Sunday, November 15, 2026
OUR PATH IS THE PATH OF PROPHETHOOD
Mustafa Özbağ
Irshad & Tasawwuf · Official Site
al-Ghazali Talks·

The Limits of Reason and the Authority of Revelation | Questions on al-Ghazali 9

Translated from Turkish. Original article (Turkish) →
Note: Qur'anic verses in this article are marked and will be completed with the Diyanet English translation; the Turkish original is linked above.

1. This Week's Text: Montgomery Watt's Interpretation of al-Ghazali

Yes.

We are continuing from where we left off last week, from the passage, or the paragraph, whatever you want to call it. Montgomery Watt, one of the professors in the Department of Arabic and Islamic Studies at the University of Edinburgh in Britain, states that al-Ghazali was in reality greatly influenced by the Greek sciences and by Greek philosophy.

In his book Muslim Intellectual, Montgomery Watt says the following: "Al-Ghazali, without any hesitation, accepts what is Qur'anic and rejects what is philosophical. Al-Ghazali would not even have consented to the philosophers saying, as al-Farabi also said, that the Qur'an, that Qur'anic concepts, are symbolic concepts put forward for ordinary people who do not understand the more abstract language of philosophy. In parentheses, Watt 2017. In the end, Ibn Rushd (Averroes) wins the debates on the intellectual level but loses on the political plane. Because the caliphs, sultans, kings, padishahs, sheikhs and emirs of the Islamic world support al-Ghazali. Consequently, in the shaping of religion-state-society relations in Turkish and Muslim countries, the historical ground, experience and tradition left by the Seljuk state reach down to the present day by way of the Ottoman State and its culture. Yes, God willing, we will continue from here.

Of course, what is at issue here is Montgomery Watt's observation, the distinction between al-Ghazali, al-Farabi and Ibn Rushd. Most importantly, I thought of separating out the thesis that Ibn Rushd won intellectually and al-Ghazali won politically.

Because this too is a thesis, Montgomery's own way of thinking. So first of all there is a basic claim here. This basic claim needs to be interpreted. What is it? It is this, in the passage on Montgomery Watt's interpretation of al-Ghazali: al-Ghazali, without any hesitation, accepts what is Qur'anic and rejects what is philosophical.

2. What Does It Mean to Say "He Accepts What Is Qur'anic"?

I mean, if this sentence explaining al-Ghazali's thought is taken like that, you know, if you took it as a kind of, uh, cliché. You published it, you said it. Normally this reduced al-Ghazali to something very simple, and normally it is a simplifying statement.

I mean, when we look at it from their perspective, otherwise, when you say al-Ghazali takes and accepts what is Qur'anic, it is not possible anyway for a Muslim to do anything other than that.

Because if a person has believed, he must take and accept something that is Qur'anic, which is the Book of Allah. He cannot reject it. If he rejects it, he falls into unbelief. So there is nothing more natural than al-Ghazali accepting something that is Qur'anic.

Today, under normal conditions, let me put it in quotation marks like this. Wherever you go in the Islamic world, something that is Qur'anic has to be accepted. One may or may not be able to live by it, may or may not understand it, but one accepts it. This is something that faith requires. But normally, of course, before rejecting philosophy, al-Ghazali was someone who researched philosophy very seriously.

3. What Did al-Ghazali Do Before Rejecting? Maqasid al-Falasifa

I mean, normally, al-Ghazali's research into philosophy, in that age, at that point, within that sphere, is something magnificent.

And this kind of research al-Ghazali did into philosophy, his having this much knowledge about it, we again know from his works. Because in his work called Maqasid al-Falasifa (The Aims of the Philosophers), al-Ghazali sets out the views of the philosophers systematically. I mean, normally, if he had not gone over philosophy with a fine-tooth comb to this extent, he would not set out the system of philosophy in his own work. Normally, after this work was published, for a long time it was regarded not as al-Ghazali's own views but as a study transmitting the views of the philosophers.

I mean, the intellectual world of that day did not see it as a work of al-Ghazali; that is, it perceived it as a book transmitting the views of the philosophers, written by someone other than al-Ghazali.

4. The Order in Which the Books Were Written: First the Maqasid, Then the Tahafut

Someone who has such mastery of Aristotle or of the other European, Greek, Hellenic philosophy, who has in-depth knowledge about it, and normally, after that, he writes Tahafut al-Falasifa (The Incoherence of the Philosophers). Look, you know, the order in which the books were written is also very important.

When you look at their dates, in a sequence, first, in Maqasid al-Falasifa, he normally sets out the system of whatever there is relating to philosophy.

From here, he is, you know, a magnificent person who thoroughly researched the philosophy and the philosophical world especially of Aristotle, of Ibn Rushd, of Ibn Sina, in my view at this point, and of all those contemporaries who appeared as the intellectual class of the Western world of that day, or of those before his own age, and who set out its system. What comes next? Next comes Tahafut al-Falasifa. I mean, in Tahafut al-Falasifa, so to speak, he goes over Aristotelian philosophy and the Hellenic, Greek, European philosophy there, so to speak, like a steamroller.

He goes over it like a steamroller. When we look at this, then, al-Ghazali has a path of knowledge of his own. A path of knowledge. This is very important. Look, this is also very important in the Islamic world.

5. A Principle: Learn, Analyze, Then Critique

This is very important in Sufism too. This is very important in trade too. Whatever work you do, this sequence is very important. You might say, are you getting to these points from al-Ghazali? Yes. Take this as a principle for yourselves. There is a matter, an event, a task in front of you.

First, learn it well. Learning it well is very important.

After learning it, analyze it. You have learned something. If you don't learn it, you cannot analyze it. This point is very important. First you will learn. After learning, you will analyze it.

After analyzing it, you will look at it with scholarly doubt and approach it critically. But if you don't learn it, if you can't analyze it, you cannot approach that matter critically. This could be a book, it could be an event, it could normally be any piece of knowledge, it could be any trade.

It could be something related to social life. It could be something related to cultural life. Here, this humble one's (faqir's) observation is that al-Ghazali normally first learns philosophy, first. Then he analyzes philosophy. After analyzing it, he writes Tahafut al-Falasifa. That is, he critiques it. And while critiquing, he reaches a conclusion. What is the conclusion? He comes to the point of rejecting certain matters. But while rejecting, he has the basic knowledge in hand.

When he rejects, he rejects in a scholarly way. In a scholarly way. So it is a measure for all of us. I took this as a measure for myself. In the measure I have taken for myself, first and foremost you need to learn. Then, after learning, you need to analyze the matter you have learned. After analyzing it, you will come to the point of putting forward a scholarly critique. Then you will write your refutation of it.

6. The Deficiency of the Last Two Hundred Years: Rejecting Without Learning

But, I say this in quotation marks, for the last 300 years or the last 200 years, one of the deficiencies in the Islamic world and in all of us is this: we do not learn about a community.

We do not analyze that community. And then we reject it directly. Just as in today's Turkey all the Sufis are rejected, or the people of dhikr are rejected, or all the communities and tariqas are stuffed into one sack and all of them rejected, or just as we reject certain groups.

May Allah forgive us. That is why al-Ghazali is not, in fact, someone who rejects without learning and without analyzing.

He learns, he analyzes. After analyzing, he determines which points he will reject. Which points he will reject. When things are presented this way, we end up placing al-Ghazali in the position of an ignorant person who rejects philosophy outright without knowing it.

Or else it becomes like certain people who, in quotation marks, see themselves as religious scholars rejecting the whole of philosophy, which would be an ignorant thing to do. That is, we need to determine the points we are going to reject.

Or a person, or an institution, an organization, or a community, or a religious or national movement: first we need to learn about it. We need to analyze it. Then we need to find the parts that are to be rejected. Then we need to reject it. That is why, here, while al-Ghazali rejects certain parts of philosophy, while he criticizes them, he takes that stance because he knows very well the logic and concepts the philosophers used. That is, he analyzed the logic of the philosopher he examined. That is, he first learned Aristotle. Then he analyzed him. Then he set out wherever Aristotle was to be objected to. Or Ibn Rushd took directly from Aristotle. He read Aristotle by way of Ibn Rushd. He learned it. After that, he analyzed it. After analyzing it, he wrote a refutation of it.

Well now, this being the case, portraying al-Ghazali like this, as a typical religious scholar who is against the whole of philosophy, would be a great injustice. May Allah forgive us. (Amin.) And the most critical point is this idea of al-Ghazali rejecting philosophy completely. Because there is such an expression in the passage. That is, al-Ghazali does not reject philosophy completely. Unfortunately, they want it to be rejected.

7. Al-Ghazali Does Not Reject the Whole of Philosophy

He does not reject it, but he rejects what needs to be rejected. That is why, normally, if you can gather it together from the previous talks, if you can remember, I too am trying to gather it together and remember. When we look, for example, when we look at the Tahafut al-Falasifa (The Incoherence of the Philosophers), the criticisms he directs at the philosophers are not aimed at the entire field of philosophy.

Well, not at the entire field. Well now, he did not reject the entire field. There are 3 or 4 points to be rejected. He rejected those. Well, if you normally get up and say that al-Ghazali rejected all of philosophy, then, I beg your pardon, even if you are a professor, you will have committed an act of ignorance.

Even if you are a professor, it shows that you have not examined al-Ghazali's most important works, Maqasid al-Falasifa (The Aims of the Philosophers) and the Tahafut al-Falasifa. Or you skimmed through them superficially and moved on. You read them, you did not understand them, you could not analyze them. You could not analyze what al-Ghazali rejected there, and what exactly. May Allah protect us.

8. Mathematics and Logic: He Did Not Reject Them, He Put Them into the Madrasa

That is why, on this point, al-Ghazali thinks differently from the philosophers' attitudes regarding mathematics and also logic.

There is no rule that he must necessarily think as they do. That is why, for al-Ghazali, for example, if you take an error in mathematics and put it into religion, that error will also be misunderstood within religion.

Or if you take an error in logic, an error in Aristotle's logic, and put it into religion, as Ibn Rushd did, as Ibn Sina (Avicenna) did, then you cannot find the correct point of this matter. Yes. A Qur'anic stance is needed. The Qur'an is clear. The noble Sunna is clear. You are a Muslim. We are Muslim believers, and if you accept the inconsistencies of the philosophers, then you end up outside the religion. On this point, al-Ghazali thinks differently from the philosophers regarding his understanding of logic or his understanding of mathematics, logic, because, or his understanding related to the universe. By thinking differently, he puts forward that thought of his. But then al-Ghazali also puts the understanding of mathematics and logic he put forward into the madrasas.

He does not fail to put this into the madrasas. That being so, normally, al-Ghazali's mathematics is not the philosophers' mathematics, and likewise his logic is not the philosophers' logic. He develops a logic within the framework of Islam, the Qur'an and the Sunna, a systematic mathematics within the framework of the Qur'an and the Sunna. Al-Ghazali puts this into the madrasas.

9. The Claim That «Al-Ghazali Is an Enemy of Reason»

And normally, portraying al-Ghazali as an enemy of reason, or portraying the Sufis as enemies of reason, is the view of those who overstep the bounds and who harbor a certain grudge.

That is, we do not hold reason above revelation.

We use reason in understanding revelation and the noble Sunna. We use reason in understanding religion and in living religion. We do not deify our reason and regard it as above revelation. Al-Ghazali's stance here is that he holds revelation superior. That he sees reason as the servant of revelation and makes reason a servant to revelation. That he makes his reason a servant to the Qur'an and the Sunna.

That he makes mathematics a servant to the Qur'an and the Sunna, makes logic a servant to the Qur'an and the Sunna. If al-Ghazali is criticized for this, then this criticism is an empty criticism, an ignorant criticism. And that is why al-Ghazali is not an enemy of reason. I say this in quotation marks.

No Islamic scholar who knows himself can be an enemy of reason. Likewise, a, in quotation marks, true Sufism that knows itself cannot be an enemy of reason. The reason we are hostile to has to do with the fools who set out to criticize revelation, who look upon revelation with doubt, who hold their reason above revelation. Look, it has to do with the fools who hold their reason above revelation. We reject their foolishness. Why should we reject their reason? That is, for that reason he accepts reason. Al-Ghazali accepts their reason.

10. The Domain Where Reason Has No Authority: Mana (the Spiritual Meaning)

But al-Ghazali does not accept reason's authority over what people today, you know, regard as metaphysical, what we, you know, describe as hal (spiritual state) or mana (spiritual meaning). There, reason has no authority. There, the reason of the heart operates. Because there, ordinary reason has no faculty. If you went today and said, "In the state of dhikrullah, on a different veil, we see the noble Prophet."

If you said, "We speak with the noble Prophet, sallallahu alayhi wa sallam," for someone else, someone who does not know this, it is metaphysical. He rejects it. Sheikhs reject it too. Why? They have no such states. Because, or if we were to say that normally, in the interpretation of dreams, reason becomes like a donkey stuck in the mud.

The reason is that the interpretation of dreams has to do with mana. With whom is this possible? Only a person who has passed through the spiritual training and teaching of a sheikh can interpret this. I mean, can you imagine? I am not saying this to belittle it or to exalt myself.

There is a reality. In the dergah (Sufi lodge) of the great Abdullah Gürbüz Efendi, the interpretation of dreams and spiritual states existed only in this humble servant. No one else had it. Because it is spiritual. That is, it has to do with the metaphysical. That is, it has to do with the reason of the heart. It has nothing to do with ordinary reason. Or the states seen in dhikrullah have nothing to do with ordinary reason. They have to do with the reason of the heart. They have to do with the working of the heart. Now, 99.9% of the sheikhs with ijaza (authorization) who say "I am a sheikh" have no knowledge of these things. Look, I am giving a very big figure.

99.9% have no knowledge of these things. Al-Ghazali stops reason there.

11. Al-Ghazali Says to Reason: «Know Your Limits»

He says, "O reason, you cannot obtain any knowledge from this realm of mana. The realm of mana is a special domain.

12. The Two Meanings of the Qur'an: The Outward (Zahir) and the Inward (Batin)

Do not talk here as if you had authority on your own, as if you had influence. Know your limits," he says. Because this place has to do with mana. What does this place have to do with? It has to do with the heart. What does this place have to do with? So to speak, it has to do with the events we call dreams. What does this place have to do with? The Qur'an has a literal interpretation. And it also has an interpretation of the heart. It has two meanings. The Qur'an and the noble Sunna. The hadiths and the verses have two meanings. There is an outward (zahir) meaning. And there is also an inward (batin) meaning. Then reason cannot rule over the inward meaning. What al-Ghazali means here, the point where he stops, is this. Well, of course, someone who has no knowledge of mana, in quotation marks a prof, a dr, or I don't know, a sheikh, a murshid, call him whatever you like, when he hears these things he reaches the point of rejecting them. He rejects them. He says such a thing does not happen. Such a thing cannot be.

13. Socrates Accepts Inspiration, the «Allama» Does Not

When you look at philosophy, the philosophers accept mana. Al-Ghazali rejects the way the philosophers accept mana. Today, if you go to Socrates, Socrates accepts the intuition of the heart and says that this is a path of knowledge, he says.

They call it intuition in a person's heart; its name is inspiration (ilham). Socrates accepts inspiration. Look, Socrates accepts inspiration.

But I am saying this in quotation marks. Great big professors do not accept inspiration. Or great big sheikhs, with an ijaza as solid as a door, do not accept inspiration. That is, because they do not know mana, because they are not acquainted with it, they do not accept it. One of our friends, it has been 5-6 years now. He said, so-and-so wants to give me sheikhhood, he said. Don't leave us, I said; he can give it to a friend. What do you say, he said to me.

14. A Memory: «How Are You Going to Be a Sheikh?»

I said, brother, I said, you do not see any state in the circle of dhikrullah.

You have no state. In the circle, I said, you do not see the Prophet (peace be upon him), the Pir Efendis, the sheikh Efendis. You have no conversation with them. You have no exchange of ideas, no exchange of words with them. I said, there is no dream interpretation. How are you going to be a sheikh, I said. Moreover, I said, even the one who is going to give you sheikhhood is not a sheikh. I did not know at that time who he was. He called me on the phone. That was that. Well, he may give it to you, I said. He gave it, and then Cafer said. He gave it to him, he said. Sheikhhood, he said. I was amazed; so he gave it, I said.

Whereas he has no knowledge of mana. How will someone who has no knowledge of mana be a sheikh? This is the point where al-Ghazali stops here. He says to the philosophers, "You have no knowledge of mana.

You have no knowledge of dreams. Mana has to do with dreams. Well, you have no knowledge of it. There is no interpretation of it. You do not see anyway. You do not see. How will you guide the one who sees? You do not see. How will you guide the one who sees? This is the point where al-Ghazali stops. Allah knows best. That is why, normally, al-Ghazali here rejects the authority of reason in mana. That is, in today's language, he rejects the authority of reason in metaphysics. He says, "Yes, reason is for understanding metaphysics. It is not for ruling over metaphysics. For example, you see a dream. Isn't that so? You slept at night. When you slept, you saw a dream. The one who sees the dream has to do with the heart. And look where that dream takes the memory. It takes it to the memory in the ordinary brain. And reason, look, reason has difficulty interpreting it. The reason is that it is not a domain it knows. It is not a domain it has learned. It cannot interpret it. That person tries to interpret it on his own. Did it mean this, did it mean that?

This happens with all dervishes. Now, of course, what else is there? What do you call it? Artificial intelligence? There is also artificial intelligence.

15. Can Artificial Intelligence Be a Sheikh?

Now some brothers write to artificial intelligence. They get the answer from artificial intelligence.

Then they write to me. I saw such-and-such in my dream, they say. And I write, this is like this, that is like that. One of them could not hold back and jumped in. He said, "You are a notch above artificial intelligence, efendim."

He said. And I wrote. "Is your sheikh artificial intelligence, I said? What did you do? You wrote that.

Tomorrow or the day after, they will make artificial intelligence a sheikh anyway. A man will say there is no need for a sheikh. Why? There is artificial intelligence. I write my dream, I get its interpretation.

How will you get the interpretation of what you saw in the circle of dhikrullah from artificial intelligence? Artificial intelligence does not even know you.

I know you. Did you see the dream under some influence? Did you want something very much and then see the dream? I know you. I also know what you want and what you do not want. We also know your problem. Don't wonder whose problem among us he knows. Don't worry. He knows the ins and outs of the dream you saw. You know it, praise be to Allah. Now, that is why, that is, there is a great conflict between al-Farabi and al-Ghazali.

16. The Conflict Between al-Farabi and al-Ghazali

In al-Farabi, philosophy is the rational investigation of truth, the rational pursuit of truth.

In al-Farabi, philosophy, and al-Farabi establishes a very strong relationship between religion and philosophy. That is, normally, because, for example, the books of al-Farabi and Ibn Rushd spread throughout the Islamic world in those years without being examined like this at all, without being researched, without being looked at from a critical standpoint.

This is one of the greatest handicaps.

A philosophical truth can be rational and at the same time something that is not concrete, something abstract. It can also be rational. Religion, however, religion gathers and collects all truths within itself and conveys them to people through stories, through examples, in a language people can understand. For example, when you look at the Noble Qur'an, in the Noble Qur'an there are the stories of past prophets. That is, some people normally, to hurt the Noble Qur'an, I am saying, to insult it. A notch above that, to reject it. If they are a notch above that, their attitude toward the Noble Qur'an is like this. You hear this too: the Noble Qur'an is a book of legends recounting legends from past prophets. You hear these things. Isn't that so? You know, the Qur'an is a book of legends. It tells you the circumstances of past prophets. So what do you understand from that anyway? Whereas religion explains matters through edifying stories, in a language all people can understand. For the Sufis this is very important.

17. Is the Qur'an a «Book of Legends»?

It explains things and matters that cannot be untangled, that ordinary reason cannot perceive, through an event, through an edifying story, and this is the way of the Qur'an. This is Qur'anic. For example, a person tells an edifying story of something that happened to his sheikh.

He tells an edifying story about his relationship with his sheikh. Or he recounts the event through an edifying story that his sheikh, or his sheikh's sheikh, or that one's sheikh, or that one's sheikh actually lived through. The Qur'an says it in the same way. You know how it says: mention Moses too, mention the prophets too. There is a verse of the Qur'an. Mention what? The events that befell them, or, in the language used today by those who want to belittle it, call them stories. Normally they are told to people as a parable, as an example. Religion is understandable. Because philosophy is not understandable in every respect.

But religion is understood. Everyone understands religion according to their own knowledge, according to their own capacity, but they do not understand philosophy. That is why religion has gathered within itself all the truths that came before it and that will come after it. The Qur'an and the Sunnah.

18. The Time That Religion Encompasses, the Time That Philosophy Cannot Encompass

The Qur'an and the Sunnah have gathered within themselves, in the matter of religion, all the truths that have been and will be, before them and after them, until the Day of Judgement.

19. Why Does the Sufi Explain Through Edifying Stories?

That is, if you sit down, you can see a veil of a truth of religion, in the matter of religion, 500 years after you. You can also see, you can hear, a veil of the truth from 2000 years before you. You can come to know it. But if there is no written philosophy from 5,000 years ago, you cannot gain knowledge of its truth by reading, by examining. Or you cannot gain knowledge of a truth that will come to pass 1000 years after you, in the future. The reason is that you have no such world of meaning. Philosophers cannot find it. That is, when you go to Aristotle, you cannot find in Aristotle the truth that will come 5,000 years later.

20. The Time That Reason Cannot Encompass and the World of Meaning

Whether you go to Ibn Rushd, whether you go to al-Farabi, al-Farabi cannot convey to you the veil of a truth 500 years after him. But a person who is effective and authorised in the realm of meaning can tell you about a truth that will come 500 years from now. He can lay down that veil of truth. The reason is that his knowledge is knowledge of the heart. And the claim in the passage that the Qur'anic concepts are symbolic concepts for ordinary people who do not understand the more abstract language of philosophy essentially belongs to the philosophy-religion interpretation in the line of al-Farabi and Ibn Sina. That is, normally al-Ghazali here will shed light on a very important history. He sets a limit. What is this limit? According to him, a philosopher, that is, a philosopher cannot say: this religious expression is actually a symbolic narration for the common people to understand. The real truth is the philosopher's metaphysical explanation.

Al-Ghazali says this, that is, a philosopher cannot say: this religious expression is actually a symbolic narration for the common people to understand. The real truth is the philosopher's metaphysical explanation.

21. The Limit Drawn by al-Ghazali: What Can the Philosopher Not Say?

Because when this is done, the nature of revelation, the source of revelation, its limits, its criteria of truth and its authority become tied to the philosopher's reason. This point is very important. According to al-Ghazali, a philosopher. This religious expression is actually a symbolic narration for the common people to understand. The real truth is the philosopher's metaphysical explanation, he cannot say. Al-Ghazali draws this limit. If this limit is not drawn, the nature of revelation, the source of revelation, the limits of revelation, its criteria of truth and the authority of revelation remain dependent on the philosopher's reason.

Whereas revelation does not depend on the reason of created beings. Revelation is above the reason of created beings. Even if all minds were to unite, they could not compete with revelation. That is why al-Ghazali draws a line for the philosopher. He says, "You are not the truth.

You can only understand the truth. If we deify your reason, then the nature of revelation, its source, the criteria of truth of revelation and its authority become open to dispute. Whereas the authority of revelation, that is, of the Qur'an, cannot be disputed. The nature of the Qur'an cannot be disputed. The source of the Qur'an cannot be disputed. Why? You can only try to understand it, or, the criterion of truth of the Qur'an cannot be disputed. Today the followers of al-Farabi, the followers of Ibn Rushd are trying to dispute these. Look, if these are opened to dispute, there will be nothing left in the middle called religion.

22. Today the Authority of Revelation Is Being Opened to Dispute

Today, unfortunately, raw bigots, the uninformed, the ignorant, who present themselves as modern religionists, modern Muslims, as if they were modern Islam, are trying to limit revelation and are disputing the authority of revelation.

They are disputing matters relating to the authority of revelation and the source of revelation.

23. Where Does Rejecting What You Do Not Understand Lead?

Look, if we open the source of revelation to dispute, if we open the authority of revelation to dispute, and if these philosophers, these Aristotelians, these followers of Ibn Rushd, these followers of al-Farabi, who think they are going on a path that is right in their own eyes, are given way, then we will say we understood revelation, and where we do not understand, we will reject it. We will say: our reason could not grasp it, therefore there cannot be such a verse. You know, I give alif-lam-mim as an example, go on, tell me, you cannot tell me. Why? You cannot interpret it. When you cannot interpret it, what will you do? You will reject it. Is that so? Short-witted one, you will reject it. Is that so? Raw one who deifies his own reason. Raw imbecile. Yes. That is, far even from understanding an event that befell a prophet. You know how it is so often debated, did the sea part or did it not part? Did it part like this, or did it part like that? His reason could not grasp it, you see. The Almighty is going to part the sea, is He? Allah does not have that power and strength, does He?

God forbid, as if He parted the sea! He parted it, what are you going to do? And normally in the Noble Qur'an there are many verses that are metaphysical, metaphysical in today's sense. We can even say that all the verses other than those relating to rulings are metaphysical. You will reject all of them when you do not understand them.

24. How Will You Explain the Metaphysical Verses with Reason?

What will you do? Where will you put Jacob's weeping? Where will you put Joseph's falling into the well? Where will you put taking Joseph out of the well and making him ruler in Egypt? And where will you put Joseph's shirt, when he sent his own shirt to his father, and when his father rubbed that shirt on his eyes, his eyes came to see? Your reason could not grasp it. When your reason cannot grasp it, are you going to find an excuse for it? What will you make up? You will make something up in its place. Am I going to look to your reason? Are you more intelligent than me? Or how will you explain with reason Abraham's being saved from the fire?

What did He do? Was an imaginary fire lit? He saved Abraham from the fire. The Almighty, the fire did not burn Abraham. Come, explain this with reason.

Would a person take his own son to be sacrificed? He would. Explain this with reason. Go on, let's see. All of you have children. And your child, still so little, will say to you, [Qur'an, as-Saffat 37:102 — verse text pending: Diyanet English translation] Go on, explain this with reason. You cannot explain it. Ishmael (peace be upon him) says, [Qur'an, as-Saffat 37:102 — verse text pending: Diyanet English translation] What are we going to do now? Is it possible to interpret this with reason? Go on, take your child. And let your child be going to be sacrificed. Let him know it. Let your child know that he is going to his death, your child. Never mind your metaphysics, we can't even get our children to pray. He has taken him by the hand and is leading him. And Hagar behind, think of a mother, left all alone in the place where the House of Allah stands. At that time there is not even the Kaaba yet. She has struggled to survive with her newborn child and has raised her son to a certain age.

After she has raised him to a certain age, his father Abraham turns up. He used to come visit them constantly. He is taking your son, the son you raised with your own hands, to be sacrificed. Go on, let someone explain this with reason. Yes. The point where al-Ghazali stands here is that he does not allow the source of revelation, the authority of revelation, the nature of revelation to be debated. That is why they don't like al-Ghazali. Otherwise everyone will do something according to his own reason. It will be unclear who will follow whose reason. Yes. May Allah protect us. (Amin.) This point is very important for al-Ghazali. It is very important for me too. It is also very important for Islamic scholars who know themselves. Here al-Ghazali is against the philosophers interpreting revelation at this point according to their own metaphysical understanding, that is, they will leave the Qur'an and the Sunna behind. They will say, I understood it this way. May Allah protect us.

That is why I actually thought of opening this up a great deal. You know, forgive me, a bit more on this point. You know, I wanted to go deeper by bringing examples from the philosophers, but we would miss the heart of the matter. That is why this is actually a place that needs to be examined more in depth. Because today too, uh, some profs in the Islamic world, drawing on philosophy, are trying to do this. Al-Ghazali's fight at this point, that is, his fight with the philosophers, is it reason or revelation, so to speak. There is no point anyway in entering such a debate, such a fight. So, reason or the Qur'an? If al-Ghazali is viewed this way on this point, if he is viewed from such an angle, he will be misunderstood. He will not be understood correctly. You know, we'll look now, reason or the Qur'an, there's no such thing, no such thing, or reason or revelation, there's no such thing.

25. The Issue Is Not «Reason or Revelation»

That is, al-Ghazali is not someone who rejects reason.

Nor is al-Ghazali normally someone who rejects the Qur'an with his reason. Seeing it that way is wrong, because al-Ghazali is one of those remarkable people who use reason very well.

26. How Does al-Ghazali Use Reason?

He uses his reason very well. He uses logic very well. He uses mathematics very well. Al-Ghazali has a way of using reason and logic and mathematics at a high level. At the same time, you know, when we look at his works, he also uses philosophical concepts. He does not reject them. He uses what is necessary, or else he uses what is correct. For example, in kalam al-Ghazali uses kalam very well.

27. The Real Question: Where Does Reason Give Certain Knowledge?

In my view, the real concern or question of al-Ghazali, or of those who think within al-Ghazali's framework, along al-Ghazali's line, may be this.

In which domain can the phenomenon we call reason give us certain knowledge? At what point does it reach its limit? Where is the point at which it must stop? May Allah forgive us.

This is where this humble servant stands. At what point can my reason, my present reason, Mustafa Özbağ's present reason, give certain knowledge, or what certain knowledge can I reach with my present reason? That is one. Second, what is the limit of this reason of mine? Al-Ghazali actually asks this question, and seeks an answer to this question in his own way, and he finds the answer to this question. He says the limit of this is revelation.

Certain knowledge is only possible through revelation. With reason. And so, at this point, al-Ghazali's basis of knowledge, authority of knowledge, source of knowledge is formed in this way. Look at its formation, that is, the source of knowledge, the nature of knowledge, the authority of knowledge. That is, at this point, since it is so, its nature, source, measure and limit, all of these related to reason, all hold an important place. That is why reason is important, it is important for al-Ghazali.

In Sufism by our standard too, reason is important. But reason is not the absolute authority. Let us set this limit. If we set our reason as the absolute authority, religiously our feet will not touch the ground. Revelation, however, is the measure both in the outward (zahir) and in the inward (batin).

It is the authority. Its basis and source cannot be debated. Let me underline this again. The nature, source, authority and truth of revelation cannot be debated. That is why reason is not the absolute authority before revelation. This is what I understand from al-Ghazali. Al-Ghazali did not see reason as the absolute authority. Whereas figures like Aristotle, Ibn Rushd (Averroes), al-Farabi and Ibn Sina (Avicenna) set reason before us as an authority. Today too, in the Islamic world and in Turkey, those who see themselves as, in quotation marks, intellectuals see their own reason as the absolute authority. Especially in university circles, in theology faculty circles, there are many people who have caught this disease. They get angry at me when I say this. Your reason is not above revelation. Be an ordinarius professor if you like. You are not above revelation.

28. «If Even the Prophets Are Not Above Revelation…»

If even the prophets, from Adam to Muhammad Mustafa, do not have authority above revelation, then your authority is not above revelation either. If you claim that your reason rises above the authority of revelation, that reason is filth. That reason is garbage. That reason is senseless. That reason is idiotic. It is nothing else. Because that reason is the reason of unbelief. It is nothing else. And the people of unbelief are the very epitome of the idiot, the maniac, the senseless. They are nothing else. So it is not possible, within my religion, within my faith, for me to accept that reason.

Reason is only valid in understanding revelation, living revelation, assimilating revelation. Reason is not an authority above revelation. It is not above revelation. Reason is not above the measure set by Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa. If someone sets a measure above the measure set by Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa, he has secretly declared himself a prophet. Yes. You know, there are some who interpret the Qur'an according to their own reason.

[Qur'an, al-Baqara 2:219 — verse text pending: Diyanet English translation] Not one in forty, that is, it's not about zakat. Or all of it. Oh, where did you get that from? From the Qur'an. Do you know the Qur'an better than the Prophet (peace be upon him)? Do you know its application better than he does? Is your reason superior to his? Are you a prophet? What are you? Hold on, brother, slow down, take it easy. Come cool and calm. They'll break your arms and legs. They'll crack your head open. Don't think the field is empty. The field is full. May Allah protect us. That is why, here, normally, if we regard reason as the authority, the final authority, both in the spiritual and in the material, we will have no faith or anything left. We will have nothing left.

29. Two Trusts: The Book and the Sunna — The Book and the Ahl al-Bayt

The authority is revelation. The authority.

The Messenger of Allah, sallallahu. 'alayhi wa sallam, said: "I am leaving you two things. Whoever holds fast to them will never go astray. One is the Book of Allah, the Qur'an. One is my noble Sunna. In one hadith, one is the Book of Allah, the Qur'an. The other is my Ahl al-Bayt." My Ahl al-Bayt. Go and find yourself a master from the Ahl al-Bayt. Go and find yourself a scholar from the Ahl al-Bayt. Go and find yourself a murshid from the Ahl al-Bayt. Go and find yourself a saint from the Ahl al-Bayt.

Sit at his knee. Obey the Prophet. [Qur'an, Al Imran 3:132 — verse text pending: Diyanet English translation] [Qur'an, al-Ahzab 33:71 — verse text pending: Diyanet English translation] Obey His Messenger. Go and find one from the Ahl al-Bayt, a perfect murshid (murshid-i kamil). Sit at his knee. The hadith is also established. Only the perfect murshids who are of the Ahl al-Bayt have the veils of spiritual states opened.

The veils of dreams are open. The veils of the heart are open. If you do not find a perfect murshid of the Ahl al-Bayt, you come blind and you go blind. The hadith is established: I have left two things. One is the Book of Allah, the Qur'an. The second is my Ahl al-Bayt. Go and find the one whose chain of masters (silsila of the sheikhs) reaches the Ahl al-Bayt. Go, don't wait. Your salvation is there. Not anywhere else. One who has no awareness of the spiritual meaning. He is no different from this pillar right here. This pillar, where dhikrullah takes place here, where sama' takes place. It is better than him. This pillar you see is more within the spiritual meaning than sheikhs who have no awareness of the spiritual meaning. More meaningful. Why? There are those here who see spiritual states. Here, in the circle of dhikrullah, Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa has manifested. The pir masters have manifested. This tree sees. You don't see. Take a look at yourself too. So never hold reason above revelation. This is al-Ghazali's battle.

In those days, al-Farabi, Ibn Sina, Ibn Rushd held reason above revelation. Today too there are those of corrupt milk, of corrupt blood, of corrupt breed. They too are trying to hold reason above revelation. Ibn Rushd answers al-Ghazali. It is Tahafut al-Tahafut. He answers al-Ghazali. Ibn Rushd is famous for this among the philosophers. You say nobody could answer the philosophers. They say Ibn Rushd did. They say it to me too, you know. Yes. He objected to Ibn Rushd. Ibn Rushd objected to al-Ghazali, and when he objected to al-Ghazali, he wrote his book Tahafut al-Tahafut. While criticizing some of the views of these philosophers, al-Ghazali demolishes their philosophical systems on certain points, and on some questions of why and wherefore he approaches with more doubt and suspicion than necessary. Ibn Rushd, however, does not have that doubt

30. Ibn Rushd's Answer: Tahafut al-Tahafut

When you probe Ibn Rushd a little like this in general, according to Ibn Rushd it is not possible for existing reason and revelation to contradict each other.

They do not contradict. According to Ibn Rushd, if there is a contradiction in the middle, the matter is resolved through the correct method of interpretation.

When I look at this, I always stop reason right there, you see. The fire did not burn Abraham. Tell me the correct interpretation, Ibn Rushd, I say. He asks this of Ibn Rushd. Explain to me, in terms of causality, of why-ness, in terms of reason, how fire does not burn a person. How does fire not burn? In fact, one day while arguing like that, I said: it did not burn me. There is lived experience. How did it not burn, he said? It didn't burn, I said. I studied metalwork, I said. I know how to heat iron. I heated it myself, I said. I heated the iron, heated it, heated it. It turned bright yellow, I said. It went from red to yellowish. He's heating it over a gas canister, you know. It was going to be a fire burhan.

31. Rifa'i Burhans and a Warning

Among the Rifa'is there is the fire burhan, the skewer burhan.

32. The Fire Burhan: "It Did Not Burn Me Either"

Those who have received Rifa'i ijaza, watch yourselves. One day someone will hand you a skewer. Rifa'i, here's a skewer for you too, right here. Those who have received Rifa'i ijaza. One day someone will come and hand you the burning "tulip." Come on, lick this, he says. Lick it, let me see you. I am explaining to the worshippers of reason. It did not burn me, I say.

How did it not burn, he said. I said, I heated it, heated it, heated it. I handed over the iron, I said, thinking he would hand it to someone else. And what did he say to me? You lick it, man, he said to me.

May Allah have mercy on him, Ali abi from Sivas. I have no objection at all.

And right before my eyes, I beg all your pardon. He spat into the palm of his hand like this. He did it. He struck the iron once and it went "tssss." We know that. We studied metalwork, you see. We used to heat the iron. Then we'd put a drop of water on the anvil. We'd strike it together with the iron, with the hammer, and the water would burst. Or you dip red-hot iron into water. Doesn't it go "tssss"? He spat, and it did. He struck once and it went "tssss." Allah knows what is inside me. My heart did not tremble one bit. The recitation of the Divine Names had broken loose. And I'm in the middle. Hayy, Hayy, Allah.

We're reciting the Names like that. The walls are shaking. The house is literally shaking. The whole place. I put it on my tongue. The Name Hayy, Hayy, Hayy. I struck "Allah." My tongue went "tssss." The smell of the hairs on my tongue reached my nose. The hairs burned, the tongue did not burn. That is no easy test. I started. Tss tss tss tss. I cooled the iron on my tongue.

I am not telling this to recount a miracle (karama). The place where reason stops. I said to them, can you explain this with reason, I said. Explain this to me with reason. There is a burning stove. Bright red, hug it and carry it to the side, next to Mustafa. As you command, sir. Take it and carry it. The burning stove, blazing fiercely. Come on, take it and carry it. Is there anything to do with reason in this?

33. A Tawhid at the Main Source of the Hot Spring

We went to the very main source of the hot spring. You can't even put your finger in it. All the people from Sivas are outside. Why on earth did Baba reserve this place? Reason makes you question. Reason even makes you question the sheikh. And none of them can undress. I took everything off. I have a bath wrap underneath. I put on the bath wrap. Mustafa Efendi, please, go ahead, sir.

Are you ready, my son? I am ready, sir. Mashallah. Go in, my son. Destur (by your leave). Bismillah. Splash, I threw myself in. So to speak, I just stayed there like that.

I move my arm, my arm burns. I froze. Mustafa Özbağ, do dhikr, don't move any part of yourself. Like this, I began reciting tawhid inwardly. Like this, those who know Sheikh Efendi know. Like this, hey, he came. Inside it was steam like this, like this he came. He said, "Assalamu alaykum." Wa alaykum assalam. He said, "How is it inside?"

I said, "Very nice, sir." He said, "Mashallah." Plop, he went in too. Hüseyin Ağa knows, in that tiny pool. We are inside, two people, the others are outside. We are talking; they don't hear us talking. We hear them. He said, "You're not stirring (depreşmek), are you?"

He said. This is the Nevşehir dialect. "No, sir," I said; he said, "If you stir, you burn." I couldn't say that I had stirred once and got burned. He said, "If you stir, you burn." I said, "May Allah be pleased with you, sir." Well, of course, the things of this path are like this, like this; we are no farther apart than this computer, I mean, like this, I said, Mustafa Özbağ, where are you, what are you experiencing, I said. "So what are you thinking?" He said. I said, my nafs, I said, is very swollen, I said. Spit into my mouth, I said, so that I may take a breath from this nafs of mine, I said.

He said, "Open your mouth, let me see." I opened it. Now, does this have anything to do with reason? He did it. May Allah be pleased with you, sir. I said, sir, I cannot free myself from the games this nafs of mine plays on me, I said. He said, "Who has ever been freed, my son?" Other private matters came into it. He began to tell those private matters. At first I am saying inwardly, you know, those standing there will hear these private matters, I am saying to myself. Then I say, man, this is a great murshid-i kamil (perfect spiritual guide), I say; I mean, thinking about these things while he is speaking is a mistake, it's wrong, I say.

Ah, Mustafa Özbağ, you've put your nafs in it again, I say. We loosened up, we opened up to each other. He spoke, I listened. He told, I listened. Nothing at all. He said, "These people won't understand," he said, "what we are doing here," he said.

He said, "Come on, let's get out now." As you command, sir. He said, "Come on, you get out first." As you command, sir. I got out, and in my own way I'm saying, you know, I wonder if there will be some change in my skin when I get out?

Reason, you see... He got out too. Of course, our duty, I immediately, like this, a cold water, we dried him off and so on, like this, we dressed him. After that, but before that, while he is getting dressed, he buttons up the last of his shirt, you see.

34. One Does Not Take One's Ease in the Presence of the Sheikh

By the time he buttons up 5 or 6 buttons of his shirt, you will be completely dressed.

Praise be to the Almighty. That is how we used to serve our master. Look, I put on his last shirt for him. By the time he buttons his shirt, I am finished. He turns. "Are you ready, Mustafa Efendi?" "I am ready, sir," I will say. I am ready, sir. Still, let's get out. Now, Hüseyin Ağa used to give massages. We used to take him there. After that, Hüseyin Ağa gives the massage. does this and that. Where to? You are not going there to take your ease beside him. One does not take one's ease in the presence of the sheikh.

One does not talk idly in the presence of the sheikh. One does not chat like that. Like that, I said, sir, lie down for a while, I say. He lies down, we wrap him up and cover him. He says to me, come on, you wash too and come out. You wash too. He even says to Hüseyin Ağa, Hüseyin Ağa, give your brother a massage too. So that his word does not go unheeded, an arm or something, those hands, okay, Hüseyin, you've done it, that's enough, I say.

Why will I get out? Because right away he will say, "Be ready," he will say, "Mustafa Efendi, are you done?" "I am done, sir," I will say.

Now explain it to me in terms of reason. How does that water not burn a person? Explain it in terms of reason. Now how does that fire not burn the man's tongue? Explain this to me in terms of reason. Explain this in terms of reason. Reason normally does not understand here. Yes. Normally, Ibn Rushd (Averroes) says that if there is something metaphysical in the Holy Qur'an that is not normally understood, we interpret it with reason. Fine, they try to interpret with reason the fire's not burning. Now how are you going to interpret it, brother? The moment you interpret it, I will heat the iron red-hot and put it in your hand. Oh, that fire was the fire of the nafs, oh, being freed from the fire of the nafs. Sit down where you are. Your reason keeps floundering like a donkey stuck in a swamp. May Allah protect us. Ibn Rushd won intellectually. He lost politically. Forgive me, but this statement is both very ambitious and very striking, yet just as inconsistent. Well, I can't pass without saying it. Inconsistent, utterly inconsistent.

35. Why Is the Thesis «Ibn Rushd Won Intellectually» Inconsistent?

Well, the reason is that Europe accepts Ibn Rushd's philosophy, which remained under the influence of Aristotle, and praises it to the skies.

Europe raises to the summit Ibn Rushd, who took all of Aristotle's thought completely and systematized it; Ibn Rushd has an extraordinary influence on the system of thought in Europe.

36. A Handicap: Books Spread Without Being Read

And when you look at the foundation of those philosophers in Europe who, in their own estimation, labor at thought, who expend effort on thinking, you will find Ibn Rushd, and when you look at his foundation, Aristotle will appear. Ibn Rushd, who interprets Aristotle, is applauded in the European arena. You know, he is applauded in a rapid fashion like this. Of course, in the Islamic world too there are some Ibn Rushd followers who sell themselves for applause.

37. When It Is Said That «Following Revelation Is Backwardness»

They too take Ibn Rushd as their measure, and they too get applauded. They said something very important. Because following revelation, in the Islamic world, is backwardness, irrationality, bigotry—following revelation.

These are classic Islamists. No good comes from them. You pitchfork-bearded people. These matters don't work with robes and turbans. You are unreasoning. You don't accept reason, and so on. And as for the Sufis, it's just "a morsel and a cloak." What will these people understand? They cannot even grasp this talk.

How could this talk come from Mustafa Özbağ, they say, and they criticize. Yes. Why? Because we are Sufi-sourced. Because we are sourced in the Qur'an and the Sunna. From Mustafa Özbağ, who is sourced in the Qur'an and Sunna, who has, in quotation marks, Sufi claims or Sufi thought, such an al-Ghazali talk shouldn't come out. I mean, where did he research and find Ibn Rushd, and find al-Farabi too, compare them, debate them. My dear, we did those things 30 years ago.

You were still running around in short pants back then. Thirty years ago we were reading the Tahafut. The Almighty bestowed it, granted it as a favor. Thirty years ago we were reading al-Munqidh min al-Dalal. The Almighty granted it as a favor, bestowed it as a gift. This is not something we did by our own groping about. Thirty years ago we were reading the Ihya'. You were still running around in short pants back then. Yes. Let me give a bit of an answer like this, I mean, it's not like that. While Ibn Rushd was becoming famous in Europe like this, and while the Europeans were giving him a standing ovation, al-Ghazali's influence in the Islamic world still has not been broken, and it will not be broken either. Yes. Ibn Rushd became famous among the philosophers in Europe. But Ibn Rushd's — I will interpret it as his incoherences. Forgive me for that. Ibn Rushd's incoherences — Aristotle did not gain acceptance, a place, in the Islamic world. He could not break al-Ghazali's influence. And it still has not been broken.

38. Why Could al-Ghazali's Influence Not Be Broken?

I mean, people in the Islamic world don't even know Ibn Rushd's book. And al-Ghazali truly established a particular system of thought in the Islamic world. He systematized it. He made it understandable, and the intellectual class in the Islamic world accepted it and assimilated it. Ibn Rushd simply could not break this. There are still Ibn Rushd followers in Turkey too. They are, so to speak, spinning their wheels trying to break it. They can't. I mean, they cannot give a proper answer to the Tahafut al-Falasifa (The Incoherence of the Philosophers). It doesn't hold. It doesn't work. I mean, if we are going to set up an equation between Ibn Rushd and al-Ghazali, at this point, within that equation, al-Ghazali and Ibn Rushd cannot even be compared. That's why, if we try to compare them, we will have insulted al-Ghazali, and it will be seen that we have not understood al-Ghazali. It will also come out that we have not read al-Ghazali, that we have not been able to learn al-Ghazali, that we have not understood al-Ghazali on this point. As has happened with some people.

Of course, the really important matter is the line of Nizam al-Mulk, al-Ghazali and the madrasa. Well, of course, we have talked about these a lot before. Now I don't want to go back and talk about these again like this, but they come up in front of us. After all, in Nizam al-Mulk's own time the Nizamiyya madrasas were founded. And al-Ghazali was the head professor of the Baghdad Nizamiyya Madrasa. Of course, when we think of Nizam al-Mulk regionally, there, on the one hand, there is a 3–4,000-year-old — in today's language Iran, in the language of the past — the Persian Empire. And there is a 45,000-year-old Turkish state tradition.

39. The Third Matter: Nizam al-Mulk, the Madrasa and Sunni Knowledge

This is Mustafa Özbağ's thesis: he is a person who synthesized the Persian Empire with the tradition, customs, töre (customary law), 'urf and state understanding of the Turkish people who came from Central Asia — Central Asia as the English put it — from Asia.

Nizam al-Mulk. A statesman. A man who thinks about the future of the state, who thinks about the future of the nation.

That's why he synthesized the three: the state, the madrasa and the Sunni path. Nizam al-Mulk.

This is such a synthesis that it became a model for both the Seljuks and the Ottomans, and a successful synthesis. This synthesis is not unsuccessful. I mean, this path that Nizam al-Mulk drew as state, madrasa and Sunni path — this synthesis — has had its correctness proven by the measures it has taken from history. Both among the Seljuks and among the Ottomans. When we examine this historically, this is a very important matter. Look, when we examine it historically, I mean, the state, the Nizamiyya madrasas and Sunni knowledge and way of life. By synthesizing this, and at the same time synthesizing into this synthesis the ancient Turkish töre, tradition and custom and the Iranian state tradition, regionally, it is valid regionally, in the region. Because whether you can do this in Europe or not is a separate matter. Whether you can do this in Africa or not is a separate matter.

Because the races', the peoples' own cultures, outlooks, perspectives, I don't know, their social lives, relationships, their relationship with religion — all of these are influential factors. But in this region, Nizam al-Mulk put it forward by synthesizing, and he succeeded. But if we look at it as: normally, Nizam al-Mulk used al-Ghazali here. At this point, he exploited al-Ghazali for his own purposes — if we look at it like that, then we will have oversimplified it. It wouldn't be right. Al-Ghazali fit snap into this threefold equation of state, madrasa and Sunni knowledge.

40. Why Did al-Ghazali Fit Into This Equation?

Within this threefold equation, al-Ghazali is the person most suited, so to speak, to sit on the throne.

41. The Problem of Institutionalization Among the Turks and the Kanunname of Mehmed the Conqueror

Well, the Seljuk state too was a state in need of a Sunni institutionalization. When we look from a historical perspective, because on one side there are the Fatimids, the Batinis, on the other side Byzantium — turmoil, confusion. Within that turmoil, within that confusion, the Seljuks need institutionalization both in terms of state authority and religious authority. Why do they need institutionalization? Up until that time, the Turks were somewhat scattered in terms of institutional statehood. I mean, every time a padishah died, or a khan died, fights broke out among the sons. They fought each other for years. The state weakened. Then one son defeated all of them. After that he too reigned for 40, 50 years, however long. Then he too died. When he died, war broke out among the sons once again. That's why the Kanunname of Mehmed the Conqueror is important too. Let me have jumped from one thing to another there.

But in the Seljuks, a state needed to be institutionalized with all its organs. The most important element in this is religion. In terms of religion, Islam needed to mature in its Sunni form in the eyes of the people. Yes. Nizam al-Mulk and al-Ghazali showed very great success in this. Nizam al-Mulk perhaps did not carry much weight as a religious thinker. As a political thinker he carried a great deal of weight. But when al-Ghazali's religious stance, knowledge and structuring are added to this, a magnificent triad emerges. The state, the madrasa and Sunni knowledge. This becomes the main foundation of the Seljuks. This is also the point I have particularly emphasized from the very beginning of the al-Ghazali study. Indeed, this threefold equation and threefold foundation of mine — of course, al-Ghazali's political thought is also important within this equation. He is not directly, blindly, Nizam al-Mulk's man.

42. The Religion–State Relationship in al-Ghazali: The Sultan Is the Servant of Religion

When we look at al-Ghazali's Nasihat al-Muluk or at the Ihya', a synthesis emerges in which religion and the state complement each other, and when we look roughly at the religion–sultan relationship, without going over it with a fine-tooth comb, religion is the foundation.

In al-Ghazali, the sultan or the state is the protector of religion and of religious life, and the one who serves so that it may be lived; the sultan is not an authority over religion. For al-Ghazali, in the thought of Imam-i A'zam, the sultan is legitimate as long as he serves religion.

If he does not serve religion — that is, the Qur'an and the Sunna — if he does not stand by right and justice, if he does not stand by the truth, then according to al-Ghazali, and to Nizam al-Mulk too, the sultan is not legitimate.

The verse (ayah) of the Qur'an: [Qur'an, an-Nisa 4:59 — verse text pending: Diyanet English translation] The verse is clear. So then: obedience to Allah, obedience to His Messenger, obedience to those in authority among you — and this is the measure of obedience. So the sultan or the state is legitimate as long as it does not do anything contrary to the Qur'an and the Sunna. But if it has gone outside the Qur'an and the Sunna, both the state and the sultan lose their legitimacy. This is also the fatwa of Imam-i A'zam. Let this be announced to the followers of Imam-i A'zam. But between Nizam al-Mulk and al-Ghazali there is not much of a difference in religion–state relations. There are fine details. That is why it may perhaps look like a continuation, but it is not a continuation. Because I do not want to tie al-Ghazali directly like this to Nizam al-Mulk's understanding of politics. Perhaps I may approach this point a little emotionally.

43. But al-Ghazali Cannot Be Reduced to Nizam al-Mulk

I am a typical Ghazalian. Yes. I always admit this. I am a typical Ghazalian. Ibn Arabi is also a Ghazalian. Hazrat Rumi (Mawlana Jalal al-Din Rumi) is also a Ghazalian. Pay attention. Hazrat Muhyiddin Uftade is also a Ghazalian. Haji Bayram Veli too. Pay attention to these. Our chain (silsila) is Ghazalian.

44. The Continuity Extending to the Ottomans

In my own self, I am a typical Ghazalian. Well, I may be emotional here now. I don't say anything against that. I mean, it could be interpreted that way, but my emphasis is scholarly more than emotional. Al-Ghazali's understanding of politics is not tied word for word to Nizam al-Mulk. If I tie him like this, word for word, to his political project, it seems to me as if I had reduced al-Ghazali to Nizam al-Mulk. Scholarly speaking, too, it seems that way. May Allah forgive us. Of course, is there also a line here extending to the Ottomans?

Yes. I mean, because in the last part of the section we read, it says that the historical ground left by the Seljuk state reaches down to our day through the Ottomans. I'll tell you about today. Yes, there is a continuity in the Ottomans. I mean, when we look at the Seljuks — state, madrasa, Sunnism, the ulema — at this point we can set out this line.

State, madrasa, Sunnism and the ulema. Eyvallah. But when we come to the Ottomans, the Ottomans institutionalize these even further, develop them, deepen them. But when we are going to look at the religion–state relationship in the Ottomans, if the Seljuks are also part of the picture, it is a bit difficult for us to define the Ottomans without understanding, without listening to, without learning about the Seljuks.

45. To Understand, One Must Go Back

That would be taking the easy way out.

46. The Institutions the Ottomans Established

It doesn't work. I mean, for us to understand the Ottomans thoroughly, we need to study the Seljuks. We need to know the Seljuks. For us to be able to know the Seljuks, we need to know what came before Alp Arslan. We need to look at what came before Tughril Beg. Well, when we look at it in its historical dimension, we need to look at what came before Tughril Beg, so that we look at the Turks' historical relations with the state, at the rules of the state, its theories, the institutions of the state at this point. Well, normally one should come through these, filtering them step by step, so that we can understand the Ottomans.

47. The Same Method Applies to Individuals Too

Or else, now when we look at Abdullah Efendi, it is the same in this Sufism.

I mean, when looking at Abdullah Efendi, we need to take into consideration the environment in which he was raised, the master who raised him, the political and economic structure of Turkey. In which center are the pressures, in which center is knowledge? In which center are the tariqas, the Sufis? In which center is the state? We need to examine all of these well, learn them well, and only after that understand Abdullah Gürbüz Efendi. Or if we are going to understand Çorumi before him — I mean, before him, we need to look at Haji Bekir Baba's life, his outlook, and the religion–state relations of that day, the religion–society and religion–tariqa relations. Otherwise it is not possible for us to understand him. Or if you are going to understand Mustafa Özbağ too, you need to understand him that way.

I mean, his relationship with Abdullah Gürbüz, the environment he lived in, the setting he lived in, his economic situation, where he came from, what he went through to get here, what he saw, where he was struck, where he was kissed, what happened from where? Who did what? Who did not do what? Who fell away halfway? Who stabbed in the back halfway? Who was left stranded on the road? Who went on along the road? Who did what? These need to be analyzed completely so that we can understand the portrait of a Mustafa Özbağ. Well, without examining this, without researching, without seeing these things, our judgment about that person is not right. Look, ours is a very short life.

I have been within Sufism for 40 years. I mean, the stages we have lived through from the beginning until here, the point we have reached, the pressures set up against us, the games set up against us, the schemes, this and that. When we look at all of these, then you will understand Mustafa Özbağ. Well, sometimes, you know, I bring the old ones to the fore. Why do I bring the old ones to the fore, really? They lived alongside me. Well, they went through the ordeal together with me. I mean, if I suffered 100, they suffered 60 or 70. There were some things we couldn't tell even them.

48. «What Did You Do When the Whistle Blew?»

We hid them from them too. These are not easy things. Well, when you look at it that way, there is a 40-year past behind you. Well, analyzing those 40 years is not easy. Well, now you look at Hüseyin, Adnan, Cafer — I mean, it has been thirty-some years.

Criticizing is easy. What did you do when the whistle blew? That is what matters.

Some went running off. "We have a shop, we have a business, we have checks to pay. Brother Mustafa is holding lessons, holding dhikrullah. If we are arrested, if we are taken in, what will become of our shop, what will become of our business?" they said. And Sheikh Efendi said to them, "Then don't you go," he said. They went through a separation from us. Efendi did not tell us to cancel the lessons.

We cancelled the lessons. Those friends did not come.

49. Those Who Were Afraid, and What Came After

They were afraid.

50. The Anatomy of an Operation

They did not stay as merely afraid. They sold us out. And not even for a penny, man — they didn't even sell us for a penny. They sold us for next to nothing. Yes. Without understanding these things — the tax office wrote an audit report on me.

Before the tax office's report even reached my hands, the audit report was in the hands of a brother whom we called our brother. He showed it to the friends, saying, "Your brother Mustafa is an issuer of fake invoices; you'll see when he goes inside," and then the lawyer — lastly Erkan Zengin in Istanbul — proved with evidence that this business was an operation, that it was a FETÖ operation.

The case is now at the Court of Cassation again. Yes. I read it. I was surprised too. The case is at the Court of Cassation again. I mean, normally, to understand these things now, one has to live through them, one has to learn them.

Well, it's the same thing — I mean, to understand the Ottomans we'll look at the Seljuks. We'll study the Seljuks. What happened that the Ottomans took these decisions? And when we look at the Seljuks — what happened from Tughril Beg onward that the Seljuks took these decisions? Before Tughril Beg, we need to go all the way back to Asia. We need to go to the steppes. We need to go back as far as Attila. Have we been able to understand our Attila? If you can't understand Attila, you can never understand Fatih (Mehmed the Conqueror). If you can't understand Fatih, you can never understand Yavuz (Selim the Grim). Yes. Like that. And what did the Ottomans do? They institutionalized even further the things that existed under the Seljuks. What did they do? For religion, they put forward the Shaykh al-Islam. There is the sultan, there is the state. But they also established the office of Shaykh al-Islam. They put the madrasa in place, they founded the office of the qadi. They brought the waqf system. Look, the Ottomans lasted 600 years, but a solid 500 years, a solid 300 years they ruled over three continents. There is a success. A success — somewhere there is a success.

That means that system held. If there is success somewhere, there is a system. That system held there, it took root. Because there is success. You carry that flag even further. There is a success. There is a system.

51. The System Established in Bursa

This system took shape in Bursa.

It took shape in Sheikh Efendi's time. It didn't take shape with Mustafa Özbağ alone, you know. It took shape through all the old friends striving with desperate effort.

In Sheikh Efendi's time they sacrificed everything they had. They sacrificed their time, their money, their possessions, their wives, their children. Everyone rushed to the lessons 5 nights, 6 nights a week. A system took shape. A system unique to Bursa. Successful.

May Allah have mercy on him. Sheikh Efendi always held up Bursa as an example. All the old ones know. One would come, and behind him 10 people would come. Look at Bursa. Yes. See how they succeed. Look, just take a look. You can't be like this. The things he would say to the dhakirs in my presence. This is success. Yes. System. That success comes with the system, it comes with spiritual meaning, it comes with the system.

They are all things that complete one another. That's why — I mean, since we are looking at the relationship between religion and state in the Ottomans, to understand it we need to know the Seljuks, to study them. But, for example, the Ottomans are not engaged in a typical copying of al-Ghazali. I mean, cut, copy, paste, the way people do today. There is no such thing in the Ottomans. Because between al-Ghazali and the Ottomans there is a time gap of 350–400 years. Everything certainly changes. And the Ottomans — yes. They have breezes from al-Ghazali, but they are building a new system.

52. Let Us Sum Up: Who Stands Where?

If we sum up the whole talk so far, together with the previous talks: in Nizam al-Mulk, the state — that is, the political order — Sunnism, and the madrasa.

In addition to this, al-Ghazali: Sunni kalam, fiqh, Sufism, logic; in addition to this, uh, when we look at Ibn Rushd (Averroes): philosophy, Aristotle, a kind of deification of reason.

When we look at Ibn Rushd, when we see this philosophy, Aristotle, as the deification of reason — uh, when we look at Ibn Taymiyya: Ibn Taymiyya's point is the Qur'an, the Sunna, and the Salaf as he understood it.

His criticism of kalam, Sufism, philosophy, Sufi practice. If we look at Ibn Abd al-Wahhab — at the Wahhabis — this is a separate handicap.

For this we need to hold a very special lesson and take time. A reformist of uncertain nature, a Salafi current, something English-like. I can even go further. I can even say a British agent. About Ibn Abd al-Wahhab.

53. An Assessment of Wahhabism

But normally, when we look at these, Wahhabism needs to be looked at on a separate plane.

For a while he remained under the influence of the French, for a while he played around together with the British.

54. The Applauded Ibn Rushd, the Unread Ibn Rushd

I mean, so to speak, a person who became a British knock-off — perhaps that's harsh, but — and a traitor who acted jointly with the British to break the Ottomans' dominion in that region. I'm 65 years old now. I won't be able to hide what's inside me. The most traitorous of traitors. A person who declared war on the Ottomans, like a knock-off of Yazid, together with Sharif Husayn — you know, Abdulhamid Khan had Sharif Husayn brought to Istanbul with his family and, so to speak, held him captive in a waterside mansion. These Unionists say, why are we supporting this Sharif Husayn and his gang from the state's funds? They, the Unionists, release Sharif Husayn. And Sharif Husayn goes and settles in the Damascus region. The one who stabbed the Ottomans in the back is Sharif Husayn. The one who brought about internal turmoil is Ibn Abd al-Wahhab. Thus Sharif Husayn from behind, and these Wahhabis from the front — these are the two traitorous figures who broke the Ottomans' authority in the Mecca–Medina region.

Even though their starting point, Wahhabism, emerged as a religious-reformist movement, the real aim is to strike the Ottomans. There, together with the British, they strike the Ottomans. I mean, they strike us. Let me wrap up the matter so that it ends for tonight.

55. Conclusion: Counting al-Ghazali as the Cause of Decline Is Ignorance

Presenting al-Ghazali as the sole cause of scientific decline, of intellectual decline in the Islamic world is truly ignorance.

When we look at it historically, when we look at it from a historical perspective, it is nothing but ignorance.

56. The Common Trait of Those Who Belittle al-Ghazali

But al-Ghazali — yes — performed very important duties in the Islamic world in reshaping the hierarchy of knowledge, the limits of reason, the domain of legitimacy of philosophy, and the madrasa-centered Sunni order of knowledge. He is a magnificent figure. Those who historically belittle al-Ghazali are worshippers of reason. They are arrogant people. Those who say he was hostile to science, hostile to reason, are truly people who are hostile to the Islamic world. That's why those who criticize al-Ghazali seem to be going rather overboard on this point.

57. What Really Needs to Be Discussed: The Works

Actually, because I'm afraid of drawing out the subject about al-Ghazali like this, I'm cutting it short.

One needs to talk about the works. For example, one needs to talk about Tahafut al-Falasifa (The Incoherence of the Philosophers).

For example, one needs to talk about Ihya' 'Ulum al-Din (The Revival of the Religious Sciences). For example, there is Mi'yar al-'Ilm (The Standard of Knowledge), that is, a book of his concerning logic and methods of correct thinking. It's a book published by the Ministry of Culture. If you can find it among the books the Ministry of Culture published long ago — formerly the Ministry of Culture used to open stands like this.

I was still a new dervish then. When I went to a city, when I went somewhere, I would go and look at those books sold by the Ministry of Culture, at those stands. I collected al-Ghazali there, from those places. These are little treatises like this. Well, some of them are in this poor one's library. Uh, some of them I gave as gifts, to those studying at universities and so on, so they could read them. But some of them are there. For example, al-Ghazali has a work on the methodology of fiqh. Al-Ghazali — for example, if someone said, you know, Imam Abu Hanifa's students Imam Muhammad, Imam Abu Yusuf, Imam Zufar — you know, they are his students. But each of them is actually like a separate madhhab imam. For example, a person may regard al-Sarakhsi as a madhhab imam for himself. Al-Ghazali too can be seen, among the Shafi'i jurists, in Shafi'i fiqh, at the rank of a madhhab imam, you know. He himself is a Shafi'i. That's why, for example, there is his al-Mustasfa. It is a book that deals with fiqh, its methodology and rational methods.

An example — actually, you know, jurists need to read this well and study it well. This is an important work in terms of fiqh.

58. Summary Questions and Answers

Well, when you examine these, a really, you know, interesting al-Ghazali emerges. So did al-Ghazali reject philosophy in its entirety?

No. That is nothing but the crudest oversimplification.

59. The Fine Distinction Between Nizam al-Mulk and al-Ghazali

Well, I've really dragged it out on the Tahafut al-Falasifa today; it's already 11:30. You know, he doesn't say that all of philosophy is wrong. He separates the philosophers' views into different areas. He rejects the ones that are to be rejected. Al-Ghazali uses logic. There is no question of him rejecting logic. So did he criticise the philosophers? Yes. Did al-Ghazali reject rational thought and the philosophical sciences? No. Well, al-Ghazali did object. Why did he object to certain philosophers? I said that in the earlier lessons. He objected to the eternity of the world. He objected to the philosophers' claim that Allah does not know the small particulars. You know, a professor also came out, I'm giving it as an example. He said Allah doesn't know tomorrow. Bayındır. He said it in a television talk. He said Allah doesn't know what you will do tomorrow. He said He only learns it when you do something. This society just passes over these things.

It doesn't see them. The philosophers deny the resurrection. Al-Ghazali rejects these. But al-Ghazali does not reject every philosopher in everything, in every single thing they say. The places he rejects are specific places.

60. The Real Problem: There Is Knowledge, but No Practice

When we look at al-Ghazali, when we look, I've written a whole lot more things here. Time won't be enough for it. May Allah forgive us. It ran long. Please forgive me. I believe I have conveyed what I meant here regarding the books. I've also written a note here that describes today.

I've written "important". The problem is here. There is knowledge, but no practice.

In today's society, among those who see themselves as knowledgeable, there is knowledge, but no practice. A professor of theology — no prayer; there is knowledge, but no practice. You know, someone has become a sheikh — there is knowledge, but no practice; there is learning — these are the problem. Today there is no sincerity (ikhlas), there is fiqh, but no morality.

There is a pious appearance, but no training of the heart. No training of the heart. The problem lies in these. Yes. In conclusion, I've written so much. I couldn't stop myself. I've written this much of these things here. Let me not waste my own effort. Let me jot down a note here. Let me continue from here. Best is this — normally from al-Mustasfa, I've written that an interesting al-Ghazali emerges. We will continue from here. Please forgive me. Let me note down "to be continued". Because I've touched on beautiful topics here, by Allah's leave. I, this a bit, like — please forgive me. You know, I had started to wonder whether I'm boring you by now. That's why I thought I'd cut it short, but this isn't something to be cut short. Insha'Allah.

61. Closing and Next Week

You know, I had thought of finishing al-Ghazali next week, but unfortunately al-Ghazali probably won't be finished next week.

I thank all of you for listening to me patiently. Please forgive me. May it be halal. From our side too, may it be halal. If there is anyone who doesn't forgive, let them say so. We know how to settle our rights with each other, I mean. It's no problem. Please forgive me. This al-Ghazali takes up a bit of my time, but I enjoy it too. While preparing, I struggle a bit — well, I won't say I don't, and I won't say I do — you know, it takes my time, but then when I come up here, alhamdulillah, I too get a taste, you know, from the sohbet. Mine becomes a bit, like, narcissistic. It might occur to you that I'm thinking of my own pleasure, but of course it isn't like that. By the way, Büşra Ay hoca has examined a book of this professor's. She made excerpts from it for the al-Ghazali talk. Those — next week — I've brought those excerpts here too, but we didn't get to them. Normally I'll look at those here too. I also thank you separately for taking an interest.

Of course, it's a good thing, a nice thing, for theologians to take a bit of interest in these matters. That's why I also thank you separately for your sensitivity. We will continue next week.

Note: This text is the speech itself as recorded in the sohbet: only spelling and punctuation have been edited, and obvious mishearings in the subtitles have been corrected; a few unintelligible places have been left as heard. Section headings have been added for ease of reading. The opening and closing prayers have not been included.


Bibliography

The text discussed in the sohbet, the works mentioned and the sources referred to are collected below.

W. Montgomery Watt, Müslüman Aydın (Muslim Intellectual: A Study of al-Ghazali) — Professor of Arabic and Islamic Studies at the University of Edinburgh. The source of the passage analysed point by point in the sohbet.

Imam al-Ghazali, Maqasid al-Falasifa — The work in which the philosophers' views are set out systematically. After its publication it was long taken to be al-Ghazali's own views, and was even not attributed to him.

Imam al-Ghazali, Tahafut al-Falasifa — The refutation written after the Maqasid. Not philosophy in its entirety but specific issues are rejected: the eternity of the world, the claim that Allah does not know particulars, and the denial of bodily resurrection.

Imam al-Ghazali, al-Mustasfa min 'Ilm al-Usul — His work dealing with fiqh, the methodology of fiqh and rational methods. In the sohbet it is mentioned as a source that jurists should study well, and is deferred to the next episode of the series.

Imam al-Ghazali, Nasihat al-Muluk — His work on the relationship between religion and state; the source of the view that the sultan is the protector and servant of religion, not an authority above religion.

Ibn Rushd, Tahafut al-Tahafut — The reply written to al-Ghazali. According to Ibn Rushd, reason and revelation cannot contradict each other; if there is a contradiction, it is resolved through the correct method of interpretation.

Al-Farabi and Ibn Sina (Avicenna) — Mentioned as the original source of the interpretation that Qur'anic concepts are "symbolic expressions for ordinary people".

The Holy Qur'an, Nisa 4/59 — [Qur'an, an-Nisa 4:59 — verse text pending: Diyanet English translation] Mentioned as the criterion for the legitimacy of the sultan.

Hadith — The two trusts — "I leave you two things; whoever holds fast to them will not go astray: the Book of Allah and my Sunna" (Muwatta', Qadar 3); in the other narration, "the Book of Allah and my Ahl al-Bayt" (Muslim, Fada'il al-Sahaba 37).

The Holy Qur'an, Surah Yusuf 12/93-96 — The shirt of Yusuf (peace be upon him) being rubbed on his father's eyes and his eyes being opened; mentioned as an example of metaphysical events that reason cannot explain.

The Holy Qur'an, Anbiya 21/69 — [Qur'an, al-Anbiya 21:69 — verse text pending: Diyanet English translation] The Qur'anic basis for the question "how does fire not burn" in the sohbet.

The Holy Qur'an, Saffat 37/102 — The words of Isma'il (peace be upon him): [Qur'an, as-Saffat 37:102 — verse text pending: Diyanet English translation]

Nizam al-Mulk, Siyasatnama (Siyar al-Muluk) — The synthesis of the triad of state, madrasa and the Sunni path; the combination of the Persian state tradition with Turkish customary law (töre).

Mustafa Özbağ Efendi, "The Limit of Reason and the Authority of Revelation | Questions on al-Ghazali 9" — mustafaozbag.com — Full text of the sohbet dated 15.08.2026.

Click for more information about Imam al-Ghazali.

Additional sources:

  • Imam al-Ghazali, Maqasid al-Falasifa (The Aims of the Philosophers); a systematic presentation of the views of the philosophers.
  • Imam al-Ghazali, Tahafut al-Falasifa (The Incoherence of the Philosophers); the twenty questions and the three views deemed unbelief.
  • Imam al-Ghazali, Mi'yar al-'Ilm (The Standard of Knowledge); logic and the methodology of syllogism (qiyas).
  • Imam al-Ghazali, al-Mustasfa; the principles of fiqh (usul al-fiqh) and rational methods.
  • Imam al-Ghazali, al-Munqidh min al-Dalal (Deliverance from Error); the classification of the paths to knowledge.
  • Ibn Rushd (Averroes), Tahafut al-Tahafut (The Incoherence of the Incoherence) and Fasl al-Maqal (The Decisive Treatise); the relationship between reason and revelation.
  • Qur'an: Anbiya 21/69; the fire being made cool and safe for Ibrahim (peace be upon him).
  • Qur'an: Yusuf 12/93-96; the shirt and the opening of the eyes.
  • Qur'an: Nisa 4/59; the measure of obedience and those in authority (ulu'l-amr).
  • Muslim, Fada'il al-Sahaba 37; the narration of the Thaqalayn (the two trusts).
  • W. M. Watt, Muslim Intellectual; the source of the thesis analysed in the sohbet.