Sunday, November 15, 2026
OUR PATH IS THE PATH OF PROPHETHOOD
Mustafa Özbağ
Irshad & Tasawwuf · Official Site
al-Ghazali Talks·

Al-Ghazali's Logic: Mi'yar and Ālah | Questions on al-Ghazali 12

Translated from Turkish. Original article (Turkish) →
Note: Qur'anic verses in this article are marked and will be completed with the Diyanet English translation; the Turkish original is linked above.

1. Picking Up Where We Left Off: al-Ghazali's Logic

We will continue from where we left off, God willing (inshallah).

We had said, let us go a bit into al-Ghazali's logic. We will continue from there.

Al-Ghazali used the philosophers' weapon against the philosophers. That is, particularly on this point, he adopted in his own way the logical tools used by al-Farabi and Ibn Sina (Avicenna), such as definition, proposition, syllogism (qiyas), demonstration (burhan), necessary conclusion and non-contradiction.

But with these, he also questioned and criticised the metaphysical conclusions of the philosophers.

2. Definition: The Glass and the Table

When we say definition, it means clearly setting out what a thing is, by the essential features that distinguish it from other things.

Philosophically, that is, this glass has such-and-such, such-and-such features distinct from the table, and the table's features are these.

Therefore the glass is distinct from the table. It is not in the same category.

When you approach this as a philosopher, it is so, but when you approach it as a Sufi, both of them are a thing. Allah created both of them. Actually, if you look at it, if you go down to its foundation, there is no difference between the two at the point of creation, at the point of the essence of creation.

3. The Four Elements (Anasir-i Arba'a) and Going Down to the Cell

But then again, if you look at it the other way, they are created from what we call the four elements (anasir-i arba'a), you know, water, air, fire and earth.

But when you go even further down into it, when you go down towards its essence, there is no difference between the cells of this wood and the cells of the glass.

If you go down even further, you will see that in both of them there is an illusion.

But in terms of defining this in the outward (zahir) world, in terms of defining things, we say this is a table; normally nobody says the table was created from air, water, earth and heat. This is, you know, wood, there are those 5 elements, right, the famous wood. And this we see as glass.

4. «Show Me the Reality of Things»

Yet the Prophet (peace be upon him), sallallahu alayhi wa sallam, says in one of his supplications: Show me the reality of things.

A person who has reached the reality of things does not normally look at things in an outward way.

5. Proposition: True According to What?

What is the second thing the philosophers speak of? The proposition.

A sentence about which a judgement is made, which can be true or false. It will propose that something is true or false. Proposition. Yes. Again, philosophically, this is correct at this point, but at the metaphysical level of the matter, true according to what?

False according to what?

This time, this side of the matter comes up. Of course, when al-Ghazali looks at this metaphysically, very different conclusions come out of it. Then every proposition, that is, things about which a judgement is made that can be true or false, you know, again as in the verse of the Qur'an: [Qur'an, al-Baqara 2:216 — verse text pending: Diyanet English translation]

True according to what? False according to what? This too is a separate proposition.

6. Syllogism (Qiyas): In Islam There Is Also a Law of Analogy

Syllogism (qiyas) is reaching a new conclusion logically by proceeding from two or more propositions. Of course, when we look at qiyas, you know, normally in Islam too there is a law of analogy (qiyas).

For example, one of the rules of analogy is, you know, if a fast can be made up, then a prayer can also be made up. From here the scholars proceed by analogy.

But in this analogy there is a comparison between things, or between ideas. Then several things may be true. From among several truths, by making an analogy, different truths may also emerge. That is why this analogy is also important from the standpoint of Islamic law.

But there are some parts of this analogy where it parts ways with philosophy.

7. Demonstration (Burhan): Proof

Burhan, as is known, means proof. So it is proving a judgement with proofs based on certain and necessary truth. That is burhan.

But again here, on the point of burhan, if it is a rational matter, fine, but if it is a metaphysical burhan, that is, if it is a metaphysical truth, then the philosophers and al-Ghazali do not stand in the same place.

In fact, the areas that the Qur'an and the Sunna accept as true and the areas that the philosophers accept as true by their own lights are not in the same category.

8. Necessary Conclusion: Fire and Cotton Again

Necessary conclusion, you know, the philosophers use this a lot in their logical standards.

A necessary conclusion is the conclusion that, when the propositions are accepted as true, cannot possibly be otherwise and follows logically by necessity. Well, fine, when we look at necessary conclusions, you know, there was the last lesson, right, you know, when fire came near cotton or cotton came near fire, it would burn.

This was a necessary conclusion, but then again, might it not burn?

The answer: it does not burn. This time, what the philosophers, especially Ibn Sina or the others, saw as a necessary conclusion does not come before us as a necessary conclusion in metaphysical matters.

9. Non-Contradiction: «Is All Existence Mortal?»

Non-contradiction is the fundamental principle which holds that a thing cannot, at the same time and in the same respect, be both itself and its opposite. Well, that is, normally this non-contradiction, of course the philosophers too hold it like this by their own lights, within their own circle. Now, if we are to give an example: are all people here mortal?

Yes, they are mortal. Well, al-Ghazali is a human being, then. Al-Ghazali too is mortal. So normally, when it is like this, this appears like this as non-contradiction from the philosophers' point of view.

But there are some matters the philosophers cannot get to the bottom of, again related to metaphysics.

Is all existence mortal? It is mortal. All existence. Then, Allah is immortal. Allah too is a being. There is a contradiction here. That is the contradiction you cannot overcome. Or else, do all existing things eat and drink something? They eat and drink. Angels do not eat and drink.

10. Do Angels Eat and Drink?

For example, we believe in this. Angels do not eat or drink anything, but do the other ones, the jinn, eat?

Yes. Does Satan eat and drink? Yes. Do people eat and drink? Yes. Do animals eat and drink? Yes. Do plants eat and drink? Yes.

So at this point there is normally a problem with non-contradiction too. Of course, from here, you know, for definition we arrive at a definition like: what is a human being? What is a human being? Now, when we say what is a human being, we need to put forward a definition.

11. What Is a Human Being? A Thinking Animal, or a Caliph?

You know, having two eyes, having a nose, having a mouth, and so on, we are going to define it, right.

Having two feet, having hands, walking on its feet, according to the Europeans, a thinking animal. Because European philosophy characterises the human being as a thinking animal.

Islam, however, characterises the human being as a caliph (khalifa). And yes, it says that if a human being follows his nafs (the self), he becomes a creature lower than an animal.

But then again, it does not normally see the human being as an animal. There are points where they part ways. That is why, normally, the conclusion that will come out of two propositions turns out to be a syllogism (qiyas).

You know, there is a proposition. That proposition, and there is one more proposition. From the two of them we draw a conclusion. That is the syllogism (qiyas), and normally, you see, it is at these critical points that al-Ghazali's understanding, al-Ghazali's logic, comes out into the open.

12. Al-Ghazali Does Not Reject These Tools

Well, al-Ghazali, regarding these kinds of, you know, logical instruments, if we accept all of them as logical instruments, he does not say, "These logical instruments came from Aristotle, they came from the Greeks," and then, "Let us reject them in their entirety."

But then again, does he himself apply these logical rules in thinking correctly and, normally, in arriving at certain knowledge?

Yes. Look, on this subject al-Ghazali, in many matters, the metaphysical matters, that is, the indispensable truths of the religion, the propositions of the religion, the syllogisms of the religion, he is not in the business of undermining them by relying on philosophy.

On the contrary, he takes all those logical rules to the Qur'an and the Sunna, accepts the ones that are correct, and uses them.

That is, there is no total rejection. And the most important concept in his understanding of logic is mi'yar. What does mi'yar mean? Mi'yar means measure, standard. It comes from mihenk, the touchstone.

13. Mi'yar: Coming from the Touchstone, Meaning Measure

You know the touchstone, right, jewellers strike gold on the touchstone, don't they, to find the purity of the gold. Mi'yar also comes from the touchstone. Allah knows best. And this means measure. So then, at this point, for al-Ghazali logic functions as a measure, a mi'yar, that separates correct thinking from incorrect thinking, that is, there is correct thinking and there is thinking that is not correct.

Here al-Ghazali, by using the measure, distinguishes the right from the wrong.

14. Instead of Rejecting It by Saying «The Science of the Greeks»

And one of the most important things al-Ghazali does here is this: instead of saying "the science of the Greeks" and then rejecting this logic, he takes its, that is, philosophy's, tools of correct thinking, normally, in his own way, and puts them into the service of the Islamic sciences.

That is, not directly Aristotle's. That is, he takes these standards of correct thinking of Ibn Sina (Avicenna) and al-Farabi, takes the ones that are correct, and places them at the command of Islam, especially of the Islamic sciences.

That is, he makes them serve the Islamic sciences.

15. Placing Logic Within Kalam and Usul al-Fiqh

And while those who looked at logic before al-Ghazali saw it as a foreign science belonging to philosophy, al-Ghazali, by using logic within kalam (Islamic theology) and usul al-fiqh (the principles of jurisprudence), consolidates, so to speak, the place of logic.

Because at this point, when we look at al-Ghazali's fiqh matters, or when we look at his kalam matters, al-Ghazali's stance stands, in the old language, muhkam, that is, firm.

That is why I think this judgement is important.

Al-Ghazali does not banish logic from the Islamic world. He does not write a refutation against it. On the contrary, he gives logic a legitimacy within the sphere of the Islamic sciences.

16. This Is Not Something Every Scholar Could Achieve

Actually, the point at which al-Ghazali stands, this is my own assessment, is not a point that every scholar could stand behind, could achieve.

Because in the process leading up to al-Ghazali, against logic, especially against philosophy, I mean, Islam up until that day was not without logic. Up until that day the scholars of Islam were using logic.

But people like al-Farabi, like Ibn Sina, the Aristotelian logic, they are received as outsiders, and people are hostile to it. But al-Ghazali, walking along such a fine line, takes the logic of Ibn Sina and al-Farabi, which was drawn from Aristotle, places it even more at the command of the Qur'an and the Sunna, and with a different argument brings it in as an instrument of service to the Islamic sciences.

17. The Introduction of al-Mustasfa

And most importantly, al-Mustasfa is a book of usul al-fiqh.

In the preface of this book of usul al-fiqh, al-Ghazali places an introduction, a preface, concerning logic, and here there is a very striking rule of his.

18. «One Who Does Not Use Logic Has No Reliability»

This rule, normally, says that the knowledge of logic does not belong to fiqh alone, that it is a fundamental introduction for all the sciences, and he has very harsh expressions for people who do not understand logic, do not grasp it, do not use logic.

And this harsh expression, that is, he says that a person who does not understand logic, who does not use logic, will have no reliability in my hands.

That harsh.

19. Who Needs Logic?

That is, that person must certainly be well-versed in that science of logic.

For example, today, for mathematicians, physicists, chemists, people in artificial intelligence, computer programmers, these are important. And then for electrical engineers, electronics, for example, this might perhaps be misunderstood, let it not be misunderstood.

For example, doctors who possess the science of medicine, surgeons, all, for example, people in trade, I am serious about this, need to possess knowledge of logic.

20. This Is Not a «God-Given Gift»

That is, don't think of this as some God-given gift, you know, like, "Oh, Allah has given it to him."

A person who makes an effort on this subject, who strives, who reads, who examines, who researches, who racks his brain over this matter, yes, can get hold of one end of that science of logic. He can do wonderful things in his own field of work, in his own, for example, field of education, but he has to, normally, apply it in his own way on the right plane.

21. Al-Ghazali Opens a Magnificent New Path

And al-Ghazali actually opens a magnificent new path for those after him.

He opens a magnificent new path. I mean, can you imagine? I mean, he places, so to speak, the science of logic inside all the Islamic sciences.

Of course, normally, to this a group of, you know, Zahiris, literalists, a group, forgive me for speaking like this, but, you know, Kharijites, you know, there are those who have put out refutations of this science of logic because it came from the Greeks.

This is, normally, not actually a correct refutation.

It is a science that ought to be used in all branches of knowledge.

22. Can There Be Fiqh Without Logic?

That is, in order to work your way through matters of fiqh, you need to use logic.

In order to make an analogy (qiyas), you need to use logic. In order to put forward propositions, you need to use logic. I don't know, in order to define something, you need to use logic.

23. Can We Define Fasting, Can We Define the Prayer?

Today, in the Islamic world, if we were to say to someone who claims "I am a scholar," "Define fasting," he could not define fasting. If we said, "Define the prayer (salat)," we could not define the prayer.

We pray because the prayer has been commanded, but we cannot fully define the prayer. Now, if I were to ask the friends here, have we ever thought about such a thing until today?

No. Well, if we said, let's define the prayer, we would define the prayer outwardly.

You know, the one for which ablution is taken, which has standing, bowing, prostration. And then we say it is an act of worship. We say it is an act of worship, but then İhsan Eliaçık comes out of the woodwork. He says the prayer is not an act of worship. An example. Now, according to İhsan Eliaçık, the prayer is not an act of worship.

24. Do We Have an Answer for the One Who Says «The Prayer Is Not an Act of Worship»?

According to 1400 years of Islamic understanding, the prayer is an act of worship.

Now, which of these are we going to believe? Yes. The prayer is an act of worship. We accept that. But when someone says it is not an act of worship, we need to have an answer to give him.

And the man is shouting it at the top of his lungs. And no one says to him, what are you saying? Under the refrain of freedom of thought, the man says whatever he likes. Well, now, when it is like this, we need to be able to define the prayer.

Are we able to define the prayer? No.

If we went and asked İhsan Eliaçık, who says the prayer is not an act of worship, if we said, define the prayer for us, he cannot define the prayer. Yes. Or else, if we went today to a professor of theology and said, "Define the prayer for us." Look, this is a different flank here. Defining a religion, defining an act of worship. Look, when we say defining, what we do now is describe the way it is performed. That is one way of looking at it. It is not the whole of the definition.

25. «He Cleansed the Madrasa of Reason» Cannot Be Defended

Now, that is why, normally, you know, it is not possible for us to put in its proper place the principle, the claim, that al-Ghazali cleansed the madrasa of reason and logic.

This is also something that cannot possibly be defended, but they will absolutely throw stones at al-Ghazali.

They will criticize al-Ghazali, sure, but even while criticizing, people need to be fair.

But there is no fairness in people. May Allah protect us.

26. The Correct Expression Would Be This

I mean, instead of saying it like this, if one said that al-Ghazali, while limiting the independent metaphysical authority of philosophy, carried important parts of Aristotelian-Avicennan logic into kalam and usul thought, if we said that, it would be appropriate.

But, however, if we do not say that and instead say that al-Ghazali cleansed the madrasa of reason and logic, then we have not known al-Ghazali, have not been able to define him.

You know, a moment ago there was the defining of the prayer; well, al-Ghazali has not been defined either. We would not have known him. For someone to be able to define al-Ghazali, at this point, I mean, he needs to sit down and do research.

Well, if an ignorant person like me can do this research, then university circles, especially this hearth, ought to define it better, research it better. But this, normally, amounts to a very great slander cast upon al-Ghazali.

27. Is al-Ghazali's Logic the Logic of Aristotle?

When we look, is al-Ghazali's logic the logic of Aristotle?

No. Is it the same? It is not.

I mean, cut-copy-paste. He did not do that. Al-Ghazali sat down. He studied Aristotle, he sat down and studied al-Farabi.

He sat down and studied Ibn Sina, and normally they neither rejected it saying this is Aristotle's knowledge, nor did they say it is Aristotle's knowledge and accept it entirely by doing cut-copy-paste.

28. Logic Is Not Truth Itself, But an Instrument

Well, what did he do?

He repositioned logic as a tool. Al-Ghazali sat down and repositioned logic. I mean, but while positioning it, for example, he did not say logic equals truth itself.

Whereas the Aristotelian al-Farabi, Ibn Sina chain said logic equals truth itself. According to al-Ghazali, logic is to be brought to the truth, it will bring to the truth; he saw it as a tool in reaching the truth. Al-Ghazali did not see it as truth itself. Normally, you know, if we were to give an example of this, you know, we took a stick in our hand. You know how the Almighty asks Moses, He says: [Qur'an, Ta-Ha 20:17 — verse text pending: Diyanet English translation]

29. The Staff of Moses (peace be upon him)

Where he could have said, it is a stick, O Lord, he says, well, with this I protect myself from predatory animals. I knock down leaves for my lambs, my animals. Well, I lean on this. I rely on this. He is describing this thing. What is it? He is describing the stick, the staff in his hand. Now, can he harm people with that staff too?

He can. Then can he wound people with that staff? Yes. Can he kill people with that staff? Yes. Can he kill his animals with that staff? Yes. Look, the staff, well, in shaking down leaves for his animals, in guarding himself against predators, well, normally in leaning on it when he got tired, and even against the sorcerers' sorcery, he threw it and it became a huge dragon.

Look, the staff, the staff as we know it.

30. Beneficial in the Right Place, Harmful in the Wrong Place

Then if we use the staff on the right path, the staff is a very beneficial tool.

But if, no, we do not use it on the right path, the staff is a tool that does harm. This is just like that. If we use logic in the right place, it is a tool that benefits us; if we use it in the right place, it is a tool that will enable us to find the truth.

But if we do not use logic in the right place, then what does this become? Then, when it is not used in the right place, it becomes a tool that does harm.

If you use it in the right place, it is beneficial; if you do not use it in the right place, it is useless. But this is the same in all sciences too.

31. The Same Holds for All Sciences

If you learn the science of hadith in order to live the religion, you will have done a right thing.

But if you learn the science of hadith to show off to someone else, to be arrogant toward someone else, that knowledge becomes a burden on you, becomes harm. If you become a possessor of knowledge in order to live the religious sciences, to teach people, those who want to learn, this is a right possessor of knowledge.

No.

But if you study the religious sciences to embarrass someone, or to show off to people, to be arrogant, or else to argue with people, you will see no benefit from that knowledge. In fact, you will be harmed.

Why did it drag you into arrogance? Why did it drag you into arguing with people? Why did you learn knowledge in order to gain superiority over people? This made you one destined for Hell. But if you acquired knowledge, studied it, in order to offer it for people's benefit, in order to live it, this became a benefit to you.

32. «Even If Knowledge Is in China»

At this point, well, logic too, if used in the right place, is beneficial to people, and if not used in the right place, it is something harmful; and logic is not, well, you know, something to be rejected because it is Greek.

Knowledge, even if it is in China, is the lost property of the Muslim. He takes it. A hadith. Because then, even if it is in Fezzan, even if it is in the most remote corner of the world, if there is knowledge, it is the lost property of the Muslim.

Taking it is the greatest right of the Muslim. Well, this being so, it is also not possible for us to reject logic because a philosopher used it, because philosophers used it.

33. There Is No Rule Saying «We Will Confiscate All the Staffs»

I mean, someone took a staff and used it.

He did something harmful. There is no rule saying we will confiscate all the staffs. There is no such logic. Nor is there any logic saying we will throw everyone with a staff into prison.

Because when the right thing was used in the right place, it was beneficial.

34. Not Every Conclusion Reached by Logic Is Certainly True

But normally, when a conclusion is reached because logic was used, it is also not possible to pass the verdict that it is absolutely, certainly true.

I mean, we laid out all the propositions of logic, of demonstration (burhan), of the syllogism. We reached the conclusion. It is also not possible for us to accept it as necessarily true, as a certain, definitive truth.

Because this is a critical line. Well, I mean, not every truth that logic accepts may be true. Because, I mean, from here, of course, we automatically move on to the Tahafut. I mean, reading the Tahafut anew, researching it anew.

I mean, I was compelled to do this.

35. Al-Ghazali's Fundamental Question

Well, I mean, as we said in previous talks, al-Ghazali's fundamental question is this: Are the conclusions the philosophers reached truly demonstrative (burhani), that is, proven with evidence?

I mean, are they conclusions that have been proven necessarily and with certainty?

Al-Ghazali asks this, and on many subjects al-Ghazali's answer comes out as no. You look, and there are roughly 17 to 20 subjects that this humble servant has identified, I mean, in my view close to 20.

36. The Eternity of the World: «You Have No Proof»

On close to 20 subjects, al-Ghazali has proofs at this point that the philosophers are not correct, again by following the very path of the philosophers. Well, normally, for example, you know, we always gave the example concerning the eternity of the world.

I mean, the philosophers say this world is pre-eternal.

You know, that it will never cease to exist. Sorry, they say it is something without a beginning. Concerning the world, they say it is pre-eternal. When it is pre-eternal, the world has no beginning. Whereas, you know, Islam does not say so on this matter.

There was nothing. Allah existed, and Allah created one thing. And from that one thing He created everything.

Then, if you regard the world as pre-eternal, well, there is no proposition for this. There is no syllogism for this. Normally, there is no rational proof for this that could be accepted either. Well, then al-Ghazali, for example, says in his Tahafut al-Falasifa: your proof, he says, is not necessarily demonstrated, he says.

You know, you regard the world as pre-eternal, but you have no proof on this matter. You have no demonstration on this matter that it is pre-eternal. Then you have produced a metaphysical proposition here. This metaphysical proposition has no proof. At this point al-Ghazali rejects the issue concerning its pre-eternity. You know, I specifically related this in previous lessons. That is why I have brought it here again. For example, al-Ghazali does not say don't use logic, but the propositions you bring must have a proof.

Well, if it has no proof, he again goes along the path of the philosophers. Using the tools that the philosophers use, he writes a refutation of them, and the philosophers cannot answer these. And normally it does not reach a conclusion by the standards of the philosophers' logic. It is not proven with certainty.

37. The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy

And when it is not proven, an interesting situation then emerges, and al-Ghazali has listed that interesting situation, I mean the places where the philosophers made mistakes, where they reached wrong conclusions as a result of their own logical propositions, one by one in his philosophy.

Well, of course, there is this, uh, Stanford University, the famous one. This university is at a very academic level internationally regarding philosophy, and al-Ghazali, while discussing the shortcomings in his Tahafut, shows that those philosophers do not meet the standards of the criteria they themselves set, and that philosophy department at Stanford University, an interesting thing, is free.

Ah, you know, you can access it on the internet.

38. «If Only My English Were Decent»

Ah, if only my English were decent, sometimes, you know, the language falls short, that's the thing. I say this with many apologies. Transfer those texts to, what's it called, His Holiness Google, then look at them again from there. You know, of course this becomes a bit tiring too. And then on Saturday, when I come up here, I come up completely wrecked. I mean, there are roughly 1800 referees there. There are 1800 philosophers. And these 1800 philosophers are constantly writing and updating everything like this. It is a very reliable source worldwide on the subject of philosophy. Even they, I want to come from there to this point. You know, perhaps, you know, I may not have come across it. My research may have fallen short.

39. Eighteen Hundred Referees

On this matter I too cannot say that I have definitely researched all of it, but those 1800, those philosophers, and moreover these 1800 are at a level where they can act as referees in philosophy across the world, and everything related to philosophy, you know, what do you call that in university language?

Something like a thesis is prepared. Articles are uploaded there. They examine those articles. They publish them there again. I mean, I am briefly passing on the information I have gathered.

40. Even They Could Not Find a Way Out

And normally, the places where, according to al-Ghazali, those philosophers made mistakes, in my view, well, 17, 18, I may have examined them incompletely. Perhaps it is 20, 25, or perhaps 15. If I said that at this point I had gone through philosophy completely, it would be a lie.

Because that is a bit difficult within this time. But even this Stanford philosophy academy, or encyclopedia, has not been able to find a way out of these answers that al-Ghazali gave to these philosophers.

From what I have identified. Well, normally, now if even they cannot find a way out of this, just think about it yourselves.

41. Becoming an Enemy When One Cannot Answer

Of course, on this matter, if a person falls short in answering something, ignorant people become hostile to him.

You know, you have knowledge.

You are a person of so much knowledge, but you cannot answer al-Ghazali. You know, you also don't want to bow before al-Ghazali. But then what do you become? You become an enemy.

Our esteemed gentlemen who appear to be, in quotation marks, intellectuals, instead of trying to understand al-Ghazali, trying to define him, turn into enemies. Well, then what was al-Ghazali's real distinction on this matter? I mean, if we set out a field, that field is al-Ghazali's general approach. You know, what is there in a field? There is logic. What is there? There is philosophy. Then what does al-Ghazali think about logic?

42. Rejecting Mathematics as Bid'a

Regarding logic, to a large extent he uses logic. To a large extent. When we say mathematics, it is not possible for a person to reject mathematics on religious grounds.

You know, like, "Mathematics is not a religious science.

This is bid'a (innovation). Let's oppose it." You know, there are such bid'a-mongers. Now this is not possible. Or there are those who call logic bid'a too and oppose it.

"Was there logic in the time of the Prophet (peace be upon him)? Bid'a." He comes out saying, "Every kind of bid'a is misguidance." No, brother, come on, it's not like this. Don't put this into such a shallow debate. By rejecting this like that, you cannot gain anything. This is not possible. Well, of course, normally, if you look at the Islamic world from this angle, then the Islamic world is a world left blind inside a blind well.

Well, go ahead and reject logic as bid'a.

43. Those Who Consider Medicine Bid'a, and the Jewish Doctors

Then go ahead and reject reason as bid'a. Reject mathematics as bid'a. Then reject medicine as bid'a. "Was there medicine in the time of the Prophet (peace be upon him)?"

I say to him, "Brother, there were Jewish doctors.

They wanted to leave Medina the Radiant. They said, 'We don't want to stay in Medina. There is no one sick here.' The Messenger of Allah, may Allah bless him. And grant him peace, assigned them a salary from the public treasury (bayt al-mal). He said, 'Teach the science of medicine to the Companions here.' He gave them a salary.

I say, how can you regard the science of medicine as bid'a? He says it is bid'a. Well, do such types exist? They exist in the Islamic world. Unfortunately, they exist.

And then, when his head aches, he runs to the doctor. So why did you run to the doctor then? "Seek treatment," it says. I tell him there is a hadith, but no. Does this shallow, barren, dark thinking unfortunately exist? It exists.

44. Astronomy or Astrology?

Do some people in the Islamic world call astronomy bid'a and reject astronomy?

Yes.

Look, I am not talking about astrologers. No. "The stars shifted from there to there, from here to here. This will happen to you, that will happen to you." Oh, just stay put where you are. When I say astronomy, I mean the Islamic world talking about astrophysics.

That is, it needs to talk about astrophysics. Well, now they are not talking about astrophysics. They practise sorcery, they make amulets, they consult star-charts (yildizname). These people pass themselves off as astrologers.

Whereas astronomy in the true sense is a separate branch of science. It is not possible to reject it. You cannot reject it by calling it bid'a.

45. Astrophysics, Astro-Mathematics, Astro-Chemistry

From there it needs to move on to astrophysics. It needs to talk about astrophysics. It needs to talk about astro-mathematics. It needs to think in terms of astrochemistry. Why? Normally, there are a great many planets in space.

The chemical substances within those planets need to be researched. Mathematics: the mathematics of the planets needs to be found. Astrophysics: the physical laws there, in the universe, need to be determined.

You call these things bid'a and reject them. You have not understood al-Ghazali at all. And then, if, looking at these people, you see al-Ghazali too as normally belonging to that class, then by Allah, and by Allah, and by Allah, you are an utterly ignorant person.

What kind of professor are you? You are nothing at all. May Allah protect us.

46. But Let the Specialist Not Pass Judgment Outside His Own Field Either

That is why, normally, but when we come to this point, I give an example: it is also not right for an astrophysicist, or a mathematician, or a physician, or a philosopher, or a logician to pass judgment on metaphysical matters.

But metaphysics, too, when we look at it from the philosophers' standpoint, is very dangerous.

And al-Ghazali is someone who told these philosophers, "Do not enter into metaphysics. Metaphysics is not your field," and wrote a refutation. "Oh, don't enter here; go and stay in your own branch."

47. "I Cannot Pass Judgment on Abdullah"

Or else, now, Abdullah is a neurosurgeon; am I going to get up and pass judgment on Abdullah in that matter?

No, that is not my business.

But Abdullah, too, will not pass judgment on metaphysics. He will say... he will stay where he is. Or a paediatrician. He'll say... he'll pass judgment on metaphysics.

Sit down, brother, you are a paediatrician. You have specialised in that field. Occupy yourself with treating children. For example, or a man who is an ordinary tradesman: brother, look after your trade, develop the science of trade in yourself.

Well, normally, don't pass judgment on other branches; but in our country, unfortunately, everybody knows everything.

Everybody knows everything. Everybody passes judgment on everything. May Allah forgive us.

48. Revelation Is the Defining Boundary

And normally, well, al-Ghazali here places revelation before everyone as the defining boundary.

That is, whether you are a mathematician, a physicist, an astrophysicist, a chemist, whatever you are, revelation is a limiting fact for you. Do not seek beyond revelation.

And what al-Ghazali seeks is ethics, and also reason, religion, and at the same time al-Ghazali seeks Sufi experience. Well, now, he is also someone who used logic very well in the methodology of fiqh (usul al-fiqh).

49. Opposition to Philosophy and Opposition to Logic Are Not the Same Thing

This being so, if you keep al-Ghazali within the same circle as regards opposition to philosophy and opposition to logic, that is not correct. That is, when we look at the historical process too, these two are not the same. That is, al-Ghazali is not someone who is completely opposed to philosophy. He identified the shortcomings and deficiencies of philosophy. He did not take logic from Aristotle just as it was.

He took what was necessary from logic, and normally he used both.

If we see him as someone who rejects both, then we will have assessed al-Ghazali wrongly. And it becomes evident that we do not know al-Ghazali, that we have not defined him.

50. Hasan Aydın's Criticism

But normally, there were those critical views we shared earlier, you know, within the texts we read.

Hasan Aydın, as you know, there was a critical paragraph of his there. He said that while al-Ghazali limited the metaphysical domain of philosophy, in the long run he narrowed the field of inquiry. When we normally pull this together, though: al-Ghazali's acceptance of logic does not automatically mean... if logic is used, in today's sense, like a limitless platform of thought and like a limitless freedom of thought, al-Ghazali is not there.

Normally there is logic in al-Ghazali's system, but the field of activity of logic is also defined, that is.

51. Defining the Domain of Each Branch of Knowledge

Because one of al-Ghazali's most important characteristics is this: he defines the domain of each branch of knowledge. That domain-defining should not be seen as a restriction. Because everything needs to be used in its proper place.

That is, al-Ghazali objects to reason saying, you know, "I can reach certain truth on my own."

Or, "I will reach certain truth with logical propositions." Al-Ghazali objects to these, and when we look at his hierarchy of thought, idea and belief, the senses are very important, reason is very important. Revelation is very important at this point.

52. The Hierarchy: The Senses, Reason, Revelation, Inspiration

The things al-Ghazali attributes importance to, and, depending on these, what the Sufis call kashf (unveiling), what I from time to time call inspiration (ilham), but which, when we look at the verses, is characterised by the verbal noun wahy (revelation): such a structure emerges in al-Ghazali.

Because normally, if the senses do not work, reason remains deficient.

The senses are important for al-Ghazali. You know, a person's seeing, hearing, feeling: these are the soldiers of reason. So then: sense, reason, revelation, and by revelation I mean the revealed Book and the Sunna.

But one notch beyond that is the person receiving inspiration. The path by which truth is reached. Look, the path that will reach the truth is the senses, reason, revelation, and inspiration, or kashf, or, at this point, what comes to that person, in a special sense, to his heart, which again I will call inspiration.

53. Al-Ghazali Does Not Deify Reason

Inspiration; and that is why al-Ghazali is far from typical rationalism, you know, from deifying reason.

Because he ties reason to revelation as well.

He even ties reason, in that person, to kashf, that is, to inspiration. But portraying al-Ghazali in this very simplistic way, as if he were an enemy of reason, truly shows that they have not defined al-Ghazali, shows that they have not understood him.

54. What Looks Like a Paradox

Of course, normally, one of the main theses of what we have discussed so far is this: while al-Ghazali struggles against the philosophers in certain respects, he places logic, the greatest instrument within philosophy, inside the Islamic system of thought.

From the outside, this point may look like a paradox.

You know, on the one hand he answers the philosophers, but on the other hand the logic the philosophers used is placed inside the Islamic sciences; it is like that saying in our language, "what kind of diet is this, with pickled cabbage?"

It may come across as a paradoxical matter like that. But in short, this is not such a paradoxical matter.

Because it is not possible for the Islamic system of thought to be illogical.

55. Signs in al-Kindi and the Tabi'un

When we go back a bit further, before al-Ghazali, to al-Kindi, it is possible for us to see this in al-Kindi as well.

In fact, when we go back even further, it is possible for us to see signs of this among the Tabi'un (the Successors) and the Tabi' al-Tabi'in (the Successors of the Successors) as well.

Although they were not understood in their own time, especially those great figures who walked the path of the people of Sufism, because the arguments they used could not be defined in their own time, they were ahead of their time. But did they use them?

They did. In fact, when we come to al-Ghazali, it is not as if al-Ghazali did not benefit from al-Kindi of old and those before him. He benefited from them too, and he came forth already having benefited from them as well.

56. He Threw Out What Contradicts Revelation and Took What Was Needed

And in this sense, he threw out the deficient parts of this logic, the logic in the line of Aristotle, Ibn Sina and al-Farabi, and the parts that are against revelation.

Al-Ghazali took the things that were needed.

57. Synthesizing Logic, Kalam and Fiqh

He placed it within the branches of the Islamic sciences, and after al-Ghazali these were used, logic was used as an instrument in kalam and in usul al-fiqh (the principles of jurisprudence); which means al-Ghazali did very important work on this matter and opened a new era for those after him, and, very interestingly, al-Ghazali synthesized logic, kalam and fiqh in a way like this, and by synthesizing it like this, by combining it, he opened a separate field within the Islamic world; and of course the debate about al-Ghazali and science varies at this point, and normally now it is: al-Ghazali rejected reason, rejected logic, banned philosophy, and the Islamic world declined.

58. How Simplistic the Thesis "Al-Ghazali Rejected Reason" Is

This remained before us as a very simplistic thesis. Now, I mean, when we examine these talks up to today like this, when we research them, when we look at what we have discussed, you know: al-Ghazali rejected reason.

A very simple, banal, low thing. He rejected logic. This too is very low, very banal, undefined. I mean, from someone who does not define al-Ghazali: he banned philosophy. This too is not something that could normally be defined. There is no proof of it.

May Allah protect us.

59. A Measured Statement Would Be This

Instead of saying it like this, had we said, or had they said, the following about al-Ghazali, it would have been more, uh, measured. Al-Ghazali largely adopted the logical aspects of Aristotelian, Avicennian thought, its correct aspects, but he did not normally accept their metaphysical conclusions or propositions, and there, so to speak, he shook the authority of philosophy, razed it to the ground.

That is exactly what offends them anyway. But in this way logic continued to live within the Islamic sciences and still continues to.

And philosophy's independent metaphysical proposals and propositions remained in a contested matter, in a contested state, and even now that Stanford University academic encyclopedia and department have not been able to get to the bottom of this.

I am speaking very assertively here, but, you know, I roughly reached this conclusion by examining it a little. You know, actually, if I had good English, I would have researched it more finely.

60. To the Young: "Have a Language"

This word of mine is to the young: truly, have a language.

Unfortunately, these kinds of, you know, research, theses, these kinds of writings around the world are in English; I mean, you look, those writings look at you, and you look at those writings. Come on, cut, copy, paste. Translate it into Turkish.

Even though we have plenty of English among us, nobody is working with me at 2 or 3 o'clock at night. I just fired a bazooka upward like that. Whoever understood, understood. Yes.

61. "My English Goes This Far"

Well, now, of course, but truly you see that, you know, the lack of language in myself. I see it. You know, my English is: what is your name?

My name is Mustafa Özbağ. That's it. There is nothing further.

For there to be anything further, I would need to make rabita (a spiritual bond) while speaking it. There is nothing further. Those who have more can of course speak. I have no problem on that point. He is studying English computer [science], isn't he, Sait?

Yes. God willing, young people will be raised with this. Then they will master the English language. I will send them passages. And they will translate them correctly into Turkish for me, but not from His Holiness Google.

I take a look, and something else comes out. I say, this should not be like this. When I say this should not be like this, I have it checked again through another channel, and something else comes out. So yes, unfortunately we are having difficulty when it comes to language. May Allah forgive us. (Amin.) Now there is a paragraph ahead of us. I worked a little on this paragraph, but I did not find my work sufficient by my own standards. It is a subject worth a whole lesson anyway. I was going to go into that subject a bit. I will go into it a bit more in depth.

62. Next Week: al-Mawardi and the State

Because there are issues related to the Islamic conception of the state as well. That is why I saved it for next week. Also, as it happened, I started early and tried to finish early like this. Next week: "Religious figures and the Islamist movement want to govern not only the spheres of faith and worship, but the state, society, education, the economy, the army, the civil bureaucracy, international relations, that is, in a sense the whole of life.

The famous Islamic jurist, the Shafi'i al-Mawardi's assessment, made nearly 1000 years ago, that religion and state are inseparable twins, would, as Professor Dr. Ahmet Ocak also expressed, lay the foundation of a political theory that would be valid throughout the entire Islamic world." Well, this is the paragraph. I need to give a substantial answer to this.

Because criticizing al-Mawardi like this from here is the easy part. We need to lay out here the environment in which al-Mawardi lived and the practices of his contemporaries, that is, of the states he himself lived in. It is not that I have not laid it out somewhat; I have. But this, you know, the idea that religion and state are inseparable twins. I mean, we normally need to open this up a bit. And in order to open it up, I mean, I took this issue all the way back to Plato.

63. "I Will Chase the Camel All the Way to Where It Was Born"

You know, what did Plato say? On the relations of religion and state, I took it all the way back there. I even took it as far as Saint Augustine, in Greek philosophy.

I don't leave things at such a close point. As we say back home, I chase the camel not to where it did whatever, but all the way to where it was born. And I don't let anyone say things like that about al-Mawardi, or about anybody, without examining and researching.

So of course, I am going to shake this out, so to speak. That is why I have a preface on this subject as well.

64. What Is Needed to Understand al-Mawardi?

Of course, in the period al-Mawardi lived in, on one side there are the Shia. The Shia have their own way of governing the state. The Persians have their way of governing the state. There is the transition from the Persians to the Shia. The Turks have their way of governing the state. You know, what they call Central Asia, in the English expression. The Turks have a way of governing the state, I mean, from Central Asia onward, and then, after becoming Muslim, an understanding of how to govern the state. There are the Umayyads, there are the Abbasids, and there is the period of the Rightly Guided Caliphs (Khulafa' al-Rashidun). Well, normally we need to talk about these state structures so that we understand al-Mawardi well. I mean, the Rightly Guided Caliphs' understanding of the state, the Umayyads' understanding of the state, the Abbasids' understanding of the state, the Seljuks' understanding of the state, the Shia's understanding of the state in al-Mawardi's time, how they govern the state, and the Turks' understanding of the state. The Abbasids, the Umayyads are separate, the Abbasids are separate, the Turks are separate. Then they become the Seljuks.

The Turks are separate. Well, the Shia are separate. Before the Shia there are the Persians. They are separate. So then, normally, the understanding of the state in that geography. And opposite all of these, there is Byzantium. Byzantium's understanding of the state, and the internal turmoil, the external turmoil. Only after analyzing all of these is it possible for us to understand al-Mawardi. I mean, only then can we understand the saying "religion and state are twin brothers" correctly.

65. The Fallacy of Secularism: The Directorate of Religious Affairs Is Tied to the State

Now, still, actually, whether people are aware of it or not, all over the world, don't be fooled, they put before us a fallacy saying that the affairs of religion and state are separate.

If they are separate, why is the Directorate of Religious Affairs (Diyanet) tied to the state? That means religion and state are still twin brothers. Since we have secularism. Since that is how they taught us about secularism in primary school, in middle school, in high school.

When you asked, "What are religion and secularism?", they said it is the separation of the affairs of religion and state.

But it is the state that takes you on the Hajj, I mean, an institution of the state, I mean the Diyanet takes you. As you know, the Diyanet is engaged in tourism. At the same time the Diyanet takes people on Umrah. Well, if you don't get a card from the Diyanet you cannot go on Hajj, you cannot go on Umrah. That means, on top of that, the Diyanet normally appoints civil servants to the mosques.

Well, religion and state continue as twin brothers. So where is the secularism here?

66. The Churches in Europe

Or else, in the countries you call secular, there are churches.

The churches normally carry on with their lives. The churches make proposals to the state, and in Europe and in America too, the state accepts the proposals of the churches.

Well then, you know, Plato in Europe, whether you say Eflatun or Platon, it's the same. That line continues in Europe.

In fact, on this point Plato has such interesting propositions; you know, he says that the people who will govern the state must receive religious training. Augustine, the state or the head of state, let me say it in their own language.

He sees him as the executor of God's commands. In that philosophy you call the West, Augustine sees the head of state, or the state, as the executor of God's commands.

Now, when we look at these, then we will understand al-Mawardi. Well now, still, on this point Europe looks as if, you know, it is practicing secularism. In every single area, religion and state are walking arm in arm there. Yes.

67. The Constitution of Medina Is Also Part of It

Now, next week, God willing, if we can do this paragraph, if Allah grants health and well-being, we will take this up at length, and this will probably be our last lesson, if we can finish with al-Ghazali.

I have drawn its main outlines.

With Allah's permission, I laid out its main outlines and actually made quite some progress on it, but I looked over an introduction a bit more again today. Then I need to expand this introduction a bit more, God willing. In fact, as an example, you know we have the famous Constitution of Medina (the Medina Charter), which is like the first constitution.

I have even put that into it. It will be a broad perspective.

If Allah permits, next week we will start earlier, and we will hardly finish this topic, but God willing we will try to finish it. Let's put it that way. Maybe it won't be finished in one more week either. Maybe it could even last two or 3 weeks. Forgive me in advance. However long it takes, let's now also look at these two questions, God willing.

68. Announcement: Program Exclusively for Women

After that, let's bring this evening to a close. Let me write "continued" here. So I don't mix it up. I hope it isn't boring. Yes.

On Sunday, September 6, that is, tomorrow, at 14:00, that is, at 2:00 in the afternoon, here at the foundation building there is a sohbet, sema and prayer exclusively for women. All our sisters are invited.

On the first Sunday of every month, the women hold a sema, prayer and sohbet program here among themselves. God willing, those who are available, those who can come, should make an effort to attend the program.

Especially our sisters should support these programs. So they should attend, God willing. There is a question.

69. Question: Did the Ottoman Sultans Pass Through the Stages (Maratib)?

Did the Ottoman sultans also pass through the stages (maratib)? Were there great saints among them?

There are some among them who are said to have been saints. So the Ottoman sultans were also people of Islam.

Some of them were Sufis. For those who were Sufis, yes, there are signs that they passed through the stages of the nafs in this way and that they were among the saints (awliya).

Allah knows best.

Note: This text is the speech itself as found in the recording of the sohbet: only spelling and punctuation have been edited, and obvious mishearings in the subtitles have been corrected; a few unintelligible places have been left as heard. Section headings have been added to make reading easier. The opening and closing prayers have not been included.


Bibliography

The verses, hadiths, works and persons mentioned in the sohbet are collected below. This lesson was devoted to al-Ghazali's understanding of logic and will continue next week with al-Mawardi and the Islamic understanding of the state.

Imam al-Ghazali, al-Mustasfa min 'Ilm al-Usul — A work on the principles of fiqh (usul al-fiqh); in the logical introduction in its preface, al-Ghazali says that knowledge of logic does not belong to fiqh alone but is a fundamental introduction for all the sciences, and he states in very harsh terms that one who does not use logic has no reliability.

Imam al-Ghazali, Mi'yar al-'Ilm (The Standard of Knowledge) and his corpus on logic — "Mi'yar" means measure; it is related to the touchstone (mihenk) — like jewelers striking gold on the touchstone to find its purity. For al-Ghazali, logic is a measure that separates correct thinking from wrong.

Imam al-Ghazali, Tahafut al-Falasifa (The Incoherence of the Philosophers) — Questions whether the conclusions reached by the philosophers are truly demonstrative (burhani); on nearly twenty issues it shows, again with the philosophers' own tools, that the answer is "no."

The Holy Qur'an — [Qur'an, al-Baqara 2:216 — verse text pending: Diyanet English translation] — The basis for the question "Correct according to what, wrong according to what?"; mentioned in the discussion of propositions.

The Holy Qur'an — Surah Ta-Ha: the staff of Moses (peace be upon him) — The question [Qur'an, Ta-Ha 20:17 — verse text pending: Diyanet English translation] and the answer of Moses (peace be upon him). The staff is beneficial in the right place and harmful in the wrong place; this example illustrates logic being a tool.

Hadith — "Show me the reality of things" — The supplication of the Prophet (peace be upon him); mentioned in the discussion that one who reaches the reality of things will not look at things merely outwardly (zahir).

Hadith — "Knowledge is the lost property of the Muslim, even if it be in China" — The proof that logic cannot be rejected on the grounds that "it came from the Greeks."

Hadith — "Seek treatment" — Mentioned in the answer given to those who consider medicine a bid'a (reprehensible innovation).

The incident of the Jewish doctors in Medina — The Messenger of Allah's assigning a salary from the public treasury (bayt al-mal) to the doctors who wanted to leave Medina al-Munawwara saying "there are no sick people here," and his saying, "Teach the science of medicine to the Companions here."

Aristotle, al-Farabi and Ibn Sina (Avicenna) — The source of the tools of definition, proposition, syllogism, demonstration (burhan), necessary conclusion and non-contradiction; they part ways with al-Ghazali as holders of the view that "logic equals reality itself."

al-Kindi and the tradition of the Tabi'un — Signs that Islamic thought was not devoid of logic even before al-Ghazali; al-Ghazali benefited from this accumulated heritage.

Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy — A free and globally trusted source to which approximately one thousand eight hundred referees have contributed; despite this, it has not been able to work its way through the answers al-Ghazali gave to the philosophers.

Hasan Aydın — Author of the critical assessment that "al-Ghazali, by limiting the metaphysical domain of philosophy, narrowed the field of inquiry in the long run."

İhsan Eliaçık — The view that "the prayer (namaz) is not worship"; discussed in the section on "definition" by comparing it with the fourteen-hundred-year-old understanding of Islam.

al-Mawardi and Prof. Dr. Ahmet Ocak — The assessment that "religion and state are inseparable twins" and its being regarded as the foundation of a political theory; announced as the topic of the next lesson.

Plato (Eflatun) and Saint Augustine — The roots of the religion-state relationship in Western philosophy: Plato makes it a condition that those who will govern the state receive religious education; Augustine regards the head of state as "the executor of God's commands."

The Constitution of Medina (Medina Charter) — A text with the character of the first constitution; included in the perspective of the next lesson.

Mustafa Özbağ Efendi, "Questions on al-Ghazali 12" — The full recording of the sohbet that is the source of this article; all of the topics above have been compiled from this talk.

Click here for more information about Imam al-Ghazali.

Additional resources: