Sunday, November 15, 2026
OUR PATH IS THE PATH OF PROPHETHOOD
Mustafa Özbağ
Irshad & Tasawwuf · Official Site
al-Ghazali Talks·

Did al-Ghazali Cause the Decline? | Questions on al-Ghazali 7

Translated from Turkish. Original article (Turkish) →
Note: Qur'anic verses in this article are marked and will be completed with the Diyanet English translation; the Turkish original is linked above.

1. The Text Under Discussion: «Al-Ghazali's Contribution to the Stagnation Is Greater»

We are continuing from where we left off. God willing, unless something comes from Allah, we will first read the text. Professor Doctor Yaşar Aydınlı says the following. It can be argued that al-Ghazali's contribution to the stagnation and decline in Islam is clearly greater than that of other thinkers. Because al-Ghazali, with his movement of revival (ihya) and renewal (tajdid), combined the Ash'ari understanding with the Sufi understanding. He nourished the epistemological infrastructure of this synthesis with a divine-illuminationist conception of knowledge that he had gathered from the philosophers. While Islamizing most of the philosophers' views of Aristotelian, that is, Platonic origin, he identified the name of philosophy, which at that time also encompassed the sciences, with irreligion, and he condemned the pursuit of worldly things and of more knowledge than necessary. Aydın 2012, page 521.

This movement of al-Ghazali prevented philosophy, which also encompassed the sciences, from being included in the madrasa curricula. It fed anti-philosophy movements in the Islamic world and facilitated the spread of Sufism and of the tariqas among the Sunnis. However, it should not be forgotten that this project of al-Ghazali was also supported by political centres. Professor Doctor Aydın. As is known, this Yaşar Aydınlı, uh, is a person of considerable standing in Turkey who has done quite a lot of work on this subject.

Of course, this text I have read is not a thought belonging only to this Yaşar Aydınlı, to Yaşar Aydın. Uh, this Yaşar Aydın is one of the leading people in this, but especially in university circles this is an issue that is talked about openly like this, openly, a front taken against al-Ghazali on this matter. That is, within the Diyanet and theology faculty establishment, there are some lecturers who, on this matter, go beyond a defensive stance into outright hostility toward al-Ghazali. Of course, normally these criticisms also exist in the West. That is, just as in Turkey, there are criticisms of this type against al-Ghazali in the West too. Of course I will regard the West's criticism as normal, but I also regard the criticisms here among us as normal, but, you know, surely these people have studied al-Ghazali better than I have.

I have no claim on this matter, but, however, when criticising someone, when examining someone, researching someone, I am in favour of being a bit fair, a bit conscientious. Yes. That is, there are sides of this text that are right, but there are also biased, hostile attitudes like this.

2. The Problem of Chronology: Al-Ghazali in the Seljuk Era, the Decline in the Ottoman Era

That is, normally, now, if we go through these point by point with examples: it can be argued that al-Ghazali's contribution to the stagnation and decline in Islam is clearly greater than that of other thinkers. Now, if we look at the matter from a historical perspective, you know, the decline begins with the Ottoman period of decline. Whereas al-Ghazali lived in the time of the Seljuks. That is, when we say decline, after the Seljuks there are the Ottomans. And the decline of the Ottomans began, well, after Kanuni (Suleiman the Magnificent). Let's put it that way. You know, in the historians' terms. When we look at it like that, there is such a great gap of years between al-Ghazali and Kanuni. Then, when we say stagnation and decline, and when you also say "in Islam," you know, "in Islam," that is, was it the Qur'an and the Sunna that declined then, or was it the Muslims? What he meant here by saying "in Islam" was presumably the Muslims.

Of course, this is the interpretation of an intellectual. This is a thesis of his. Well, can this be regarded as something proven? No.

3. To Whom Does This Thesis Belong? Criticism of al-Ghazali in Turkey and in the West

But normally, of course, as I also said in the last lesson regarding this view, you know, among those who criticise al-Ghazali, of course, these too defend the same thing.

They say that, you know, with al-Ghazali there came a period of stagnation. With al-Ghazali there came a period of decline. Normally, well, who is there? There is Hasan Hanafi. We talked about him last week. Who is there? There is al-Jabiri. These are the advocates of this thesis. Who is there from Europe? There is Ernest Renan. Who is there? There is Bernard Russell. Who is there? There is George Saliba. That is, when we identify these at this point, we see that they and, what's-his-name, Yaşar Aydınlı meet at the same point.

That is, they say that, well, with al-Ghazali a stagnation took place in the Islamic world, a decline took place.

4. The Counter-Thesis Was Also Written by Europe: A Bitter Observation

Of course, the most interesting point of the matter is this.

Those who opposed this are also Europeans. Again, look, normally, unfortunately, the people of these lands did not seriously, loudly, crying out like this, oppose this.

These are our bitter sides. Or, let's say, you know, I researched for a work on this subject and I could not find one. Let that be my shortcoming. But no serious, strong voice was raised against these. Who, who came forward from Europe? Frank Griffel came forward, George Makdisi came forward, Richard Frank came forward, Dimitri Gutas came forward. These, normally, academically, you know, saying that with al-Ghazali there was no stagnation, there was no decline, put forward a counter-thesis. That being the case, you know, uh, this is the reason I said "a little fairness, for heaven's sake." That is, they say the stagnation, the decline of the Islamic world began with Kanuni, you know, they call it the period of stagnation after the return from Vienna. Normally, they say it began then. Let us suppose the Islamic world stagnated after Kanuni.

That is, that the period of stagnation began after turning back from the gates of Vienna is the thesis of some historians, and not all of them either, but al-Ghazali is someone who lived long before this. So, ah, you will say that al-Ghazali's influence caused this, led to the stagnation like this. These debates, I beg your pardon, earlier, back in the days in Ödemiş, we used to debate these with certain groups for whole nights. They used to put forward these theses back then as well.

5. A Memory: The Debates of the Years Eighty-Nine and Ninety

They even used to say that, you know, the fact that no great scholar emerged after al-Ghazali, that, you know, none emerged because of al-Ghazali's influence; they had put such a nonsensical thesis in front of me.

Well, of course, back then there was youth. Age-wise, I'm in my thirties. I am a good defender of al-Ghazali. And under my arm there is the Ihya'. That is, back then the Ihya' was just newly being translated into Turkish and sold.

Many books were being translated into Turkish and sold at that time. Just newly. It was forbidden. Because you could not act so freely back then. These were, like, the books of Ibn Taymiyya, the books of Mawdudi. These were being translated into Turkish, rendered into Turkish, and just beginning to be sold at that time. Of course, al-Ghazali's Ihya' too, at that time, like, for instance, while the books of Ibn Taymiyya or the books of Mawdudi were selling more, al-Ghazali was selling less. The years I am talking about are 89, 90. This debate existed back then as well. At that time, in fact, these debates were taking place among people whom we could call members of Islamic communities.

That is, I am now speaking about these things openly. The Milli Görüş supporters, for example, were debating this. The people where we were debated like this. That is, they were saying that al-Ghazali, er, regressed, that he caused regression. They were defending Ali Shariati. For example, the man is a hadith denier. They were defending him, or else, what can I say, there were various people like that whom they defended. But nevertheless, I mean, this al-Ghazali debate is not new.

But when we look at it historically, I do not think that he had any share in the decline, or in the stagnation, of Islam, or rather of the Islamic world.

6. What Are Ihya' and Tajdid? The Conditions of al-Ghazali's Time

Through the movement of ihya' and tajdid, he united the Ash'ari understanding with the Sufi understanding.

Ihya', that is, restructuring, and tajdid, that is, renewal. That is, for that time, you know, I touch on this from time to time in these lessons.

You know, in these lands, after Manzikert in 1071, the Seljuk state was established, but after Alp Arslan and in Alp Arslan's time there was a great deal of internal turmoil. A great deal of external turmoil. There is extreme external pressure. On one side there is extreme Byzantine pressure. Down below, normally, there is the pressure of the Fatimids from Egypt. And inside there are the Assassins (Hashshashin). At the same time there are the various branches of the Shi'a. There is the Ismaili, the Isma'iliyya Batini branch. These are normally in the midst of internal turmoil, and al-Ghazali is a man of that period.

That being so, a body of thought is needed that will secure the unity and togetherness of society from within. A new ihya' movement, a movement of renewal, is needed.

7. Today Too There Is a Need for an Ihya' Movement: Internal and External Occupation

Actually, now I'm going to sound like I'm launching missiles, but right now, within the country too, there is a need for something like this.

In the country there needs to be a tajdid once again, an ihya' movement once again. This is absolutely essential.

The country is being prepared for occupation from inside and from outside. Let me not sound like some bad alarmist in your presence. But nevertheless, what kind of occupation? Cultural occupation. What kind of occupation? Occupation by indecency. What kind of occupation? How is it occupation through drugs? How is it occupation through gambling? How is it occupation through fashion? Normally there is an occupation by taking the entire filth of the West into ourselves. This is the internal occupation. There is this external occupation. How is there an external occupation?

Right under our noses there is Israel. On one side there is Greece. These are not friends of ours at all. Well, all right, Armenia has calmed down now, in connection with Azerbaijan. But normally Turkey could be exposed to every kind of operation at any moment. Honestly, I do not see much difference between that period of the Seljuks and today.

8. The Fragmented Family: Where Does the Unity of Society Break?

Within the country religious factions have multiplied, and the Muslims within the country, from being busy with one another, have become unable to see the external danger. Even families are now in a fragmented state.

Families too are getting their share of this fragmentation. Two siblings are not on speaking terms. Parents are not on speaking terms with their children. Children are not on speaking terms with their parents. Relatives are clashing with one another. Partners, people who do business together, are clashing with one another. That is, at this point, dynamite has been thrown into families as well. The family has not remained united.

In a place where family togetherness no longer remains, you cannot establish the unity of society, the order of society. Mothers, fathers, I beg your pardon, but they are uninformed, ignorant, not of the capacity to gather together their children, their daughters-in-law, their grandchildren. Their nafs has hit the ceiling.

The grandfather has ceased to be a grandfather, the grandmother has ceased to be a grandmother. The son-in-law has ceased to be a son-in-law, the daughter-in-law has ceased to be a daughter-in-law, the child has ceased to be a child. Everyone has followed their nafs, they are running after their nafs.

9. Communities and Tariqas: Those Who Have Taken the Path of Filling Their Purses

The communities, the tariqas, instead of striving to truly inform people, to make people conscious, to explain a certain Islamic framework to people, to live it and keep it alive, have taken the path of filling their purses, filling their money, their bank accounts. Instead of serving the dervishes or their community, they have taken the path of fleecing them. They have sunk into filth, and they have nothing they can explain. They have nothing they can say. This is a very bitter thing, and we are living this bitterness right now. Of course, if a person is concerned with these matters, if he is sensitive on this subject, if he has knowledge on this subject, then he will understand this. Otherwise, can you imagine? A father at odds with his children, a mother, a grandfather, a grandmother at odds with their grandchildren, their children. Such a thing is unthinkable. An elder at odds with little tiny children. Such a thing is unthinkable. Husband and wife at odds at home.

Both of them in separate places. Unthinkable. They immediately think of divorce. Now, I mean, culturally, religiously, morally, we are in the midst of a great collapse. And in the midst of this collapse, the Islamic world, or the communities, or the tariqas, or individual Muslims, instead of pulling themselves together, shuddering and saying, "What are we doing?", have fallen upon one another. Husband and wife do not speak at home for days. A mother does not speak with her children. A father does not speak with his children. A mother and father do not speak with their son-in-law. They do not speak with their daughter-in-law. With their relatives... Everyone has gone off chasing after their nafs. The communities and tariqas are affected by this as well.

Because this starts with the individual. The followers of the same dergah do not meet with one another, do not speak with one another. They do not consult one another. People who are to run on the same path do not think of running toward the same goal.

10. For the Economy to Recover, Morality Must First Recover

When we look back, this was the point the Seljuks fell to. This was also the point the Ottomans fell to in their final period. Under the Seljuks too the economy had collapsed. Under the Ottomans too the economy had collapsed. Right now too the economy is in a collapsed state. That is, for the economy to be able to recover, morality has to be gathered back together.

Morality has to be gathered back together. People's way of looking at one another has to change.

But if we cannot do this even in a tiny community, if we cannot put this into practice, and if the members of that community cannot behave tolerantly toward one another, if they do not embrace and enfold one another, then when you extend this to the Islamic world, the Islamic world is the same.

11. A Society That Says "I Am Sunni" But Has No Prayer

On one side the Wahhabis, on one side the Shi'a, on one side a Muslim community that says "I am Sunni" yet has nothing to do with being Sunni.

Sunni, very nice. No prayer, no ablution, no fasting, no hajj, no zakat, but Sunni. If you ask, he says, "I am Sunni." How nice. No prayer, no fasting, no dhikr, no thought. But Sunni, Hanafi, Shafi'i, Maliki, Hanbali, whatever school it may be from, an Islamic society without prayer, an Islamic society without ideas, an Islamic society without thought, an Islamic society that produces ideas, that cannot produce them, an Islam far from producing, and an Islamic society that, in order still not to produce, not to work, not to strive, sleeps until morning, and when it should wake from its morning sleep, looks for a way to sleep even longer until noon; an Islamic society that does not read, does not work, does not examine, does not critique, and feels no need to read, feels no need to research, feels no need to work.

It is a very bitter thing, look. This is a very bitter thing. Normally, through the movement of ihya' and tajdid, al-Ghazali at that time united the Ash'ari understanding, that is, the Ash'ari creedal method, with the Sufi understanding. That is, what was there before al-Ghazali?

12. Three Disconnected Groups Before al-Ghazali: The Theologians, the Jurists, the Sufis

In Islamic society, the theologians (mutakallimun) had separated off into one place. What else was there? Sufism. The people of tasawwuf. They had separated off into a field we call the Sufis.

What else happened? The jurists had separated off into a field of their own. And they were all disconnected from one another. Look, the jurists criticized both the people of tasawwuf and the theologians. When we look, the theologians also criticized both of the others.

There were three main groups. And the three main groups were criticizing one another. Look, there were three main groups. There were Sufis before al-Ghazali. That is, the Sufis did not begin with al-Ghazali.

There were Sufis before al-Ghazali too. But some of those Sufis before al-Ghazali, I am very sorry to say, but when you examine them you will see this. Deviant. That is, the Hashshashin (Assassins) look like a Sufi community. They are themselves Batinis. They look like a Sufi community, but they are deviant. There are deviant ideas, deviant thoughts. As for the jurists, they were far removed from the aesthetic side of the matter. And the theologians were completely immersed in kalam.

13. What Does the Ihya' Do? The Things That Invalidate the Prayer and the Things That Corrupt the Heart

In his revival, in the Ihya' 'Ulum al-Din, al-Ghazali strengthens the creed of Ahl al-Sunna and, normally, of course, he upholds Shafi'i fiqh.

At the same time, he brings Sufism into the same system. Today, when you look at the Ihya', just as you learn the things that invalidate the prayer, you also learn the things that corrupt the heart.

Just as you learn the things that break the fast, you also learn the afflictions of the tongue. You also learn the afflictions of the ear. You also learn the afflictions of the hand, the foot, the limbs. That is, when you read al-Ghazali, he enables you to climb out of the pit of backbiting and filth into which today's Islamic society has fallen.

14. The Pit of Backbiting and Slander: «If You Keep Silent, You Are a Mute Devil»

Today the Islamic world is wandering around in the pit of backbiting. Backbiting, the pit of filth, slander are corrupting Islamic society today, spoiling it, and spoiling the dervishes too, the tariqas too, the religious communities too.

He sits down and backbites. He sits down and backbites about the honor of a brother right beside him. Within the same community, within the same group, if the honor of one of your brothers or sisters is being talked about next to you and you keep silent, you are a mute devil. Women, men. Look, this al-Ghazali says, "Among the afflictions of the tongue, put backbiting first," and he puts slander.

But Islamic society has drifted away from one another, separated from one another. Even those we call the elders of the dergah, those we call the elders of the community, are wandering around inside that pit. May Allah protect us. (Amin.)

15. Al-Ghazali Is Not the Founder of Sufism, but Its Systematizer

And thus al-Ghazali, these three important branches of Islamic science, in the Ihya', or rather in himself. And some of the people of tasawwuf.

I am included in this too. They take the Ihya' as a textbook for themselves. I sometimes add a note, you know. That is, be careful when reading the Ihya': if it came out of the hands of a Shafi'i jurist, it will tell you Shafi'i fiqh.

Be careful, I say. Because al-Ghazali himself is a Shafi'i. But normally, if someone of the Hanafi school is translating it, he adds a note underneath. Saying, among the Shafi'is it is like this, among the Hanafis it is like this. Now, that is why many researchers, you know, see al-Ghazali as the founder of Sunni Sufism, but actually he is not the founder, to tell the truth plainly.

Because Sufism is not a movement that began with al-Ghazali. But I appreciate and acknowledge this about al-Ghazali. He brought Sufism under a certain discipline and systematized it. He made it systematic. That is, you can learn the beginning and the path of Sufism from the Ihya', you can read it. That is how it is. So then, when we look, I do not see it as something to be criticized either, that al-Ghazali, within this movement of ihya' and movement of tajdid, you know, at this point united the Ash'ari school and Sufism.

16. A Contradiction: Al-Ghazali, Called «Anti-Rationalist», Belonged to a Rationalist School

And yet, you know, they regard al-Ghazali as anti-rationalist.

Whereas Ash'arism is rationalism. There is an interesting contradiction here. Because the Ash'ari school is a rationalist school of kalam. Now normally, when we look at this, when we examine the Ash'ari school a little, it interprets the articles of faith rationally.

You know, when we look, if one is on the line of Imam Abu Hanifa (Imam-i A'zam) and Imam al-Maturidi, rational interpretation, is there or isn't it, there is none. We accept directly, we believe. But when we look at the Ash'ari position, yes, it is rationalist. But normally, of course, here Imam al-Ash'ari and those who follow him do not regard reason as above revelation.

Reason is not above revelation, as some deviants hold. Imam al-Ash'ari, Imam al-Maturidi, and Ahl al-Sunna are all on this line.

17. What Is Sufism Built Upon?

Well, when we look at tasawwuf, or when we look at Sufism, well, Sufism is built upon the love of Allah.

It is built upon the love of the Messenger of Allah, upon the rulings of the Qur'an. It is built upon the noble Sunna. It is built upon the purification of the heart. Sufism is built upon the purification of the heart. The heart must be purified. For the heart to be purified, one must stay away from the major sins.

The purification of the heart cannot be expected from someone who does not stay away from the major sins. For the heart to be purified, that person must fulfill his obligatory duties. He must draw near to Allah through supererogatory acts. He must love Allah. That person must love the Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him. He must love the believers. He must love the friends of Allah. The purification of the heart is possible through these. And when we say Sufism, it is becoming a friend of Allah, being near to Allah.

When we say Sufism, there is a spiritual experience. When we say Sufism, it cannot be without spiritual experience. And who is this? It is that person's master. His master's master. His master's master. His master's master. The chain (silsila) goes back to Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa, peace and blessings be upon him. From him back to Adam, peace be upon him. This chain comes from Adam, peace be upon him. The beginning of this chain is Adam, peace be upon him. That being so, when we say Sufism, nearness to Allah, a moral depth and conformity to moral rules are also possible.

When we say moral rules, these are the facts that make a human being human. They are the principles that make a human being human.

18. Yunus's Measure: «You Eat Whatever Comes to Hand, You Say Whatever Comes to Your Tongue»

Well, you eat whatever comes to hand, you say whatever comes to your tongue; let such dervishhood be.

You cannot be a dervish, said the great Yunus; he is on the same line. That is the line of al-Ghazali. It is the line of al-Ghazali. Hazrat Rumi and Muhyiddin Ibn Arabi are on the line of al-Ghazali.

Hajji Bektash Veli and Hajji Bayram Veli are on the line of al-Ghazali. Yunus Emre is on the line of al-Ghazali. Muhyiddin Uftade is on the line of al-Ghazali.

That is why they attacked al-Ghazali; actually, the path they were attacking is Sufism. They attack Sufism.

19. Deifying Reason: Yesterday's Theologians, Today's Theology Academics

Well, before al-Ghazali, the theologians set out to deify reason.

The theologians tried to deify reason. Just as reason is deified today, just as a segment of the West has deified reason, and just as some theology academics in Türkiye today deify reason, we can accept that some communities outside religion deify reason.

But there is a segment in the country that, while being within the religion, deifies reason and tries to do away with some verses of the Noble Qur'an by their reason. They are playing with fire. But normally, now, the Sufis too, in al-Ghazali's time, before al-Ghazali, some Sufis had fallen into states, behaviors and statements contrary to the sharia.

20. Today's Equivalent: Those Who Say «Salat Is Not the Ritual Prayer»

And now in the country they say there is no need for the ritual prayer. Salat does not mean the ritual prayer. Come on, they go even further. The man says, "May Allah curse those who made this prayer a calamity upon the Ummah." So the prayer is supposedly a calamity upon the Ummah.

Those who say this are professors. And they are listened to in the country. He says, "May Allah curse those who made this prayer a calamity upon the Ummah." (Amin.) That is what they say. Those saying "Amin" aren't listening to what I'm saying either. Yes.

Look, this is our picture. This is the point the country has now reached. This is the point the religious segment has reached. But what did al-Ghazali do this time?

21. Al-Ghazali Disciplined the Sufis Too: «If Your Tongue Backbites, Don't Pose as a Sufi»

Normally, he took up both the training of the nafs (the self) among the Sufis and, at the same time, moral discipline.

He took up the discipline of the sharia. Al-Ghazali disciplined the Sufis too. That is, nobody could say, "I am flying through the air."

Nobody could say, "This is what was commanded to me. Tomorrow you will do this like this." Why? Because al-Ghazali established that discipline.

If your tongue backbites, don't pose as a Sufi. If your tongue slanders, don't pose as a Sufi. If right beside you someone speaks against people's honor, if such things are being said, don't you pose as a Sufi. If right beside you backbiting, gossip and slander are running rampant, don't you pose as a Sufi. If backbiting keeps coming out of your home, don't you pose as a Sufi. Don't say, "That night you did a very beautiful dhikr of Allah."

First guard your tongue. Open the Ihya' and read it. Read about the banes of the tongue, and take control of your tongue. Read about the banes of the eye, and take control of your eye. Read about the banes of the ear, and take control of your ear. If you cannot do that, then what you are or who you are does not matter. This is al-Ghazali's discipline.

22. A Great Revival Movement in the Madrasas and the Dergahs

Well now, the revival—in this way, in the Islamic world, the Sufis, the Sufis of that day, the Sufis who received al-Ghazali's training, started a very great revival movement in the Islamic world.

Look, a very great revival movement began. Together with Nizam al-Mulk, together with al-Ghazali, a very great revival movement began in the madrasas and in the dergahs (Sufi lodges) and tekkes.

Tajdid, that is, renewal, which began with al-Ghazali—the philosophers had gathered, the theologians had gathered, and they were attacking the Islamic world with all their might.

The Batinis on one side. I set the Ja'faris apart. The corrupt factions of the Shi'a on one side. The Islamic world was in a state of intellectual plunder. Al-Ghazali, normally, for that day, is someone who revived and renewed Islamic thought, and while renewing it—I underline this—

Al-Ghazali is not an enemy of logic. Nor is al-Ghazali an enemy of kalam (Islamic theology).

23. Al-Ghazali's Synthesis: Logic, Kalam, Philosophy and Sufism Under the Same Roof

Al-Ghazali—logic and kalam and Sufism—look, from my point of view this is a very important observation.

Al-Ghazali showed the skill and the success of logic, kalam, Sufism and philosophy—let me put that in too. Interpreting philosophy along the line of the Qur'an and the Sunna. He showed the skill and success of keeping it along the line of the Qur'an and the Sunna.

And by synthesizing this with Sufi experience, he brought it to perfection. He is a magnificent person who combined the rationalism of Ash'arism with the meaning, the spirituality, of the Sufi. They'll be angry with me now. Yes. Can you imagine? A magnificent person who synthesized reason, logic, philosophy and Sufism under the same roof.

Well, of course, we continue point by point. He gathered his epistemological foundation from the philosophers. Normally, here, when it says he gathered it from the philosophers, this is not a bad thing. This is not something to be looked at critically.

24. «He Gathered It from the Philosophers» — This Is Not a Flaw

Because for us the standard is the Qur'an and the Sunna. In a hadith narrated from Abu Hurayra.

It appears in al-Tirmidhi and Ibn Majah. The Messenger of Allah, sallallahu alayhi wa sallam, says the following. Wisdom is the lost property of the believer. Wherever he finds it, he has more right to take it. Wisdom (hikma) is normally conveyed to us as knowledge. This wisdom also includes knowledge.

Wisdom—reaching the reality of things, of nature, of existence, is also wisdom. That is why wisdom is like this dome. Under it, all branches of learning, all knowledge are contained. Let us view wisdom like that.

The Messenger of Allah, sallallahu alayhi wa sallam, brings the Islamic world and the Islamic system of thought, Islamic logic, into a very wide framework. He says, "Wisdom is the lost property of the believer. Wherever it is, taking it is his right before anyone else, he says. He has the right to it." Because who is the owner of wisdom? Allah. Because there are many verses in which the Almighty speaks with reference to His prophets. I didn't feel the need to include them here. He says that He gave the prophets wisdom along with the Book. If there is no wisdom along with the Book, it is not possible for anyone to understand, perceive and live the divine Book. A superficial book like that is left lying there. You won't understand what is meant by the prayer. And then you'll pray however you please. May Allah protect us. (Amin.) Yes.

When we look at al-Ghazali, he learned the logic of Aristotle and the logic of Ibn Sina (Avicenna) very well, analyzed them very well, evaluated them very well, penetrated deeply into them, and normally, after learning them, he uttered his famous saying. He said, "The knowledge of one who does not know logic cannot be trusted." Look, he said, "The knowledge of one who does not know logic cannot be trusted." Logic is an important body of knowledge.

25. He Took Logic, but Not the Metaphysics of the Philosophers

Because, you know, we say, "Use your logic." None of us actually uses our logic. I am saying this about myself. We don't know the method of using it. Because there is a separate method for putting logic to work. In dervishes, this method develops through abundant dhikr. In the person's own self, in the individual himself. But there is a methodology to this. That method is important. Of developing logic—and consequently, al-Ghazali took logic, but he did not take the metaphysics of the philosophers. The meaning found among the Sufis, the states found among the Sufis, dreams—and there are sections in the Ihya' that explain these. He takes these anyway. That is what they are most angry about. He rejects the metaphysics of the philosophers, or, in today's sense, the metaphysics of the West. He doesn't take that. What is the thesis on philosophy? The philosopher's, you know, Aydınlı's thesis—I am going step by step. What does it say? He Islamized the views of the philosophers. Al-Ghazali does not reject Aristotle. He does not completely reject Ibn Sina.

26. Through Whom Did al-Ghazali Take Aristotelian Logic?

Al-Ghazali took Aristotelian logic not directly, but through al-Farabi and Ibn Sina. Al-Ghazali did not sit down and take Aristotle directly. Actually, the one who first translated Aristotle, his book, into Turkish—into Arabic at that time—is also an interesting thing. Before al-Ghazali, it is al-Kindi. The first to translate Aristotelian logic into Arabic, that is, normally from Greek into Arabic, is al-Kindi.

Al-Kindi, too, comes before al-Ghazali. Look, al-Kindi, too, comes before al-Ghazali. Well now, when we look at it that way, Aristotelian logic had actually already entered the Islamic world through al-Kindi, before al-Ghazali. Well, it entered through Ibn Sina. It entered through Ibn Sina as well. It entered through al-Farabi as well.

That being so, al-Ghazali benefits from them. He does not reject them. His aim, in my view, is not to make philosophy dominant over the Islamic sciences; that is not al-Ghazali's aim. But what did he do? He actually made logic methodological within religious thought. When we look at this, he produced magnificent works, and unfortunately the methodology of al-Ghazali's logic is not taught in the universities. It is a bitter thing. Europe reads this methodology. It reads it through al-Ghazali. Look, it reads it through al-Ghazali. But in my country, unfortunately, al-Ghazali is not read and not known to that extent. And al-Ghazali makes logic legitimate in the Islamic world. He does not stop at making logic legitimate. He disciplines it. He establishes it as a discipline. And that being so, logic now begins to be taught in the madrasas along with al-Ghazali. For example, he is one of the important people in the Islamic world who defined logic.

He is someone who made extensive use of analogy (qiyas) and of reason, and who defined them. From al-Ghazali, what does reason mean? What does logic mean? What are their methodologies? How does one reason? A person can learn these things very well from al-Ghazali, but of course, we don't feel the need, do we. May Allah forgive us.

27. In Tahafut al-Falasifa Only Three Views Are Deemed Unbelief

But, for example, in Tahafut al-Falasifa (The Incoherence of the Philosophers) he counts only three views as unbelief (kufr).

The first is the eternity of the world. That is, the West does not accept the Day of Judgement. The Western philosopher does not accept the Day of Judgement. Whereas we believe. The Hour will come, and everything will perish, and nothing will remain. Everything that has been created will cease to exist. That is, created things are not eternal. Created things will one day come to an end, as the life of this world. And what will the Almighty (Allah) do with absolutely everything again? He will revive it, He will resurrect it. And something al-Ghazali opposed—look, I am saying this again, underlining it. That Allah does not know particulars. I mean, someone came out on television and said it, you know.

A professor said Allah does not know tomorrow. This is Western philosophy. Allah does not know particulars. Allah does not know what you will do in a moment. Allah does not know what you will say in a moment. Who is the one saying this? Bayındır. Not our one from Bayındır, though. Had I not heard it on television with my own ears, I would look at it with suspicion. Allah does not know what you will say. God forbid. This is the product of Western philosophy. And Western philosophy also denies being raised again, resurrection. Now, are there people in Turkey too who reject resurrection?

There are. There are politicians of ours. They reject resurrection. We have big, big politicians. We have big, big scholars. They reject resurrection. Now, the three very important main points that al-Ghazali opposed. First, the eternity of the world. 2. That Allah does not know particulars. 3. The denial of bodily resurrection. That is, that there will be no bodily resurrection again. He denies that. Otherwise, for anyone who has studied the Tahafut a little, al-Ghazali goes like this, passage by passage.

Because there he proceeds through those quotations. When we look, al-Ghazali says some things are wrong. There, you know, he does not find it appropriate. And this is something his knowledge brings. Otherwise he does not reject them completely. "Al-Ghazali identified the name of philosophy with irreligion." I mean, for me this is a very heavy and controversial claim. I mean, when we look at al-Ghazali, in his works, philosophy, this—may Allah forgive me—when our brother said "let's talk about al-Ghazali," I said to myself, after years, I said, it has come before me, al-Ghazali has come before me again; the reason I say "come before me" is this. When I was only 29 or 30 years old, we were talking about al-Ghazali. Then 35 years have passed, and again we are talking about al-Ghazali. Well, I remembered the old days, of course. Well, now the great majority don't have it in their library. Tahafut al-Falasifa. I mean, without reading it you cannot debate with an atheist.

Without reading it you cannot talk with someone who has deified his reason. Or else there must be a stirring in the heart, so that inspiration comes to your heart. Get acquainted with it, debate with it. Because al-Ghazali is someone who divides philosophy into sections. For instance, an example. For him, one section of philosophy is mathematics. Look, the West is currently using mathematical philosophy. We are, at present, truly very far behind in mathematical philosophy. They imagine something that does not exist and try to construct its mathematics. Like quantum physics. A brain surgeon looks at the brain mathematically. Can you imagine? The brain surgeon is sitting right there, you know. Now I won't stop without taking a jab at him. Over the brain, he looks at the brain mathematically. Looking at the brain mathematically. For example, at how many kilometres per hour does a thought travel inside the brain?

At how many kilometres per hour did the brain that stores it commit it to memory? Looking mathematically. At how many kilometres per hour did it commit what it saw to memory? At how many kilometres per hour did it commit what it heard to memory? Looking at the brain mathematically. The instant you see everyone here at once, how many million neurons worked in your brain? Looking mathematically. You looked at Dursun. The instant you looked at Dursun, how many million neurons did what regarding Dursun? And at how many kilometres per hour did they do it, and how much volume did it take up? In my brain, how many cubic millimetres did Dursun take up? Looking mathematically. Can you imagine? Now, when it came to that point there, we got into the brain.

28. Looking at Existence Mathematically: An Attempt at Contemplation

Now, I mean, can you imagine? You identify all the people here, and you identify them in an instant. The speed of light loses its swagger. When you contemplate the speed next to the brain, the speed inside the brain, the speed of light is left far behind, eating dust. Now, what does the scientific world say now?

It says the fastest is the speed of light. Right? Forget about that. The speed of light is a tortoise's speed. Like a tortoise, next to the speed inside the brain, and while travelling at that speed it goes without colliding with anything. It doesn't collide with anything. Sometimes I contemplate it like that. Istanbul, I say, a handful. Take Istanbul into the palm of your hand.

No being, as a cell, collides with another; each continues on its way. It goes so fast that, as I say, light would be left like a lame donkey beside it. Looking mathematically, looking at existence mathematically, looking at existence, at things, mathematically; looking at the world, the sun, the moon, the year, the sky mathematically.

Looking at the Hereafter mathematically, looking at the reckoning and the account mathematically. Their reckoning is settled swiftly. How shall we measure that speed? What kind of speed is that? All the people of so vast a universe gathered at the place of assembly (mahshar), and everyone's reckoning is settled swiftly, in an instant. Where is this speed?

29. «He Identified the Name of Philosophy with Irreligion» — A Heavy and Controversial Claim

What is the mathematics of this? Al-Ghazali is going to oppose this? Is that so? And logic. For al-Ghazali, the second main set within philosophy at large is logic. Come on, how are you going to reject logic, come on? He is one of those who laid the foundations of logic. What is the other one? What is the second thing that philosophy deals with, for al-Ghazali? Existence: you live within nature. It is impossible for you to reject it. What is the third? Man is not made of matter alone. Man has a metaphysics. He has a spirit. The Almighty (Allah) says: [Qur'an, al-Hijr 15:29 — verse text pending: Diyanet English translation] He has metaphysical dreams. Metaphysics. Philosophy. I do not see this as the philosophy of the West. I see it as the philosophy of this place. It is impossible for al-Ghazali to reject this. So how, normally, would you reject mathematics, ban it? You would reject logic, ban it. Come on, he himself wrote a book on logic anyway. It is impossible.

That is why saying that al-Ghazali declared all philosophy to be irreligion did not agree with al-Ghazali's own books. It became a contradiction.

30. Aristotle, al-Kindi, Ibn Sina and Ibn Rushd: The Question of Metaphysics

Now, according to Aristotle, metaphysics studies being insofar as it is being.

That is, it does not place any particular quality upon it. It investigates the most fundamental principles of existence. Aristotle looks at first causes. These may sound strange. These things I am putting together. Now, normally, first principles, first causes and the existence of Allah. I describe it as the existence of Allah. They say the existence of god. Aristotle deals with subjects that cannot be grasped directly by the senses, such as the nature of the soul and the order of the universe.

Some of these are areas that Islam is also concerned with. You know, there are existing physical rules. Aristotle deals with what lies above those physical rules. That is, two times 2 makes 4. It is mathematical. Aristotle deals with what is above this. That being so, they generally define that thing of Aristotle's as follows. Those who define it as first philosophy, or else, well, the West defines it as first theology, first religion. An interesting thing. Now, you know, al-Kindi sat down and had Aristotle's Metaphysics translated into Arabic.

Look at what magnificent things they did in the Islamic world. And he too named that book of Aristotle's "first philosophy." When we look at Ibn Sina (Avicenna), he too systematized metaphysics under the name of ilahiyyat (divine matters) and set about studying the abstract beings that come after physical beings. That is, abstract beings, unseen beings, that is, angels, that is, jinn, that is, Satan. Now you look at Ibn Rushd (Averroes). Ibn Rushd wrote the most comprehensive commentary on Aristotle's Metaphysics.

According to him, the expression "after physics" indicates the order of teaching. Not the order of existence. Al-Ghazali, these people I have listed, these persons, and there are others that could be listed. he rejects the views of Ibn Sina and Ibn Rushd on the relationship between god and the world, in Western language, on matters of causality, and he accepts the method of this metaphysics through logic, through syllogism.

That is, there is no acceptance for nothing like that. This is the difference between them. Again we are going point by point.

31. The Claim That «He Prevented the Sciences from Entering the Madrasa»

He prevented philosophy, which also included the sciences, from entering the madrasa.

This is a much-debated topic. That is, normally, ever since I first became acquainted with Islam, this has been talked about a lot on the side of the universities, those who have swallowed a bit of ink, so to speak. Especially the theologians and so on have made this their constant refrain. They chew on it like chewing gum. Normally, yes.

In the Nizamiyya madrasas Aristotle's logic was not placed on the curriculum. Fair enough, but there is logic, there is astronomy, there is arithmetic. That is, there is mathematics, there is medicine.

They began to be taught in the madrasas. Until then, medicine was not being studied in the madrasas, astronomy was not being studied, mathematics was not being studied.

32. Both Theologian and Mathematician: Names After al-Ghazali

Look, these are the subjects that were placed on the curriculum and began to be taught in the Nizamiyya madrasas. Together with al-Ghazali, for example, Nasir al-Din al-Tusi, Qutb al-Din al-Shirazi, Fakhr al-Din al-Razi: both theologians (mutakallims) and philosophers, and mathematicians too.

For instance, a note is added to al-Razi's Qur'anic commentary. The Islamic world says he is a philosopher.

When reading al-Razi we need to read carefully." it says. But al-Razi is at the same time a theologian. At the same time he is also a good mathematician. For example, His Eminence Ibrahim Hakki is a good astronomer.

Now when we go to Tillo, we see the mathematics of His Eminence of Tillo. There he calculates the light of the earth and the sun reaching the head of the grave at certain times. This is mathematics, and at the same time it is astrology. That is, normally, al-Ghazali did not reject these things.

These are subjects that were taught in the Nizamiyya madrasas together with al-Ghazali. Now, in fairness, while criticizing: he somewhat facilitated the spread of Sufism and the tariqas.

33. «He Facilitated the Spread of Sufism» — I Applaud This Observation

Yes, that is true. I applaud this observation. After al-Ghazali, the people of Sufism became organized into tariqas. Yes.

They gained legitimacy. They gained legitimacy in the eyes of the state as well.

How did they gain legitimacy? They set themselves right within the bounds of the Qur'an and the Sunna. When they set themselves right within the bounds of the Qur'an and the Sunna, they gained legitimacy in the eyes of the state too. Yes. After al-Ghazali, the Qadiriyya, the Rifa'iyya, the Shadhiliyya, the Naqshbandiyya took off and spread. Yes, true. But normally it is simply not possible to attribute all of these to al-Ghazali.

Because the chain (silsila) of the people of Sufism, as Muhammadan, goes all the way back to His Holiness Muhammad Mustafa.

34. Where Will You Put the Murshids Before al-Ghazali?

Where shall we put Hasan al-Basri, before al-Ghazali? Where shall we put Rabi'a al-'Adawiyya, before al-Ghazali? Where shall we put Ma'ruf al-Karkhi, before al-Ghazali?

These are persons who are in our chain. All of them are before al-Ghazali. Where will you put Sari al-Saqati? Where will you put Ibrahim ibn Adham? Where will you put Mansur al-Hallaj? Where will you put Bayazid al-Bistami? These are magnificent saints before al-Ghazali, magnificent perfect murshids (spiritual guides). Now these are before al-Ghazali; that is, if you say the tariqas became legitimate after al-Ghazali, you will have thrown all the perfect murshids before al-Ghazali into the trash.

He did not bring forth a path that did not exist; al-Ghazali was in any case someone who had received that Sufi training. When you look, inside the Ihya' you will see quotations from Bayazid, from Sari al-Saqati, from Fudayl ibn 'Iyad.

All of them are before al-Ghazali. But al-Ghazali takes up this heritage. He takes up the Sufi heritage. He forms a synthesis with Ash'ari kalam, with reason and with Sufi experience. Fair enough.

35. «We Neither Reject Reason Nor Deify Reason»

And he legitimizes both the rational side and the heart side of Sufism. You know, I sometimes say: we are not among the Sufis who reject reason.

We are not among those who deify reason. We do not reject reason. Nor do we deify reason. And what matters for us is that the heart is set in motion.

It is the working of the heart's reason. The working of the heart's reason is love of Allah, love of the Messenger of Allah. It is beautiful character, deep and refined character, and abundant dhikr. Then the heart's reason works. That being so, as a rule of our own path as well, we are not at a point of rejecting reason.

Al-Ghazali does not reject it either.

36. «This Project Was Supported by Political Circles» — Yes, It Was Supported

Now, this project was supported by political circles. Yes, it was supported. Nizam al-Mulk, the Seljuk state, the Abbasid caliphate: they are the order-builders of the same period.

When we look, on one side there is Batini propaganda. Now normally, against Batini propaganda, a Sunni propaganda ought to be supported. Now normally, we cannot regard al-Ghazali at this point as someone who held back from struggling against the diseases of his time.

Islamic thought and the Islamic movement of revival (ihya) and renewal (tajdid) struggles against the diseases of its time. It struggles against the dangers of its time. It struggles against everything in its time that would harm the Islamic world at this point, everything that would harm Islamic thought, reason, ideas, logic and production.

37. The Sufi Does Not Step Aside When He Sees the Fire

This is the command of the Almighty: while there is deviation somewhere, you cannot sit still.

You must not sit still.

If somewhere there is moral collapse, if there is cultural collapse, if there is economic collapse, if there is a collapse of justice because of injustice, it is impossible for the Sufi to remain silent there.

If, on one side, the individuals, identities and factions that have seized the state are laying their hands on the state's property, and public property is being squandered, the state's money is being squandered, bribery is rampant, immorality has risen above everyone's head, then it is unthinkable for a Sufi to remain silent about this. It is unthinkable for a Muslim to lie comfortably in his bed. It is unthinkable for a Muslim to take his ease. A Muslim must feel anguish over this. He does feel anguish. If his homeland is on fire, if there is a cultural, economic, political, military fire, then a Sufi stepping aside with the air of "every man for himself" and making dhikr will not save him.

Impossible. Perhaps you can save your own self, but you cannot save the generations to come. Your own child will come before you and say, "Well, I've become such-and-such." You cannot stop him. It is impossible for a Sufi to close his eyes to this.

38. The State's Support Does Not Make al-Ghazali Insincere

Because the Sufi is the one who stands against every kind of devilry, every kind of self-indulgence of the nafs. The Sufi is not someone who steps aside, remembers Allah and saves his own skin. That one is not a Sufi in the true sense. The Sufi, indeed, sees the fire. He throws himself toward the fire with all his might. That is the Sufi. Al-Ghazali does that too.

That is why al-Ghazali being supported by the system, the way being opened before him by the system, does not show, may Allah forgive me, that he was insincere. It does not show that he lacked sincerity (ikhlas).

Al-Ghazali is someone who caught fire from that blaze, whose heart was torn to pieces. He paid no heed to night or day; he took to the roads. He worked with all his strength for the Islamic world to be resurrected, to be revived again, to be renewed again. That is why al-Ghazali's being influential over the political authority of that day does not make him insincere. Nor does it require us to have doubts about his sincerity.

39. Conclusion: A Text That Criticises for the Sake of Criticising

Now, when we look from here, from this angle, I see Aydınlı's text as a delirium of the critical gaze toward the Islamic world.

I see it as a text that criticises for the sake of criticising. May Allah forgive me. I mean, when we say al-Ghazali is the main cause of the stagnation, when we say he identified philosophy with irreligion, when we say he drove the sciences out of the madrasa, this is not something that holds up either academically or in terms of its physical manifestations.

I see this somewhat as a war waged against the Islamic world by way of al-Ghazali. Because those who cannot dare to fight directly make themselves fight by way of something else. It feels to me as though it has become that kind of evasion.

40. The Worth of the Ihya': An Eighteen-Volume Commentary on Four Volumes

Al-Ghazali powerfully synthesised the kalam of Ahl al-Sunna, its fiqh, and the Sufism, the Sufi way, of Ahl al-Sunna.

The Ihya' is a perfect work in this respect. Where had I read it? Now, Ibn Hajar is a Shafi'i jurist.

The Ihya' is four volumes. He writes an 18-volume commentary on it. Ibn Hajar himself is a famous hadith scholar. At the same time he is a Shafi'i scholar, a jurist. Brothers and sisters, the Ihya' is four volumes. He writes an 18-volume commentary on the Ihya'. The Ihya' is that valuable a work. That is why, yes. Al-Ghazali was truly loved, held a place and found acceptance, especially in Sufi circles.

41. A Rose That Bloomed in the Midst of That Turmoil

That is why attributing to al-Ghazali the decline of science and learning in the Islamic world, or, I don't know, certain stagnations and declines, is to my mind truly a text that oversteps its bounds.

I mean, when you study al-Ghazali's time a little, the Mongol invasions, the political fragmentation, the economic collapses, the dispersal and collapse of educational institutions, and amid many internal and external factors, he is, so to speak, an honourable person who emerged like a rose in the midst of that chaos, that turmoil, that swamp.

That being so, I look at al-Ghazali somewhat with this eye. If I have made a slip of the tongue, may it be forgiven, but to overlook al-Ghazali's influence in the midst of that turmoil, to overlook his being a remedy for the diseases that caused the turmoil in the midst of that turmoil, would truly be the greatest betrayal against al-Ghazali.

Please forgive me any rights I owe you. May it be halal.

42. A Confession: How These Talks Are Prepared

I am trying to keep it as short as possible, but I also don't want to break up the passage. And also, you know, these al-Ghazali talks, you know, they tire a person out in the preparation stage.

Thanks and praise be that the Almighty had us acquire certain works like these beforehand, knowingly or unknowingly, let us call it a happy coincidence. Yes. It takes up our nights a bit, but then, when I finish the Saturday sohbet like this, my tiredness, in my own way, comes out.

I mean, I say, praise be. Now normally my al-Ghazali trauma will start again on Monday-Tuesday. Normally the al-Ghazali trauma goes on for 4 or 5 days with me. After that I take a text and put it there. Should I look at that part of this one, should I look at this part of that one? Where should I look at what? First I arrange the works in my own way. With what I have at hand. The ones I don't have, I try to research and find on the internet. But, in my own way, I enjoy this preparation.

I don't know whether you enjoy it? If there is anyone who says they don't, let them say so. We've gotten used to it these days anyway. So that we know, I mean, and act accordingly. Anyway, my neurons are moving very fast these days too. Very fast. Tell me then, at how many kilometres per hour does a piece of information travel in a neuron? Hayal, let me give you a task then. This is the brain's working system. I've become especially fixated on neurons lately. Normally, something happened to me like this in a waking vision. To determine this speed, this speed. I mean, to catch this speed like that, you know. By catching I mean determining. One needs to find the mathematics of this. Let me research it too then, inshallah. Yes.

And on this subject too, like this, on a Saturday, whenever it suits us, because you have your shifts and so on, I'm not pressuring you, but like this, about neurons, section by section, first explain neurons to us, for example, then inside the brain... We didn't make you a brain surgeon for nothing, I mean. Thank you, dear father. You were going to go into other fields. No, I said, you will become a brain surgeon. May Allah be pleased with you too. We turned you back from psychiatry. We turned you back from internal medicine. Well, normally, actually, you know, there is the hadith about whoever knows their nafs knowing their Lord. Of course the brain is also within the nafs; when we look at the nafs, there is a wholeness. Because, for example, a person... this is my own personal thesis from my own inner world, I don't know how much the brain's working system amounts to. I... we don't know the sum total of the whole system. Now when you look at Salih, you can find Salih's physical volume in cubic metres.

You measure his height, his width. It is possible for you to find his cubic volume. You find that. But the brain, you know, here the matter slips a bit into meaning, into metaphysics. How great is the brain's metaphysical working system?

43. On the Speed of the Brain: A Talk of Contemplation

Physically, in the past, something like this was known, dear father. Now, we have a memory centre. When we learn something, when we learn it through the senses, say when we look at Salih, his image, his tone of voice and so on, all the information related to him used to be gathered in our memory centre.

Now normally, it's true that there is a place called the memory centre, but this has been discovered. Actually, every piece of information we learn is projected onto the entire brain. I mean, it is distributed across the whole of it, and when recalling it, it doesn't come only from the memory centre. That's why, as one learns information, that place doesn't actually fill up. And new connections form between new cells.

Now, cells have arms, branches. Then, as you said, let me organise them, inshallah, explain them, turn them into a visual presentation. I mean, there are amazing things. Now, when a nerve has one connection, two connections, when it receives new information, yet another new connection grows out of it. That enters into connections with other neurons. There are millions of neurons. When you look at something, millions of neurons are working at the same time. The more knowledge, experience and seasoning there is, the more neurons and connections it means. And intelligence is, in fact, already connected to this. That's why, I mean, people who have a lot of knowledge, seasoning and experience think much faster.

In fact, their speech cannot keep up with their thought. It doesn't keep up. They think a great deal, but when conveying it, language falls short, remains deficient, so to speak. Because it cannot keep up with that speed. It is impossible for the tongue to keep up with the speed of those neurons. It is impossible for words, for letters, to keep up. It is impossible for sight to keep up. It is impossible for hearing to keep up. They work so fast that, I mean, there is nothing in the outside world that can keep up with their speed.

And they are in such fast traffic that none of them touches another. That is what amazes me the most. Nothing, it works without anything touching anything, without colliding. If they touch, there is a malfunction anyway. It becomes an illness, or there is a momentary malfunction. Like in my case. God forbid. Well, it's there in me. Son, you said, you said 40 vessels were blocked. This is the state of being blocked. If it weren't blocked... it means it now compensates for it from somewhere else. It says, this road is blocked, let's open another road here, it says. They don't stop. It produces alternatives, the brain produces. I mean, that blockage doesn't stop it. I mean, maybe you define it like that. Your blockage has opened. No, it doesn't open. It finds a separate path for itself. I mean, it knows how to bypass that spot. There is already a mechanism called a bypass, father, from there. Yes, it can use it. It's impossible not to be amazed at this, you know.

Where have we come to from where now? The Almighty, you know, this is the easy side of the matter. He created such a brain, and right now the world of science, the world of medicine, you know, the brain... let's say we say one in a million, that's too little. It doesn't know even one millionth of it. Look, 1 million is too little, I mean. Neurons need to be counted in billions.

44. «The Human Being Who Cannot Command a Single Particle of His Own Brain»

In trillions, they need to be counted in trillions. And every neuron has a function of its own.

Every neuron has its own function. It has a language of its own. It has a mind of its own. It doesn't listen to you. It isn't dependent on you. It isn't dependent on you. You cannot direct it. Such-and-such neuron, you go over there. Such-and-such neuron, you come over here. There is no such thing. It is independent of you. And so independent that you can do nothing. If it were left to us, we'd die, father, these controls. Well, even if you set up factories all the way across Turkey, it wouldn't be enough. Making the whole world into a factory, never mind Turkey. Perhaps you could describe this as a really far-fetched statement.

Never mind Turkey. Even if you turned the whole world into a factory, you could not manage the neurons in your brain. No, you could not manage them.

And this human being, who cannot command the tiniest particle in his own brain, the human being who cannot command a single particle that has been given to him, is unfortunately far from knowing Allah, far from being a servant to Him, and busies himself with empty things. It is a very bitter thing. Al-Fatiha with salawat. Amin. Next week we will continue with al-Ghazali. I suppose there are about 2 weeks of al-Ghazali left, or it seems there were 3 weeks. There are 3 or 4 more weeks of al-Ghazali. If Allah permits, inshallah, we will continue from where we left off. Forgive me any rights I may owe you. They are forgiven. May Allah be pleased with all of you. See you, inshallah. Peace be upon you. And upon you be peace.

45. Closing: The Live Broadcast Issue and an Apology

There was a question here. We listen to the sohbet from outside the city via YouTube. For the last 3 weeks the sound has been very low. We would be very glad if the volume level were increased by the technical team. Another matter: on Thursdays, the broadcast is shut off right after the dhikr. We can't stay informed about the announcements. Could the broadcast be shut off after the announcements? First of all, we offer our thanks to you, our esteemed master, and to the team that brings those far away close through social media. May Allah be pleased with you.

This place where I stand is not a place for complaining, but unfortunately we have been having problems for 3 or 4 weeks. There are complaints about this. Inshallah, brother Cafer will take this matter in hand on Monday and resolve it at the root.

Sometimes there is metal fatigue, or there is a fatigue of thought and logic. Sometimes, when a person is inside a task, there is a fatigue of seeing. This happens with shopkeepers too. A man grows tired inside the same shop. The goods need to be moved around. He doesn't move them. It causes a blindness in a person. While a person is busy with a job, there can also be a blindness that comes from that job. That is why complaints have increased lately. Putting the complaints in order and setting things right at this point is also our job. Inshallah, from Monday on, inshallah, we will solve the live broadcast problem. So may all the brothers and sisters forgive us their rights. May it be halal. Because today is Thursday, and today too we couldn't broadcast this daytime sohbet live.

Last week too, and on the Thursdays before that, one or two problems came up. We'll say, all right, this is not in our hands, some things can happen technically, but when this goes further, it goes beyond a technical fault. May Allah forgive us, inshallah.

Note: This text is the speech itself as found in the recording of the sohbet: only spelling and punctuation have been edited, and obvious mishearings in the subtitles have been corrected; a few unintelligible places have been left as heard. Section headings have been added to ease reading. The opening and closing prayers have not been included.


Bibliography

The text discussed in the sohbet, the figures mentioned and the works referred to are collected below.

Yaşar Aydınlı (2012), p. 521 — The source of the critical passage analysed point by point in the sohbet; on al-Ghazali's place in the stagnation-and-decline debate.

Imam al-Ghazali, Ihya' 'Ulum al-Din (The Revival of the Religious Sciences) — His four-volume main work; a book of spiritual training that treats the outward rulings of the acts of worship together with the afflictions of the heart, the tongue, the eye and the ear.

Imam al-Ghazali, Tahafut al-Falasifa (The Incoherence of the Philosophers) — The work in which only three views are counted as unbelief: the eternity of the world, the claim that Allah does not know particulars, and the denial of bodily resurrection.

Imam al-Ghazali, Mi'yar al-'Ilm (The Standard of Knowledge) — His work on the science of logic; the basis of the criterion "the knowledge of one who does not know logic cannot be trusted."

Ibn Hajar al-'Asqalani — commentary on the Ihya' — The Shafi'i scholar and hadith master who is reported to have written an eighteen-volume commentary on the four-volume Ihya'; mentioned as an indication of the work's scholarly standing.

Hadith — "Wisdom is the lost property of the believer" — A narration transmitted from Abu Hurayra; Tirmidhi, 'Ilm 19 and Ibn Maja, Zuhd 15. Evidence that the criterion of knowledge, rather than its source, is what is essential.

Ernest Renan, Bertrand Russell, George Saliba — Mentioned as names in the West who defend the thesis that "al-Ghazali caused the decline of Islamic thought."

Frank Griffel, George Makdisi, Richard Frank, Dimitri Gutas — Western researchers who academically oppose the same thesis and defend the view that "the decline did not begin with al-Ghazali."

Hasan Hanafi and Muhammad 'Abid al-Jabiri — Names from the Islamic world who defend the same decline thesis; they were also dealt with in the 6th talk of the series.

al-Kindi — The figure who first had Aristotle's metaphysics translated from Greek into Arabic; he named his work "first philosophy." He predates al-Ghazali.

al-Farabi and Ibn Sina (Avicenna) — The philosophers through whom, rather than directly, al-Ghazali received Aristotelian logic; Ibn Sina systematised metaphysics under the name "ilahiyyat" (divine matters).

Ibn Rushd (Averroes) — The philosopher who wrote the most comprehensive commentary on Aristotle's metaphysics; he interprets the expression "after physics" as an order of teaching.

Nasir al-Din al-Tusi, Qutb al-Din al-Shirazi, Fakhr al-Din al-Razi — Scholars who emerged after al-Ghazali and who were both theologians of kalam and mathematician-astronomers; evidence against the claim that "the sciences were removed from the madrasa."

His Holiness Ibrahim Hakki of Erzurum — The Sufi scholar who demonstrated his knowledge of astronomy and mathematics with the sun calculation at Tillo.

Hasan al-Basri, Rabi'a al-'Adawiyya, Ma'ruf al-Karkhi, Sari al-Saqati, Ibrahim ibn Adham, Bayazid al-Bistami — Perfected spiritual guides (murshid-i kamil) who lived before al-Ghazali; they show the limits of the claim that "Sufism was legitimised with al-Ghazali."

Yunus Emre — "You eat whatever comes to hand, you say whatever comes to the tongue" — The line of verse that gives the moral criterion of dervishhood; mentioned in the sohbet as the counterpart of al-Ghazali's line in popular wisdom.

Nizam al-Mulk and the Nizamiyya madrasas — The institution through which logic, astronomy, arithmetic (mathematics) and medicine entered the madrasa curriculum; the policy of strengthening Sunni scholarship.

Mustafa Özbağ Efendi, "Did al-Ghazali Cause the Decline? | Questions on al-Ghazali 7" — mustafaozbag.com — Full text of the sohbet dated 01.08.2026.

Click here for more information about Imam al-Ghazali.

Additional sources:

  • Imam al-Ghazali, Ihya' 'Ulum al-Din; the sections on acts of worship, customs, the destructive matters (muhlikat) and the saving matters (munjiyat).
  • Imam al-Ghazali, Tahafut al-Falasifa; the twenty questions and the three views counted as unbelief.
  • Imam al-Ghazali, Mi'yar al-'Ilm and Mihakk al-Nazar; logic and the methodology of syllogism.
  • Imam al-Ghazali, al-Munqidh min al-Dalal; the classification of the paths of knowledge and the transition to Sufism.
  • Tirmidhi, 'Ilm 19; Ibn Maja, Zuhd 15 — the narration "wisdom is the lost property of the believer."
  • The Holy Qur'an, al-Baqara 2/151 and 2/269; the giving of wisdom together with the Book.
  • Frank Griffel, Al-Ghazali's Philosophical Theology; an academic objection to the decline thesis.
  • George Makdisi, The Rise of Colleges; the madrasa institution and the teaching of the sciences.
  • Dimitri Gutas, Greek Thought, Arabic Culture; the translation movement and the course of philosophy.
  • al-Shahrastani, al-Milal wa al-Nihal; an introduction to Ash'arism, Maturidism and the sects.
  • al-Qushayri, al-Risala; one of the fundamental sources of the Sufi tradition before al-Ghazali.