1. One More Night to Understand al-Ghazali Better
As you know, last week we said, so that we could understand al-Ghazali better, normally finish the passages, but we said let's do one more lesson like this. And in this lesson, we had talked among ourselves about doing one more night, one more sohbet (spiritual discourse), on al-Ghazali's views on obedience, the sultan, the caliphate and order. Today's talk may be a bit long. So, God willing (insha'Allah), please be patient from the start. I thank you in advance for your patience.
I had some notes of my own on this. Let's make one more night's lesson out of these notes. Actually, I had no particular concern to produce a lesson like this, but it is so that the matter can be understood better. And also, you know how they speak of "modern times"; well, the people who later criticised al-Ghazali had criticisms on these points. I had noted down those criticisms a bit for myself as well. So this will also serve as an answer to them.
2. Tonight the Knots Will Be Untied
Of course, tonight, regarding al-Ghazali, our minds will, I hope so. That's what I think. Tonight al-Ghazali will settle firmly in our minds and our hearts, God willing. Because, you see, all along, every week we tied a knot. Tonight, I believe, those knots will be untied.
3. The First Question: May One Rise Against an Unjust Sultan?
According to al-Ghazali, may one oppose an unjust or flawed sultan? We are discussing this directly through al-Ghazali. Now, in your own inner world, in your own world of ideas, you may or may not look at it according to this age. The listeners, and, if we later turn this into a book, the readers, will have their own opinions of their own. One more question, I mean, what is the first question? According to al-Ghazali, may one oppose an unjust or flawed sultan? One more question.
4. The Second Question: The Breakdown of Order, or the Unjust Ruler?
Is it the breakdown of order? Or is the existence of an unjust ruler the greater danger? Because this is a conclusion I drew from the criticisms of modern times. That is, is the breakdown of order or the existence of an unjust ruler the greater danger? I mean, somewhere there is a state order. Is the breakdown of the state order the great danger, or is the existence of an unjust ruler the great danger?
5. The Culture of Obedience and the Concept of the «Islamic State»
And if we proceed from this understanding, how was the formation of a culture of obedience in, in quotation marks, Islamic states affected? "Islamic state" is normally the name the modern critics have given it like this, but I do not regard even the Ottomans as an Islamic state. There is a system that tries to live Islam and to keep it alive. In quotation marks, I do not regard the Seljuks as an Islamic state either.
As for the Abbasids and the Umayyads, I don't regard them as such at all anyway. In my view, the Islamic State to be taken as an example is the period of the Prophet (peace be upon him) and the Rightly Guided Caliphs (Khulafa' al-Rashidun). I do not regard any of the remaining systems as an Islamic state. This is my own personal opinion. Nor do I believe that there is an Islamic state in the world at present. On this point too, this is my personal opinion.
6. The Political Picture in Which al-Ghazali Lived
Of course, in order to understand these things, we need to see the political picture of the time in which al-Ghazali lived. Al-Ghazali normally 500, I mean, his death is normally 1111; he died in 505 AH, he died in 1111 CE. And when I look at the period of the Prophet (peace be upon him) and the Rightly Guided Caliphs, I think that al-Ghazali did not live within an independent Islamic state, and that is the judgment I reach for myself. I mean, al-Ghazali did not live within the order of an independent Islamic state.
In his time, I mean in his time, there is an Abbasid caliph in Baghdad, but in the real sense military power, administrative power and political power are in the hands of the Seljuk sultans. And the Seljuk vizier Nizam al-Mulk is, so to speak, more powerful than the sultan.
7. The Shi'i-Fatimid Rival in Cairo
There is Nizam al-Mulk, and there is the Shi'i Fatimid state. They are in Egypt, in Cairo, and that Shi'i Fatimid state stands as a political and religious authority … against both the Seljuks and the Abbasids. A rival, I mean, a rival to the Seljuk and Abbasid state system and religious system, to the religious authority: the Shi'i Fatimids in Egypt, and within this there are also the Batinis. I mean, outwardly it is Fatimid. I mean, if you look at that Fatimid thing too, the founder of the Fatimid state and of its creed was also a Jew.
Let's set this aside as well. Now, this Shi'i, Fatimid, Batini state in Cairo is hostile to the Abbasids and the Seljuks. And at this point, within this sphere, al-Ghazali is in close relationship both with the Seljuk state and with the Abbasid caliph… caliphate.
8. The Weak Shape Themselves According to the Strong
This, normally, this point is very important. Why is it important? I mean, a state or an Islamic movement shapes itself according to the dangers around it. Because if you are strong, if authority is entirely yours, if you are strong, you apply the rules and the law. Those who are weak shape themselves in response to you. But if you have no power, you shape yourself in response to the stronger one. This is a rhythmic thing, both at the level of states and at the level of religious authorities.
This is a rhythmic thing in families too. I mean, a family creates an enemy for itself. It puts itself on the defensive against that enemy.
9. The Example of a Business, a Tariqa and a Political Party
Or think of a business. A business has firms it competes with. If you are the strong one, you set the rules. You give discounts on goods, you extend payment terms, you crush the small ones. The small ones then try to do business in spite of you. It is like this in trade too. Or, on today's plane, in Turkey the tariqas (Sufi orders) too are trying to show themselves as strong like this. They engage in shows of strength.
They collect money. They build dormitories, inns, bathhouses and so on. Dollars, gold, it's all flowing in abundance. They see the other, you know, people of the tariqa or communities as rivals. This one tries to trip that one up. Tries to take over his tekke. That one tries to do this or that to him, like that. Political parties are the same. Look, if there is someone competing with you, putting on a show of strength against you, you shape yourself in response to that person showing strength.
You are weak, because if you are strong, you are the law, you are the court, you are justice. You are everything. If you are strong; but if you are not strong, you determine your policy according to the strong.
10. Caliph Plus Sultan: Not a Philosophy, but a De Facto Situation
That is why, normally, al-Ghazali's caliph-plus-sultan is not a philosophy. It is a political situation, a legal situation, that emerged de facto. Normally, as much as it is political and legal, it also concerns religion. And al-Ghazali is trying to establish its religious side. Let's put it that way.
11. Manzikert and Alp Arslan
In al-Ghazali's time, one of the most important problems for al-Ghazali is this: there is a caliph, but the power lies with the sultan. That is, among the Abbasids there is an Abbasid caliph, but after 1071 the Seljuk sultans are very powerful. Because after Manzikert, just imagine an Alp Arslan. He has torn through everything. In 1071 he achieved a magnificent success. The Almighty (Allah) bestowed His grace, honoured him. He scattered Romanos Diogenes and his army. He utterly routed an army twice, three times the size of his own.
This, for a head of state who has won a pitched battle, who has seriously won a war, is a magnificent political, military state authority. He succeeded because he displayed genius militarily. Politically, normally, he displayed genius. Normally, the state showed what it is to be a state. It has now become an unstoppable power like this. Look, it has become an unstoppable power. Thank goodness it did.
12. If Manzikert Had Not Been Won
There is also this side of the matter. Because, you know, Manzikert has not yet been fully understood in the Islamic world. It is not something that has been fully researched and brought to light on this subject. In quotation marks, one of our most important, biggest weaknesses is that our successes, or what we have done, are not publicised. Our not telling about it. That is, Manzikert is, unfortunately, a pitched battle that has not been understood in this respect.
Because if at Manzikert Alp Arslan and his army had not been victorious against Romanos Diogenes, today we would not be sitting here either. Perhaps I said this just recently, too. Perhaps it is a very bold statement, but today there might not even be a world called the Islamic world. Because if Romanos Diogenes and his army had been victorious, they would have rushed straight to Mecca, Medina, Jerusalem, and they would have put the entire Islamic world to the sword.
Now those who bomb, who are bombing the Islamic world, Israel's oppression of the Palestinians, continues from where Romanos Diogenes left off. They are doing everything they could not do back then.
13. The Caliph in the Classical Sunni System
Now of course here, you know, there is a caliph; the power is the sultan's. Well, there is, so to speak, a paradox here. Because normally, you know, in the classical Sunni system the imam or the caliph is at the same time the political leader of the umma. At the same time he is the military leader. At the same time he is the political leader. At the same time he is the head of state. His Excellency the Prophet (peace be upon him), Hazrat Abu Bakr, Umar, Uthman, Ali, and the six-month period of Hazrat Hasan are given to us as the example.
In the classical Sunni system, you know, the caliph must be the political and the military leader of the umma as well as its head of state. But in al-Ghazali's time the de facto situation is not like that. That is, the caliph stands like a symbolic gateway of religious legitimacy. But with the sultan, that is, with the Seljuk sultan, there is military power, there is political power, there is administrative power. That being so, pardon my expression. The classical Sunni system is not like this. In the classical Sunni system the caliph must hold political power, must hold military power, and also administrative power, state power. Well, now in the Seljuk period there is no such thing.
14. The Question of Religious Legitimacy among the Ottomans
Well, Yavuz Sultan Selim (Selim I) later gathered this in himself. That is, throughout history these deficiencies, these mistakes, these dead ends, these paradoxes always caused trouble. For example, Orhan Bey has no religious legitimacy among the Ottomans. That is, there is no authorisation (ijaza) from the caliph. Osman Bey doesn't have it, Orhan Bey doesn't have it. Murad I, Murad II, Mehmed the Conqueror don't have it. After Mehmed the Conqueror, up until Yavuz Sultan Selim, there is none. There is none in terms of religious legitimacy. These are perhaps different subjects.
15. If al-Ghazali Had Rejected the De Facto Situation
Well, now in al-Ghazali's period the caliph has no political power, no military power, no administrative power, but the sultan has political power, administrative power, military power. Well, normally, if al-Ghazali had rejected this existing de facto situation, let's say he rejected it, an enormous chaos would have erupted. The sultan made an appointment. He appointed a governor. If there is no legitimacy, then no one should obey the governor the sultan appointed.
The rulings of the qadis would have been invalid. The law runs through the qadis. Then the rulings of the qadis would also have been invalid. When the rulings of the qadis are invalid, well, of course, we don't know Islamic law very well, do we. When the law of the qadis is invalid, people's marriages would also have been invalid in the eyes of the state. Now when the law of the qadis, the law of the governors is invalid, taxes will be invalid too.
Because there is a state order. Well, normally then military and administrative affairs will be invalid too. The people, the subjects, will say this ruler has no legitimacy, and when they say he has none, will they rebel, will a civil war break out? When we set it out like this, we understand much better the position where al-Ghazali stands.
16. Placing De Facto Power within Abbasid Legitimacy
Now let's ask ourselves. That is, suppose we said the existing state has no legitimacy. Nor does the governor, nor the government, nor, what do I know, the justice system; marriages are scraps of paper with no validity. A tremendous chaos erupts. That is why, normally, al-Ghazali places this de facto power, that is, the de facto power of the Seljuks, within the legitimacy of the Abbasid caliphate. All of these are my own ideas. Let me say this openly, too. That is, these are my own analyses like this, may Allah forgive me. I am not saying it out of arrogance.
17. An Ineffective, Powerless Caliph Who Is Nevertheless the Centre of Legitimacy
And in al-Ghazali's political theory it is not "obey the sultan", that is, obey him blindly like this. In al-Ghazali this does not exist. But if we look from today, al-Ghazali builds a complex structure. If we look from today, but if we look from here, what a complex caliph there is. Ineffective, powerless, but the centre of legitimacy. Understand this caliphate well, too. The Abbasid caliphate is actually a caliphal system that will shed light on all ages. How will it shed light? A bright light? No. A bright light for us as to what should not be done.
18. «They May Bring Before Us a Cardboard Caliph»
Because I, and this too is my own belief, my own view. In the coming years they may bring before us a cardboard caliph. An ineffective, powerless figure. They may even bring him from abroad. In parliament, the caliphate, right now, parliament may get up and, as a result of pressure, say so-and-so is caliph. Put this aside for now as well.
19. The Criticism of Modern Researchers
Like this, of course, the caliph is the centre of legitimacy, but the Seljuk sultans hold de facto executive and military power in their hands. Well, the body of the ulama, that is, the qadis, maintain the legal and religious order. And society carries on its life of security and worship within this order. This approach is seen as a formation aimed at legitimising the Seljuk sultans. Modern researchers criticise this point. Why did al-Ghazali not disrupt this?
You know, their thesis is that al-Ghazali further strengthened this. Normally, of course, a large portion of these researchers are Western, and especially in Turkish universities, too, writings like this have been written taking inspiration from these Western sources. Critical writings have been written, critical writings like Ocak's.
20. The Aim Is Not to Respond, but to Understand Better
Well, it is not my place to respond to all of them. I did not prepare this topic in order to respond to anyone anyway. I prayed to the Almighty (Allah) for the way to understand better. So that we may understand better. Not, you know, research I did for Professor X or Professor Y. So that I myself and our brothers and sisters may understand this topic better, realistically. That is my effort. Because, as is known, there is a work called Politics in Islam. This has become a series of talks somewhat close to that. But the critics criticise at this point.
21. What al-Ghazali Valued: Order
Now, when we look at al-Ghazali, what al-Ghazali valued is order. Today, wherever you go, I am giving an example, even in a Sufi community, order is sought. In a state system there must be order; in a family system there must be order. Order is sought. A family system without order does not move forward. It cracks, it bursts. Order. There must be order in a business. Even if it is a tiny little business, there must be order.
You do farming. Even in farming, order is needed. Now, say we were to ask Muhtar, when I say, "Muhtar, what do we need to do with these trees now?" he will tell us that within an order. If we disrupt that order, we cannot get any fruit from there. Or, you know, say we told Fatih, as a mechanical engineer, that we are going to produce a part. There must be an order, a system, a sequence for producing that part. Isn't that so, Fatih? If that sequence goes wrong, does a product come out? Actually, it does not.
22. Order in the Universe, in the Qur'an and in Fiqh
Even the structure of our bodies is within an order. The Almighty (Allah) has given an order to the whole universe. There is something Muslims have forgotten. Order: all the stars are within an order. The world is within an order. The planets are within an order. When you study the Qur'an, the Qur'an is upon an order. When you study the hadiths, the hadiths are upon an order. When you look at fiqh (Islamic jurisprudence), fiqh is upon an order.
When you look at kalam (Islamic theology), kalam is upon an order. You know, I tend to look at things a bit classically. When you look at the old classical works, all of them are upon an order. Establish an order. First you establish an order. Then you fill in the inside of the order, its bottom, its top, its right, its left. You cannot do that without order. For example, even this talk has an order. Topics that will proceed step by step. First those topics will be determined. After those topics are determined, upon that order, the verses and hadiths related to those topics, and what did al-Ghazali say related to that topic, related to that agenda heading? It has to be upon an order. That is why, you know, al-Ghazali, too, is a man of order.
23. Understanding Fitna in Order to Understand al-Ghazali
Well, to understand al-Ghazali we of course also need to understand fitna (discord, civil strife). On this subject, you know, we will put fitna at the centre. We need to proceed through fitna. Because in the middle there is a different system. On one side there is the caliph. An ineffective, powerless figure. On the other side there is the sultan. Is he powerful? Powerful. Powerful with his administration, his military, his state, his politics. And opposite this dual system there is a Shi'i, Fatimid, Batini system.
And the founder of that Isma'iliyya. The founder of the Fatimids was a Jew. I was not saying this. I was not saying it, you know, so that your view of the Shi'a would not become different. I mean, if necessary we will go into the founding of the Shi'a as well. Then all hell breaks loose. Yes. Now, of course, that is not our topic tonight.
24. There Is No Anarchy in Islam
I mean, what al-Ghazali and the classical Sunni ulama of Islam saw as the greatest danger is fitna and anarchy. You know, sometimes in talks I say there is no anarchy in Islam. There is no anarchy in Islam. A Muslim, a believer, cannot cause anarchy. I mean, he cannot take up a weapon and carry out an action on his own initiative. Now, fitna and anarchy, the thing that the typical classical ulama of Islam and al-Ghazali saw as the greatest danger, and what is the thing that the Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, also saw as a great danger? Fitna.
25. Bab al-Fitan and the Hadith of Thawban
Now, the brothers and sisters will remember: bab al-fitan, that is, in al-Bukhari, in Muslim, in al-Tirmidhi, in Abu Dawud, in the Kutub al-Sitta, there is a chapter called bab al-fitan. There is a section. I mean, they are well known as the fitna hadiths. Well, now, with those fitna hadiths standing there, there is nothing more natural than the classical ulama seeing fitna and anarchy as a great danger. Now, let us take a narration from Abu Dawud on this, so that it may shed light on our own day as well.
This narration actually sheds light on all times, but today it also sheds light on our day. Just as it sheds light on our day, it sheds light on al-Ghazali. Just as it sheds light on al-Ghazali, it sheds light on the classical ulama. Hazrat Thawban narrates. The Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, said: "The time is near when foreign nations will call one another to pounce upon you, just as eaters call one another to a dining spread."
One of those present asked whether that would be because of our small numbers on that day. He said, "No." On the contrary, on that day you will be many. But you will be like the scum and debris that a flood carries and heaps up, debris that has no weight at all. Allah will remove from the hearts of your enemies the feeling of fear towards you, and He will cast weakness (wahn) into your hearts. What is weakness? it was asked, O Messenger of Allah. He said: love of the world and fear of death.
26. Like Eaters Calling One Another to a Dining Spread
Now, this is in Abu Dawud, but it is possible to find it in all the hadith books in different versions. For example, a separate version. It says you will be like foam on top of the sea. For example, there are differences at this point, you know, differences in wording. Pay attention. What would they do? The time is near when foreign nations, that is, enemies, that is, non-Muslims, will call one another just as eaters call one another to a dining spread.
27. Afghanistan, Iraq, Syria, Iran, Libya
Let me now give you examples from the recent past. Afghanistan, what did he say? Bush said, either you are with me or you are with them. They gathered all the Christians and Jews in a single centre and razed Afghanistan to the ground. What was it? What was it? Was it September 12? Was it September 11? Related to September 11. Yes. What did he say? Either you are with us, he said, or you are with them, he said. They bombed Iraq. They levelled it to the ground. Syria likewise, and they gathered wherever they pleased.
They gathered. As a gang of five they levelled it to the ground. Now they have gathered again. Against whom have they gathered? Against Iran. What did they do? While Iran was being bombed, did any group raise its voice? No. And they devastated Libya. They killed the head of state of Libya, pardon the expression, in a place like a rat's hole, showing it off for all to see; they martyred him. I mean, who actually said anything to them? Nobody could say anything, and they gathered. Like these eaters, what are they doing? They are attacking the Islamic world.
28. The Houthis: "What Kind of Game Is This?"
But now from within, the Houthis drop a bomb somewhere. Our poor Muslims applaud it. The same Houthis are now bombing Saudi Arabia. The same Houthis are doing the biggest job in dividing and breaking up Saudi Arabia. The same Houthis said that if Turkey does something on this matter, we will give it the necessary response. They said it. Who could be behind the Houthis, I wonder? Let it not be a staged fight.
Or has the time come for Saudi Arabia to be broken up? It is an interesting thing. If you follow the press, for example, the Houthis and the Americans have agreed not to attack each other. What kind of game is this? What kind of game is this? Wasn't America supposed to be the greatest Satan? What kind of game is this?
29. The Greatest Fitna and al-Ghazali's Time
This hadith of ours sheds light on al-Ghazali's time as well. It sheds light on our time as well. It will shed light on the times after us as well. Fitna. So what is the most important fitna, then? Your being weak against the unbelievers, and the unbelievers gathering together in one place and attacking you. In al-Ghazali's time this danger existed too. How did this danger exist? Down in Egypt there is a Shi'i, Fatimid state whose founder was a Jew. and it attacks as an enemy both the Abbasids and the Seljuks.
30. The Assassins, the Batinis, the Druze and the Denial of Hadith
And inside, within the Seljuk state, there are the Assassins (Hashshashin). The Assassins inside deny the hadiths. The Assassins inside say that prayer is not an act of worship. They regard prayer as unnecessary. The Assassins inside, and the Fatimid state in Cairo, and the Batinis who emerged from among them also regard prayer as unnecessary. The Druze who emerged from among them regard prayer as unnecessary.
Now in the country, too, there are those who regard prayer as unnecessary. Now in the country, too, there are those who deny the hadiths. The Assassins also denied the hadiths. The Fatimids, the Batinis, the Druze also denied the hadiths. Now, too, they deny the hadiths. So I sit and I say: at the root of those who deny these hadiths, I say, there are the Jews. The Jews are feeding them. Because in Egypt, within the Fatimid state, there are Jews.
They too are deniers of hadith. The Assassins too are deniers of hadith. The Shi'i, Fatimid Batinis deny prayer. They deny fasting. The Assassins also deny the Hajj. Now, too, there are those who deny them within the Islamic world and in our country. Let us see, what difference is left?
31. A Life Spent Writing Refutations
Fitna, and all of these, in fact, the Seljuks are dealing with these as well. The most important thing al-Ghazali dealt with at that time: he writes, you know, against the Batinis. He writes refutations. He writes refutations of the philosophers. And not only of philosophy. He writes refutations of those who are problematic in matters of creed ('aqa'id). His life was spent writing refutations. Well now, if you weaken people's religious feelings, thoughts and beliefs, and if you place a fitna within their beliefs, it is very easy to occupy that place. It is very easy for you to break that place apart, to corrupt it.
32. Byzantium, the Mongols and Internal Turmoil
Al-Ghazali and his contemporaries are dealing with these, and around the Seljuks there are the Byzantines who want to swallow the Seljuks whole, there are the Mongols. Down below there are the Fatimids, there are the Batinis. And inside there are the Assassins. And there is internal turmoil.
33. Mentesh and the Baba Ishaq Revolt
One example of internal turmoil is Mentesh, the brother of Haji Bektash Veli. I can't not talk about these. Mentesh raises a great revolt in that region, Sivas, Erzurum. It is known as Baba Ishaq. Yes. But Mentesh is within it. Mentesh is an important figure. The Seljuks kill Mentesh, of course. We have closed this parenthesis too. That is probably enough. Of course, right now in Turkey there are professors who support Baba Ishaq.
Right now there are, in quotation marks, Alevis who support Baba Ishaq. There are Alevis who support Baba Ishaq and love him very much. There are Shi'a in Turkey who support Baba Ishaq. There are our leftist brothers who support Baba Ishaq. We have closed the parenthesis.
34. The Seljuks Caught in a Vice
The Seljuks are dealing with these as well. I mean, when you go down, when you go down towards the south, there is already trouble with the Abbasids. But there is a caliph there. When you go a little further down, there is great trouble in Cairo. There are the Fatimids. They keep on occupying the border regions like this. There is a problem. They put Muslims to the sword, they put Muslims to the sword. I mean, does Byzantium stay still? Byzantium too puts them to the sword in the border regions every time. I mean, nothing stays where it is like that. Yes.
35. Security Is a Prerequisite for the Continuity of Religious Life
Now, al-Ghazali, there are many hadiths about fitna. Let us set this aside too. For al-Ghazali, for the continuity of religious life, in al-Ghazali security is a prerequisite. Law is a prerequisite, the state is a prerequisite and order is a prerequisite. I mean, if people do not have security of life and security of property, the order of worship breaks down. The knowledge of society disappears. Well, trade breaks down. If there is no security of life and property in a country, trade breaks down. Family order breaks down.
Law becomes impossible to apply. And when it is like this, society falls apart. When society falls apart, the state falls apart. All of these are things connected to one another.
36. A Country Without Security of Life and Property
Well now, imagine a country. I mean, there is no security of life in the country. Anybody shoots anybody. He gets out after 20 years. Well, imagine a country. There is no security of property. Anybody seizes some property. Seizes a company. Various mafias have sprung up. There is no security of property. For example, Yenidağ: where 22 billion dollars went is unknown. There is no security of property. Who will give account for the 22 billion dollars?
37. Three Bankruptcies
One night, towards morning, I went bankrupt. How did I go bankrupt? During the government of Tansu Çiller and her people, Tansu Çiller abolished the penalty on cheques. My cheques worth 500,000 liras at that time became waste paper. It was over. When the penalty on cheques was lifted, nobody paid. Not a single servant of Allah paid. And all of them ended up in court. Where is the security of property? In the morning … I said, I have gone bankrupt. My second bankruptcy was the dollar rising from 300 liras to 3,000 liras overnight.
Yes. My 3rd bankruptcy was February 28. The state imposed on me a fine of 3, at that time 1 million dollars. The court case lasted more than 10 years. I won in court, but for me it was already too late.
38. Without Security of Property, Everything Breaks Down
Without security of property, absolutely everything breaks down. What breaks down? The individual's order of worship breaks down. What order? What breaks down? The individual's trade breaks down. What breaks down? The individual's family order no longer remains. What no longer remains? Normally, while these things are already happening, the law does not work properly either, and society, be it a part of it, be it a section of it, be it all of it, becomes restless, and society also becomes divided.
39. «Religion and the Sultan Are Twins»
This being so, al-Ghazali does not see the state merely as an apparatus of administration. Al-Ghazali sees the state, the worldly order, as a condition for religious life to be sustained. Because if there is a state, there is political order, there is religious order. And of course this idea later arrives at a formula. What is this formula? Religion and the sultan are twins. Religion is the twin sibling of the state. Something like: religion is the twin of the state.
40. This Saying Is Not a Hadith
Well, normally of course, if you look at this saying, some have characterised it as a weak hadith. A few people have said so, but I looked, may Allah forgive me, at the hadith books on this point, the ones I have. I did not come across such a hadith. I wanted to point this out specifically like this. Of course al-Ghazali, this too, in the context of al-Iqtisad fi'l-I'tiqad, this is al-Ghazali's saying. Look, al-Ghazali does not call it a hadith. Al-Ghazali, this.
Some say that al-Ghazali fabricated this as a hadith. That is not so. They are slandering him. So where did al-Ghazali say this? May Allah forgive me. I looked into that too. Al-Ghazali, in the context of al-Iqtisad fi'l-I'tiqad, says "it has been said that religion and the sultan are twins." "It has been said that," he does not call it some hadith-schmadith, al-Ghazali. May Allah forgive us. I said hadith-schmadith. He does not call this a hadith like that. But they speak of it as if al-Ghazali had fabricated such a thing.
41. The Foundation and the Protector: Religion and the Sultan
Whereas when we look, before this became an Islamic principle, remember this from earlier lessons. Normally the Romans used it too, the ancient Greek philosophers used it too. Iran, the Sasanian State, also used it. Now, this being so, in terms of understanding al-Ghazali, this note is also important. That is, then, how are we to understand the formula "religion is the twin of the sultan"? In al-Ghazali's thought there is roughly the following logic.
Religion is the fundamental matter. The sultan is an organ that protects that foundation. Well, can a building stand without a foundation? It cannot. Fine, you have built the building. Can you protect the foundation without its protector? No. Then, if you cannot protect that building without a protector, what is the protector here that protects the building, that protects the foundation? The state, that is, the sultan.
42. Religion Cannot Be Reduced to Any Institution
But reducing religion to the state is a great danger. It is not possible for religion to be reduced to the state, or for religion to be reduced to any institution or organisation, for religion to be reduced to any tariqa, any spiritual disposition, profession, or school of law, or a community. You know how we sometimes see these phrases. Those who are of us are destined for Paradise, those who are not of us are destined for Hell. Those who vote for us are destined for Paradise, those who do not vote for us are destined for Hell.
I mean, Trump is saying the same thing now. Those who support us are destined for Paradise, he says. Those who do not support us are destined for Hell. It is not possible for the phenomenon of religion to be reduced to a community, an association, a leader, a state, any institution or organisation, or to a tariqa, to the sheikh at the head of a tariqa, to a community, to the teacher at the head of a community. Let us put this out in the open. I mean, that teacher died, so religion died: there is no such thing. That state died, so religion died. There is no such thing.
43. The Nonsense of «There Is No Need for the State»
But for religion to be lived, for society to be able to stand, is political authority necessary? Yes. Is the state necessary? Yes. You know how sometimes some people come along who see the state as unnecessary. Like, in modern times there is no need for the apparatus called the state. What shall we do? Let us abolish all states. Let all people live in peace and so on. There is this kind of nonsense and what have you. May Allah forgive me.
Well, this is not normal either. Al-Ghazali… normally, at this point, religion needs to be distinguished from the state. That is, normally, or rather, religion must not be reduced to the state, must not be reduced to a group.
44. There Is No Unconditional Obedience
When we look at al-Ghazali, at his works, he is not at the point of "whatever the sultan does is right." Such a thing never comes out of al-Ghazali's mouth. Well, but at this point there are certain hadiths. It is not possible for al-Ghazali to ignore those hadiths either. For example, it is found in al-Bukhari. A Muslim listens to the word of the amir and obeys him, even if he does not like it. If the amir commands something that is a sin, it is not necessary to heed that command. With this hadith standing there, al-Ghazali has no notion that the sultan must be obeyed unconditionally in everything.
It is unthinkable anyway; none of the Ahl al-Sunna accept this. Well, again, there is a narration coming from Ibn Abbas. Whoever sees something the amir has done as bad, let him be patient. Because whoever separates from the sultan by a single cubit dies the death of the Jahiliyya. Al-Bukhari. I mean, with these hadiths existing, al-Ghazali has no position that the sultan is to be obeyed unconditionally. He reads these hadiths, and I read them too.
Well now, with these hadiths, or certain verses of the Qur'an, standing there, al-Ghazali has no stance that whatever the sultan does, he is right and it is his right.
45. Nasihat al-Muluk: The Fundamental Quality of the Ruler Is Justice
Well, normally, quite the opposite: al-Ghazali, so to speak, places heavy responsibilities on the sultan. Because when we look at Nasihat al-Muluk, when we study it, that book is very important. For al-Ghazali's political, military, state stance, and at this point also his Islamic stance, that book is very important. Well now, al-Ghazali sets down justice as the fundamental feature of his ideal ruler. For al-Ghazali, the indispensable, most important feature in a sultan is that the sultan be just.
46. Head of the Family, Sheikh, Dhakir: Everyone Must Be Just
If the sultan is not just, alas; the man who is the head of the family must be just. The sheikh at the head of a dergah must be just. A dhakir must be just. Someone who gives a lesson must be just. Justice is one of the most important qualities of a leader. The head of the family must be just. Justice must, absolutely and absolutely, be in the hands of the head of the family. Injustice is the greatest fitna.
Injustice is the greatest anarchy. You have three children. You discriminate, you show favouritism towards one of them. You behave unjustly. You are the father of the family. You cannot behave unjustly towards your wife. You have to behave justly towards your wife. If you do not behave justly towards your wife, you are not a good father. You are not a good husband. You are a master. You have to behave justly among the dervishes. You have to behave justly among the dhakirs.
If you do not behave justly, you are not a good sheikh. You are a dhakir. You have to behave justly among the dervishes. If you do not behave justly among the dervishes, you are not a good dhakir. If you bow and scrape to the rich and push the poor away from you, then whether you are a dhakir, a sheikh or a murshid, whatever your title may be, you are not just. Yes.
47. Justice in the Family
Within the family you have to behave justly towards your wife and your children. If you do not behave justly, you are not a good father, not a good husband. It is the same for women. Women, too, have to behave justly towards their husbands. They must not make problems out of trivial, petty matters. They will behave justly. Children, too, will behave justly towards their mothers and fathers. Justice is indispensable for every part of society, but for a head of state, for a state, it is extremely important. If there is no justice, then, in inverted commas, that state does not earn the quality of being an Islamic state.
48. The Sultan Must Attend to the Needs of the People
The sultan must refrain from oppression. Al-Ghazali says this. The sultan must not oppress his subjects. He must ensure justice. He must attend to the needs of the people. He must not simply hand over the state's property and money to the rich. He must attend to the poor and the needy among the people. He must attend to the poor and the needy among the people. Take 22 billion dollars and multiply it out at today's rates: how many years of pensions would that have paid to all the retirees? If he does not attend to the needs of the people, then the sultan is an oppressive sultan.
49. He Must Supervise State Officials
He must supervise state officials. If the sultan does not supervise state officials, and if state officials torment the people, if state officials do not see to the needs of the people, if they do not protect the rights and the law of the people, if state officials shut their eyes and stopped their ears while 22 billion dollars went out the door, then they became partners in oppression. They became partners in theft.
50. Consultation with Scholars — But Which Scholars?
So the sultan of the state must consult with scholars and experts. With scholars, but not with hadith deniers; with scholars, not fiqh deniers; with scholars, not with those caricatures of scholars who say, "Oh, interest is permissible up to the rate of inflation." Not with Masonic-minded people and Masonics, not with Soros supporters, not with those parodies of scholars who have sold their souls to Jewish organisations, not with people who have profited from, lived off Soros's foundation and handed their souls over to Soros.
Rather, with the ulema who in the true sense hold fast to the Qur'an and the noble Sunna. With perfect murshids who hold fast to the Qur'an and the noble Sunna. Not with appointed sheikhs. Not with sheikhs backed by the CIA. Not with sheikhs whom Mossad has seated at the head of the tariqas it has founded. Not with those at the head of the counterfeit communities and tariqas that Byzantium and the Jews have engineered within the country.
51. An Expert in His Field
With scholars in the true sense, with perfect murshids and with experts in their fields. If the matter at hand is finance, then finance is not run by seating at its head someone who knows nothing about finance and saying, "Look at the light in my eyes," nor does someone carrying a British passport make a financier either. A financier in the true sense is needed. Well, now, he will consult with these people. I mean, at one time there was this poor fellow.
In the ANAP period the man served as Minister of National Defence, he served as Minister of National Education. The man served as Minister of the Interior. There was no ministry left that the man hadn't held. Man, what a well-equipped fellow he must have been! He understood everything. Yes.
52. Extravagance: Umar and the Governor of Yemen
Most importantly, the sultan must avoid extravagance. Oh, what a man Umar was! He went to Egypt. To inspect the governor, sorry, he went to Yemen. To inspect the governor. The governor, for the standards of that time, brought honey sherbet with wheat bread. He served it up in front of the governor. He called him. "O governor, come here. Come, quickly, come." The governor came running, and he said, "Sit down here." "Does the poorest of your people eat this?" he said. "Does the poorest of them eat this honey sherbet and this wheat bread?" he says.
Because people were eating barley bread. "No. No, O Commander of the Faithful," he says. "Take this away," he says. "Take this away. A governor or head of state who does not eat what the poorest of his people eat, drink what they drink, wear what they wear, is a liar," he says. "He is a liar." Ah, Umar, what a man!
53. The Door of the Governor of Egypt
And what does he do to the governor of Egypt? The governor of Egypt put up a door. And he put a secretary there. And he put a soldier there too. That is, you would have to get past that soldier. Then you would have to get past the secretary in order to meet him. Then you would come to the governor. He sends a letter. "If you do not tear down that governor's building," he says, "I am coming there," he says. He has the governor's building torn down. Why? Bid'a (innovation). Because there was no guard at the door of the Prophet (peace be upon him).
Oh, the great Prophet! Hey, there was no watchman at the door of our master Abu Bakr. Oh, the great Abu Bakr! Ah, Umar had none. Uthman had none. Ali had none. Our master Hasan had none. At their doors, guards — they had no guards at the door of the state. Nor were there guards at the doors of their own homes.
54. Compassion, the Love of the People and the Gate of Evil
The sultan must avoid extravagance, and the sultan must be compassionate; he must not be merciless towards his subjects, and the sultan must win the love of the people. The people must not loathe him. And the sultan must encourage good and prevent evil. That is, the sultan must not open taverns. The sultan must not open, nor have opened, places that are contrary to the Qur'an and the Sunna, and the sultan must not give free rein to hadith deniers. The sultan must not give free rein to those who deny verses of the Qur'an.
The sultan must not give free rein to deniers of the madhhabs. He must close the gate of evil. Of evil — the sultan must not give free rein to Jewish caricatures.
55. "Will the Viziers Never Run Out?"
A little while ago our Yusuf Hoca touched on something. I really liked it, I mean. He said, "Will the viziers never run out?" "What he meant by 'Will the viziers never run out?' is the story of the vizier in the Masnavi." Go back and read the story of the vizier in the Masnavi once more. Yes. Therefore, to place the sentence "the sultan is powerful, therefore he is right" at the centre of al-Ghazali's political theory would be an outright error and a slander. A more accurate expression might be this. The sultan is the holder of power. But this power is limited by justice and responsibility.
56. The Hardest Question: Obedience to an Oppressive Sultan
Now we have come to the hardest question. Truly, this part fried my brain. Obedience to an oppressive sultan. This is the most debated point in al-Ghazali. You know, those critics in modern times, those who scrutinise this subject, those who try to pass verdicts on this issue and so on. They have debated al-Ghazali a great deal on this point. Of course, the statement, the view attributed to al-Ghazali is this. If trying to overthrow a bad and oppressive sultan who holds military power, solely because of his oppression, would lead to greater fitna and bloodshed, then the continuation of the existing government is preferred.
While al-Ghazali thinks this way, I did not just say "al-Ghazali thinks like this" about the matter and leave it there, you know, so that the issue might be better understood.
57. Nisa 4:59 and the Hadiths on Obedience
We must not ignore the verses and hadiths on this subject either. Nisa 4:59. [Qur'an, an-Nisa 4:59 — verse text pending: Diyanet English translation] Of course, there is more after this. We will come to the part where it says that if you fall into disagreement, refer it back to Allah and His Messenger. And of course, the Prophet (peace be upon him) also has hadiths related to obedience like this. "Whoever obeys me has obeyed Allah.
Whoever disobeys me has disobeyed Allah. Whoever obeys the emir has obeyed me. And whoever disobeys the emir has disobeyed me." I am saying this in quotation marks. Some of the Sufis use this hadith as well. That is, they take it in the sense that obedience to the master is obedience to the Prophet. We do not like to use this very much like that. I have closed the parenthesis.
58. "You Will See Matters in Which Others Are Preferred over You"
Again, the hadith is found in Bukhari and Muslim. "After me you will see certain matters in which others are preferred over you, you will see certain matters that you dislike." After me, others will be preferred over you. If we normally take this in the time of the Companions, you know, they will not prefer the Companions, they will prefer others. If we take it to our day, or to al-Ghazali's day, there are, somewhere, people who follow the Qur'an and the Sunna.
These are not preferred. Others are preferred. We saw this with the Umayyads, the Abbasids, the Seljuks. We saw this with the Ottomans too. This is just how it is, this is something visible.
59. Those Who Were There at the Start of the Road Are Cast Aside
You know, it normally happens with politicians too, right, at the start of the road it is Qur'an, Sunna, homeland, nation. We are all running together. Ah, then we look and see that towards the end of the road, in the middle of the road, some of us have fallen away. Then, ah, when we walk a bit further, we look and see that, oh, nobody who was there at the start of the road is left. New generations have formed. The rich and whatnot, those who got rich; those like our Yusuf Hoca have been cast aside.
I mean, this exists. This exists in every period, in every field, in every community. I sometimes say this so that it serves as a measure. Well, in Bursa, with whom did we set out at the start of the road? There you go, Cafer, Adnan, Hüseyin, 30 years have passed and they are still going. And in Bayındır, Harun Hoca, Oktay, you know, what's his name? Nuri, from the start of the road, is still going. I mean, it's not like, you know, a rocket goes and drops one stage, then drops another from behind. It's not like that.
60. "Ask Allah for Your Own Right"
But the Messenger of Allah gives an example from that time. He says that some will prefer others. You will see certain matters that you dislike. When the Companions asked, "O Messenger of Allah, then what do you command us?" he said the following. "Give them their rights. As for your own right, ask Allah for it." So, my friend, he does not say, "Stir up anarchy." One has no right to stir up anarchy.
61. Whoever Separates a Hand-Span from the Community
Again, a hadith of Bukhari and Muslim. I deliberately took ones from Bukhari and Muslim. So that they have no room left to object. You know, how they normally say, "Oh, you can take a hadith like that from Tirmidhi," right? No, Bukhari and Muslim. "Whoever sees his emir do something he dislikes, let him be patient. For whoever goes out a hand-span from the community dies the death of the Jahiliyya." In quotation marks, the Sufis use this part too. Some Sufis say, "You have separated from the master, you have separated from the community."
"That is why your death is a death of the Jahiliyya," they say. The Sufis view separation this severely. I mean, sometimes, you know, friends would say to me, "Come on, if only you would show a little mercy to these ones who leave." Now nobody can say it, but before they used to say it like that. I would say, "Look, mind your own business." Because these hadiths are very, you know, sound and very sharp.
62. The Hadith of Hudhayfa ibn al-Yaman
In fact, there is one more hadith. Normally, you know, it says that if that person separates from the community, kill him. Hudhayfa ibn al-Yaman, as you know, was the secret-keeper of the Prophet (peace be upon him). He narrates it. It is a long hadith. I took the part connected to the subject. "After you there will be leaders who will not be guided by my guidance. They will not practise my Sunna." Pay attention. They will not be guided by my guidance.
They will not practise my Sunna. This means that these will not follow the way of the Prophet (peace be upon him), and they will not practise the Sunna of the Prophet (peace be upon him). They will think lightly of the Sunnas, see them as unnecessary, deny the hadiths. When this blessed person, Hudhayfa, asked, "If I live to see that time, what should I do?", he said, "You listen to the emir and obey.
Even if your back is beaten and your property is taken, still listen and obey." These are the hadiths under debate. Muslim narrated it.
63. If Sin Is Commanded, There Is No Obedience
This, again, is a hadith of Bukhari, Muslim and Ibn Majah. "It is incumbent upon a Muslim to listen to and obey the emir in matters he likes or dislikes, so long as he is not commanded to sin. If he is commanded to something that is a sin, then there is no listening and no obeying." The Sufis have used this hadith as well. That is, in this sense a Sufi, whether he likes it or not, if it is within the Qur'an and the Sunna, if nothing sinful is being commanded, is obliged to listen to and obey his master.
And likewise towards the emir; I mean, some of these hadiths are found in the old Sufi books. Sufis like these take them as examples for themselves. Again, a hadith from Muslim. "There is no obedience to a creature in a matter that is disobedience to Allah."
64. The Stance of the Imams of the Schools towards the Oppressive Sultan
In the light of these hadiths, the subject will now get a bit long. Please forgive me. I believe this subject needs to be understood well. Because what was the stance of the imams of the schools of law towards the oppressive sultan? What were their views in fiqh? What exceptions did they bring? These are matters that perhaps have never been discussed in a Sufi community until today. Let me go further. Things that no community or tariqa would find the courage to talk about. If they researched these, they could actually find them. Very easily.
65. Imam-i A'zam: A Corrupt Ruler Loses the Qualification of Imamate
Of course, first, what is the view, the ijtihad, the exception of Imam-i A'zam, Abu Hanifa, on this point? Let us look at that. Abu Hanifa — in quotation marks, I am a bit of an Abu Hanifa man, you know — against the general tendency of Ahl al-Sunna to be patient no matter what, personally carried out an active but controlled opposition against oppressive government. According to Abu Hanifa, it is a condition that the head of state be just. Even if an oppressive and corrupt person is initially chosen in a legitimate manner, if he later turns to oppression, he loses the qualification of caliphate and imamate.
The most radical fatwa on this matter is in Imam-i A'zam, among the Hanafis — you know how they ask us, what is your madhhab? Abu Hanifa. What is your creed? Imam al-Maturidi — I say inwardly, if you had known Imam-i A'zam, you would not dare to say this. O Hanafis, the fatwa of Imam-i A'zam: if a head of state slides into oppression, into tyranny, and comes to be described as a corrupt person, he loses the qualification of imamate.
66. Armed Uprising and Its Strict Condition
Of course, Imam-i A'zam also has an exceptional condition. This is the most dangerous point regarding an oppressive ruler. He theoretically considers an armed uprising against an oppressive ruler permissible. However, there is a very strict condition for this. This strict condition is very important. Those who are going to overthrow the ruler by the sword must have a very high likelihood of success. If the rebellion will lead to greater chaos, to the blood of Muslims being shed in vain — that is, if there is no chance of success — he does not consider the uprising right.
This is its exceptional condition. That is, bringing down an oppressive ruler by the sword is permissible. Bringing him down through an uprising is permissible. But the chance of success must be very high. Otherwise, those who undertake this are responsible for the blood that is shed and the losses that occur.
67. To Those Who Say «There Is No Politics in Religion»
Of course, all four of the imams of the four madhhabs had a political stance. Normally they tell us, you know, there is no politics in religion. Sit where you are and keep quiet. Ignorant, utterly ignorant man. Real politics is in the religion of Islam. The religion of Islam is at the very heart of politics. It is not on its margins.
68. Imam-i A'zam, the Umayyads and the Abbasids
Throughout his life, Imam-i A'zam opposed Umayyad and Abbasid oppression. He refused the offers of office from the Umayyads. Because he refused, he was flogged. As for the Abbasid period — and it was Imam-i A'zam who gave the fatwa for the overthrow of the Umayyads. He both gave a fatwa for the overthrow of the Umayyads and also helped financially.
69. Not With Money Collected From the People
Imam-i A'zam was a wealthy man, but not with money collected from the people. He was not someone who set up a company there and said that within the community, zakat would be distributed with goods bought from this company. He was not one of those imams who said: those who are going to distribute zakat will come and buy the cloth from me. If it is this cloth, you will distribute zakat with it. We will build a caravanserai, we will build a bathhouse, we will build a mosque, we will build a road. He was not someone who said, oh, we will dig a well somewhere or other, and then pocketed the money.
He was not someone who collected who knows how many tons of gold. He was not someone who set up giant companies and used those companies to rob the people blind. Imam-i A'zam did not take a single penny for the fatwas he gave or from the students he taught. Yes.
70. Refusing the Office of Chief Judge and Being Martyred
In the Abbasid period, he supported — both with his fatwas and materially with financial aid — the armed uprisings launched against their oppressive rule by Zayd ibn Ali of the Ahl al-Bayt and later by Muhammad al-Nafs al-Zakiyya. He refused the Abbasid caliph al-Mansur's offer of the office of chief judge so as not to become an instrument of legitimacy for an oppressive regime, and because of this he was thrown into prison and martyred by being flogged.
After Imam-i A'zam was martyred, Imam Abu Yusuf accepted this post. Imam Muhammad did not accept it. Then his student … did not accept it either. Write this down on the side as a note as well.
71. Imam Malik and the Muwatta'
Of course, after Imam-i A'zam, one of the most important imams of the madhhabs, Imam Malik, studied under Imam-i A'zam. And Imam-i A'zam studied under Ja'far al-Sadiq. Imam-i A'zam's teacher is Ja'far al-Sadiq. From the Ahl al-Bayt. Ja'far al-Sadiq is not like today's Shia. Ja'far al-Sadiq stands on the Qur'an and the Sunna. Yes. Imam Malik is, as is well known, the founder of the Maliki madhhab. Of course, Imam Malik is regarded as the school of the Hijaz region, especially the school of Medina.
That is, he wrote the Muwatta', for example, for the Hijaz region. Imam Malik also did not want the Muwatta' to be taken outside the Hijaz region.
72. «An Allegiance and an Oath Taken Under Coercion Are Invalid»
Of course, Imam Malik too normally attached great importance to the peace of society and public order. However, he displayed a juristic stance against oppression. In general, so that fitna does not arise and Muslims do not kill one another, he holds that one should be patient with the ruler even if he is oppressive. But he too has an exception, and he has a political stance. In the Abbasid period, when Muhammad al-Nafs al-Zakiyya rose up against the caliph in Medina, the people of Medina came to Imam Malik: we have given allegiance to the caliph al-Mansur.
If we join this rebellion, will we have broken our word, they asked. Imam Malik gave one of the most courageous fatwas in the history of Islamic law. In my view, that is how I described it. I said, he gave a very courageous fatwa. In the time of the caliph al-Mansur, this is not an easy fatwa. You gave allegiance to al-Mansur under pressure and coercion. An allegiance and an oath taken under coercion are invalid." — this was the fatwa he gave. This fatwa opened the way for the people to rise up against the oppressive sultan.
Because of this juristic stance, he was arrested and flogged by the governor of Medina. He was subjected to torture to the point that both his arms were dislocated from his shoulders, and both his arms were indeed dislocated, and because they were never treated, Imam Malik was never again able to do any work with his two arms. Despite this, he did not retract his fatwa.
73. Imam al-Shafi'i
Well, let us come to Imam al-Shafi'i. Now Imam al-Shafi'i, too, both because of his deep love for the Ahl al-Bayt and because of his juristic path, always kept a distanced relationship with oppressive rulers. Imam al-Shafi'i's view, according to the Shafi'i madhhab, is that if a head of state commits oppression or becomes corrupt, he does not automatically fall from office, and one does not march against him with the sword. However, the people's obligation to obey him is limited only to his commands that are in accordance with the sharia.
Imam al-Shafi'i generally stayed in the Yemen region, and while he was there, he was accused of plotting a rebellion against the state on the grounds that he opposed the oppression that state officials inflicted on the people and that he protected supporters of the Ahl al-Bayt. He was put in chains and brought before the caliph Harun al-Rashid in Baghdad. But Imam al-Shafi'i, with his sharp intelligence and his juristic defences, was saved from execution at the last moment.
But Imam al-Shafi'i regarded going to the doors of those oppressive rulers and currying favour with them as the ruin of scholars and of scholarship. I am cutting it short, briefly. Today I am going to take up a lot of your time.
74. Imam Ahmad ibn Hanbal and the Mihna
Imam Ibn Hanbal, on the other hand, is the imam who most rigidly and uncompromisingly defended the Ahl al-Sunna view of being patient with an oppressive ruler rather than causing fitna. He considers armed uprising against the head of state, for whatever reason, absolutely forbidden (haram). He argues that one must be patient even if oppression reaches its peak, because the harm that a civil war would bring is many times greater than the harm of an oppressive sultan.
Imam Ahmad and his stance were neither cowardice nor submission but complete civil disobedience. In today's language. Because during the times of the Abbasid caliphs al-Ma'mun, al-Mu'tasim and al-Wathiq, the idea imposed by state force that the Qur'an is created, which, as is well known, is the view of the Mu'tazila. He rejected it. He saw this imposition by the caliphs as an act of oppression and a blow against the Islamic creed. He did not submit to the official view of the state. He remained in prison for years.
He was subjected to severe torture and floggings, yet he never compromised this belief of his. Despite this, he always stood in the way of those who wanted to incite the people to armed rebellion against the caliphs who had thrown him into prison. Saying, "Do not shed blood, do not disturb the peace of the Muslims," he advised patience.
75. The Common Ground of the Four Imams
There is something on which these four imams normally meet at a common point. Even if the sultan is oppressive, if fitna is going to break out, if blood is going to be shed and victory is not certain, they recommended patience. After all, Imam al-Ghazali is a Shafi'i. He himself. According to the imam of the Shafi'i school too, it is not possible for him to oppose it.
76. al-Ghazali in the Modern Arena
That being so, in the light of these juristic rulings, al-Ghazali's view, of course, in this modern arena, in this arena where it is not clear who is what, I mean, was the man fed by Soros? Was he fed by the Jews, was he fed by the CIA? Was he fed by Mossad? Is he an English lackey, a German plaything, it is not clear what the man is. In this arena all of these are being debated. Of course, there are also those who tear al-Ghazali to pieces on this point, but nobody looks at the view of the four schools, the view of the imams of the schools; they ignore it.
It is not possible for al-Ghazali to go outside the view of those imams of the schools. That being so, these gentlemen say that al-Ghazali, in particular, accepted the de facto order of the sultanate and the existing administrative institutions rather than regarding them as entirely invalid.
77. al-Ghazali Does Not Say «Oppression Is Good»
But here we need to make an important distinction. What is it? al-Ghazali's logic is this. al-Ghazali does not say oppression is good, nor does he say the oppressive sultan is good, nor does he say an oppressive administration is good. His logic is this: if an attempt to remove oppression will give rise to greater oppression and fitna, he thinks that the outcome of destroying the existing order could be worse. That is, normally there is an existing system. If, when we set out to destroy this existing system, something worse will happen, then let us not destroy it.
Let us not attempt to destroy it. Let us try to correct it. His logic is: let us try to correct it without destroying it. And this, normally, I mean, does not give moral approval to that oppression. He sees it as a political and legal necessity, which the hadiths also foresee. No anarchy. Look, this point is very important. Anarchy must not break out in the Islamic world.
78. The Tension Between Justice and Order
Well now, this thing in al-Ghazali's thought, of course, brings out a tension. The tension you know. On one side there is justice, on the other side there is order. Of course, al-Ghazali, at that time al-Ghazali asks himself this. While wanting to change an unjust order, what if a greater disorder emerges? This is exactly where al-Ghazali acts with caution. Because, in quotation marks, there is an order in the Seljuk state.
Within that order there is security of the people's life, security of property, security of honour, security of the mind. If we destroy this order, says al-Ghazali, then what kind of thing will come in its place? If nothing comes, blood will be shed, there will be chaos. This time everything will be turned upside down. There are already elements waiting for the Seljuks to be turned upside down. Byzantium on one side, the Fatimids on one side, the Mongols on one side. The Seljuks caught in a pincer.
That being so, al-Ghazali says for that day that we need to improve this system. We need to make this system better. Just as with Nizam al-Mulk's madrasas and the strengthening of the Sunni system, the opening of madrasas and the teaching of their religion to the people.
79. Lambton and Marx
Well, of course, I took quotations from foreigners here, and when I looked at those foreigners, they did not look at all at the conditions of the age in the environment in which al-Ghazali lived and stood. I mean, on this subject they have put forward a somewhat deliberate criticism. The most important man among them is Lambton. This man emphasises this in his study on al-Ghazali's understanding in Nasihat al-Muluk as well. And he criticises. You know, he says al-Ghazali should have striven to destroy the order of that day.
Of course, they look at it from this angle. You know, this somewhat calls Marx to mind. Let me drop a bit of a bombshell. You know, Marx too makes armed uprising a condition, armed uprising for the power of the proletariat, and the proletarian order must definitely be established through armed actions. However much blood is shed, it does not matter. Indeed, revolutions are written in blood. There you go, a wall slogan for you. We read those a lot. We erased them a lot.
Well, this "revolutions are written in blood" should remind you of some other things too. They wrote revolutions in blood. Yes.
80. The «Obedient» Label and the 1095 Turning Point
Of course, this gentleman Lambton looked somewhat critically at al-Ghazali, at Nizam al-Mulk, at the Islamic scholars of the Middle Ages. Here, labelling al-Ghazali, of course, as an obedient scholar, thinker, an obedient Sufi, an obedient organ of the state, and labelling him like this, would be one of the greatest slanders against al-Ghazali on this point. Because in al-Ghazali's life there is a very important turning point in 1095, and his death is in 1111 anyway. That is, he dies some years later. al-Ghazali leaves his post.
81. Why Did al-Ghazali Leave His Post?
Now we are coming to that point, to the end now. Why does he leave? Around the palace he sees a serious conflict between position, wealth and fame on the one hand and the religious life on the other. A little while ago our Yusuf Hoca, inside, asked why al-Ghazali left. al-Ghazali sees that those chasing position, those chasing wealth, chasing fame, have multiplied around the palace. Palaces are like that. Yes.
82. The Hunters of Wealth, Position and Fame Around the Palace
Those chasing position, those chasing fame and wealth surround the palace. al-Ghazali, who wanted a genuine religious life, and al-Ghazali, who ran and struggled for a state order within the framework of Islam, at the end of that running about, in the last 6 years of his life, because he believed that he had now, in his own estimation, fulfilled his duty, carried out his task, at least that he had done in his own self what he had to do, and most importantly, the fools, the bootlickers, the dishonest, the dishonourable, the shameless around the palace.
That was a bit harsh, but when the wealth hunters, the position hunters, the fame hunters around the palace multiply, and when the gentlemen inside the palace also become blind of eye, stone of heart, dark, they become unable to see the true scholars and learned men. They become unable to see the true Sufis. And the one sitting in that palace is taken in by the applause. "As you wish, sir," and he gives more credit to the bootlickers and fools around him. al-Ghazali is not a man of such an environment.
al-Ghazali is not a man of such an environment. At that time he has a connection with the palace, he has a connection with the viziers, he has a connection with the caliph. Had he wanted position, fame and wealth, he would have stayed there. But with Imam al-Shafi'i's fatwa standing there, the fatwa that the scholars close to the palace, the scholars who bootlick the palace, are certainly doomed to perdition, al-Ghazali did not stay either.
83. Satanised People Surround the Sultan
That is why he may have thought that if he stayed there, the otherworldly side of his life would remain lacking, that he would face trouble on this point, that, and Allah knows best, his salvation, his last breath … would be put in danger among those fools for wealth, position and fame. Because those fools for wealth, position and fame are the soldiers of Satan. They are satanised people. They are, directly, satanised people. They do not see the needs of the people.
They do not see what the people are going through. And they surround the sultan too, they surround the palaces. They prevent the sultan, too, from seeing the truth and the reality.
84. In Companies, in Religious Communities, in Sufi Lodges
This exists in trading houses too. In companies. The managers are actually unsuccessful. The managers make the company look very successful. This exists in religious communities too. Bootlickers, fools, wealth hunters, position hunters surround the hoca. And because the hoca's heart is not working either, he cannot see the truth. They make off with the money. These also surround sheikhs who are not qualified. They do the same thing to the sheikh.
Wealth hunters. "Efendi Hazretleri, we need to build a tekke here. You need a tekke. It would suit you very well. Let us collect from the friends. Let us open a madrasa here." Of course the Efendi Hazretleri also says, "Yes, a madrasa is needed here, let us open one. That madrasa never gets finished." When you look, you see the ostentatious lifestyles of these sheikhs. They set aside a share for the sheikh too. Our Cafer never figured out these things. He never figured them out, and he won't figure them out at this point either. Yes. al-Ghazali too, normally... Yes.
85. The 3 S's: Servet, Şöhret, Şehvet (Wealth, Fame, Lust)
al-Ghazali may have defended the state, but al-Ghazali is not a man who entered into the state and profited from power, wealth and lust. I mean, we normally, I do apologise, call this wealth, lust, fame. These three are a very great disease. There is a lot of it around palaces. There is a lot of it inside palaces. Three S's: servet, şöhret, şehvet, wealth, fame, lust. This is what destroys all palaces. I call these the 3 S's. This is also something that destroys a person.
A person is destroyed by these three S's. Wealth, fame, lust are a disease. This is a satanic disease. This satanic disease does not care whether you are a woman or a man. When this satanic disease enters a person, it burns and wrecks everything around. A person can no longer see anything. Nothing at all. Let wealth, fame, lust enter a dervish. You cannot hold that dervish back. No way. Let it enter a bureaucrat, it ruins him.
86. Epstein and the Set-Up
There are many of these around the order of the state like this. What was it? Epstein in America? Something came out, Epstein was it? What was its name? What was Epstein? Wealth, lust, fame. All three are in it. Isn't that so? Look, all the world leaders have passed through that set-up. All the bureaucrats have passed through that set-up. All the company owners have passed through that set-up. They have passed through that set-up. Even Trump passed through that set-up. There's that video of him dancing away, bopping along like that. Would Mossad ever let you go? Allah. Yes.
87. Not Confusing the Sultan with the Caliph
Here we must absolutely not confuse the sultan and the caliph with each other. The most important aspect of al-Ghazali's system is, roughly, that the caliph is the legitimate imam of the umma. There is an imam descended from the Abbasid line. There the caliph is the centre of religious and political legitimacy. The sultan, on the other hand, holds the actual military power in his hands. He governs the country and maintains public order. But he does this within the framework of the caliph's legitimacy. al-Ghazali's solution actually answers the question "caliph or sultan?" in the form: the two are parts of the same political order with different functions.
88. Power + Allegiance to the Caliph + Public Order
In studies in Europe too, it is said that al-Ghazali's defining of a new relationship between the sultanate and the caliphate was aimed at legitimising the sultan's rule. But what al-Ghazali does here is a very, how shall I say, typical, a typical theoretical change. This change, you know, in the classical sense the caliph, the imam, comes first and power is in his hands. But in the period in which al-Ghazali lived, military power is with the sultan. The caliph, on the other hand, is the seat of legitimacy.
Therefore al-Ghazali is obliged to answer the question of how the sultan can be legitimate. We see this in his works. Because a formula that emerges here can be summarised as: power plus allegiance to the caliph plus public order equals the acceptability of de facto sultanate. I mean, this is a rather ready-made answer that al-Ghazali gives to the political reality he lived in.
89. The Continuation of Nisa 59: Return to Allah and His Messenger
Well, from the standpoint of the Qur'an, the basic verse al-Ghazali relies on is this. One of the most important issues. [Qur'an, an-Nisa 4:59 — verse text pending: Diyanet English translation] But in the continuation of the verse there is this. Let us not skip over this. [Qur'an, an-Nisa 4:59 — verse text pending: Diyanet English translation] There is an important limit here. al-Ghazali, too, gives great importance to this limit. What is it? The command to return to Allah and His Messenger. This is something that concerns absolutely everyone.
90. No Obedience Is Absolute
That being so, obedience to those in authority (ulu'l-amr) is not absolute, or obedience to the father is not absolute. Obedience to the sheikh is not absolute. Obedience to the husband is not absolute, or this is not absolute obedience to the head of state. This point needs to be understood well. Because the leader, the father, the sheikh or an administrator, what will be the measure at this point? The Qur'an and the Sunna, and obedience to those in authority. But if there is disagreement, if there is wrongdoing, one will return again to the Qur'an and the Sunna.
There is no absolute obedience here. It says: return again to the Qur'an and the Sunna. If a disagreement arises. That is why it is not possible to derive from the Qur'an an equation of the form "obedience to the sultan is absolute obedience to Allah."
91. Timur's Text and Ocak's Paragraph
I mean, in the passage, what was it saying, what was written there by Timur? It said that obedience to the caliph is obedience to Allah. And it said that if you do not obey us, if you have rebelled, you will have rebelled against Allah. But normally, in the Ahl al-Sunna consciousness, in the creed of Ahl al-Sunna, the Qur'an says obedience to Allah, obedience to the Messenger and obedience to those in authority. But if there is a problem, if there is a disagreement, it says return again to the Qur'an and the Sunna.
Then, this being so, you know, this also becomes an answer to Ocak's paragraph. You know, there was that paragraph by Ocak that we read in the last lesson, to that as well.
92. «Obedience Is Only in What Is Right (Ma'ruf)»
But the hadiths also lay out this limit clearly. What was the famous hadith? It was in al-Bukhari and Muslim. There is no obedience to a servant in disobedience to Allah. Obedience is only in what is right (ma'ruf). I mean, this also appears in other hadiths with different wordings. That being so, al-Ghazali's understanding of obedience is not "whatever the ruler commands, he is obeyed." That is not possible. But for the preservation of the political order, obedience to the existing government is the principle.
However, if there is disobedience to Allah, if it is something outside the Qur'an and the Sunna, it is not obeyed. Look, it is not obeyed.
93. The Key Point: The Consequence of Rebellion
Of course, the most important problem here concerning al-Ghazali is this: rather than obedience, the consequence of rebellion, and that is the key point of today's talk. Al-Ghazali separates two things from each other. One, the moral assessment. The sultan may be a tyrant. Two, the political consequence. Armed struggle to overthrow him may give rise to greater harms such as civil war, bloodshed, the collapse of state institutions, and the disappearance of the legal order.
Al-Ghazali gives great importance to the second question. Therefore his approach is not "love the tyrannical ruler." Rather, it is: take into account the overall outcome that will emerge in the struggle against tyranny. This is what I understand. Someone else may understand it differently.
94. The Strong Side: Well-Intentioned Rebellion Does Not Produce Good Results
Of course, this idea has a strong side. It also has a weak side. It has a problematic side. We can read al-Ghazali critically. The strong side is this. In politics, al-Ghazali does not accept well-intentioned rebellion. He does not accept the assumption that it automatically leads to a good result. I mean, we rebelled with good intentions. Come on, we launched a Gezi. That does not produce an absolute result. A good result. This is a historical interpretation, a historical reality. Well-intentioned rebellions have not produced good results.
Throughout Islamic history, well-intentioned rebellions, look at the rebellions in the Islamic states of Islamic history, the internal… in none of them did a good result come about.
95. Destroying Is Easy, Building Is Hard
Because overthrowing a government is easy. Overthrowing a government is very easy. Ruining a family is very easy. Toppling a family is very easy. Breaking up a family is very easy. But building a family is very hard. Breaking up a dergah (Sufi lodge) is very easy. Someone stirs up some fitna (discord) there. 5-10 people leave. They carry on in opposition. Breaking up is very easy. Bringing together, keeping together is very hard.
96. «I Do Not Take Back Those Who Leave»
You throw some fitna into Demirtaş. You can break up Demirtaş. You can never gather it again. That is why I do not take back those who leave. Everyone who leaves goes by destroying. Because they go by talking, by criticising, by stirring up fitna. That is why I do not forgive them my right. The reason has nothing to do with my own nafs (self). You break up 10 people there. 10 people were gathering. They were doing the remembrance of Allah (dhikr). What did you want from that?
You threw in some fitna. That place broke up. I speak with examples, with evidence. Is the ladies' gathering still there? Isn't it very small there now? Isn't it clear who broke it up? It's clear. Ismail does not forgive. We talk with Ismail. I don't forgive either.
97. There Is Nothing in the World as Easy as Destroying
Whoever broke it up: while a place is being built, effort is spent, tears are shed, sweat is shed. Time is given. Then someone stirs up fitna there. An impossible fitna, a fitna about nothing. He breaks that place up. There is nothing on earth as easy as destroying. They are trying to break up this community too. They don't like us. Because, you see, we don't collect money. We call white white and black black. We don't see black as white. And we don't see white as black. Whatever our view is, it's out in the open.
98. 15 July and 12 September
That being so, al-Ghazali does not struggle for the destruction of the existing system. Because whatever will take its place, or else if nothing takes its place, it turns into a lake of blood. We lived through a 15 July. Isn't that so? 300 people died. Before 12 September, 30 people were dying a day. And all those who died were going to save the homeland. All of them were going to save the homeland, and al-Ghazali is against rebellion even with good intentions. Yes. Because overthrowing a government is easy. Establishing order afterwards is very hard.
99. Married Men, Fathers: Establishing Order Is Hard
Look, never forget this throughout your lives. Especially married men, fathers. Married men, fathers. Establishing order is very hard. If you destroy it, establishing order again is very hard. if a man is a man, if he is a real man, he protects his home, preserves it, keeps it going. If he is a real man, unless there are absolutely indispensable things, if it becomes compulsory, then there is nothing left to do. You know, I tell the men: if your wife wants a divorce, don't wait, divorce her.
You yourselves should not want divorce. It is you who will save the marriage, who will protect it. Because as men. But if a woman wants a divorce: have you thought it over well? You have. Don't hold on for a single day. Because in today's system she can get you into trouble. It's very simple. One phone call. "My husband might beat me." That's all. Not "he beat me." "He might beat me." Bang, a restraining order on the man. 3 months. Yes.
100. There Is No Sin as Great as Disrupting Order
There is no sin as great as disrupting order. You know, causing a rift between married people is a major sin. Causing a rift between the dervish and the murshid (spiritual guide) is a major sin. Criticising a zakir behind his back to a dervish. It cools the dervish towards the zakir. And therefore it cools him towards the sheikh. The man says, the dervish says: the zakir makes this many mistakes. Doesn't the sheikh see this? He doesn't see. Meaning he's one of the blind, you see. He says this dergah is no dergah. That dervish is not aware of what he is doing.
Ignorant. Whereas until he became a dervish, how much effort his sheikh, his zakir, his çavuş, the neighbourhood coordinator spent on him. And you got up and told that dervish about the mistake of a zakir, of a sheikh. You cooled that dervish's heart. You destroyed his spiritual life. How are you going to give account for this? The greatest tyrant is you.
101. «You Are Satan's Decorated Soldier»
He came to your shop or to your workplace, or he came to visit you. A dervish; by what right do you criticise to him any element of the dergah, its mistake, its fault? You ringleader of fitna. You fitna-monger. To destroy a dervish is to destroy a world. He came to your shop. What business is it of yours? Do your trading. You criticised the dergah's zakir, its sheikh, the way the dergah is going, and what happened to that dervish? Did you gain something? Did you gain something? Did someone pin a medal on you? Who pinned it? Satan pinned it. You are Satan's decorated soldier.
102. The Weak Side: Making the Tyrannical Ruler Untouchable
That is why al-Ghazali says: there is an existing system. If this collapses, there will be chaos. Blood will flow. Blood will flood everything. It will collapse. He says that for Muslims, rising up against this is not permissible. Imam al-Shafi'i says the same thing. So the bad side of this way of thinking is this. Always being patient with a tyrannical ruler so that a system does not collapse. This is the bad side. But if it is like this, then we make a tyrannical ruler untouchable.
This is problematic, but I mean, this is already one of the most debated issues about al-Ghazali after al-Ghazali.
103. Obedience and Legitimacy Are Not the Same
Obedience and legitimacy are not the same. Because this distinction must especially be noted. Al-Ghazali saying that the existing sultan must be obeyed. This does not mean that this sultan is morally just. In the same way, his saying that the existing political order produces legal consequences does not mean that the ruler is God's representative in everything he does. The legal recognition of the de facto political order and the ruler being morally ideal are different things from one another.
If we do not make this distinction, we see al-Ghazali as more authoritarian than he is, or as more idealised than he is.
104. In Nasihat al-Muluk the Sultan Is Warned
Another important point is al-Ghazali's criticism of the sultan. In Nasihat al-Muluk the sultan is constantly warned. Do not oppress. Be just. Consult with the scholars. Look after the rights of the people. Supervise your officials. Do not be wasteful. See to the needs of the people. Do not forget that the life of this world is temporary. For this reason, to read al-Ghazali's understanding of politics merely as "people, obey; obey the sultan" would be a great deficiency. When we look at Nasihat al-Muluk, if you were to say to me, you know, summarise Nasihat al-Muluk for us in one sentence.
Regarding the sultan, I could say that the sultan must know his responsibilities and must be just. Justice, justice, justice.
105. The Debate over the Authorship of Nasihat al-Muluk
Of course, the last point regarding Nasihat al-Muluk: there is a debate about whether all of it belongs to al-Ghazali. Don't mind my laughing. You will say, didn't I know this? I knew it. That's why I left it to the end. There are researchers on whether it really belongs to him. They are researching this point. According to some, only the matters of faith belong to al-Ghazali, that is, the introductory section. And some say, you know, there are also those who say that the subjects other than the matters of faith do not belong to al-Ghazali.
So, you know, when saying about al-Ghazali "al-Ghazali definitely said this," it is beneficial to be careful regarding this Nasihat al-Muluk.
106. A Map of al-Ghazali's Political Thought
Yes, we have come to the end of al-Ghazali and of tonight's sohbet. We can draw al-Ghazali's political thought like this. God's ruling: religion, that is, the sharia; the caliphate: legitimacy; the sultan: de facto power and execution; the ulama and the qadi: the religious-legal order; justice plus security plus public order; the society being able to sustain its religion and its worldly life. But standing constantly against this is the danger of tyranny, and opposite it, fitna, civil war, anarchy.
We can say that al-Ghazali's political thought takes shape precisely in the tension between these two dangers. Because there is tension in both of them.
107. The Next Question: Ijtihad
I didn't want to prolong the subject any further. This is the last note. I was going to go on longer, because there are things I deleted here. I wanted to finish tonight. And it's already 11 o'clock. Yes. I mean, that was brother Hakan's last paragraph. In these questions, everything is quoted. I may have made mistakes. Forgive me. If we prolong it a bit more, the subject will go to ijtihad. God willing, let the next question be ijtihad. He had said at the very end: we will discuss whether it will bring about the revolutions through renewal or through returning to the essence. Yes.
108. How This Talk Was Prepared
There are also many places where I quoted while preparing this talk. When making the quotations: cut, copy. Generally, you know, I did the quotations by writing. I am slowly learning to have it converted into text by reading it aloud like this. Then there's a Windows key here. And there's an H here. When you press the two and speak, it writes. As if I were in a sohbet. I press them. That's how it talks. No, the people passing in front of the door will say, what's going on, Mustafa… is talking.
Sometimes I say it shouting and it doesn't pick it up. Our thing, the computer. Sometimes it can't convert my letters either. I get annoyed. Then it writes it all over again from scratch.
109. Apology and Thanks
Well, I have my sources in hand for preparing this subject. As you know, I strove to prepare the al-Ghazali talk by reading those sources and then examining them. There will have been places that I saw as mistaken, where I myself, I mean not in al-Ghazali but in myself, made mistakes, places I saw wrongly, saw incompletely, saw incorrectly, could not see fully. Well, it turns out interpreting al-Ghazali is not an easy thing.
I understood it once I got into it, but we had gotten into it once. And then there's the Özbağ ambition, you know, and there's also the Bayındır spirit. You know, I'll get out of this, God willing. We have got through it. So, like, I don't remember ever turning back from anything up to today. By God's permission I believe we have finished it, but I surely will have had mistaken, incomplete, wrong aspects. So I apologise to all of you, and to those listening and following, and I ask forgiveness from God in this matter as well.
Because I have no ulterior intention. No, making al-Ghazali look very good or sinking al-Ghazali, I have no such concern. But looking at al-Ghazali more with the naked eye, trying to understand al-Ghazali more, that was my concern. God willing, I benefited a great deal from these studies, by the way. God willing, you too will have benefited.
110. Final Word: The Hadith of 'Arfaja
As a final word, I have taken a hadith here. I'm going to make you jump out of your seats a little. 'Arfaja narrates. The Messenger of God, peace and blessings be upon him, said: "There will be evils and corruptions. Whoever wishes to cause division within this ummah while it is united, whoever he may be, strike off his head with the sword." In one narration he said, kill him. Let me read it to you again. There will be evils and corruptions. Whoever wishes to cause division within this ummah while it is united, whoever he may be, strike off his head with the sword. And in one narration it was said, kill him.
111. Protect Your Family, Your Dergah, Your Workplace
Do not break your unity. And do not give an opportunity to those who want to break your unity. (Amin.) Because the time is a time of evils and corruptions. In a time of evils and corruptions, whoever is working to break your unity, to stir up your unity, silence him. I cannot tell you to kill. Because killing belongs to the state. But do not listen to him; silence him. Because fitna and corruption are the greatest satanic acts that ruin societies. In the family, do not give an opportunity to those who want to ruin your family.
Even if it is your wife's mother and father, even if it is your husband's mother and father. Do not give an opportunity to those who want to ruin your family. Protect your family against fitna, against evil. Protect your dergah. Protect your workplace. Yes. Do not give an opportunity to evils, to corrupters, to fitna-mongers. May my Lord protect us. (Amin.)
112. The Hadith of Thawban: Those Who Join the Polytheists and Those Who Worship Idols
The talk is over. I had taken a hadith down here. Let me read this one too. Thawban (radiyallahu anhu) narrates. The Messenger of Allah (sallallahu alayhi wa sallam) said: "What I fear for my ummah is misleading imams. Once the sword enters among my ummah, it will not be lifted until the Day of Judgment." The Hour will not come until some tribes of my ummah join the polytheists, until some tribes of my ummah worship idols.
What were they going to do? Some people from his ummah were going to join the polytheists. Wait. And what were some of them going to do? They were going to worship idols. We have seen those who worship idols. We have also seen those who join the polytheists. Then that means the Hour is near. That hadith too, as the last hadith, I mean, normally later on, you know, while I was looking at the hadiths I saw that one too, and I said let me just take this one as well. A warning. So what were some of the ummah going to do?
They were going to join the polytheists. What does joining the polytheists mean? Taking everything the polytheists do and say as one's own standard and supporting the polytheists. And some of them were going to worship idols. And some of them were going to worship idols. Look, he says some of them are "from my ummah." That is, you will see them as Muslims. And they too will say, we are from you. We are Muslims too.
They will say, we too say la ilaha illallah Muhammadun Rasulullah. But they will worship idols. Lat, Manat, Uzza. Do not forget these idols either.
Note: This text is the speech itself as found in the recording of the sohbet: only spelling and punctuation have been edited, and obvious mishearings in the subtitles have been corrected; the places of a few words that could not be made out are marked with «…». Section headings have been added to make reading easier. The opening and closing prayers have not been included.
Bibliography
The verses, hadiths, works, persons and events mentioned in the sohbet are collected below. This lesson closes the discussion of al-Ghazali with his understanding of obedience, the sultan, the caliphate and order; the next question will be ijtihad.
The Holy Qur'an, al-Nisa 4/59 — Diyanet translation: [Qur'an, an-Nisa 4:59 — verse text pending: Diyanet English translation] In the sohbet it is asked that, together with the first part of the verse, the ruling in its continuation — that if you fall into dispute you are to refer it to Allah and the Messenger — not be passed over; from this it is derived that obedience to those in authority (uli'l-amr), to a father, to a sheikh, to a husband and to the head of state is not absolute.
Hadith — narration of Thawban, Abu Dawud — The report that foreign nations will call one another against the Muslims as eaters call one another to a dining spread; that on that day the Muslims will be many but will be like the scum and debris carried by a flood, and that "wahn" (love of the world and fear of death) will be cast into their hearts. In the sohbet it is read as the greatest of fitnas.
Hadith — Bukhari — «A Muslim listens to the word of the amir and obeys him even if he dislikes it; if the amir commands something that is a sin, there is no need to listen to that command.»
Hadith — narration of Ibn Abbas, Bukhari — That whoever sees something he dislikes in his amir should be patient; that whoever separates from the sultan by a hand's span will die the death of the Jahiliyya.
Hadith — «Whoever obeys me has obeyed Allah» — «…Whoever obeys the amir has obeyed me; whoever opposes the amir has opposed me.» In the sohbet it is noted that some Sufis use this hadith for obedience to the master, but that one does not wish this to be used much.
Hadith — Bukhari and Muslim — «After me you will see others being preferred over you, and certain things you will dislike.» To the question «Then what do you command us?»: «Give them their rights; and as for your own right, ask it of Allah.»
Hadith — narration of Hudhayfa ibn al-Yaman, Muslim — Concerning leaders who will not be guided by the guidance of the Messenger of Allah and will not practise his Sunna; «Listen and obey, even if your back is struck and your wealth is taken.»
Hadith — Bukhari, Muslim, Ibn Majah — «It is incumbent upon a Muslim to listen to and obey the amir in matters he likes or dislikes, so long as he is not commanded to sin; if he is commanded to something that is a sin, there is neither listening nor obeying.»
Hadith — Muslim — «No creature is to be obeyed in a matter that is disobedience to Allah.» Also Bukhari and Muslim: «There is no obedience to a servant in disobedience to Allah; obedience is only in what is ma'ruf (right and recognised as good).»
Hadith — narration of Arfaja — «There will be evils and corruptions. Whoever wishes to sow division within this ummah while it is united, whoever he may be, strike off his neck with the sword.» In the sohbet it is read with the qualification «killing belongs to the state; you, do not listen to him, silence him.»
Hadith — narration of Thawban — «What I fear for my ummah is misleading imams. Once the sword enters among my ummah, it will not be lifted until the Day of Judgment. The Hour will not come until some tribes of my ummah join the polytheists and worship idols.» It is read separately at the end of the sohbet.
Imam al-Ghazali, al-Iqtisad fi al-I'tiqad — The place in al-Ghazali of the saying «Religion and the sultan are twins»: al-Ghazali does not transmit it as a hadith but with «it has been said that». In the sohbet it is said that no such hadith is found in the hadith books, and that those who say al-Ghazali "fabricated a hadith" have slandered him.
Imam al-Ghazali, Nasihat al-Muluk — Counsels on the sultan's avoiding oppression, justice, consulting scholars, supervising officials, avoiding extravagance, and the transience of the world. At the end of the sohbet, the debate among researchers over whether the entire work belongs to al-Ghazali is recalled.
Ann K. S. Lambton — The researcher referred to in the sohbet as «Lambton», who, in her study of al-Ghazali's understanding in Nasihat al-Muluk, criticised al-Ghazali for not striving to overturn the order of his time.
The stance of the imams of the madhhabs toward the oppressive ruler — Imam Abu Hanifa (Imam-i A'zam): that the corrupt and oppressive ruler loses the qualification for the imamate, and that armed uprising is permissible only if the likelihood of success is very high; his support for the revolts of Zayd ibn Ali and Muhammad al-Nafs al-Zakiyya, and his refusal of al-Mansur's offer of the chief judgeship. Imam Malik: his fatwa «An oath of allegiance and an oath taken under coercion are invalid» and his being tortured. Imam al-Shafi'i: his being brought in chains before Harun al-Rashid because he had opposed oppression in Yemen. Imam Ahmad ibn Hanbal: his refusal to submit to the imposition of «the Qur'an is created» in the periods of al-Ma'mun, al-Mu'tasim and al-Wathiq and his being flogged, while nonetheless standing against armed rebellion.
Hazrat Umar and the governors — His saying «Do the poorest of your people eat this?» when the governor of Yemen offered him honey sherbet and wheat bread; his having the governor's residence torn down after the governor of Egypt placed a guard at his door.
Manzikert, 1071 — Alp Arslan's routing of the army of Romanos Diogenes, and the Seljuk sultans' coming to the fore thereafter as a military-political power; the assessment in the sohbet that «had Manzikert not been won, there might be no Islamic world today».
Menteş and Baba Ishaq — The revolt mentioned as an example of the internal turmoil of the Seljuk period; the place in the sohbet where Menteş is mentioned as the brother of Hajji Bektash Wali.
Prof. Dr. Ahmet Yaşar Ocak — The paragraph on kut (divinely granted sovereignty) and the caliphate read in the previous lesson, and the inscription in Timur's mausoleum reading «obedience to the caliph is obedience to Allah»; in the sohbet, the continuation of Surah al-Nisa' 4:59 is presented as an answer to this paragraph as well.
Mustafa Özbağ Efendi, «Questions on al-Ghazali 15» — The full recording of the sohbet that is the source of this article.
Click here for more information about Imam al-Ghazali.
Additional resources: