Sunday, November 15, 2026
OUR PATH IS THE PATH OF PROPHETHOOD
Mustafa Özbağ
Irshad & Tasawwuf · Official Site
al-Ghazali Talks·

Why Did al-Ghazali Leave Baghdad? | al-Ghazali Talks 4

Translated from Turkish. Original article (Turkish) →

1. A Multidimensional Occupation: Military, Economic, Political, Cultural, Religious

Today too, with its Salafis and its Wahhabis from within, with British agents who have sold out from within, and from outside with America's structure under the NATO umbrella, the country is ready for occupation.

Economically, the country is ready for occupation. Politically, the country is ready for occupation. Culturally, we have already been occupied. Religiously, it is ready for occupation. You are going to forget the verses of jihad.

You are going to forget the defence of the country. You are going to forget the economy. You are going to forget interest. You are going to forget fornication. With drugs, with alcohol, with drugs, with nakedness, your brain will freeze. Yes. In this country the age of drug use has dropped to 10, to 10. The age of prostitution has dropped to 13. People are struggling to make a living. Yes. It is ready for occupation. In that day too, the Seljuk state was ready for occupation.

There is turmoil within. That is why Byzantium comes under the command of Romanos Diogenes. Had 1071 been overcome, you would not exist today. That is why al-Ghazali is not a man made to order.

2. «Al-Ghazali Is the Highest Mind of His Day»: Criticising in Hindsight Is Easy

He is the summit of that day, the highest mind of that day. I say people do their duty in their own day. What kind of duty they performed becomes clear later. Criticisms are made by those who come later, yes, criticisms. It is everyone's right; I have nothing to say against that.

That is why al-Ghazali's regret and confession are not about having served the state. They are about his own nafs. I attribute that to Sufism. You know how Hazrat Pir says, "Yesterday stayed in yesterday, my dear soul." Today one must say new things. That is what the Sufis say. They regret their yesterday. They say, "If only I had loved more, if only I had lived more, if only I had gone deeper." This, you know, with al-Ghazali too, I believe in that. His intention is very pure. It is clear and pure. But those who come later muddy the purity and clarity of that intention.

3. «There Is Hazrat Rumi, and There Are the Rumi-ists»: Those Who Corrupt the Path of the Pir

You know, there is Hazrat Rumi.

And then there are the Rumi-ists, right? Just as there is Ibn Arabi and then there are the Ibn Arabi-ists, like that. There is Imam Abu Hanifa (al-Imam al-A'zam), and then there are the Abu Hanifa-ists. What? "I am a Hanafi." What part of you is Hanafi? Imam Abu Hanifa struggled for the downfall of the Umayyad house.

What part of you is Hanafi? It is like that.

4. From Baghdad to Damascus: Two Years of Seclusion in the Minaret of the Umayyad Mosque

That is why, in this sense, al-Ghazali, for instance, leaves Baghdad in his last two years. Al-Ghazali moves to Damascus. He resigns from the state and says, "The duty I have done is enough." He moves to Damascus. In Damascus he shuts himself up in the Umayyad Mosque for two years. He shuts himself up in the minaret of the mosque.

Yes. I do not see this as al-Ghazali's regret. I mean, he now says, "My road is near its end; now I must set right the mathematics of my own nafs." That is why, for me, al-Ghazali's leaving Baghdad is not running away from duty. For me it is not a rebellion either.

5. Going into Khalwa: The Inner Reckoning of Every Sufi

Well, I mean, there is an inner reckoning present in every Sufi.

Great Sufis generally, because of that inner reckoning of theirs, wish to withdraw into seclusion, to go into khalwa. They say: so much heat, so much noise, so much, you know, rushing about and struggle. Then they say, let us do a bit of inner reckoning. Let us step back for a while.

See this like i'tikaf. You know, the Prophet (peace be upon him) used to make i'tikaf in the last ten days of Ramadan. He would not speak with anyone. He would be constantly, you know, in intimate company with the Almighty (Allah). Yet he was always like that, but still he would, so to speak, withdraw himself into such seclusion. Well, this too is something befitting al-Ghazali. The great pirs have always done the same things. You know, within the Sufi teaching there is this, going into khalwa, stepping aside like this.

Now, normally, brothers and friends may perhaps perceive this a little differently. You know, I too sometimes say, I want to step aside like this. You just cannot overcome that feeling. Then you think: there are so many brothers, friends, this one, that one. Then, in its own way, a dream comes, a spiritual state, something happens. And again, you know, you say: run, walk, carry on. It is something like that. What I see in al-Ghazali is, let us say, an inner reckoning of this kind, or a bit of going into khalwa, a bit of being alone with oneself. That is how I characterise it. It is not anything else.

6. Al-Ghazali's Conception of the State and Islam: Remaining Moral Within the System

Normally now, looking from this paragraph and that paragraph, when we look at al-Ghazali in general, for example, al-Ghazali does not conceive of an Islam outside the state.

Now let me touch on Hakan's critical point.

I mean, al-Ghazali places the state and Islam within each other. There is no conception of an Islam outside the state in al-Ghazali. Now, he mentioned Ibn Rushd (Averroes), right? For example, in al-Ghazali there is no radical libertarianism in today's sense. I am not saying these things to please Hakan. I mean, these are my observations. Well, al-Ghazali is more of a man within the system.

But when I say a man within the system, I cannot skip over this aspect of his. While remaining within the system, he wants to equip the system with moral rules, and he does equip it. He does not stay outside the system. He does not place himself outside the system. But the system must be moral and lawful. Al-Ghazali tries to pull the system towards a moral and legal footing; he limits it. It has become 11 o'clock. Please forgive me your rights. May it be halal. The last word at this point, tonight's last word.

7. The Scholar Has No Presumption of Infallibility: Being Wounded, Healing with Knowledge

I have taken your time. Please forgive me your rights. So apparently I did not want to break it off here either. I just kept going. Al-Ghazali, I will read from the last paragraph I wrote.

Like every believer, like every human being, he is not an infallible scholar or dervish. Apart from the Prophet (peace be upon him), there is no one who possesses the presumption of infallibility. Because in Islamic belief no sheikh, no scholar, no head of state possesses the presumption of infallibility. Everyone has errors and mistakes, shortcomings and deficiencies, sins. In the hadith: there is no one whom a sin has not seized by the forelock. That is why al-Ghazali is not within the presumption of infallibility. He too, like every believer, is human on one side. After all, al-Ghazali is not a blind functionary of those in power either.

He did have contact with the state. I also believe he was wounded by this contact. He was wounded by this contact. Because every sheikh, every scholar, everyone, every scholar who comes into contact with the state is wounded. That is why the Sufis take extreme care not to come into contact with the state. So as not to be wounded. And he received this wound, but he sought the way to heal this wound with knowledge and morality, and he walked on that path. This is my last word. Please forgive me your rights.

8. Nizam al-Mulk vs. Machiavelli: The Clash Between Divine Legitimacy and Secular Legitimacy

Next week the Day of Judgment will break out. Amin. How will the Day of Judgment break out next week?

Nizam al-Mulk bases the source of political power on a divine power, on Allah, and on religion, that is, on Islam. Machiavelli, on the other hand, points to worldly and secular justifications. Nizam al-Mulk, who states that in every age Allah gives the authority to govern to certain persons whom He chooses from among the people, thereby offers political power a strong theological foundation by stating that obeying the sultan means, in a sense, submitting to Allah.

Machiavelli, however, opposes this in his book The Prince and seeks the source of power in social dynamics. Let us not scatter the subject. Nizam al-Mulk forms the curriculum of the Nizamiyya madrasas with an understanding opposed to the Batiniyya, the Ismailis and Shi'ism.

Al-Ghazali's work titled The Inner Face of Batinism, in which he declared Batinism and Shi'ism to be outside Islam, is famous. Yes, we will continue from here. Next week a tough talk awaits us. If Allah permits, inshallah. If He grants health and well-being, we will continue from here, inshallah.

Please forgive me your rights. Of course, in your presence I also thank Brother Hakan, who brought such a subject before us. He turns me into this kind of researcher. I dive once again, you see, into books, once again into this kind of research. After that, my shutters are closed. No communication. I am going to research these things. Thank God, by saying "I will bring it here," he steers me too into a fine occupation. I thank him from here. May Allah be pleased with him. (Amin.)

9. Those Who Will Keep the Country Standing: «Be a Little Crazy»

I apologise to the friends. To all the dervish brothers and sisters. I have no time left to attend to their personal matters like this. So on this matter too, may the brothers and sisters, inshallah, forgive me their rights. May it be halal. And if there is anyone who does not, let them say so. We know how to settle accounts. I mean, our hands aren't exactly idle either. I mean, if you take this as a threat, you may take it so. No problem. The blood flowing in our veins is clear. We are not normal. We never were anyway. And don't you be either.

Yes. Don't be normal. Be a little crazy. Those who will keep the country standing are the crazy ones. Those who will defend the homeland, those who will defend the religion, faith, Islam, are the crazy ones. No good ever comes from sluggish, snivelling people.

That is why it is not clear what awaits the country. Look, a foreigner just went in swinging his arms freely and occupied a place. I have been saying it for years, haven't I: who knows that tomorrow it won't be here, I say. Do not trust anyone or any state at all. We are surrounded on all sides. As a country we will be vigilant, we will be one. We will be careful. Anything of any kind can happen, from inside and from outside. That is why we will most certainly, most certainly be careful. We will be careful, inshallah.

Note: This text is the speech itself as found in the recording of the sohbet (spiritual discourse): only spelling and punctuation have been edited, and obvious mishearings in the subtitles have been corrected; a few places that could not be made out have been left as heard. Section headings have been added to facilitate reading. The opening and closing prayers have not been included.


Bibliography

Work: Imam al-Ghazali, al-Munqidh min al-Dalal (Deliverance from Error) — account of the period of withdrawal into seclusion from the Nizamiyya madrasa of Baghdad to Damascus

Work: Imam al-Ghazali, Fada'ih al-Batiniyya (The Inner Face of Batinism) / al-Mustazhiri — scholarly refutation of the Batini-Ismaili-Shi'i doctrine

Work: Nizam al-Mulk, Siyasatnama (Siyar al-Muluk) — the divine source of the sultan's authority to govern; theological legitimacy

Work: Niccolò Machiavelli, Il Principe (The Prince), 1513 — grounding power in secular/social dynamics — the opposite pole to Nizam al-Mulk

Historical Site — Umayyad Mosque (Damascus): The Umayyad Mosque of Damascus (al-Jami' al-Umawi) — built between 705 and 715, one of the oldest great mosques of the Islamic world. The place where al-Ghazali is reported to have entered i'tikaf in the corner of the minaret for more than two years after leaving Baghdad. — Ibn al-Subki, Tabaqat al-Shafi'iyya, IV/110

Hadith — Sin and Repentance: «Every human being errs; and the best of those who err are those who repent.» — al-Tirmidhi, Sifat al-Qiyama, no. 2499; Ibn Majah, Zuhd, no. 4251

Sufi Tradition — Khalwa (Seclusion): The Sufi's withdrawing from the world for a set period to be alone with Allah; the principle of «Khalwat dar Anjuman» (seclusion within the crowd) is one of the fundamental disciplines of the Naqshbandiyya. It is the Sufi manifestation of the sunna that began with the Prophet's (peace be upon him) tahannuth in the cave of Hira and continues with i'tikaf in Ramadan. — S. Uludağ, Tasavvuf Terimleri Sözlüğü (Dictionary of Sufi Terms), entry «Halvet»

This text has been compiled from the 4th lesson of Mustafa Özbağ Efendi's «Questions on al-Ghazali» lecture series and re-edited to thesis quality. Source video: YouTube

Additional sources:

  • The Holy Qur'an, al-Nahl 16:125; the principle of inviting with wisdom and good counsel.
  • The Holy Qur'an, al-Ahzab 33:21; the Messenger of Allah being the beautiful example.
  • al-Nawawi, Riyad al-Salihin, chapters on taqwa, sincerity and good character.
  • Imam al-Ghazali, Ihya' 'Ulum al-Din (The Revival of the Religious Sciences), chapters on the training of the heart, character and sincerity.
  • al-Bukhari, chapters of Iman and Riqaq, narrations on intention, sincerity and character.
  • Muslim, chapter of Birr and Sila, narrations on good character and brotherhood.
  • al-Tirmidhi, chapters of Birr and Sila, Zuhd and Da'awat.
  • al-Nawawi, Riyad al-Salihin, chapters on sincerity, taqwa, dhikr and good character.
  • Ibn Hajar al-'Asqalani, Fath al-Bari, commentary on the relevant narrations of al-Bukhari.
  • al-Qushayri, al-Risala, sections on the etiquette of Sufism, states and stations.