Sunday, November 15, 2026
OUR PATH IS THE PATH OF PROPHETHOOD
Mustafa Özbağ
Irshad & Tasawwuf · Official Site
al-Ghazali Talks·

Al-Ghazali and the State | al-Ghazali Talks 11

Translated from Turkish. Original article (Turkish) →

1. The Internal and External Problems of the Seljuks: Rebellions and «Smoking Hashish and Founding an Islamic State»

When we look at the time of the Seljuks, we see that from period to period the Seljuks had both internal problems and external problems.

For example, they had to deal with various rebellions. And some of the groups whose rebellions they had to deal with were people who regarded themselves as authorities in religion.

For example, who was there? Who was it that smoked hashish and tried to found an Islamic state? The Hashshashin (the Assassins).

2. The Kharijites: A Clique That Has Existed Since the Time of Hazrat Ali

Now, the Seljuks deal with the Hashshashin. The Seljuks — please excuse this expression, my expression. There is a clique that the Islamic world has been dealing with ever since our master Hazrat Ali.

Who? The Kharijites. Al-Ghazali deals with the Kharijites too. Al-Ghazali deals with the Hashshashin too.

He also deals with the communities within the Islamic world of that day which did not conform to Islamic creed ('aqida).

3. The Hurufis, the Batinis and Jewish Guises Hidden Within Islam (the Sabbateans)

On one side there are the Hurufis. On one side there are the Batinis. Within the Shi'a itself there are various branches. On one side there are the Fatimid partisans.

On one side there are Jewish cliques that have concealed themselves and appear as if they were within Islam. You know the Jewish clique — that is, there are Jewish cliques like today's Sabbateans.

4. «I Distinguish Genuine Shi'a from Deformed Shi'ism»: Protecting Imam Ja'far

For example, within the Shi'a — I mean, I distinguish genuine Shi'a from, you know, the Shi'ism that later became deformed.

For example, I have nothing whatsoever to say against Imam Ja'far.

I distinguish Imam Ja'far from the Shi'ists. Because these are very broad issues. They are historical issues. I distinguish them in my own way. That is, just as I distinguish Ibn Arabi from the Ibn Arabi-ists, just as I distinguish Hazrat Rumi from the Rumi-ists, I distinguish them. Just as I distinguish Imam al-A'zam (Abu Hanifa) from the Hanafis.

5. «Are You in the Madhhab of Imam al-A'zam?»: The Conditions of Being a Hanafi

Sometimes in lessons I say, you know — everyone [says] Imam al-A'zam; [I ask,] who are you following in madhhab? You are not of Imam al-A'zam. You are not a Hanafi, I say. This person is taken aback. If you are a Hanafi, you cannot bow to oppression. If you are a Hanafi, you cannot bow to oppressors. You, a Hanafi — it is not possible.

Your stance cannot be at this point. Imam al-A'zam is the man who gave a fatwa for the Umayyads — for the overthrow of the Umayyads.

6. «Today You Pray the Friday Prayer as the Umayyads Prescribed It»

Today you pray the Friday prayer as the Umayyads prescribed it. Not as the Prophet prescribed it. Look, the order in which the Friday prayer is performed today belongs to the Umayyads.

When you say "I am a Hanafi," you will start first with the Friday prayer. You will say: this is not the order in which His Excellency the Prophet, sallallahu alayhi wa sallam, performed the Friday prayer. Well, you will first perform the prayer and then deliver the sermon (khutba). If you are not first performing the prayer and then delivering the sermon, then you are leading me in the Friday prayer that the Umayyads had led.

7. «You Cannot Beg for Money from the Pulpit, You Cannot Take a Salary for Leading the Prayer»: The Hanafi Condition

Are you a Hanafi? Yes. Come, start first with the Friday prayer. Are you a Hanafi? Yes. You cannot beg for money from the sermon. Are you a Hanafi? Yes. You cannot take a salary for leading the prayer. There is no such thing as just saying "I am a Hanafi" and getting away with it.

Now, like this — I mean, when we look at al-Ghazali, al-Ghazali is a person who lived in a region and a time in which there were political upheavals, intellectual upheavals, scholarly upheavals and doctrinal upheavals.

8. The Seljuks' Prevention of These Centres of Agitation: The Madrasa and the Appointment of al-Ghazali

Now, when we look at al-Ghazali, whatever lay outside the line of the Qur'an and Sunna within the framework of that day was running rampant both inside and outside the Seljuk realm. The Seljuks, in order at least to keep hold of their internal organisation, and so that these outside — nowadays they say "centres of agitation," don't they — so that these operations from outside would not roam freely inside at the scholarly level, establish the madrasa.

And they bring al-Ghazali to head the madrasa, and they do not interfere in al-Ghazali's work. They say: you wage the struggle of the Qur'an and Sunna here.

Keep the creed sound.

9. Where Does His Salary Come From? — «From the Seljuks»: Salaried Clergy Continues

And where does his salary come from? From the Seljuks. Let us underline this as well. Where does the money (akçe) come from? From the Seljuks. That is, it is with state money. Now, normally, is there an ijtihad on this in the Hanafi school?

Yes. Because the state is obliged to protect the religion of its subjects. The state is obliged to protect the reason of its subjects. The state is obliged to protect the honour of its subjects. The state is obliged to protect the lives of its subjects. The state is obliged to protect the property of its subjects.

10. «Against Whom Will It Protect the Religion of the Seljuk Subjects?»: Hurufi, Batini, Fatimid Partisan, Zoroastrian

Now, when we look at it from this angle, the state is doing this. The Seljuk State says: I must protect the religion of my subjects. Against whom? Against the Hurufis. Against the Batinis. Against whom? Against the Fatimid partisans.

Against whom? Against the Zoroastrians.

11. The Jews of Upper Mesopotamia: They Conceal Themselves Within Society

There are these Jews of Upper Mesopotamia.

These Jews of Upper Mesopotamia conceal themselves within society. They do not show themselves within society.

Within this society — for example, normally, which state in the world has the largest number of Jews as a state? Now you might say Russia. Isn't that so? You might say Turkey. You might say where? You might say Iran. Where? You might say Azerbaijan. Where? Dagestan. For example, there are the Khazar Jews. Between the Euphrates and the Tigris, starting from Baghdad — starting from Baghdad, from even further down, and indeed upward into the Turkic Republics, they reach as far as Kazakhstan, Turkmenistan, Turkestan.

These are the Khazar Jews. These Khazar Jews never bring themselves out into the open.

12. Professor Yalçın Küçük's Research on the Khazar Jews

On this, there is Professor Veli — what was it?

Yalçın Küçük. I apologise. Yalçın Küçük has magnificent research. Whether it is right, wrong, incomplete or excessive — I am not getting into that side of the matter. Yalçın Küçük has research concerning the Khazar Jews. These too regard themselves as Turks.

As a side note of this kind, I had told you before as well. Mossad has a study of this kind. Claiming that the Turks are Jews. We have closed the parenthesis.

13. Al-Ghazali's Era: «Amid Political, Military, Intellectual, Doctrinal and Philosophical Upheavals»

Now, al-Ghazali's era is such a turbulent era. Both inside and outside. There are both political upheavals and military upheavals. There are intellectual upheavals. There are doctrinal upheavals. There are philosophical upheavals. He is in the midst of these. Is it possible for al-Ghazali not to be affected by them?

It is not possible. He was affected; after all, while writing responses to these, he also had to examine and research them in his own way.

14. «You Wield the Sword of Whoever's Bread You Eat»

And that is why, normally, now in Eastern Islamic thought, when we ask what kind of role the state played here in these societies in the development of society and the economy — yes, al-Ghazali is a person who, in the relationship between the individual and the state, took his stand on the side of the state. This is my own assessment. Someone may see this as incomplete or mistaken.

Because there is one thing — my greatest, uh, thing that I dwell on very meticulously on this subject. You wield the sword of whoever's bread you eat. Or else, like Abu Dharr al-Ghifari, the sword is at your neck.

If you are not eating anyone's bread, then — pardon my expression. Let all of them, starting from our master Hazrat Uthman, and the Companions too, pardon my expression. If the sword is at your neck, you will go after even Hazrat Uthman. If the sword is at your neck, you will go after Mu'awiya too.

15. «Not the Sword at Your Neck, but Seized by the Throat»: An Explanation of Dependence

If the sword is at your neck, you will do it.

If the sword is not at your neck, but rather someone has seized you by the throat, then you wield the sword of the one who has you by the throat. Set this aside. An analysis.

Al-Ghazali, after all, is a scholar who drew a salary from the state. However, when al-Ghazali wrote the Ihya', he wrote it once his relationship with the state had ended. Take this down as a side note as well.

16. Scholars and Companions Who Took the Side of the State Throughout History

This being the case, it is something that has been seen — in al-Ghazali's time, or before al-Ghazali, in the time of the Abbasids and the Umayyads as well — that in the relationship between the individual and the state, some scholars, and even Companions — let us include them too — some Companions took their stand on the side of the state. For example, you can see the Companions who took the side of Mu'awiya.

You can see the Companions who took the side of Yazid. You can see Companions who left our master Hazrat Husayn stranded in the middle. These are things that pain us.

They are things that pain us. But because of the saying "My Companions are like the stars," we cannot let our tongues loose against them.

Note: This text is the speech itself as recorded in the sohbet: only spelling and punctuation have been edited, and obvious mishearings in the subtitles have been corrected; a few unintelligible passages have been left as heard. Section headings have been added for ease of reading. The opening and closing prayers have not been included.


Bibliography

Figure — Hasan Sabbah and the Assassins (Hashishiyya): A deviant organisation founded by the Nizari Ismaili leader who established his headquarters at the fortress of Alamut and who, it is reported, trained fida'is (devotees) by giving them hashish. He had hundreds of statesmen assassinated, including the Seljuk vizier Nizam al-Mulk (484-518 AH / 1090-1124 CE). — B. Lewis, The Assassins: A Radical Sect in Islam

Historical Movement — The Kharijites: The group that objected to Hazrat Ali's acceptance of the "arbitration" at the Battle of Siffin, declared both Hazrat Ali and Mu'awiya unbelievers, and later had Hazrat Ali martyred. They are known for their thesis that "one who commits a major sin becomes an unbeliever." — al-Shahrastani, al-Milal wa'l-Nihal; M. Watt, Islamic Philosophy and Theology

Deviant Organisation — Sabbateanism: The community of "Dönme" (converts) descending from the school of Sabbatai Zevi (1626-1676), outwardly Muslim while secretly preserving Jewish beliefs. A controversial historical phenomenon claimed to have been influential in the late Ottoman period and in the founding of the Republic of Turkey. — G. Scholem, Sabbatai Sevi: The Mystical Messiah

Figure — Imam Ja'far al-Sadiq (80-148 AH / 700-765 CE): The sixth imam of the Ahl al-Bayt; the son of Hazrat Husayn's grandson. Teacher of Imam-i A'zam Abu Hanifa and Imam Malik. A central name in the Sufi chains of transmission; a historical figure standing between the Shi'a's claim upon him and the respect of the Ahl al-Sunna. — Abu Nu'aym, Hilyat al-Awliya', III/192

Historical Claim — The Khazar Jews Thesis: Yalçın Küçük (1938-2021) — Turkish Marxist academic and writer. In works such as Tekeliyat (2003) and Şebeke / Network (2002), he put forward analyses claiming that some elites in Turkey were of Khazar Jewish origin. These are claims open to academic debate. — Y. Küçük, Tekeliyat: Eleştiri-Marksist Cumhuriyet Tarihi

Hadith — The Highest Form of Jihad: "The highest form of jihad is to speak a word of truth to the face of a tyrannical sultan." — Abu Dawud, Malahim, no. 4344; al-Tirmidhi, Fitan, no. 2174

Figure — Abu Dharr al-Ghifari (d. 32 AH / 652 CE): One of the closest Companions of the Messenger of Allah; in Damascus, at Mu'awiya's palace, he stood firm against the caliph on the matter of "the right of the poor," and was ultimately exiled to the desert of Rabadha, where he passed away. In the Sufi tradition, he is the exemplar of the type of "the scholar who speaks the word of truth with the sword at his neck." — Ibn Sa'd, al-Tabaqat al-Kubra, IV/219

The Martyrdom of Hazrat Husayn — Karbala (10 Muharram 61 AH / 10 October 680 CE): The besieging and martyrdom at Karbala of Hazrat Husayn, who refused to pledge allegiance to Yazid ibn Mu'awiya, together with a small group of 72 people. The failure of some Companions to support Hazrat Husayn has been debated throughout history from the standpoint of love for the Ahl al-Bayt. — Ibn al-Athir, al-Kamil fi'l-Tarikh; al-Tabari, Tarikh al-Rusul wa'l-Muluk

This text has been compiled in full detail from the 11th lesson of Mustafa Özbağ Efendi's «Questions on al-Ghazali» lecture series and re-edited to thesis quality. Source video: YouTube

Additional sources:

  • The Holy Qur'an, al-Nahl 16/125; the principle of inviting with wisdom and good counsel.
  • The Holy Qur'an, al-Ahzab 33/21; the Messenger of Allah being the fine example.
  • al-Nawawi, Riyad al-Salihin, chapters on taqwa, sincerity and good character.
  • Imam al-Ghazali, Ihya' 'Ulum al-Din, chapters on the training of the heart, ethics and sincerity.
  • al-Bukhari, chapters on Faith (Iman) and Heart-Softeners (Riqaq), narrations on intention, sincerity and character.
  • Muslim, chapter on Righteousness and Maintaining Ties (Birr wa'l-Sila), narrations on good character and brotherhood.
  • al-Tirmidhi, chapters on Righteousness and Maintaining Ties (Birr wa'l-Sila), Asceticism (Zuhd) and Supplications (Da'awat).
  • al-Nawawi, Riyad al-Salihin, chapters on sincerity, taqwa, dhikr and good character.
  • Ibn Hajar al-'Asqalani, Fath al-Bari, commentary on the relevant narrations of al-Bukhari.
  • al-Qushayri, al-Risala, discussions on the etiquette of Sufism, states and stations.