Sunday, November 15, 2026
OUR PATH IS THE PATH OF PROPHETHOOD
Mustafa Özbağ
Irshad & Tasawwuf · Official Site
al-Ghazali Talks·

From Kut to the Caliphate: State, Legitimacy, and Obedience | Questions on al-Ghazali 14

Translated from Turkish. Original article (Turkish) →
Note: Qur'anic verses in this article are marked and will be completed with the Diyanet English translation; the Turkish original is linked above.

1. This Week We Have Reached the Last Paragraph

Yes, this week we have reached the last paragraph — in al-Ghazali.

Of course, actually, after commenting on this paragraph, perhaps for next week, separately, I added something like this for you at the end. There won't be time for that. And that is just optional, as you like; let us say it, inshallah.

But this week the main theme will be finished.

As you know from last week, let me read that last part so that we make a connection. Because last week we talked at quite some length about that last part. Because this year, this week, I won't make it that long.


2. Last Week's Paragraph: «Religion and State Are Inseparable Twins»

«The religious scholars and the Islamist movement want to govern not only the domains of belief and worship but the state, society, education, the economy, the army, the civil bureaucracy, international relations — that is, in a sense, the whole of life. The assessment made almost a thousand years ago by the famous Shafi'i jurist al-Mawardi, that 'religion and state are inseparable twins', would, as Professor Dr. Ahmet Ocak puts it, lay the foundations of a political theory that would hold throughout the entire Islamic world.»

We read this last week. We tried to comment on it — or rather, not to comment: we gave a direct answer, so to speak.

In that chain of answers, of course, normally now it says «well, it tries to run the state, the economy, politics, this and that, all of it.» True. Now, precisely because there is no such governance, the Islamic world is already suffering.

So how will this pass into practice? Professor Dr. Ocak explains it as follows.


3. The Last Paragraph Read: From Kut to «Allah's Shadow on Earth»

«This interpenetration of the state and Islam turned the Qaghan and Khagan — who, since the pre-Islamic period, were believed to rule for the happiness of the people thanks to the kut granted by the Sky God and to have been chosen by the Sky God himself — with the acceptance of Islam, into Allah's shadow on earth, in whom all creatures take refuge.

From now on the Turkish sultans, as emphasized in the magnificent gold-lettered thuluth script on the inner wall band of Timur's mausoleum, are at the same time a supreme spiritual authority, obedience to whom is counted as obedience to Allah and rebellion against whom is counted as rebellion against Allah; and one step further, they are Allah's caliph on earth.»

Professor Ahmet Yaşar Ocak — date 2017. This is the last paragraph.


4. The Note Added by Brother Hakan, Who Wrote the Questions

Normally, after this, Brother Hakan, who wrote the questions anyway — the reason for this sohbet (spiritual discourse) — added the following at the very end:

«Everything in these questions is quoted. I may have made mistakes. Forgive me. If we extend it a bit further, the subject will move on to ijtihad; inshallah let the next question be ijtihad. Will it bring about revolutions through renewal, or through returning to the essence? We will discuss it.»

Because he is again the revolutionary brother. That is why he said how the revolution will come about. May Allah be pleased with him. This is the last paragraph, inshallah.


5. To Resolve the Matter We Must Separate Three Things from One Another

Now, as you know, in the previous paragraph, or else when we look back over the whole series of talks: al-Mawardi, al-Ghazali, the Seljuks, religious legitimacy — that is, this was important in our talk.

But in order to understand correctly what Ahmet Yaşar Ocak is describing here — that is, to understand correctly what he is saying — we need to separate these from one another.

That is: the Turkish state tradition. The language of Islamic legitimacy. The sacralization of political power.

That is, we need to take each of these up separately so that we can try to resolve the matter better.


6. The Main Idea of the Section We Read: Kut Did Not Disappear Entirely

And the main idea of this section we read is this: that is, when the Turks accepted Islam, the notion in the old Turkish tradition of the ruler possessing kut did not disappear entirely.

It did not disappear among the Seljuks either. It did not disappear among the Ottomans either.

Qaghan son of Qaghan, Sultan son of Sultan — this is the tradition among the Turks. This continued. He says that it was, that is, reinterpreted within Islamic concepts and symbols.

Yes. When we look at it from one angle, is it like this? The answer: it is like this.


7. The Pre-Islamic Notion of Kut and Rulership

Pre-Islamic — then we now normally, since the Turks have been mentioned — we will look at the pre-Islamic notion of kut and rulership.

That is, in the old Turkish political understanding, the ruler's power is not seen as an ordinary power. That is, this Khagan, or even his viziers, are not an ordinary power.

This kut, in its simplest sense, is believed to be of divine origin. That is what kut is.

That is, normally when you look at Timur, there is a Khagan of divine origin. Or when you look at Mete, when you look at Attila, all of them, in their own view, possess kut — that is, they say they were appointed by the Sky God, or by God.


8. But This Is Not Something Seen Only Among the Turks

But while saying this, the masters of all the empires that were their opponents, their contemporaries — the empires — also see themselves as chosen.

This is not something seen only among the Turks.

That is, when we look at their counterpart at that time, the Chinese Empire, they too are chosen. Or when we look at the empires in Europe, they too are chosen.


9. It Is Also the Same Today: Trump, Bush, Netanyahu

At the same time, it is the same today: that is, Trump too sees himself as chosen. Trump too sees himself as appointed by God.

The one before him too — Bush too — used to say that he was appointed by God.

Today it is also said of Netanyahu that he is appointed by God.

Today it is also claimed that the British royal family is appointed by God.


10. The Declaration of «Descendants of the Messenger» and the Claim of a Sayyid Lineage

Even further — as you know, a Sheikh Efendi who has passed away had even declared them to be descendants of the Messenger.

He had said: «These have been chosen from the lineage of the sayyids.» This was said in terms of lineage.

Now look: if even a British royal family is honored with a claim that it was chosen by God, and if they too see themselves this way — then normally understanding this solely as Islamic politics or as the political understanding of the Turks becomes a sterile circle.


11. European Politicians Including Macron, and the Oath on the Bible

Today even politicians in Europe — Macron included — think this, that they have been chosen by God.

And because they think they have been chosen by God, they see themselves, in their own eyes, in quotation marks, as God's appointees; and all of them take office by swearing on the Bible.


12. Hitler, Mussolini, and Those in Whose Name the Call to Prayer Was Recorded

Let me go even further: Hitler too said that he was chosen by God. Mussolini too said that he was chosen by God.

It is said that Mustafa Kemal Atatürk too was chosen by God. The call to prayer was recorded in his name by those around him. In his name normally — yes, — an amentu (a creed) was written in his name.

He too, and those around him too, say that he was chosen by God.

Now when we look, the great majority of the heads of state who govern the states of the world say that they were chosen by God, that they were sanctified.


13. The Four Concepts Contained Within Kut

Now, this being so, the old Turkish tradition that is of course at issue here for us — the political tradition — this being so, in that old Turkish tradition, kut contains within it the concepts of fortune (that is, destiny), power in that person, the capacity to rule in that person, and legitimacy.

That is, in a person who has kut, one: there will be fortune. Two: there will be power. Three: there will be the capacity to rule. Four: he will be legitimate.

For him to be legitimate, again, he must be a Kaan son of a Kaan. Otherwise there is a problem with legitimacy.

He must have the capacity to rule: from childhood onward he is given a region. He is the sultan of that region, or else its vizier. He comes to possess the capacity to rule.


14. Among the Turks There Is Also This: When the Father Dies, the Country Is Divided

But among the Turks there is also this: that is, when their father dies, how many sons are there? There are four sons. There are three sons.

When you examine history, the country is divided into three. Each becomes the kaan of the place where he is.

Then they fight one another, they wage war. One of them prevails. He oversees the whole country.

This internal turmoil is something that was lived through every time a khagan died. Where am I going with this? Where I am going with this is: the fratricide in the Kanunname (law code) of Mehmed the Conqueror. Let me take the short route now.


15. The Khagans Would Not Say «I Am Strong, That Is Why I Rule»

But the khagans among the Turks would never say «I am strong, that is why I rule.»

That is, they thought that their authority came from a higher source, from a sacred source.


16. The Difference Between the Designation «Sky God» and «God Is in the Heavens»

That is, normally of course, in history books it is designated as the Sky God. Among the Turks there is no notion of a sky god.

When we look, researchers say «sky god»; but among the Turks there is no notion of a sky god. Only this: God is in the heavens.

Look, the two understandings here are very different: when you say «sky god», this is not monotheism. You would also need an earth god. Then you would also need a sea god.

It is not like this. The understanding among the Turks is: God is in the heavens. He is high, He is exalted.


17. The Question the Prophet (peace be upon him) Asked a Slave Girl

You know, His Excellency the Prophet, sallallahu alayhi wa sallam, asks a slave girl. Was it a slave, a slave girl, what was it? Now my mind went back and forth between the two. He asks:

«Where is Allah?» he says. «Allah is in the heavens,» she says. That being so, she has faith in Allah. «Set her free,» he says.

That is, by her saying «Allah is in the heavens», she ascribed loftiness to Allah. Because she ascribes loftiness, she says «Allah is in the heavens.»

That is why the understanding among the Turks is this too.


18. The Duty of the Kaan: The Order, Happiness, Justice and Survival (Beqa) of the People

That is, the Kaan is normally a person appointed by God. That is why he is charged with securing the order of the people, the happiness of the people.

And the one who is the khan of khans, or the person called the Kaan, has legitimacy, and normally has equality. He holds society equally. He ensures justice. He ensures right and law.

And beqa — that is, he thinks of the survival (beqa) of the state.


19. Survival Is Not at the Beginning, but at the End

Actually, this point needs to be stirred up a bit more. You see, here I put survival at the end; but in that old Turkish culture too, survival is at the end.

Survival is not at the beginning. That is, the survival of the state is not at the beginning; the survival of the state is at the end.

If normally — because if that khagan is a legitimate khagan and holds his people equally, if he ensures justice among the people and holds right supreme — that state is legitimate; that state will have no survival problem.


20. In a Turkish State There Is No Survival Problem

Because among the Turks — now I put it this way because I think you will sometimes compare this with new rhetoric — that is, in a Turkish state there is no survival problem.

In a Turkish state there is legitimacy; that is, there is a legitimate state or government, a state and government that ensures justice, a state and government that abides by right and law.

If it is legitimate, if it ensures justice, if it acts in accordance with right and law, that state does not experience a survival problem.


21. A State That Puts Survival First Drifts Away from Right and Justice

The survival problem, the idea of survival, is not at the beginning among the Turks. Now, a state cannot put survival first and drift away from right and justice.

It cannot put survival first and commit injustice, it cannot act unlawfully.

Look: putting survival first and saying «we have a survival problem, that is why we did not ensure justice here»; «we have a survival problem, that is why we could not stand on right here» — this does not exist in Turkish state policy.


22. From Central Asia Onward: «You Can Call Me a Racist, I Don't Care»

From Central Asia onward, fifty thousand years, a hundred thousand years. Now don't mind them saying «one hundred fifty-two thousand years.»

That is, when you say Turkish states, you can go back from here even five hundred thousand years. Five hundred thousand years.

From this you can say that I am a racist. I don't care about that. This has nothing to do with racism.


23. The Understanding of Kut and the Understanding of the Caliph Are Not the Same

Now, that being so, here he says that the pre-Islamic understanding of kut — yes — evolved after Islam into the understanding of the caliph.

The understanding of kut and the understanding of the caliph are not the same.

That this is so, you know, researchers may say that they are the same. That is, yes, there is a historical process. The same geography. It is perfectly normal for the same geography to be influenced by one another.


24. Things That Share a Geography Resemble One Another, but Are Not the Same

Well, it is also normal for some things to resemble one another. You share a geography; that is why some things can come to resemble one another.

You know, just as the food culture on the same Anatolian lands came to resemble one another.

That is, the Armenian, the Greek, then the Turk — many branches within the Turks. When we look at these, their food cultures have resembled one another. Their music has resembled one another. Their customs, traditions and practices have resembled one another; but they are not the same.

It is worth distinguishing this.


25. Was There a Very Great Difference Among the Turks After Islam?

Then, you know, after Islam, was there a very great difference in the Turks' understanding of the state, understanding of right and justice, understanding of legitimacy, understanding of survival? There was not a very great difference.

But look, what was, normally, the claim of Professor Ocak here? The old system was not entirely abandoned, but it was relegitimized with Islamic concepts.

That is, are there places that resemble this? Yes. While there was the understanding of the khagan to whom Gök Tengri (the Sky God) gave kut (divine charisma), did expressions such as «the shadow of Allah on earth» also begin to be used for the ruler in the Islamic period? The answer: yes.


26. The Ruler Was Now Surrounded by a Language of Religious Legitimacy

Is this an extremely important transformation from a political point of view? Yes.

Normally the ruler now — once there was Islam — is not only a holder of military power, a member of the dynasty, an administrator of the state.

At the same time, rulers now came to be surrounded by a language of religious legitimacy.


27. There Is No Hadith About «The Shadow of Allah on Earth»

And of course here we are going back again. When we go back to al-Ghazali's issue: what does «the shadow of Allah on earth» mean?

Look, there is no hadith on this matter. There is no hadith with the meaning «Khagans or padishahs are the shadow of Allah on earth.»

But for a ruler this is a powerful symbol of political legitimacy. Can its meaning expand? The answer: it can expand.


28. When Opposing the Ruler Is Considered Disrupting the Divine Order

That is, opposing the ruler is not merely a political rebellion; it can also be perceived as disrupting the divine order.

There are also fatwas related to this: You know, if you rise up, you are in the status of a baghi (rebel). And if you are in the status of a baghi, you are killed; and when you die, you die as an unbeliever.

That is why normally here, of course, if it is perceived as «disrupting the divine order,» critical problems arise.


29. From the Duty of Ensuring Justice to an Instrument of Immunity

While at the beginning the ruler's duty of ensuring justice, preserving order and protecting the people was emphasized, over time the same concept can also turn into an instrument that strengthens the ruler's immunity.

That is, rulers who are heads of state become untouchable.

These things are not very distant from you. Throughout history these are not distant things for any community.


30. Whom Can You Not Touch?

You cannot touch the British royal family — it is untouchable.

You cannot touch Bush. Just as they could not touch him, you cannot touch Trump. You cannot touch heads of state. You cannot touch royal families.

Today you cannot touch the Saudi kingdom. The Jordanian kingdom, as you know, you cannot touch. They have immunity. And they are untouchable by the constitution, at that.

You cannot touch members of parliament; they have immunity. That is, even if one commits a crime, normally members of parliament are tried once their term as deputy comes to an end. Ministers have immunity.


31. If We Say «Sultans Are Untouchable,» We Are Not Egalitarian

That is, if we just say, you know, «rulers are untouchable,» or if we say «sultans are untouchable,» then we are plainly not egalitarian. We will not have stood at the point of right and justice.

That is why, I mean, the statement «the ruler carries the trust of Allah» and the statement «obedience to the ruler is obedience to Allah, therefore what he does cannot be questioned» are not the same thing.

In my view, this is one of the most important points of the historical transformation that, you know, Professor Ocak pointed to: the matter of «obedience to them is obedience to Allah.»


32. From the Perspective of the Qur'an We Must Be Very Careful: Nisa 59

Here we must be very careful from the perspective of the Qur'an. I am looking at it from the perspective of the Qur'an. In the Qur'an, in Surah al-Nisa, verse 59, there is a command like this:

[Qur'an, an-Nisa 4:59 — verse text pending: Diyanet English translation]

Obey Allah, obey His Messenger; obey those in authority among you, your administrators.


33. The Verse Establishes Obedience to Those in Authority (Ulu'l-Amr), But Not Absolute Obedience

Look, the verse of the Qur'an is something interesting: That is, it also — it also — establishes obedience to those in authority (ulu'l-amr).

But it is not possible to derive this from it: there is no question of absolute, unlimited obedience to those in authority or to the ruler. Or at least that is how I understand it.

Because in the continuation of the verse it says something interesting: [Qur'an, an-Nisa 4:59 — verse text pending: Diyanet English translation]


34. The Qur'an Fires the Signal Flare in Advance

That is, disagreement will arise. A problem will arise here. The Qur'an fires the signal flare for us in advance.

Disagreement will arise here among people. When disagreement arises, it says «return to the Qur'an and the Sunna.» «Return to Allah and His Messenger.» Why?

That is, the fundamental measure the Qur'an sets is this: because political authority is not the ultimate truth and the absolute authority.


35. Political Authority Can Err, Can Commit a Deliberate Crime

They can make mistakes, they can do wrong, they can fall short. They can even commit a deliberate crime. They can step outside the Qur'an and the Sunna. These are possible.

If they do, then return to Allah and His Messenger. That is, you return to the very essence. Make a return to the essence, return to the essence.

Learn from the essence how that disagreement is to be resolved. Because there are unshakable and timeless principles brought by Allah and His Messenger.


36. There Is Obedience to the Administrator, But It Is Not Identical to Obedience to Allah

So then, consequently, there is obedience to the administrator; and yet we cannot say «obedience to the administrator is identical to obedience to Allah.»

Here I had normally treated this, you know, very extensively in relation to «politics in Islam.» So there is a great difference between them.

Because rulers, khans, administrators, heads of state, ministers, viziers — it is possible for all of them to make mistakes and do wrong. Is there such a danger? There is.


37. That Danger Also Exists for Sheikhs, Zakirs, Naqibs and Dervishes

So that danger has not passed for anyone: not for sheikhs, not for zakirs, not for naqibs.

When we look from the perspective of the Sufi world, among dervishes too the danger of making mistakes and faults, doing wrong, falling short exists for all of them.


38. Our Subject Is Politics: Let Us Go to the Essence of the Matter

But our subject is politics, after all. Since our subject is politics, come, let us go to the essence of the matter. To the essence of the matter.

His Excellency Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa, sallallahu alayhi wa sallam, was both a prophet, and a head of state, and also commander-in-chief. He was in the army.

He was both the head of a family and a father. And also a man of trade. Look, he was also a man of trade.

When we look, there is a prophet who would look, and did look, in every direction within life, and who lived every aspect of life.


39. When That Prophet Passed Away: The First Caliph, Hazrat Abu Bakr

And when that prophet passed away, the first caliph was our master Hazrat Abu Bakr. Now, as a measure, the first caliph. Because the caliph — the first caliph elected — was our master Hazrat Abu Bakr.

When we look, then we have a measure: First there was a prophet who was infallible — for whom it was impossible to err, impossible to follow his whims and desires, and whatever he said was the tongue of truth.

And all the Muslims were living within that prophet's system.

The Prophet passed away, sallallahu alayhi wa sallam. In his place His Excellency Hazrat Abu Bakr, radiyallahu anh, was elected. And this is the first sermon of our master Hazrat Abu Bakr.


40. Source: al-Suyuti, Tarikh al-Khulafa', Page 35

There are normally different versions of this. I took this from al-Suyuti — let me state it this way.

Normally there are different narrations through different channels; the sermon on this is long, because al-Suyuti also took this as the core essence.

Normally I can give the reference too: Tarikh al-Khulafa', page 35. You can look it up there.

You know, my heart leans a bit toward the Sufis like this. Al-Suyuti is also a Sufi, one of the people of Sufism. So because my heart leans that way, I took it from him. Let me speak openly.


41. This Sermon Is a Measure for Everyone

Yes. This is the first sermon of our master Hazrat Abu Bakr upon being elected. "O people" — listen well to this part. Look, this is a great measure for us.

This is a measure for politics, this is a measure for the tariqa, this is a measure for Sufism, this is a measure for sheikhs; for dervishes, for those who lead the dhikr, for naqibs, for the nuqaba, for the empty gourds — this is a measure for all of them.

This is a measure for everyone. For all who govern, too.

Are you an administrator? Are you a father? Yes — it is a measure. Are you a mother? A measure. Are you a boss? A measure. Do you lead the dhikr? A measure. Are you a naqib? A measure. Do you have ten people around you? A measure. Are you a minister? A measure. Are you an administrator? A measure.


42. The Official Car and "Come Along, My Ayvaz; Off You Go, My Tingoz"

Where? Say, are you a chief in the municipality like this? You've got in the back. You're clinging like this to the thing — to that handle. Like this, full of yourself, with your driver up front.

You know, you're a chief somewhere there, or you have a post there; and they've given you an official car too. Every morning they've taken you for somebody.

Like this, the official car brings you around, "come along, my Ayvaz; off you go, my Tingoz," you know. All of them hold posts — everyone, I mean.

And on top of that, they rent thousands of cars for the municipalities. Thousands of cars. Thousands — look, thousands. Everyone holds a post. Because there's no staff to do the work. May Allah forgive us. (Amin.)


43. "I Have Been Placed Over You Though I Am Not the Best of You"

"O people! I have been placed over you although I am not the best of you."

He doesn't say "I took charge" — he says "I have been placed over you."

"If I carry out my duty as it should be done, help me." If I carry out my duty as it should be done, help me.

"If I do my work badly, set me right." If I do my work badly, set me right. "Truthfulness is a source of trust, and lying is treachery."


44. The Weak Are Strong, the Strong Are Weak

"The weak among you are strong in my sight, by Allah's leave, until their rights are handed over to them."

You'd want the earth to split open and swallow you.

"And the strong among you are weak in my sight, by Allah's leave, until I take from them the rights of those weaker than them."


45. "If Immorality and Indecency Spread, Allah Sends Calamity Upon All of Them"

"If immorality and indecency spread, Allah sends calamity upon all of them."

That is, in a country, when we say immorality and indecency, this includes fornication, homosexuality, prostitution; I mean gambling, alcohol, indecency, all of them come into it —

when these become widespread, upon the whole community — what does he say? Allah sends calamity upon all of them.

"Obey me as long as I obey Allah and His Messenger. But when I disobey Allah and His Messenger, you are not obliged to obey me."


46. al-Bukhari: "Obedience Is Only in What Is Right (Ma'ruf)"

Al-Bukhari: "Obedience is only in what is right (ma'ruf)." Let me add that right away too.

In the hadith, you know, normally the Messenger of Allah, sallallahu alayhi wa sallam, says: "Obedience is only in what is right (ma'ruf)." That is, in goodness.

That is, the obedience of a wife to her husband, of a disciple to his murshid, of a child to his parents, of a people or of a citizen — the subjects — to the caliph or the head of state, is in what is right. That is, in goodness.


47. Obedience in Goodness Is Obligatory

If parents advise their child to do good, if they command it, the child is bound to obey. It is obligatory (fard).

If a husband tells his wife what is good, what is beautiful, what is right, truth and justice, within the bounds of the Qur'an and the Sunna, she must obey. It is obligatory.

That being so, now if the one who governs says something within the bounds of the Qur'an and the Sunna, obedience is obligatory.


48. The Limit of the Hadith "Each of You Is Responsible"

But if he has gone outside of this — you know there is the hadith, "each of you is responsible, you are responsible for those under your charge" —

that responsibility is within the bounds of the Qur'an and the Sunna. If he goes outside of it, those under your charge are not obliged to listen to you. Indeed, they will not obey.


49. The "Aura" Bestowed on the Ruler and Its Condition

Now, normally, when it is like this, bestowing on the ruler a religious elevation, a religious measure, a religious — what do you call it in the new language? Do you call it an "aura"? — bestowing something like that on him...

Then normally he has to comply with the Qur'an and the Sunna. If he does not comply with the Qur'an and the Sunna, then there is a problem there.


50. From the Ruler Possessing Kut to the Caliph of Allah

Then, when we look at this in the pre-Islamic Turkic tradition, there is the ruler possessing kut (divine charisma) — indeed, there is the ruler possessing kut.

But upon encountering Islam, then "the sultan who is the shadow of Allah" was a more advanced political legitimacy; and when he also took religious legitimacy upon himself, he became "the caliph of Allah." That is, he became a representative of the divine order.

In this process, then, rulership ceased to be merely an office of government. It also turned into an authority supported by spiritual and religious symbols.


51. al-Mawardi's Theory Comes Into Play Immediately

Now, when it is transformed like this, al-Mawardi's theory immediately comes into play here.

Then, when we look, both the Seljuk and pre-Seljuk and the Seljuk tradition of rulership — we can put the Ottomans in this too. Then what happened? It began to intersect, together with this kut.

Then in al-Mawardi's system, normally the caliphate — that is, the imamate. Because in the Shi'a there is the imamate; the Sunnis' term is the caliphate. That being so, the caliphate, or — I put a delta there like this and wrote "imamate."

Then what became their duty? The protection of religion and the governing of the world became the fundamental aim. That being so, the idea took shape of the ruler possessing kut, the ruler who establishes order with divine support.


52. Two Different Historical Legacies United in the Same Political World

Now these two different historical legacies began, over time, to unite in the same political world. The possessor of kut and the caliph — the two began to merge.

That being so, when religion came into question, fiqh entered the picture, the ulama entered.

This team of fiqh and ulama — let me put it that way — provided the religious and legal legitimacy of the government. Al-Mawardi too. And the sultan held de facto, military and political power in his hands.

The caliph — because among the Seljuks there is not yet a caliph. The caliph is with the Abbasids; the caliphate stands with the Abbasids. That being so, the caliph is still in a separate place for now. Then the caliph is a traditional source of religious legitimacy.


53. This Structure Worked This Way Especially in the Seljuk Period

This structure worked this way especially in the Seljuk period.

So, since it worked this way in the Seljuk period, it gave us an important — if I may put it so — datum for understanding that period.


54. Where Is al-Ghazali in This Equation? This Is the Most Critical Link

Now, where does al-Ghazali fit here? This is the most critical link. I mean, where is al-Ghazali in this equation, or rather, where is al-Ghazali in this system?

Now, there is the Abbasid caliph. But de facto and political power is to a large extent in the hands of the Seljuk sultans.

Because the Seljuks — that is, the Turks — are a warlike nation. A fearless nation. I mean, the Seljuks are a nation that would say "why did you look at me sideways?" and start a war on the spot.


55. Don't Look at the Last Hundred and Fifty Years: "We've Degenerated a Bit"

Don't you go by the Turks' life of the last century, these last hundred and fifty years — I mean, the Turks are not like this. Truly, they are not like this.

I mean, they degenerated us a bit, so to speak. Today there's been a lot of talk about "degenerate." We've degenerated a bit.


56. Religious Legitimacy with the Abbasids, Military Force with the Seljuks

Now, that being so, where did al-Ghazali fit here, then? I mean, religious legitimacy lies with the caliphs — that is, with the Abbasids; political and military force lies with the Seljuks.

Normally, the Sunni world at that time is also in a rivalry with the Shi'i Fatimid states. There is a rivalry both political and religious, with these Shi'i Fatimids.

Now, the Nizamiyya madrasas institutionalized, strengthened and systematized the Sunni understanding of knowledge.


57. Al-Ghazali Was Not Concerned Only with "What Is Man, What Is Truth"

In such a world, al-Ghazali was not concerned only with — "what is man? what is truth?" as the philosophers busied themselves — only with these. He was not concerned only with these.

At the same time, he was living within a tangle of historical problems. There are historical and geographical problems.

I mean, this is not some such thing, I mean, it is not something to be taken lightly. There really are great problems. I mean, I always say this.


58. On One Side, Fatimid and Batini Turmoil, the Hashshashin, the Kharijites

On one side, Shi'i, Fatimid and Batini turmoil inside. What were they again? The ones who used drugs. (The Hashshashin.)

There are the Hashshashin. There are the followers of Hasan Sabbah. The Kharijites are there anyway. And the Kharijites — need I say more? They are a great trouble already. A trouble in every era. They are there.

Now, on top of that, on one side Byzantium, with which political and also military conflicts are constant; from within on another side, from everywhere. The Mongol invasion on another side. These are not things to be brushed aside like that.


59. Al-Ghazali's Concern: How Will the Sunni Political and Religious Order Be Preserved?

So normally al-Ghazali is, at the same time, troubled by the concern of how the Sunni political and religious order will be preserved.

He is writing works against the Batinis, publishing treatises. On one side there are debates on imamate and caliphate: the Shi'is say imamate, the Sunnis say caliphate. And there are debates between the two of them as well.

And then there are very deep debates about political authority. Al-Ghazali lives in a geography of crises in which these are directly experienced.


60. Let Me Fire a Quick Missile at Today as Well

Now let me fire a quick missile at today as well: Today, too, these crises continue in this geography.

These crises exist, and these crises are being experienced very deeply. Look, they are being experienced deeply.

And formerly this was within themselves, like that. I mean, Rome, Byzantium did not have much influence at this point.

But now, you see, Israel on one side, America on one side, Europe on one side — they are making these political and religious authorities clash in the Islamic world. Look, they are making them clash.


61. The Wahhabis Have Been Added to the Shi'a and the Sunnis

I mean, right now — formerly there were only the Shi'a and the Sunni camp. Now the Wahhabis have been added to this.

I mean, now, are we going to regard the Wahhabis as Sunni or not? That is a separate debate too.

I mean, who is Shi'a, who is Sunni, who is Wahhabi — normally we don't even need to debate this only on the basis of names. In practice, who is doing what? That is what we need to look at.

Fine, judging something by looking at written works is one thing; but when you look at practice — I mean, at actions — it is something else.


62. Two Drones in the Skies of Mecca, But Why No Voice for Jerusalem?

I mean, you look, and there are two drones flying in the skies of Mecca. Mecca becomes sacred to all of us. Right? Right. Is Mecca sacred to all of us? It is.

Why not Jerusalem? A whole string of questions. Why is al-Masjid al-Aqsa not our sacred place? They close it. They kept it closed for months. Why didn't it become our sacred place? Why didn't the Islamic world rise up?

For Muslims there are three sacred cities: Mecca, Medina, Jerusalem. Why is Jerusalem not sacred for Muslims? If it is sacred, why don't they do anything?

Two drones flew in the skies of Mecca; everyone made a statement. Quite right. Why didn't they do it for Jerusalem?


63. The Borders of the Hijaz Region Are Clear — Riyadh Is Within It Too

So Mecca is sacred. Isn't Riyadh, seventy-eighty kilometres further on, sacred? The Hijaz region is that whole area. Isn't that so?

I mean, for the whole Islamic world it is the Hijaz region. Its borders are clear, its geographical borders are clear. Riyadh is within it too.


64. The Concert Given on a Model of the Kaaba in Riyadh

Well, let me fire a missile now: In Riyadh, on top of a model of the Kaaba, barely dressed — that Rihanna or whatever her name is — someone got up there, so why didn't the Islamic world rise up?

You've forgotten those images, of course, haven't you? I never forgot.

Which American singer went there? Was it Rihanna? Who was it? (Did Shakira go?) No. (That Kaaba…) (Was it Shakira?) Pardon? Not at the World Cup, my dear brother. She gave a concert there, you know. (Shakira went too, apparently.)

Look, son, I don't follow these things. I just read it at the time in the thing. What's it? I had read it in the news. It had upset me, and I had switched it off.


65. "Look, Did I Say Jennifer Lopez?"

Look, just look at these brainless ones: "Jennifer Lopez went, apparently." Look, did I say Jennifer Lopez? Who did I say? Did I say Rihanna?

Okay, look, Lopez went, apparently. Should I really go and memorize those too?

Even the kids threw me a look: "What's up, Dad, what's going on, where are you drifting off to?" and so on.


66. I Was Very Saddened Then: The Model Came Down, Everyone Stayed Silent

Now, normally, at that time I had been very saddened. It had really upset me.

I mean, the House of Allah — there's this thing, there's a model of the Kaaba. She came out onto the stage on top of the model. Then the model came down downward. I remember it very well; that's how I watched it.

Very — everyone stayed silent, you know. The whole Islamic world stayed silent about this. No one said "what is this disgrace?" What is this disgrace — they didn't say. No one.


67. The Same Geography, Sectarian Difference, and a Time Pumped Up from Outside

Yes. Now we are living in a time brought about by the same geography and by the sectarian differences within the religion itself, and pumped up by the outside world.

I mean, normally now, al-Ghazali was in that environment of crisis; and now there is crisis too.

In this environment of crisis, how should Sufism be? In this environment of crisis, how should political authority be? In this environment of crisis, what should the governing of the state do?

Look, these too are topics that need to be discussed and talked about in depth like this.


68. What Was al-Ghazali's Critical Role Here?

Now, what was al-Ghazali's critical role here at that time — in such a time, in such a field?

Normally, let's also bring the past talks together here. There is a structure taking shape around here. In the structure taking shape, al-Mawardi. The structure taking shape.

Because normally there was that chaos, that squabbling, in the political, the religious, and the communal, social sphere alike.


69. A Turkish Element Emerging from Nomadism

Because also at that time, you know, the Seljuks, the Turks — I mean, they have a standard understanding of life. Nomadic people.

Those nomadic people are leaving nomadism for the first time.

I mean, not founding cities anywhere — earlier, in the Turkish republics, they had founded cities, but in the times that continued from there they no longer founded cities.

I mean, new areas are opening up. There is a Turkish element that opens out into new areas. These are nomads.


70. I Don't Like the Thesis "The Turks Were Nomads Throughout History" at All

And there's this thesis I very — I don't like it at all: "The Turks were nomads throughout history."

Oh, sit down! Don't say it like that. Don't say it. They founded so many states. They founded so many cities. They founded cities from scratch.

I mean, when you open it up and examine it going back, you know, they made all the Turks goat herders, as the Byzantines said. There's no such thing.

Right now there are nomads in Turkey too. Is all of Anatolia nomadic now? No. The Byzantines make these things up. May Allah forgive us. (Amin.)


71. The Four Pillars of the Structure Taking Shape

Al-Mawardi systematizes political and legal theory.

Nizam al-Mulk strengthens the institutions of the state and the madrasa.

And al-Ghazali reintegrates creed, fiqh (Islamic jurisprudence), ethics and Sufism within a Sunni framework.

The sultan has now become Muslim, you see — the sultan wields actual, military and political power. And the caliph provides a religious and symbolic legitimacy. At that time the Abbasid caliphs are not very strong.


72. This Is Not a Project Planned Together

All of these should not be thought of as if they planned the same project together.

Historically, within the historical cycle, it is a structure in which they complement one another, or else are built one on top of the other.

But this structure, by legitimizing religious authority and political authority, forms a strong structure. I mean, when we look, there is a strong structure in the Seljuk state.


73. "So Why Did the Seljuk State Collapse?" — Because It Strayed from Justice

You'll say: "Well then, why did the Seljuk state collapse?" It collapsed because it strayed from justice.

Because if the mechanism of justice in a state does not work properly, that people has no peace.

If in a state the rights of the powerless are not given, there one cannot speak of right and justice.


74. Critique of the Paragraph: Was al-Ghazali Merely the Scholar of the Order?

Normally, when we come back, what is correct in the paragraph is this — or rather, when we look at the paragraph, I mean, what it presents as a critique is this:

Was he merely the scholar of the order? Or did he play an important role in the formation of this order's religious and intellectual legitimacy?

When we answer this — I said this about al-Ghazali last time too — it would not be right to define him as "a functionary of the palace," or as "a mere ideologue of the ruling power."


75. If He Were a Functionary of the Palace, What Would He Have Had to Say?

I mean, normally, if you say "this is a functionary of the palace," he would have to set forth rules of fiqh the way the palace wants.

I mean, what would he have to say? He would have to say, "Interest is permissible up to the rate of inflation."

If he were a functionary of the palace, he would have to say, there you go, "TOKİ's interest is not interest."

That being so, he would have to keep silent about alcohol, gambling, indecency, obscenity, disgrace, bribery.


76. But al-Ghazali Is Not Like That: His Fiqh, Kalam and Hadith Are Very Solid

But al-Ghazali is not like that. Al-Ghazali's fiqh is very solid, his kalam (Islamic theology) is very solid, his hadith is very solid.

In this regard al-Ghazali is not that kind of person. I mean, he is not a mere ideologue of the ruling power.


77. The Ihya': A Work Written to Bring the Whole Islamic World into Line

At this point, when we look at the Ihya', we see it as a work written generally for the whole Islamic world, for it to come into line.

When we examine his works, he is someone who established and settled the Sunni system of thought.

But in that day, political authority also needs that religious — let me not say "philosophy" — that religious formation.

That political power, by also taking al-Ghazali's religious approach alongside it, secures the order of the people. It is not possible for us to skip over this.


78. Where Is the Real al-Ghazali Knot Untied?

Actually, having come this far, we need to move on to al-Ghazali's understanding of obedience, the sultan, the caliphate and order.

The real al-Ghazali knot is untied when we move on to this; it is understood fully.

So if you wish, we can work through this next week. So that it settles and sinks in better.

Next week, if you permit, then let's continue again with al-Ghazali. The passages are finished.


79. We Will Talk About al-Ghazali One More Week

I mean, next week, if we go over al-Ghazali's understanding of obedience, the sultan, the caliphate and order once more, directly through al-Ghazali himself, I am of the opinion that the talk concerning al-Ghazali will, I think, settle more properly into place.

We will talk about al-Ghazali one more week. Forgive us your rights. (They are forgiven.) From our side too, may they be forgiven, inshallah.


80. Reply to Brother Hakan's Note: We Did Not See Anything as a Mistake

So once again — actually, the series of questions, or the paragraphs, that have been the subject of our talks up to today are finished.

So let me write this last paragraph like this. Let me read the last paragraph; let's continue next week.

"Everything in these questions is quoted. I may have made mistakes. Forgive me."

God forbid. For us there was no problem at this point. We did not see anything at all as a mistake like that. Let us say this from here as well.


81. "The Topic Will Move to Ijtihad" — The Ijtihad Hakan Is Preparing

"If we stretch it a bit more, the topic will move to ijtihad."

You probably won't need to go there. I'll touch on this topic a bit while touching on al-Ghazali; but he will prepare that ijtihad.

Hakan said: "I'm preparing something on ijtihad," he said. "Inshallah," I said, "we'll talk about it; no problem," I said.

"Inshallah, let the next question be ijtihad." Eyvallah.


82. Through Renewal, or Through Returning to the Essence? — We Will Not Lose the Essence

"Will it make the revolutions through renewal or through returning to the essence? We'll discuss it," he said. Yes.

I mean, it's not renewal versus returning to the essence; we will do this by keeping the essence strong, keeping it solid, and renewing.

I don't see it merely as returning to the essence like that. We will not lose the essence. What is the essence? The Qur'an, the Sunna. That is the essence.

But do we need to renew ourselves? The answer: yes. Anyway, that is a separate topic.


83. Next Week We Will Close the al-Ghazali Talk

Inshallah, next week we will also discuss al-Ghazali's understanding of obedience, the sultan, the caliphate and order. We will close the al-Ghazali talk.

Forgive us our rights over you. (Forgiven.) May it be forgiven on our side too, inshallah.


84. Sema Dancer Guests from Brazil

We have guests among us from Portugal. It turns out they are sema dancers (semazen) there. We had a brief talk inside for a little while.

Then, when we learned they were sema dancers, we said, "You can perform the sema"; and then, after the sema, we said, "The talk can continue inside."

Today, at this point, we have guests from Brazil — sorry, I said Portugal, it was Brazil — we have guests from Brazil.

After that, inshallah, they will also perform the sema here, by Allah's leave. Forgive us our rights over you. (Forgiven.) May it be forgiven on our side too.


Bibliography

The verses, hadiths, works, persons and historical events mentioned in the talk are gathered below. This lesson closes the final paragraph of the al-Ghazali section with an analysis of Prof. Dr. Ahmet Yaşar Ocak's paragraph on kut and the caliphate; next week it will continue directly with al-Ghazali's understanding of obedience, the sultan, the caliphate and order.

Prof. Dr. Ahmet Yaşar Ocak (2017) — Source of the final paragraph read in the talk: "This interpenetration of the state and Islam turned the Qaghan and the Khan — who since the pre-Islamic period had been believed to rule for the happiness of the people by virtue of the kut bestowed by the Sky God, and to have been chosen by the Sky God himself — with the acceptance of Islam, into the shadow of Allah on earth in whom all creatures take refuge. From now on the Turkish sultans, as emphasised in the magnificent gold-inscribed thuluth calligraphy on the inner wall band of Timur's mausoleum, are at the same time a lofty spiritual authority, obedience to whom is counted as obedience to Allah and rebellion against whom is counted as rebellion against Allah; and, one step further, they are the caliph of Allah on earth." In the talk, the historical part of this observation is affirmed, but an objection is raised to equating the concepts of kut and the caliphate.

The Holy Qur'an, al-Nisa 4/59 — Diyanet translation: [Qur'an, an-Nisa 4:59 — verse text pending: Diyanet English translation] The main basis of the talk: while the verse commands obedience to those in authority (ulu'l-amr), it immediately thereafter commands returning to Allah and the Messenger in case of dispute, thereby closing the door to absolute and unlimited obedience.

The first sermon of Abu Bakr (may Allah be pleased with him) — al-Suyuti, Tarikh al-Khulafa', p. 35 — In the talk it is stated explicitly that this report is taken from al-Suyuti; the reason given for this preference is that al-Suyuti was among the people of Sufism. The parts of the sermon that serve as a standard: "I have been placed over you although I am not the best of you… If I perform my duty properly, help me; if I do my work badly, set me right. Truthfulness is a source of trust, and lying is betrayal. The weak among you are strong in my sight, by Allah's leave, until their rights are restored to them; and the strong among you are weak in my sight, by Allah's leave, until the rights of those weaker than them are taken from them. If immorality and indecency spread, Allah sends calamity upon them all. Obey me as long as I obey Allah and His Messenger; but when I disobey Allah and His Messenger, you are not obliged to obey me."

Hadith — "Obedience is only in what is right (ma'ruf)" (al-Bukhari) — The standard that obedience is in goodness. In the talk this standard is applied to all forms of obedience: of the wife to her husband, of the disciple to his murshid, of the child to the parents, and of the citizen to the head of state. Obedience to what is said within the bounds of the Qur'an and the Sunna is obligatory; when those bounds are exceeded, the obligation of obedience lapses.

Hadith — "All of you are responsible; you are responsible for those under your charge" — In the talk it is pointed out that this responsibility too is limited to the bounds of the Qur'an and the Sunna; a superior who steps outside those bounds is not one whom those under his charge are obliged to heed.

Hadith — The question "Where is Allah?" to the slave girl — The Prophet (peace be upon him) asked a slave girl where Allah is, and upon her answer "In the heavens," he said, "Set her free." In the talk this report is cited as evidence that the expression "in the heavens" is not a designation of place but an attribution of loftiness, and it is compared with the understanding "God is in the heavens" in the old Turkic belief.

al-Mawardi, al-Ahkam al-Sultaniyya — The two fundamental duties of the caliphate — the office which the Shi'a call the imamate: the protection of religion and the governance of the world. In the talk al-Mawardi's theory is treated as the link that, intersecting with the idea of the kut-bearing ruler, laid the groundwork for the Seljuk political order.

Nizam al-Mulk and the Nizamiyya madrasas — The strengthening of the institutions of state and madrasa; the Nizamiyya madrasas' institutionalising and systematising of the Sunni understanding of scholarship. In the fourfold classification in the talk, al-Mawardi is the one who systematised the theory, Nizam al-Mulk the one who built the institutions, al-Ghazali the one who integrated creed, fiqh, ethics and Sufism, and the sultan the party holding actual power.

The Fatimids, Hasan Sabbah, the Assassins and the Kharijites — Elements of the geography of crisis in which al-Ghazali lived: the Shi'i-Fatimid and Batini turmoil, Hasan Sabbah's drug-using fida'is, and the Kharijites who have been a source of trouble in every era; to these are added the conflicts with Byzantium and the Mongol invasion.

Timur, Mete Khan and Attila — Historical examples of the conception of the kut-bearing ruler: rulers each of whom claimed to have been commissioned by God, grounding their power not in their own strength but in a higher source.

The Kanunname of Sultan Mehmed the Conqueror — The historical background of the internal turmoil experienced whenever a qaghan died, as the country was divided among the sons who then fought one another, and the connection of the fratricide article in the kanunname with this background.

Jerusalem, al-Masjid al-Aqsa and the drone incident in the skies of Mecca — When two drones flew over the skies of Mecca, everyone issued statements; by contrast, the Islamic world remained silent while al-Masjid al-Aqsa was kept closed for months. In the talk, the three holy cities of the Muslims — Mecca, Medina, Jerusalem — are enumerated and this double standard is questioned.

The concert given on a model of the Kaaba in Riyadh — A concert given on a stage set up on a model of the Kaaba, within the geographical boundaries of the Hijaz region; the whole Islamic world remaining silent in the face of this incident. In the talk there is some hesitation together with the congregation regarding the singer's name, and the name is not confirmed.

Imam al-Ghazali, Ihya' 'Ulum al-Din — The assessment in the talk: the Ihya' is a work written, in general, so that the entire Islamic world might be set aright. Since al-Ghazali's fiqh, kalam and hadith were sound, it is not possible to define him as "a functionary of the palace" or "a mere ideologue of those in power."

Mustafa Özbağ Efendi, "Questions on al-Ghazali 14" — The full recording of the talk that is the source of this article; all the topics above have been compiled from this talk.

Click here for more information about Imam al-Ghazali.

Additional resources: