1. The Framework of the Topic: Nizam al-Mulk or Machiavelli?
As you know, there was a period of i'tikaf. So, God willing, we will continue with al-Ghazali from where we left off. Nizam al-Mulk bases the source of political power on a divine power, on Allah and on religion, in parentheses, on Islam.
Machiavelli, on the other hand, points to worldly and secular justifications. Nizam al-Mulk, who states that Allah, in every age, grants the authority to govern to certain individuals He chooses from among the people, offers a strong theological foundation for political power by stating that obeying the sultan means, in a sense, submitting to Allah. Machiavelli, in his book The Prince, opposes this.
And he looks for the source of power in social dynamics. Let me not scatter the topic. Nizam al-Mulk forms the curriculum of the Nizamiyya madrasas with an understanding opposed to the Batiniyya, the Ismailis and Shi'ism. Al-Ghazali's work titled The Inner Face of Batinism, in which he declared Batinism and Shi'ism to be outside Islam, is famous. That is this evening's topic paragraph. Of course, this text compares two different views in the world. In general terms it looks at these matters from the perspective of historical concepts. Nizam al-Mulk's understanding of politics is correct. I mean, what is explained here is this, because in his Siyasatnama (Siyar al-Muluk) Nizam al-Mulk argues that rulership is given by the decree of Allah. According to him, a just ruler is like the shadow of Allah on earth. That is how it is regarded. Because there is also a hadith on which this is based. That is why they judge that a ruler who conforms to the Qur'an and the Sunna is the shadow of Allah.
Because, for example, after the Seljuks, the Ottoman sultans too were given the title of the shadow of Allah on earth. It was attached to them as a title like that. This is called Zillullah. That is, he is the shadow of Allah on earth.
2. "The Shadow of Allah on Earth": Zillullah and the Double Standard
Look, while saying this, the counterpart of it, normally now, this is Allah's zillullah on earth, but in the Christian world the pope sits in the station of Jesus.
He claims authority to change the Gospel. He can change the Gospel. And normally the rulers blessed by the Pope, those there as well, they too are the equivalent of this. That is, when we compare these with their own contemporaries, then what the matter really is comes out. For example, now some people say all sorts of things in order to oppose the Ottomans, but in return they would not say a word, for example, against the British royal family.
Monarchies still continue in Europe. Nobody says anything to them. In Europe, too, they say nothing. There is a monarchy in Belgium. There is a monarchy in Switzerland. Then there is a monarchy in Spain. There is a monarchy in the Netherlands. There is a monarchy in Norway. They never say a word against these. But in Turkey, disparaging the Ottomans, disparaging the sultans, and when we go further back, disparaging the Seljuks, disparaging the Seljuk sultans, this is something different. I mean, a perception is created as if, by disparaging the Ottomans, the Republic will rise up to the heavens.
3. The Limit of Obedience Is the Qur'an and the Sunna
That is why, normally, yes, in this understanding, obedience to the sultan is regarded as a religious obligation as long as it is legitimate.
Correct. Because in Islam, normally, [Qur'an, an-Nisa 4:59 — verse text pending: Diyanet English translation] This is normally established by the verse, but "those in authority among you." Because obedience with us is bound to the Qur'an and the Sunna. A child's obedience to his mother and father is limited by the Qur'an and the Sunna. A woman's obedience to her husband is limited by the Qur'an and the Sunna. We say these things like this, but these forms of obedience no longer remain.
Neither the obedience of children to their fathers remains, nor the obedience of women to their husbands. I mean, this is normally one of the most important elements of the corruption in society right now. This obedience has been abolished. It does not exist right now. I mean, these dervishes may say that it exists among themselves. We are a small community. It no longer remains like that. For example, a child now does not ask his mother and father for permission for everything. A woman does not ask her husband for permission. She says, "I am going there." That's it, that's all. If she even says "I am going," that's good. She doesn't even let him know. She goes off somewhere. Plainly, she doesn't even let him know. Right now the concept of family that the Qur'an and the Sunna command no longer remains. These are bitter things, I mean. Because if you look at the noble Sunna, the concept of family has collapsed in the Islamic world. This was the West's aim anyway. Because what keeps a country standing, I mean, what keeps a state, a nation standing, is the family.
If the family has been torn apart, that country is doomed to sink. It is also doomed to occupation. Because if belonging to the family no longer remains, belonging to the land does not remain either, belonging to the state does not remain either; it collapses. Think of a body.
4. The Virus That Enters the State and the Family: Fitna
If you think of the state and the nation as one body, the state and the nation are normally in the form of one body. How does an infection enter the body there? One cell becomes sick. If the whole body becomes sick, the same thing applies to the state and the nation. A disease spreads there. When the disease spreads, everything falls into ruin. The same thing. Let a virus enter the family, and the family falls apart. Or let a virus enter here, into the community, and the community will fall apart. What is the virus? Fitna (discord, civil strife). What is the virus? Something outside the Qur'an and the Sunna. It is the same in families. It is the same in the state. The state becomes sick.
With what does the state become sick? It becomes sick with bribery. It becomes sick with unqualified people. With what does the state become sick? With discrimination. It becomes sick with favouritism. With what does the state become sick? It becomes sick with interest. With what does it become sick? It becomes sick with excessive taxes. With what does it become sick? It becomes sick by oppressing its subjects. The state too becomes sick. How does a family become sick? The man, the father, oppresses his wife and children. He does not let his wife and children live within the bounds of the Qur'an and the Sunna. It becomes sick. The family, the family becomes sick. How? The mother is not within the bounds of the Qur'an and the Sunna. It becomes sick. What? Disease has entered. You know how they say the fish rots from the head. The fish rots from the head. I mean, imagine a woman who does not obey her husband. Imagine a man who oppresses his wife. A sick family is troubled.
5. "Obedience Is Only in What Is Right (Ma'ruf)": The Hanafi Stance
Now Nizam al-Mulk also puts obedience at the top.
This is the command of Islam.
6. Nizam al-Mulk's Four Foundations and the Meaning of Merit
[Qur'an, an-Nisa 4:59 — verse text pending: Diyanet English translation] "Those in authority from among you." The Hanafis have, in principle, structured this. What does "from among you" mean? He must have believed in the Qur'an and the Sunna. He must be a Muslim. Two, he must live his religion. Three, he must be just. If he is not just, he is not from among us. That is why Imam Abu Hanifa (Imam-i A'zam) issued a fatwa for the overthrow of the Umayyads. Because the Umayyads were not just. And the one who issued the fatwa for the overthrow of the Umayyads was Imam Abu Hanifa. Don't go by the fact that you say "we are Hanafi." Hanafism is not some easygoing, carefree school of law. According to the Hanafis, in principle, if a head of state is oppressing, he is not to be obeyed. His overthrow is rightful. He himself struggled with his wealth, he waged jihad. That being so, if a ruler is to be obeyed, he is obliged to act in accordance with Islamic law, with the sharia.
A ruler, I mean a ruler, cannot make interest permissible, cannot make fornication permissible or leave it free, cannot leave alcohol free. An Islamic ruler cannot leave free in his own land the things the Almighty has forbidden. If he leaves them free, he is not an Islamic ruler. Obeying him is not obligatory. And speaking about these things openly like this is not something just anyone can do. Well now, that being so, I mean, if he is in accordance with Islamic law, that ruler is obeyed. If he rejects Islamic law, if he does not apply it, that ruler is not obeyed. Whether this is the imam of the mosque, or a party leader in politics, or someone called a sheikh, it does not matter at all. Whether it is your mother, or your father, or your husband, if they ask of you something outside the Qur'an and the Sunna, there is no obedience to them. Because there is a hadith that says obedience is only in what is right (ma'ruf). The Hanafis have particularly taken this up. Obedience is in what is right.
That is, in what is good. One obeys in what is good. If a father says to his son, "You will go and drink alcohol." He is not obeyed. If a husband says to his wife, "You will drink alcohol. You will not pray. You will not fast. You will not go to dhikr. You will not do the remembrance of Allah (dhikrullah)." Where did you get that from? He is not obeyed. In fact, a husband who forbids an obligatory act leaves the religion. He needs renewal of faith (tajdid al-iman) and renewal of marriage (tajdid al-nikah). And if a woman nags her husband about his fulfilling his obligatory acts, keeps going on and on, eats away at his head like that, the woman leaves the religion. May Allah protect us. This time she needs renewal of faith. May my Lord protect us. Nizam al-Mulk's understanding of politics was shaped on the basis of justice, merit, absolute centralism, and the unity of religion and state.
Justice first, look, justice, merit. Justice, then merit. What is merit? Are you competent for that job or not? Merit. Now if we said to Master Lütfü, "Master Lütfü, would you take me on as a painter, as a master?" He wouldn't. The reason: I am not a master at that. I do not have merit in that field. Right, Master Lütfü? Look, he can't say anything now. He can't even tell me "I can't take you." Master Lütfü's face turned red. Now he needs merit. Why? He doesn't know that job. Someone who doesn't know that job will come and act as a master there. He'll wreck things, he'll make the master suffer losses there. While saying "I'll fix the headlight," he won't know how to remove the headlight. He'll break the headlight. There's no merit. Because he's not a master. He can only come up through apprenticeship.
What sinks states is lack of merit. The first is injustice. If there is no justice, that state sinks, that nation sinks, that family sinks. What is lack of merit? He is not qualified for that job. Now, for example, I'm giving an example. What is that person? Say, an electrical-electronics engineer. Fine. Where are we going to make him a minister? Oh, let him head a ministry too. Let him come and be health minister, why not. He doesn't know how to measure blood pressure. How on earth are you going to make him health minister? Lack of merit; or else go and put at the head of the Ministry of National Defence someone who has nothing at all to do with national defence, nothing at all to do with the military, without merit. Why, man? That person has no business with soldiering. He doesn't know the military profession. He has nothing to do with the military. This is merit. I mean, whom are we going to make mayor? I'm just giving an example. Mayor: what does that city need? It needs infrastructure. What does it need? That city needs superstructure.
What does it need? It needs things related to construction. Whom did we make mayor? An agricultural engineer. Good God, what is this man going to do? Is he going to plant fields and such? Sow crops, or what? A veterinarian. Man, what business does a veterinarian have in the mayor's office? But he's from our party, you see. We'll elect him again anyway. He's from our party. Is that merit? It is not merit. Or else what are we going to do? For example, we're going to choose a provincial chairman. Whom are we going to choose? You won't be choosing. Someone will be appointed. We appointed: make so-and-so provincial chairman. Fine. Has this man combed Bursa inch by inch? Does he know its streets? Does he know its avenues? I'm going to make this man provincial chairman. Is he among the people? Does he know who is hungry and who is full? No. Then what does he know? He got appointed. That's it. Without merit. The tariqas are the same. You appointed someone as zakir (leader of the dhikr). Fine, you appointed him, but does he have merit? Will he be able to serve as zakir?
Will he be able to manage? 10 people, 20 people, 50 people, 100 people, 200 people; or someone appointed a chavush (assistant) somewhere. Allah has appointed him. I ask, "Hajji brother, did you see this person in your dream or something?" "What's it to you, man?" he says to me. "Hajji brother, about the dream: I made rabita (spiritual connection) during the dhikrullah," I say. I'm saying it openly. "I didn't see his being chavush," I say. "What's it to you, I'm saying?" he said to me. Good God, I said. Now at the next dhikrullah I make rabita. I consult, I ask, I inquire.
7. Merit in the Tariqa Too: The Story of the "Spinach Chavush"
I don't see the man as chavush. This matter takes place in Ödemiş, by the way.
I said, I prayed. "O my Lord," I said, "show me the truth of this matter." Now you don't know this kind of dervishhood. This is a dervishhood you don't know. Every morning I change the coal bucket of his stove. I go in the morning, I empty what is left from the evening. The ashes; I fill the new bucket, I light it, I leave it in the bucket. In the evening I come again. I change it once more. I have a set time. That day I was late. I was a bit late. I came to change the bucket. I looked, and the man had a bag of spinach and leeks in his hand, like this. "What are these?" I said, and he went, stammering, um, um. "I brought them for Hajji brother. I brought them for Hajji Baba," he said. It came to my heart. Ah, I said, he became chavush from these leeks and spinach he brings, I said. I named him the spinach chavush. That expression of mine, "spinach chavush," comes from there. Spinach chavush. Why? Spiritually, it had not been seen in a dream, it had not been seen in a spiritual state (hal).
Will it be of any use? No. And it was of no use at all. He just kept on carrying spinach anyway. Unworthy, look, unworthy. This happens in dergahs too. Lack of merit is a great problem.
8. Merit in the Family: Being Fit for Marriage and the Place of Anger
For example, we look at our son. When it comes to marriage, can he manage a household or can he not?
He cannot. Then, as mother and father, do not marry him off. Why? He is not fit for that marriage. Because he will not be able to keep that marriage going. The same applies to a daughter. You look, and whether you walk in front of the girl it's one trouble, whether you walk behind her it's another. Her tongue is as big as a shoe. Just say "How are you?" and she'll strike you down. Or the man is the same way. What? "Our son is very hot-tempered." Your son has followed Satan. "Our daughter is not very hot-tempered." She has followed Satan. How? Plainly and simply, anger is from Satan. Within the bounds of the Qur'an and Sunna, show your anger to the unbeliever. Show your anger to something outside the bounds of the Qur'an and Sunna. You don't show it to that. To whom? You show it to your mother and father. You show it to your spouse. You show it to your children. You show it to the women and men around you. You're the big one, aren't you. You crush everyone around you.
May Allah protect us. Lack of merit, then: normally, at this point, if there is no merit, there is trouble. And one of the most important characteristics of Nizam al-Mulk is absolute centralism. Nizam al-Mulk is a statist man. He makes the state strong; he is a centralist. He is not federalist like America. He is a centralist. Everyone is tied to the center. Going further, Nizam al-Mulk, for example, does not want certain family groups like this to form in the periphery. And he shapes things on the basis of the unity of religion and state. Nizam al-Mulk's conception of the state, that is, religion and state are, in a way, intertwined in Nizam al-Mulk. Because this is such a thing that the survival of the state is connected to the rulers' morality remaining firmly bound to divine norms. That is, the survival of the state is possible through the rulers remaining firmly bound to Islamic morality and law. This is one of the causes of the collapse of the Ottomans.
It is connected to the rulers, that is, the pashas or the lalas (tutors of the princes), the ministers, not remaining firmly bound to divine norms. They too started taking bribes, they too started favoritism. Thus that is also one of the items among the causes of the collapse of the Ottoman State. And if their morals are not upright in that religious respect, then deviation will begin in that person, in the authority of the state. And normally, at this point, a definite authority and a definite discipline are necessary in the bureaucracy; according to Nizam al-Mulk, if that authority is absent within the bureaucracy and if divine order does not prevail in that bureaucracy, that is the cause of the state's downfall. And Nizam al-Mulk's understanding of politics at this point is not merely a theory of governing a state either. If we perceive it that way, then, in Mustafa Özbağ's view, we will have made a mistake. Because in Nizam al-Mulk two traditions, two cultures, two conceptions of the state have been blended, so to speak. How have they been blended?
9. Centralism and the Synthesis of Two State Traditions
There is one state tradition in the region.
It belongs to Iran. There is a second state tradition. It has to do with the Seljuks. Nizam al-Mulk synthesizes the Iranian state tradition and the Seljuk state tradition. He does not set them against each other. He takes for himself what is needed. Never characterize Nizam al-Mulk in some different way like that. For his day, he identified the dangers both within the state and within the people, and at the same time he also identified the Christian or various other powers threatening the state from outside. Because on one side there are the Fatimids in Egypt. And in Anatolia, as is well known, there is Byzantium. The state is under threat. The Batiniyya within the borders of the state. Batini, God forbid, the Batinis. A branch of the Ismailis is threatening the state from within as well. For example, to give an illustration, Menteş, the brother of His Holiness Hajji Bektash Wali, rises up against the Seljuks.
When Menteş rises up in the Sivas region, he falls into the category of baghi (rebel). When he falls into the category of baghi, the Seljuks are forced to fight them. And when the Seljuks fight them, according to some historians they even get help from Byzantium, and with help from Byzantium they slaughter Menteş and those around him, those around him. After that, Hajji Bektash Wali goes to the village where he is now located. It wasn't even a village then. It later became a village. He goes there, to a hamlet, and settles. He never makes a sound. What is the reason? What is the reason for that? It is because of Menteş. And until he dies, Hajji Bektash Wali never, ever gets involved in politics. He does not come into confrontation with the Seljuks. Now when it is like this, normally these experiences, that is, the state also has troubles from within. Because the state doesn't only have troubles from outside. Every state, give or take, has troubles from within and from outside. That is, troubles from within are one thing, troubles from outside are another.
10. "Who Is the Internal Enemy?": Law, Democracy and Legitimacy
For example, you know how the State of the Republic of Turkey sometimes has news or statements like this, in a block, where they say "internal and external enemies."
Fine, we understand the external enemy. Who is the internal enemy? That is, normally the people don't know who the internal enemy is. The rulers know who the internal enemy is. We can't know that. For example, previously, I mean, the Muslims in Turkey were the internal enemy. "These people are against secularism," they used to say. They were characterized as the internal enemy. February 28 was the result of this. I mean, what was it? Muslims were the internal enemy. They had to be fought against. February 28 was a coup. The internal enemy became the Welfare Party (Refah Partisi). Example: from time to time, you know, at security meetings they talk about the "red book" and so on, which we hear about in the news. That changes over time, you know. The real thing there is this. What is it? That is the measure. Whom does the state see as the internal enemy. Here, in countries like ours, law and justice, articles, these are empty things.
If the state has characterized him as an internal enemy, it abolishes him. It rolls over him like a steamroller. Law articles, justice, constitution, penal code, so they say. All of those are empty words. Why do I say empty words? I'll give an example. While the court case for the closure of the Welfare Party was ongoing, the Constitutional Court annulled an article and punished the Welfare Party. It annulled an article. I never forget it, though I don't remember that article right now. I mean, in order to punish, that article of the constitution had to be annulled. While that article stands there, they cannot punish. I mean, the ordinary courts cannot punish it. Because the article stands there. What? Very simple. That Constitutional Court convenes and makes a decision. "I have annulled such-and-such article," it says. Once it is annulled, you get the punishment. You can't even object to it. Democracy, shmemocracy, so they say. All of these are empty words too. We study it in middle school, in high school. What was it supposed to be?
What was democracy supposed to be? It was supposed to be the people governing themselves, after that. Come on, brother, give me a break. Fine, you can make them believe this in middle school, you can partly make them believe it in high school. At university you can't make them believe it. And once they grow up a bit more, especially once they reach 65 like me, you can't make them believe it at all. Why, really? What does it have to do with anything? It was supposed to be the people governing themselves. You appoint the provincial chairman, you appoint the mayor, you appoint the national assembly, you appoint the members of parliament too. All the parties included. And what do you do with the ones they appoint? You stamp the ballot for the one they appointed. You elect them. Whom did you elect? The one he appointed. Your head doesn't work. His head works. You cannot choose. If you can't choose the right person, what happens then? "Raise your hand" and he'll raise it. "Lower your hand" and he'll lower it, those are the people they need. "Raise your hands," and they'll raise them. "Lower your hands," and they'll lower them. Would they elect me as a member of parliament? They wouldn't.
If they elected me, the very next day I would put forward a legal article concerning all the forbidden things (haram). I would say: here is a legal article for these to be prohibited. Faith on one side, the legal article on the other. Which one will you raise your hand for? If I became a member of parliament, first thing, right the next day, the first legal article would be the reduction of interest in Turkey to zero. Done. The next day the assembly would convene. To strip me of my parliamentary seat.
Then a court, for trying to drag the country into a theocratic order, and bam, you're inside. It's that simple. For trying to turn the secular, democratic state system that respects human rights into a theocratic state system, bam, you're inside. That's it. You can't even ask for it. In Mudanya they said to me, "Well, you see, we don't have a speaker here." That MHP, the Welfare Party, and there was also Edibali, you know, the three of them formed a coalition like that. They were going to run in the election. There was that watchmaker Mehmet, he came and begged and pleaded with Sheikh Efendi. "We don't have a speaker, you see." "Give us Brother Mustafa, let him come and speak." "This one," he said, "will speak about the Qur'an and the Sunna there," he said. "He won't get into your politics," he said. "Whatever happens, let him come and be the speaker." Fine, I'm going as a speaker, and now there, in a coffeehouse, I never forget it, a conversation took place. I said, "Would you want your mother, your younger sister, your older sister, your wife, your aunt, your daughter, anyone at all, to work in a brothel?" I said.
From the village coffeehouse. "No," they said, "we wouldn't want that." "Well," I said, "the most luxurious brothel in the Balkans is opening in Bursa." "Why don't you object to it?" I said. Not a sound. The community here wouldn't want it either. Right? I'm telling you the 2013 figures. 115,000, 1000 women applied for permission to work in a brothel. According to the Ministry of the Interior's 2013 figure, there are 11 brothels in Turkey. So then, normally, our obedience is tied to the Qur'an and the Sunna. So then, for the state to be Islamic, a person will follow the Qur'an and the Sunna, and the bureaucrat within the state will also follow the Qur'an and the Sunna. We are talking about the Nizamiyya madrasas.
11. The Siyasatnama: A Guide to Wearing a «Shirt of Fire»
That is why we can say that the Siyasatnama (Siyar al-Muluk), Nizam al-Mulk's most important work, is both a guide for statesmen and a classic book of politics that sets out the conception of the ideal ruler.
In my opinion, it is a book that every bureaucrat ought to read. They should print that Siyasatnama in its entirety. They should make it compulsory for all bureaucrats to read it. Of course, there is also a historical background to this.
What is this background? Nizam al-Mulk served as vizier to both Sultan Alp Arslan and Malik-Shah for about 30 years. I mean, 30 years within the state. And especially when you say Sultan Alp Arslan, I mean, Sultan Alp Arslan is the very summit of this matter. Serving as vizier to him means wearing a shirt of fire. Now, for example, being vizier to such a Khagan is a shirt of fire. It's the same thing. For example, there is a certain profile of man like that. Being his wife is wearing a shirt of fire. For example, there is a master like that, a murshid like that. Serving as his zakir is like wearing a shirt of fire. The reason: you'll always be meticulous, you'll always be strict like that, you'll always be running, you won't stop, and you won't give your nafs any credit. It's a shirt of fire. For example, may Allah have mercy on him. Serving as zakir beside Sheikh Efendi is a shirt of fire. Just try being a zakir. Then you are a zakir like that. But otherwise, it's a shirt of fire.
He looks at you like that once, and that's enough for you. He asks once, "What did you do about the guests?" You hemmed and hawed, didn't you? Okay, it's over. How is it over? He won't ask you again, "What did you do about the guests?" I'm giving this as an example. He came to city X, right? And five guests came there too. Suddenly you see Sheikh Efendi himself sending the guests somewhere. He doesn't leave it to the zakir. Why? The zakir failed in that matter before. Or else that zakir didn't take care of the guests. The next time he goes, he doesn't have him look after the guests. In fact, if someone is going to come there, he says on the phone, right beside the zakir: "Peace be upon you." "And upon you be peace." The person says, "Efendim, well, we were going to come and visit you." He says, "I am in place X." Now, let me not name the province, they take offense. They both get angry at me and follow the talks. "Wow, he took a jab at us," they say. Say, province X. I'm beside him. He says, "Don't come here," he says.
"We're in no position to host guests here." "From here I'll go to Bursa," he says. "You come to Bursa," he says. He doesn't want them there. The reason: they won't be hosted there. He won't come out of it with honor there. That's why it's like a shirt of fire. The same thing: serving as vizier beside Alp Arslan is like a shirt of fire. Indeed, it is precisely a Khagan, a sultan, a padishah whose viziers have put on a shirt of fire. Whose pashas have put on a shirt of fire. Then the state stands firm. Look, then the state stands firm. That man is such a man that his wife has put on a shirt of fire. Then that becomes a home. Look, then it becomes a home. If the man earns and brings it home and the woman squanders it, if the woman doesn't keep to the line the man has drawn, while the man is within the bounds of the Qur'an and the Sunna, then that will not be a home. Look, everything from the family to the state is affected. That's why, I mean, in the era of Nizam al-Mulk the state has to be a real state.
Because the state is struggling with Byzantium. I mean, Alp Arslan defeated Romanos Diogenes in 1071. Was the Byzantine threat over? No. On one side, the state is dealing with internal rebellions. And on the other side, it finds itself face to face with the Batini and Ismaili movements. Inside, too, there are normally Batini and Ismaili movements. And in Egypt there are the Fatima, the Fatimids. They turned Batiniyya into a state, and at the same time, within the borders of the state there are different ethnic communities, different sectarian communities. You know how they say geography is destiny. There are ethnic and religious communities. Well, after all, these lands are the starting point of humanity. These lands are the place where every kind of belief, every kind of ethnic origin has been blended together. Look, this is a place where every kind of ethnic origin and every kind of religious difference, factions, every kind of different political faction, are all in one place.
That is, here you have a concern such as administering the state, or running the country in this sense in peace and with justice. That is why in Nizam al-Mulk's time they were dealing with these kinds of things, and the Siyasatnama, in this sense, moves away from being an abstract politics or political theorising. It is not political theory. Well, what emerges then is a Siyasatnama that seeks solutions to the crises the state was going through and develops practical methods in this regard. Because there is a crisis. There is a crisis inside the country, for one. There are different ethnic and religious communities. And inside the country there are different political communities. And outside the country there are various pressures between states. That is why, normally, governing the state here, managing those crises, is not an easy thing. Well, now, if we proceed from here, then the source, the foundation of the state has to be divine legitimacy. You know, in recent times too there have been fights over legitimate, over legitimacy.
For example, in the Ottoman state too there was the first legitimacy, the second legitimacy, the 3rd legitimacy. Those continue. They continue even in the Republic of Turkey. There is a crisis of legitimacy. This crisis exists among the Seljuks too.
12. Divine Legitimacy and the Ruler's Heavy Responsibility
That is why, according to Nizam al-Mulk, rulership is not an ordinary office.
Look, in every age Allah chooses certain people from among humankind and charges them with the administration of the state. Now, you, or some circles, may object to this, may rebel against it. But this is a divine legitimacy. For example, among the Turks, all the way from Central Asia onward, this is important. The khagan who will take the head of that state is sacred. He has been sanctified. He is kut (divinely blessed). The reason is that he has been chosen. That same phenomenon, for example, also exists within Sufism. That is, I am giving an example: the saints are kut. They are chosen. Among these, the saints are the chosen of the chosen. Among these, the poles and the pole of the age are chosen from among the chosen. This, normally, this is divine legitimacy. That is why this understanding is only the union of the kut idea in Iran, within Iran itself, with Islam's understanding, established by a verse, that Allah gives dominion to whom He wills. It is the union of the understanding that Allah gives dominion to whom He wills. This: [Qur'an, al-Baqara 2:247 — verse text pending: Diyanet English translation] It is established by a verse.
Allah also gives the administration of the state to whom He wills. It is established by a verse. Just as He gave it to Solomon, just as He gave it to David. This is established by a verse. That is why that head of state is in office by the grace of Allah. This point is important, and he is obliged to represent justice there. And at the same time he is responsible for his people's peace, for his people's safety of life, safety of property, safety of honour, safety of religion, safety of reason. Look, he is responsible. He is responsible for his people's, his people's safety of reason, safety of religion, safety of honour, safety of property, safety of life. He is obliged to fulfil that responsibility. He is obliged to rule with justice and to choose competent statesmen.
Because the people's peace is important. There must be no gangs in your state. Bribery must not be rampant in your state. There must be no discrimination, no favouritism in your state. In your state, no person should go hungry till morning. In your state, the rich do not have to become richer and the poor poorer. It must not be so. The state is "al-fakhri faqir." That is, the state is the servant of the poor. The state is together with the poor. According to Nizam al-Mulk, you cannot just say, "I have been chosen, I have the divine kut," sit in the head of state's seat, and crush the poor. Because the Siyasatnama thinks about how the peace of the whole people is to be secured. If someone comes and sprays your home or your workplace with bullets, the state punishes him. It finds him and punishes him. If he has killed someone, the state executes the killer, the one who killed unjustly. The state executes.
Because the state is the possessor of justice. If a man rapes a woman by force, it punishes him. The state is the possessor of justice. The state does not go and seize someone's goods and property. The state is the possessor of justice. If a man does not want to sell his goods, he does not sell them. The state cannot say, "Why aren't you selling?" and sell off his goods through foreclosure. The state is the possessor of justice. That is why, normally, you know, the understanding that even if it is the head of state, that head of state, that is, the ruler, does not err, does not exist in Nizam al-Mulk. In the contemporary Iranian kingship of that day, however, the head of state is infallible.
In Iran the head of state is infallible. He does not make mistakes. It is not in this sense. The understanding in Nizam al-Mulk. Quite the contrary, in the Siyasatnama Nizam al-Mulk frequently explains that a head of state who is unjust, who favours his partisans and at this point hands over the state's resources to his partisans, and such a state, cannot survive for long. Because it cannot survive.
13. "The State Is Founded by the Sword, but Lives by Justice": Justice and Economics
And at this point, according to Nizam al-Mulk, the main foundation of the state is justice.
One of the most repeated principles of the Siyasatnama is this. In the Siyasatnama: the state is founded by the sword, but it lives by justice. According to Nizam al-Mulk, an oppressive, tyrannical understanding of the state, tyrannical bureaucrats, judges, administrators rot the state. These are quotations I have taken from Nizam al-Mulk's Siyasatnama. An oppressive, tyrannical understanding of the state, tyrannical bureaucrats, judges, administrators rot the state. According to Nizam al-Mulk, justice revives the economy. The people become attached to the state. The army grows stronger. Again, according to Nizam al-Mulk, the idea that justice strengthens the economy has a strong foundation both in historical and in modern economic analyses. In societies where justice is ensured, trust, property rights and the investment climate develop. And this directly supports economic growth. These are quotations. The basic logic: justice protects the rights of individuals and institutions.
This climate of trust encourages investment and production. Mustafa Özbağ's analysis, from the classical thinkers, if we are to give examples, you will say, "Look, we came here for a Sufism talk."
What is going on? Yes. Plato and Aristotle. Let us go to Greek philosophy now. He says the basic condition of social order and prosperity is justice. Adam Smith, the intellectual father of capitalism. He says that without the rule of law, market order and the happiness of society are not possible. Well, one cannot pass by without looking at Karl Marx. Now, back in my ülkücü (nationalist) days, nobody would read Karl Marx. Yes. According to Marx, the use of law in the interest of the powerful classes gives rise to injustice in the factors of production. Equal distribution is only possible with a sound legal infrastructure. I am saying this in quotation marks. Well, now imagine a state. That state, you know, does not conform to Nizam al-Mulk. Its basic idea is not justice. It is not the protection of units, individuals and institutions. Look, we went, what if that state in quotation marks were to say, you know, is he taking this thought, this idea of his from the West?
But, I mean, according to Aristotle and according to Plato too, such a thing is not possible, you see. He too says, you know, that the fundamental condition of social order and prosperity is justice, he says. Well, if justice has gone on holiday, what are we going to do now? Well, we go to Karl Marx. Is that alright? It is. Let him look. You know, that person is presumably defending a Marxist system. He too says: the use of law in the interests of the powerful classes. Come on, how so, I mean? Well, when so-and-so becomes the president of that football club, then go ahead and hold those drug parties at his house. Let drugs be found in his house. Let drugs be found in his hair, in his blood. In through one door, out the other. When 1 gram of drugs is found in some other poor wretch's house, give him 8.5 years.
If more than 3 grams were found, classify him as a dealer and give him 25 years. Well, look, I have a company. I actually pay every kind of tax. Well, some taxes, forgive some companies' corporate tax, whatever-it-is tax, wipe it out. Come on. Well, what happened? The law came under the command of certain powerful families, or powerful politicians, or powerful individuals. According to Marx, we're hostile to Marx. Why did you become hostile? This part is correct. You know, some Epstein whatever blew up in the USA, didn't it? I mean, can you imagine an 8-year-old child being raped? Of a girl child; the country, child country, countries, or rather, child rapists are running them. What was it? Was it Epstein or what? His plane too went in and out of here a lot. What did it come in to do, what did it go out to do? Whom did it take away? Is it being investigated? They reached as far as the British palace. They reached into Europe. Does anyone know whether there are connections in Turkey too or not?
In today's terms, the legitimacy of the state arises not from power alone but from justice. According to Nizam al-Mulk. Religion and state, according to Nizam al-Mulk, are not separated.
14. «Religion and State Are Twin Brothers» — But Which Religion?
What was his famous view?
Religion and state are twin brothers. According to this idea, religion provides morality and the state provides order. Well, if you have declared war on religion and the religious, how will that religion provide morality there? Look, for 150 years you have waged war on the religious. You banned the Qur'an. Learning religion... Then you set up a Diyanet (Presidency of Religious Affairs). Then you set up a theology faculty. And with that you corrupted, you spoiled classical religious belief. Then when someone, a Muslim, makes a mistake, you beat the defenseless one, saying, "the religious are like this." Where was that religious person raised? He was raised in these lands. What education did he receive? He received the curriculum of national education. Who educated him? The secular Religious Affairs educated him. Who? What do you expect from the secular Presidency of Religious Affairs? And on top of that you have already frightened people. 10 people gather to do dhikrullah (remembrance of Allah). 50 police officers raid them. We were going to hand out ashure right here. 600 police officers raided.
Ashure, the ashure you know. You know, the ashure we ate last week. We couldn't hand it out here, you see. Simple things. Right? This place stayed closed for 7 months.
It was closed by order of the governor's office. We took it to court. We won in court. It closed it again. We took it to court again. We won again. If it wants, it'll close it again. Then how will a religious person be raised in a tyrannical environment? He'll be raised crooked. The reason? Back-alley. Yes. And this is exactly what is wanted anyway; you know, the religion that is wanted is: if you recite so many of whatever, they'll give you so many houris; if you recite so many of whatever, there's that famous one: if a person, before the morning prayer, takes a proper clean ghusl, turns toward the qibla, and recites the noble basmala 786 times for 7 days, God willing, by Allah's permission, he will be freed from prison.
I'm telling you what I read. Man, the guy committed rape. He murdered a whole lot of people, or else committed a whole lot of crimes. For 7 days before the morning prayer he will take a clean ghusl and recite the noble basmala 786 times. He'll get out of prison. Is that so? Is this religion? Now I read it, I looked, I said, look, I said, people are going to read this as religion. What I read, then someone else also read it in a talk. They asked me about it as a question. On this subject I have read neither a hadith nor a verse, neither a hadith did I read. I said I don't know. There is no such thing. In the religion I learned there is no such thing. Wherever they learn it from, someone wrote that. What happened? It did not conform to the Qur'an and Sunna. Look, right now in the country, those who say, "we hold fast to the Qur'an and Sunna, we follow the ijtihad of the imams," are in the class of the pitch-black ignorant. Why? We're Muslims, alhamdulillah. Let's snort the cocaine too. We're Muslims, alhamdulillah. Ah. Allahu akbar.
Takbir. Allahu akbar. Well, there's no prayer. We're Muslims. Takbir. Allahu akbar. Come on, let's go to the beach. Let's lounge around there. Let our women wear bikinis. And let our men wear tiny shorts. In fact, tiny shorts won't do either. Men need to wear briefs. Women wear bikinis below. What shouldn't men wear? Let them wear them too. But we're Muslims. Years and years ago something happened concerning my mother. I just couldn't persuade my mother. Then one Saturday like this I came out of the sohbet. I put my foot down, after the morning prayer, you know, around 8 or 9 in the morning I went to Bayındır. I made amends with my mother. Okay, mom? Okay. From there I'll go to Gelibolu. I'll make it to the sohbet.
I put my foot down on the road, and after passing, like, a halı, somewhere around Dikili or around Ayvalık, I said I'll pray the noon prayer, you know, there on the, like, the coast, well, the coast on my left, the mosque on my right, it was convenient for me. I said, let me go into this mosque here and quickly pray my prayer. Ah, I went into the mosque. They had put showers like this in the mosque courtyard. Ah, women in bikinis are taking showers there. I went into the restroom, came out, quickly took my ablution. Head down. I'm about to bump into something. Ah, for the women they had also put out, like, wide skirts there. They had put out something like a blouse to wear on top. They had put out headcovers. The woman covered herself like this. Her hair and such is showing. No problem. Aegean Islam. You know, those skirts aren't long either, and they pray like that. I said, okay, look, she's praying. You can't say anything. Are you going to tell someone who is praying not to pray? Now, this is the understanding of religion that is wanted. Our boy, rakı, what?
Do you know why it was made haram? God forbid, brother. You know better. Apparently the Prophet's Companions were drinking like this somewhere. As the Prophet was passing by, he looked and saw how nicely cheerful they were. He said, "Oh, what lovely cheer, the Companions are enjoying themselves." He said nothing. On his way back he looked and saw that they were brawling and making a racket, fighting each other. He said, "O Lord, make this drink haram for my ummah." So it is this drink, I mean the kind followed by brawling and fighting, that is haram. I listened. I'm a new Muslim, you know, brother, I've never read anything like this in the hadiths. He said, there are mistakes in the books you've read, he said. I mean, now I, I mean our boy said, after drinking, if you drink like a gentleman, he said, then it isn't haram, he said.
This is the Islamic understanding and way of life that is wanted. There's a wedding. Let's drink, dance, jump around. Let's mix, women and men together, and turn the place into a disco. How lovely it turned out. Of course, the Islam that is wanted, I mean, is not the Islam I live. According to Nizam al-Mulk, however, without religion in the true sense, the state turns into tyranny. That is, there must be religion in the true sense so that the state does not become tyrannical, and without a truly just state, religion cannot be protected either. Religious people cannot be protected either. Why? I beg your pardon. Some buffoon comes along. He says a sacrifice can even be made from a shoe. And you listen. Some buffoon comes along and says the headscarf does not exist in Islam. And you listen. Then they grow even bolder. There's no such prayer as this prayer you perform. Another buffoon comes along saying what is meant by salat is not this prayer. He says, may Allah curse whoever made this prayer a calamity upon the Muslims. Allah, Allah.
I play the video again, I listen again. Yes, that's what he says. May Allah curse whoever made this prayer a calamity upon the Muslims. Allah, who made it a calamity? If we were to see it as a calamity, prayer is the command of Allah. Just as prayer was made obligatory upon all the prophets and past communities since Adam, it has been made obligatory upon you as well. Who made it obligatory? Allah. Who performed that prayer? Our master the Prophet, sallallahu alayhi wa sallam, and the past prophets. Well, this manner of performing it also belongs to the prophets and belongs to our Prophet. Sallallahu alayhi wa sallam. Oh, so they've made prayer a calamity upon this ummah. Is that so? Yes. Are you doing anything against this? No. Can you? Would you dare to do anything? No. His became freedom of thought. If you or I were to stand up and say, may Allah curse the one who says "may Allah curse those who made prayer a calamity upon this ummah."
If I said amen, I mean, I said it or I didn't. This is not the understanding of religion that is wanted. The understanding of religion that is wanted is what? I mean, if possible, pray your prayer from one Eid to the next. Say you are Muslims, but don't live Islam. Yes. According to Nizam al-Mulk, the ulama and the state administration must be in constant cooperation. But which ulama? Those who make the Qur'an and the noble Sunna functional both on the intellectual plane and on the practical plane. Yes. Nizam al-Mulk regards the strengthening of local lords as dangerous. That is, you will be subject to the central authority. There's no dividing the country into 5 or 10 like that. No dividing it into 20 or 30. There is no form of state based on ethnic origin, or a form of state based on religious, ethnic, ethnic origins. According to Nizam al-Mulk, religiously speaking, the religion is Islam. It is the Qur'an and the Sunna. And at this point, the one who is strong is the state. Not the feudal lords around, or the beys, or certain families, certain landowners.
For this reason, according to Nizam al-Mulk, a central bureaucracy, a regular tax system, a civil service based on merit, and a strong army are the foundation of the state. The foundation of the state is a strong army and, normally, a central bureaucracy, a regular tax system, a merit-based bureaucracy and civil service. Merit-based. If it is not like this, then this state system is doomed to collapse. That is, according to Nizam al-Mulk, what is at stake is a strong public administration. A strong public administration. This is Nizam al-Mulk's foresight and view. What is the most important thing in this? Merit. In the Siyasatnama a warning is given frequently. And this warning is: offices are not to be given to friends, partisans, relatives. And if they are to be given, these must be competent people. People who have specialized in their field. A person who has specialized in their field, in their office. You cannot put a health-care doctor in charge of the fight against terrorism.
He is not qualified in this matter. For the ministry, for example the Ministry of Health, you have to bring someone who has matured within it, who came from medicine, who actually treated patients, who worked in various state hospitals, who has been successful in this way. You have to bring such a person. Merit is very important. According to Nizam al-Mulk, you cannot put ignorant, and in this respect lazy, tyrannical administrators in office. Because he is inadequate. If you bring an inadequate person into the state bureaucracy, he will sink that state. The state is not your farm. If an ignorant person has no knowledge of a matter, you cannot put that ignorant person at the head of that matter. If you do, you will sink the state, and you cannot put a tyrannical judge, a tyrannical administrator in office there. Because he causes the state to collapse.
Because if you make these unqualified, ignorant, tyrannical people, who in this respect lack sufficient experience, into administrators, they will crush the people. They will raise taxes. Bribery multiplies. And in the end the state collapses. Because he is tyrannical, because he is ignorant, because he is inadequate, unqualified, or else, without knowing the conditions of a country he hasn't lived in, he comes and serves as minister of the economy in that country. The whole state hung on his every word. Who? Kemal Derviş. Where did he come from? He came from the IMF. Did they bring him and put him over us? They did. He sold the factories, sold this, sold that. He increased the taxes. Were you able to raise your voice? No. According to the Siyasatnama, according to Nizam al-Mulk, you cannot bring this man and hand the economy or the state over to him. Because those who hand it over are unqualified too.
15. Merit, Oversight and Intelligence: The Institutions That Keep the State Standing
Because those who hand it over are ignorant too. For this reason, viziers, that is ministers, and senior bureaucrats must be constantly overseen.
According to Nizam al-Mulk, viziers must be overseen. Senior bureaucrats: according to Nizam al-Mulk's Siyasatnama, a bureaucrat or vizier who is not overseen commits tyranny, commits treachery, takes bribes. He hands things out to his relatives, hands things out to his partisans. He hands out the state's revenues, the tenders. Because at 12:00 at night a law or a decree is published. It is said that the import of 5,000 tons or 50,000 tons or 500,000 tons of sugar has been permitted. At the same moment 500,000 tons of sugar enters the country and the quota is filled. You read the decree. You say, let me bring in sugar from somewhere tomorrow too. Before you've even started negotiating, it's announced in the morning. It's said that the 500,000-ton sugar quota import permit has been closed. Huh, where was it? So the man had loaded it onto ships. I'm reading these things in the press. He had loaded the ships and was waiting. Meaning, such a quota is going to be lifted. It will be granted. It was granted.
He submitted all the declarations to customs, 500,000 tons filled, tax-free. Well, I'm bringing in one container of yarn. When I brought in one container of yarn, it came to 140 billion or something. I paid tax. The man brought 500,000 tons of sugar into the country tax-free. Yes. For Nizam al-Mulk, the intelligence system is important. Nizam al-Mulk is quite a realistic statesman.
He says the ruler must know what is happening in every corner of the country, must keep secret agents, and must supervise the governors. Because if administrators are not supervised, they may oppress the people. The most important danger was the Batiniyya; in the period Nizam al-Mulk lived in, the Nizari Ismailis were known for political assassinations. If there are political assassinations in a country, pay attention. In a state system designed by Nizam al-Mulk, no opportunity is given to political assassinations. And yet, while he attached so much importance to this, he is killed in a political assassination in 1092. For this reason the Nizamiyya madrasas are founded. Sunni scholarship is strengthened. Scholars are trained. The intellectual unity of the state is sought to be preserved. Who was the comparison with Nizam al-Mulk? It was with Machiavelli, Niccolò Machiavelli.
16. Final Comparison: Nizam al-Mulk or Machiavelli?
His approach, in this passage we took, you know, we read it from the beginning, normally, yes, this is largely correct. The passage: in his work titled The Prince, power was explained not so much through divine legitimacy but through force, the continuity of the state, human nature and political realism.
For this reason Machiavelli is regarded as one of the pioneers of modern secular political thought. The difference between Nizam al-Mulk and Machiavelli: for Niccolò Machiavelli, the purpose of the state is the continuation of power. For Nizam al-Mulk, however, first comes the pleasure of Allah, then justice, then the survival of the state. While Machiavelli puts success at the centre, Nizam al-Mulk puts legitimacy, justice and religious responsibility at the centre. From today's perspective, important political scientists point out that Nizam al-Mulk's thought is still striking today in the following respects.
Merit is the most important. An emphasis on justice close to the idea of the rule of law, public oversight, accountable administrators, a strong bureaucracy, the strategic importance of educational institutions for the state. On the other hand, the understanding of divine legitimacy and the unity of religion and state differ considerably from modern, democratic and secular political theories.
17. An Important Correction: al-Ghazali Is Against the Batiniyya, Not the Shi'a
The Nizamiyya madrasas were indeed founded with the aim of strengthening the Sunni, Ash'ari, Shafi'i tradition. One of the reasons for this was to train scholarly cadres against the Batini-Ismaili activities supported by the Fatimid state of the time. However, the sole purpose of the madrasas, underline this, it's important, important. Mustafa Özbağ's observation: the sole purpose of the madrasas was not opposition to Shi'ism. Teaching hadith, fiqh, tafsir, kalam and the other Islamic sciences was also among the fundamental goals. That is, it would be wrong to see the Nizamiyya madrasas merely as anti-Shi'i madrasas. And al-Ghazali is not an anti-Shi'i person either.
Neither am I. I am against certain factions within the Shi'a. Let us state this clearly. But right now there is a great danger being thrown into the Islamic world. The Shi'a-Sunni conflict, and they are dividing them in such a way, trying to make them fight in such a way, that they are doing one of the greatest evils. We can't say a word against Imam Ja'far, can we? He is both of the Ahl al-Bayt and the teacher of Imam-i A'zam (Abu Hanifa). Declaring the Shi'a entirely beyond the pale, declaring the Sunnis entirely beyond the pale, declaring them unbelievers, is not a correct approach. Neither is it right for those who say "I am Sunni" to regard the Shi'a entirely as unbelievers, nor for the Shi'a to regard the Sunnis entirely as unbelievers, unbelievers, to pass such a judgment. That is why al-Ghazali is one of the scholars who wrote the most important refutations against the Batiniyya.
But against whom? He wrote against the Batiniyya. May Allah protect us. The work we mentioned is, by its Arabic name, Fada'ih al-Batiniyya, or in its Turkish equivalent, The Inner Face of Batinism. Al-Ghazali declared war on the Batiniyya. Not on the Shi'a. Here I want to make an important correction. Forgive me your rights. Al-Ghazali did not declare all the Shi'a wholesale to be outside Islam. One needs to study al-Ghazali well. The "Ghazalians" who are unaware of al-Ghazali present it as if al-Ghazali had opened fire on all the Shi'a and declared all of them beyond the pale. May Allah protect us. (Amin.) His criticisms are essentially of the Batini Ismaili movement's understanding of the imamate and its esoteric interpretations. This must be distinguished.
Otherwise, those who want to throw the Islamic world into a very great fire regard themselves as Sunni and declare the Shi'a entirely beyond the pale, and within the Shi'a, too, some people regard the Sunnis entirely as unbelievers, and they want to make them fight each other. I underline it again. The Nizamiyya madrasas and al-Ghazali are against the Batini Ismaili movement. Not against the Shi'a as a whole. That is why, throughout history, some of the Sunni scholars also expressed different views and thoughts about the Shi'a. Some were very harsh and condemned the Shi'a wholesale. Some Shi'i scholars, too, condemned the Sunni community wholesale. I do not see this as a correct point. In conclusion, the main idea of the text, that is, the difference between Nizam al-Mulk's understanding of politics based on divine legitimacy and Machiavelli's secular and realist understanding of politics, is accurate on this matter. That is, the one in the passage.
But in particular the statement "al-Ghazali declared Shi'ism to be outside Islam" should be expressed more carefully from a historical perspective, since it may be understood as covering all Shi'i schools. A more accurate expression, in my opinion, would be that al-Ghazali harshly criticized specifically the Batini Ismaili doctrine and wrote a refutation against it. I thank you for listening to me patiently.
The topic was long. I came and sat down without giving any tea break in between. I wanted to carry the topic through to the end like this. So as not to give any room for misunderstanding, I aimed to finish the whole paragraph. I thank you separately for listening to me with patience and great attention. Forgive me your rights. May it be forgiven. From our side too, may it be forgiven. If there is anyone who does not forgive, let him raise his hand. We'll settle it somehow. No problem. Next week, if Allah permits, if there is health and life, if we are here: in the work that he evidently wrote to support the policy Nizam al-Mulk wanted, and at his request, he says of Batinism that its outside is Rafidism and its inside is complete unbelief. God willing, we will go into both this Rafidism and a bit into Batinism, and after that we will continue the al-Ghazali talks, God willing. Forgive me your rights once again. May it be forgiven. May Allah be pleased with you.
Note: This text is the speech itself as found in the recording of the sohbet (spiritual discourse): only spelling and punctuation have been edited, and obvious mishearings in the subtitles have been corrected; a few unintelligible passages have been left as heard. Section headings have been added to make reading easier. The opening and closing prayers have not been included.
Bibliography
Verse of the Qur'an — Obedience to Those in Authority: [Qur'an, an-Nisa 4:59 — verse text pending: Diyanet English translation]
Hadith — The Limit of Obedience: «There is no obedience to a creature in disobedience (to Allah); obedience is only in what is ma'ruf (lawful and good).» — al-Bukhari, Ahkam, no. 7257; Muslim, Imara, no. 1840
Main Work — Siyasatnama: Nizam al-Mulk (Abu Ali Hasan ibn Ali, 1018-1092), Siyasatnama (Siyar al-Muluk). The classic book of statecraft by the Seljuk statesman who served as vizier to Sultan Alp Arslan and Malik-Shah for ~30 years, setting out his conception of the ideal ruler and just governance.
Main Work — The Inner Face of Batinism: Imam al-Ghazali (may Allah have mercy on him), Fada'ih al-Batiniyya. The fundamental refutation written against the Batini-Ismaili movement's conception of the imamate and its esoteric (allegorical, ta'wil-based) interpretations. As emphasized in the sohbet, the work targets not the whole of the Shi'a, but specifically the Batini doctrine.
The Opposite Pole — Machiavelli: Niccolò Machiavelli, Il Principe (The Prince), 1513. The pioneering text of modern secular political thought, which grounds power not in divine legitimacy but in force, the continuity of the state and political realism.
Historical Context — Manzikert and the Seljuks: Sultan Alp Arslan's defeat of the Byzantine Emperor Romanos Diogenes at Manzikert (Malazgirt) in 1071; the opening of Anatolia to Islam and the scholarly-political ground of the Nizamiyya madrasas (founded 1067). — General sources on Islamic and Seljuk history
Concept — Zill Allah fi al-ard & Qut: The synthesis of the view that the just ruler is regarded as «the shadow of Allah on earth» and the concept of «qut» (divine mandate to rule) in the Turkic state tradition with the Islamic principle expressed in [Qur'an, Al Imran 3:26 — verse text pending: Diyanet English translation].
Personality — Hajji Bektash Veli and Mentesh: The rebellion of Mentesh, the brother of Hajji Bektash Veli, against the Seljuks, which placed him in the category of baghi (rebel), and Hajji Bektash's withdrawal from politics after this event. — The oral tradition of Anatolian Sufism and the manaqibnamas (hagiographies)
This text has been compiled and re-edited from the 5th lesson (18.07.2026) of Mustafa Özbağ Efendi's sohbet series «Questions on al-Ghazali». Source video: YouTube. About the speaker: Mustafa Özbağ Efendi.
Additional sources:
- Nizam al-Mulk, Siyasatnama, the sections on justice, merit, oversight and central administration.
- Imam al-Ghazali, Fada'ih al-Batiniyya (The Inner Face of Batinism), critique of the imamate and ta'wil.
- Imam al-Ghazali, Ihya' 'Ulum al-Din, the sections on politics, commanding the good (amr bi'l-ma'ruf) and ethics.
- The Noble Qur'an, al-Nisa 4/59 (obedience to those in authority) and Al 'Imran 3/26 (the Owner of sovereignty).
- al-Bukhari and Muslim, the narrations «obedience is only in what is ma'ruf» (chapters of Ahkam / Imara).
- Machiavelli, The Prince (Il Principe), power and political realism.
- General sources of Islamic history and Sufism on the Seljuks and the Nizamiyya madrasas.