1. Was al-Ghazali a Project Man? The Difference Between a Court Scholar and a Scholar Who Thinks for the State
Al-Ghazali sets out the technique of this, but it is taught in the madrasas. But normally this is an interesting thing. Look, a separate study needs to be done on this. The Sufis of Anatolia are, generally speaking, Hanafi. They are not Shafi'i. I mean, in the Southeast and the East there are Shafi'is in very small numbers. Generally they are Hanafi. Now we are pulling the subject together from here. Again we come to the thing. What? We come to the paragraph. But he is a project man. The state bureaucracy commands and he carries it out. He has become a payroll cleric. Later he feels regret for this and confesses it. Now, was he a project man? Yes. But you expected me to say no. Is he a project man? Yes. Al-Ghazali project Some of this, you know, I do apologise very much, those who see themselves as Ghazalians will object, but that doesn't concern me, but this "yes" of mine is not a "yes, but".
There is no ordinary meaning in this. Well, partly he is a project man. I mean, what is this? A moment ago I told you about the pit the Umayyads fell into, right? Religion comes under the command of politics. Now when you look at the Islamic or non-Islamic states in the world, in all of them religion is under the command of the politicians. I mean, religion is under the command of states. An imposed religion is lived. The Christian, the Jew, the Muslim. There are over 4000 religions in the world, belief systems.
2. Chief Professor of the Nizamiyya Madrasas: Solutions to the State's Ideological Crises
Now al-Ghazali, under the patronage of Nizam al-Mulk, becomes the chief professor (mudarris) of the Nizamiyya madrasas.
He produces solutions to the state's ideological crises. Look, in my opinion this is something all states are in need of right now. Responding to the ideological crises of states and of their subjects. I mean, there is a capitalist system.
You will give an ideological answer against the capitalist system. You have an interest system. You will give an ideological answer against the interest system. There is a legal system. Corrupt, distorted, wrong. Arbitrary. You must give an ideological answer to this. Al-Ghazali does this.
Now when you think of it this way, al-Ghazali has done a magnificent job. But al-Ghazali is a project man, yet he is not a court scholar. I mean, how is he not a court scholar? I mean, he is the state's advisor. The state consults him, but, but he thinks for the state. Look, he thinks for the state. He is not under the command of the state. I underline this point again and again. Not the state's scholar, not under the state's command, but a person who thinks for the state. I mean, if you research all of al-Ghazali's books, you know, may Allah forgive me, I too have the mainstream books as, uh, thing, what's it, loaded on the computer. You know, 6 or 7 of them, including the Ihya'. I have them in my library, but, you know, there is the Ihya'. Then there are another 3 or 4 small treatises like that. There is that Falsafat al-... that book. I mean, normally, as a thing, you know, there are 6 or 7 of his books that are not in digital form, including the Ihya'.
But almost all of his books are on my computer, in my library. All of his major books that have been translated into Turkish. For example, you cannot find the following in al-Ghazali.
3. "The Sultan Is Not Infallible, the State Is Not Sacred"
I couldn't. That's why I took it down here as a note. The sultan. In al-Ghazali the sultan is not infallible. In al-Ghazali the head of state is not sacred. In al-Ghazali the state, too, is not absolute, it is not sacred.
It is an interesting thing. For example, al-Ghazali never, in any of his works or in his conduct, makes the caliph infallible either. I mean, what do I mean by caliph? The highest authority of the religion of Islam. Isn't that so? The caliphate is that in Islam. Why
Al-Ghazali saw their shortcomings and errors in the historical sense for that time. Because if we had brought Ibn Rushd instead of al-Ghazali, yes, this is one of the points where al-Ghazali stands sharply. Philosophically, al-Ghazali is defensive. On this point al-Ghazali, you know, as I said in the last lesson, you know, al-Ghazali does not have, you know, a philosophical opening within a very broad framework. But within the plane of that day, al-Ghazali or Ibn Rushd? Al-Ghazali. Because order has to be established. There has to be a fusion of state and nation. That's why, for example, al-Ghazali, the caliph as you know.
4. Not Making the Caliph Infallible: A Departure from the Umayyad-Abbasid-Fatimid-Shi'a Line
He does not regard the caliph as infallible. Whereas among the Umayyads, the Abbasids, the Fatimids, the Batinis, and the Shi'a, the caliph is infallible. Now, do you know what you face when you make the caliph infallible? The Pope is infallible too. Now if you make the caliph infallible, the caliph has the authority to abolish any legal matter of Islam. He is infallible. The Pope is the same. Only, that's why al-Ghazali stands on the line of the Qur'an and Sunna.
On matters of creed, too, he stands on the line of the Qur'an and Sunna. On matters of worship, too, he stands on the line of the Qur'an and Sunna. He brings the sultan and the state, too, to the line of the Qur'an and Sunna.
If the state is to be legitimate, it has to conform to the law of the Qur'an and Sunna. It has to be just. According to al-Ghazali, the legitimacy of the state passes through justice. And for al-Ghazali, the legitimacy of the sultan, too, passes through the Qur'an and Sunna and through justice.
5. The Payroll Cleric: Salary Dependence vs. the Limit of Contentment
That's why, you know, when these are laid out as such a clear line, I don't see him as a court scholar. Nor do I see him as a prisoner of the payroll, or as an agent of various channels. May Allah forgive me. Now when we say payroll cleric, technically, yes, he was receiving a salary. We don't deny that. Was he employed by the state? Yes. Like today's President of Religious Affairs. But will we, will I, this humble one, look at the matter here in terms of salary? Or will we look at the degree of dependence, or the point of dependence? I don't see it as salary dependence, but al-Ghazali is not a personality who would say yes to the errors of the state and of those who govern the state.
For example, if he had bent and twisted religion to legitimise the state, if he had bent and twisted religion, religious rulings, the law, to legitimise statesmen or the state bureaucracy, then I would say: a salaried payroll under the command of the state and of politics. So as not to lose his salary, he would have said "my lord" to whoever came and "my pasha" to whoever went. But it is not like that.
6. Severity Toward Tyrannical Sultans in the Ihya': "Al-Ghazali Buries the Merchants of Religion"
If he drew a boundary for the state in order to protect religion and the religious, religion's law of the state of that day, actually among the Seljuks there is no fully religious law. Because the state has various subjects. There are various laws. But if all subjects are treated at a legally equal level before the state, and if at this point the state's subjects can obtain their rights before the state's legal system, then I normally cannot look at him, I mean, as an agent of the state. Because when we look at the Ihya', for example, I'm illustrating this from the Ihya'.
There are very heavy accusations against sultans who commit oppression. For example, in the Ihya' there are very heavy words like this against those who act as sheikhs although they are not truly sheikhs. I mean, to put it in today's language, al-Ghazali buries the merchants of religion. Al-Ghazali buries the bureaucrats, the politicians, the sultans who make religion a screen for themselves and commit every kind of dishonour behind it. Looking at it this way, now when I look from here, al-Ghazali doesn't seem to me like he was, you know, an agent of the state.
Well of course this sort of thing isn't something payroll captives could do, is it? A scholar who is a payroll captive, I mean, gives whatever fatwa the state wants. You know what they say now, the payroll-captive scholars say that TOKİ's interest is not interest. These are examples. Payroll captive. What do the payroll captives say, for example? They say interest up to the rate of inflation is permissible. These are payroll captives. What does the payroll captive say? They say that if a woman is officially married to whoever she is married to, even if she goes around with 10 men her marriage still stands. I mean, her marriage, her official marriage, with whom? With person X, can the woman go around with a different man every night? She can. Does her marriage still stand? It stands, he says. Payroll captive. Well now, that being so, I mean, in al-Ghazali there are courageous words and deeds that would not befit payroll captives.
We continue.
7. The Refutation of the Batiniyya: "Pulling the Chair Out from Under Them"
Did he carry out what he was ordered to do? Against the Batiniyya, yes, he carried out what he was ordered to do.
He wrote a refutation. But anyone who looks even a little at the refutation he wrote, I mean, I would like you to examine that refutation against the Batiniyya. When you examine it, for example, it is not sloganeering at all; it is scholarly. He pulls the chair of legitimacy out from under the Batiniyya.
This is this humble one's assessment. I mean, I am not someone who has studied the Batiniyya in that way. When the question came, what did al-Ghazali say regarding the Batiniyya? Then I looked. I mean, that is my own assessment. I said, he pulled the chair, the seat they were sitting on, out from under them. I said, I mean, he doesn't refute you, but he pulls away the seat you're sitting on, and you topple over. Tremendous intelligence.
That is why, for example, al-Ghazali did not even declare the Batinis unbelievers (takfir). An interesting thing. Al-Ghazali has no takfirism. But if he had been at the command of the state, he would have declared them unbelievers.
8. "The Culture of Takfir": Al-Ghazali Does Not Declare Even the Batinis, the Fatimids or the Philosophers Unbelievers
Ah, now there are certain people who are at the command of the state.
What is there? There are Salafis, Wahhabis. Do they declare everyone unbelievers? They do. There is a famous tariqa in Turkey. Do its disciples declare people unbelievers? They do. Parties were founded in Turkey. Those who are declared unbelievers if they don't cast a vote for them.
Look, these are people fed from the same vent. From the same vent, I mean, they have their scholars. I mean, they have their tariqas, they have their politics. Now the scholars declare you an unbeliever if you are not on the same line. They steer you toward takfir. They have their sheikhs, and they too declare people unbelievers. They have their politicians, and they too declare people unbelievers. Look, a culture of takfir has formed in the country. And these takfiris were people fed from the same center. But al-Ghazali has no takfir against the Batinis, against the Ismailis, or against the Fatimids.
Isn't that an interesting thing? In fact, al-Ghazali does not even declare the philosophers unbelievers.
9. The Answer to the Philosophers — Tahafut al-Falasifa: Dismantling the Doctrine
Al-Ghazali's method is magnificent. He pulls at the chair they're sitting on. I mean, in Tahafut al-Falasifa (The Incoherence of the Philosophers), rendered in Turkish as an answer to the philosophers, in the Tahafut he dismantles the doctrine on which the philosophers are sitting.
He pulls the chair out from under them. He did the same with the Batinis. He did the same with the Ismailiyya. Going further, he did the same with the Shi'a of that day. That's how it is, and that is why they stone al-Ghazali so much anyway.
For example, there are certain schools that stone al-Ghazali. For example, the Shi'a stone al-Ghazali, modernist thought stones al-Ghazali. You know, someone said, "Ibn Rushd or al-Ghazali?" Yes. There is a debate about this, for example. They stone al-Ghazali. Whereas al-Ghazali, in his own time, in his own time, truly and truly did magnificent work. Today we can criticise. And the Seljuks, I mean Alp Arslan.
10. Tughril Beg, Alp Arslan and the Nizamiyya Madrasas: "Had It Not Been for the Turks, There Would Be No Islam"
Before Alp Arslan, his uncle Tughril.
Look, these are historical facts. These are historical facts. If it had not been for Tughril's, uh, love of jihad and fighting, his courage, his prudence, Tughril's, Alp Arslan's defence of Islam, defence of the homeland, defence of the state and strengthening of the state, and, connected with this, the Nizamiyya madrasas and al-Ghazali, you would not exist today. I am saying this very seriously.
On the plane of that day, if these crazy Turks, those Turks who played with death without batting an eye, who, so to speak, mocked death, had not existed, call this racism if you like. I don't care at all. If those Turks had not existed, the Islamic world would right now be a slave before Byzantium.
Note: This text is the speech itself as found in the recording of the sohbet: only spelling and punctuation have been edited, and obvious mishearings in the subtitles have been corrected; a few unintelligible passages have been left as heard. Section headings have been added for ease of reading. The opening and closing prayers have not been included.
Bibliography
Work: Imam al-Ghazali, Ihya' 'Ulum al-Din (The Revival of the Religious Sciences) — Sections on the severe stance against tyrannical sultans and merchants of religion
Work: Imam al-Ghazali, Tahafut al-Falasifa (The Incoherence of the Philosophers) — Critique of Greek philosophy from the standpoint of Islamic coherence
Work: Imam al-Ghazali, Fada'ih al-Batiniyya / al-Mustazhiri — Scholarly refutation of the Batini-Ismaili doctrine
Work: Imam al-Ghazali, al-Munqidh min al-Dalal (Deliverance from Error) — Autobiographical work: withdrawal from the Nizamiyya madrasa into seclusion, and remorse
Historical Context: Nizam al-Mulk (1018-1092), Siyasatnama (Siyar al-Muluk) — As Seljuk vizier he founded the Nizamiyya madrasas and appointed al-Ghazali chief professor at the Nizamiyya Madrasa of Baghdad (484 AH / 1091 CE). — The state–madrasa–scholar relationship in the Seljuk period
Historical Context: Tughril Beg (1038-1063), Alp Arslan (1063-1072) — The Anatolian conquests of the Seljuk dynasty along the Sunni-Hanafi line; Manzikert 1071. Impartial academic source: O. Turan, Selçuklular Târihi ve Türk-İslâm Medeniyeti (History of the Seljuks and Turkish-Islamic Civilisation) — The historical ground of the Turkish-Islamic synthesis
This text has been compiled from the 1st lesson of Mustafa Özbağ Efendi's lecture series "Questions on al-Ghazali" and re-edited to thesis quality. Source video: YouTube
Additional sources:
- The Holy Qur'an, al-Nahl 16:125; the principle of calling with wisdom and good counsel.
- The Holy Qur'an, al-Ahzab 33:21; the Messenger of Allah as the beautiful example.
- al-Nawawi, Riyad al-Salihin, chapters on taqwa, sincerity and good character.
- Imam al-Ghazali, Ihya' 'Ulum al-Din, chapters on the training of the heart, ethics and sincerity.
- al-Bukhari, Books of Faith (Iman) and Heart-Softeners (Riqaq), narrations on intention, sincerity and character.
- Muslim, Book of Righteousness and Maintaining Family Ties (Birr wa al-Sila), narrations on good character and brotherhood.
- al-Tirmidhi, chapters on Righteousness and Maintaining Family Ties (Birr wa al-Sila), Asceticism (Zuhd) and Supplications (Da'awat).
- al-Nawawi, Riyad al-Salihin, chapters on sincerity, taqwa, dhikr and good character.
- Ibn Hajar al-'Asqalani, Fath al-Bari, commentary on the relevant narrations of al-Bukhari.
- al-Qushayri, al-Risala, discussions of the etiquette of Sufism, states and stations.