1. «I Recognise No Limits»: Mustafa Özbağ Efendi's Freedom of Thought
Otherwise, normally, when it comes to free thought, I personally recognise no other limit.
I can put my thinking, my knowledge, to work however I wish. But when we look at al-Ghazali, I mean, normally I am not someone who has sat down and read the Ihya' from cover to cover. I mean, if I have looked into the Ihya', I have looked at 3 or 5 issues. But, you know, you will say: are you an al-Ghazali specialist?
I am not, but nevertheless, as far as I know, I have not come across any passage indicating that al-Ghazali put a lock on free thought. Perhaps if something like that concerning it is identified in the coming pages, we will analyse that too.
2. «I, Who Am Hostile to Philosophy, Do Not See al-Ghazali as an Enemy of Philosophy»
Someone almost hostile to philosophy. I do not see al-Ghazali as an enemy of philosophy either. Why don't I? I mean, if he had been hostile to philosophy, he would not have sat down and written the Tahafut al-Falasifa. As a response to the philosophers, there is al-Ghazali's famous Tahafut al-Falasifa (The Incoherence of the Philosophers).
I mean, I think even the philosophers in Turkey would have a hard time understanding it. It is hard for a philosopher who says "I am somebody" to find his way out of the Tahafut al-Falasifa. You know, as a response to the philosophers. Later I heard of one more work. Recently a brother wrote to me. A work called a response to the response to the philosophers. I haven't looked at it at all, but in those days, I mean in al-Ghazali's time, in the end al-Ghazali threw the philosophy of the ancient Greek aristocracy into the rubbish bin.
Perhaps al-Ghazali, I said perhaps, normally, for that time, used very harsh styles while answering the Greek philosophers.
3. «Had He Seen It as an Enemy, He Would Have Rejected It, Not Written a Response» — He Followed His Predecessor
He can be seen as an enemy of philosophy, but had he been an enemy, he would have rejected it at the root. He would not have written a response. Actually, if you look at it, he wrote a response.
He too followed his predecessor. Who is the predecessor? Al-Kindi: ultimately, if a person is going to respond to something, he cannot approach it with a feeling of enmity and respond to it with rancour. I mean, he has to establish communication with it. By establishing communication he has to understand it and respond to it that way. Is he someone who gifted us reliance on transmitted knowledge (naql)?
4. «The One Who Gifted Reliance on Naql»: The Essence of All Religions Is Transmitted Knowledge
If you look at it, all religions are built upon transmitted knowledge (naql). It is not possible for you to reject naql. If you reject naql, nothing at all remains of the essence of religion. You would have to reject all of them. Because all religions consist of naql. I mean, the Qur'an, the Gospel (Injil), the Torah (Tawrat), the Psalms (Zabur), which we describe as divine books, or the scrolls that came to the other prophets, all of them consist of naql.
Of naql, I mean: Allah did not send down a book from the sky, nor did He say, "I have placed a book in such-and-such a cave, go and take it from there and follow it."
Revelation came to the hearts of the prophets through Gabriel (peace be upon him), and the prophets transmitted the revelation that came to them to the believers.
5. «The Essence of All Religions Is Naql»: Even Philosophy Cannot Reject Transmitted Knowledge
That is why reliance on naql is the essence of all religions. Look, even the Qur'an is naql. That is why, if the matter in question is religion, you cannot deny naql.
Indeed, even if the matter in question is philosophy, you still cannot deny naql. Look, if it is philosophy, you still cannot deny naql.
And when we go back, we do not know when writing was discovered. You know, historically. Because when Adam (peace be upon him) was sent down to earth, he knew how to write and read. He was not ignorant. And he was sent down with the ten commandments in his hand. He was sent down with a scroll. That is why Adam (peace be upon him) was not an ignorant person who could not read and write.
He was acquainted with the reality of things. Of existence. That being so, that too consists of naql. All religions consist of naql. It is not possible for us to deny naql.
6. «The Greatest Architects» of Sunni Islamic Thought: Personalities of High Capacity
Or the greatest architects of the thought of the Sunni Islamic world. Isn't that so? Well, normally now, yes. In the Islamic world, people of this type, you know, of high capacity, have appeared from time to time.
Actually, if you look at it from this angle, this too exists in a hadith. Every 100 years, what comes, sir? A mujaddid (renewer) comes. What is a mujaddid? One who renews religious understanding; this is something that exists in the fitra, in the nature, of Islam. That is why in certain periods such people of higher capacity appear, scholars appear, masters appear.
These are important in terms of religion being understood anew or comprehended anew, or of responding to the illnesses, the illnesses of their own times, and al-Ghazali too is one of these personalities.
7. «Al-Ghazali Is One of the Greatest Architects, But Not the Only One»
That is why we can describe him as one of its greatest architects. But if we say its greatest architect, that would not be right. Because every person is valuable, valuable in his own time.
The reason is that people's perception changes. People's degree of perfection changes. People's degree of knowledge changes. That being so, we may see the knowledge of someone from the past as having become outdated, as having lost its value, relative to the person of today.
8. «The Only Thing That Does Not Change in Islam Is the Law» — Understanding of Ambiguous Verses and Ijtihads Change
Because the only thing that does not change in Islam is the law. In Islam the law does not change. In the other, ambiguous (mutashabih) verses, perception and understanding are all open to change. In fact they need to change. For example, ijtihads (independent juristic rulings) also need to change.
Ijtihads too are in need of fresh ijtihad. I am saying this while underlining it. But, you know, perceptions of the mutashabih also need to change, for Islam is a religion that renews itself in this respect.
With what does it renew itself? Well, with high-capacity scholars, with Sufis, what does it do? Islamic thought renews itself.
9. «If All Books Vanished and the Ihya' Remained, It Would Suffice»: «The Ghazalian Camp»
Is he such a scholar as to make people say, "If all books on Islam vanished and only the Ihya' remained, it would be enough"? Well, normally, from time to time, yes, I read this phrase in various places. You know, there is a kind of Ghazalian camp in the Islamic world.
They say this from time to time. You know, "if all books vanished, the Ihya' would suffice for all books, for everything." There are many books in the Islamic world with a status like that of the Ihya'.
Look, there are many books. That is why placing this solely upon al-Ghazali would be an injustice done to other scholars, other virtuous people, other people who have attained perfection.
10. «Radiant of Heart, Radiant of Mind, Radiant of Thought, Radiant of Remembrance»: The Quality of the Mujaddids
That is why in the Islamic world, from time to time, such radiant people have appeared.
Radiant of heart, radiant of mind, radiant of thought, radiant of remembrance (dhikr). They have offered remedies for the illnesses of their day. Eyvallah.
11. Al-Ghazali's Teaching as an Ideological Apparatus and the Description «A Rector Appointed by the Seljuks»
How did Imam al-Ghazali's teaching become an ideological apparatus of governance in the hands of the ruling classes and powers in Islamic societies, and what role has ideology, as a superstructural institution, played in the development of the state, society and the economy in Eastern Islamic societies?
Now, at the beginning of this talk I said, didn't I, that al-Ghazali is, in the end, like a professor appointed by the state. You know how today, normally, the state, for instance, appoints a rector to something, to a university. Al-Ghazali, too, is a rector appointed by the Seljuks. When we look at the Seljuk era, the Seljuks had, from period to period, both internal problems and external problems.
Note: This text is the actual speech from the recording of the sohbet: only spelling and punctuation have been edited, and obvious mishearings in the subtitles have been corrected; a few unclear passages have been left as heard. Section headings have been added for ease of reading. The opening and closing prayers have not been included.
Bibliography
Work: Imam al-Ghazali, Ihya' 'Ulum al-Din (The Revival of the Religious Sciences) — a 40-book corpus that prompted the saying «If all books were lost and the Ihya' remained, it would suffice»; a synthesis of creed, fiqh, ethics and Sufism
Work: Imam al-Ghazali, Tahafut al-Falasifa (The Incoherence of the Philosophers) — a refutation of ancient Greek aristocratic philosophy on 20 issues deemed incoherent from an Islamic standpoint
Work — The Tahafut Tradition: Ibn Rushd (Averroes), Tahafut al-Tahafut (The Incoherence of the Incoherence, 1180); Hocazade (Khojazada), Tahafut (15th-century Ottoman kalam); Sadruddinzade al-Tavili, commentaries on the Tahafut — the continuation of the philosophy–kalam debate over centuries
Hadith — The Mujaddids: «Allah will send to this community at the head of every century someone who will renew (revive anew) its religion for it.» — Abu Dawud, Malahim, no. 4291; al-Hakim, al-Mustadrak, IV/522
Philosophical Position — Reason and Transmitted Knowledge: The debate in the history of Islamic kalam over the balance between «reason» ('aql) (ra'y / qiyas / logic) and «transmitted knowledge» (naql) (Qur'an–Sunna–Ijma'). The Mu'tazila give precedence to reason, the Hanbali school gives precedence to transmission; Ash'ari–Maturidi kalam balances the two. Al-Ghazali develops the thesis that both are necessary. — M. Watt, Islamic Philosophy and Theology; T. Izutsu, The Concept of Belief in Islamic Theology
Creed — Revelation and the Chain of Transmission: Beginning with Adam, every prophet conveyed to his people the revelation (wahy) he received through Gabriel (peace be upon him); his community in turn carried this transmission to later generations through memorisation, writing and practice — the fundamental epistemological structure of the religion. — Imam Abu Hanifa, al-Fiqh al-Akbar; al-Maturidi, Kitab al-Tawhid
Historical Figure — Adam (peace be upon him): The first human being and the first prophet. In Islamic belief it is held that when he was sent down from Paradise to the earth he was sent down with ten commands and with scriptures, and that he was created not as an ignorant, unlettered person but as a learned one acquainted with the reality of things ([Qur'an, al-Baqara 2:31 — verse text pending: Diyanet English translation]). — Ibn Kathir, Qisas al-Anbiya'
This text has been compiled in full detail from the 12th lesson of Mustafa Özbağ Efendi's «Questions on al-Ghazali» lecture series and re-edited to thesis standard. Source video: YouTube
Additional sources:
- The Holy Qur'an, al-Nahl 16/125; the principle of calling with wisdom and good counsel.
- The Holy Qur'an, al-Ahzab 33/21; the Messenger of Allah as the beautiful example.
- al-Nawawi, Riyad al-Salihin, the chapters on taqwa, sincerity (ikhlas) and good character.
- Imam al-Ghazali, Ihya' 'Ulum al-Din, the chapters on training the heart, character and sincerity.
- al-Bukhari, the books of Iman and Riqaq, narrations on intention, sincerity and character.
- Muslim, the book of Birr wa al-Sila, narrations on good character and brotherhood.
- al-Tirmidhi, the books of Birr wa al-Sila, Zuhd and Da'awat.
- al-Nawawi, Riyad al-Salihin, the chapters on sincerity, taqwa, dhikr and good character.
- Ibn Hajar al-'Asqalani, Fath al-Bari, commentary on the relevant narrations of al-Bukhari.
- al-Qushayri, al-Risala, the sections on the etiquette of Sufism, states and stations.