1. This Week's Plan
In the last al-Ghazali sohbet (spiritual discourse), we talked about how he answered the philosophers, on which issues, and where he parted ways with them. This week, if we can get through it, we will both continue to explain that parting of ways with the philosophers, and also our Yunus said, "Why don't you go into al-Ghazali's logic a bit?"
Well, he didn't actually say "a bit", but I am going to go into al-Ghazali's logic a bit. Because it is a broad matter. It needs to be done as a separate lesson. When I dug around a little, things got stirred up, but still I tried to gather it together in its main outlines. Hopefully, inshallah, this evening, if we can bring these two together, we will bring them together.
If we can't bring them together, we'll leave it where we leave off. We'll continue next week. But I was saying that this would probably be wrapped up in a few weeks. Again, we probably won't be able to wrap it up in a few weeks. We've plunged into this, sort of haphazardly.
Normally, inshallah, we will come out of this, by Allah's leave. Inshallah we will compile it, we will put it in order. As a fine al-Ghazali study, inshallah, an orderly piece of work will remain for our friends and brothers and sisters. I mean, we weren't thinking of it this way at the start of the road, but with us the load always gets straightened out on the way.
We have a Yörük proverb. They say, "The load settles on the road." With us, too, everything settles on the road. Inshallah this will settle on the road too. Unless something comes from Allah, there is a short question. Let's give an answer to this at the start. Then, our brother asked why our Master the Prophet (sallallahu alayhi wa sallam) did not have the Noble Qur'an compiled into a book while he was alive. There were hafizes.
2. Question: Why Was the Qur'an Not Compiled into a Book While the Prophet Was Alive?
At that time the Islamic State did not possess very vast lands, but the Noble Qur'an was in fact written down.
I mean, because His Excellency the Prophet (sallallahu alayhi wa sallam) had the verses of the Qur'an written down. Which surah, which verses, in the hands of which Companion — this was known. That is why, when the Qur'an was compiled into a book, the written verses in the hands of those Companions were in fact gathered.
Thus it was made into a mushaf. But most importantly, there were hafizes. Because those hafizes constantly preserved the Noble Qur'an, because they memorized it, they were among the Companions. Of course, when we come to the time of Hazrat Abu Bakr, Umar and Uthman, well, the Islamic lands expanded.
And when they expanded, it was made into a mushaf and one mushaf each was sent to those places as a model. Thus that mushaf — in fact, even in those first fatwas, it is like this.
3. Taking a Mushaf to Dar al-Harb
Formerly it was forbidden to take the Noble Qur'an to a place that was dar al-harb.
I mean, if there was no Islamic law in a place, if there was no Islamic state there, a mushaf would not be taken to that region, to that town. That is, it was not appropriate to take the mushaf outside Islamic lands.
It was forbidden. In short — this is a separate topic, but let us have answered it briefly. Yes.
4. The Real Breaking Point: Causality
The real breaking point between al-Ghazali and the philosophers concerns causality. Causality — you know, whatever has become a cause; what we call the cause is the reason, I mean, first the cause, you know, its reason comes about?
The thing that comes first and produces the result. The cause? You know, a thing has something before it. And that produces the result. This is causality. And the result, what we call the effect, is the event or state that emerges after the cause.
I mean, there is a cause. Because of that cause, something results.
The clouds gather. This is the cause. Then rain falls. This is the result. Something like this. Of course, there is a very fine veil here where the philosophers and al-Ghazali part ways.
Inshallah, may the Almighty grant us, too, to explain that fine veil.
5. The Philosophers' Law of Causality
This principle of causality is something much discussed, settled and established among the philosophers.
I mean, under the same conditions, the same cause will always lead to the same result.
I mean, thunder, when the same causes come about, will lead to the same result; or snowfall — when the causes come about, snow will fall; or you plant a grain of wheat in the soil.
When the causes come about, wheat will come up. The philosophers put this forward like a law.
Al-Ghazali criticizes this. Of course, al-Ghazali's criticizing this — when you look at the sources, in this period described as the recent or modern period, al-Ghazali's opposing this causality is heavily criticized.
That's why they say that because al-Ghazali criticized this, science and knowledge came to a halt — they strike up that old refrain.
6. The Example of Fire and Cotton
Now, when we look at this, let me give an example: if we took a lighter from over there, and put a piece of cotton here, and brought the lighter close to the cotton — if we brought it close, would the cotton burn?
It burns, doesn't it?
Fire is a burning substance, or fire burns. Normally, when we see this, what do we say? We say the fire burned the cotton. Even if a thousand years pass, when fire comes close to cotton, it will burn.
Or if a spark went into a piece of cotton there, will that spark burn the cotton? It will. Or — we studied metalwork.
7. What We Learned at the Forge and the Lathe
In metalwork, of course, we light the forge bellows. We start forging the iron. They made us forge plenty of iron. You know, the iron is red, heated up like this, and the hammer strikes it.
Like sparks flying out. There is rust on it. That rust comes off as fire. It would land on us and burn — the fabric, for example, would get holes there. Or while working at the lathe or the milling machine, a small piece comes off the mill.
When that tiny piece lands on you, it burns. Because it is hot. I mean, when something comes near heat or fire, what does it do? It burns. So then the philosophers say that fire is the necessary cause of burning. I mean, there is fire. When fire touches something, it necessarily burns it. Now normally everyone believes this way, right? Al-Ghazali makes a distinction here. Because what drives al-Ghazali to make the distinction is the verse of the Qur'an concerning Ibrahim (peace be upon him). Here al-Ghazali says: you know, the fire burned the cotton, or, in astronomy, rain — minus and plus collided with each other and it became lightning. Or the weather conditions suddenly cooled at a certain point and it became rain. And if it cools further, what will happen? It will become snow. I mean, this is what he calls causality. But al-Ghazali says stop to this. He says not all of it is like this. What does he say there? Right before the verse, al-Ghazali says this.
8. «Fire Is the Necessary Cause of Burning»
The philosophers say that fire on its own possesses the power to burn necessarily, right? Al-Ghazali says: stop here.
He says fire does not necessarily burn everything. This is where he parts ways with the philosophers. Well, because in the Holy Qur'an there is the story of Ibrahim. In the story concerning Ibrahim (peace be upon him), the Almighty says in the verse: [Qur'an, al-Anbiya 21:69 — verse text pending: Diyanet English translation] he says.
9. The Verse That Drove al-Ghazali to This Distinction
Be cool and be safe. I mean, when it says "be cool," it would freeze.
"Be safe": don't freeze him either. Don't burn him, and don't freeze him either. I mean, because the point all the commentators reach and stop at from "safety" is this. That is, don't you freeze him. That is, I told you to be cool. Coolness has no limit, you see. But not to the point of freezing him either. He says "be safe." I'm not the one saying it. The safety here is this. Let the fire not trouble you at all.
There is a command to the fire. Because the Almighty commands the fire.
[Qur'an, al-Anbiya 21:69 — verse text pending: Diyanet English translation] That is, neither burn, nor trouble, nor scratch, nor let even a single hair be affected. Be safe. Let him be at ease there. Let nothing negative whatsoever befall Ibrahim. It is established by the verse.
10. Laws Have a Limit
So since that is the case, here al-Ghazali says "stop" to the causality that the philosophers set down like a law.
Yes. You can place this causal, cause-and-effect relationship upon the laws of the Almighty in the realm of existence, you know.
But these laws have a limit. How do they have a limit? You know, a person falls into water and sinks, but the Almighty commands the water and says "don't sink him."
He doesn't sink. Or the ship, you know, as we said last week in the story of Khidr (peace be upon him), in fact if it takes on water it sinks, but if a command comes to the water from the Almighty's divine knowledge, that water will not sink the ship.
This is something like that too. Now, this being so, this is the point where al-Ghazali parts ways with the philosophers on causality.
Allah knows best.
11. Saying «Al-Ghazali Killed Science» Is Crude-Mindedness
Well, if from this they then draw the conclusion that al-Ghazali killed science, then, I'm very sorry, but that would be crude-mindedness.
Because throughout history many miracles have been seen at the hands of the prophets. These miracles are miracles above reason. So to speak, they checkmate reason. When reason is checkmated, it is not possible to reject a place that reason does not accept, where it is checkmated.
Look, it is not possible to reject it.
But if we reject it, we will have rejected the verse of the Qur'an. This is the point where al-Ghazali parts ways. And so here one must be fully attentive.
12. There Is a Power Above the Fire
Because today the people we call modern science, scholarship, normally investigate experimentally why fire burns.
The point where al-Ghazali stops here, however, is very clear and plain, in Mustafa Özbağ's terms.
Because when we say the burning of fire is necessary metaphysically, that is, in terms of spiritual state, or within the circle of the Qur'an and Sunna, then a problem arises here.
That is, the burning of fire is not necessary. Because there is a power above the fire. There is the power of Allah. Well, normally, when we look at these normally, last week too, you know, we briefly mentioned a burhan (demonstration) of the Rifa'is. The fire burhan. Well, so it does not burn.
13. The Fire Burhan of the Rifa'is
That is, not every fire burns everything. Well, this being so, then, here al-Ghazali says to the philosophers, metaphysically, in terms of spiritual state: stop.
Don't you meddle with this side. The fire did not burn Ibrahim. And also think of the, in quotation marks, Sufis in al-Ghazali's time.
Fire burhans flying through the air. Sword burhans flying through the air. Skewer burhans flying through the air. Poisons that would poison, you know, a calf, a cow, or say 5, 10 cows, calves, people, flying through the air. People experience these as burhans. Of course, since these are above reason, now they are being rejected, you see.
14. Two and a Half Years' Sentence for the Skewer Burhan
You know, when it is rejected, or, I'm giving an example now, if a person performs a skewer burhan, there is a sentence of 2.5 years.
Whereas not even blood comes out of the man's side. Or you drive the skewer through his chest and not even blood comes out. Not even blood comes out.
If a tiny bit of blood comes out and beads up, stopping that bead is another burhan. That becomes a burhan upon a burhan. You know, where it bleeds, you pulled out the skewer and a little blood came out. When that little blood comes out, stopping that blood too is a separate burhan. Well, of course, these are now things that are unknown, you see.
This being so, this is above reason.
15. «I Have Personally Experienced These Burhans»
Now, have I, as Mustafa Özbağ, experienced these burhans myself? Yes. Now nobody can explain to me cause, reason, the cause-and-effect relationship.
The reason is that I experienced this personally, because, I mean, the fire does not burn.
However much you tell me scientifically that fire burns, I will say metaphysically that there is a power above the fire. When He tells it "don't burn," it doesn't burn. Or a person, think of an army, does one drown in water, I mean, does one go into the water or not.
16. Musa Crossed, Pharaoh Drowned
Musa walks over the water together with his people.
A path opens. We have believed in this.
But when Pharaoh enters the same path, the water drowns Pharaoh and his soldiers, yet it does not drown Musa and the believers. Now you may, in your own way, reject this, you know, this spiritual state or this metaphysics.
Does a person drown in water? He drowns. But he doesn't drown. Musa and his people also passed through the water. They walked on and went. None of them was left behind.
17. Noah's Flood: The Same Water, a Different Ruling
For example, Nuh and the believers were saved from that calamity, but his wife and child could not be saved.
The same water, the same disaster, the same flood, yet nothing touched Nuh.
But what was Nuh's prayer?
[Qur'an, Nuh 71:26 — verse text pending: Diyanet English translation] (Amin.)
Look, his wife is included in this. His son is included in this too. He even said to his son, "Come, believe. He said.
18. The Reasoning of Noah's Son
And his son said, "No, I will not believe." And he also knows that the flood will break out.
He said, "I'll flee to the summit of the mountain. I'll be saved from there."
Look, an interesting thing. Look, the reasoning here is different. This is what following reason is. We reject this reasoning. Nuh's son says: I'll climb to the summit of the mountain and be saved from there.
He puts forward this reasoning. Nuh says, "No, my son, come, believe. Board the ship. Board the ship of faith." He says, "No, no, I'll climb the hill." The Almighty says to Nuh: don't look behind you.
Of course, this time those waters swallow both his son and his wife. What is important here? To believe. But did the water swallow them? It swallowed them all.
19. To Those Who Say «The Qur'an Is a Book of Legends»
When we look at the floods, you know, normally, I beg your pardon, some Islamists who see themselves as, like, modern intellectuals say, you know, that the Qur'an is just a book of legends, and you fool, you are supposed to take a lesson from that legend.
Your heart isn't working. You have no reasoning of the heart. That is why you read it as a little legend.
It isn't. In that legend there are many wisdoms. It checkmates that tiny reason of yours right there.
20. Hud (peace be upon him) and the Wind
When we look at Hud (peace be upon him), at the destruction, the wind is normally in Hud's hand. Hud moves his hands toward that side.
That side is destroyed. The wind makes it, you know, ice-cold. It freezes that person. That person literally freezes, becomes like ice. Then it strikes them against a wall like this, you know, the way cells crumble, something like that. tap tap tap, they all crumble away like grains of sand, and this is normally beyond reason; and the person reading the Qur'an, metaphysically, as a spiritual state (hal), when he reads those verses in the Noble Qur'an, he doesn't live this before his eyes, does he, and since he doesn't live it, he tries to work out the destruction of the people of Hud (peace be upon him) in his time by his own reasoning, through the methods of reason.
No, my dear brother. There is something metaphysical here. There is a spiritual state. You are to be imbued with that state. You will see how the people of Hud (peace be upon him) were destroyed.
21. The Event of the Elephant: The Fire Carried by the Birds
Or else, now, what did he come to do?
He came to destroy the Ka'ba. He came with his elephants. Isn't that so? What did the Almighty do?
He sent down birds from the sky, and in those birds' beaks, as hot earth, normally that's how they interpret it, isn't it?
The Almighty sent down upon them such a destruction that, look, that tiny piece of fire in each bird's beak. The birds are carrying fire.
And such a fire that when it comes onto the elephant, it makes the elephant explode completely. Tiny, cell-like, like a cell. You can't put a name to it. You can't say it resembles this. I liken it to a cell, or something small like a tiny drop of water, and it annuls the elephant. It destroys it, tears the elephant to pieces. It literally tears the elephant to pieces.
This is something beyond reason. We believe in this. Look, that is why al-Ghazali says that here not every causality brings the same result.
22. Drawing a Limit to Causality Did Not Kill Science
From this, you will now say of al-Ghazali that he questioned causality. He drew a limit to causality, metaphysically.
And so science died. When you say it like that, this is not possible. Historically, too, this doesn't hold. Because, I mean, after al-Ghazali such scientists emerged among the Seljuks, among the Ottomans, that the Ottomans ruled over three continents.
After the Ottomans, no empire attained this state, and they advanced so far in knowledge, in science, in technology that if things had gone backward after al-Ghazali, there would have been no Ottomans either.
There would have been no Ottomans. So it is not possible for us to say such a thing, that after al-Ghazali, because al-Ghazali questioned causality, and so on.
I mean, to portray al-Ghazali's placing a reservation on causality, or al-Ghazali's understanding of causality, as if it were an obstacle to science is truly an ignorant thing.
23. What Should a Muslim Scientist Do?
Now, a Muslim scientist might think as follows for himself.
Allah has established various orders and systems in the realm of existence. Let scientists examine these orders, these systems, research them, and, as I always say, find their mathematics.
In all of these there is a mathematics.
But Islamic scientists do not research these mathematics. They don't research these mathematics and put forward a science. They, in their own way, I mean, try to submit it to reason. And when they try to submit it to reason in the European way, then they end up exceeding the bounds of the Qur'an.
Surah al-A'la, the second and third verses, 2 and 3.
24. Al-A'la 2-3: Measure, Order and Harmony
[Qur'an, al-A'la 87:2-3 — verse text pending: Diyanet English translation] Look, when you look at existence, when you look at created beings, the Almighty has placed a measure in everything, a measure in all actions, in all manifestations, He has placed an order, and He has given harmony to that order.
And all of existence is fulfilling its duty within that harmony, within that order.
Reason, I mean in this sense divine reason, divine power, might, strength is at work every moment.
Find the mathematics of that working power, might, reason. Solve it. If you are an Islamic scientist. Surah al-Mulk, third verse, 3.
25. Al-Mulk 3: «Turn Your Eyes and Take a Look»
[Qur'an, al-Mulk 67:3 — verse text pending: Diyanet English translation]
The Almighty here, so to speak, is boasting. So to speak, I'm going to use a very colloquial expression, you know.
He's showing off.
He says: come on, look, I created the seven heavens separately, layer upon layer, and I created them in harmony with one another. I created them within an order, and they are working in harmony. They fulfil their duties, their functions. Turn your eyes and take a look, He says. Turn your eyes and take a look. Look either with your normal outward eye, or look with the eye of the heart.
If you look with the eye of the heart, you will see farther. Because the Almighty said, didn't He, "I become his eye with which he sees." Then if you see with the eye of Allah, or by Allah's showing, then you reach the reality of the matter.
26. Can You Stop the Sun?
But no, if the eye of your heart is closed, you look with the normal eye.
Even if you look with the normal eye at the sky, look at the sun, look at the moon, look at the stars, ever since they came into existence they have been moving along within an order. They neither deviate by 1 cm, nor go 1 cm farther away, nor come 1 cm closer. Even if it goes farther away, you can't stop it.
Even if it comes closer, you can't stop it. You can't have any effect on it. Try to influence it as much as you like. You can't influence it.
Come on, stop the sun; you can't stop it. Come on, put a screen in front of the sun; you can't screen it. Come on, stop the stars from sliding; you can't stop them. Come on, the stars are fulfilling their functions within a harmony.
If you are only watching, if you have eyes. No. If you have no eyes you can't even watch, but if the eye of your heart is open, you see the reality of the matter. That is why, normally, Allah continues to run the realm of existence upon a mathematics. Upon mathematics. You go and solve its mathematics. Now, you can't stop the speed of light. Light travels at a certain speed. If you say, let's make that light go even faster, you can't speed it up. You can't slow it down either.
27. The Speed of Light, the Rotation of the Earth
It continues within this harmony. You can put a barrier in front of light. You think, in your own mind, that you've put up a barrier. No, you can't put a barrier in front of light either. It continues upon a harmony. You can't have any effect on the speed of the earth's rotation.
While the earth is turning so fast, you inside it don't get dizzy. You're not aware that you are turning. The Almighty (Allah) has established a harmony. The earth also revolves around the sun.
It also rotates around its own axis. And while rotating around its own axis, it rotates at a great speed. While it rotates at a great speed, you don't even feel it. Now, if you got into a car and drifted at great speed, you'd get dizzy.
Isn't that so? But it doesn't make you dizzy. Because He has completely encompassed existence with His power, His might, His knowledge, and created it upon a reckoning, upon an order. It continues in that. And normally, now, when drawing conclusions from causality, al-Ghazali put a reservation here.
28. The Grudge Behind This Thesis
And because he put a reservation, to say that after al-Ghazali knowledge came to an end.
By Allah, anyone who says all that, I, I mean, I truly don't even want to regard as a person of knowledge. Yes. I mean, there is a kind of intent here.
There is a grudge here. He is trying to take revenge. Whatever it is they're taking revenge for, those who say this, normally I would expect this from the people of unbelief, but I don't expect it from the people of Islam.
This is a bitter thing. So why is this thesis put in front of us? The thesis that al-Ghazali set the Islamic world back. What's the reason? I mean, why, what was it that al-Ghazali did? The strengthening of the madrasas. Is that what bothered them? That's what bothered them. The madrasas grew stronger.
29. So What Did al-Ghazali Do That Bothered You?
Well, normally, of course, after al-Ghazali the sphere of legitimacy of philosophy narrowed.
Before, the philosophers were all "hit it and let it burst, play and let it dance." I mean, where they would stop wasn't clear. But after al-Ghazali, al-Ghazali narrowed the circle of legitimacy of philosophy. He said: stop here at the border. Don't go beyond this, beyond metaphysical matters. You are trying to crush the Qur'an. Don't try to crush the Qur'an. Stay within the rulings of the Qur'an," he said. Well now, after al-Ghazali, kalam (Islamic theology) grew stronger.
And when kalam grew stronger, then understanding and logic changed in the Islamic world. So is that what bothered you? Well now, after al-Ghazali, Sunni Sufism (tasawwuf), Sunni Sufi practice, became established doctrinally in the Islamic world.
It became established doctrinally. It became established as knowledge. It became established as ethics. And normally its ethical rules became established. Its teaching became established. So now, is that what bothered you? Yes, that's what bothered you. Well, after al-Ghazali, the religious sciences entered the center of the education system.
Before al-Ghazali, the religious sciences were not at the center of the education system. But after al-Ghazali, the religious sciences became systematically established within education in the madrasa. And now, once it became established, normally, of course, those who are bothered by this say the following. After al-Ghazali, knowledge and science came to an end.
30. "We Abandoned al-Ghazali — What Did We Become?"
Fine, you, we abandoned al-Ghazali; look at our streets.
We abandoned al-Ghazali; look at the education system. We abandoned al-Ghazali; look at the universities. We abandoned al-Ghazali.
As if, after we abandoned al-Ghazali, our universities got into the top 100 in the world rankings? Did they get into the top 50? Did they get into the top 10? No. Well, we couldn't update al-Ghazali's education system and bring it to the present day.
Fine, I mean, we couldn't bring it. We even rejected it. We rejected it in connection with laicism. And when we rejected it, we closed down the Islamic sciences, the madrasas, the tekkes (Sufi lodges), all of them.
31. We Became a Consumer Society
What did we become? Our mothers used to hide their underwear.
They couldn't hang it on the line. Now people walk around outside in their underwear.
What have we become now? We became a consumer society.
What are we doing? We go to cafés. We drink coffee for 200 lira, 300 lira, 400 lira, 500 lira. Are we producing anything?
32. Fatih Was Nineteen Years Old
Is our 19-year-old child producing anything?
When Fatih (Mehmed the Conqueror) conquered Istanbul, he was 19 years old. He was 18 years old. Our 19-year-old children wander around in cafés. Now, when Fatih conquered Istanbul, he was 19 years old. The 19-year-old Fatih knew 8 or 9 languages. He knew 8 or 9 languages. He had, you know, the equivalent of a doctorate in 7 or 8 sciences.
He was ahead in chemistry, in physics, in mathematics. Those around him were also ahead in medicine. The science of medicine, you know. Come on.
33. A Tekke Sheikh Used to Hold Ijazas in Eight Sciences
The science of medicine; in the past, for a person to sit at the head of a madrasa, he needed to have an ijaza (license) in 8 branches of science.
In the past, a tekke sheikh needed to have an ijaza in eight branches of science.
The sheikh of the tekke, pay attention.
That tekke sheikh needed to have knowledge of mathematics, physics, chemistry, medicine, astronomy.
We abandoned it. Now, I include myself in this. Gather all the tekke sheikhs. Let's see, how many tekke sheikhs are there who possess 8 sciences?
Whoever gets up early in the morning becomes a sheikh. Someone who gathers 5 or 6 people, 10 people around him, they say, well, we've chosen you as sheikh. He becomes a sheikh.
34. Postnishins on the Ministry of Culture's Payroll
Or else the Ministry of Culture says to you, I've appointed you here as sheikh, I've appointed you as postnishin (head of the lodge).
And take a salary from the state, too. You know, a salaried employee of the Ministry of Culture. He became a postnishin, he became a sheikh. A salaried employee of the Ministry of Culture.
And on top of that, the Ministry of Culture's salaries aren't subject to 657. That man says, I'm a good postnishin, and it gives him 50 million a month, gives him 100 million. However much it gives. Because the Ministry of Culture's salary isn't tied to any such thing. He says, I'm an artist, I do ballet.
35. Swan Lake with My Taxes
Swan Lake, she walks on the tips of her toes and takes the money. Yes.
Or he says, I'm a theater person. He goes and brings some theater translated from Europe, straight from its mother's eye. It doesn't belong to our culture. Theater doesn't belong to anything of ours at all. He goes up on stage and does something. He takes a fortune, he takes it from my taxes.
As if I'm obliged to watch Swan Lake. With my taxes, who is he having watch Swan Lake? He's having a handful of a minority watch it.
What's that? Well, Mozart's creaking door. Creak-a-creak, creak-a-creak, creak, creak. From where? The Ministry of Culture. Who pays the money? It does. Oh, and they'll put on two shows a year.
Two creak-a-creaks. And they'll gather there like this. They don't want children. They don't want noise. Full attention, art is being performed there. Well, this is the point we've come to. Yes.
36. The Dilemma of Conservative Governments
Then the very people the Ministry of Culture pays salaries to march in protests against their own government.
Indeed, this is the greatest dilemma of so-called, in quotation marks, conservative governments. What is their dilemma?
On their way to power it's homeland, nation, Sakarya, religion, Qur'an, Sunna, and they come to power. After that, these men do somersaults to curry favour with the leftists, the secularists, the liberals, the libs, the homosexuals. I'm 65 years old. I've been watching this for 50 years.
At 10, I, at 14 I got to know the Idealist (Ülkücü) movement. At 13 I got to know the Idealist movement. I don't hide this. I'm still an Idealist. I don't deny that either. But this is what conservative right-wing governments have done throughout my history. Yes. It's an interesting thing. I mean, at election time it's prayer, ablution, fasting, Qur'an, Sunna, homeland, nation.
When the election is over, wherever there's a lib? Wherever there's a pseudo-intellectual type? Wherever there's a Dönmeh? Wherever there's someone of double gender? Wherever there are those who see themselves as libs, as liberals like this? Wherever there are those who see themselves as leftists, as this or that sort of Kemalist, odds and ends. They bring all of them to some positions. Yes. Like this. So what happened? Where did Turkey go? Or what has happened since the last period of the Ottomans?
37. «You Were Going to Build Missiles, and the Headscarf Stopped You?»
You know there's that famous saying, you know: you were going to build missiles, and was it women's headscarves that stopped you?
You know: you were going to build missiles, and was it the Muslims' beards, their baggy trousers, their robes that stopped you?
What did you do? You rejected al-Ghazali. You made al-Ghazali into nothing. You put limits on al-Ghazali. You put limits on Islamic knowledge and upbringing. Where did you get to?
Tell me the place you've got to. Did you invent a single thing and put it forward? No. Did you get ahead in mathematics? Did you get ahead in physics? Did you get ahead in chemistry? Did you get ahead in philosophy? Well, you went and translated Europe's philosophy into Turkish.
You brought it over. Just as you translated the laws and brought them over. Yes. Did you publish something? Something international. Oh, did they discover something? You did it. These are bitter things.
38. Being Applauded the More You Disparage the Old
Well now, of course, normally it's easy to make al-Ghazali out to be something nasty, or to say things against al-Ghazali.
Why? Well, al-Ghazali isn't around anyway, there's no one out there to answer you, is there. Throw it out, say whatever. And nobody says anything to you. Why? The more you disparage the old, the more they applaud you. Yes.
In our country there's a sickness like this. The more you disparage the old, the more you're applauded.
I said the old. The Ottomans are included in that. The more you disparage the Ottomans and what came before, the more you applaud. The more of a position you get. Well, of course, now al-Ghazali wrote such a work.
39. Becoming a Scholar Without Reading
He put forward the Ihya'. The Ihya' revives humanity. I'm saying it in quotation marks. How many people from this sort of Islamic segment have read the Ihya'?
We're scholars without reading anyway. I mean, that's why, you know, when we look at al-Ghazali: let's reject philosophy completely in al-Ghazali's way.
There's no such thing. Let's draw a limit to philosophy. Yes. Let's draw a limit to reason. Yes. This is there. Well, I mean, look at the Ihya'. Of course, meanwhile, I talk about the Ihya' a lot, don't I. Yes. Let it be a bit of a message, you know.
40. What Does the Ihya' Tell Us?
Well, look at the Ihya'. Moral, you'll see the moral layers, the dimensions of Islam.
You'll see the morality of Islam.
At the same time, above the moral dimension of the matter, you'll see a spiritual dimension. You'll see the diseases of the heart. You'll see the diseases, the afflictions of the eye. You'll see the afflictions of the ear. You'll see the afflictions of the tongue, of your hands, of your feet.
When you look at al-Ghazali, there's no "the prayer is performed only like this, ablution is performed like that." There's the heart side of the matter. Well, of course they'll be hostile to the Ihya'. Why?
There's the heart side of the matter. There's the metaphysical side of the matter. Then someone comes out. And this, my ears heard this. Supposedly the majority of the hadiths in al-Ghazali, pardon, I apologise, in the Ihya', are fabricated. I mean, al-Ghazali transmitted a hadith.
41. The Claim That «Most of the Hadiths in the Ihya' Are Fabricated»
I heard it with my own ears about the hadiths al-Ghazali transmitted in his Ihya'. He says they are fabricated. I mean, they may have no basis whatsoever.
He's throwing a doubt at you, you see. Even supposing, let's say, al-Ghazali took it even as a solitary report (khabar al-wahid).
How can you create doubt in a person's mind? It does create it. Actually, al-Ghazali's Ihya' really should be taught as a course in the, in the imam-hatip schools. Al-Ghazali's Ihya' should be taught as a course in the theology faculties.
42. The Ihya' Should Be Taught as a Course
Normally, the Ihya' should be taught as a course both in the imam-hatip schools and in the theology faculties. The Ihya' should be taught as a lesson in the mosques. Only then will you understand both the rational, the logical and the spiritual dimension of religion.
Otherwise, otherwise it stays superficial.
Otherwise it stays superficial. It becomes difficult for you to understand the reality of the prayer, the reality of fasting, the reality of zakat, the reality of the pilgrimage, and the metaphysical phenomena in this matter. May Allah forgive us.
43. Al-Ghazali's Time and Today
That being so, of course, al-Ghazali in his own time made Islamic society aware, conscious, and brought it to life with the Ihya'.
He made it throw off the deathly torpor lying over that Islamic society. Because in al-Ghazali's time, let's put it like this. Actually, it's no different from this time.
That's why I get a bit excited like this. It may seem as if I'm getting angry. It's not that, it's from my excitement.
In al-Ghazali's time too, there was knowledge but no practice. Now you look, a 15-year-old child is arguing hadith with you.
There's knowledge, but he doesn't pray. No practice. He doesn't fast. No practice. You look, people are very knowledgeable right now. Because, you know, there's this phenomenon we call social media, the internet; there's knowledge.
Wonderful. But there's no practice. But no prayer, but no fasting, but no zakat, but no pilgrimage. But no good character. There's knowledge, but go to the luxury cafés, there are debates about Islam. They even invited me to one.
44. A Debate on Islam in a Luxury Café
They said, in some such thing, he said to me, hey, if we invite you one day, if we come, I said, the coffee's expensive there, I said, I'm like this, they said.
Hocam, you know, we'll take care of the coffee. You know, who's going to tell these people too, they said. Fine, I said, are we going to pray there?
I mean, when we sit down, is there a place to pray?
He looked: do you pray? He was stuck. Well, I said, what am I going to do there when prayer time comes? That's right, isn't it. No.
45. There Is Knowledge, but No Sincerity
I mean, there's information, no practice; there's knowledge, no sincerity (ikhlas). He's describing al-Ghazali's time. There's knowledge, no sincerity. Now too there's knowledge, no sincerity.
He takes the bribe. There's knowledge, no sincerity. He passes whichever student he wants. Whoever he doesn't want, he doesn't pass. I mean, think of a student in a faculty of theology.
"We follow Mustafa Özbağ." If he says, "We follow such-and-such," he puts every kind of obstacle in his way. Come on, give the kid what he's due. There's knowledge, no sincerity.
46. The Professor Who Sells His Lecture Notes for Money
Can a professor of theology do this? He's selling his lecture notes for money. He's made a deal. With a place in Bursa, something like a bookshop, a student goes and buys the lecture notes there, for money.
Apparently the professor asks the questions he's going to ask from those notes.
I said, my dear child, is this definitely so? Yes, he said. I'm going to go now and buy them with money, he said. There's knowledge, no sincerity; there's fiqh (Islamic jurisprudence). There are plenty of chief fatwa-givers.
47. There Is Fiqh, but No Morality
They even give fatwas for interest.
At one point things got stirred up, remember? I mean, is TOKİ's interest interest or not? That was the debate. Isn't that so? There's fiqh. Oh, and what was the debate at one point?
Does so-and-so run a dergah (Sufi lodge) from the grave or not? There's fiqh, no morality. There's no system.
48. «The Dead Are Already Running Us Anyway»
Someone asks, while I was in i'tikaf, he said, hey, they're saying this about so-and-so.
I mean, they said he's apparently running the dergah from the grave.
And I said, hey, the dead are running the whole country. So what, I said, what would it matter if a dead man, I mean a sheikh, ran a dergah, a tariqa (Sufi order), too, I said.
He was stuck like that. How so, Hocam, he said. Well, I said, the dead are already running us anyway, I said. So what would it matter if, normally, a dead man ran a dergah?
49. The Companions Did Not Say This
I mean, Hazrat Abu Bakr, Umar, Uthman, Ali, the ten promised Paradise, the Companions did not say this.
They did not say, "The spirituality of His Excellency the Prophet, sallallahu alayhi wa sallam, will run us." They did not say there's no need for Abu Bakr. Before the funeral was even carried, Hz. Abu Bakr, our master, was chosen as caliph.
When he passed away, no one thought this. They did not say, "Hazrat Abu Bakr, His Excellency the Prophet, sallallahu alayhi wa sallam, and our master Abu Bakr are enough for us, brother, there's no need for anyone to run things." Hz. They chose our master Umar. Then Hazrat Uthman, then Hazrat Ali, then Hazrat Hasan, radiyallahu anh, may the intercession of all of them be upon us. Amin. They did not say, let a dead man run us.
Now the dead are running our dergahs. The dead are running our tekkes. The dead are running the country. The world, huge masses of humanity, are being run by the dead. Yes.
50. The Dead Run the Schools Too
The dead are running the schools.
A man wrote a thesis. He said man descended from the ape. He's the one running things.
Huge education systems are straining themselves over man having descended from the ape. A thesis, a plain old thesis. A man wrote a thesis, that's all. I mean, does it have proof? No. And they also say, reason, see, reason, fine, brother, but this has no proof. It has remained an unverified thesis.
No one asks, why are you teaching me this as knowledge?
We are communities descended from the ape. How do you mean? Plain and simple. Good thing we didn't descend from lizards. How, plain and simple: Allah turned some peoples into lizards. And some peoples He turned into apes. They lived three days. That's what we know. So apparently they didn't live just three days. So apparently their lineage continues. The man believes that. Look, this is a thesis. Why did you put a thesis in front of me as if it were real knowledge? You put it there. We put it there. Done. What happened? May Allah protect us. This is the state we've come to. And in al-Ghazali's time too there was religiosity. There was no training of the heart.
51. There Is Religiosity, but No Training of the Heart
Now too there's religiosity.
There are Imam Hatip schools, theology faculties, mosques, imams, muezzins, muftis, professors of theology, faculty members, associate professors, doctors, Imam Hatip schools. Those who graduate from these, those who learn religion from their mothers and fathers, we are a religious society.
But is there training of the heart? No. Is there training of the heart? No.
Does that religiosity stop him from taking bribes? No. Does it stop his unlawful earnings? No. Does it stop him from committing injustice? No. Does his prayer keep him away from the forbidden? No. Does it keep him away from someone else's due, from their rights? No. Does his being religious stop him from drinking alcohol?
No. Does it stop him from using drugs? No. On Friday he sends a message. "May your Friday be blessed." Does it stop him from using cocaine? No. Does it stop him from pocketing the property of the state, of the public? No. Religious, but no training of the heart. I always give examples, you know.
52. The Official Taking Bribes in Syria
In Syria we're going to cross the border gate. The man's shoulders are crowded, his chest is crowded, it's obvious. He's someone with rank there. There's an Arab in front of us there, begging.
I mean, he's going to get it stamped. He's going to enter Syria. He's asking for a bribe outright. The man gave the money in his hand.
He crumpled it up. There's a glass thing like this. He tossed it over that. He said, "Hurry up, sallu. I'm going to prayer," he said.
Prayer did not keep him from the bribe. Nuri was in front of me; Nuri, I said, this state is doomed to collapse.
This Syrian state, I said, is doomed to collapse.
53. Visiting Ahmad Kuftaro
People can't even talk.
They can't talk about something and criticise it. Everyone is afraid of each other. You can't criticise the system, you're afraid. You can't criticise the government, you're afraid. They can't criticise.
I had gone before too, in Ahmad Kuftaro's time. He was the Grand Mufti of Syria back then. That blessed man took us; inside the date orchards like this, he had a small house of his own like this.
He hosted us there. Even while hosting us there, he speaks in whispers. Lest we criticise the system. I asked him a question.
I said, "Tell me something clear about the Hama-Homs massacre," I said. He told me about the Homs massacre. He told me what happened."
54. The Hadith at the Centre of the Ihya'
Now, that being so, I mean, when we look at al-Ghazali's Ihya', my own view is that there is a religious and moral restoration right at the centre of it.
Because this hadith appears in al-'Ajluni, in Kashf al-Khafa'.
Al-Ghazali took this into his Ihya' as well. I mean, this hadith that al-'Ajluni transmits, al-Ghazali took it as a measure for himself and for his Ihya' as well.
People have perished. Except the scholars. The scholars too have perished. Except those who act upon their knowledge. Those who act have also perished. Except the people of sincerity. As for the people of sincerity, they too face a very great danger.
When we read this hadith, we all come under a veil of despair. That wind of despair sweeps over all of us. Well, al-Ghazali is thinking about this. Al-Ghazali acts with this in mind. So now come back towards the beginning.
55. The Claim That «He Prevented Philosophy from Being Included in Madrasa Curricula»
When we come back towards the beginning, I mean, we shared this in the text, you know.
They were saying, you know, that al-Ghazali's movement prevented philosophy, which also included the sciences, from being included in madrasa curricula.
It isn't so. I mean, to prove this, someone has to build it into a thesis historically and put it in front of us. Because the one saying this is a professor. Well then, turn it into a thesis.
Put before us, historically, what was where. If you don't bring this before us historically as a thesis, if you don't actually document it historically, if you don't document it, if you can't actually back it up with evidence for us historically, then what you're saying is left hanging in the air.
Because al-Ghazali put logic into the madrasas as a subject. Now, in a little while, if we have time left, we'll get into al-Ghazali's logic. Well now, when that's the case, I mean, this claim then doesn't hold up.
56. Al-Ghazali Put Logic into the Madrasa as a Subject
Because al-Ghazali, setting limits to logic, put it into the madrasas as a subject.
And the most interesting thing is that logic was taught in the madrasas throughout history. Mathematics was taught throughout history. Astronomy and medicine were taught throughout history, taught in the madrasas.
Look, you'll see astrology in Ibrahim Hakki Hazretleri. Look, you'll see astrology in Tillo, you'll see mathematics. Look at the old madrasas: in all of them, mathematics, astrology, medicine. You'll see this. Well then, here, this business of "he blocked science, he blocked knowledge."
Where did it go? After al-Ghazali, mathematics is taught in the madrasas, logic is taught, astrology is taught, physics is taught, chemistry is taught. So on what basis are you going to say that after al-Ghazali knowledge became like this? There's no way you can say it.
57. Madrasa, Waqf, State and the Ulama
Well now, the purpose for which the madrasas were founded is clear.
The system of the waqfs (pious endowments) is clear. The policies of the states are clear. The Seljuk and the Ottoman, and the structure of the ulama, are clear. Both among the Seljuks and among the Ottomans. Well now, when you look at these structures, there is a structure that works perfectly.
There's this kind of joint working together. And then madrasa, waqf, state policy and the structure of the ulama are locked into one another. Because this formed a strength against the Mongol invasions, against political fragmentation, against economic changes and against the various transformations in Europe, and when we look, among the Seljuks and the Ottomans it fulfilled this duty.
It carried out this duty. Well now, when that's the case, despite all that internal and external turmoil and confusion, this founding and order of the madrasas, well, the waqf system, the order and structure of the ulama, and at the same time these state policies carried the Seljuks and the Ottomans forward.
It also kept the people inside within an order.
58. One Body Against Three Fronts
Well, there was the Mongol invasion, there was political fragmentation, there were economic changes.
Meanwhile the West isn't sitting quietly either. There are the Crusades of the West. Now, when we look, there is a mass of people standing religiously, morally, with their hearts, against the Crusades of the West.
A nation. At the same time it became a political formation. Everyone became intertwined with their state, with their nation. Madrasa, state, ulama, waqfs, all of them intertwined.
Against the turmoil inside, against the Mongol invasion coming from the east, and against the Crusades coming from the west, there is a system of one body standing there in the middle.
59. Because We Cannot Build That System Today
Today, because we cannot form that one-body system, we cannot stand against the economic, cultural, political and military pressures of the West. Because there is no such single structure. Yes. We are left with no choice. Under the hegemony of the West, all our resources beneath our soil, above our soil — whether with interest, or with inflation, or with the IMF, or with who knows what — the West fleeces us.
Yes, it fleeces us. No country pays the interest that this country has paid.
Yes. It fleeces us. Its IMF has fleeced us too for years. They fleece us with interest. With the stock market. We keep transferring money abroad.
We've only now started to grow strong. Until yesterday, this huge country was standing at Israel's door. Pardon the expression, not even at its door, it was standing at its tail. Big, important chiefs of the General Staff used to go to the Wailing Wall. They would weep there. We were like Israel's servants and slaves, plain and simple.
We still can't give Israel a full rejection. We don't know what's right and wrong. Goods, products, fuel, ships are still coming and going. May Allah forgive us.
60. The Chain of al-Mawardi — Nizam al-Mulk — al-Ghazali
That's why that system which al-Ghazali formed, which Nizam al-Mulk, al-Mawardi, al-Ghazali formed in a chain one after another, did its job historically.
61. Ibn Rushd: «He Won Intellectually, Lost Politically»
Well now, let's go back once more to the matter of Ibn Rushd (Averroes).
The other day a brother had shared something related to Ibn Rushd. Now, there was the sentence in the passage, you know, "Ibn Rushd won intellectually, lost politically." Well, let's look at that a bit. Well, when we examine it a little, what happens? Now, Ibn Rushd's Aristotelian philosophy, I mean, it's nothing other than being an Aristotelian philosopher.
All right, it found an extraordinary response in Latin Europe. Europe applauded Ibn Rushd. Our people at home applauded Ibn Rushd too.
They considered Ibn Rushd superior to al-Ghazali and strove to present him as superior. He gained an extraordinary influence in Europe. In the Islamic world, the kalam, the fiqh and the Sufism that al-Ghazali established became more lasting, more institutional.
Well, then, when this is more institutional, more lasting, why shouldn't it be defended?
62. Wherever an Idea Lives, That Is Its Living Space
Because it is not a question of a philosopher winning or losing because of his ideas.
Which thought, which institutions lived within which country? That place became its living space. Well, al-Ghazali found his living space among the Seljuks and the Ottomans.
And people embraced this. But Ibn Rushd was embraced in Europe.
Is Europe so much superior to us? Do their minds work so much better? Well, of course, when we come here, Nizam al-Mulk immediately comes before us. Because at the starting point of the matter there are al-Mawardi and Nizam al-Mulk. Well, now when we come to this point with al-Ghazali, well, you go back to Nizam al-Mulk again, this time going backwards.
63. The Chain of the Nizamiyya Madrasas
Because there is an idea, and there is also an institution.
Well, the idea develops from Nizam al-Mulk, in al-Mawardi and Nizam al-Mulk. It reaches its perfection in al-Ghazali. Well, if it had not been institutionalised, then this idea would be left out in the open.
No one would be left to take ownership of it. Nizam al-Mulk founds the Nizamiyya madrasas.
He strengthens the chain of madrasa, mudarris — in the old language, I mean today's professor — student, ulama and qadi. This, again, this chain: there are madrasas. In the madrasa there are teachers, professors. There are mudarrises. There are the students they train, and the body of ulama those students in turn train. And there are the legal qadis who emerge from among those ulama. This is a powerful synchronisation. Well now, al-Ghazali puts kalam into this structure. He puts fiqh into this structure.
64. What Did al-Ghazali Put into This Structure?
He puts logic into this structure. He puts Sufism (tasawwuf) into this structure. He puts ethics into this structure.
This structure becomes so strong that after al-Ghazali — can you imagine? Madrasa, mudarris, student, then ulama, qadi, and at the same time kalam, fiqh, logic, Sufism, ethics — a great intellectual system takes shape. Now, against Ibn Rushd (Averroes), would this system be defeated?
It would not be defeated. And if you also bring the state into the matter, a tremendous fortress takes shape.
Well now, it becomes institutionalised in the end. Well now, once it is institutionalised, al-Ghazali's historical power comes out into the open.
This is historical power. Whether you accept it or not. Before this historical power you are obliged to bow your head. Well then, let us sum the matter up. In a moment we will get into logic. Because if we have time left, when we look — you know, last week we separated four judgements from one another. What were they? Philosophical: al-Ghazali did not know philosophy at all.
65. Let Us Separate the Four Judgements
No, that was known wrongly.
Al-Ghazali was against reason and science. No. An excessive generalisation. There is a kind of grudge in this matter. There is hatred and loathing in it. Historically this is not possible. Well, normally, come and put it before us historically, prove it. Then we will accept it too. Well, normally, yes, al-Ghazali drew a boundary for philosophy in the Islamic world, especially in metaphysics.
Yes. He drew a boundary in a serious way. He did not let it breathe. So to speak. He said, "Do not get into matters that are beyond your limits. So to speak, this. Insolently, he said, do not poke your nose into everything. Stay where you have been stopped," he said. He stopped it where it stood. Yes.
Al-Ghazali formed a powerful Sunni synthesis of kalam, fiqh, logic and Sufism. Yes. Al-Ghazali formed a very powerful synthesis. Sufism is in it too. Within it there is logic, there is fiqh, there is kalam, there is ethics, there is training of the heart within it. Yes. He formed a magnificent synthesis. Pay attention, I am underlining this. He formed a Sunni synthesis. Far from the Batiniyya, far from the Jabriyya, far from the Qadariyya, far from the Ismailis, far from the Fatimids, far from deviations — he formed a powerful Sunni synthesis. Yes. And of course at this point al-Ghazali became very influential in Islamic thought after him. Yes, that is right. He became very influential.
66. Were They Able to Break His Influence?
Well, did al-Ghazali's influence become completely effective after him — in the madrasas, among the ulama, in the system of judgeship, in the waqfs, and in the education system?
Yes, it did.
Were they able to break this influence? Yes, they could not break it. Yes. That is why we cannot say here that al-Ghazali himself blocked the way of scientific thought.
I mean, perhaps I would separate this, you see.
67. Al-Ghazali and the Ghazalians Are Different Things
Al-Ghazali and the Ghazalian tradition or the Ghazalians, Ibn Arabi or the Akbarians, Rumi or, you know, the followers of Rumi — I distinguish these, you see, like this; or the same thing applies in fiqh too.
I mean, Imam Abu Hanifa (Imam-i A'zam) and the followers of Imam Abu Hanifa — these are different things.
I mean, let us look at what the person himself said, not at those who said things later.
Perhaps at this point the Ghazalians may have interpreted his system of thought by narrowing it. But al-Ghazali bears no blame in this. That one failed to understand, narrowed it. He said, "I am a Ghazalian." May Allah forgive me. As I say, but he may have narrowed it.
And this is always the case. There is a difference between al-Ghazali and the Ghazalians who formed years later. But when we go to the centre, I mean when we examine the works al-Ghazali wrote in his own time, you find that he is different from some of the Ghazalians.
68. «It May Be Like This After Me Too»
The same thing will apply to us as well.
I am not such a very important person. After us, perhaps something like that will form concerning me as well.
Does this danger exist for everyone? It does. Yes.
I would want people after me to speak of more advanced things. Yes. Let them speak more deeply. Let them speak more advanced things.
69. The Real Mistake: «Al-Ghazali Was Against Logic»
Well, normally — Nizam al-Mulk, the Nizamiyya, al-Ghazali, Ibn Rushd, Ibn Khaldun — in my view the most important point at which these philosophy and madrasa debates stand is that they defend the thesis that al-Ghazali was against logic.
This is very wrong. Al-Ghazali is not, er, against logic, not its enemy.
He is someone who drew a circle around logic, drew a framework, and used logic. I mean, even if at first glance there seems to be a contradiction — I mean, when we look at the Tahafut al-Falasifa (The Incoherence of the Philosophers), he is someone who, you know, says to logic "stop here", says to philosophy, to the philosophers, "stop here, do not go any further."
Because why? I mean, at the metaphysical point you are left stranded.
I mean, as Hazrat Rumi (Mawlana Jalal al-Din Rumi) said, I mean, when reason comes to metaphysics it flounders like a donkey stuck in the mud. Metaphysics is that kind of thing.
70. To Oppose Something, One Must First Know It Well
Well now, then, if al-Ghazali were against philosophy, why would he use logic?
Why would he put logic into the lessons? Well now, when we look at it that way, then al-Ghazali has no such struggle against logic, against philosophy.
There is only finding its mistakes and setting them out.
I mean, let someone find my mistake and set it out. I would be glad of that. Well, al-Ghazali too is someone who identified the mistakes of those philosophers and laid them out in the open. Well, to be able to identify a mistake, he has to examine it well, research it well, and have a sound opinion about it.
Well, if he does not examine it well, if he does not have a sound opinion, on what basis did you oppose it?
You opposed it off the top of your head. You lumped everything together. I mean, as in our country, declare war on all Sufis. Declare war on all the religious communities. They are all rubbish. Well, did you come and examine us? No. What did you do? You put all of them in the same basket and rejected them. Well, this is something like that. May Allah forgive us. That is why: "al-Ghazali, you see, killed philosophy, rejected reason."
No. "Al-Ghazali was a completely rationalist philosopher." This too, no. Both of them, no. Well, that being so, the turn comes to al-Ghazali's logic. Now Yunus said, "Well, father," he said, "normally we talked about, you know, Ibn Arabi's logic. Well, are we going to pass without talking about al-Ghazali's logic?" he said.
71. Al-Ghazali Did Not Watch Logic from Outside and Reject It
Well, I said, fine, we will go into al-Ghazali's logic a little too, I said. If Allah permits, I said, insha'Allah. It is 10:30 now.
I will not keep you any longer. And also, we need to do a lesson like this on al-Ghazali's logic, at least so that there is no break in the subject. Let us make an introduction like this.
Al-Ghazali is not someone who watched logic from the outside and, after this watching, rejected it.
You know, you watch something from the outside, then you reject it. You know how they come here and watch the sema and then reject it, or they watch the sema, say, on social media and reject it. Right away he starts. "There is no such thing in Islam." Well, the other day I shared a clip of dhikr.
The man wrote underneath it. "There is no such thing in Islam." Now there is no need to argue with the man. "There is no such thing." You know, you would say, what knowledge do you have, what are you?
Have you read any verse or hadith related to dhikr? A hadith related to dhikr, tell me five hadiths. None. Tell me five verses. None. Do you have any research on this subject? None. Is there anything you have read on this subject? None. On what basis did you reject it? From the "İşkembe-i Kübra", out of thin air, from his own gut. Not from anywhere else. Ignorant. plain and simple. Ignorant. Plain and simple. Ignorant. This is something like that too.
72. He Has Five Books on Logic
Al-Ghazali, the man who is normally said to have no connection, no relation to logic, has five books related to logic.
Look, to study al-Ghazali's logic, there are five books of al-Ghazali's related to logic.
Bring me a scholar, bring me one of the 'ulama, bring me a professor. Let him have five books related to logic. Yes. First, Mi'yar al-'Ilm fi Fann al-Mantiq. 2. Mihakk al-Nazar. 3. Al-Mustasfa 4. Maqasid al-Falasifa, and also al-Qistas al-Mustaqim. Just think of a scholar.
You say al-Ghazali is an enemy of logic. You say he rejected logic completely. Al-Ghazali has five books related to logic. When I researched, I saw that there were five books.
I knew of three. Let me speak openly. I knew of three. Al-Ghazali has five books related to logic. In fact, al-Mustasfa has an introduction.
73. The Introduction of al-Mustasfa
You would say, oh, until today I had never defined reason and logic at all.
I swear, today's professors cannot unravel that introduction. Yes, and this, I am, you know, by myself during the week, like this, always dealing with this, you see. I also apologize to all the brothers and sisters. I mean, there are those I could not reply to, because truly I apologize very much to all of them. May they forgive me their rights. I mean, when I looked, you know, sometimes, like, the shutters were closed, there were people who turned back from the door and so on, they wrote, they wrote to me. I could not look at the great majority of things, of messages; well, I stopped and said to myself, Mustafa Özbağ, in your own way you say "I am a Ghazalian." You have no idea of two of his books. I was ashamed of myself, and, I mean, I was astonished that these professors say al-Ghazali rejected logic, regarding his logic. That is why I made an introduction like this. Now, five books related to logic by this noble person, this noble person. Yes. The more I studied al-Ghazali, the more my admiration grew. For al-Ghazali. Yes.
This noble person has five books. On logic. only. And when you look at that, you know, logic introduction of al-Mustasfa, do you know what a muqaddima is?
A foreword. I just stopped, stood there like that. And then I asked myself this question. I said, did these professors not see these? Did they not research? An ignorant, unlearned man like me finds these when he researches. I was almost going to say I can barely read and write. After a sohbet like this someone, may Allah forgive me, this is not to boast.
74. «I Am a Primary School Graduate»
"Hocam, which university did you graduate from?" he said.
I am a primary school graduate, I said. "Impossible," he said. Now, come on, I said, let me not mess with his mind too much now, I said to myself.
I said, I am a vocational high school dropout, he said. "Impossible," he said. "You must be," he said, "covering yourself up."
No, I said, my only covering is trousers and a shirt, I go around like this, I said. Now when people research, you know, when they bend over it a little, they find some things on it.
I wondered, I said, these professors must surely have researched. And besides, you have all those slaves of yours under your hands. Students.
75. «You Have All Those Students Under Your Hands»
At university, students are in the position of slaves to the professors, the faculty members, in Turkey. Yes. You research this. You research this.
You research this. You research this. You research this. Done. This is your thesis for passing the class. Research it and bring it. This is your thesis for passing the class. Research it and bring it.
I look, there are lots of theses. You know, I research, there are theses. To tell the truth, I also, you know, take quotations from the Encyclopedia of Islam regarding the individuals while researching, the one published by the Diyanet. Well, now you find it, so how do you say about al-Ghazali that he rejected logic?
May Allah forgive us.
76. Mi'yar al-'Ilm Should Be Taught in All Universities
I mean, especially Mi 'Ilm, Mi'yar al-'Ilm, I mean, I looked at it a little, really it should be accepted as one of the foundational works in the field of logic and taught in universities.
Yes. It should be taught not in the faculties of theology but in all universities. In all branches, this may be quite a big claim.
Really, in all branches of the university, physics, chemistry, mathematics, medicine, then computers, software, in all branches, yes, Mi'yar al-'Ilm should be taught.
It should be taught so that people know how to use their logic, and know what is what. A civil engineer needs to read it, my daughter. You should have studied it at university, I mean. Computer people, software people need to read it. Really, medical people need to read it. Just like that, take the scalpel and cut a vein there.
Your job is done. It is not like that. Yes. Look, this is a tremendous thing, this.
77. Ibn Sina, Ibn Hazm and Ibn Rushd Should Also Be Known
Normally, people should also know the logical tradition of Ibn Sina (Avicenna).
They should know Ibn Hazm too. They should know Ibn Rushd (Averroes) too. Someone studying at a university should also know their logic.
They should also know their philosophies, in order to compare.
78. Striking the Philosophers with the Philosophers' Own Weapon
Well, now, when we look at al-Ghazali, he learned the thoughts, the logic, the analyses of those philosophers, those thinkers, seriously, and he never made his criticisms ignorantly; he criticized by setting forth his evidence, his proofs.
Of course, earlier we had passed over this superficially. That is how it is, I mean.
In this sense al-Ghazali used the philosophers' weapon against the philosophers. I mean, he struck both al-Farabi and Ibn Sina with their own weapon.
We will continue next week. If nothing comes from Allah, if my Lord grants health and well-being. We will make a sort of introduction towards al-Ghazali's logic a little, insha'Allah. If we have made a slip of the tongue, may it be forgiven. That is why, for next week, the sohbet a bit more, like this, I have set out its main lines here a little. After that it will probably seem to go a bit heavier, but with Allah's permission we will manage this too. My Lord will make us bring it together, insha'Allah. (Amin.) May Allah open our insight. Amin. May He open your insight to understand too, insha'Allah. (Amin.) May He open our insight to explain, too. (Amin.) May the Almighty, insha'Allah, let us understand what we read and research and come before you like this and explain it correctly. Amin. Again, if we have made a slip of the tongue, if we have had any shortcoming or mistake, I apologize to everyone. There is no claim in these matters.
79. I Make No Claim
I make no claim in such a matter. Let me add this at the end as well. This is the result of my own research, done as best I could, with whatever help came to hand. I may have made mistakes. I may have acted emotionally. Where, you know, would my acting emotionally come from?
Because I am a typical Ghazalian, at the end of every lesson this, but I forget to say it, but I do not forget. That is why I want to state this in particular.
I am open to criticism on this matter as well. To criticisms that will come from outside, that will come from inside, "We found such-and-such a mistake here." If they say, "This part was not like this," I will examine it once more and strive to bring the most correct version before you. Well, my concern is not to show off, not to utter ecstatic boasts (shatahat).
Like this, in my own way, may Allah forgive me, it is not to be arrogant, not to boast. My concern is to convey what is right. To convey what I have understood correctly. I have no other concern. Please forgive me any rights I owe you, insha'Allah. May it be halal. Sir, to you. Yes.
80. Last Question: What Does "The People of Sincerity Are Also in Danger" Mean?
At the end you said that the sincere are also in danger. I understood that about the scholars who do not worship, those who do not worship with sincerity, but those who are sincere are in danger?
Could you open that up a little for us?
That is a long matter. All right. Forgive me any right I owe you. Not at all (Estaghfirullah). My time is up. I was going to finish today's sohbet at 10:30. It is 10:38 now. Forgive me. I mean, so that I do not leave your question as if unanswered. It is like this: the sincere are also in danger.
That person will continue to live rightly by calling himself to account at every moment.
I mean, he will not say "I am sincere" and fall into heedlessness. May Allah protect us. (Amin.)
Everyone will put himself in order on this point. It is related to that.
Note: This text is the actual speech from the recording of the sohbet: only spelling and punctuation have been edited, and obvious mishearings in the subtitles have been corrected; a few unintelligible passages have been left as heard. Section headings have been added for ease of reading. The opening and closing prayers have not been included.
Bibliography
The verses, hadiths and works mentioned in the sohbet are gathered below. In this sohbet the speaker grounded the question of causality in verses and hadiths, and answered the thesis that "al-Ghazali stopped science" with historical evidence.
The Holy Qur'an, al-Anbiya 21/69 — [Qur'an, al-Anbiya 21:69 — verse text pending: Diyanet English translation] The verse at the centre of the discussion of causality; the meaning of the command not stopping at "be cool" but adding "and safe" is treated in particular.
The Holy Qur'an, al-A'la 87/2-3 — [Qur'an, al-A'la 87:2-3 — verse text pending: Diyanet English translation] Measure and order in the realm of existence — the basis of the call to "find its mathematics."
The Holy Qur'an, al-Mulk 67/3 — [Qur'an, al-Mulk 67:3 — verse text pending: Diyanet English translation] Proof of the harmony in the universe.
The Holy Qur'an — Moses and the parting of the sea — Moses and his people crossing and Pharaoh and his soldiers drowning; the same water carrying two different rulings is given as an example of the limit of causality.
The Holy Qur'an — Noah and the Flood — The salvation of Noah (peace be upon him) and the destruction of his wife and son; his son following reason by saying "I will climb to the top of the mountain" and rejecting the invitation to "board the ship of faith."
The Holy Qur'an — Hud and the wind — The destruction of the people of 'Ad by the wind; mentioned as a state above reason.
The Holy Qur'an, Surah al-Fil — The destruction of the army of the elephant by the stones carried by the Ababil birds; an example of events "above reason."
Hadith Qudsi — "I become the eye with which he sees" — Mentioned in the discussion of looking with the eye of the heart; it is explained that seeing through Allah's showing leads to the truth.
Hadith — al-'Ajluni, Kashf al-Khafa' (also transmitted by al-Ghazali in his Ihya') — "People have perished, except the scholars; and the scholars have perished, except those who act upon their knowledge; and those who act have perished, except the people of sincerity; and the people of sincerity are faced with a very great danger." Also the source of the sohbet's closing question.
Imam al-Ghazali, Tahafut al-Falasifa (The Incoherence of the Philosophers) — The main text of the critique directed at the philosophers; the source of the boundary drawn for logic and philosophy.
Imam al-Ghazali, Ihya' 'Ulum al-Din (The Revival of the Religious Sciences) — Assessed as a religious and moral restoration; the afflictions of the tongue, the eye, the ear, the hand and the foot, and the diseases of the heart are described here. It is recommended that it be taught as a course in Imam Hatip schools, theology faculties and mosques.
Imam al-Ghazali, Mi'yar al-'Ilm fi Fann al-Mantiq (The Standard of Knowledge in the Art of Logic) — The first of al-Ghazali's five works on logic; it is said that it should be taught not only in theology faculties but in all universities.
Imam al-Ghazali, Mihakk al-Nazar — The second work on logic.
Imam al-Ghazali, al-Mustasfa min 'Ilm al-Usul — A work on the principles of fiqh (usul al-fiqh); the logical introduction at its beginning is mentioned in particular — "today's professors cannot unravel that introduction."
Imam al-Ghazali, Maqasid al-Falasifa — The work in which the views of the philosophers are set out; the stage of learning before criticism.
Imam al-Ghazali, al-Qistas al-Mustaqim — The fifth work on logic.
al-Mawardi and Nizam al-Mulk — The starting point of the idea and the institution; the establishment of the Nizamiyya madrasas and the chain of madrasa, teacher (mudarris), student, ulema and qadi.
Ibn Rushd (Averroes) and the Aristotelian tradition — Analysis of the passage "The intellectual won, the political lost"; a comparison of the reception it found in Europe with the institutionalisation in the Islamic world.
Ibrahim Hakki Hazretleri (of Erzurum) and the Tillo tradition — Mentioned as proof that astronomy and mathematics were taught in the madrasas.
Mustafa Özbağ Efendi, "Questions on al-Ghazali 11" — The full recording of the sohbet that is the source of this text; all the topics above have been compiled from this sohbet.
Click here for more information about Imam al-Ghazali.
Additional resources: