1. The Purpose of This Talk: A Foundation for Future Generations
Last week, as you know, about al-Ghazali, I said let me open this subject up a little more, and I also said let me extend it a little more.
It's related to al-Ghazali. That's why I'm going to open it up and extend it a little more. I thank you in advance for your patience. Perhaps the sohbet (spiritual discourse) is getting a bit technical, but this, you know, will also form a groundwork for future generations, or for those who will now study this subject, who will do research on it.
It will form one.
I'm not making any grand claim. By examining, by looking through the works, the books I have at hand, a study like this comes out, let's say something like an article. It's getting a bit long, but God willing the brothers, the friends, future generations will, God willing, benefit from it. Now tonight, God willing, it's something like a recap again.
Did al-Ghazali reject philosophy in its entirety?
2. A Confession: Where Does My Ghazalianism Come From?
You know, regarding al-Ghazali: when I had newly come to Islam, when I was still around 26 or 27, there was an Ihya' storm back then. Everybody was reading the Ihya'.
Some people had the works of Mawdudi. With others, the works of the Muslim Brothers, that is, the Ikhwan al-Muslimin, were circulating around.
It's an interesting thing, in my youth, I mean, on one side the Ihya', al-Ghazali, and on the other side, at that time, Mawdudi. There was that Egyptian, the Qur'an commentator, Sayyid Qutb. Something formed as if we were at opposite poles like that. My Ghazalian stance, its foundation was laid back in those times.
I'm a typical Ghazalian. That's how it can be described. And then, but back then in our youth, the topics we debated, especially in Ödemiş, I mean, I apologise very much, I'm going to speak about some things openly like this. These were normally the things we used to spar and argue about back then with the former Welfare Party people, I mean, the Milli Görüş (National Outlook) people; they would read Sayyid Qutb and then Mawdudi and argue on that basis.
And I, back then, with the Ihya', I was even teaching lessons from the Ihya' in those days. In Ödemiş I was teaching lessons from the Ihya' to the friends. With the Ihya', as if they were clashing with it, I'd explain these things openly like that. So now, normally, our, my foundation in al-Ghazali goes back to that time; or, for example, they don't accept al-Ghunya li-Talibi Tariq al-Haqq of Hazrat Abd al-Qadir al-Jilani, for instance.
Back then we were reading al-Ghunya. Normally, Hazrat al-Jilani has his, you know, his manaqib (accounts of his virtues). We'd read those and so on. So this Ghazalianism in me has its foundation from that time. I mean, my age was still only 28, 29. The al-Ghazali research and debates date from that time. Now sometimes the friends must be wondering, you know, "where did this come from?" Well, of course, when a whole series of questions about al-Ghazali came in like this, our Ghazalianism flared up again.
3. Wholesale Judgement: The Danger of Rejecting Something in Its Entirety
My al-Ghazali... these people who came later, who see themselves, in their own way, as Islamic intellectuals, and this has its roots in Europe too: "Al-Ghazali rejected philosophy completely and accused the philosophers of unbelief."
"He issued the fatwa of unbelief." That's what they say, but it's not like that at all.
Did al-Ghazali reject philosophy in its entirety? No. This is normally a very oversimplifying take on al-Ghazali. If you reject something, if you reject the entirety of something, you will be mistaken.
For example, a person. If you reject a person in their entirety, you will be mistaken. That person has good sides. Then you will have rejected their good sides as well. Or if you reject a community entirely, you will have rejected that community's good sides as well.
This point is dangerous. This wholesale approach does not exist on the Islamic intellectual plane. This falls into wholesale judgement. If you reject a group completely, I mean, truly you will have rejected its good sides as well. That's why, I mean, normally, actually, when we look at al-Ghazali's Tahafut, in the Tahafut it is not said that the whole of philosophy is wrong. I mean, I've had the Tahafut, by God, for roughly more than 20 years. It's even longer, I'm just saying that so as not to exaggerate. I mean, normally from '92, '93 onwards, '92, it must be '92.
4. What Is Needed to Read the Tahafut?
I've had the Tahafut since '92 now, but to read the Tahafut you need to have good knowledge of creed ('aqa'id).
You need good knowledge of the Qur'an and Sunna so that, while studying the Tahafut, you understand the answers al-Ghazali gives. I mean, normally, in the Tahafut al-Ghazali divides philosophy into sections, and when he divides it into sections, you see his different criticisms in different areas when you read the Tahafut.
And, for example, when you read al-Ghazali's Tahafut, you understand this. For example, he doesn't reject mathematics.
It's impossible to reject mathematics anyway. Or, normally, he doesn't reject logic. For example, come on, it's not possible for someone to reject logic.
5. "Al-Ghazali Criticised the Philosophers" — That Is the Most Accurate Expression
So since that's the case, then saying "al-Ghazali criticised the philosophers" is the most sensible explanation of this.
This is perfectly normal. I mean, a person can sit down, identify the philosophers' mistaken points and criticise them.
This criticising, there's no problem in it. This is a scholarly thing.
In a scholarly way, you have doubts about something. You look into the doubt. And when you look into the doubt, you establish its logic, its basis, and you can give a counter-answer. And if your counter-answer is consistent: if it's religious, it has to be consistent religiously, within the bounds of the Qur'an and Sunna. If it's fiqh, it has to be consistent within the bounds of fiqh. If it's creed, at the level of creed; if kalam, at the level of kalam; if hadith, at the level of hadith; if tafsir, at the level of tafsir, you will have a consistent justification. You put it forward in a scholarly way. That's why, you know, normally, when we say he criticised the philosophers, this is correct. Yes, he criticised the philosophers, but I criticise the philosophers too. Now, I criticise the philosophers on some points, say. Normally, now, nobody would say Mustafa Özbağ criticised them completely, would they?
No, I mean, if there are aspects to be criticised, we have to criticise them within the bounds of the Qur'an and Sunna. We have to say, in fact, this point is contrary to the Qur'an and Sunna. This point is contrary to this verse. This point is contrary to this hadith.
We have to say this point is contrary in terms of creed.
6. A Thesis That Went Uncriticised: "We Came from Apes"
If we don't criticise, and it wasn't criticised, they told these children, these young people, all of us, people, that we came from apes.
It wasn't even criticised. Come on, this is a thesis; this isn't something proven.
How can you teach something unproven as a school subject to children, to children? But in this country it was taught, and we told the children of this country, the Muslim children, that they came from apes. There are still those who say it. There are one or two Masonic scholars in the Islamic world, 2 or 3, who say this is possible. Look, they don't say it is so.
"Such a thing could be." "Humans too, well, normally, might have come to this state over time" — they say illogical things like that.
7. The Hostility Toward al-Ghazali in the Theology Faculties
That is why, if we say about al-Ghazali, for example, that he rejected rational thought, that he rejected all of philosophy, we would be slandering him. I mean, this is not true. But when you look, especially in this recent period, in some of the — in quotation marks — theology faculties there is a hostility toward al-Ghazali, and it's as if, I mean, if they sat down — I'm going to speak very boldly here.
I mean, these critics truly cannot read al-Ghazali's Tahafut.
Even if they read it, they cannot understand it. Because if they understood it, they could not make such harsh criticisms.
8. What Did al-Ghazali Oppose? Five Headings
Why did he object? What he really objects to here relates to metaphysics. I mean, normally the points al-Ghazali objected to are clear.
For example, what? The eternity of the world. What else? Whether or not Allah knows particulars. Why? The bodily resurrection. And what else? Causality. And also Allah's relationship with the world. Now when we look, well, normally al-Ghazali sat down and criticised these, but where does al-Ghazali stand when he criticises? What did he criticise? How did he criticise? I mean, it needs to be examined. Yes. The eternity of the world, that is, the world has no beginning.
9. The First Issue: The Eternity of the World
Can you imagine? When you say the eternity of the world — the one who is eternal is Allah.
Allah has no beginning. You philosophers, they claim that the world has no beginning. But normally, now when we look, ah, if we look at the philosophers, the world has no beginning. Allah is without beginning. Surah al-Hadid, the third verse, 3.
[Qur'an, al-Hadid 57:3 — verse text pending: Diyanet English translation] Look, and at the end: He knows all things. Then Allah is the One who is the First.
The First is not the world. Allah is the First. In fact, the Sufis use this hadith qudsi a great deal. When there was nothing, He was.
When there was nothing, He was. And Hazrat Ali continues. He says: "And He is still as He was." I mean, Hazrat Ali regards the entire world as non-existent. But normally the hadith qudsi says: when there was nothing, He was. And He created one thing. There was nothing.
He created one thing. From that one thing He created everything. Then nothing that has emanated into existence, apart from Allah, is eternal. Then now you philosophers saw the whole world as eternal. The moment you accept this, you fall into disbelief. The One who is eternal is Allah. If a being came into existence, if it was brought into existence, it has a beginning. The One without beginning is Allah. Well, now again, a hadith is narrated in Muslim and in Tirmidhi. "O Allah, You are the First." "There is nothing before You." "You are the First." "There is nothing before You."
10. «You Are the First, There Is Nothing Before You»
"You are the Last, and there is nothing after You. You are the Manifest, and there is nothing more evident and above You. You are the Hidden, and there is nothing more hidden and beyond You." Muslim included this hadith in the chapter on dhikr, and Tirmidhi also in the chapter on dhikr.
Now when you accept the eternity of the world, you end up denying this verse and this hadith. Al-Ghazali criticises this. Now, is the point al-Ghazali criticises justified?
Yes. And al-Ghazali normally speaks of someone who defends the eternity of the world in terms of disbelief. He says: if you defend this, you are among the people of disbelief. Well, take this to anyone who knows creed, if he knows this science — if you say the world is eternal, it has no beginning, then it becomes equal with Allah.
You end up associating partners with Allah. I mean, what happened? Did Allah act as God over a world that came into being later? Ah, that doesn't work. This does not befit Allah's Godhood. This is not possible. Well now, I prepared these in such detail because there are theologians. The theologians look at this too, they go on, they lash out. Well, let everyone keep their feet on the ground. The moment you get up and say in front of me that normally al-Ghazali rejected philosophy completely — hold on, brother, he did not reject the entirety of philosophy. I listed them point by point. You can't read the Tahafut, because I'm not telling this to you. Those who reject these, even if they read the Tahafut, cannot decipher it. They cannot understand it. He read it. He needs to decipher it. He can't decipher it. He can't find that path. And when he can't find that path, their minds flounder like a donkey stuck in the mud. May Allah protect us.
Allah's knowing of particulars — I mean, normally al-Ghazali again criticises the philosophers on this point. But because this does not accord with the verses in the Qur'an. I mean, what he calls particulars are the parts (juz'). The philosophers call them "particulars."
11. The Second Issue: Does Allah Know Particulars (Juz'iyyat)?
The parts — I mean, the philosophers say, the philosophers, Ibn Sina (Avicenna) among them, maintain that Allah knows small things by way of general principles.
But normally al-Ghazali, normally, says that He knows everything directly and in detail.
This is a matter of creed, since in Surah al-Hadid, which I just read, it says He knows all things. When it says He knows all things, then He knows whatever there is, great or small.
Allah knows tomorrow too. Allah is the Knower of the unseen. Allah knows what will be thousands of years from now. He knows what will be millions of years from now. Allah is the Knower. Because His knowledge is both first and last. Allah's knowledge is both manifest and hidden. It is not possible for us to set a limit on Allah's knowledge. That being so, Ibn Sina says, well, that He knows all things as wholes. Then, normally, He knows the small parts through their cause-and-effect relations, that is, by means of general laws. No. Allah knows even if there is no general law in anything. Because Allah knows the falling of a leaf too.
Allah knows the blowing of the wind too. He also knows when, which wind will make which leaf fall. Allah knows in detail. Allah knows the small and knows the great. And normally Allah's knowledge does not change either. It is both pre-eternal and everlasting. That being so, you get up and the philosophers' view is: Allah doesn't know small things, He doesn't know the parts. Great things must come about so that afterwards He may know the parts. This is nothing but sophistry. Normally this is also contrary to the Qur'an and the Sunna. Because Allah knows all things, and he criticises Ibn Sina harshly. Yes. His criticism is very harsh. Here, someone else reading it might say, "Come on, how harshly he criticised!" — but why would he say that? He says it because he has no knowledge on that subject. You know how I sometimes say: Rumi (Mawlana Jalal al-Din Rumi) said, "One who has no share of love is no different from a donkey."
12. «One Who Has No Share of Love Is No Different from a Donkey»
When I first read that, I said, how harshly he spoke.
13. Why Is This a Matter of Creed?
But over time, as I watched people, as I observed them, I saw that a person who has no share of love is no different from an animal. Yes. If that person has no portion of being a lover, we have experienced this. We have experienced this over time. Through experience I said, "O great elder, you truly behaved with courtesy. You said he is no different from a donkey. Especially in this age he would have spoken even more harshly. And I say that he is a creature lower than an animal. If he has no portion of being a lover." Yes. This is proven by experience over time. You see this: if he has no share of being a lover, he truly becomes a creature lower than an animal. Would a human being stab his wife in 38 places? 38 times "loving" her. Would a human being rape his own child? Would a human being rape his own sister? A creature lower than an animal. Animals do not mate with their own offspring. I am saying these things like this. This is the point our society has come to. We are in a moral dead end.
With drugs, with gambling, especially with drugs, they have poisoned the minds of the young. Young or old, it doesn't matter at all. The children of this country have been poisoned with drugs. He doesn't recognise his mother, doesn't recognise his sibling, doesn't recognise his grandmother, doesn't recognise his aunt. He becomes a creature lower than an animal. That is why al-Ghazali, you see, charges with unbelief the claim that He does not know the particulars, that is, the parts. Correct.
14. Proof: al-An'am 59 and Saba' 3
Here is a verse (ayah) of the Qur'an for you. [Qur'an, al-An'am 6:59 — verse text pending: Diyanet English translation] Now, with this verse right here, if you say that Allah does not know the small parts, you fall into unbelief.
Another verse of the Qur'an. So then, normally, this means that when we look at this verse, Allah knows whatever there is, great or small. Look, I underline it again. His knowledge is both First and Last. Another verse of the Qur'an. Saba', the third verse, verse 3. That one was al-An'am 59. Open it and read. I mean, those who are going to criticise should open it and read. I mean, they shouldn't criticise emptily like that. They shouldn't say, "This man has come out with that cap on his head and look, he's criticising this." Let them sit down and study. Let them sit down and examine and research. Let them sit down and read. Let them come to me with knowledge. Let them not come at me over the skullcap on my head. They are displaying their ignorance. They are displaying their obliviousness. Come with knowledge, brother. We are citing a verse of the Qur'an. Come and oppose the verse of the Qur'an. Yes. Saba', the third verse, verse 3.
[Qur'an, Saba 34:3 — verse text pending: Diyanet English translation]
15. The Attributes of Allah Are Pre-eternal
Come on then, now you say that Allah does not know small things, or that Allah's knowing of small things comes about after the great.
None of Allah's attributes come into being afterwards. They do not ripen afterwards. This isn't an apple, to ripen later. This isn't a Bursa peach. To ripen later.
The attributes of Allah are pre-eternal (qadim). What does pre-eternal mean? His measure is pre-eternal. His attributes are pre-eternal. Allah does not come to see afterwards.
Allah is the All-Seeing. Allah does not come to hear afterwards. Allah is the All-Hearing. Allah does not come to know afterwards. Allah is the All-Knowing. He is the One who holds power and strength in His hand. So then, if we say He does not know small things, we fall into unbelief.
16. A Statement Made on Television
Abdülaziz Bayındır said it on television. He said, "Allah does not know what you will do tomorrow." He needs a renewal of faith (tajdid al-iman) and a renewal of marriage (tajdid al-nikah).
And he must stand up before the public, again on a television programme, and say, "I have retracted this statement of mine, I have repented." If he doesn't say it — Allah knows your tomorrow. This man is a professor of theology. What a pity.
These people are training the young in the theology faculties. "Allah does not know your tomorrow." Come on, you are going to live tomorrow, and Allah won't know it, is that so? Unbelief. "When he says things like this, he took a dig at the theologians." Brother, I'm not taking a dig. What are we to do? Should we keep silent? Let him turn back. We are inviting him to faith.
17. The Pen Has Dried: A Book That Has Been Written
Well now, small and great, all of it is in a clear Book. Who wrote the Book? Allah.
Who had it written? Allah.
He commanded the Pen. He said, "Write." When the Pen said, "What shall I write?", He said, "Write whatever is going to happen from this day until the Day of Judgement." "Write the things that are going to happen from now on." He said. When the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings be upon him) ascended on the Mi'raj, he heard a scratching, the scratching of the Pen.
He said to Gabriel (Jibril), "O Gabriel, what is this scratching? "It is the scratching of the Pen," he said. He said the Pen is still writing and erasing. And now you are going to say that Allah does not know your tomorrow, what you will do tomorrow.
God forbid! The verse of the Qur'an says He knows. Are we going to look to theology professors? Or are we going to look to the verse? Al-Ghazali criticises this.
18. Proof from the Hadiths
Al-Tirmidhi, the chapter on divine decree (qadar), hadith number 6. The hadith. Read al-Tirmidhi. Al-Tirmidhi is also a Sufi. They don't like al-Tirmidhi; I like him. Al-Tirmidhi, in the chapter on divine decree, hadith 6 of the chapter on divine decree. "The knowledge of Allah has encompassed everything that has been and will be."
That has been and will be. Allah has encompassed it in every respect. There is nothing the Almighty (Allah) has created that He has not encompassed. And Allah also knows what will and will not happen to the thing He created from the moment it was created. It is found in al-Bukhari. The chapter on tawhid (divine oneness). Hadith number 22. In other sources it may be under other hadith numbers. I am citing it by giving references from the sources I have.
"The knowledge of Allah has encompassed what is in the heavens and on the earth." Can you now say it? "Allah doesn't know the parts." "Allah doesn't know tomorrow." You would have to have denied the verses and the hadiths. When you deny a verse and a hadith, you fall into unbelief. May Allah protect us. Again, there is a hadith found in Muslim.
"Allah knows the whispering (waswasa) that comes into the heart of any one of you." A hadith. Allah knows even the whispering that comes into your heart. There is nothing that Allah does not know. Now where are you going to come up with this? O philosophers, are you now going to say that Allah does not know the parts, or that He knows them when they happen?
Well now, these verses and hadiths show us that you are mentally backward. Ah, now, a European philosopher, a Christian theologian, a Christian researcher might say this like that.
19. A Christian Theologian Can Say It, But You Cannot
He can say this. But you, a Muslim researcher — if a Muslim says "La ilaha illallah Muhammadun Rasulullah," he cannot say this, my brother. If he says this, he falls into unbelief. Now a Christian theologian, or a Christian researcher, a Christian philosopher can say this. And in any case, those who applaud Ibn Rushd (Averroes) and Ibn Sina are the Western world anyway.
The Christians applaud. Why do they applaud you? Why do they applaud? Because they applaud you not for your knowledge, not for your philosophy, but because you are an Aristotelian. They applaud you because you are an Aristotelian. Why? Because you have become a Westerniser.
Normally, you did not look to your own veins, to your own blood. You did not look to your own knowledge. You went and took Aristotle wholesale, you accepted him. Yes. And the Europeans applauded you. Now our theologians, too, want the Europeans to applaud them. They want the Masonic mentality to applaud them. So that they can get money from the Soros foundations. They defend these things in front of us. These people are Soros people.
A hand grenade with its pin pulled, thrown into the middle of the Islamic world. Let them come.
Mustafa Özbağ is right here. And what he has explained is right here. I explain al-Ghazali with verses, with hadiths. I do not just say "this is like that." I am reciting verses to you. Please, come. Yes.
20. Why Am I Listing So Many Proofs?
Get up from your comfortable armchairs. Put al-Ghazali's published books on logic, on philosophy, on your desks and try to understand them. First of all, my words are not addressed to you. Try to understand. Try to analyse. Then speak. Do not lump everything together like that. And these verses and hadiths are al-Ghazali's fundamental basis.
Allah's knowledge is pre-eternal. Because Allah's knowledge is first, because. And Allah's knowledge encompasses everything, whether it moves or not. If something has emanated into existence, if it has emanated from His own divine knowledge, Allah encompasses it with His knowledge, in every single respect. Everything that comes forth from His divine knowledge — there is nothing that does not come forth from His divine knowledge. There is nothing that emanates into existence that does not come forth from His divine knowledge. And Allah possesses complete knowledge concerning everything that emanates from His own divine knowledge. He possesses complete power. He possesses complete strength. He is the complete Knower at this point. And He is the complete Lord, the One who nurtures and trains. Nothing over Him is outside of His knowledge. Where are you getting this from? You are making it up. Then you are fabricating this by yourselves.
I mean, it is not Ibn Sina, not al-Farabi, not Ibn Khaldun, my brother, no, come on. Ohh, not them. It is al-Ghazali. Yes. Why? Because he speaks from his own source, you see. That is why it's "yucky." Al-Ghazali is "yucky." That means declaring it. Declaring something "yucky" means destroying an entire great culture. Yes. What was one of them? What was the third thing al-Ghazali criticised? The bodily resurrection. Yes. When you look, al-Farabi, Ibn Sina — I am naming names for this because, I beg your pardon, their bootlickers are many in this country. There are bootlickers of this Ibn Sina, of al-Farabi, in this country.
21. The Third Issue: The Bodily Resurrection
These bootlickers are the ones who accept Ibn Sina and al-Farabi exactly as they are and applaud them. I call them the bootlickers of Ibn Sina and al-Farabi. Yes. Wherever they are, whatever professor they may be, these people — the resurrection — there are certain groups in the country who see themselves as lofty Sufis. There are even "Mawlana-ists" who exploit Hazrat Rumi on this subject. They argue that the resurrection is not bodily. There are groups like this under various names.
22. Those Who Exploit Rumi
These people define themselves as Sufis. Ah, these people go off. What was it, at one point they said the Day of Judgement was going to come. Where was it, some place? Was it Şirin? What was it? Şirince? They had gathered there and so on.
23. Those Awaiting the Day of Judgement: Pitching Tents
Supposedly the Day of Judgement was going to come, but nothing would happen in Şirince. And where else? Supposedly there was some Mr. So-and-so in Bozdağ. Supposedly he had a hotel, a motel there. Supposedly there was a zone there. And supposedly the Day of Judgement would not come there either. I personally spoke with these people. They were around our Hakan. They bought car batteries, they bought things. What were they? They bought batteries, they bought lights. Where did they go? They went to Bozdağ. They pitched their tents. Pitching the tent costs money, food and drink cost money.
They really waited for the Day of Judgement. Because Mr. Işık said so. Now, what's-his-name will listen to this. Our Hakan. When he listens, he will agree, I said. Hakan, do they believe this? They believe it, he said. And I also sat down with someone who believed this.
I spoke with Hakan's friend. They truly believed it. They went. Was that place Şirince? I don't have any geographical knowledge, you know. Şirince. Selçuk? Yes. Hey, Nuri, you didn't know it. No, huh. Let Oktay come and deal with you. These people went to Şirince, they went to Bozdağ. They literally waited for the Day of Judgement. Even though I said "Don't do it, don't," he went. And these people, you know, in general, you know, do not accept being resurrected again with the body. They say that this resurrection, the resurrection again, is spiritual. Now where am I going to take you with this? I am going to take you to Hindu belief. Let me not leave you there.
24. Reincarnation and the "Chakra-Jumping" Market
Now, according to Hindu belief, they believe in reincarnation, you know. And in our country there are reincarnationists too. They sit and go "ummm," you know. Of course. What's that, the hands are supposed to be like this? Ah, we are waiting for the sunrise.
New energy will come to you. The energy has come to you. Where's the energy? 10,000 dollars. A 3-day session. 10,000 dollars. If you are going to jump a chakra, if you are going to go to a more masterful person, 20,000 dollars — they are in the same hotel. I spoke with him too. I also spoke with someone who went there. What are you doing, I said. What they do is like this and like this, he said.
They had gathered in a hotel in Mudanya years ago. What are you doing? Well, if you try to jump a chakra with an assistant, 7,500 dollars for that day. If you have a higher-level assistant, 10,000 dollars. You know that lady with the red dot, the one they would bring and take away with a crane? If you attend her meeting, the session is 30, 40,000, 50,000 dollars. What's that, she will make you jump a chakra? Look at the red dot. Above this park they had a place like an association. They had put up the portrait of the lady with the red dot.
I swear, no one leaves turning their back on the portrait, the picture of the woman with the red dot. Big, big managers, big, big superiors. One is a factory manager at a dye house, another is manager of whatever, wherever. These are big, big managers. These are big, big bosses. They have graduated from several universities. I looked like that. I said, what's going on? If you turn your back on the portrait, your chakra closes. Man, our dervishes barge in and barge out.
Barging in and out. We say, look, fine, I mean, no problem at all. Come in, go out, just remember Allah. But normally, do you know what they believe in? Shall I tell you a little from Osho? I tell it sometimes.
25. A Page I Read from a Book
I opened Osho's book. What did I read? The place I read: a monk is about to die. While the monk is about to die, he says to a young girl, "Come, let us be together, I mean, let us have relations." And the girl does not accept. Then, in front of the monk as he is about to die, a donkey has relations with another donkey. The girl's mother says: "My child, why didn't you surrender yourself to the monk? If only you had surrendered." And Osho says, "If she had surrendered," he says, the monk's soul would have passed into the girl. A wise soul. But, he says, because she refused, at that moment, he says, when the two donkeys united with each other, he says, the monk's soul passed into the donkey.
A monk with a donkey's soul. Now go and believe in this as a religion. So what are these people saying now? There will be no bodily resurrection. Oh, there will be a resurrection of the soul. No. It is not like that. The resurrection is not bodily, they say. Yes. Yasin, verses 78-79. Yasin, verses 78-79.
26. Come to Me with Verses and Hadith
Anyone, if it is Islamic, if it is religion, if it concerns the religion of Islam, speak to me with verses and hadith. Speak to me with creed ('aqa'id). Speak to me with fiqh. Do not speak to me from somewhere else. This humble servant has been giving sohbet for 35, 40 years. Not a single servant of Allah has brought this before me. "Here you spoke against a verse." "Here you spoke against a hadith." "Here you spoke against the creed" — not a single servant of Allah has come and said this to me. Go ahead. If what I say is outside the verses and hadith, outside fiqh, outside the creed, I will come out and apologize before the public. We will turn back from that idea. Very easily. Yes. Yasin, verses 78-79.
27. Resurrection Is Bodily: Proof from the Verses
Allah's answer to the question of who will revive the rotten bones: [Qur'an, Ya-Sin 36:78-79 — verse text pending: Diyanet English translation] According to al-Ghazali, this verse shows that the re-creation of bodies is not rationally impossible, that it is possible through the power of Allah. Al-Ghazali took this verse as the criterion. Well, this humble servant also has a few verses to add to this. Al-Ghazali cut the matter short. There he contented himself with a single verse. He said that the scholars of today — of that day — fall silent when they see this verse, he said. But today's ignorant ones are insolent. Downright insolent. Yes. Baqara 28. Baqara 28. [Qur'an, al-Baqara 2:28 — verse text pending: Diyanet English translation]
Do you believe from this verse that the resurrection is only spiritual? No. This verse says that the resurrection is both spiritual and bodily. Abasa, verses 21-22. Al-Ghazali took just a single verse for this. I am listing them. Not to support al-Ghazali. God forbid. I am listing them as an answer to those who oppose al-Ghazali. Abasa 21-22: [Qur'an, 'Abasa 80:21-22 — verse text pending: Diyanet English translation]
Does it say "spiritually" here? It does not. Completely whole. Then is there a single verse stating that the resurrection is only spiritual?
There is not. Where did you get this from? Where did al-Farabi and Ibn Sina (Avicenna) get this from? May Allah forgive us. A hadith. These are not in the Tahafut.
28. The Hadith of the Tailbone
These last ones I read are from al-Bukhari and Muslim: people's bodies decay. Only the tailbone remains. On the Day of Judgment, one is re-created from it.
29. Why Are Sufis Criticized for This?
Here is the hadith. Even if your tailbones enter into a fire, they do not burn. This is a tiny bone. Even smaller than a bone. This is a tiny thing. Yes. I mean, normally now you think the body completely perishes. That is how you see it. In the tiny tailbone, something like this remains. It does not burn, it does not melt. It does not decay, it does not vanish. On the Day of Judgment you will be resurrected from there. You will be clothed in a body. So normally, then, the resurrection means — as they say in today's European language — it will be a concrete resurrection. Not abstract. Then if you say the resurrection is only spiritual, you have fallen into unbelief (kufr). Al-Ghazali says this. You fall into unbelief. That is why among the Sufis there is something like this, you know, the Sufis are criticized for it. These Sufis do not put limits on the power of Allah. You know there is this metaphor: can a camel pass through the eye of a needle? The answer: it can.
Is Allah's power sufficient to pass it through there? There is nothing for which Allah's power is not sufficient. There is nothing for which Allah's strength is not sufficient. There is nothing, as knowledge, that Allah's knowledge does not encompass and envelop. Now, normally, this view of the philosophers is also rejected rationally. It is not possible not to reject this. If you do not reject this, you fall into unbelief. But here, of course, the important detail concerning al-Ghazali is this.
30. Al-Ghazali's Scholarly Method: Not Leaving Things Half-Done
I mean, al-Ghazali does not reject everything the philosophers say.
He rejects the places that are contrary to the Qur'an and the Sunna. One must distinguish. That is why, for example, al-Ghazali has a tremendous thing. He has a scholarly path. The scholarly path is this. Al-Ghazali — I explained it in the previous lesson — has decoded the logic of the philosophers. Having decoded their logic, he strikes the philosophers with the philosophers' own logic. And of course, when he strikes, it makes an impact. He does not leave it half-done. When you strike something, you must not leave it half-done. If you leave it half-done, it pulls itself together and strikes you. Then look, when you strike something, you must not strike half-heartedly. You will strike fully. It will never be able to pull itself together again. Al-Ghazali struck in such a way that they can never pull themselves together again. You must not leave it wounded. Even in hunting, if you leave a predatory animal wounded, that animal will kill you. It will wreck you. In its desperation it will strike you, it will kill you. You must not leave it wounded. Intellectually, too, you must not leave it wounded. You will go over it like a steamroller.
It will never be able to raise its head again. That is why I am gathering the verses. And normally, al-Ghazali's refutations at this point concern certain topics of the philosophers; the other topics he normally does not reject. Al-Ghazali, for example, does not reject the logic and the mathematics of the philosophers. If he had rejected these, we would say he rejected everything completely. There is this claim going around, you know, that he rejected reason. Why would al-Ghazali reject reason?
31. Who Rejected Reason Before al-Ghazali?
Who has rejected reason? And in the Islamic world, al-Ghazali of all people should reject it? Before al-Ghazali, too, there is no one who rejected reason.
32. Why Does the Claim «Al-Ghazali Rejected Reason» Not Hold?
There are some currents that are not Sufi in the sense of being fully based on the Qur'an and Sunna, currents somewhat more influenced by the East, influenced by the Hindus. Before al-Ghazali there were currents like this. In India, or as you go somewhat further, uh, towards India, you can see these currents. But normally al-Ghazali uses reason tremendously in everything.
His interpretations are rational, his examinations are rational, and yet al-Ghazali does not hold this reason above revelation. And normally, for example, he has his al-Mustasfa, al-Ghazali does. I normally mentioned this in the last lesson too. In the principles of fiqh (usul al-fiqh), it defines the paths to be followed in deriving rulings related to fiqh. What kind of path will you follow in it? For example, definition — the definition of something, I mean, the definition of a telephone.
33. Al-Mustasfa: The Method of Reason in Fiqh
Definition, analogy (qiyas).
34. It Shows Which Source You Are Nourished From
Comparing something with something else. Logical inference. These are the things al-Ghazali applies, and al-Ghazali uses methods there such as cause-and-effect relationships and providing evidence. In fact this is a saying of al-Ghazali. I mean, he says that if a person does not have these kinds of logical and rational methods, that person cannot do fiqh, should not do fiqh. A faqih (jurist) won't come out of him. You know, he says that a faqih won't come out of a person who doesn't use logic. For al-Ghazali, a person who doesn't use reason is, for al-Ghazali, an empty tin can. A faqih won't come out of him, according to al-Ghazali. Well, if we now say that al-Ghazali's foundation is rejecting reason and accepting revelation, that would be far too simplistic. That would truly be an insult to al-Ghazali. That would be not knowing al-Ghazali. That would be the greatest slander ever cast upon al-Ghazali. You'd be a slanderer. You'll come out on the Day of Gathering and you won't be able to give account to Allah. If you're a Muslim you'll have to give account, right? You won't be able to. If you're a Christian, well then, off you go to hell anyway.
There's no reckoning, no book. These ones, you went with disbelief. Is there no reckoning, no book? Yallah, ruh — where to? To hell. Here, let Malik see to your account. Who is Malik? The angel of hell. Everyone will get acquainted with him. They'll walk on and go to hell. There's no reckoning, no book in that.
35. The Three Sources and Three Limits of Knowledge
I mean, if we were to say that al-Ghazali — I mean, the senses, reason and revelation — each of these has its own domain of knowledge, and all of them have limits.
For example, what we call feeling, intuition, has a limit.
Reason has a limit. Revelation. That too is defined by the verses. We have a concrete Qur'an in front of us. Revelation is defined. Well, its limit is defined too. Since you cannot bring a new verse, and since you cannot take away a verse either, revelation is defined. Well, I mean, then when we look at al-Ghazali's stance on this point, al-Ghazali says that one must reach a certain judgment, a certain truth, at a point that cannot be doubted, and he sees himself at this point as a student, and sees himself as someone trying to reach the truth. And, for example, regarding the senses.
36. Can the Senses Deceive Us?
The senses — what, I mean, there are five senses, right: seeing, hearing, then tasting, touching.
Normally reason can be mistaken through the things it has taken from these senses. The people of Sufism defend this anyway, the Sufis. You — the senses can deceive you. Because they can deceive, for example, for you to reach a ruling of zina (adultery) about a person, four male witnesses are required.
Why? Because the senses can deceive you. What you see can deceive you. Because, for example, a devil can appear in human form.
An angel can appear in human form. I mean, men, if a woman next to you says, "I saw you with a woman."
"No, come on, that was a jinn." "You must have seen it that way." Don't go down this path. This road is closed. Don't fall into that kind of trap either, you know. "With which one?" Ha, so that means there are several. Men don't have a nimble wit on this subject. Except Mustafa Özbağ. So, when it's like that, you know, the senses can deceive you. I'm giving an example. Now normally everyone is sitting, someone might hear something from over there. Yes. This happens among dervishes, or it can also happen to those whose spiritual state is somewhat elevated. They may experience different things. Again, the dervishes must by no means use this as a route like that. I'll set your kindling on fire, then. Someone like that apparently said, "Probably the jinn tribe visited you, it seems," he said. Where? Inside — now his wife is messaging me after midnight. "Did the jinn tribe visit me?" "Who said that?" I said. "My husband," she said. She said. Of course. "How did you judge that?" I said. Where? You're at the door, aren't you?
How did you judge that? Ha, there's your lamp. Are you still sleeping with the lamp on? Ha. Someone will come and do something in your ear. Okay. Well, if he doesn't change the house, come to me. He'll change the neighbourhood. He can't change the city, but he'll change the neighbourhood. What was it with the poor woman? She said, "What did you say?" "What did you say?" "Say it again, let me see." "Say it, say it." "Ha, you said it might be inside." "Let me tell you. Let Rapunzel come and strangle you with her hair for once." Now, it really can appear. I mean, normally the jinn tribe, for example, can appear in the form of an animal. The jinn tribe can appear in human form. Well, normally, for example, for a person to be able to notice this, the 5th
37. What Rank Is Needed to Notice This?
He needs to reach the Name (Asma). Without reaching the 5th Name, he cannot notice this.
He cannot know this. In between, like that, you know, like water leaking from a crack, he sees some things at the 4th Name, but it truly, fully, clearly, at the 5th Name begins to be seen. At the 6th, at the 7th, that vision reaches perfection. At that moment, when he sees, he says, "This is a devil." At that moment, when he sees, "This is an unbelieving jinn, this one's a hypocrite." Then he says, "A Muslim jinn." He says, "This is a dervish jinn." This becomes clear at the sixth, the seventh. Now, when these are seen in this form, then your seeing, your sense organ, can deceive you. Then your organ of hearing can deceive you. You know, our people from Bayındır know this well now.
38. The Story of a Man Who Said "I Flew"
We had a well-known brother of ours, Abdullah abi.
39. A Malami State and a Warning
While he was doing dhikrullah at night, they said to him, "You've arrived." "Come on, do a dive over the Bayındır plain." "Go around, tour it," they said. The man says, "I heard this voice, my dear Mustafa." "I heard this voice," he says. I spoke with him personally. And we were new dervishes then, like that. And he loves me a lot. He knows our childhood. Because he was a warehouse clerk at Tekel. We were getting cigarettes for the grocery shop, you know, Tekel goods. I mean, my grandfather and so on wouldn't go. Since everyone knew my grandfather, we would go, we'd deposit the money, and have the receipts cut there. And he's in the warehouse. We'd take the goods from that warehouse and come back to the shop. He himself is a Pomak. Yes. And Pomaks are like that, solid, stubborn. Normally, if he calls a crow an eagle, you can't turn him around. My grandfather used to say that. Now, he knows our childhood. Plus, we're more or less from the same neighbourhood. "Abdullah abi, how did you throw yourself?" I said. "At night, at 2, 2:30, we're wandering around on İstasyon Street."
There's no one but the two of us. Every now and then he bursts out with a divine Name. "Hayy, Hu!" like that. Normally some apartments open up onto the, you know. Nobody would dare walk around Bayındır with him. In Bayındır, when you said tariqa, everyone thought of "I Flew." Abdullah comes to mind. And the saying in our youth was this: "What, are you going to end up like 'I Flew' Abdullah too?" They have a resettlement house. A muhacir (immigrant) house. Normally the state gave it to them when they migrated. 1, 2, 3, 4 storeys. The 4th is a wooden house. The 4th floor is a single room. And Abdullah abi lives in that room. I know it. It's one room. There's a roof there. Behind it there's another roof. Below it another roof. I asked him. "Abdullah abi, how did you throw yourself?" Well, of course, everyone knows him as "I Flew" Abdullah. In our youth we heard about it too. I mean, Abdullah abi jumps. Head, arm, leg. After that, in the thing, what's it called? In plaster. "My dear Mustafa," he said.
"When you enter the realm of dhikr," he said, "it's not empty like that, you know." He had spiritual states. Harun Hoca would know better. Maybe he was seeing states now and then like that. For us back then, these states and such were new, they were flying around us. Everything is interesting. I have an i'tikaf story about him. Because one morning he came to me during my i'tikaf too. Anyway, I said, "Abdullah abi, what did you do?" "How did it happen, my dear Mustafa?" he said. "I passed into the realm of dhikr," he said. "While I was doing dhikrullah," he said, "a voice," he said, "said to me," "it said," he said, "'Abdullah, you've made it. Fly, do a dive. Do a dive over the plain.'" As if the blessed man were a glider. He says "Allah" and throws himself out of the window. Seriously. Of course, first floor, second floor, 3rd floor, when you drop floor after floor like that, it's no small drop down. Otherwise he'd die from there. Is his house still standing or not? From Araba Boynu, right as you head to our neighbourhood, it was on the corner on the right side. Is that house still standing?
Man, we should go and visit Abdullah abi's house... he already passed away, didn't he? May Allah have mercy on him. (Amin.) Yes, so he must have asked us for mercy. He loved me a lot. May Allah be pleased with him. He was a Malami. Now and then you could see Abdullah abi playing the football pools in a coffeehouse like that. Don't you dare look down on that. A different kind of personality.
40. My First I'tikaf
Abdullah abi, of course, look, the voice deceived him, but this same Abdullah abi, I'm in i'tikaf, I'm reciting the call to prayer for the dawn prayers myself, I'm in the masjid in Bayındır, I'm reciting the adhan live, there's no one, no one comes, the last 10 days of Ramadan, nobody from the neighbourhood comes to the dawn prayer, up in the masjid I normally climb up high, I recite the adhan live, then I go back inside.
I go to the mihrab. I pray the sunna. I pray the fard. After that I do a short dhikr by myself. I go into my cell. There's a cell there too. Our friends know it. Anyway, one day I'm like that again. I recited the adhan. I went over to the, the mosque side. Normally I'm forbidden to go out among the people. I don't meet with anyone, I don't speak. With nobody at all. I don't go out into the sun. When I'm going to make ablution, I put a cover over my face and body. I quickly make ablution and go back in.
On the first day I'll eat three morsels, on the second day two morsels, on the 3rd day one morsel. After that, water and tea. Nothing else. That's what i'tikaf is like. 70,000 tawhid a day. And you also do your wird. In the first 3 days you recite 70,000 each. After that, if you see the Prophet, sallallahu alayhi wa sallam, or hear, or perceive, if something happens, on the 4th day after that you recite 10,000 salawat. On the 5th day you recite the Majestic Name (Allah) 100,000 times. On the 6th day 70,000 tawhid. On the 7th day the Majestic Name 100,000 times. On the 8th day tawhid. On the 9th day the Majestic Name. On the 10th day you finish with tawhid. That is i'tikaf. No worldly talk. No animal food. No going out into the sun. This is my first i'tikaf. Sheikh Efendi put me into i'tikaf like this. My cheeks had sunk in.
My cheekbones were sticking out. On the 4th day I involuntarily looked in the mirror like that, I'd wasted away. For 5 days you can't sleep anyway. You have to finish the wird, you see. There's no leaving the wird like that. And how big is that room? Is it even 2 by 2, Nuri? It's like 1.5 by 2. Yes, I'm in there. An interesting thing.
41. The Food Left in Front of the Door
People, someone had brought food to the front of the door because I'd entered i'tikaf.
42. What Is the Measure of I'tikaf?
Of course I don't know anything about the food. The food just stayed right where it was there in front of the door. The poor woman took it from there and said, "If you want to find out whether your husbands' earnings are haram or halal," they said, "go and put food in front of the door." Ours stayed right where it was. I have no idea. I'm inside. Anyway, creak, the door opened. I don't look behind me at all. A divine Name came to my heart. I said, "Abdullah abi has come." Abdullah abi has come.
43. The Guest Who Came to the I'tikaf
I had just prayed the sunna like that. I'm about to stand for the fard. He prayed the sunna.
I don't look behind me at all. I stood up and recited the iqama. I made the intention for the fard. I prayed the fard of the dawn prayer. He followed me. He prayed too. Of course, during the prayer there's a "Hayy," a "Hu" going on. I turned around and began the tawhid. La ilaha illallah.
La ilaha illallah. He's reciting tawhid together with me. Then all at once I began the Name Allah, "Allah." But how we're doing dhikrullah with him like that! May Allah accept it. (Amin.) There's nothing like it.
At one point I opened my eyes and saw his knees at the level of my eyes. I said, "What, are you seeing a state?" I opened them again, and again like that, with every "Allah" he rises. Like that, I see his knee in front of me. Of course, we let go into the dhikrullah. At one point a whisper of doubt, something like that, you see.
"Now he's going to jump out the window," I said. "Here comes trouble." That's the waswasa, you see. Look, Satan sticks a spoke in the wheel there. Satan stuck a spoke in. I said, "Ashhadu an la ilaha illallah wa ashhadu anna Muhammadan 'abduhu wa rasuluh." I ended the dhikrullah.
44. «Al-Jilani Sent Me»
But he's not himself. He swayed back like this and was gone.
I made a supplication. He said "Amin" loudly, shouting. After that he got up, a dervish, and gave salam."
"Hu," he said. "Mustafa Efendi," he said. Whereas he calls me Mustafa. "Mustafa Efendi," he said. "Hazrat al-Jilani sent me. 'Go, our child is there all alone in i'tikaf, go and visit him. Receive his prayer,' he told me." he said.
"Hu," he said. He walked off and left. Now, did Abdullah abi come in the flesh?
Did he come normally? Did he come the other way? This occurred to me later. It didn't occur to me at that moment. I couldn't ask Abdullah abi about this again. He never brought this subject up with me. And never, ever did he fall short in respect toward me either. A grown man. Now, the senses can deceive. What you hear can deceive you. What you see can deceive. What you touch can deceive you. That is why al-Ghazali does not regard the knowledge of the senses as reality. The philosophers regard it as reality. And can the senses mislead reason? The answer: they can mislead it. A hadith.
45. Hadith: «It Is Enough of a Lie for You to Relate Everything You Hear»
What does the Messenger of Allah, sallallahu alayhi wa sallam, say?
46. A Warning on the Matter of the Jinn
It is enough of a lie for you to relate what you hear. It is enough of a lie for you to relate what you hear. Why? What you hear misleads you. The senses cannot be trusted. It continues. Normally this continues.
47. Al-Ghazali, Centuries Before Descartes
Now, when something like that happens, al-Ghazali, interestingly, centuries before Descartes, used methodological doubt as a means of purification and a starting point.
Purification from doubt. Now in the Islamic world they talk about Descartes' purification from doubt, methodologically, from doubt. Where do you get this talk of purification from doubt? Al-Ghazali found it. Al-Ghazali spoke of purification from doubt. Now you're going to read Descartes. You're going to come and stand in front of me. Is that so? No such thing. But al-Ghazali spoke of that purification from doubt. Al-Ghazali conveyed this as the insecurity of the senses, and al-Ghazali said that the senses can mislead and cannot give certain knowledge, like the sense of hearing taking the movement of a shadow to be stationary, like the sense of sight taking the movement of a shadow to be stationary.
Look at what al-Ghazali drew out from where!
48. The Example of the Shadow
Is a shadow fixed? No. A shadow is, as its name says, a shadow.
Then shadow-beings can also deceive you. If you see the shadow as fixed, stand up. There's a shadow here. Come forward a bit. The light hit it: a shadow. Now, is the shadow fixed? Is there a shadow? No. Look, what did you say? You said there's a shadow. Sit down. You were mistaken. The shadow is not reality.
Because the existence of the shadow depends on something and on light. You saw it as existing like that. In fact it doesn't exist. Al-Ghazali set the limit of reason. The limits of reason are like taking what is seen in a dream to be real at that moment. You see something in a dream. At that moment you think it's real. Isn't that so? I end up drenched in sweat. My God, what troubles, what troubles. Then I wake up. "No," I say, "oh, I was asleep." Sometimes I even say to myself, "No, man, you're asleep." "This thing is a dream you're seeing," I say. It continues. That thing is still what I'm seeing. Well, there are also, you know, the things seen without sleeping, and there are things seen while awake. And there are the things you see while awake. Apart from what you see in yaqaza. Apart from what you see in sleep. And there are the things you see while awake. When we look at these, you take all of those things seen to be real in that instant. I mean, while I was in i'tikaf, I looked and found I was standing up.
And someone was looking at me like this and that. He looked at me, I looked at him. He froze, hocam. "You scared me," he said. "But why are you just standing there?" I said.
49. A State in I'tikaf: «You Were Standing Up»
"Why didn't you sleep?" He pulled the blanket down over his head. He told the one next to him. "The hoca is standing up," he said. "At night he was talking to himself in his sleep," he said. "He was shouting and yelling," he said. That one told this one. This one told that one. Everyone is looking sideways like this. As I said, news spreads fastest there. Now me: what happened? What happened? What happened? What happened? What happened? I pulled it together. But I didn't piece together that I had been standing. I don't remember that. Then I remembered that I had met his eyes. I pulled him aside. "What were you doing?" I said. "You were sitting," I said. "And you were standing," he said. "What was I saying?" I said. "You were shouting and yelling," he said. "You were giving a talk," he said. "You were driving some people away," he said. I said, "Did you go and tell the whole ward about this now, man?" "I was scared," he said. "Hocam," he said, "I was really scared," he said.
50. The Example of the Dream: The Limit of Reason
Now you think it's real. At that moment you think it's real. Hazrat Pir, Hazrat Rumi (Mawlana Jalal al-Din Rumi), you know, this appears in the Masnavi. He says if a person sees in his dream that his arm has been severed, he thinks it's real.
When he wakes up, he says, the first thing he does, he says, is to reach his hand to that arm. He sees that his arm is in place. He heaves a sigh of relief, he says. So then, normally, it's like this: reason has a limit. Al-Ghazali said that, just as what is seen in a dream is taken to be real, rational data can be questioned by a higher state of consciousness, that is, the state of wakefulness.
Well, when that's the case, then there's also the insecurity of the senses that follows. Then there's purification from doubts. He identifies these before Descartes. When he identifies this, this point, you're simply left standing there. And normally, when that's so, regarding the overcoming of doubt, the impasse of the senses and reason, the impasse of the senses and of reason, how does al-Ghazali make it possible? Do you know what he says the way out of there is?
51. So Where Is the Way Out? Divine Light and Unveiling
Al-Ghazali says it is opened by means of a divine light, by unveiling (kashf).
That is, al-Ghazali says one can be freed from the impasse of the senses and reason through the working of the heart's intellect, through unveiling coming to the heart, through wonder coming, through 'ilm ladunni (knowledge directly from God) coming to the heart. Well, of course, would al-Farabi or Ibn Sina (Avicenna) understand this?
They wouldn't understand it. Whose business is this? The business of the Sufis. This too is the business of the Sufis. The heart being set in motion. We shout it out at the top of our lungs, don't we? If you want to see the truth, if you want to hear the truth, if you want to understand the truth, your heart has to be working.
52. Why Is This Not the Business of the Philosophers?
For the heart to work, attention is needed. For the heart to work, you need to focus with complete attention.
53. What Does the Heart Need in Order to Work?
For the heart to work, you must not be chatting and laughing with the person next to you.
If you want your heart to work, your heart has to be immersed in dhikrullah.
It has to love Allah. It has to love the Messenger of Allah. It has to love the master. And dhikrullah has to settle in the heart.
Then the heart will make its way toward the truth. Otherwise it won't make its way. Let it be thrown out, it's falsehood, it's garbage in terms of truth. Yes. Otherwise you'll keep spinning around endlessly inside whisperings, in the spiral of reason and feeling. You'll never find the truth. Be a professor as much as you like. This is something that transcends reason and the senses. But it is something whose truth is certain both through verses and through hadiths. Through verse and hadith, its truth is certain. When that's the case, then the source of knowledge appears before us. We're going rather slowly, but please forgive me. When that's the case, the source of knowledge will be discussed. Then what is the source of knowledge? Right, isn't it? Then when we look at the source of knowledge, first, sound senses are needed.
54. The Source of Knowledge: Three Steps
That is, the perception of the physical world is this first step. Right, isn't it? And when we look at the source of knowledge, normally, this first step is open to error.
After this, reason must come. That is, rational necessities, reason must come, for the source of knowledge. When we look at that, then rationally, mathematical propositions, logical propositions, for example, 10 is greater than 3.
Correct? Yes. These are normally necessary principles, things related to reason, that is. Yes. Is reason valuable at this point? It is valuable. But reason, this is what al-Ghazali says. If it is left on its own in metaphysical matters, it is limited. What is the domain that concerns the Sufis?
When we say metaphysics, dreams, spiritual states, knowledge of the heart come into the matter. Then, as the source of knowledge, immediately, automatically, from reason we will then come to inspiration (ilham), we will come to unveiling (kashf), we will come to the eye of the heart. Source of knowledge. Then normally, what does this concern? It concerns the Sufis. What does this concern? It concerns Sufism (tasawwuf). Then this directly means the purification of the heart, the cleansing of the heart, the purification of the heart, the cleansing of the heart; gossip, backbiting, all the trivial nonsense, abandon the forbidden things.
55. The Condition of the Third Step: Purification of the Heart
Leave the afflictions of the tongue, the afflictions of the eye, the afflictions of the ear, leave the afflictions of the hand, the afflictions of your foot; al-Ghazali explains these in the Ihya'.
Leave these. Purification of the heart.
This is the business of Sufism. This is the business of tasawwuf. This is the business of being a dervish. It is purification of the heart. Being a dervish. It is cleanliness of the heart. Being a dervish. Sufism is cleanliness of the heart. Sufis do not strive to set up companies in their dergahs. A Sufi movement does not strive to build itself upon a company. Trillions don't circulate around those at the head of that Sufi movement. Kilos of gold don't circulate. They don't go and invest money in who knows how many buildings. They busy themselves with purification of the heart.
56. The Obstacles Before Purification of the Heart
The first of the purification of the heart is, in any case, distancing oneself from love of the world. When we say distancing from love of the world, it doesn't mean abandoning the world here. Distancing oneself from love of the world. Well, if you still say, "I'll eat whatever comes to hand, I'll say whatever comes to my tongue," if you still carry on with gossip, backbiting, slander, if you still busy yourself trying to throw mud at this one and that one, if you're still busy with this one and that one, it is not possible for you to achieve purification of the heart.
If you're fighting with your spouse, if you're cursing your spouse, if you're sulking at your spouse, if you're oppressing your children, if the woman oppresses the man, the man the woman, it is not possible for purification of the heart to come about.
Purification of the heart; good character is purification of the heart; fulfilling the obligatory duties. Purification of the heart is observing people's rights and their due; purification of the heart. You need to be far from bribery, from this and that, from everything. Oh, grow your mustache thin like a cord, like that, an almond mustache. And open the thingy of the desk, too. Open its drawer.
"I'll sign it, but take care of this here." "It's worth it." Damn your prayer too, you shameless man. And on top of that, don't you talk to us about Islam. Don't you talk to us about being a dervish. Look down on your dervish brother. Then, purification of the heart. There is no such purification of the heart.
57. "I Am With the Poor"
Al-faqru fakhri (poverty is my pride). "I am with the poor," said the Messenger of Allah, sallallahu alayhi wa sallam.
If you act according to people's wealth, half of your religion is gone.
Purification of the heart.
If you bow and salute someone because of his position in the state, because of someone's wealth, if you bend your neck before him, half of your religion is gone. It is established by hadith. Purification of the heart. You've got some business with him. If you're fawning, purification of the heart. "No, you too fawned because of your business." You, purify your heart. Hold fast to the Qur'an and the Sunna. Purification of the heart. And that is why they criticize the Sufis of the heart. When the Sufi reaches this state, when he begins to receive inspiration in the heart, when unveiling opens up in him, he has walked toward the reality of that reality. You're reading from a book.
58. Hadith Qudsi: "I Become the Eye With Which He Sees"
He speaks not from the line, but from the breast. Didn't the Almighty also say in the hadith qudsi?
I love him, and he loves Me. When I love him, I become his seeing eye, his hearing ear, his speaking tongue, his grasping hand, his walking foot. He sees through Me, he hears through Me, he grasps through Me, he walks through Me, he speaks through Me. Then that heart, his unveiling has opened. His.
He has passed from veil of bewilderment to veil of bewilderment. He now possesses the essence of knowledge. His heart receives inspiration.
Don't lie to him. So as not to embarrass you, he won't throw your lie in your face. Don't attempt to deceive him. So as not to embarrass you, he won't say, "You're deceiving." Because he has taken on the character of Allah's character. He doesn't embarrass people in front of people.
59. What Does Distancing Oneself From Love of the World Mean?
Don't you go and say something to him. No. Don't think he doesn't know. Don't think he doesn't see. These are the places where dervishes are deceived. May Allah protect us.
60. Its Name in the Qur'an: 'Ilm Ladunni
Now, what is this? What is its language in the Qur'an? Knowledge from His presence. 'Ilm ladunni (knowledge directly from God).
The knowledge of Khidr, 'ilm ladunni. Come on, now sit down, you. How did Khidr kill the boy? He killed him.
Didn't he kill him? "This is metaphorical." No, this is reality.
61. "If You Enter There With Your Reason, You Will Drown"
Drown there. With your reason you will drown there. Khidr is the possessor of 'ilm ladunni. He killed the boy. He slew the boy. Do you have anything to say? He was the possessor of that knowledge. It is established by the Qur'an. And you go and say, "No, well, he killed him metaphorically." "In fact he didn't kill him." Sit down, sit right down on the floor, you worshipper of reason. Possessor of 'ilm ladunni. Go on, deny that knowledge.
62. The Question Put to Moses (peace be upon him)
What was said to Moses (peace be upon him)? Someone asked.
"O Moses, is there anyone on earth more learned than you?" Moses said, "No." The Almighty cut off the connection with Moses. Moses walked to Mount Sinai.
As every time, he wept, he implored, he beseeched. He stayed there in seclusion (khalwa) for 40 days. He said, "O my Lord, You cut off the connection with me. You cut off the intimate conversation with me." He cut off His intimate conversation with His prophet. He cut off His connection.
The dervish who sees himself as exalted, who sees himself as untouchable, who sees himself as lofty, who sees himself as arrogant. Do you think He will establish a connection with you? He cut off His connection with His prophet. Is He going to establish a connection with you? You monument of arrogance. He said to Moses, "O Moses, in such-and-such a place one of My servants asked you such a question.
And you said to him, 'There is no one more learned than me.' This drew Allah's astonishment," He said. Moses said, look at the humility:
63. The Humility of Moses: "I Want to Become His Disciple"
"O my Lord, I want to become his student."
64. The Dried Fish: The Meaning of a Sign
"I want to become his disciple," he said. Let them not twist and turn the words. Let them go and ask Khidr. And if their hearts are brave enough, let them ask Moses (peace be upon him). Let them say, "What did you say to Allah?" He said, I want to become his disciple. Who is this person? The Almighty said, "Take a dried fish with you. Go to such-and-such a place," He said. Walk along the seashore. Look, these are signs. Whenever, He said, the dried fish, He said, comes back to life, there, He said, I have a servant. He, He said, "is a greater scholar than you." He went and found Khidr. Let me say it in my sheikh's words: "Peace be upon you, O..." he said to him. This is my sheikh's expression. Khidr turned around. "And upon you be peace, O Moses," he said. This too is my sheikh's state. This too is my sheikh's 'ilm ladunni (knowledge directly from God). You cannot read this in a book either.
65. Every Perfect Murshid Passes Through a Station of Khidr
Because every perfect murshid (spiritual guide) passes through a station of Khidr, and becomes acquainted with a Khidr, with that Khidr.
Let no one consider himself a perfect murshid without having become acquainted with that Khidr. It is the 5th station.
I am saying these things openly. 5th. In the station, one meets with Khidr. In the Ulu Cami (Grand Mosque). Yes. The Ulu Cami is the 5th. Station. One passes through the station of Khidr. It cannot be without passing through the station of Khidr.
I will die and be gone, and tomorrow or the day after someone will get up and pose as a perfect murshid to you. He is saying it so that you know. I am not speaking to praise myself. May Allah forgive me. (Amin.) I will walk on and be gone. My age is 65, how much is left here? My life had 60 years left. 55 are left. When you subtract 65 from 120, 55 remain. What is left? Allahu a'lam. Allah knows. I have been wrestling with your heads. He went to Khidr (peace be upon him).
66. "Our Knowledge Is Bitter; You Cannot Be Patient"
He said, I want to become your disciple. Let me go back to my sheikh again from here. Let me not tell anything from myself. "I want to become a disciple."
When he said this, Khidr said to him, "Our knowledge is bitter. You cannot be patient," he said. You cannot bear it, he said.
It is bitter. You cannot be patient, you cannot bear it. He said.
Moses said, "I will be among those who are patient. I will be among those who bear it. I," he said, "will be among those who follow you in this matter." All right, said Khidr. Let me again go on from my sheikh. I liked it. He liked it too. O Abdullah Efendi, how could we ever forget you? We have never forgotten. May Allah have mercy on him. (Amin.) A ship in the distance. I am telling this from my sheikh. A ship from afar. Not the kind of distance where any sound whatsoever could be heard. Khidr (peace be upon him) turned toward the ship.
67. The Story of the Ship: Where Reason Stops
He said, "Hey, you on the ship, we are two old men," he said. There is no youth of Moses here. Those who say it was before his prophethood are misleading you. Moses was a prophet at that time. "No, he met Khidr before his prophethood." You are a fool. Khidr (peace be upon him) said, "O you on the ship, we are two old men. Take us from here," he said. Those on the ship heard the voice.
They lowered a rowboat. Two people are coming, rowing and rowing. Coming toward the shore. They are coming to two old men. They look and they see the old men. The distance between them is very great. This part is from Mustafa Özbağ: the distance between them is very great. Not meters but kilometers. It is not even possible to see that ship from that far away. Moses was astonished. Because there is no ship anywhere around. Moses is in amazement. There is no ship, but Khidr... "O you on the ship, we are two old men. Take us from here," he said. Those in the rowboat do not know where they are rowing.
They see. It is not outward (zahir). Even the rowboat. They cannot steer it. Yes. They came, they looked: two old men. They could not bring the rowboat all the way to the shore, you see.
Khidr (peace be upon him) took Moses (peace be upon him) by the hand. Walking on the water, they went to the rowboat. The rowboat sank down like this. Tak, they stepped into it. Then the rowboat rose up again. Moses is in amazement.
68. One Stroke, Twenty Strokes
They pull one stroke, and they go as if they had pulled five strokes. They pull one stroke, they row as if it had gone 10 strokes. They pull one stroke, they go as if it were 20 strokes. It is not like a rowboat, it is as if, you know, there are these fast things nowadays, tiny things. It goes like that. In the blink of an eye the rowboat reached the ship.
Those on the ship are astonished too. The great Khidr has come, with Moses beside him.
The ship sank down. The rowboat rose up. The ship sank down. Everyone is astonished. Normally isn't it with a ladder like that? Should Mustafa Özbağ struggle to climb a ladder, like a cat ladder? There is no such thing. They boarded the ship. Those on the ship hosted them, fed them, gave them drink, served them. They went on, it was a fishing ship. They went and came right up to the city. Moses (peace be upon him), the thing, Khidr (peace be upon him), with Moses beside him, you see.
69. The Plank Struck With an Axe
He went down and found an axe there. This part is from my sheikh. He struck one blow with the axe, boom. He broke one of the planks.
Water began to come in. When the water began to come in, Khidr (peace be upon him) said to the water, "Be calm, be safe, do not sink the ship."
He said. Of course, before that Moses could not hold back. He said, "These people served us, showed us respect. And you are doing them harm," he said. "To the ship," he said. He turned to Moses. He said. Did I not tell you that you cannot be patient? Our knowledge is bitter. I will be among the patient ones, he said. Moses... the moment he said to the water "be safe," he froze the water like this, and it stayed. No more water comes in. They got off as if nothing had happened. Those on the ship did not see the water. They looked and saw the plank. They do not see the water. They walked off and went, they went to the city. Let me cut this short; I will tell it again later. This is related to unveiling (kashf), related to 'ilm ladunni.
70. The Wisdom Was Revealed Afterwards
Then, that place had a tyrannical king.
He was going to set out on a campaign.
71. The Slain Boy: The Heaviest Test
These were like the Israelis. They too were the Bani Isra'il. Degenerate Jews. They were going to set out on a campaign. Pharaoh-like people. They looked and said, "The ship is sinking. They quickly abandoned it." Khidr then said to Moses, "They were seven brothers. There is a secret in this seven. Put that aside. They were seven brothers," he said. "These," he said, have an old mother and father. They look after them, they work as fishermen.
72. The Measure Drawn From the Story: The Apparent and the Reality
Those tyrannical soldiers came, he said. They saw the ship was sinking. They got scared and left it. They abandoned it. They were seizing it. After us, he said, the seamen will repair it. They will carry on with their work, he said. Then what is the source of knowledge? It is 'ilm ladunni. The source of knowledge. Of course, do the philosophers accept 'ilm ladunni? They do not. Normally Aristotle, Socrates, Plato accept this. Intuition, science, as a source of knowledge, from the Greeks.
73. Closing: Causality Next Week
Where is the real break? Causality? It is related to the philosophers. The time is 23:13. Let us continue from here. All right? Forgive me any rights I owe you. Forgiven.
We will continue from causality. To the answers to the philosophers. I am taking up a lot of your time on this subject. Today, also, from Bayındır, our friends and companions from the old days, from before the dervish path, and at the same time our first dervish brothers in Bayındır, came to visit us.
May Allah be pleased with them. So we had a pleasant chat with them for a while. That was partly the reason we were late. But we had such a flourishing (bayındır) conversation, a Bayındır sohbet. We talked about the old days and so on. Our hearts were gladdened like that. May Allah be pleased with all of them, inshallah. That is why we were delayed.
Forgive me any rights I owe you. Forgiven. From our side, too, may it be forgiven. To our dervish brothers who ask for forgiveness. If there is anyone who does not forgive, let him say so. Let us make our peace from here, from up here, up close. It is no trouble at all. I mean, we know how to make our peace. I mean, if an apology is due, we apologise. If it is a debt, we pay it, no problem. But if someone says "I do not forgive" out of mere whim and desire, we will take care of that too. Yes.
Note: This text is the speech itself as found in the recording of the sohbet: only the spelling and punctuation have been edited, and obvious mishearings in the subtitles have been corrected; a few unintelligible passages have been left as heard. Section headings have been added for ease of reading. The opening and closing prayers have not been included.
Bibliography
The verses, hadiths and works mentioned in the sohbet are gathered below. In this talk the speaker chose to ground al-Ghazali's views directly in evidence from transmitted knowledge (naql).
The Holy Qur'an, al-Hadid 57/3 — [Qur'an, al-Hadid 57:3 — verse text pending: Diyanet English translation] The fundamental verse for the refutation of the eternity of the world and for the all-encompassing nature of Allah's knowledge.
The Holy Qur'an, al-An'am 6/59 — [Qur'an, al-An'am 6:59 — verse text pending: Diyanet English translation] Evidence that Allah knows the particulars.
The Holy Qur'an, Saba' 34/3 — [Qur'an, Saba 34:3 — verse text pending: Diyanet English translation]
The Holy Qur'an, Ya-Sin 36/78-79 — [Qur'an, Ya-Sin 36:78-79 — verse text pending: Diyanet English translation] The verse on which al-Ghazali relies in the discussion of bodily resurrection.
The Holy Qur'an, al-Baqara 2/28 — [Qur'an, al-Baqara 2:28 — verse text pending: Diyanet English translation] Evidence that the resurrection is both spiritual and bodily.
The Holy Qur'an, 'Abasa 80/21-22 — [Qur'an, 'Abasa 80:21-22 — verse text pending: Diyanet English translation]
The Holy Qur'an, al-Kahf 18/60-82 — The story of Moses (peace be upon him) and Khidr; the Qur'anic source of 'ilm ladunni and the place where the word «ladun» occurs (al-Kahf 18/65).
Hadith — «You are the First, there is nothing before You» — Muslim, Dhikr 61 (no. 2713); al-Tirmidhi, Da'awat 19. Mentioned in the refutation of the eternity of the world.
Hadith Qudsi — «He was when there was nothing» — A widespread transmission in the Sufi tradition, connected to the narration in al-Bukhari, Bad' al-Khalq 1 (no. 3191); mentioned together with the addition of Ali (may Allah be pleased with him): «and He is still as He was.»
Hadith — The all-encompassing nature of Allah's knowledge — al-Tirmidhi, chapter on Qadar; al-Bukhari, chapter on Tawhid: «Allah's knowledge encompasses everything that has been and will be»; «Allah's knowledge encompasses what is in the heavens and on the earth.»
Hadith — The knowing of what passes through the heart — Muslim: «Allah knows the whispering that comes into the heart of any one of you.» Mentioned in the discussion of the knowledge of particulars.
Hadith — The tailbone — al-Bukhari, Tafsir 39; Muslim, Fitan 141 (no. 2955): «The whole of a human being's body decays except the tailbone; on the Day of Resurrection he will be created anew from it.»
Hadith — The Pen — «Allah created the Pen and said to it 'Write'…» Abu Dawud, Sunna 16; al-Tirmidhi, Qadar 17. Mentioned in the discussion of destiny (qadar) and divine knowledge.
Hadith — «Relating what one hears» — «It is enough of a lie for a person to relate everything he hears.» Muslim, Muqaddima 5; Abu Dawud, Adab 80. Used as evidence in the discussion of the reliability of the senses.
Imam al-Ghazali, Tahafut al-Falasifa (The Incoherence of the Philosophers) — It is not philosophy as a whole but specific issues that are refuted. In the sohbet, these issues were substantiated one by one with verses and hadiths.
Imam al-Ghazali, al-Mustasfa min 'Ilm al-Usul — Methods of deriving rulings in the principles of fiqh (usul al-fiqh): definition, analogy (qiyas), logical inference, the cause-and-effect relationship and the provision of evidence. The clearest answer to the claim that "al-Ghazali rejected reason."
Imam al-Ghazali, Ihya' 'Ulum al-Din (The Revival of the Religious Sciences) — The afflictions of the tongue, the eye, the ear, the hand and the foot; the methodology of purifying the heart. Mentioned in the sohbet as the condition for the third level of knowledge.
Rumi (Mawlana Jalal al-Din Rumi), Mathnawi — The example of the person who sees in a dream that his arm has been torn off; evidence that the certainty given by reason can be called into question by a higher state of consciousness.
Abd al-Qadir al-Jilani, Ghunyat al-Talibin — One of the works the speaker read and discussed in his youth; mentioned as a source from the period in which his own Ghazalian line took shape.
Mustafa Özbağ Efendi, «The Source of Knowledge and 'Ilm Ladunni | Questions on al-Ghazali 10» — mustafaozbag.com — Full text of the sohbet dated 23.08.2026.
Click here for more information about Imam al-Ghazali.
Additional sources:
- Qur'an: al-Hadid 57/3; Allah, Who is the First, the Last, the Outward (al-Zahir) and the Inward (al-Batin).
- Qur'an: al-An'am 6/59 and Saba' 34/3; the all-encompassing nature of divine knowledge.
- Qur'an: Ya-Sin 36/78-79, al-Baqara 2/28, 'Abasa 80/21-22; bodily resurrection.
- Qur'an: al-Kahf 18/60-82; the story of Moses and Khidr and 'ilm ladunni.
- al-Bukhari, Riqaq 38; the hadith qudsi on drawing near through supererogatory acts.
- al-Bukhari, Tafsir 39; Muslim, Fitan 141; the narration of the tailbone.
- Muslim, Dhikr 61; the supplication «You are the First, there is nothing before You».
- Muslim, Muqaddima 5; the standard for relating what one hears.
- Imam al-Ghazali, Tahafut al-Falasifa and Maqasid al-Falasifa.
- Imam al-Ghazali, al-Mustasfa; the principles of fiqh and rational methods.
- Imam al-Ghazali, Ihya' 'Ulum al-Din; the sections on the afflictions and the training of the heart.