qur'an, al-Nahl 16/125; the principle of inviting with wisdom and good counsel.
  • The Holy Qur'an, al-Ahzab 33/21; the Messenger of Allah being the beautiful example.
  • al-Nawawi, Riyad al-Salihin, chapters on taqwa, sincerity (ikhlas) and good character.
  • Imam al-Ghazali, Ihya' 'Ulum al-Din (The Revival of the Religious Sciences), chapters on the training of the heart, character and sincerity.
  • al-Bukhari, the books of Iman and Riqaq, narrations on intention, sincerity and character.
  • Muslim, the book of Birr and Sila, narrations on good character and brotherhood.
  • al-Tirmidhi, the books of Birr and Sila, Zuhd and Da'awat.
  • al-Nawawi, Riyad al-Salihin, chapters on sincerity, taqwa, dhikr and good character.
  • Ibn Hajar al-'Asqalani, Fath al-Bari, commentary on the relevant narrations of al-Bukhari.
  • al-Qushayri, al-Risala, discussions on the etiquette of Sufism, states and stations.