1. This Week's Text: Is al-Ghazali Part of a «Salafi Line»?
Yes, we are continuing with al-Ghazali, God willing.
Every week... probably after this week it will continue for two more weeks. It is wrapping up now. God willing, if Allah grants us life, we will have completed a study of al-Ghazali. We are continuing from last week, God willing. First I will read in full the part we will be discussing in our sohbet (spiritual discourse) tonight. After that, we will again make our way slowly, section by section.
It is clear that Imam al-Ghazali and the revival movement followed the same method. The essence of the movement consists of a return to the Qur'an, to the Sunna, and thus to the Asr-ı Saadet, that is, the period called the age of bliss of Islam, the period in which the Prophet Muhammad and the Companions lived. The leading figures of these ideas, as Hasan Aydın has also pointed out, are scholars whom we may call Salafi, such as Ahmad ibn Hanbal, a student of Imam al-Shafi'i and the founder of the Hanbali school, born in 780 and died in 855, and his followers Ibn Hazm of Andalusia, born in 994 and died in 1064, and Ibn Taymiyya of Harran, born in 1263. Died in 1328. Scholars who lived in more recent history, such as Muhammad ibn Abd al-Wahhab, who reproduced the same line with a more radical approach in the 18th century, born in 1703 and died in 1765, or political Islamists, are the most extreme examples of this line. That is the passage in question for tonight.
I took a short one. I noticed in the past weeks that we finish at 11, 11:30 or so. That's why I said, so it won't be long, and took a short passage. Well, as is known, al-Ghazali, of course, I say this in every lesson.
There are those who view him positively, and there are those who view him negatively. Well, there is no rule anyway that says everyone will view such a person positively. But we, in our own way, within our own circle, within our own sphere, state our perspective on al-Ghazali. We do not normally claim that it is necessarily this way. Of course, when we look at this text, these are, for instance, the standard ideas of people who generally call themselves contemporary, who want to be referred to that way. You may agree with it, you may not. These are different things, but normally, when we look at this text, I, within my own personal sphere, do not have the luxury of saying that this is entirely wrong either.
Just as there are correct observations in it, there are also debatable points when we look at it from a historical dimension. So I will list the things I have identified in my own way, without departing from the essence of the text. May Allah make us, and our thoughts, hit the mark, God willing. Amin. It is clear that al-Ghazali and the revival movement followed the same method.
2. What Is Meant by the «Revival Movement»?
What is meant here by the revival movement is, uh, the revitalisation of religious life, the revitalisation of religious thought.
It is not talking about the Ihya' 'Ulum al-Din (The Revival of the Religious Sciences). That is, today too, for example, religious thought and religious life need to be revitalised.
For example, the religious communities, the tariqas (Sufi orders), the groups we describe as political Islam, or society, society as a whole, truly need such a revival movement. This is my own view. There is a world of difference between what people, in quotation marks, live, or believe they live, or what they in their own way mean by this "Islam," and the Islam that the Qur'an and the Sunna set before us.
So, truly, when we look at it from this angle, it seems to me that the Islamic world today also needs a renewed revival movement.
Otherwise, I do not think that what is meant by revival here is the Ihya' 'Ulum al-Din.
3. The Picture in al-Ghazali's Time: The Separation of the Outward and the Inward
And indeed, when we look historically at al-Ghazali and the period of that day, the outward (zahir) part of religion had become separated.
The Batinis, who presented themselves as "battini," as it were, as "inward-ists." That is, the Batinis, as the Ismaili Fatimid Batini movement, formed a separate school.
And among those who called themselves Sufis, I won't say people like us, some stood at deviant points while others strove to stand on the line of the Qur'an and the Sunna. This being the case, al-Ghazali at this point aims to unite both the rulings and the understanding of the outward (zahir) and the inward (batin) of religion.
One of the most important measures of this is the Ihya' 'Ulum al-Din. In the Ihya' 'Ulum al-Din, while there are matters of what invalidates and what does not invalidate the prayer, that is fiqh (Islamic jurisprudence). It also describes the virtues of the prayer. This is normally the inward side of the matter, the spiritual side. Al-Ghazali tries to unite these in his own self. And, for example, for that day it had reached a peak, an interesting thing. My observations are my own. Surely you too are noticing these, you are noticing them.
4. Al-Ghazali's Real Target: Knowledge Without Practice
Today too, for example, there are people who have knowledge without practice.
5. This Illness Exists in the Dervish Too
What does knowledge without practice mean? He doesn't pray, doesn't keep the fast, doesn't give zakat, doesn't go on hajj. But he has more knowledge than you or me. That is, when we look today at the theology faculty or the imam-hatip circles, or, in quotation marks, I don't accept this, but we had talked about this at length. When we look at the gentlemen who today describe themselves, or are described, as Islamic politicians, under the heading of political life in Islam, there is knowledge without practice in them. That is, he knows more hadith than we do. He recites the Noble Qur'an beautifully, but there is no prayer. He recites the Noble Qur'an beautifully. A white skullcap on his head. Wherever he sees a mosque, a gathering? He recites the Eûzü and the Basmala more beautifully than I do. He recites them more beautifully than all of you, too. But, however, he also takes the bribe. They recite Surah Yasin wonderfully. I don't have it memorised. Ha, Surah Yasin.
They have Surah Yasin memorised, but the drawer of the bureaucracy, of the bureaucrats, is open. They take bribes shamelessly. They practise favouritism shamelessly. Al-Ghazali criticises this knowledge without practice. Look, he criticises knowledge without practice. That is, normally, our dervish brothers, our Sufi brothers, their knowledge is fine. There is no practice. How is there no practice? It has to do with morals. We pray, but we have a problem when it comes to morals.
And al-Ghazali criticises knowledge without practice. Otherwise, al-Ghazali has no problem with knowledge. And we see this with al-Ghazali especially when we study the Ihya'. When we look at the Ihya', he puts sincerity (ikhlas), genuineness, and good character at the forefront.
6. Al-Ghazali Puts Not Worship but Sincerity and Morals at the Forefront
Look, when you look at al-Ghazali, he does not put much emphasis on worship.
Al-Ghazali puts morals at the forefront. He puts genuineness at the forefront, he puts sincerity at the forefront. Al-Ghazali, uh, that is exactly what we need today anyway.
We are not normally people who expect a great deal of knowledge. But sincerity is needed, genuineness is needed. As the Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, says in the hadith, religion is sincerity.
Well, religion is sincerity. Well, what we too want and seek right now is sincerity among the religious, sincerity among the Sufis, sincerity among the politicians, sincerity in the bureaucracy; that is what we need too.
7. «What If the Mosques Overflow?»
Well, and in al-Ghazali's time, what does al-Ghazali do?
Normally he puts sincerity and morals at the forefront. Look, he puts sincerity and morals at the forefront.
Your mosques may be full to overflowing, but if right next door, in an apartment building or in those things they call "aparts", prostitution has run rampant, or if drugs in the country have come down to the age of 12, 13, or else if prostitution in the country has come down to the age of 14, 15, then what difference does it make if the mosques are overflowing? Or else, let your mosques be full and overflowing, wonderful, but if those who openly commit the filth that the people of Lot committed are roaming the streets freely, and if they have become first-class citizens in the country, while my bearded, robed, turbaned and headscarved brothers and sisters are still treated as second-class citizens in the country, then it no longer has any meaning. Here, normally, morals have not been put at the forefront, sincerity has not been put at the forefront, genuineness has not been put at the forefront, the principles of the Qur'an and the noble Sunna have not been put at the forefront.
And al-Ghazali struggles to keep the living of religion alive within society and to keep religious life alive, and he puts forward ijtihads so that religion may once again become livable.
And when we look at it normally, then the concept of ihya', that is, renewing, living anew, tajdid, the concept of renewal, from al-Ghazali, gathers around al-Ghazali. That being so, anyway, yes.
8. Murtada al-Zabidi's Judgment on al-Ghazali
And this observation, I mean, I accept al-Ghazali's ihya' movement as correct, and those who came after al-Ghazali have magnificent observations concerning al-Ghazali.
One of those observations is from the commentator of the Ihya', that is, the one who wrote a commentary on the Ihya'. The great scholar, the Hanafi jurist, the hadith hafiz Imam Murtada al-Zabidi, may Allah be pleased with him, said the following. Imam al-Ghazali is, by consensus, an authority (hujja) in fiqh, in usul al-fiqh and in usul al-din.
That is, he is a proof. In Sufism (tasawwuf) he is the possessor of the supreme siddiqiyya. In the Shafi'i school he is one of the ashab al-wujuh and of tarjih, and he is an imam. Now, while there are those who praise al-Ghazali like this, would we call these the new contemporary Islamic thinkers? Would we or would we not? Would we call them the Islamic intellectual class or not? All of these are matters of debate. Why are they matters of debate? I mean, those they put in front of us as intellectuals, those they put in front of us as the intellectuals of the Islamic milieu, some of them with a cigar in their mouths, legs crossed one over the other. He says "the Prophet" or "Muhammad wishes thus." No adding the salat, the salat and salam after it. Some of them, with their foulard worn to the side, are handing down verdicts.
9. Those Put in Front of Us as «Intellectuals»
Some of them, normally, have come out in front of us in different outfits, handing down verdicts.
The great majority of them are a Soros-backed troop of so-called ulama supported by Western sources. Some of them are of a masonic mentality. Mason. Plain and simple mason. Inside the faculties of theology, outside the faculties of theology, inside the Diyanet, outside the Diyanet, these masonic mentalities, these Sabbatean mentalities, these Dajjalist mentalities, just as back then they normally criticized al-Ghazali's path, or else al-Ghazali's ihya' movement, or al-Ghazali's knowledge and stance, today too they criticize the ulama who stand purely on the line of the Qur'an and Sunna, and the Sufi folk who stand on the line of the Qur'an and Sunna.
Because they are Dajjalist, Sabbatean, Jewish-sourced Soros-fed people who do not want the pure implementation of the Qur'an and the Sunna. Soros-fed. In our Islamic society there are many Soros-fed theologians, Soros-fed people posing as great scholars, Soros-fed politicians, Soros-fed people who appear to be the intellectual class. I mean, when you look back into his past, he has received a scholarship from a foundation backed by Soros.
He has received a scholarship. There are many people in front of us who serve in the state bureaucracy, who serve as ministers, who do politics, who are members of parliament, who have received a scholarship from a foundation or an institution backed by Soros, many who have supposedly done lots of studies with Europeans; there are such people in the Islamic world, and in our country too there are such people. These, of course, heavily criticize al-Ghazali and his line.
10. The Gentleman Who Says «Most of the Hadiths in the Ihya' Are Not Sound»
For example, on this subject, someone who has supposedly become a great scholar of hadith.
He says, "The great majority of the hadiths in al-Ghazali's Ihya' are not sound (sahih)." That is what he says. These are people who could not even be the dust on al-Ghazali's fingernail.
But he has taken on the task of tearing the Ihya' to pieces. He explains that the hadiths in the Ihya' are not sound. He said this. I am giving this as an example. He said it on television. I listened. And I threw it in the trash. Or else, a professor who is regarded as a scholar had said this. And I threw it in the trash. I mean, normally, if you are saying that, you are not giving al-Ghazali his due. Or else, you know how today in the Islamic world the bureaucrat and political class who see themselves as somewhat Islamic intellectuals put Ali Shariati in front of us.
Who? Ali Shariati, a denier of hadith. I mean, in our country too there are professors serving on the fatwa board of the Presidency of Religious Affairs (Diyanet) who say that even the verses should be approached with suspicion. He will look even at a verse with suspicion. And he says this in our country. Yet that person is not put on trial for inciting the public to hostility on account of people's religious beliefs, and this person is employed at the Diyanet institution, and he does not even claim that he did not say these words. These are anti-Ghazalians. These are anti-Qur'an. These are anti-Sunna. These are anti-Sufi. These are anti-jurists. These are anti-fiqh, that is. He rejects fiqh. These reject the hadiths. I mean, you will look at all the hadiths with suspicion.
You will even look at a verse with suspicion. He is playing with people's faith. May Allah forgive us. We are progressing slowly on this subject, you see. What is the second thing I have identified? Return to the Qur'an and the Sunna and to the Age of Bliss. What a magnificent thing. Isn't that so? When we look, look here, the point that Aydın normally criticizes: in al-Ghazali, he says, there is a return to the Qur'an and the Sunna. There is also a return to the Age of Bliss. He strives for this, he says. Well, now when we look, yes, that is true. Al-Ghazali struggles for this.
11. The Second Observation: «Return to the Qur'an and the Sunna, to the Age of Bliss»
I mean, in the yearning, in the longing to live the Islam of the Age of Bliss, which Muslim would not want the Islamic life, the Islamic way of living, the Islamic thought of the Age of Bliss, which Muslim?
A conscious believer. If we now asked conscious Muslims one by one, wouldn't you want to live the Islam of the Age of Bliss? Everyone would say yes. But these anti-Ghazalians and anti-Qur'anists, these anti-noble-Sunna people, do not want this. Yes. Openly, in this country too, there are those who do not want a complete life and thought of the Qur'an and Sunna to prevail. They appear as if they were one of us. And yes, whether you look at al-Ghazali's Ihya' or at his other works, when we look at it religiously, he wants the Muslims of that day to live the religion that the righteous predecessors (al-salaf al-salih) lived. Today, normally, if we said to any Muslim who knows himself, wouldn't you want to live the Islam that the Companions lived? Yes.
Which Muslim would not want to live Islam at the knee of the Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him?
There is nothing in this to be criticized. There is something in this to be ashamed of, to feel regret over. How? Why? We need to be ashamed and feel regret because we cannot live it.
12. The Confusion Surrounding the Concept of Salaf
But here, of course, when we say al-salaf al-salih (the righteous predecessors), or when we say Salafi, there is a confusion of concepts in this country.
The reason: a group of people emerged.
13. The Difference on Four Counts: Sufism, Kalam, Logic, Ijtihad
They described themselves as Salafi. Their Salafi understanding, their thinking, their way of life and al-Ghazali's understanding of the salaf are not at the same point. Today's movement, which you could call neo-Salafi, that is, the new Salafi movement, is a movement of 15-20 years. Let's say 30 years since it got its name. When I had newly become a Muslim, this movement was new. We would have these kinds of debates, these exchanges with them, all night long. These people, this new movement, for example, do not accept Sufism or the people of tasawwuf.
But al-Ghazali accepts it. These people, for example, reject kalam.
Al-Ghazali accepts kalam. Well, these people reject logic.
Al-Ghazali accepts logic. He accepts it, he embraces it. This so-called Salafi, this new Salafi movement, for example, does not value ijtihad.
But al-Ghazali values ijtihad. That is why those persons, those individuals who appear today as the Salafi movement, not only fail to unite with al-Ghazali on the point of Sufism, on the point of kalam, on the point of logic and on the point of ijtihad, but they also cannot get along with those who today hold a sound understanding of Sufism based on the Qur'an and Sunna.
14. «They Issue Fatwas Declaring Us Unbelievers Because We Do Dhikrullah»
For example, a Salafi, very easily, regarding me, let me speak about myself, issues a fatwa declaring me an unbeliever.
Very easily. Why? Because we do dhikrullah (remembrance of Allah), and supposedly there can be no such dhikrullah. Therefore we are people of bid'a (innovation). If we are people of bid'a, then we are people of unbelief. When I say, what is your proof that it is not so, he says, there is no such thing. You put forward a hadith that it is dhikrullah in congregation. There, you put in front of him the hadith that describes the virtues of dhikrullah in congregation.
Then you put forward verses of the Qur'an related to dhikr. He has put on blinkers like a horse. He doesn't want to see anything else. Well, when we look now, aren't there people in our country who present themselves as great scholars ('allama), who find the dhikr worship of today's Sufis, their remembering Allah when they gather, distasteful, who see it as wrong, see it as deficient, and even see it as bid'a?
There are. What are these, then? From where? Whose hirelings are these? These are Soros's hirelings. These are a spoiled black breed. These are Mossad's floozies.
15. A Harsh Answer and Its Justification
And then they say to me, "Well, would such things come out of the mouth of a saint (wali)?
I should actually say worse, but my adab does not permit it. You are a Mossad mongrel. You are nothing else. You are a CIA floozy. You are nothing else. You are a Soros hireling. You are nothing else. If you are trying to silence a voice in your own country that says Qur'an and Sunna, that says homeland and nation, you are the very unbeliever himself. You are the very hypocrite himself. You are nothing else.
You don't deserve adab, so why should we treat you with adab? Whoever behaves without adab toward one who deserves to be treated with adab is the one without adab.
But approaching with adab someone who has no adab, a traitor, an infidel, an unbeliever, someone who attacks your religion, your faith, your homeland, your nation, your flag, is a lack of wisdom. That is injustice. You cannot approach a traitor with adab. A traitor is a traitor. Because a traitor is not approached with adab. Whoever approaches him with adab is blind. He has received no share of wisdom, received no share of virtue, received no share of the spirit of jihad. He is one of the vulgar ones. He is nothing else. So then you, brother, you who say Qur'an and Sunna, who say homeland and nation, who at this point remember Allah in your own way: in accordance with the hadith, the hadith qudsi, they, although they have no trade between them, although they are not relatives, although they draw no benefit from one another, love one another for the sake of Allah, and when they gather they remember Allah.
Those people will be shaded in the shade of Allah on the Day of Gathering, when there is no other shade. If you brand as unbelievers a Sufi community gathered fi sabilillah (in the way of Allah) to live this hadith qudsi, then yes, you are the very vulgar one himself. Yes, you are a Soros hireling, a Mossad floozy, a CIA mongrel. you are nothing else. You are a devil. You are a person who has become a devil. You are a prostitute who has sold yourself to the Dajjal-system. An ordinary prostitute sells her body. You have sold your faith. What I say to you is not too harsh for you. It is even mild. Yes. That is why al-Ghazali's struggle was with hypocrites who appear as if they were Islam.
16. Against Whom Was al-Ghazali's Struggle?
What al-Ghazali did is also related to deviants without deeds who appear as if they were Islam, as if they were Sufism. Whom does al-Ghazali fight? Struggle against, on the intellectual plane? The Batinis. Whom? The Isma'iliyya school. Whom? The Fatimid school.
Al-Ghazali does not fight the Ja'faris. Al-Ghazali fights the Hashashin (Assassins). Al-Ghazali's war is with these; well, now, are there Hashashin of our own day?
There are. I am not the one who appears to be one of us and snorts heroin and cocaine. I am not the one who sends Friday greetings and snorts cocaine in his car. I am not the one who sends Friday greetings and takes bribes. I am not the one who sends Friday greetings and then, when Ramadan comes, commits who knows what dishonorable acts on who knows which islands. I am not the one who puts a white cap on his head, recites Surah Ya-Sin among people, and then carries off bribes by the sackful. Nor is this community.
17. «We Go Hungry So As Not to Exploit the Religion»
When we gather, we remember Allah fi sabilillah. We don't say "Shay'an lillah (something for Allah's sake), hands into pockets." We ask nothing from anyone. And we say, whoever asks is not one of us. We say, if we ask, may our tongue be torn out. Yes.
We go hungry so as not to exploit the religion. We don't say we're hungry. So as not to exploit the religion, we don't do it, saying, brothers, this place has rent to pay. How will I manage? But we don't do that. we are not floozies, we are not beggars. We are not of corrupt milk, of corrupt blood.
We are truly, truly out in the open. We are the ones who hold fast to the Qur'an and Sunna and cry out the principles of the Qur'an and Sunna. When we love, we love all the way. We love for the sake of Allah. No one can stand in the way of our love. Our hatred is for the unbeliever, for the hypocrite, for the enemies of religion; we do not wage war on Muslims, on believers. But our business is with those of corrupt milk who appear to be Muslim. We have no business with anyone else. We are on the same line as al-Ghazali. Yes. we are on the same line. That is why I come here having studied al-Ghazali in greater depth. We continue with the names. Ahmad ibn Hanbal, Ibn Hazm, Ibn Taymiyya, are they the same line? That's what it says, right? Our brother who wrote the text, or rather Aydın who relayed the text, says so, right?
18. Now Let's Look at the Names: Who Is Ahmad ibn Hanbal?
Well, now we need to look at these a bit. Well, how will we look? When we look at Ahmad ibn Hanbal, our Ahmad ibn Hanbal is a hadith scholar.
He is of the Hanbali school. He is a student of Imam al-Shafi'i. Imam al-Shafi'i is on the line of Imam Malik and of Imam-i A'zam (Abu Hanifa). Normally you wouldn't know Imam al-Shafi'i as being on the line of Imam-i A'zam. Well, now when we look, yes, Ahmad ibn Hanbal keeps somewhat of a distance from kalam, but he is a great mujahid.
He is a great resister. The great majority of the entire Islamic ummah sees Ahmad ibn Hanbal as a hadith scholar and at the same time as the founder of a school. Don't see him that way. Ahmad ibn Hanbal is the greatest resister of his own time. What does he resist? Mihna is the Abbasid caliph of the Mihna period.
19. The Mihna Period: The Imposition of «The Qur'an Is Created»
In that period his caliphate lasts about 15 years. In this period the caliph makes the Mu'tazila's view that the Qur'an is created into the official ideology of the state and tries to force the scholars to accept it.
And those who refuse are subjected to torture. Look, the debate over whether the Qur'an is created. This is normally a system of thought whose seeds were sown in the time of the Umayyads, in the time of Hazrat Imam-i A'zam. Let me put it that way. It is an ijtihad.
Imam-i A'zam struggled against it with all his might. Imam Malik struggled against it. Imam al-Shafi'i struggled against it. Then the turn in the struggle comes to Ibn Hanbal. And Ibn Hanbal, regarding this, rejects it.
When he rejects it, he is imprisoned and tortured. Imam Hanbal is subjected to very severe tortures, and the Mihna period, that Mihna Abbasid caliph, wants to have him executed. The soldiers take him from the prison where he was normally held. While he is being taken to be executed, on the way, the Mihna period is overthrown. That is, the Abbasid caliph... from execution, the Almighty (Allah) saves him that way. And normally, you know, he waged a very great war against the idea that the Qur'an is created, that it was brought into being, and he resisted. He is someone who was tortured and saw prison over this matter. Prison... at that time the qadis, the hadith scholars, the ulema are interrogated, and those who do not say the Qur'an is created, some are hanged, some are thrown into prison, some are subjected to tortures, some are dismissed from their posts, and normally their testimony is declared invalid in that period.
That is, if you don't say the Qur'an is created, you cannot bear witness. There is such a period of torture. Of 15 years. And normally Ahmad ibn Hanbal is the flags of that resistance. He is the banners of that resistance.
He is the great scholar of that resistance. He is the great hadith scholar of that resistance. He is the great jurist of that resistance, a great authority on creed of that resistance. With Ahmad ibn Hanbal. Now, have you been able to reconcile Salafism with that? Now, can you reconcile Ahmad ibn Hanbal with today's Salafi movements?
20. Ahmad ibn Hanbal Is Not Against Sufism: The Story of Shayban al-Ra'i
And Ahmad ibn Hanbal is not against Sufism (tasawwuf) either.
You know, it's well known, whether it happened or not. There's a conversation related to Shayban al-Ra'i, you know. You know, Imam Hanbal, the student of Imam al-Shafi'i, you know, it's well known about Imam al-Shafi'i. You know, he says: this Shayban al-Ra'i is ignorant, why do you tremble like this, quivering, in front of him? You're a great imam, he says. And normally, you know, to show his own knowledge and Shayban al-Ra'i's lack of knowledge, he says, "It's well known, you know, that incident.
I'm going to ask him a question, he says. Imam al-Shafi'i says, "Don't ask." But at that time there's that kind of arrogance of knowledge, you know. He says, "Master, I'm going to ask you a question."
Go ahead, ask. If a person has failed to pray one of the prayer times, and forgets which time he didn't pray, which one should he make up, he asks, and Shayban al-Ra'i immediately turns.
That person has spent his whole day in heedlessness. Let him make up all his prayers. Imam Hanbal faints flat out.
He's not ready for such an answer. Then Imam al-Shafi'i says to him, "Didn't I tell you?" he says. "Don't overstep your bounds." There's that kind of knowledge, you know. It is insolent.
21. A Jest: «What Did You Graduate From?»
I'm going to ask you a question. Whoever I've asked until today couldn't answer it. The things I'm subjected to. God forbid (Astaghfirullah). Go ahead, ask. Will you be able to answer? We're scholars of what we know. He asks. Now there you are, giving the answer. What did you graduate from? Allah Allah. I told one person: primary school.
You're lying, he said. No, I'm a primary school graduate, I said. He's asking about the last thing you graduated from, you know, in his own mind. What did you graduate from? Primary school. I graduated from primary school. Then if he'd asked, I'd say middle school. He just doesn't get it. What did you graduate from, he said. Primary school, I said. And even that was hard, I said.
How do you mean, he said. My grandfather was a grocer, I said. The teacher always owed us money, I said. It really was like that. I could never study my whole life. That's why someone here doesn't study at all either. I can't get angry at him. But I'm not a grocer, you see. My grandfather was a grocer. Hey teacher, what are you complaining about, man? The teacher is complaining about me.
What are you complaining about, man? Shall we change your school? He doesn't change me. He'll change the teacher's school, of course. Ah, half the district is in his books. Hey teacher, what are you complaining about? Shall we change your school? No. Uncle Ahmet, I didn't mean it that way, hey, don't be like that. What's the man supposed to do, he'll pass me? What would he say, what? Well, my primary school graduation is like that. May Allah forgive us. And the middle school graduation has to do with Seval Kaplan. She took the report card and passed it around everywhere. That's how we graduated from middle school. May Allah forgive us. He's one of those "people of knowledge," you know. When I said primary school to "what did you graduate from," he flipped out. May Allah forgive us. And on top of that he says, you're lying. May my Lord forgive us. Ibn Hazm. That is, now it's not possible for Ibn Hazm and Imam Hanbal to be on the same line. It's not possible for Ibn Hazm and Imam al-Ghazali to be on the same line. Look. Ah, you'll say. Doesn't this Aydın know these things? An example.
Doesn't Aydın know? He probably knows better than I do, but he'll build a connection that doesn't exist so that he can belittle al-Ghazali in the eyes of Muslims. These are connections that don't exist. Well now, how are they connections that don't exist?
22. Ibn Hazm: The Zahiri School and the Rejection of Qiyas
Ibn Hazm is of the Zahiri school,
Not Hanbali, not Maliki. Not Hanafi, not Shafi'i. What? Zahiri. Now, the Zahiris reject qiyas (analogical reasoning).
Al-Ghazali accepts qiyas. Well, the Hanbali also accepts qiyas. All four of the four schools accept qiyas. The Zahiris don't accept it. Well, Ibn Hazm is a very strong logician.
Accepting logic is one thing. Deifying logic is another thing. Ibn Hazm is a very strong logician.
23. A Bayındır Jest: «Are You an Aristotelian?»
I'm not saying it in the sense of deification now, so that I don't fall into sin. But normally al-Ghazali accepts logic. He accepts from logic, he benefits from logic. But according to al-Ghazali, not everything is logic. Because the limit of everything is in the Qur'an and the Sunna. It's like that in al-Ghazali and in Imam Hanbal too. It's not like that in Ibn Hazm. Ibn Hazm, moreover, is a very orthodox sort of Aristotelian. He is such a strict Aristotelian that he doesn't merely benefit from Aristotle's logic. He accepts it completely. He is a very strict Aristotelian. Ibn Hazm. For example, go now, those who see themselves as intellectuals at universities will put not Aristotle but Ibn Hazm in front of you.
Now if he says Aristotle to you, you'll give him a direct, rhythmic answer. You'll stand against it. What the hell, in our Anatolian or folk expression now, what the hell? They'll say to him, are you an Aristotelian? What? Meaning you're on the Greeks' side, huh. What the hell? Was your mother Greek? Was your father Greek? That's what the conversation will be. Well now, I'm a Bayındır kid.
If you come before me as an Aristotelian, what are you, when the Greeks came here did your mother and father get mixed up with them? I'll say, I'm going to do something with them. Because there really are those who got mixed up with them when the Greeks came.
My late maternal grandfather was an Efe. He knew those who had got mixed up. When someone was talking about one of them, he'd say like this, "Oh go on, you donkey's kereta, drop that," when he said drop a whole family, ha, nobody would do anything. I'm standing there. What happened in that family? Then when we were alone, grandpa, huh, you did that to that family, you wiped them out and threw them away. Such-and-such of theirs' so-and-so had an aunt. That aunt of theirs, well, there was a Greek sergeant there. She was flirting with him. The man knows the history of Bayındır. When the Greeks came to Bayındır, which family gave them wheat? Which one gave flour? Which one gave meat? Gave meat of the other kind? The man knows. When that's done, stop. Now go and talk about Aristotle to a Bayındır kid. The man will say, "What the hell? Are you some Greek knock-off?" But now in our Islamic world there are Ibn Hazm followers.
Ha, a man who's a hadith professor. You're talking. While he's describing Ibn Hazm's logic, I say to myself, this one is an Aristotelian too. Now rejecting Aristotle's logic is a different thing. Using from his logic. Knowledge, even if it is in China, is the lost property of the Muslim. Using it is a separate thing, but this is a typical, fierce Aristotelian. This is a different thing. Well, Ibn Hazm too is, well, an extremely rigid Aristotelian like this. And an orthodox sort at that. Well now, when we look, for example, can we call Ibn Hazm the continuation of Ibn Hanbal? No. Can we call him the continuation of al-Ghazali? No. Well, Aydın, where did you get this from? Where did you make this up from? When we look, their lines are very different. Of course, while writing this passage now, Aydın, I mean, doesn't think about whether someone in the Islamic world will get up and examine these individuals' ideas, thoughts, attitudes, styles and paths or not. They won't examine them.
He's the authority. If Ibn Hazm said it's on this line, sit on that line. In place of where you sit, someone comes along, someone like me whom you see as ignorant, and sits down. He studies Ibn Hazm too, he studies Aristotle too, he studies Ibn Khaldun too. He studies Muhyiddin Ibn Arabi too. He comes here and disgraces you. Yes. How are you going to see them on the same line? Ibn Hanbal has no connection at all with Aristotle. He doesn't accept Aristotle's logic either. He is directly a man of hadith. He takes Islam directly on the axis of hadith. It's not about rejecting the verses here. On what basis are you putting them on the same line? You can't. Ibn Taymiyya, now when we look, let's open that up a bit too.
24. Ibn Taymiyya: Common Points and Serious Divergences
Now when we look at Ibn Taymiyya, he is a scholar who comes from the Hanbali tradition. But Ibn Taymiyya criticizes many of al-Ghazali's ideas. He even rejects them. For example, he rejects al-Ghazali's perspective on the Sufis, on Sufism. He rejects kalam. Ibn Taymiyya also rejects some of the institutions and establishments of Sufism, its system of thought, its system of life. Philosophy, well, it's not even criticizing; Ibn Taymiyya rejects it outright. Well, therefore, al-Ghazali and Ibn Taymiyya do have common points, but they have serious differences of thought. They have very serious differences in fiqh. So on what basis are we now going to put al-Ghazali and Ibn Taymiyya on the same line? It's not possible. Look, it's not possible. Now sometimes friends, brothers ask me, "Should we read Ibn Taymiyya?" I say, I don't read him. What do you say?
I say, I'm not saying anything about Ibn Taymiyya. Why? Now these, Ibn Taymiyya has, you know, places where he's against Sufism. He has places where he accepts Sufism. There are places where he accepts al-Ghazali, Muhyiddin Ibn Arabi. There are places where he criticizes them very decisively, sharply. There are many places. But now sit down and, you know, recommend this to the friends. It's a bit difficult.
25. According to al-Ghazali, the Heart Is Purified Only Through Sufism
Well now, do I see al-Ghazali and Ibn Taymiyya on the same line? No. Absolutely not. First of all, according to al-Ghazali, without a Sufi way of thinking, a Sufi mind, a Sufi heart, the purification of the heart is not possible. The purification of the heart is possible only through Sufism. According to al-Ghazali, that is, if a person is not one of the people of Sufism, if he has no murshid (spiritual guide), that person's heart cannot be purified, cannot be cleansed. I'm saying this according to al-Ghazali. But when we look at Ibn Taymiyya, I mean, he doesn't reject Sufism entirely. But, for example, he criticizes and rejects wahdat al-wujud (the unity of being) in a very harsh way. He harshly criticizes some tariqa practices. At this point, Ibn Taymiyya's understanding of Sufism and al-Ghazali's understanding of Sufism, it's not possible. They don't match each other. They're not on the same line. Well, when that's the case, it's not possible anyway to see him on the same line. How is he supposed to have been influenced by al-Ghazali and come to such a point?
No, that's not possible either. Well, let's come now to Abd al-Wahhab. That is, Wahhabism, which forms the religious belief, forms the foundation, of today's Saudi state system. Well now, when we look at Wahhabism, people in general, for example, define the Wahhabis in their own way like this.
26. Abd al-Wahhab and Wahhabism
They define themselves that way anyway. Imam Hanbal, Ibn Taymiyya, Ibn Qayyim. And then, what's his name, what is it? Abd al-Wahhab. But it's not possible to stick al-Ghazali onto this line, this category. Besides, Abd al-Wahhab is a controversial figure. How is he a controversial figure? He is a British agent. He is a creature fed by the British. He is the religious foundation of the political circle formed to stab the Ottomans in the back. If we open this up a bit more, things will be shaken from their place. That is, the British founded the Saudi state. When the British founded the Saudi state, they would never want a state on the line of the Qur'an and the Sunna. In none of the countries the Ottomans left behind do they leave a state on the line of the Qur'an and the Sunna. The British, none of all the states founded after the Ottomans is a state on the line of the Qur'an and the Sunna either.
Their foundations were laid differently, each in its own way, so that, with their foundations laid differently, when the time came they would clash with one another. So that they would fight. When that's the case, normally here in Anatolia too, in the first years of the founding, in Anatolia in the last period of the Ottomans, these, almost whenever the turn of the sohbet comes to it, there are tariqas founded by the British. There are communities founded by the British. The thing I mention from time to time, that these run free in this country, run riot, exists in Saudi Arabia too. That's why Abd al-Wahhab, in this sense, and this is my own personal opinion. He is a person who is a British agent. He is a student of Lawrence.
27. Why Is There No One to Say This? The Visa Issue
There is no one at all who will say these things with courage. Do you know why you can't say them? Do you know why they can't say them? Because the Saudis take note, and set aside, every scholar, every member of the ulema, every tariqa sheikh who voices this kind of thing. When you apply for a hajj or umrah visa, they won't give you a hajj or umrah visa. I'm someone who has been turned down for a visa two or three times. Yes. For no reason. The last time, Hacı Ahmet's older brother and so on, a few people like that, the owners of Korkmaz, Sait knows them. We applied again in Istanbul to go on hajj. So, like this, we were going to get a worker's visa. Butcher's assistant. I'm saying to myself, well, maybe it'll work out in Istanbul. Lift the weight, put it down. Hacı Sait knows this kind of thing. Back in the earlier days, the times when I was going to go. All of them went. I couldn't get a visa. And I'm the youngest among them. They're tearing themselves apart over why it didn't work out.
And of course money is flying around in the air too. You know, Ahmet Acar is in on it too, he's going to sort it out with money. My case didn't get sorted out. They went. After that we applied once more. Again it didn't work. After that, our Hacı Sait's, may Allah be pleased with him, that blacksmith of ours, what was his name? Yakup said, "I'll sort it out," he said. Hacı Sait knows that conversation too. After that I said, "Okay, if you're going to sort it out, take the passport." We went with Kasapoğlu that time, didn't we? The first time we went with Kasapoğlu. How the visa came to me on a worker's visa, I don't know. I don't mind telling this, mind you. It's no trouble to me. Now, that being so, for example, when you look at al-Ghazali's Ihya', the Sufism there that has been methodised, made methodical, for example, has been put into methodical form.
28. The Sufism in the Ihya' and Wahhabi Thought Are Irreconcilable
Sufi knowledge, the knowledge of the Sufis, the stories of the saints: when you look at the Ihya', you find these. Methods of dhikr, methods and methodology of training the heart. When you look at all of these, you see that al-Ghazali and Wahhabi thought stand at very opposed points. For example, when you go to Mecca, you cannot display such a Sufi stance. In fact, let me say it openly. You can't gather ten people in Mecca, normally at the House of Allah, ten people in one place, and form a circle like this. Even if you do nothing at all, the Saudis will come and break up that circle. God forbid they hear you reciting the words of tawhid like this while circumambulating the House of Allah. In '92 I'm on hajj. I'm on my own. La ilaha illallah. La ilaha illallah. La ilaha illallah. Saying la ilaha illallah over and over, I'm performing the tawaf. Like this, that's all.
29. A Tawaf in Ninety-Two: «Are We Not to Remember You Even in Your Own House?»
Look, I mean, quietly like this: la ilaha illallah. La ilaha illallah. That's how I'm saying it. A man in a robe came up like this and shook me like this. I'm wearing a turban, of course. I have a haydari vest on, a turban. Sufi la, Sufi la, Sufi la, Sufi la, he's saying. He's shouting like this. And there's youth too, you know, I said, "Dhikrullah, Allah," I said back. Now he stayed there like that, of course. The tawaf pushes you from behind, you know. All of a sudden he let go of my arm. I began. O Lord, are we not to remember You even in Your own House? He has climbed up on this marble and is looking around like a tough guy. You know, he's looking for me. I looked like this. I said "Allah Allah," now he looked at that in the tawaf, now he himself is crazy. I'm crazier than him. Of course the tawaf moves on. This time I let it all out. Remembering "Allah Allah, Allah Allah," I'm performing the tawaf. And Sheikh Efendi, may Allah have mercy on him, was under the Golden Spout (Altınoluk); the tawaf ended.
I went and greeted him. He pointed to the place beside him like this. I went and sat beside him. "What happened?" he said. I said, "Efendim, it happened like this and like this." He did this, shook his head. It hurt me so much, there's youth, you know, and on top of that you can't stomach it. And it's not something to be stomached either. I'm letting it out, pouring it out, bringing the house down. Even in Your House we are not to remember Allah. Are we this much of a stranger? I'm already someone with no one. I've come here, I said. Am I going to taste my having no one here too? Are You going to make me taste my loneliness here too? Are You going to make me taste my strangeness here too? Am I not going to be able to remember You here too? Am I not going to be able to do this here too? At the station of Ismail, peace be upon him, there are those marbles, you know, he's standing on those marbles, you know.
I looked: Sheikh Efendi, with an Ottoman slap, pat pat pat, how he's beating him, but him, my... but my heart won't cool down, I'm still saying, was I going to be a stranger here too, I said, in my own country I'm raided every night, I said, police investigations, this and that, I said, I can't remember You there, I can't remember You here, where am I going to remember You? Am I not going to be able to cry out Your name? Am I not going to be able to say Your name? I keep pouring it out. Sheikh Efendi is beside me too, but when I say beside me, out of courtesy I'm about a knee's length behind him. I'm both pouring it out and opening my eyes like this. Sheikh Efendi is beating him. I close them, Sheikh Efendi is beating him. At one point he looked like this and said "Hu." I stopped. Not a single word. An hour later, the man is gone too.
30. «My Son, He Got the Spiritual Slap»
For the rest of the hajj period I never saw him there again. Afterwards we went together on umrahs many times, went on hajj, and so on. I never saw the man. Of course, after this state, "What happened?" he said. I said, "Efendim, it happened like this, like this, like this, like this." "My son, he got the spiritual slap," he said. "That'll teach him not to lay hands on every dervish he comes across." That's what he said. "Let him know his place," he said. "Yes," he said, "okay, the matter is finished." Sometimes the matter goes out of your hands, out of my hands. Once the matter has been referred to the spiritual realm? Its punishment is great. That's why I say it. Be careful about your dealings with dervishes. May Allah protect us. (Amin.)
31. On the Concept of «Political Islam»
The connection to political Islam is there at the end of the text too, you know. "Political Islamists" is used like this. Well, actually I'm against this word, because it's a broad concept. In every country, everywhere, different identities, personalities, groups can fall within it. For example, there were the Muslim Brothers, you know, they were famous for a while, the Muslim Brotherhood that we call the Ikhwan al-Muslimin; in Africa under different names, and as we come here towards Asia, I mean Morocco, Tunisia, Algeria, Egypt, then Jordan, from here Syria, Iraq. On this line, normally, you know, the communities with a political stance that we call the Ikhwan al-Muslimin, the Ikhwan al-Muslimin and the Muslim Brotherhood, in Turkey the Welfare Party, Milli Görüş (National Outlook), they are pretty much the same line in Turkey. And normally, what we might call the Salafi movements, you know, when we look at the Salafis in today's new sense, you know, there's the Jama'at-i Islami of these Islamic things.
Then, you know, in Pakistan, what was it, there's the Tablighi Jama'at in Pakistan. In Turkey, and like this all over the world, there are communities as the Tablighi Jama'at, right. When we look at these, all of them, for example, in their concepts of belief and creed and their convictions, and in their understanding and concepts of fiqh, and as for their view of Sufism, all of them are already in rejection. Well, normally, when we look at their understanding of the state, some of them resemble each other, but some of them are very far from each other. Well, for this reason, normally, showing them on a single line, showing all of them on al-Ghazali's line, for me, is overstepping the bounds. Well, if it's like that, then when we take them into that, you know, that general assessment, all of them, some of them later on, for example, well, they evolve, they get overturned, they get recruited. Al-Qaeda comes out of them. So-and-so comes out of them.
I mean, normally, when we look now, CIA men come out of them. I mean, CIA men. Mossad men come out of them. Well, floozies come out of them. Bribe-takers come out of them. Cronyists come out of them. Among them, you look and someone has gone and made a deal with the English. Among them, you look and some of them have received training from Mossad. Among them, you look and the man is an operative raised by the CIA. Among them, from within various communities and tariqas, there come certain personages who received training from the CIA, received training from Mossad, grew up in America's lap, and are still in America's lap. These have no tie, no connection with al-Ghazali's line. These have no tie, no connection with the line of the Qur'an and Sunna either.
Since some of them are like that, it is also not possible to see them on al-Ghazali's line or to see al-Ghazali at their foundation. And that being so, I mean, al-Ghazali's idea of returning to the essence, to the Qur'an and Sunna, is my idea too. At this point, if we normally read this as a historical tradition, the great majority of these listed individuals, with the exception of one, Ibn Hanbal, are not on al-Ghazali's line. I mean, when we look at Ahmad ibn Hanbal, he is a person centred on hadith and Sunna. Al-Ghazali, too, by synthesising the kalam of Ahl al-Sunna, fiqh and Sufism, tried to revive the religion. He tried to revive religious life. If you look at Ibn Hazm, with a Zahiri method he defends a law independent of the Qur'an and Sunna, Ibn Hazm the Zahiri. Let me blow that one open too.
32. Ibn Hazm's Present-Day Extension: Those Who Say «It Won't Work with 1400-Year-Old Law»
You know how today people tell you, those who say "we cannot be governed by the law of 1400 years ago," they are Ibn Hazm followers.
33. Conclusion: Except for Ibn Hanbal, This Line Is Not al-Ghazali's Line
When you say that, this society doesn't know where that phrase, that saying, comes from in the tradition or in its historical dimension. In his own way he says, "Yes, the religion needs to be renewed," he says. "The religion doesn't need to be renewed. The religious people need to be renewed." Let them not try to make us swallow Ibn Hazm's understanding of law independent of the Qur'an and Sunna as bait. I mean, the one who does not tie thought to the Qur'an and Sunna is Ibn Hazm. The one who does not tie law to the Qur'an and Sunna is Ibn Hazm. He takes this from Aristotle. They take Greek culture, understanding and thought, package it up and wrap it in a bundle as if it were Islam, and put it in front of us. You Ibn Hazm followers, you mouthpieces of the people of unbelief who try to build a law far from the Qur'an and Sunna, a thought far from the Qur'an and Sunna! Sit down where you're sitting. When we look now, we say to Ibn Taymiyya: where did it come into your head to reject the Sufism that is on the line of the Qur'an and Sunna?
Purifying the heart. Where are we going to put purifying the heart?
There is such an organ in a person that if it is clean, the whole body is clean. And that is the heart. How are we going to purify that heart? Now we look at Abd al-Wahhab, the Wahhabis were influenced by Ibn Taymiyya. They are harsher than Ibn Taymiyya.
So much so that they are insolent enough to criticise everyone and every community in the Islamic world. Yes. Well, when we look now, were these the ones who were going to be on the path of returning to the Qur'an and Sunna, or those who stand purely, unadulterated, within the circle of the Qur'an, the Sunna and the ijtihad of the imams?
That's why, when I look at this passage, keeping Imam Hanbal aside, it is not possible to reconcile the other personages, and the Islamic tariqas, communities, groups, whatever they are, that were founded later, with al-Ghazali.
I am not a community founded later on.
34. «My Path Was Not Founded Later On»
My sheikh, my sheikh's sheikh, my sheikh's sheikh, my sheikh's sheikh, my sheikh's sheikh, my sheikh's sheikh, it goes all the way to Hz. Muhammad Mustafa, all the way to him, sallallahu alayhi wa sallam. I was not founded later on. My path is 1400 years old. If you look at spirituality, it goes back to Adam. If you look further back from there, you go up beyond the world of spirits too. If you catch your breath with your foot on the fixed entities (a'yan thabita), there is still more beyond where you caught your breath well.
My path is not new. My path is not an English counterfeit, nor a CIA floozy, nor a Soros hireling. Otherwise what business would we have here? They would give money to our dergah or our foundation too, and they would say:
"You deserve better places, but you'll make a concession." Of what? Of your faith. Of what? Of the Sunna, of what? Of the hadith, of what? Of the verses. Of what? Of your path. No. We don't have pockets reaching down to our knees. Oh, and I also published the state's decision, didn't I. What did it say? That I have no movable or immovable property. There's no money to be managed with me either.
"Is this the community's money?" "Is this the ummah's money?" "Is this that person's money?" There won't be any fighting and uproar behind me.
35. «This Is Who We Are»: The Declaration of a Stance
Well, that being so, well, naturally we normally have no tie, no connection with these people. We are followers of al-Ghazali. Yes. We are followers of Ibn Arabi. Yes. We are followers of Hazrat Rumi. Yes. We are followers of Shams al-Din of Tabriz. Yes. We are Husaynis. Yes.
We are not crooked, backhanded types. May Allah forgive us. (Amin.)
Let whoever loves, love like this. Let whoever comes, love like this. And let whoever is going to come, come like this. This is who we are. Pure. Qur'an, Sunna, homeland, nation is our way of thinking. Qur'an and Sunna is our religious stance.
Homeland and nation is our national stance; this is our politics. Whoever serves this homeland, this nation of ours, honours it, works for it, is our brother at this point. Whoever says Qur'an and Sunna and holds fast to them, lives them and struggles to keep them alive, is our brother. We have no problem on this point. But, however, those outside of this are not our brothers. May Allah forgive us. (Amin.)
36. Next Week: Montgomery Watt and the Claim of «Greek Influence»
Yes, from next week, God willing, Montgomery Watt, one of the professors in the Department of Arabic and Islamic Studies at the University of Edinburgh in Britain, states that al-Ghazali was in reality greatly influenced by the Greek sciences and philosophy.
We will continue from the passage that says, "Montgomery Watt says the following in his book titled Muslim Intellectual."
Now we're also going to enter the University of Edinburgh. I'm going to find this man from the University of Edinburgh. I'm going to make use of this man's books and treatises too. Don't worry. Next week we'll expose him too, by Allah's leave. No problem. What will happen? I'll have 3 or 4 days.
It doesn't matter at all. Let the nights be ours, by Allah's leave. But I think it's turning into a good study of al-Ghazali, isn't it? Yes.
37. Closing: «Why Do They Do This?»
If Hasan Aydın listens to this talk, he'll probably tear his hair out. Let him tear it out, if he has any hair. May Allah forgive us.
My concern isn't to mock anyone, but he has made such a connection that, I mean, it's impossible to tie that connection to anything, I mean. But do you know why they do this, you know, like this? The people who do these things see those in front of them, or those who will read them, as inadequate, worthless people who won't do any research.
That's the problem, really.
And when this is the problem, they get struck down. May they not be struck down. That's why they should normally produce straight, upright work. This is our concern. May Allah forgive us. Forgive us any rights we may owe you. May it be halal. And from our side too, may it be halal.
Note: This text is the speech itself as found in the recording of the sohbet: only spelling and punctuation have been edited, and obvious mishearings in the subtitles have been corrected; a few unclear passages have been left as they were heard. Section headings have been added to make reading easier. The opening and closing prayers have not been included.
Bibliography
The text discussed in the talk, the figures mentioned and the sources cited are collected below.
Hasan Aydın (2012), p. 521 — The source of the passage analysed point by point in the talk; the thesis positioning al-Ghazali within the «Salafi line».
Imam al-Ghazali, Ihya' 'Ulum al-Din — The main source that combines, in the same work, the matters of what does and does not invalidate the prayer (the fiqh aspect) with the virtues of the prayer (the spiritual aspect); the methods of dhikr and the methodology of training the heart are also found here.
Murtada al-Zabidi, Ithaf al-Sada al-Muttaqin — The commentary on the Ihya'. The author's judgement on al-Ghazali is cited in the talk: by consensus an authority (hujja) in fiqh, the principles of jurisprudence (usul al-fiqh) and the principles of religion (usul al-din); possessor of the rank of siddiqiyya in Sufism; an imam in the Shafi'i school.
Ahmad ibn Hanbal and the Mihna Period — The Abbasid caliph's making the view that «the Qur'an is created» the official ideology, and the period of persecution lasting about fifteen years; Ibn Hanbal's resistance, his imprisonment and his being subjected to torture.
The Story of Shayban al-Ra'i — The question about a forgotten prayer that Imam Ahmad ibn Hanbal asked Shayban al-Ra'i in the presence of Imam al-Shafi'i, and the answer he received; one of the classic Sufi anecdotes concerning the arrogance of learning.
Ibn Hazm al-Zahiri — The greatest representative of the Zahiri school; he rejects analogical reasoning (qiyas). While all four of the four schools accept qiyas, this stance of his and his strict Aristotelianism are shown in the talk as the fundamental point on which he parts ways with al-Ghazali.
Ibn Taymiyya — Although he comes from the Hanbali tradition, he rejects al-Ghazali's understanding of Sufism, kalam and philosophy; he severely criticises wahdat al-wujud. He has serious intellectual and juristic differences with al-Ghazali.
Muhammad ibn Abd al-Wahhab and Wahhabism — The religious foundation of the Saudi state system. The assessment in the talk regarding the political background of the movement is a view the speaker explicitly expressed with the qualification «my own personal opinion».
Hadith — «Religion is sincerity» — The narration «al-din al-nasiha»: Muslim, Iman 95 (no. 55); Abu Dawud, Adab 59. Cited as the basis of al-Ghazali's emphasis on sincerity (ikhlas) and ethics.
Hadith — The seven categories who will be shaded in the shade of the Throne — The item «two people who love one another purely for the sake of Allah»: Bukhari, Adhan 36 (no. 660); Muslim, Zakat 91 (no. 1031). Cited regarding a community that gathers fi sabilillah (in the way of Allah).
The Qur'an, al-Ra'd 13/28 — [Qur'an, ar-Ra'd 13:28 — verse text pending: Diyanet English translation] — the Qur'anic basis of the discussion of congregational remembrance of Allah (dhikrullah).
Hadith — The heart, the piece of flesh in the body — «In the body there is a piece of flesh; if it is sound, the whole body is sound… beware, it is the heart»: Bukhari, Iman 39 (no. 52); Muslim, Musaqat 107 (no. 1599).
W. Montgomery Watt, Müslüman Aydın (Muslim Intellectual) — Professor of Arabic and Islamic Studies at the University of Edinburgh. His thesis that al-Ghazali was influenced by Greek philosophy has been announced as the subject of the next talk in the series.
Mustafa Özbağ Efendi, «Is al-Ghazali on the Salafi Line? | Questions on al-Ghazali 8» — mustafaozbag.com — full text of the talk dated 08.08.2026.
Click here for more information about Imam al-Ghazali.
Additional sources:
- Imam al-Ghazali, Ihya' 'Ulum al-Din; the sections on acts of worship, customs, the destructive matters (muhlikat) and the saving matters (munjiyat).
- Imam al-Ghazali, al-Munqidh min al-Dalal; the classification of the paths of knowledge and the transition to Sufism.
- Murtada al-Zabidi, Ithaf al-Sada al-Muttaqin; the most comprehensive commentary on the Ihya'.
- Muslim, Iman 95; «al-din al-nasiha» — religion being sincerity.
- Bukhari, Iman 39; the central place of the heart in the body.
- Bukhari, Adhan 36; those who will be shaded in the shade of the Throne.
- Qur'an: al-Ra'd 13/28; hearts finding tranquillity through the remembrance of Allah.
- Qur'an: al-Ahzab 33/41-42; the command to remember Allah abundantly.
- Ibn Hazm, al-Muhalla and al-Ihkam; Zahiri methodology and the rejection of qiyas.
- Ibn Taymiyya, Majmu' al-Fatawa; his assessments of Sufism and kalam.
- W. M. Watt, Muslim Intellectual: A Study of al-Ghazali; the subject of the next talk.