1. The Turkish Conception of the State: «The State Does Not Impose Religion on Its Subjects»
A state can never impose religion on its people. Normally, in the Turkish state system, the state does not impose religion on its own subjects. It lays down law. In fact, to say Turk is to say law. I suppose my nationalist vein has flared up a bit.
You may see it that way. It doesn't matter at all. I am a nationalist person. I don't deny that either. Yes. I love my nation. I am not one of those who say the Turkish race is the supreme race. No. To say Turk is to say law. Justice; to say Turk is to say humanity. To say Turk is to say one who raises his head against the oppressor, who rises up against him. To be a Turk is to stand beside the one who is in the right, not the one who is in the wrong. Turks have never had a polytheistic religion.
2. The Turks Are Monotheists and Accepted Islam Very Easily
Turks have a monotheistic religion, and they have been Muslims ever since the son of Noah. Yes. Tomorrow they'll stone me on social media. I couldn't care less.
Turks have never held a polytheistic belief. They are monotheists, and the Turks have been Muslim for as long as they have existed. That is why they accept Islam very easily. Very easily. For example, the Bosniaks and the Pomaks are Turks.
The Bulgarians are Turks. The Hungarians are Turks. Those who went over the top of the Caspian Sea went to Europe. Those who came from below it came to Anatolia. But normally these migrations took place in very ancient times. World history was built upon Turkish civilisation. To say Muslim is to say Turk. And to say Turk is to say Muslim.
3. «No Turkish People Ever Buried Its Own Daughter Alive»: Arab Jahiliyya
In short, you know how people ask: why did He send the Prophet to the Arabs?
The Arabs were the most vile nation at that time. The most ignorant beings were they, they. That is why the Almighty (Allah) sent the Prophet to the Arabs.
You will not find a single Turkish people that buried its own daughter alive; the Arabs buried them alive. You will not find a single Turkish people. Driving a woman out into the desert when she was about to give birth: the Arabs drove women out into the desert when they were about to give birth. You will not find a single Turkish people. Throwing a woman out of the tent when she was menstruating: the Arabs threw her out of the tent. You will not find a single Turkish people. You will not find a single Turkish people that sold women in the market, that put its own wife up for sale.
Who sells them? The Arabs sell them, the English sell them. Until the 1800s, until the 1900s, the English used to sell their own wives in the market. You will not find this in a single Turkish people. You now, Westernisers, and by "you" I don't mean you here. Saying "Westernism", people became the tail of the English. Who are these English? Those who took their own wives to the market and sold their own wives. A man who sells his own wife. The English would sell you and me without a second thought anyway. You will not find a single Turkish people like this. Selling his wife in the market.
4. Al-Ghazali, a Typical Turk and Statist: «Statism Runs in Our Veins»
I've wandered off the subject. I got carried away.
Please forgive me. Now, that is why al-Ghazali is a typical Turk. Al-Ghazali is at the same time a statist, not as a chronic illness but genetically.
In fact, statism runs in all of your veins. It runs in mine too. Even if the state were to cook boza on the back of our necks, we would not turn into enemies of the state. If something were to happen, we are the ones who would march at the very front, barefoot, bareheaded, bare-legged. Again it is us, no one else.
5. The 15 July 2016 Coup Attempt: The Stance of the Dergah
Examples of this have been seen as well. I am happy with this community, I am proud of it.
I mean, in the end, chaos broke out. We didn't even wait for the President's word. We gathered before everyone else. We too stood against the coup. And that is why we were subjected to coups ourselves.
Underline this too. While we were out in the square, some AK Party members of parliament were still rubbing their eyes; as we were leaving the square, they were just arriving. They waited. They waited to see which way the coup would turn.
Anyway, that is why statism runs in our veins. We do not betray the state. This is our genetics, this is ours. We cannot reject it. And I don't fight against it anyway. Look, I don't fight against it. I am a statist person. The state has broken gears, it has faulty sides. There are administrative problems. There are, and there certainly are. But I am still a statist person. May Allah forgive us. (Amin.)
6. The Nizamiyya Madrasas: The First State Educational Institution in the Islamic World
Nizam al-Mulk, who sought to secure unity and order in the Seljuk State politically, ideologically and socially, founded madrasas in all the principal cities of the country, Baghdad first and foremost.
These schools, called the Nizamiyya madrasas, were the first educational institutions in the Islamic world built by the hand of the state, underline this part, giving education with a state budget, and whose curriculum was determined by the state. Yes, that is correct.
Normally, these Nizamiyya madrasas are the first madrasas, or universities, founded by the hand of the state in the Islamic world. Normally their funds come from the state. Their curricula also come from the state. I agree with all of it.
7. «The State Is Responsible for Protecting the Religion and Reason of Its Subjects»
And normally, the Seljuks, now, governing a state, I beg your pardon, is not like running a henhouse.
Those governing the state at that time did this so that people would not sink and be lost in such deviant thoughts and ideas. The state undertook these efforts so that people would not sacrifice themselves to deviations.
I am not against these. Because the state is responsible for protecting the religion and the reason of its subjects. That is why it is responsible for providing education. Now, their content can be debated. That is a separate matter. God willing, next week we will continue from here.
8. Brother Hakan's Question-and-Answer Work: The «Nefes» Series Books
If you bring a pen, let me write "to be continued" here. Will you add anything to the questions? Will the questions stay? Let them stay. No. If you put together a set of questions based on what I talked about today, I mean, next week we can again go through those sets of questions. We have no concern that my analysis must necessarily be right. Well, I thank brother Hakan once again.
It had been quite a long time since he prepared questions like this. In fact, I sort of said to him, "Hey, lately no questions are coming at all." "You're not getting us excited about this at all," I said. I even said, "Have you given up hope?" He would tell me, "I'm preparing such questions, your head will hit the ceiling from your chair," he'd say. Our heads haven't hit the ceiling just yet, but, you know, it became a means for good. May Allah be pleased with him. Well, are our Nefes 1-2-3-4 coming out, or did we get stuck at 3 with Nefes?
Are we going to do 4 by ijtihad? Okay. God willing. Nefes 1-2-3. Of course, it came into being through brother Hakan's questions. And also Politics in Islam. That too came into being through brother Hakan's questions. Well, we've had the books printed too. Only the Masnavi is left, I suppose, isn't it? Has the Masnavi been printed too? It's at the press. God willing, once that's finished too, we'll slowly begin offering them to the brothers. We're waiting for that to be finished as well. If nothing comes from Allah, God willing. May the Almighty grant all the brothers to read them. (Amin.) God willing, it will be beneficial. God willing, they will benefit from it. Al-Fatiha. Amin.
9. How the Nizamiyya Madrasas Began with Good Intentions and Later Became Corrupted
The Nizamiyya madrasas, then, I'll talk about this next week, but the Nizamiyya madrasas, as a beginning, as a goal, were very well placed, but unfortunately they later lost their function.
Other things got mixed up in it. When other things got mixed up in it, I mean, I'll introduce this next week. Concerning the Nizamiyya madrasas. I mean, the beginning was a very, a well-intentioned beginning. While setting out with good intentions, they did set out with good intentions, but unfortunately, you know, the disease in the Islamic world of setting out with good intentions and then going bad along the way, going bad along the way, infected them too.
I've saved this for next week. Now I've gotten into the Nizamiyya madrasas there. I'll analyze this a bit next week, I'll analyze it so that it sheds light on our own day. Because when setting out, everyone sets out saying Qur'an and Sunna, homeland and nation. As a beginning it's very nice.
10. «Setting Out as a Mujahid, Becoming a Contractor, Unmannered»: The Chronic Disease of the Islamic World
You know, in my own expression, one sets out as a mujahid. Then along the way he becomes a müteahhit, a contractor. Then he becomes an it, a dog, then he ends up becoming dinsiz, faithless. This is normal, in the Islamic world this is a chronic disease. You know, when they see position, rank, money, they change.
The Nizamiyya madrasas, well, such a later, but this later, such a, you know, going off its orbit, while it was a thing, a phenomenon that ought to bring benefit, a movement that ought to bring benefit, it then comes to the point you mentioned. I mean, this place ceases to be a community open to opening up, open to change.
11. State Hegemony and Political Islam Beginning with Mu'awiya
That's when they harm the Islamic world. They harm the Islamic system of thought, the Islamic system of fiqh. I mean, normally, I mean, while they should be functionally developing, changing, deepening and elevating themselves, they remain in a bigoted way. And when they remain like that, then everything becomes blunted. First the state, from its sleep, I mean, it departs from what is normally the understanding of the state, too.
The state is one thing, the ruler at its head is another, those who administer the state are another. This time the matter goes beyond, you know, even the correct, well, line within the state itself. Those who govern the state do this. Those who govern the state this time take the madrasas under their own thing. What is that? They take them under their hegemony. Political Islam, well, that political Islam existed from before.
The place where political Islam began is Mu'awiya.
Note: This text is the speech itself as found in the recording of the sohbet: only spelling and punctuation have been edited, and obvious mishearings in the subtitles have been corrected; a few unintelligible places have been left as heard. Section headings have been added to make reading easier. The opening and closing prayers have not been included.
Bibliography
Historical Context — The Nizamiyya Madrasas: A network of madrasas founded by Nizam al-Mulk from 459 AH/1067 CE onward in Baghdad, Nishapur, Balkh, Herat, Isfahan, Basra, Mosul and other Seljuk cities. The first institutions of higher education in the Islamic world to be founded with state funds and to have their curriculum determined centrally; with an emphasis on Sunni-Ash'ari kalam and Shafi'i fiqh. — G. Makdisi, The Rise of Colleges: Institutions of Learning in Islam and the West
Work: Nizam al-Mulk, Siyasatnama (Siyar al-Muluk) — the Seljuk vizier's guide to statecraft — The theorization of the State–Madrasa–Scholar relationship
Historical Event — 15 July 2016: A military coup attempt carried out by a FETÖ-affiliated group; it was suppressed when the people took to the streets. The statement mentioned in the sohbet, «a turmoil broke out, we didn't even wait for the President's word, we gathered before everyone else and stood against the coup», refers to this event. — Current political event
Person — Brother Hakan: An interlocutor who frequently attends Mustafa Özbağ Efendi's talks, who prepared the questions for book projects in question-and-answer format such as «Nefes 1-2-3», «Politics in Islam» and «Masnavi», of leftist background, and who constantly questions matters of Sufism. — Oral tradition of the Karabash-i Veli dergah (Sufi lodge)
Historical Context — The English «Wife Sale» Custom (1700-1900): The custom, in rural England before the Industrial Revolution, whereby husbands who could not afford the costs of legal divorce sold their wives to the highest bidder in a marketplace — with a rope tied around their necks. It was not officially prohibited; its last instances are recorded up to 1913. — S. P. Menefee, Wives for Sale: An Ethnographic Study of British Popular Divorce, Oxford 1981
Custom of the Jahiliyya — Burying Girls Alive («Wa'd»): The custom among the Arabs of the Jahiliyya of burying newborn daughters alive because they regarded them as a cause of shame. The Holy Qur'an explicitly forbade and condemned this: [Qur'an, at-Takwir 81:8-9 — verse text pending: Diyanet English translation] — M. Hamidullah, The Prophet of Islam, I/27-32
Historical Context — The Beginning of Political Islam: Mu'awiya b. Abi Sufyan (r. 661-680) — through the Umayyad caliphate he established in Damascus after the martyrdom of Ali, he transformed the caliphate into a sultanate; by appointing his son Yazid as heir apparent, he established the principle of hereditary succession based on fait accompli instead of election. The thesis that «political Islam begins with Mu'awiya» rests on this event. — M. Abu Zahra, History of Islam; M. A. al-Jabiri, Political Reason in Islam
This text has been compiled from the 9th lesson of Mustafa Özbağ Efendi's «Questions on al-Ghazali» lecture series and re-edited to thesis quality. Source video: YouTube
Additional sources:
- The Holy Qur'an, al-Nahl 16/125; the principle of inviting with wisdom and good counsel.
- The Holy Qur'an, al-Ahzab 33/21; the Messenger of Allah being the beautiful example.
- al-Nawawi, Riyad al-Salihin, chapters on taqwa, sincerity and good character.
- Imam al-Ghazali, Ihya' 'Ulum al-Din (The Revival of the Religious Sciences), chapters on the training of the heart, ethics and sincerity.
- al-Bukhari, chapters on Faith and Riqaq, narrations on intention, sincerity and character.
- Muslim, chapter on Birr and Sila, narrations on good character and brotherhood.
- al-Tirmidhi, chapters on Birr and Sila, Zuhd and Da'awat.
- al-Nawawi, Riyad al-Salihin, chapters on sincerity, taqwa, dhikr and good character.
- Ibn Hajar al-'Asqalani, Fath al-Bari, commentary on the relevant narrations of al-Bukhari.
- al-Qushayri, al-Risala, discussions on the etiquette of Sufism, states and stations.