1. «To Be Against Reason Is to Be Against Fitra»: al-Ghazali Did Not Pour Concrete over Reason
Is he someone who poured concrete over reason in Islam, who put an end to free thought, who was almost hostile to philosophy, who bequeathed us literalism (naqli-ism), or is he one of the greatest architects of thought in the Sunni Islamic world, a scholar of such stature that people would say, "If all the books on Islam were lost and only the Ihya' remained, it would be enough"?
Yes to all of them, and no to all of them.
Pouring concrete over reason in Islam. That is, in fact al-Ghazali is actually against the worship of reason. It is not possible for al-Ghazali, or an Islamic scholar, or a Sufi, to go against reason.
To be against reason is to be against man's fitra (innate nature). To be against reason is to be against the essence of religion. Against the fitra of religion. This is not possible.
2. Some Sufis Ranking Reason Below Transmitted Knowledge Is Not Killing Reason
For example, some Sufis holding reason ('aql) below transmitted knowledge (naql) is not killing reason. Because when it comes to belief, transmitted knowledge comes first. Reason does not come first.
Reason exists in order to understand the transmitted knowledge. Reason exists in order to live the transmitted knowledge. Reason exists in order to analyse the transmitted knowledge. Reason exists in order to derive ijtihad from the transmitted knowledge. Ijtihad without reason is not ijtihad. It is reason that will understand the transmitted knowledge, that is, that will understand revelation. Because revelation is for those who possess reason. Revelation is for the one who thinks, who perceives, who investigates.
3. Passing Revelation Through the Filter of Reason: «99% of People Possess a Plain Reason»
Revelation, for example, the one who possesses a plain reason has difficulty understanding revelation, and 99% of all believers possess a plain reason.
That is, they are imitators (muqallid). They are not verifiers (muhaqqiq).
Since Adam, the great majority of believers have been far from analysing revelation. They are far from deriving ijtihad from revelation. They are far from understanding the true meaning of revelation. This is the greatest handicap of all believers since Adam. And that is why the great majority of people also fail to reach the reality of faith.
Pay attention, I am not saying they have not believed. They have not reached the reality of faith.
4. «The Prophets' Greatest Battle Is with the People of Religion»: Religion as the Prop of Tyrants
Because people have not passed revelation through the filter of the reason of the heart and of the present reason.
And the prophets' greatest battles are with the people of religion. Look, the people of religion, because religion belongs to Allah. Religion belongs to Allah, but religion becomes a prop for tyrants so as to rule people easily. Those who do not use their reason. If the minds of people who do not perceive revelation through the filter of reason, whose hearts are already not working, have gone blind, also do not work, then they remain far from understanding revelation, from analysing revelation, from living revelation.
5. Exploiters of Religion Who Remove the Safety of Reason
Then people of various appearances who exploit religion come before those people and remove the safety of their reason, and those people become unable to think correctly, unable to reason correctly.
Now, when we look at al-Ghazali, al-Ghazali does not pour concrete over reason. He speaks ahead of the people of his own time.
6. The Chain of Muhyiddin Ibn Arabi: Ibn Arabi → al-Ghazali → al-Kindi → Imam Abu Hanifa (al-Imam al-A'zam)
Like al-Tirmidhi, like Ibn Arabi. Now this may seem strange to you. You do not look at al-Ghazali from the direction of Ibn Arabi. For example, when you look at Ibn Arabi's spiritual chain, al-Ghazali has a very great influence on Ibn Arabi. This seems strange to everybody. Now it seems strange to the one who asked this question too. Now, for example, in Ibn Arabi's Fusus, in his Futuhat, especially in the Futuhat, there are many quotations from al-Ghazali.
That line, you know, Ibn Arabi, then al-Ghazali, before al-Ghazali al-Kindi, that is a chain, for example.
It is like the links of a chain. That chain, when you look at the links of the chain, when you go to Ibn Arabi you see al-Ghazali behind him, when you go to al-Ghazali you see al-Kindi behind him, when you go to al-Kindi you see the Salaf (the early generations). But who is the greatest imam of the Salaf? It is al-Imam al-A'zam (Abu Hanifa). The state system of the time martyred him. The state that martyred him presents itself as Islam. Pay attention.
7. «I Do Not See al-Ghazali as Someone Who Poured Concrete over Reason»: A Diagnosis of Jealousy
Now, when we look at al-Ghazali, I do not see him as someone who covered, poured concrete over reason in Islam. But in fact, are there people in the Islamic world who see it that way? Yes.
I see this somewhat as jealousy. That is, I see it as a failure to understand al-Ghazali. For example, yes, all the Islamic scholars are in agreement. On this matter, they hold revelation ahead of reason. Pay attention. They hold revelation ahead of reason. That is, on this point, whichever Islamic scholar or Sufi you go to, he will hold revelation first.
8. «Holding Revelation First in a Bigoted Way»: Those Who Think Allah Has a Hand Like a Human
However, this holding of revelation first, in some of them, I very much apologise, I put this in parentheses, I cannot find another word for it. They hold revelation first in a bigoted way.
As an example of those who hold revelation first in a bigoted way, there are those who think Allah has a hand like a human. This example is holding revelation first in a bigoted way. Things like this.
That is why, in fact, for me revelation is always ahead of reason. At that moment your reason may have difficulty understanding revelation, analysing it, resolving it like this, understanding what it actually means. Because revelation, that is, the Qur'an, is, uh, never at the point you know it to be.
9. The Outward and Inward Faces of the Qur'an: «It Is Never at the Point You Know It to Be»
That is, because the Qur'an, the verses have a visible face, an apparent face. This is established by hadith. And there is also an invisible, inward (batini) face.
That is why, if a person cannot see the inward face of the verses of the Qur'an, if he does not know their inward exegesis, that person remains at the outward (zahir) when looking at the verses of the Qur'an. And when he remains at the outward, again, forgive my expression, he remains bigoted. You see a bigotry there, right there. I agree on this, but a person who does not know that the Qur'an has an outward and an inward, that the verses of the Qur'an have different aspects, different depths, different heights, look, different heights, that a single word contains very different meanings, yes, such a person looks at the verses of the Qur'an only from the outward point.
On some points, bigotry emerges from this.
10. «The True People of the Qur'an Do Not Pour Concrete over Their Reason»
And the person of reason who sees that bigotry says, "Look, these people," he says, "look, they are like this." Are they right? They are right. But the true people of the Qur'an never pour concrete over their reason. This is not possible. Because if you look at the inward aspect of any verse of the Qur'an, it again wants to go deeper into it.
Now this moves beyond scepticism. It wants to deepen as it deepens, to rise higher as it rises.
Then what will perceive that deepening, that rising, that widening, what will comprehend it, is, after the reason of the heart, the present reason. Because the reason of the heart has all the knowledge it has received, all the knowledge, including inspiration (ilham), preserved by the present reason, and has the present reason trained in it. That being so, it is not possible for a person, in fact, to reject this reason.
11. The Reason of the Sufi: «The Reason of the Heart Nourishes the Present Reason; It Is Always at Work»
Indeed, that reason takes those filters, those manifestations of revelation (wahy), those manifestations of inspiration (ilham), and draws one huge picture. And while drawing that picture, it draws it with its reason. It analyses. After analysing, it puts a question mark there again. "I wonder?" it says.
The more it says "I wonder," the more new knowledge comes. Because that person, this is the reason of the Sufi. Let me make a note of this on the side as well. This is the reason of the Sufi. Because every state (hal) is transient. And within the state too there is depth. You cannot remain stuck in that state.
All inspirations are transient. Inspiration too has a depth. Every inspiration that comes, you take it and accept it, but it takes you to another veil. You submit yourself again to its manifestations at another veil, in another form. This is the reason of the Sufi.
So then the heart of the Sufi and the reason of the Sufi are always at work. It is always operating. Because they are always at work, always operating, and they also, that is, because the reason of the heart nourishes the normal reason, they are always at work. They are always drawing new pictures, and breaking them down.
12. The Only Limit of Free Thought: «Contemplating the Essence of Allah»
That being so, when this matter is looked at in Islam, that is, from a Sufi perspective, I cannot see al-Ghazali as concrete poured over reason in Islam, or as a person pouring concrete.
Secondly, the one who ended free thought. What are we to understand by free thought? We need to look at what we would understand as free thought. What should we understand by free thought?
For example, I see the only place where free thought is limited as contemplating the Essence of Allah. That is, our limit stops at contemplating the Essence of Allah. Otherwise, personally, I do not recognise any other limit when it comes to free thought.
Note: This text is the talk itself as given in the recording of the sohbet (spiritual discourse): only spelling and punctuation have been edited, and obvious mishearings in the subtitles have been corrected; a few unclear passages have been left as heard. Section headings have been added for ease of reading. The opening and closing prayers have not been included.
Bibliography
Hadith — The Prohibition on Contemplating the Essence of Allah: «Contemplate what Allah has created; do not contemplate the Essence of Allah. For you cannot bear the majesty of Allah.» — al-Bayhaqi, Shu'ab al-Iman, no. 119; Abu Nu'aym, Hilyat al-Awliya', VI/67
Hadith — The Renewers (Mujaddids): «At the beginning of every century, Allah sends to this community one who will renew its religious affairs for it.» — Abu Dawud, Malahim, no. 4291
Work — The Science of the Outward and the Inward of the Qur'an: Imam al-Ghazali, Jawahir al-Qur'an (Jewels of the Qur'an) — the inward layers of meaning of the verses of the Qur'an; Ibn Arabi (Muhyiddin Ibn Arabi), al-Futuhat al-Makkiyya and Fusus al-Hikam — the Sufi tradition of exegesis that continues with quotations from al-Ghazali — Corpus of inward (batini) exegesis
Hadith — The Outward and the Inward of the Qur'an: «The Qur'an has an outward (zahir) and an inward (batin); and its inward has an inward, up to seven inward levels.» — Ibn Hibban, Sahih, no. 75; al-Suyuti, al-Durr al-Manthur
Philosophical Line — The Chain of al-Kindi, al-Ghazali, Ibn Arabi: Ya'qub ibn Ishaq al-Kindi (d. AH 256 / 873 CE) — the first Muslim philosopher; an attempt, under Mu'tazila influence, to reconcile Greek philosophy with Islamic creed. Criticised in al-Ghazali's Tahafut al-Falasifa via al-Farabi and Ibn Sina. Traces of al-Ghazali's conceptual world are found in Muhyiddin Ibn Arabi's Futuhat. — H. Z. Ülken, İslâm Felsefesi Tarihi (History of Islamic Philosophy)
Historical Event — The Martyrdom of Imam-i A'zam: Imam-i A'zam Abu Hanifa, who refused the Caliph Abu Ja'far al-Mansur's offer of the post of judge, was imprisoned and flogged, and died in the prison of Baghdad in AH 150 (767 CE). According to some sources, he was poisoned. A classic example of the type of "the scholar martyred by the state system." — al-Khatib al-Baghdadi, Tarikh Baghdad, XIII/367
The Science of Sufism — The Reason of the Heart and the Present Reason: Two layers of reason in Sufi psychology: 1) The present reason ('aql al-ma'ash, partial reason) — the logical reason that operates with the senses and concepts; 2) The reason of the heart (universal reason, 'aql al-qalb) — the spiritual rank that can receive revelation and inspiration directly. A matter treated in the line of Hakki Bursevi and al-Junayd of Baghdad. — I. Hakki Bursevi, Ruh al-Bayan; A. Schimmel, Mystical Dimensions of Islam
Sufi Concept — The Transience of States and Manifestations: On the Sufi path every state (intoxication, sobriety, love, fear, hope, contraction, expansion, etc.) is transient; the seeker does not remain stuck in a state, but passes on to deeper manifestations. The dynamic understanding of the triad "moment–state–station" (waqt–hal–maqam). — al-Qushayri, Risala; A. Süleyman Erbani, Tasavvuf Terimleri (Terms of Sufism)
This text has been compiled in full detail from the 13th lesson of Mustafa Özbağ Efendi's «Questions from al-Ghazali» lecture series and re-edited to thesis standard. Source video: YouTube