Sunday, November 15, 2026
OUR PATH IS THE PATH OF PROPHETHOOD
Mustafa Özbağ
Irshad & Tasawwuf · Official Site
al-Ghazali Talks·

Esotericism, Reason and "Modern Islam" | Questions on al-Ghazali 6

Translated from Turkish. Original article (Turkish) →
Note: Qur'anic verses in this article are marked and will be completed with the Diyanet English translation; the Turkish original is linked above.

1. Q&A: Is Employing a Worker Without Insurance a Violation of the Rights of Others?

Yes. Before the al-Ghazali talk, we have an urgent and important question.

If an employer does not register the insurance of the worker working for him, has he usurped a right? How should this be settled, how should forgiveness be sought? Now, if a person employs a worker, he is obliged to register that worker's insurance.

If he doesn't, he has usurped a right. He doesn't settle with him; he has to settle with him and seek his forgiveness. But not registering insurance, if the insurance institution detects it, back when I was employing workers it was 2,500 lira or something? Where is Savaş? Give Savaş a microphone. Go ahead, sir.

What is the penalty for employing a worker without insurance? If the SSK detects it, the penalty amount changes depending on how far back they go, sir. But if we assume we go back one year, there is a yearly penalty of approximately 720,000. How much? 720,000. 720,000 per year. The yearly penalty, sir. Excluding premiums. Excluding premiums. If there are premiums. If there are premiums, sir, around 250,000 lira in premiums are assessed based on the minimum wage. And on top of that they charge a penalty, that is, interest. Sir, if it goes back, say, 3 years, 5 years, how do they calculate those?

They update it to the present using whatever the late-payment interest rate for that year is. Sir, I mean, if we calculate on the basis of one year, around 1 to 1,200,000 lira in premiums and penalties would be assessed, sir. If we go on the basis of one year, on the basis of one year, sir. Wow, yes, normally then, let's say, they came and raided our place, for instance, they had reported us back then, saying he's employing workers without insurance. They came and raided the workplace, and back then they took everyone's ID cards.

They checked each one's ID numbers. All of them were insured. And then of course, back then when they came to us, I, I was registering everyone's insurance. If someone started that day, I registered them that day. Because, you know, I'm someone who gets a lot of complaints filed against him. Yes. They said, well, it's routine. I said no, if it were routine you would go into the shop below, you'd go upstairs, you'd go across the street. This kind of thing isn't routine, I said. Then of course he went quiet. The official didn't say anything at that moment, but for instance he came and drew up a report. During the inspection he took their ID numbers. He recorded the report normally. There were this many employees. All of them are insured, he said. Otherwise, I mean, right now it's 1,200,000 lira per year including the penalty. Yes, sir. Well, let's say they raided there the way they raided my shop. How does it work then? They do the check in the same way, sir.

They can instantly query the ID number and determine whether the person is uninsured or not. Previously we could already register up to one month in advance. They abolished that a long time ago. Now employers are obliged to register the insurance one day in advance. One day in advance. One day in advance. So they can check with the tablets in their hands whether a person has insurance or not. Instantly, sir. Even if it's one day retroactive, there's a penalty of 67,000 1000 lira. Sir, the person who asked the question has surely heard it here already. I don't have much knowledge on this subject. That's why I said let's ask Savaş about this. That's why I asked you. The person who asked the question upstairs must be satisfied now, I suppose. May Allah grant safety.

So employing workers is not an easy thing, it seems. Yes. Allah well, yes. Now here there are questions related to, related to tonight. With permission, if the person asking this question permits, let us first read a passage and finish this part. Then let's move on to its questions and answers. Is that alright? Fine, let's ask permission, come on. Let us not, again, do things without permission. Yes. The answer to your question has come too. Very good.

2. This Week's Text: «Did al-Ghazali Turn the Umma into a Community That Does Not Question?»

Grumbles] We are continuing the al-Ghazali talks from last week.

Of course, the al-Ghazali talks may come across as a bit too technical to the friends, but as you know, our Hakan prepares that series of questions as a result of long study. It's not easy. Asking questions also requires a separate accumulation of knowledge, or research. So may Allah be pleased with him. He shows good work in this regard.

We are continuing from where we left off. In the work which, it is understood, he wrote in order to support the policy Nizam al-Mulk wanted and at his request, he says of the Batiniyya: its outside is Rafidism, its inside is pure unbelief. By establishing in the Islamic world the principle that philosophy and reason are not to be mixed into creed, al-Ghazali lays the foundations for turning the people and the umma once again into a community of servants who do not question and who take transmitted knowledge (naql) as the basis. From here, from "turning the people and the umma once again into one that does not question," he draws the conclusion that, in other words, there used to be questioning before, but after al-Ghazali there was no more questioning.

From here, "lays the foundations."

This issue was something that, back when I had just become a Sufi, the educated, those who saw themselves as learned and literate, would heat up again and again and serve to us, if I may say so, like reheated leftovers. Especially in Ödemiş, maybe because of that, when I moved to Ödemiş there were various communities there who saw themselves as somewhat radical, who threw stones at Sufism, who made snide remarks about it. With those communities, with small groups among them, we would debate these subjects a great deal and examine them at length. Especially these recent ones, you know, those who deify their reason and so on, those who deny hadiths and so on, these are a kind of mixed community.

Even though there are different factions among themselves, these are interesting types. That is why this is one of the issues much debated in the Islamic world after al-Ghazali. Of course, when our brother brings this passage here, he too takes it inspired by these debates.

So there are two issues here.

3. Separating Two Things: Historical Facts and Modern Interpreters

We need to distinguish these two issues, or two phenomena, from each other. What is this?

First, there are historical realities. There are historical facts. That is, there are facts related to Nizam al-Mulk's and al-Ghazali's time, to the time and geography in which they lived. And normally, how do today's historians or today's philosophers interpret these? How do they deal with them, what do they look at and how? This is important. For instance, this text we have read, especially, there is a segment in the Islamic world who, you know, see themselves somewhat as modern politicians.

This is a segment that stands at a modern-politician, modern-Islamic point and tries to influence people on this matter. This segment, in its own way, has taken on Western culture, studied in Western schools, and there are analyses by people who accuse the Islamic world of backwardness, accuse it of lagging behind, think the cure for this lies in the West, and who still see themselves as thinkers within the Islamic world. So, for instance, if they looked at this, does al-Ghazali really see the Batiniyya as unbelief or not, or else if they had studied the Batiniyya, and surely they do study it.

4. What Is the Batiniyya? Annulling the Outward Meaning of the Qur'an

But if, after studying it, they still do not see the Batiniyya as unbelief, then another problem arises here. Because, for instance, in al-Ghazali's work titled The Inner Face of the Batiniyya (Fada'ih al-Batiniyya), al-Ghazali severely criticizes the Ismaili Batini movement.

This is true. But, well, I had already mentioned this in previous lessons. That is, in the work, specifically and in summary, al-Ghazali says that interpretations that completely annul the outward meaning (zahir) of the Qur'an cannot be accepted. Now I need to open this up a little. How do I need to open it up? The very reason the Batiniyya is called Batini is that, well, they regard the outward rulings of the Qur'an as entirely null and void.

Now, yes, there is a hadith. You know, the verses of the Qur'an and the hadiths have an outward meaning and also an inward meaning. This is established by hadith. The Sufis, for instance, expressed this through those commentaries we call allusive exegesis (ishari tafsir). But none of them rejected the outward rulings of the Qur'an.

Now, when you say Batiniyya, there is a rejection of the outward rulings of the Qur'an. There is a rejection of the law within the Batiniyya. Now this is such a point that, then, when looking at the Batiniyya, where are we to look from, by ourselves? We will look at the Batiniyya from the works they produced. Where will we look from? We will look from Hasan-i Sabbah. For example, where will we look from? Well, we will look from the Fatimid state. Then, normally, when we look at the Batiniyya, something very different will appear before us.

Well, now, when that very different thing appears, normally now, may Allah forgive us, our not seeing this as unbelief would make us fall into unbelief too. Well, al-Ghazali, well, on the Ahl al-Sunna line, normally, of course, he will see this matter as unbelief. Because you annul the outward meaning of the Qur'an. Because this is what the Western world wants.

5. What Remains When the Outward Is Removed? Law, Prayer and Covering

The Western world wants the outward meaning of the Qur'an to be annulled. Especially, it wants its law to be annulled. Indeed, if you remove and annul the law of the Qur'an, only the worship part remains.

Well, if you also remove the outward form of worship, that is, well, what is the prayer (namaz)? It is a worship fixed with its bowing, its prostration, its standing, the things to be recited, the things to be done. It doesn't appear as namaz, it appears as salat. Yes. Once it is salat, if you pray however you like, that is not prayer. You'll do it sitting down, and if you call that prayer too, what are you going to call it? That's what they do. Or else, the covering of women, or else the sharia of Islam, sharia law — when these are in question, you will do away with the outward.

As for the law, yes. Back then Arab society needed that law. That's what they'll say. May Allah protect us.

6. The Doctrine of the Infallible Imam: A Claim Without Proof

The most important place we will look at critically in the Batiniyya is the doctrine of an infallible imam after the prophets.

Well, normally this has no religious proof. Only His Excellency the Prophet, may Allah bless him and grant him peace, and the prophets were infallible.

Well, the Prophet, may Allah bless him and grant him peace, passed away. The office and institution of prophethood ended outwardly: "After me there will come neither a nabi nor a prophet." It is established by a verse that the last prophet is His Excellency Muhammad Mustafa. May Allah bless him and grant him peace. After him, no prophet will come. Then where did this doctrine of the infallible imam come from?

It came from Ismaili Batinism. So, normally, there is no proof for it in the Qur'an or in the noble Sunna. Because there is no proof from the Qur'an and the noble Sunna, al-Ghazali insistently denies it and writes a refutation of it.

7. The Political Side of the Batiniyya: The Project to Topple the Seljuks

Of course, one of the most important measures, rules of the Batini is that this thought carries a political aim, and what is the aim?

It is to topple the Seljuks. Behind the religion, behind the religious thought, the religious stance, the religious style, there is the toppling of the Seljuk state. Now, we don't even need to go back to the Seljuk era.

Look, if you try to topple a state, that state responds to you rhythmically. This is the reason a state is a state. You can criticize some of the state's laws, institutions, rules, but if you are trying to topple the state, the state responds to you rhythmically. Especially if, against a lineage that has come all the way from Central Asia, founded so many states and toppled states, you form an action or a series of actions trying to topple the state, the state responds to you rhythmically.

This is rhythmic. Certain organs within the state watch these. They track these. Whom did you turn your weapon against? You turned it against the state. The state, if I may put it this way, rolls over you like a steamroller. One of the most important errors of the Batiniyya is toppling the state, and it does this through assassinations.

It places various agents inside the state. In its own way, through the assassinations of those agents, it puts considerable pressure on the Seljuks.

8. An Important Distinction: al-Ghazali Does Not Declare the Shi'a Unbelievers

But interestingly, al-Ghazali does not make takfir of the Shi'i, of the Shi'a.

He does not make takfir of the Shi'ites either. Well, now, among today's Shi'ites, there are the Twelver Shi'a. Now, at present, within the Shi'ites there is Twelver Shi'ism.

This Twelver Shi'ism and the Ismaili Batini movement that was being fought against back then are not at the same point. If, normally, we confuse this and see them at the same point, I, as Mustafa Özbağ, would regard that as not having analyzed it correctly. So Twelver Shi'ism and the Ismaili Batini line are not the same line. And if you cut the religion, Islam entirely, off from its outward meanings and render the acts of worship invalid, then this time you will have set against yourself those who live that religion, who, while living within that religion, are distinguished by their knowledge.

Well, now, when we look, there is such a problem in the Batiniyya. That is, cutting the religion off from its outward meaning and pushing absolutely everything, in their own way, into Batinism.

9. Today's Batiniyya: Those Who Say «Doing Good Is Also Salat»

Today, too, under the name of Sufism or under various other names, there are again groups and elements in the Islamic world trying to cut the religion off from its outward meaning.

Normally, if that person, you know, goes on television and says, well, doing a kindness to someone is also salat, there is a problem.

Or else, if a person says with full conviction, "May Allah curse those who made this prayer a calamity upon the Umma," there is a problem here.

Then there is no difference between the Batiniyya of that day and those who say these things today. These, normally, inspired by Fazlur Rahman, are identities of this type within the Islamic world. These are Masonic identities. Being a graduate of al-Azhar does not change their identity.

10. Secrecy and Closed Organisation: «Our Door Has Been Open for Forty Years»

That is why there is also secrecy and closed organisation among the Batinis.

Look, in Islam there is no secrecy and closed organisation. This humble servant has been giving sohbet for 40 years.

For 40 years the door has been open. We have nothing secret or hidden. We have no back garden. The religion is this. We explain the Qur'an and the Sunna. As far as our tongue allows, as far as we know. We explain Sufism as far as our tongue allows, and our message is open.

Let me give an example. Our talk here is broadcast live on YouTube. It is possible for you to find my talks going back 25 years, 30 years. They are broadcast on YouTube. We have no concealment, no secrecy. Because the religion of Islam is open to everyone. Sufism, too, is open to everyone. That being so, there is nothing hidden or secret. And there should not be. But in the Batiniyya there is a secrecy. There is a closedness. There is this kind of keeping themselves to themselves, within their own circle.

Look, today there are communities and tariqas that practise this same thing. What of yours is secret, my brother? Islam, the Qur'an, is out in the open, it is not secret. The hadiths are out in the open, they are not secret. Or the words spoken by the people of Sufism are not secret. They are in the books. Then what of yours are you hiding? If you are concealing something, hiding something, there are other things behind it. Yes. That is why the Batinis, normally, also associated themselves with political rebellions and stirred up fitna in society, and by stirring up fitna in that society they left society exposed to fitna.

When we look at that, then, he did not regard the Batiniyya as reasonable. Or else, if you cover an Islamic formation or an Islamic community with secrecy and closedness, to a greater or lesser degree, then there is something different there. One must be careful. On one point: why did Nizam al-Mulk support al-Ghazali? We need to look at the reason for his support here in terms of the historical context. And we also need to look at it in the religious context.

11. Why Did Nizam al-Mulk Support al-Ghazali? The Historical Context

Well, now, when we look from the point of view of the historical context, in that century the Seljuk state is hostile to the Fatimid state.

The one in Egypt. And internally there is the movement of Hasan-i Sabbah. As is well known, he has settled himself in and established himself at Alamut Castle. That is, it is an organisation trying to destroy the state from within. And normally there is also Ismaili propaganda. The Seljuk state is also dealing with that Ismaili propaganda. Now, you are the state.

You are a state. When you say the Seljuk state, it is a Muslim Turkish state. Do not take this as racism. And while founding that state you went through great hardships. You gave many martyrs, and to keep that state standing you struggled with Byzantium. 1071, Manzikert. And Nizam al-Mulk is, after all, Alp Arslan's vizier. Well, now, he knows very well where Alp Arslan came from, and he also knows very well where the Turkish states came from.

And he also sees very well the dangers coming to the state from within and from without. That being so, Nizam al-Mulk normally thinks of the continuity of the state, its survival. He does not think day to day. He does not think in terms of 5 years, 10 years. He thinks of the survival of the state.

12. The Nizamiyya Madrasas: Answering Ideas with Ideas

That being so, he founds the Nizamiyya madrasas. Because one of their aims, one of the aims of the Nizamiyya madrasas, as I mentioned in previous lessons, is to strengthen Sunni scholarship. Because against those Ismaili Batini ideas, against the ideas of Hasan-i Sabbah, the struggle must again be waged with ideas.

That is why the Nizamiyya madrasas train scholars bound to the Qur'an and to the state of that day.

13. Every State Has a Religious Pillar: England, the Vatican, America and France

These are scholars. Look, do not forget this.

All the states in the world have, in their own way, a religious pillar. Whether it is right, whether it is wrong, whether it is deficient.

Today you go to England; England has established the church of its own royal family. That state takes its religious power from the royal family. Others, for example, are bound to the Vatican. Of course, there is a pope in the Vatican. Of course, Trump too at one point had his eye on the papacy. He was going to topple this pope and become pope himself. Because himself, look, all American presidents see themselves as divinely ordained presidents.

Shall I underline this once again? All American presidents believe that they have been chosen by the divine Lord. Each of them believes that they were sent by the divine Lord and that they are helpers of Jesus. All American presidents, they have been specially chosen. They will prepare the ground for Jesus to descend to earth again. All states, even France, are not secular.

If it were secular, it would not bother with Muslims' headscarves. If they were secular, they would not bother with Muslims. If secularism is as it has been explained to us, then we have no definition of secularism anyway. With us it came from France. We do not live the secularism that is in France. That is a separate matter too. That is why these are the reasons for his supporting al-Ghazali. To ensure the unity of state and nation. And in ensuring the unity of state and nation, religion is one of the most important factors. And while al-Ghazali was writing a refutation of the Batiniyya, alongside the principles of the religion he also entered into politics. Politics, politics too answered him. Now, what else was there?

14. The Claim «al-Ghazali Rejected Reason»: Rejecting versus Setting Limits

One of the points is that al-Ghazali completely rejected reason.

This is talked about even in university circles. A professor, a professor once told me this. He said, "The Islamic world, one of the greatest harms al-Ghazali did," he said, "is his rejecting reason in the Islamic world," he said. I said, Hocam, don't misunderstand me, but there is no such thing in al-Ghazali.

Back then I too was leafing through books a bit. I said, when we look at the Ihya', there is no such thing. That is, rejecting reason is a different thing.

Setting limits on reason is a different thing. They do not explain this fine line. They do not put it like this. When they come before society, they produce slogan-like words. They produce sentences. "Al-Ghazali rejected reason."

Al-Ghazali does not reject reason. He sets limits on reason. How does he set limits on reason? To reason he says: reason stops at the boundary of revelation. That is, it cannot rise above revelation. That is, study al-Ghazali a little, just a little like this. Study a few of his books, for example Mi'yar al-'Ilm (The Standard of Knowledge), study that one too. There is no rejection of reason. That is, he has a small treatise called al-Mustaqim. Study that. There is no rejection of reason there. In fact, in those places al-Ghazali defends logic. He is not an illogical person.

15. «The Knowledge of One Who Does Not Know Logic Cannot Be Trusted»: al-Ghazali as a Logician

Al-Ghazali is a logician. In fact he says, this is al-Ghazali's own saying. He says the knowledge of one who does not know logic cannot be trusted. For example, if a person does not know logic, his fatwa cannot be trusted.

If a person has nothing to do with logic, that person's fatwa is not valid. That is, this is in fact one of today's handicaps. Or else, fatwas are not produced according to the person.

That is one of today's handicaps. What does the man need? What does that region need? What does that family need? How should what be? There is also individual fatwa in Islam. At present there is no organization in the Islamic world that can give that individual fatwa. Al-Ghazali does not reject logic.

What does he reject? He rejects reason getting ahead of revelation. This is exactly where he stands.

16. The West's Proposal: «Set Revelation Aside, Use Your Reason»

This is the parting of ways between the West, the Westernizers, and the thinkers or scholars of the classical Islamic world.

The West and the Westernizers say to us, "Set revelation aside, use your reason. You are human beings, you are superior beings. Walk by reason. Not by revelation, come on." They go even further. What do they say? "Muhammad," that's how they say it.

They don't say sallallahu 'alayhi wa sallam. "Muhammad was a very intelligent man among the Arabs. He thought, how can I govern these Arabs? He went to Mount Hira. After thinking, he said, I will govern them with religion. He started writing Qur'anic verses," they say. They walk by reason and they say that these Qur'anic verses cannot possibly be applied in this age. They walk by reason. And al-Ghazali makes the defense against this.

Because the Batinis were pressing very hard at that time. At the same time, theology was being studied in Europe. Theology in Europe, that is, the history of religion, was being studied, religions were being studied. There too there was a great preparation. What was the preparation? To drag the Islamic world down on the intellectual plane. And they had to carry out this dragging down, again, by means of elements within the Islamic world. Because, not for today but for that day, it was not possible for them to fight the Muslims, wage battle on the field and defeat the Muslims.

They won temporary, small victories. But the Muslims would pull themselves together and give them a very sharp answer, and they kept being defeated. There are 6, 7 Crusades. They were defeated in all of them. And having been defeated in all of them, this time they had to collapse the Islamic world from within. That is, they had to say, go to Lausanne and promise at Lausanne that you will abolish the caliphate.

And we will promise to recognize your state. They had to collapse it from within. When we look at this normally, at that time there were very great dangers not only over the Seljuks but over the entire Islamic world.

17. The Meaning of 1071: The Sign of a Revival

In saying it this way I may have spoken with ecstatic boldness (shatahat). That is, if 1071 had not happened, today you could not be talking about Islam.

Look, today you could not be talking about Islam. These, you know, are the turning points of a community, of a religious community, or of a nation, these are.

That is, 1071 is a turning point in this sense. It is the sign, the banner of the Islamic world's revival, of its rising up again, of its becoming strong again. 1071, and this is not to be thought of merely as a victory of the Turks.

18. The Reason of the Heart: The Realm Where Reason Cannot Produce Knowledge

In 1071, it is all the Muslim elements in this geography coming together, entering into a very great jihad against Byzantium, against the unbelievers, and from there reaching victory by the grace and generosity of the Almighty. This is the grace and generosity of Allah. This is the revival of the Islamic world. That is why 1071 needs to be looked at again and again. For example, Çanakkale (Gallipoli) is like this too. But 1071 is more important than Çanakkale. Alp Arslan and Nizam al-Mulk are aware of the danger, conscious of it. That is why al-Ghazali, for example, keeps revelation ahead of reason, in front of it. He does not hold reason above revelation.

He does not let the verses of the Qur'an be mocked. He does not let the hadiths be mocked. At this point al-Ghazali wages this struggle. Al-Ghazali wages the struggle of holding fast to the Qur'an and the Sunna.

And while waging this struggle, one of the most important pillars, elements, foundations is the Sufi world. The Sufis of that day, the Sufi world, stand in front of and behind the Seljuks and al-Ghazali. And those who criticize al-Ghazali are those who say he opened a great deal of ground, a great deal of room for Sufi-ness, that is, for Sufism (tasawwuf). It was not appropriate to open so much ground, so much room for them, they say. And al-Ghazali, reason... you call it metaphysics, don't you.

We say ma'na (meaning), we say the spiritual. Now in the new language they say metaphysics. For example, reason knows nothing of dreams, of spiritual states, of ma'na. Reason cannot produce knowledge there. Because it is a realm reason does not know. That is the realm of the reason of the heart.

You see a dream. That dream is not something reason can interpret, not something reason can work out. It is something only the reason of the heart can work out. And that too is related only to the light of discernment (firasa) coming to that heart, to divine knowledge coming to it. Well, this is something above reason.

The reason of the heart is above ordinary reason. Because the realm of the reason of the heart is vast. Its understanding, its perception, its manifestations are above normal reason. Because normal reason acquires knowledge from what it reads, what it sees, what it tastes, what it touches. Whereas the reason of the heart binds itself to Allah by a divine path. The reason of the heart takes knowledge from Allah. Its, the reason of the heart's, state is reality (haqiqa). It takes its knowledge from the veil of reality, from the realm of reality. That being so, it is not possible for ordinary reason to keep pace with it. Al-Ghazali explains this to people. He says, it is not possible for you to grasp these divine wisdoms with your normal reason.

Because the Almighty, in the verses of the Qur'an, gave His prophets wisdom (hikma) together with the Book. Wisdom is to become acquainted with the essence, the reality of a matter. The way to this passes through Sufi-ness. I am saying the way to this is through Sufi-ness, I am not saying through Sufism (tasawwuf). Sufism is its written form. Sufi-ness is its lived form. The way to this passes through Sufi-ness. That being so, al-Ghazali, in that famous Tahafut al-Falasifa (The Incoherence of the Philosophers) of his, if I may put it this way, it was a work I studied 20 years ago. May Allah forgive us. He slaps al-Farabi and Ibn Sina (Avicenna). And this is what offends these worshippers of reason the most. This greatly offends these university circles. Because both al-Farabi and Ibn Sina defend the eternity of the world. Al-Farabi and Ibn Sina too, pay attention to these points, you know, I am now going to connect this to something. He says that Allah does not know particulars. He says Allah does not know the particulars.

19. Tahafut al-Falasifa: An Answer to al-Farabi and Ibn Sina

Ibn Sina as well as al-Farabi. Now, a professor came on television and what did he say?

He said Allah does not know the next day. All of Turkey listened to him and nobody raised their voice. He said it openly on television. He said Allah does not know the next day. Do you know whose saying this is?

This is the saying of Ibn Sina, of al-Farabi. The first to say this in the Islamic world is al-Farabi. It is Ibn Sina. Before them too there were those who spoke of it. These are Jewish corruptions. Those who corrupt the religions on earth are the Jews. These Masonic Jews hold themselves obliged to corrupt all religions and religious people other than themselves. These are Jewish corruptions. They try to corrupt your creed. That professor comes out and says on television, looking all the people right in the eye, Allah does not know tomorrow, he says. And normally, what do they say?

Some professors come out and say, they mock the gathering of the Last Day. On the Day of Reckoning you will not be clothed in a body again. The Day of Reckoning, that is, there is no resurrection, they say. Al-Farabi says this too, Ibn Sina says this too. These are the corrupt voices of Ibn Sina, of al-Farabi, in this century.

For that time, al-Ghazali does a great work. With Tahafut al-Falasifa (The Incoherence of the Philosophers) he buries Ibn Sina and al-Farabi and their corrupt ideas. You know, its description in Turkish is "a reply to the philosophers." The Turkish description of the book, that is, al-Ghazali does not debate reason but the limits of reason. Al-Ghazali does not debate reason itself. The Islamic world does not debate reason. Because the verse (ayah) of the Qur'an is for those who possess reason. Religion is for the one who possesses reason.

20. Religion Is for Those Who Possess Reason: Reason Is the Condition of Worship

Prayer is for the one with reason, fasting is for the one with reason. Zakat is for the one with reason. Hajj is for the one with reason. The prohibitions are for the one with reason. Dhikr... The man without reason has no prayer. The man without reason has no fast. The man without reason has no zakat. The man without reason has no hajj. He is a person without reason. Because that person without reason denies Allah. He has no reason. Because religion is for the one who has reason. It is not for the one who has no reason.

That being so, it is not possible for al-Ghazali to reject reason, to debate reason. For example, the first exegetes, or the Tabi'un and the Tabi' al-Tabi'in, never enter into a debate concerning the existence of Allah.

Because they say this. If a person is going to debate the existence of Allah, he is without reason, they say. We cannot debate with a person without reason, they say. Because we would have fallen to his level, they say. Why? The existence of Allah is not up for debate. Because if someone possesses reason, he does not debate it. But normally, of course, by saying it this way, what do they say? There, see what al-Ghazali did? After him he turned society into sheep that do not question. The one who really turned societies into sheep is the West. The ones who really turned society into sheep are the Westernizers. But today those who have come under the hegemony of the West, who have come under the hegemony of the imperialists, who have handed over their hearts, their minds, their bodies to the West, they question al-Ghazali or they question Islam. They say, "You are like sheep." Come on, when saying these things, have a little fairness. Put your hand on your conscience. Normally, who defends this in the Islamic world?

When you look into it a little, it appears before you. Who is it? Muhammad Abid al-Jabiri. Who? Mohammed Arkoun. Who? Hassan Hanafi. Who? Fazlur Rahman. These have followers inside the country.

21. The Sources of This Thesis: al-Jabiri, Arkoun, Hassan Hanafi, Fazlur Rahman

There are followers, just as you know. That is, normally, some, for example, well, those who newly see themselves as modern historians, when you look into them a little, who is it? Muhammad al-Jabiri. This one, for example? This one is talked about a lot in university circles. They quote from them. One who quotes from him, normally, well, I had heard the name from a professor in Çanakkale. His Fazlur Rahman, everyone knows already. These, normally, today's Islamic politicians, you know, those in Islam who are involved in politics, they cut, copy and paste from the writings of these men as if they were their own ideas. But if you haven't studied these men, if you haven't looked at their books, you won't know that he cut, copied and pasted. You say, oh how nice, he has such interesting contemporary ideas. Who is this? He is Moroccan. He is a Moroccan philosopher.

He is not a scholar of Islam. This man says the reason the Islamic world has fallen behind is its way of thinking. The Islamic world does not think, that is, according to him. And normally he also says that the things that kill this thinking, the things that kill thought, are these transmitted texts (naql). You know, when you say naql, the Qur'an is naql. The hadiths are naql. If you live by looking to these transmitted texts, you cannot develop, he says. But, and according to al-Jabiri, the Islamic world fell behind because over time it moved away from using reason. That is what he says. And while criticizing al-Ghazali, he also says that al-Ghazali gave great importance to kalam, that he placed Sufism at the center of Islamic life and thought, and that he set philosophy back.

22. The Litmus Test: Hostility to Sufism

Look, their trouble is always the Sufis. Now, if a politician is busying himself with the Sufis, know that he has taken breezes from al-Jabiri. Whoever it is, see this criticizing of Sufism, being hostile to it, like litmus paper. If a person, quietly, underhandedly, seeing the shortcomings and deficiencies of the Sufis, criticizes the Sufi world, the Sufi movements in front of you, runs them into the ground, writes refutations, yes, he is a Fazlur Rahman follower. He is a Jabiri follower. Who is that? Mohammed Arkoun. Where? Do you know where this Algerian served? In France, at the Sorbonne University. When you research the Sorbonne University a little, do you know what comes up before you? When the Sorbonne University was founded, it was founded purely on theology. That is, related to the history of religions. Right in the very middle of Paris, well, I'll tell you roughly as much as I remember.

Later you can research and correct it. Do you think a university founded in the 1300s, 1400, in the 1400s, would be beneficial to the Islamic world? He served there. His post, what? Anthropology. What does it have to do with religion?

23. Historicism: Localizing the Rulings of the Qur'an

There is anthropology, and they say that in the Islamic world no idea can be voiced about its view. It has been made unthinkable, he says. Normally, the Qur'an, look, I am saying these things openly. When you research these, what do they say in their books or in their treatises? When you look at the academic studies, the theses, other articles in university circles, you see these things in fine detail. That is, well, he wants to look at loyalty to the Qur'an, at the hadiths, at fiqh, at kalam, through a historical filter. That is, the Qur'an, the Sunna, fiqh, kalam, Sufism, all of them must be put through the historical filter. Now come over to this side. Right now there is historicism in the theology faculties. Articles are being published in the faculties of theology. Concerning the historicity of the Qur'an. That is, if the Qur'an, Islam, has ruled on something from the standpoint of law, it must be looked at historically, he says. It must be looked at locally, he says. You cannot look at this universally, he says.

Who is the intellectual father of this? The intellectual father of this is Mohammed Arkoun. Raised in Algeria. Fed and fattened up in France. Thrown into the Islamic world like a bomb. Who is one of the most important critics of al-Ghazali? Hassan Hanafi. When we look at Hassan Hanafi, it sounds soft to us. It sounds sweet to us. Why? As a name it comes from Imam Hanafi. We look warmly on every name Hanafi. So to speak, we jump at it. It isn't so. He too is a professor at Cairo University. Do you know what his basic view is? A Marxist, Leninist man. Is his being Marxist-Leninist a danger? It isn't important to me. He is someone who tries to combine Marxism and Islam. This one criticizes al-Ghazali. He himself, for example, as a Marxist system, says, come on, everyone should be equal. He puts forward the things of the Marxist system, just as you know it. Who? Hassan Hanafi.

Where was it that I read a small treatise? These are, you know, the new understanding. There are the existentialists, there are the who-knows-what-ists. They have lots of things. Little ones, like this. Now, I haven't been able to read for a long time anymore. I mean, for a very long time my eyes have been troubling me. May Allah forgive me, inshallah. This isn't like running away from duty. I had read it somewhere. Like that, he had various treatises like that. Yes. He himself is a Marxist-Leninist. But in my view, someone trying to synthesize Islam and Marxism is just a poor wretch. Who is the most important one? Fazlur Rahman. I put him last. Because in this country there are Fazlur Rahman followers. And this university youth, or a portion of university faculty members like this, and a portion of Islamic politicians, I mean, are Fazlur Rahman followers, are Taymiyya followers. For example, there was that thing who denied the hadiths and lived in America, sir, the Ali Shariati followers.

These are interesting types. And a portion of the Islamic political people in Turkey go along the Fazlur Rahman, Ali Shariati line. Like this, for example, they see us as reactionary. Classical Muslim, classical Sufi. Never form a bond with us. You won't become what they want. They also cut their ties with the people who form a bond with us. Well, when we are firmly bound to the verse, the hadith, and then fiqh, firmly like this, it doesn't suit these imperialists. Yes. Those imperialists also have their own agents inside the country. The man has handed over his heart, his soul, his body, everything of his to imperialism. The man takes pleasure in being violated by Satan. Yes. This Fazlur Rahman is actually Pakistani himself. Do you know where he served as a faculty member? In Chicago. The University of Chicago, where Fazlur Rahman served as a faculty member. The University of Chicago, where he did his work.

Is this enough for you? I mean, can you imagine? I don't know what there is in this America. Whatever deviants there are in the Islamic world gather in America. There's one more, you know, he too publishes in America. What was his name? He went from Turkey. His father disowned him. Metin Yüksel, Edip Yüksel. Where? In America. If your ideas are right, come and defend them here. If you're going to go to prison, go. If you're going to suffer hardship, suffer it. Why are you sitting in the lap of the infidel and pronouncing judgments from there? These have sat in the lap of the CIA. They pronounce judgments from there. Ha, from there he gives ideas about how the Islamic world will develop. Come and develop it here, explain your ideas, let us benefit. As an entire ummah, they're nowhere. Where will they go? One is in Paris. Where? One is in Chicago. Where? One is in England. I'm giving examples. These are over there. Whoever it is that feeds them.

For example, one of Fazlur Rahman's ideas says: we look at which purpose the ruling fulfilled in the society in which the Qur'an was revealed. I mean, the Qur'an revealed a ruling. It revealed it to that society. It achieved that society's purpose. I mean, not to Anatolia, not to England, not to America. This is Fazlur Rahman. Their common aspect, all of them, these four people we listed, these, I took them as examples. These aren't four people. There are many of these. I took the famous ones. These are anti-Ghazali, these are anti-hadith, these are anti-fiqh.

24. Renewing Ijtihad and Rejecting Ijtihad Are Not the Same Thing

Look, someone performing ijtihad anew on a matter in the name of Islam, in the name of his own Islamic life, is one thing.

Throwing out the ijtihads entirely, saying "yuck, dirty," is another thing.

I am in favor of some matters being subjected to ijtihad anew. Yes, right. The ijtihads need to be renewed. Yes, right. Renewing ijtihads is one thing. Rejecting ijtihads entirely is another thing.

Interpreting the ambiguous (mutashabih) verses of the Qur'an is one thing. But you abolishing the legal verses of the Qur'an that are not ambiguous is another thing. These are trying to abolish the legal verses of the Qur'an, I mean the radiant sharia. This point is a different thing. I mean, there it says interest is forbidden, right. He says: in the Arab society of that day, interest doubled and multiplied was forbidden. Well, in today's society, he says, interest is necessary.

25. The "Doubled and Multiplied Interest" Interpretation and the World's Interest Order

That's why, he says, if it isn't doubled and multiplied, look, they say this to you in a scholarly manner. They say it sweetly, sweetly. Doubled interest was made forbidden. If it isn't doubled and multiplied, it isn't forbidden. Because, he says, in today's economic society money, he says, money has a value.

Money has a worth. Money normally has, you know, a cost. The cost of that money is interest, he says. We have to take this, he says. Who are the biggest usurers of this world?

The Jews; the biggest usurers of the world are the Jews and Jewish imitations. It is these usurers who exploit all the states and all the people. The world owes these usurers 375 billion dollars. States are included in this. If you knew the interest that the State of the Republic of Turkey pays, you would jump up and down every month. If you love your state and your nation, if they distributed that interest paid every month to the poor and needy, the country would become rich. To whom does this interest go? It goes to those rich companies, it goes to the money barons. When it is like this, those who hold this type of thinking say "classical," you know, in order to belittle it like that.

26. What Is It You Call "Modern Islam"? — A Series of Questions

These have remained in classical Islam. What is modern Islam? What do you understand by modern Islam? On the beaches you uncover every part of yourselves. To uncover even more? Under the name of art you commit every kind of disgrace. Is it to say yes to those? What do you understand by modern Islam? Let someone explain this to us. We normally don't know what is hidden behind the words.

If the thing you make us swallow as modern Islam is the abandonment of the Qur'an and the Sunna, let me say it openly. Is what you call modern Islam an Islam without prayer, without fasting, without zakat, without hajj?

Is what you call modern Islam a community of beardless men? Is what you call modern Islam having men open their collars and chests, have their hair and body hair removed, plucked like chickens, dressed in skin-tight trousers and made to walk like homosexuals? What is it? What is it that you understand by modern Islam, that you want to give us?

As modern Islam you stripped our women, turned them into peeled onions, plucked them like chickens. Is this modern Islam? Saying "modern Islam," with balls and this and that, this society was corrupted. Is this modern Islam? Is modern Islam fornication being free? Is modern Islam interest being free? Is modern Islam gambling being free? What is modern Islam? Is it children not listening to their mothers and fathers, not obeying them? What is modern Islam? Is it women not listening to their husbands, not obeying them, going around with five men in a single day? What is modern Islam? Modern Islam: even if the woman goes around with five men, her marriage stands with whomever she is officially married to. Is this modern Islam? Is this what you are trying to tell us as modern Islam? I am curious. What are we going to fill modern Islam with, top to bottom? Whatever. A group of women has come out. They have uncovered every part of themselves. Everyone screaming along with them.

Is holding a rite there modern Islam? What is modern Islam? Is it accepting the lack of culture that corrupts us, the exhibitionism that corrupts us, every kind of devilry that corrupts us?

What is it that we understand by modern Islam? I am curious. Someone says to me, "Hocam, you are classical Islam." Well, fine, who is classical? Right?

27. «You Are Classical Islam»: The Beard, Artificial Intelligence and Being Sixty-Five

Well, I say it to our friends too. Let's buy me a classic car, I tell them. We couldn't come across a 1938 model. Yes. I am classic. That's what a lady said.

If I am overstepping my bounds, I apologise, forgive me, but, she said, if you could shorten your beard a little, she said. Oh, so when it's modern Islam, the beard will be short. Oh, and apparently I would be very handsome if I grew stubble; she even made one with artificial intelligence and sent it to me. Look, Hocam, she said. This is how you look with stubble in artificial intelligence. You look very young, she said.

So I wrote back, I said. I am 65. Leave walking aside, I said. After that, don't even turn around and look, I said. That's behind me now, I said. You are very outspoken, she said. Well, I'm classic, I said. That's why I am outspoken. Come on, what is modern Islam? Let someone explain this to me, come on. They can't explain it. So these individuals, the individuals in question and their extensions, the imperialists and their local collaborators, are trying to separate us from the Qur'an and from the Sunna.

This was the danger al-Ghazali saw in his own day. In that day, its advocates were the Batinis. In that day, it was the Ismaili-Batini line. Well, normally, of course, when we look at these individuals, sometimes, while preparing this sohbet, I said to myself, you know, as I said, are you being unjust, going this far — you know, you wrote even heavier things, I'm not reading them now. For a moment I stepped back, I mean, I said, are you perhaps being unjust towards them, I said. No, no, I mean, what does it mean to interpret the verses historically, come on? What are you going to destroy? What does it mean to interpret the hadiths historically? What are you going to destroy? May Allah forgive us. (Amin.)

28. The Slogan «Critical Philosophy Weakened»

And normally, of course, these people say that after al-Ghazali, you know, al-Ghazali opened a door ajar, opened a door. As if that door had been closed. As if that door was opened with al-Ghazali. As if al-Ghazali had spoken of something that hadn't existed until that day, they say, you know, you gave importance to transmitted knowledge (naql), you gave importance to revelation (wahy). That is, you abandoned critical philosophy. It weakened, you see. Critical philosophy. Oh, isn't that such a modern sentence? Sit and think about critical philosophy until morning. You've got nothing better to do, Mustafa Özbağ. Of course, critical philosophy. What did you understand? Now you're going to say this to society. You're going to say critical philosophy weakened. Our Anatolian Muslims will sit from morning till evening. They'll say, what was critical philosophy again? Well, now when we look here, 60–70% of the friends here are university graduates. Fine. Now when we say critical philosophy to them, 50 or 60% of them will understand this.

How are you going to say this to Islamic society? After al-Ghazali — friends, I need one of those things too. Is it called a scarf, is it called a foulard, right? And it'll be a coloured scarf, right? Like this on my throat, around my neck. And it won't be this outfit either, right? And we'll toss the scarf over to the side, friends. After al-Ghazali, this society weakened in critical philosophy. Society abandoned critical philosophy. Allah Allah. So what happened? With al-Ghazali you became sheep. Allah Allah. With al-Ghazali we became sheep. Is that so? Allah Allah. Who on earth turned us into sheep, come on? The only work of al-Ghazali read in this country is his Ihya'.

29. Where Did This Nation Become Sheep? Booklessness, the Gallows and Hunger

And he wrote the Ihya' after leaving his state post. The Ihya' has many translations. When you read the Ihya', you don't become sheep at all. If these people read the Ihya', they would criticise. And whom would they criticise? They would criticise you, you enemies of hadith. If these people read the Ihya', they would say: you unbelievers. Yes. This society of ours does not read al-Ghazali.

Our society doesn't read Imam Abu Hanifa (Imam-i A'zam) either. Our society doesn't read Imam Muhammad either. How could it read them anyway? Until 50 years ago it was impossible to find Turkish versions of their books. Where would it read them from? Until 30, 40, 50 years ago this society didn't even know a Turkish version of the Ihya' anyway. From al-Ghazali's Mantiq al-Tayr to the Falasifa, there was no Turkish version. This society can't read the Qur'an anyway. And those who could read it, we hanged. And those who knew, we hanged. As for those who could read, some of those who knew, we gave as martyrs at Çanakkale. Then we gave martyrs in the War of Independence. Those who read, those who knew, saying "homeland, nation," gave up their lives, gave them. And the rest, those who were left behind, we hanged them, didn't we. Where did this nation become sheep? From al-Ghazali, whom it doesn't read? From the hadiths, which it doesn't read? Did it become sheep from the Qur'an, which it doesn't read? Where did this nation become sheep?

I'll tell you where you became sheep, but no one can bear the weight of it.

I am included in this too. If you make books unreadable in a nation's hands, then you become sheep. If you hang the scholars and sheikhs who are the nation's leaders, then you become sheep. There is no one left to stir you into action. Because, well, that's how this nation became sheep. That's how the Islamic world became sheep. If you put Saddam at the head of Iraq, if you put Assad at the head of Syria, if you erect statues of the father Assad, of the whole Assad, everywhere, if you erect statues of Saddam everywhere, and whatever you have of the Qur'an and the Sunna is taken from your hands, you become sheep.

Then imagine a society.

30. The Other Tools of Turning People into Sheep: Food, Debt and Consumption

With what is a society that has not learned its religion turned into sheep? With irreligion. With what does a person become a sheep? With lust, with whims and desires (hawa). With what does one become a sheep? With alcohol, with drugs. With what does a person become a sheep? With hunger. With what do people become sheep? With food. Food.

If you make red meat 1,000 lira a kilo and chicken 300 lira a kilo, you make everyone eat chicken. And those who eat chicken become like chickens. They have no strength left to think. If you feed that society unnatural food with corrupted chemistry, you make them all sick. You keep building big hospitals. Because everyone is sick. The hospitals aren't enough. Why aren't they enough? Your food is corrupt. Why aren't they enough? Your water is corrupt. Why aren't they enough? Your air is corrupt. Why aren't they enough? Your starts in life, your standard of living, are corrupt. Why aren't they enough? Your family life is corrupt. Why aren't they enough? You are living in chaos. Why aren't they enough? You are unhappy. They aren't enough. Why do you become sheep?

You can't keep up with the money. You can't keep up with education. You can't raise your children. You can't protect the family. You get tossed about, you become unable to think. That is when the real irrationality begins. How much is this? 500 lira. Do you have the money? No. You go and buy it in installments. That's what you think about. They've come out with another new collection. So-and-so, this company, this fashion, this brand. You have to buy it. If you don't buy it, you can't sleep at night. That's how you are corrupted. You become a sheep.

31. A Response to the «One Morsel, One Cloak» Criticism

Why did they take shots at the Sufis?

"You are people of one morsel and one cloak." Oh, if only it had been one morsel and one cloak, and this state didn't have its debts.

If only it had been one morsel and one cloak, and we hadn't been corrupted. If only it had been one morsel and one cloak, and the beaches weren't filled with stark-naked people.

If only it had been one morsel and one cloak, and in five-horned hotels 1,000, 2,000 women from Russia, from Belarus, from here and there, didn't come and make prostitution a reality in this country. If only we had been one morsel and one cloak, and lack of culture weren't knee-deep among us, irreligion weren't knee-deep, faithlessness and abandoning prayer weren't knee-deep, our women weren't so exhibitionist, if only we had stayed with one morsel and one cloak. Yes, this was their concern. They succeeded. After that, what will they say?

What will the modern historian say? The modern Islamic thinker. Modern Islamist, what is your problem with these? What is it with you, brother? If it's being servants and slaves to imperialism, we've become that. We pay I don't know how many billions in interest every month. If it's being servants and slaves to imperialism, we've become that. Gambling, prostitution, interest, drugs, all of it is inside this country. What more do you want from us? They've sat down and are shaking a stick at the Islamic world by way of al-Ghazali. What did al-Ghazali do?

"Al-Ghazali rejected reason." He didn't reject it, brother. Come, let me prove it to you. What else? "He weakened critical philosophy." Al-Ghazali did not weaken critical philosophy.

32. Al-Ghazali Did Not End Thought, He Rebuilt It

Those who weakened critical philosophy in the Islamic world are the imperialists. You go and tell this nation the truth of Islam. First you'll end up in prison. So where is this weakening of critical philosophy? You'll place the Constitution and the Penal Code there like the sword of democracy. And you'll say there's no critical philosophy. What are you going to criticize? But you can criticize Islam by way of al-Ghazali. Criticize the Qur'an by way of al-Ghazali. Do whatever you like, or through person X, it doesn't matter.

Al-Ghazali did not end philosophy. Al-Ghazali laid the foundations of rethinking in the Islamic world. He laid the foundation of thinking. He laid the foundation of logic. Al-Ghazali laid it anew. It was al-Ghazali who put the logic course, logic lessons, into the Nizamiyya madrasas. Logic used to be taught in the Nizamiyya madrasas.

O brothers, in the past, the perfect murshid (murshid-i kamil) who was to sit on the post of a dergah (Sufi lodge), of a tariqa (Sufi order), had to take lessons in logic. His logic had to be strong. Yes. His kalam had to be strong, his fiqh had to be strong, his hadith had to be strong. In an Islamic madrasa, for someone to become a professor, he had to receive an ijaza (authorization) in 6 or 7 branches of knowledge. Logic is among them too. There's physics too, there's chemistry too, there's mathematics too. It's not only hadith and fiqh.

33. Rumi's Ijazas: The Critic Has Not an Atom of Knowledge

Hazrat Rumi (Mawlana Jalal al-Din Rumi), whom they take shots at and criticize, held ijazas in 8 branches of knowledge; Hazrat Rumi had them in tafsir, in hadith, in fiqh, in kalam, in 'aqa'id (creed), in mathematics, in physics, in chemistry, in astrology, and in logic as well. Shameless, ill-mannered people. Think 100,000 times before you take Hazrat Rumi's name in your mouth.

You don't have an atom of his knowledge. What exactly are you criticizing?

Whoever would criticize al-Ghazali has not an atom of knowledge before al-Ghazali, before him. Now he's sat down and read two books. He submitted a doctoral thesis through bribery. He went and toadied to the professor. He submitted his doctoral thesis. Through toadying... let me not say any more than that. My sense of propriety (adab) doesn't permit it. How those doctoral theses are granted, how people become associate professors, how they advance, well, and now he's going to stand up and criticize al-Ghazali. Is that so? Hah. He's going to stand up and criticize Hazrat Rumi. He's going to stand up and criticize Muhyiddin Ibn Arabi. Well of course, go on and criticize, of course. The field is empty anyway. May Allah forgive us. (Amin.) Yes. Nizam al-Mulk made Sunnism state policy in order to preserve the political unity of the Seljuk state.

And in this political and religious struggle, al-Ghazali wrote powerful works, especially against the Batini Ismaili movements. And these works are still standing, alive, upright like centuries-old plane trees. And a work against those works has still not been written.

With al-Ghazali, in the Islamic world, there is a firm holding fast to revelation, a firm holding fast to the noble Sunna and the hadiths, a firm holding fast to fiqh, and a renewed strengthening of Sufism in the Islamic world. That's right. Burn yourselves up. Because this is true. Those who are enemies of al-Ghazali. Yes. Because in al-Ghazali there is also knowledge of the heart. Al-Ghazali is at the level of a perfect murshid. Yes. This is al-Ghazali. You can criticize al-Ghazali. I mean, I'm saying this for the Westerners. Because they don't like it. Because they can't answer. Yes. Al-Ghazali also systematized kalam. Al-Ghazali also systematized logic. Al-Ghazali made it systematic and placed it in the madrasas. He had both the science of kalam and the science of logic placed in the madrasas. Thank goodness he did. Well of course, normally, may Allah forgive us, al-Ghazali, of course, every person can be criticized.

They criticize al-Ghazali too. A friend asked, "Could you give a bibliography?" Yes, let me give the bibliography as well. Nizam al-Mulk's Siyasatnama (Siyar al-Muluk), al-Ghazali's Fada'ih al-Batiniyya, al-Ghazali's Tahafut al-Falasifa (The Incoherence of the Philosophers) are magnificent. If you want to clear your head, open them up and read. You can read them. Just don't say afterwards, "I couldn't sleep." Tahafut al-Falasifa is tremendous. There is Mi'yar al-'Ilm (The Standard of Knowledge). And al-Munqidh min al-Dalal (Deliverance from Error). Those are normally works printed by the Ministry of Culture. I also used to have an illness, so to speak. So that illness wasn't for nothing after all. I used to go to the shelves where the books printed and published by the Ministry of Culture were sold, and buy these interesting books there. This humble one has al-Munqidh min al-Dalal, for example. That's why, you know, I have nothing to do with this cut, copy, paste business.

By the way, my eyes are a bit weak, but, you know, to prepare the talks, well, I'm not complaining. It takes a bit of time. Well, we have to read various, you know, treatises or theses too. Even if only briefly. Children, forgive me. We can't spare much time for you either, by the way. The brothers also call on the phone, and, I don't know, they do this and that. I somewhat enjoy these al-Ghazali talks myself. I see myself as if I've gone back down into such fields again. God willing, we will carry on. Now, these questions here don't have numbers 1, 2, 3. You had put them in order. We don't know which is 1, which is 2, which is 3. We've lost track of the order here. Pass this up so they can put it in order. Send it to me again; they had asked during the day, this question was in the, the talk. I said, put that in for the evening so there is unity of subject, I said.

So let us do questions and answers within the unity of the subject, God willing. Let them put a little hot water on top of this for my throat. Let it come. Thank you.

34. Q&A: Why Did the Saints Stay Away from Governing the State?

"So long as there is no religion in the true sense, the state falls into tyranny." Nizam al-Mulk. "The saints are the heirs of the prophets." Hadith. From the past until today, the great saints have stayed away from governing the state. They did not want to take up a post in the state. Since, after the prophets, it is the saints who live religion in the true sense, shouldn't the saints have come to govern the state? Why have the saints stayed in the background on this point? They have generally been at odds with authority. If we start from the end: the saints are not generally at odds with authority.

In fact, because those in authority who run the state display conduct, behaviour and governance outside the Qur'an and Sunnah, the saints do not support that administration. They do not stay within that administration. The reason for this has to do with authority departing from the Qur'an and Sunnah.

The saints do not become part of an oppressive system. A perfect murshid (spiritual guide), a saint, does not become the prop of an oppressive machine, a system outside the Qur'an and Sunnah, or a cog in its wheel. Nor is it possible for him to be. That is why the saints generally give their message through their ideas, their thoughts, and the dervishes they raise. But in general it has been like this from the Umayyads onward.

From the Umayyads onward, those saints who struggled to truly live and keep alive the Qur'an and Sunnah groaned and moaned under the tyranny of that state. Imam Abu Hanifa (Imam-i A'zam), Imam al-Shafi'i, Imam Malik, Imam Ibn Hanbal, al-Sarakhsi are typical examples of this. Muhyiddin Ibn Arabi is a typical one, Abd al-Qadir al-Jilani is a typical example. Imam al-Tirmidhi is a typical example of these. Because when the authority there is not bound to the Qur'an and Sunnah, to the Sunnah, they fall out with the saints.

In fact, it is not a matter of the saints fighting with authority. Nor is it a matter of them being at odds with it.

35. Q&A: The Kut Tradition, the Election of the Caliph, and the Claim "There Was Consensus"

But when authority is outside the Qur'an and Sunnah, then it is authority that parts ways with the path of the saints. That, in my view, is the reason, as with the prophets.

"To govern the state and its crises, legitimacy must lie at the foundation of the state." "Therefore rulership is not an ordinary thing." "It is chosen by a divine power." Nizam al-Mulk. After the passing of the Prophet (peace be upon him), the head of state was determined by election, by securing consensus and unity. We know that the kut tradition (the notion of divinely granted fortune to rule) prevailed in the ancient Turkic states. What is the perspective of the Islamic understanding of the state on the kut tradition? Now, it is said that this happened by election. When it is said it happened by election, you assume that today's elections and the election of Hazrat

Abu Bakr, Umar, Uthman, Ali and Hazrat Hasan are the same thing. The election of Hazrat Abu Bakr was by al-'Ashara al-Mubashshara. That is, the Companions who were given the glad tidings of Paradise. So then, if a new ijtihad is to be derived from this, the election, for example, ought to be carried out by a group of scholars in a country. As an example. Which scholars will do this? For instance, the election of Hazrat Abu Bakr, Umar, Uthman and Ali was not by the consensus of all Muslims, you see. Those promised Paradise are the ten, al-'Ashara al-Mubashshara. Hazrat Abu Bakr passes away.

See al-'Ashara al-Mubashshara as something like an electoral board. After that, they elect Hazrat Umar. Then they elect Uthman. Then four of them remain. And of those four, three of the four, together with Hazrat Ali himself, elect Hazrat Ali. Two are on Mu'awiya's side. Well, then they too pass away. When they too pass away, those who remain elect Hazrat Hasan. Our master Hasan's rule lasts 6 months. After 6 months, Hazrat Hasan renounces it so that the state is not divided and the blood of brothers is not shed.

He is elected out of the headship of state in favour of Mu'awiya. He withdraws from the headship of state. Mu'awiya's becoming head of state is not by election. Then Mu'awiya leaves the headship of state to his own son, in his own lifetime. The people of Kufa write a letter to Hazrat Husayn. Saying, "We want to pledge allegiance to you." The people of Kufa write to him to pledge allegiance. Then the Kufans give it up on the way, because of pressure. And Hazrat Husayn is martyred. Now, in the Turkic tradition there is kut.

Kut means that for a person to be able to become head of state, that person's father must also be a bey. An ordinary marauder cannot become a bey. He comes as son of a bey, son of a bey, son of a bey, son of a bey, son of a bey. Because when they speak, they say, for example, "My forefather Tughril." The Turkic tradition is like this too. The son of a bey becomes a bey. How is this reconciled with Islam? In Islam, its reconciliation comes from Hazrat Ali.

Hazrat Ali, and then afterwards Hazrat Hasan, comes to the head of the state. The Turks say that this is the proof. That is why in the Turkic tradition only the son of a bey succeeds to the beylik. There is also a fatwa of Imam Abu Hanifa. Can one also become a bey by the sword? Yes. That is why, after the passing of the Prophet (peace be upon him), there was no complete consensus among the Companions.

For instance, Hazrat Abu Bakr was elected, but some of the Companions, some said it was Hazrat Ali's right. There were those who said the caliphate was his. Because of this gossip, Hazrat Ali did not leave his house for 6 months. He did not pledge allegiance to Hazrat Abu Bakr. For 6 months he did not pledge allegiance. When did things calm down? After things calmed down, he went and pledged allegiance to Hazrat Abu Bakr. That is why, from the standpoint of historical knowledge, it is incomplete for us to say that among the Companions there was complete consensus regarding Hazrat Abu Bakr's caliphate. Because, for example, the Ansar, that is, the people of Medina, also had their own candidate for head of state. It was dropped only when the hadith "The head of state is from Quraysh" was cited. That is, the Ansar too were putting forward a candidate for head of state. But, well, there is consensus. You know, the brother who wrote this may have thought there was consensus on this point. There was no consensus. That is, in the Islamic world such consensus in the full sense is not sought.

36. "Consensus Is Not Sought": Thinking Differently Brings the Truth to Light

Let me add a note on this too. For example, in no group, in no faction is consensus sought. Because thinking differently brings the truth to light. For example, I never look at Sufism from that angle.

I do not seek consensus on a matter. The reason I do not seek consensus in our community either: then they would not have acquired the capacity for different thought. I would see them as not having acquired the capacity for free thought. Certainly, specific duties are divided up and given among specific people, but there is no rule that they will all be in consensus. Adnan thinks differently, Hüseyin thinks differently, Cafer thinks differently, Ertan thinks differently. Muhammed Hasan thinks differently.

He thinks. All of those with duties can think differently, each in their own way. The dervish brothers too, differently. I see that as richness. I do not see it as division. Erdoğan thinks differently, the doctor thinks differently, Ali thinks differently. Now, all the friends, old or new, it does not matter. My system of administration is based on consultation. I listen to everyone. If there is a matter, I do not seek consensus. In fact, seeking consensus is rejecting and burying people's own individual ideas and thoughts. That cannot be.

In a family, too, consensus is not sought. A family consists of mother, father and children. When the children grow up, you cannot seek consensus there. The reason is that each child's mind, ideas and thinking are not the same, after all. Their outlook on life is not the same, after all. You, as father, as mother: "I will dress him in one garment. They will all wear the same garment." You cannot do such a thing. That consensus is not sought. I beg your pardon. I do not seek consensus here. Let the university graduates raise their hands. Raise them. your hands. Women and men, take a look around you. Look up and down. Yes. Put your hands down. Now, so many people have studied at university. All of them studied in different fields. As for the great majority here who did not study at university, it is not "No, we didn't study." Don't belittle yourselves like that. There are tradesmen here who have specialized in their own work.

There are people who have specialized in their work, specialized in their business both within the city and between cities. There are friends here, there are craftsmen here.

37. Keeping Them Under One Roof Is a Miracle (Karama)

The man has been kneaded in that craft for years, kneaded in trade, stood on his own feet, done business. There are people from Demirtaş here. All of them are in the Grand Bazaar. A tradesman in the Grand Bazaar means years of labor. They were all still so young. Right? How many years have you been in the bazaar? 25 years. Aren't you in the bazaar, İsmail? You were in the bazaar before. How many years? You stayed 25 years. Where are the other people from Demirtaş? Where? Let my eyes see, let me look. Raise a hand. People from Demirtaş, look, Abdurrahman, how many years have you been in the bazaar? How many? 42 years. Still there. Is it easy to be a tradesman in the Grand Bazaar? Don't regard him as someone whose head doesn't work. The man has ideas, he has thoughts.

How many years have you been in clothing? It's been 22 years. The man was a manager at Vakko. Would Vakko give a managerial post to a man whose head doesn't work? That's not how it is, I mean. "Consensus will come out of here." It won't, my brother. Everyone has ideas. Everyone has thoughts. Everyone has experience. Erdoğan, how many years have you been a tradesman? 35 years. Master Lütfü, how many years? 45 years. Cevdet, how many years? 35 years. Where would you get off saying this man has no ideas?

Now what matters is being able to keep them all under one roof. And that is a miracle (karama). Abdullah, how many years did you study? A man who studied for 23 years. Keeping such a man under one roof is what matters. Consensus does not matter. That is why in the Islamic world consensus is not sought. Consensus is in the Qur'an, in the Sunna, in fiqh. The Islamic world holds every color within it. Sufi communities above all are multicolored. I sometimes say, you know, and I don't say this as ecstatic utterance (shath):

Let your most famous sheikh come and act as sheikh here. Whoever he may be. Let's see who turns out to be the sheep and who the shepherd. May Allah forgive us. (Amin.) Yes. According to Nizam al-Mulk's understanding, the state strengthens the economy by establishing justice. Do you believe that the shaken sense of justice of present-day humanity will be revived by being supported with economic models? No. Will the world's humanity be able to make the Islamic socioeconomic model dominant in the world through revolution?

38. Q&A: Is the Sense of Justice Revived by Economic Models?

No. That is, because you cannot restore the shaken sense of justice of present-day humanity by reviving the economy.

First you need to set the mechanism of justice in order, so that only then will the economy recover. If the mechanism of justice is not set in order, then the economy will not revive. That is, you need to establish justice in Turkey or justice in the world.

The mechanism of justice needs to work properly. Judges and prosecutors need to decide with free consciences. Then you would need to change the constitution and criminal law completely. And they will not let you change the constitution and criminal law. That being so, you cannot make the mechanism of justice work properly. You cannot establish justice by passing laws.

Pass as many laws as you like. You cannot establish justice. for justice, virtue is needed, discernment (firasa) is needed, perfection (kamalat) is needed. For justice, those people, the people within that mechanism of justice, need to be free. If a political member of parliament goes and influences the judge, no justice comes out of that. If you give person A this punishment and person B that punishment, no justice comes out of that. If the rich have a separate justice, the select few have a separate justice, and the people's justice is separate, no justice comes out there. That is why, as for a fully just system being able to form, being able to be formed in the world, well, I'm not saying I don't believe it.

This means the collapse of the capitalist-imperialist system of the entire world order. First, the servants of the capitalist-imperialist system within your own ranks will rise up. You cannot do it.

39. "Will the Islamic Model Prevail Through Revolution?" — Reading Reality

Will the world's humanity be able to make the Islamic socioeconomic model dominant in the world through revolution? No, this is not a case of despair.

This is a case of reading reality. I am reading reality. Today the world's humanity is in a state of enslavement. It does not have the courage to dare to free itself from that slavery. Muslims are leading the way in this. Muslims are leading the way. The Islamic world cannot free itself from that system of slavery.

Let me give an example. The infidel bombs whatever place he wants whenever he wants. Do you make a sound? No. What happened? Is Gaza over? It's over. Those who died stayed dead. What was destroyed was destroyed. What happened with the Gaza issue, come on? What happened? Where is the Iraq, Syria issue? Where is the Lebanon issue? Where is the Bangladesh issue? Where is Afghanistan? Bosnia. What happened? It's over. Come on, let's march again this Sunday, where to? From Heykel to Zafer Plaza. What happened?

You cannot bring about that revival. You cannot do it. You cannot give up the food in your cupboards, the clothes in your wardrobes. The wird you know, I mean, friends, brothers, how long do the daily wirds take?

40. Self-Criticism: Will Someone Who Cannot Recite a Half-Hour Wird Save the World?

It takes half an hour, it takes 45 minutes. Come on, the Islamic world cannot recite even this. The Sufis, the dervish brothers do not recite this daily. Come on, what do you want from someone who cannot discipline himself in this? Are you expecting him to save the world?

Are you expecting a Muslim who does not pray the five daily obligatory prayers to save the world? You cannot bring yourselves to tell your own son, your own daughter, "Pray." You cannot tell your spouses. Come on, tell your children, you cannot tell them. Are we going to save the world?

I am stating the reality. I have nothing to say against anyone's dervishhood, come on. Is a dervish who is far from reciting his lesson going to save the world? Let him first save his own nafs. Let him first sit down and recite his lesson. Let him, after the morning prayer, pray the morning prayer on time. Let him firmly establish his attachment like this. Let him say, "I am a fully attached dervish. I have made this a discipline. I do not step outside his word," let him say. Fine, let him not step outside it. We, I mean, within the Islamic world, in this country, are one of the communities that are disciplined in our own way. Look, when we really look, I say we are disciplined.

But even we cannot achieve that discipline from ourselves in prayer, in dhikr, in any activity. We cannot stand united like this. Come on, for days I have been saying this, not out of weariness from talking about it, for days I have been saying this: Do not fall out with one another. Do not criticise one another. Stand united with one another. Be together with one another. Do you know what this means, friends? You criticise one another mercilessly. You do not listen to your parents. You criticise your parents mercilessly. Your spouses mercilessly. Women and men, you criticise mercilessly. You make remarks. You do not listen to the master. Whom will you listen to?

In my dervishhood I do not know what it is not to listen to the sheikh. I will speak openly. Truly, I mean, may this not sound a bit like praising myself regarding Sheikh Efendi. I believe that Sheikh Efendi, in that murid–murshid relationship we had, truly exercised his sheikhhood over me very beautifully. And I feel great happiness at this. Look, I feel a very great happiness. He says, I said, I mean, he exercised his sheikhhood over me. Without hesitation, never a question mark in his head, "He won't do this." He never thought, "Will Mustafa Efendi do it?" Praise be to God.

We are a small example of the Islamic world. That is why we cannot do what is before our eyes, what is at our fingertips. We cannot do what is within our power, so how would we do the rest? You will say, "Come on, are we really that bad?" No. But don't we also need to criticise ourselves? Yes. I believe that under these conditions it is very difficult for the Islamic world to rise to its feet.

Because it has grown used to comfort. I beg your pardon, but it has grown used to luxury. It has fallen into indolence. It has fallen into ostentation. It has fallen into extravagance. "Isn't this our right too?" It is not. Pardon me very much, it has fallen into shamelessness. The Islamic world has become shameless. Looking at this, I say, come on, who will leave his comfortable bed, someone who does not get up on time for the morning prayer, who does not leave his comfortable bed? What would he give up, come on? "Let's not set aside half an hour a day for the wird." Half an hour, I mean half an hour, come on, the daily wird is half an hour. Someone who does not set aside time for that, what would he set aside? And there is also something like this among dervishes now. He does not recite a half-hour wird, but he will close his eyes all the time and see spiritual states. The man does not get up for the morning prayer. "If I made a mistake, they would correct me. I would see it in my dream," he says. Hey man, what are you going to see in your dream? You don't get up for the morning prayer. You're snoring away like me. What are you going to see? Well, look at the Islamic world.

We are a Muslim country, aren't we? I cannot walk in the street. I cannot go out to the marketplace. If I have to go somewhere twenty steps away, I say, "Hasan, come, son, we're going over there." Childlike, he will think, "Has my father lost his mind?" I cannot walk, friends. I literally cannot go out to the marketplace. I cannot stand in front of the door. That is why I said, those who work in the marketplace, is it easy to work in that marketplace? We are the Islamic world. Yes. These are bitter, bitter things. Bitter. If I go somewhere, I go out of necessity. Not as if I did it constantly reciting tawhid, reciting and reciting dhikr. I say, "O Lord, put me behind a separate veil." Because I am conscious of that. May Allah forgive us. (Amin.) This is not despair. This is a reality. I am speaking about reality. Forgive me any rights I owe you. May it be halal.

Note: This text is the speech itself as found in the recording of the sohbet: only the spelling and punctuation have been edited, and obvious mishearings in the subtitles have been corrected; a few unintelligible passages have been left as heard. Section headings have been added for ease of reading. The opening and closing prayers have not been included.


Bibliography

During the sohbet one of our brothers asked for a bibliography; the works mentioned and the other sources referred to in the talk are gathered below.

Nizam al-Mulk, Siyasatnama (Siyar al-Muluk) — The fundamental work written by the Seljuk vizier on statecraft, justice, merit and legitimacy; the starting point of the quoted paragraphs in the talk.

Imam al-Ghazali, Fada'ih al-Batiniyya (The Infamies of the Batinis) — Al-Ghazali's refutation written against the Ismaili-Batini movement; a critique of the doctrine of the infallible imam and of the interpretation (ta'wil) that nullifies the outward (zahir) meaning of the Qur'an.

Imam al-Ghazali, Tahafut al-Falasifa (The Incoherence of the Philosophers) — A response to the views of al-Farabi and Ibn Sina (Avicenna) on the eternity of the world, Allah's not knowing particulars, and the denial of bodily resurrection. It was mentioned in the talk as "magnificent."

Imam al-Ghazali, Mi'yar al-'Ilm (The Standard of Knowledge) — Al-Ghazali's work on the science of logic; mentioned as one of the foundations of the thesis "there is no refutation of reason, there is a limit."

Imam al-Ghazali, al-Munqidh min al-Dalal (Deliverance from Error) — The autobiographical treatise in which al-Ghazali recounts his intellectual journey; an account of the path from doubt to certainty and of his transition to Sufism.

Imam al-Ghazali, Ihya' 'Ulum al-Din (The Revival of the Religious Sciences) — His main work, written after leaving state office; mentioned in the talk as "his only work read in this country."

Muhammad Abid al-Jabiri — Moroccan philosopher; representative of the line that attributes the backwardness of the Islamic world to its "mode of thinking" and its centring on transmitted knowledge (naql), and that criticises al-Ghazali for causing philosophy to regress.

Mohammed Arkoun — Academic of Algerian origin who worked in the field of anthropology at the Sorbonne; mentioned as the intellectual father of historicism, which views the Qur'an, hadith, fiqh and kalam through a historical filter.

Hassan Hanafi — Professor at Cairo University; mentioned as the representative of an approach along Marxist-Leninist lines that attempts to synthesise Marxism and Islam.

Fazlur Rahman — Academic of Pakistani origin who worked at the University of Chicago; a populariser of historicism with the approach that "one looks at the purpose of a Qur'anic ruling in the society in which it was revealed."

Machiavelli, The Prince (Il Principe) — The work compared with the Siyasatnama in the 5th talk of the series; in this talk it stands as the background to the discussion of legitimacy.

The Noble Qur'an, al-Ahzab 33/40 — [Qur'an, al-Ahzab 33:40 — verse text pending: Diyanet English translation] — the subject of the finality of prophethood and the baselessness of the doctrine of the infallible imam.

Hadith — "The saints are the heirs of the prophets" — The narration mentioned in the text of the question; concerning scholars and saints being the heirs of the prophets (Abu Dawud, 'Ilm 1; Tirmidhi, 'Ilm 19).

Hadith — "The imams/heads of state are from Quraysh" — The narration that brought to a close the discussion of the Ansar's candidacy at the Saqifa (Bukhari, Manaqib 2; Ahmad ibn Hanbal, Musnad).

Imam al-A'zam Abu Hanifa — fatwa on the imamate and the oath of allegiance (bay'a) — The assessment in Hanafi fiqh concerning the question "Can one also become a ruler by the sword?"; the discussion of reconciling the Turkic tradition of kut (divinely granted charisma to rule) with Islamic legitimacy.

Mustafa Özbağ Efendi, "Batiniyya, Reason and Modern Islam | Questions on al-Ghazali 6" — mustafaozbag.com — Full text of the talk dated 25.07.2026.

Click here for more information about Imam al-Ghazali.

Additional sources:

  • Imam al-Ghazali, Fada'ih al-Batiniyya; critique of Batini esoteric interpretation (ta'wil) and of their doctrine of the imamate.
  • Imam al-Ghazali, Tahafut al-Falasifa (The Incoherence of the Philosophers); the debates on the eternity of the world, God's knowledge of particulars and bodily resurrection.
  • Imam al-Ghazali, Mi'yar al-'Ilm (The Standard of Knowledge) and Mihakk al-Nazar; his works on the science of logic.
  • Imam al-Ghazali, al-Munqidh min al-Dalal (Deliverance from Error); doubt, certainty (yaqin) and the turn to Sufism.
  • Nizam al-Mulk, Siyasatnama (Siyar al-Muluk); discussions of justice, merit and the survival of the state.
  • The Noble Qur'an, al-Ahzab 33/40; his being the Seal of the Prophets.
  • The Noble Qur'an, al-Baqara 2/269; the granting of wisdom together with the Book.
  • Abu Dawud, 'Ilm 1; Tirmidhi, 'Ilm 19; scholars being the heirs of the prophets.
  • Bukhari, Manaqib 2; the narration concerning the imamate being from Quraysh.
  • Ibn Khaldun, Muqaddima; analyses of group solidarity ('asabiyya), the state and legitimacy.
  • al-Shahrastani, al-Milal wa al-Nihal; presentation of the Isma'iliyya and Batiniyya sects.